Synthetic models for the active site of cytochrome P450

Rejigging Electron and Proton Transfer to Transition between Dioxygenase, Monooxygenase, Peroxygenase, and Oxygen Reduction Activity: Insights from Bioinspired Constructs of Heme Enzymes

Nature has employed heme proteins to execute a diverse set of vital life processes. Years of research have been devoted to understanding the factors which bias these heme enzymes, with all having a heme cofactor, toward distinct catalytic activity. Among them, axial ligation, distal super structure, and substrate binding pockets are few very vividly recognized ones. Detailed mechanistic investigation of these heme enzymes suggested that several of these enzymes, while functionally divergent, use similar intermediates. Furthermore, the formation and decay of these intermediates depend on proton and electron transfer processes in the enzyme active site. Over the past decade, work in this group, using in situ surface enhanced resonance Raman spectroscopy of synthetic and biosynthetic analogues of heme enzymes, a general idea of how proton and electron transfer rates relate to the lifetime of different O2 derived intermediates has been developed. These findings suggest that the enzymatic activities of all these heme enzymes can be integrated into one general cycle which can be branched out to different catalytic pathways by regulating the lifetime and population of each of these intermediates. This regulation can further be achieved by tuning the electron and proton transfer steps. By strategically populating one of these intermediates during oxygen reduction, one can navigate through different catalytic processes to a desired direction by altering proton and electron transfer steps.

Electrocatalytic O2 Activation by Fe Tetrakis(pentafluorophenyl)porphyrin in Acidic Organic Media. Evidence of High-Valent Fe Oxo Species

O₂ activation under mild conditions remains a weighty challenge for chemists. Herein we report a study of electrochemical O₂ reductive activation catalyzed by Fe^III(F₂₀TPP)Cl, by means of cyclic voltammetry and UV-vis spectroelectrochemistry in acidic solutions of N,N-dimethylformamide. Two parallel catalytic pathways have been evidenced occurring at different overpotentials. At high overpotential a classical electron-proton (EPT) pathway where protonation of Fe peroxo ultimately leads to the formation of high-valent Fe oxo species dominates. At low overpotential a proton-electron (PET) pathway involving a hydrosuperoxo species has been identified.

Resonance Raman Spectroscopy and Density Functional Theory Calculations on Ferrous Porphyrin Dioxygen Adducts with Different Axial Ligands: Correlation of Ground State Wave Function and Geometric Parameters with Experimental Vibrational Frequencies

A dioxygen adduct of ferrous porphyrin is an important chemical species in nature as it is a common intermediate in all oxygen transfer, storage, reducing, and activating heme enzymes. The ground state (GS) wave function of this complex has been investigated using several techniques like resonance Raman (rR), Mossbauer, and X-ray absorption spectroscopies. The Fe-O and O-O vibrations of these six-coordinated diamagnetic species show a positive correlation with each other in contrast to analogous ferrous carbonyl complexes where the Fe-CO vibration correlates negatively with the C-O vibration due to a synergistic effect. In this Article, three Fe-porphyrins with different axial ligands (imidazole, phenolate, and thiolate) are investigated using rR spectroscopy and density functional theory (DFT) calculations. The GS wave functions of these species are analyzed, and the contribution of the three primary bonding interactions in the Fe-O₂ unit (a σ interaction from the in-plane π* of the superoxide to the vacant d_z² of Fe, a π donation from the out of plane (oop) π* to the d_π orbital of Fe, and a π back bonding interaction from the d_π orbital of Fe to the oop π* of the superoxide) to the calculated Fe-O and O-O vibrations and bond lengths are deconvoluted using a MO theory framework. The GS wave function provides a basis for the correlations observed between different vibrational and geometric parameters of these dioxygen adducts. Furthermore, the correlations obtained allows estimation of the GS wave function and geometry of these species (both natural and artificial) using their experimentally observed Fe-O/O-O vibrations. The wave functions thus extracted from the experimental vibrational data reported offer insight into the role of the axial ligand and hydrogen bonding on the geometric and electronic structures of these crucial chemical species in different protein active sites.

