Mechanism of cytochrome P450 reductase from the house fly: evidence for an FMN semiquinone as electron donor

Biochemical and structural insights into the cytochrome P450 reductase from Candida tropicalis

Cytochrome P450 reductases (CPRs) are diflavin oxidoreductases that supply electrons to type II cytochrome P450 monooxygenases (CYPs). In addition, it can also reduce other proteins and molecules, including cytochrome c, ferricyanide, and different drugs. Although various CPRs have been functionally and structurally characterized, the overall mechanism and its interaction with different redox acceptors remain elusive. One of the main problems regarding electron transfer between CPRs and CYPs is the so-called “uncoupling”, whereby NAD(P)H derived electrons are lost due to the reduced intermediates’ (FAD and FMN of CPR) interaction with molecular oxygen. Additionally, the decay of the iron-oxygen complex of the CYP can also contribute to loss of reducing equivalents during an unproductive reaction cycle. This phenomenon generates reactive oxygen species (ROS), leading to an inefficient reaction. Here, we present the study of the CPR from Candida tropicalis (CtCPR) lacking the hydrophobic N-terminal part (Δ2–22). The enzyme supports the reduction of cytochrome c and ferricyanide, with an estimated 30% uncoupling during the reactions with cytochrome c. The ROS produced was not influenced by different physicochemical conditions (ionic strength, pH, temperature). The X-ray structures of the enzyme were solved with and without its cofactor, NADPH. Both CtCPR structures exhibited the closed conformation. Comparison with the different solved structures revealed an intricate ionic network responsible for the regulation of the open/closed movement of CtCPR.

Biochemical and structural insights into the cytochrome P450 reductase from Candida tropicalis

Cytochrome P450 reductases (CPRs) are diflavin oxidoreductases that supply electrons to type II cytochrome P450 monooxygenases (CYPs). In addition, it can also reduce other proteins and molecules, including cytochrome c, ferricyanide, and different drugs. Although various CPRs have been functionally and structurally characterized, the overall mechanism and its interaction with different redox acceptors remain elusive. One of the main problems regarding electron transfer between CPRs and CYPs is the so-called "uncoupling", whereby NAD(P)H derived electrons are lost due to the reduced intermediates' (FAD and FMN of CPR) interaction with molecular oxygen. Additionally, the decay of the iron-oxygen complex of the CYP can also contribute to loss of reducing equivalents during an unproductive reaction cycle. This phenomenon generates reactive oxygen species (ROS), leading to an inefficient reaction. Here, we present the study of the CPR from Candida tropicalis (CtCPR) lacking the hydrophobic N-terminal part (Δ2-22). The enzyme supports the reduction of cytochrome c and ferricyanide, with an estimated 30% uncoupling during the reactions with cytochrome c. The ROS produced was not influenced by different physicochemical conditions (ionic strength, pH, temperature). The X-ray structures of the enzyme were solved with and without its cofactor, NADPH. Both CtCPR structures exhibited the closed conformation. Comparison with the different solved structures revealed an intricate ionic network responsible for the regulation of the open/closed movement of CtCPR.

Short-lived neutral FMN and FAD semiquinones are transient intermediates in cryo-reduced yeast NADPH-cytochrome P450 reductase

The electron configuration of flavin cofactors, FMN and FAD, is a critical factor governing the reactivity of NADPH-cytochrome P450 reductase (CPR). The current view of electron transfer by the mammalian CPR, based on equilibrium redox potentials of the flavin cofactors, is that the two electron-reduced FMN hydroquinone (FMNH2), rather than one electron-reduced FMN semiquinone, serves as electron donor to the terminal protein acceptors. However, kinetic and thermodynamic studies on the CPR species originated from different organisms have shown that redox potentials measured at distinct electron transfer steps differ from redox potentials determined by equilibrium titration. Collectively, previous observations suggest that the short-lived transient semiquinone species may carry electrons in diflavin reductases. In this work, we have investigated spectroscopic properties of the CPR-bound FAD and FMN reduced at 77 K by radiolytically-generated thermalized electrons. Using UV-vis spectroscopy, we demonstrated that upon cryo-reduction of oxidized yeast CPR (yCPR) containing an equimolar ratio of both FAD and FMN, or FAD alone, neutral semiquinones were trapped at 77 K. During annealing at the elevated temperatures, unstable short-lived neutral semiquinones relaxed to spectroscopically distinct air-stable neutral semiquinones. This transition was independent of pH within the 6.0-10.7 range. Our data on yeast CPR are in line with the previous observations of others that the flavin short-lived transient semiquinone intermediates may have a role in the electron transfer by CPR at physiological conditions.