Electron Transfer Control of Reductase versus Monooxygenase: Catalytic C-H Bond Hydroxylation and Alkene Epoxidation by Molecular Oxygen

Catalytic oxidation of organic substrates, using a green oxidant like O₂, has been a long-term goal of the scientific community. In nature, these oxidations are performed by metalloenzymes that generate highly oxidizing species from O₂, which, in turn, can oxidize very stable organic substrates, e.g., mono-/dioxygenases. The same oxidants are produced during O₂ reduction/respiration in the mitochondria but are reduced by electron transfer, i.e., reductases. Iron porphyrin mimics of the active site of cytochrome P450 (Cyt P450) are created atop a self-assembled monolayer covered electrode. The rate of electron transfer from the electrode to the iron porphyrin site is attenuated to derive monooxygenase reactivity from these constructs that otherwise show O₂ reductase activity. Catalytic hydroxylation of strong C-H bonds to alcohol and epoxidation of alkenes, using molecular O₂ (with ¹⁸O₂ incorporation), is demonstrated with turnover numbers >10⁴. Uniquely, one of the two iron porphyrin catalysts used shows preferential oxidation of 2° C-H bonds of cycloalkanes to alcohols over 3° C-H bonds without overoxidation to ketones. Mechanistic investigations with labeled substrates indicate that a compound I (Fe^IV=O bound to a porphyrin cation radical) analogue, formed during O₂ reduction, is the primary oxidant. The selectivity is determined by the shape of the distal pocket of the catalyst, which, in turn, is determined by the substituents on the periphery of the porphyrin macrocycle.

A siloxyl bis-pocket thiolate-tailed Fe(III) porphyrin complex

We report the synthesis and characterization of a bis-pocket iron(III) porphyrin complex that has a covalently attached siloxy thiolate group as the axial ligand. As a new cytochrome P450 model compound, this siloxyl bis-pocket thiolate-tailed iron(III) porphyrin is easily synthesized and is surprisingly stable under air due to the extreme steric protection of the siloxy pockets on both faces of the porphyrin. A single-crystal XRD structure has been determined; the Fe–S bond distance is 2.237 (7) Å with Fe–N bond distances of 2.100 (8) and the Fe is 0.5 Å out of the mean porphyrin plane. The Fe–S bond distance in the siloxy thiolate-tailed iron(III) porphyrin is very similar to that in cytochrome P450 and this structure represents a very rare crystallographically-characterized five-coordinate high spin alkylthiolate-tailed ferric porphyrin. EPR spectrum of this compound showed g values and an E/D ratio very similar to those of cytochrome P450 (CYP450) enzyme, demonstrating the importance of using a very basic thiolate group as the axial ligand in P450 model studies. UV-vis studies of its reduced form with carbon monoxide shows a hyper spectrum, which is characteristic of carbonyl complexes of Fe(II)porphyrin thiolates.

Biomimetic Reactivity of Oxygen-Derived Manganese and Iron Porphyrinoid Complexes

Heme proteins utilize the heme cofactor, an iron porphyrin, to perform a diverse range of reactions including dioxygen binding and transport, electron transfer, and oxidation/oxygenations. These reactions share several key metalloporphyrin intermediates, typically derived from dioxygen and its congeners such as hydrogen peroxide. These species are composed of metal-dioxygen, metal-superoxo, metal-peroxo, and metal-oxo adducts. A wide variety of synthetic metalloporphyrinoid complexes have been synthesized to generate and stabilize these intermediates. These complexes have been studied to determine the spectroscopic features, structures, and reactivities of such species in controlled and well-defined environments. In this Review, we summarize recent findings on the reactivity of these species with common porphyrinoid scaffolds employed for biomimetic studies. The proposed mechanisms of action are emphasized. This Review is organized by structural type of metal-oxygen intermediate and broken into subsections based on the metal (manganese and iron) and porphyrinoid ligand (porphyrin, corrole, and corrolazine).

Oxygen oxidation of ethylbenzene over manganese porphyrin is promoted by the axial nitrogen coordination in powdered chitosan

A less wasteful production method of oxidation ethylbenzene to acetophenone and phenethyl alcohol was adviced. It revealed an important role in tuning catalytic reactivity of metalloporphyrins by the axial ligand for oxidation of hydrocarbon.

A biosynthetic model of cytochrome c oxidase as an electrocatalyst for oxygen reduction

Creating an artificial functional mimic of the mitochondrial enzyme cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) has been a long-term goal of the scientific community as such a mimic will not only add to our fundamental understanding of how CcO works but may also pave the way for efficient electrocatalysts for oxygen reduction in hydrogen/oxygen fuel cells. Here we develop an electrocatalyst for reducing oxygen to water under ambient conditions. We use site-directed mutants of myoglobin, where both the distal Cu and the redox-active tyrosine residue present in CcO are modelled. In situ Raman spectroscopy shows that this catalyst features very fast electron transfer rates, facile oxygen binding and O-O bond lysis. An electron transfer shunt from the electrode circumvents the slow dissociation of a ferric hydroxide species, which slows down native CcO (bovine 500 s(-1)), allowing electrocatalytic oxygen reduction rates of 5,000 s(-1) for these biosynthetic models.

Effect of axial ligands on electronic structure and O2 reduction by iron porphyrin complexes: Towards a quantitative understanding of the "push effect"

Axial ligands play a dominating role in determining the electronic structure and reactivity of iron porphyrin active sites and synthetic models. Several properties unique to the cysteine bound heme enzyme, cytochrome P450, is attributed to the "push effect" of the thiolate axial ligand. In this mini-review the ground state electronic structure of iron porphyrins with imidazole, phenolate and thiolate complexes, derived using a combination of spectroscopy and DFT calculations, are discussed. The differences in kinetics and selectivity of oxygen reduction reaction (ORR), catalyzed by these iron porphyrin complexes with different axial ligands, help elucidate the varying push effects of the different axial ligands on oxygen activation by ferrous porphyrin. The spectroscopic and kinetic data help to develop a quantitative understanding of the "push effect" and, in particular, the electrostatic and covalent contributions to it.

Synthesis and photophysical studies of self-assembled multicomponent supramolecular coordination prisms bearing porphyrin faces

Multicomponent self-assembly, wherein two unique donor precursors are combined with a single metal acceptor instead of the more common two-component assembly, can be achieved by selecting Lewis-basic sites and metal nodes that select for heteroligated coordination spheres. Platinum(II) ions show a thermodynamic preference for mixed pyridyl/carboxylate coordination environments and are thus suitable for such designs. The use of three or more unique building blocks increases the structural complexity of supramolecules. Herein, we describe the synthesis and characterization of rectangular prismatic supramolecular coordination complexes (SCCs) with two faces occupied by porphyrin molecules, motivated by the search for new multichromophore complexes with promising light-harvesting properties. These prisms are obtained from the self-assembly of a 90° Pt(II) acceptor with a meso-substituted tetrapyridylporphyrin (TPyP) and dicarboxylate ligands. The generality of this self-assembly reaction is demonstrated using five dicarboxylate ligands, two based on a rigid central phenyl ring and three alkyl-spaced variants, to form a total of five free-base and five Zn-metallated porphyrin prisms. All 10 SCCs are characterized by (31)P and (1)H multinuclear NMR spectroscopy and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry, confirming the structure of each self-assembly and the stoichiometry of formation. The photophysical properties of the resulting SCCs were investigated revealing that the absorption and emission properties of the free-base and metallated porphyrin prisms preserve the spectral features associated with free TPyP.

Studies of iron(III) porphyrinates containing silanethiolate ligands

The chemistry of several iron(III) porphyrinates containing silanethiolate ligands is described. The complexes are prepared by protonolysis reactions of silanethiols with the iron(III) precursors, [Fe(OMe)(TPP)] and [Fe(OH)(H2O)(TMP)] (TPP = dianion of meso-tetraphenylporphine; TMP = dianion of meso-tetramesitylporphine). Each of the compounds has been fully characterized in solution and the solid state. The stability of the silanethiolate complexes versus other iron(III) porphyrinate complexes containing sulfur-based ligands allows for an examination of their reactivity with several biologically relevant small molecules including H2S, NO, and 1-methylimidazole. Electrochemically, the silanethiolate complexes display a quasi-reversible one-electron oxidation event at potentials higher than that observed for an analogous arenethiolate complex. The behavior of these complexes versus other sulfur-ligated iron(III) porphyrinates is discussed.

EPR, resonance Raman, and DFT calculations on thiolate- and imidazole-bound iron(III) porphyrin complexes: role of the axial ligand in tuning the electronic structure

Iron(III) porphyrin complexes bearing covalently attached imidazole and thiolate axial ligands are investigated using resonance Raman, electron paramagnetic resonance, and cyclic voltammetry. The thiolate ligand stabilizes a low-spin ground state in solvent-bound six-coordinate species, weakens the Fe-N(pyr) bonds, and shifts the Fe(III/II) potential more negative by ~500 mV relative to an imidazole-bound species. Density functional theory calculations reproduce the experimental observation and indicate that the covalent charge donation from thiolate to iron reduces the Z(eff) on the iron. This increases the Fe(3d) orbital energies, which changes the bonding interaction present in these complexes significantly. In particular, the increase of the Fe(3d) energies activates an iron-to-porphyrin π*-back-bonding interaction not present in the imidazole-bound complex.

Host-guest interactions of cyclodextrins and metalloporphyrins: supramolecular building blocks toward artificial heme proteins

Cyclodextrins are versatile building blocks for a variety of macromolecules due to the inclusion complexes that are formed with hydrophobic organic molecules. Cyclodextrin-porphyrin interactions are of particular interest since cyclodextrins can serve as a non-covalent binding pocket while metalloporphyrins could serve as the heme analogs in the construction of heme protein model compounds. Various approaches to the design and assembly of biomimetic porphyrin constructs are compared and contrasted in this minireview with a particular emphasis on self-assembled and porphyrin-cyclodextrin systems. Several recent advances from our laboratories are described in this context. A sensitive fluorescent binding probe, 6A-N-dansyl-permethylated-β-cyclodextrin (Dan-NH-TMCD), was found to form 2:1 complexes with the meso-tetraphenylporphyrins Mn(III)TCPP , Mn(III)TPPS and Mn(III)TF 4 TMAP with high binding constants. A perPEGylated cyclodextrin, heptakis(2,3,6-tri-O-2-(2-(2-methoxyethoxy)ethoxy)ethyl)-β-cyclodextrin (TPCD), has been shown by 1 H NMR spectroscopy to form a 1:1 complex with H 2 TCPP with a binding constant above 108M-1. Such a strong binding constant is the largest found for a 1:1 complex between a monomeric cyclodextrin and a guest. TPCD was also found to bind Mn(III)TCPP with a binding constant of 1.2 × 106 M -1. A novel, self-assembled hemoprotein model, hemodextrin is also described. The molecular design is based on a PEGylated cyclodextrin scaffold that bears both a heme-binding pocket and an axial ligand that binds an iron porphyrin. The binding constant for Fe (III) TPPS (iron(III) meso-tetra(4-sulfonatophenyl)porphyrin) by py-PPCD was determined to be 2 × 106 M -1. The pyridyl nitrogen of py-PPCD was shown to ligate to the iron center by observing signal changes in the Fe(II) -porphyrin 1 H NMR spectrum. This hemodextrin ensemble, a minimalist myoglobin, was shown to bind dioxygen reversibly and to form a stable ferryl species.

Molecular dynamics assignment of NMR correlation times to specific motions in a "basket-handle porphyrin" heme

Iron (II) basket-handle porphyrins (BHP) are a series of encumbered heme models designed several years ago to mimic the ligand binding site of hemoproteins. Contrary to expectations, kinetic investigations have revealed that the k(on) rates for CO and/or O2 binding were only marginally affected by the assumed central steric hindrance of the iron atom. Thus, it was hypothesized that the internal dynamics of the molecule might be at the origin of the poor steric protection. To address this issue, measurements of nuclear magnetic resonance relaxation rates, fluorescence anisotropy experiments, and molecular dynamics simulations were undertaken. The size of BHP is small enough to allow the simulation in explicit chloroform with an almost complete sampling of the conformational space. The order parameters calculated from the MD trajectory compare well with the NMR experimental data and the predicted rotational correlation time corresponding to the Brownian motion of the molecule is in good agreement with the fluorescence measurements. Moreover, combining the results obtained using the three techniques allows the attribution of each internal NMR correlation time to a particular internal motion, revealing that even such medium-sized molecules are able to display quite complex internal dynamics. In particular, the handle phenyls that were assumed to sandwich the porphyrin have in fact a vanishing probability to be found in the proximity of the iron atom. They are therefore unable to reduce ligand accessibility significantly, which may explain the behavior of the k(on) rates.

Thermodynamic and Kinetic Studies on the Binding of Nitric Oxide to a New Enzyme Mimic of Cytochrome P450

A new model for the P450 enzyme carrying a SO(3)(-) ligand coordinated to iron(III) (complex 2) reversibly binds NO to yield the nitrosyl adduct. The rate constant for NO binding to 2 in toluene is of the same order of magnitude as that found for the nitrosylation of the native, substrate-bound form of P450(cam) (E.S-P450(cam)). Large and negative activation entropy and activation volume values for the binding of NO to complex 2 support a mechanism that is dominated by bond formation with concomitant iron spin change from S = (5)/(2) to S = 0, as proposed for the reaction between NO and E.S-P450(cam). In contrast, the dissociation of NO from 2(NO) was found to be several orders of magnitude faster than the corresponding reaction for the E.S-P450(cam)/NO system. In a coordinating solvent such as methanol, the alcohol coordinates to iron(III) of 2 at the distal position, generating a six-coordinate, high-spin species 5. The reaction of NO with 5 in methanol was found to be much slower in comparison to the nitrosylation reaction of 2 in toluene. This behavior can be explained in terms of a mechanism in which methanol must be displaced during Fe-NO bond formation. The thermodynamic and kinetic data for NO binding to the new model complexes of P450 (2 and 5) are discussed in reference to earlier results obtained for closely related nitrosylation reactions of cytochrome P450(cam) (in the presence and in the absence of the substrate) and a thiolate-ligated iron(III) model complex.

The strength of hydrogen bonding to metal-bound ligands can contribute to changes in the redox behaviour of metal centres

A series of nine tripodal tetradentate ligands based on tris(pyridyl-2-methyl)amine TPA with hydrogen bond donors R in one, two and three of the pyridine 6-positions (R = NH2 amino, L(Am-1,2,3); NHCH2(t)Bu neopentylamino, L(Np-1,2,3); NHCO(t)Bu pivaloylamido, L(Piv-1,2,3)) and TPA are used to investigate the effect of different hydrogen bonding microenvironments on electrochemical properties of their LCuCl complexes. The hydrogen bond donors are rigidly preorganised and suitably oriented for intramolecular N-H...Cl-Cu hydrogen bonds. Cyclic voltammetry studies show that the reduction potential of the Cu(II)/Cu(I) couple as a function of the ligand follows the order TPA < L(Am-n) < or approximately L(Np-n) < L(Piv-n), and that the magnitude of the effect increases with the number of hydrogen bonding groups. These trends could be explained in terms of the steric and electronic effects exerted by these groups stabilising the Cu(I) oxidation state. In fact, the X-ray structure of the air-stable [(L(Piv-3))Cu(I)Cl] complex is reported and shows elongated Cu-N and Cu-Cl bonds, presumably due to the combination of steric and electron withdrawing effects exerted by the three pivaloylamido groups. We reasoned that the strength of hydrogen bonding in the Cu(I) and Cu(II) oxidation states could differ and therefore contribute also to the aforementioned redox changes; this hypothesis is tested using IR and NMR spectroscopy. IR studies of the [(L(Piv-1,2,3))Cu(I)Cl] and [(L(Piv-1,2,3))Cu(II)Cl]+ complexes in acetonitrile show that the intramolecular N-H...Cl-Cu hydrogen bonding weakens in the order L(Piv-1) > L(Piv-2) > L(Piv-3), and that it is stronger in the Cu(I) complexes. The 1H NMR spectra of the [(L(Piv1,2,3))Cu(I)Cl] complexes are in complete agreement with the IR data, and reveal that the stability of the Cu(I) complexes to oxidation in air increases in the order L(Piv-1) < L(Piv-2) << L(Piv-3). The hydrogen bonds in the Cu(I) complexes are stronger because of the higher electron density on the Cl ligand, when compared to the Cu(II) complexes. This is consistent with ab initio MP2 calculations performed on the complexes [(L(Piv-3))Cu(I)Cl] and [(L(Piv-3))Cu(II)Cl]+. Thus, the electron density of a metal-bound ligand acting as hydrogen bond acceptor is revealed as the major factor in determining the strength of the hydrogen bonds formed. From the IR data the energies of the N-H...Cl-Cu hydrogen bonds is estimated, as is the contribution of changes in hydrogen bond strength with the oxidation state of the copper centre and number of interactions to stabilising the Cu(I) state. Some of the implications of this result in dioxygen activation chemistry are discussed.

A Thiolate-Ligated Nonheme Oxoiron(IV) Complex Relevant to Cytochrome P450

Thiolate-ligated oxoiron(IV) centers are postulated to be the key oxidants in the catalytic cycles of oxygen-activating cytochrome P450 and related enzymes. Despite considerable synthetic efforts, chemists have not succeeded in preparing an appropriate model complex. Here we report the synthesis and spectroscopic characterization of [FeIV(O)(TMCS)]+ where TMCS is a pentadentate ligand that provides a square pyramidal N4(SR)apical, where SR is thiolate, ligand environment about the iron center, which is similar to that of cytochrome P450. The rigidity of the ligand framework stabilizes the thiolate in an oxidizing environment. Reactivity studies suggest that thiolate coordination favors hydrogen-atom abstraction chemistry over oxygen-atom transfer pathways in the presence of reducing substrates.

Oxygen Activation and Electron Transfer in Flavocytochrome P450 BM3

In flavocytochrome P450 BM3, there is a conserved phenylalanine residue at position 393 (Phe393), close to Cys400, the thiolate ligand to the heme. Substitution of Phe393 by Ala, His, Tyr, and Trp has allowed us to modulate the reduction potential of the heme, while retaining the structural integrity of the enzyme's active site. Substrate binding triggers electron transfer in P450 BM3 by inducing a shift from a low- to high-spin ferric heme and a 140 mV increase in the heme reduction potential. Kinetic analysis of the mutants indicated that the spin-state shift alone accelerates the rate of heme reduction (the rate determining step for overall catalysis) by 200-fold and that the concomitant shift in reduction potential is only responsible for a modest 2-fold rate enhancement. The second step in the P450 catalytic cycle involves binding of dioxygen to the ferrous heme. The stabilities of the oxy-ferrous complexes in the mutant enzymes were also analyzed using stopped-flow kinetics. These were found to be surprisingly stable, decaying to superoxide and ferric heme at rates of 0.01-0.5 s(-)(1). The stability of the oxy-ferrous complexes was greater for mutants with higher reduction potentials, which had lower catalytic turnover rates but faster heme reduction rates. The catalytic rate-determining step of these enzymes can no longer be the initial heme reduction event but is likely to be either reduction of the stabilized oxy-ferrous complex, i.e., the second flavin to heme electron transfer or a subsequent protonation event. Modulating the reduction potential of P450 BM3 appears to tune the two steps in opposite directions; the potential of the wild-type enzyme appears to be optimized to maximize the overall rate of turnover. The dependence of the visible absorption spectrum of the oxy-ferrous complex on the heme reduction potential is also discussed.

Proton-coupled O-O activation on a redox platform bearing a hydrogen-bonding scaffold

Porphyrin architectures bearing a hydrogen-bonding scaffold have been synthesized. The H-bond pendant allows proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) to be utilized as a vehicle for effecting catalytic O-O bond activation chemistry. Suzuki cross-coupling reactions provide a modular synthetic strategy for the attachment of porphyrins to a rigid xanthene or dibenzofuran pillar bearing the H-bond pendant. The resulting HPX (hanging porphyrin xanthene) and HPD (hanging porphyrin dibenzofuran) systems permit both the orientation and acid-base properties of the hanging H-bonding group to be controlled. Comparative reactivity studies for the catalase-like disproportionation of hydrogen peroxide and the epoxidation of olefins by the HPX and HPD platforms with acid and ester hanging groups reveal that the introduction of a proton-transfer network, properly oriented to a redox-active platform, can orchestrate catalytic O-O bond activation. For the catalase and epoxidation reaction types, a marked reactivity enhancement is observed for the xanthene-bridged platform appended with a pendant carboxylic acid group, establishing that this approach can yield superior catalysts to analogues that do not control both proton and electron inventories.