Cloning, purification, crystallization and preliminary X-ray analysis of a chimeric NADPH-cytochrome P450 reductase

NADPH-cytochrome P450 reductase (CPR) is the favoured redox partner of microsomal cytochromes P450. This protein is composed of two flavin-containing domains (FMN and FAD) connected by a structured linker. An active CPR chimera consisting of the yeast FMN and human FAD domains has been produced, purified and crystallized. The crystals belonged to the monoclinic space group C2 and contained one molecule per asymmetric unit. Molecular replacement was performed using the published rat and yeast structures as search models. The initial electron-density maps revealed that the chimeric enzyme had crystallized in a conformation that differed from those of previously solved structures.

Global effects of the energetics of coenzyme binding: NADPH controls the protein interaction properties of human cytochrome P450 reductase

The thermodynamics of coenzyme binding to human cytochrome P450 reductase (CPR) and its isolated FAD-binding domain have been studied by isothermal titration calorimetry. Binding of 2',5'-ADP, NADP(+), and H(4)NADP, an isosteric NADPH analogue, is described in terms of the dissociation binding constant (K(d)), the enthalpy (DeltaH(B)) and entropy (TDeltaS(B)) of binding, and the heat capacity change (DeltaC(p)). This systematic approach allowed the effect of coenzyme redox state on binding to CPR to be determined. The recognition and stability of the coenzyme-CPR complex are largely determined by interaction with the adenosine moiety (K(d2)(')(,5)(')(-ADP) = 76 nM), regardless of the redox state of the nicotinamide moiety. Similar heat capacity change (DeltaC(p)) values for 2',5'-ADP (-210 cal mol(-)(1) K(-)(1)), NADP(+) (-230 cal mol(-)(1) K(-)(1)), and H(4)NADP (-220 cal mol(-)(1) K(-)(1)) indicate no significant contribution from the nicotinamide moiety to the binding interaction surface. The coenzyme binding stoichiometry to CPR is 1:1. This result validates a recently proposed one-site kinetic model [Daff, S. (2004) Biochemistry 43, 3929-3932] as opposed to a two-site model previously suggested by us [Gutierrez, A., Lian, L.-Y., Wolf, C. R., Scrutton, N. S., and Roberts, C. G. K. (2001) Biochemistry 40, 1964-1975]. Calorimetric studies in which binding of 2',5'-ADP to CPR (TDeltaS(B) = -13400 +/- 200 cal mol(-)(1), 35 degrees C) was compared with binding of the same ligand to the isolated FAD-binding domain (TDeltaS(B) = -11200 +/- 300 cal mol(-)(1), 35 degrees C) indicate that the number of accessible conformational substates of the protein increases upon 2',5'-ADP binding in the presence of the FMN-binding domain. This pattern was consistently observed along the temperature range that was studied (5-35 degrees C). This contribution of coenzyme binding energy to domain dynamics in CPR agrees with conclusions from previous temperature-jump studies [Gutierrez, A., Paine, M., Wolf, C. R., Scrutton, N. S., and Roberts, G. C. K. (2002) Biochemistry 41, 4626-4637]. A combination of calorimetry and stopped-flow spectrophotometry kinetics experiments showed that this linkage between coenzyme binding energetics and diffusional domain motion impinges directly on the molecular recognition of cytochrome c by CPR. Single-turnover reduction of cytochrome c by CPR (k(max) = 15 s(-)(1), K(d) = 37 microM) is critically coupled to coenzyme binding through ligand-induced motions that enable the FMN-binding domain to overcome a kinetically unproductive conformation. This is remarkable since the FMN-binding domain is not directly involved in coenzyme binding, the NADP(H) binding site being fully contained in the FAD-binding domain. Sequential rapid mixing measurements indicate that harnessing of coenzyme binding energy to the formation of a kinetically productive CPR-cytochrome c complex is a highly synchronized event. The inferred half-time for the decay of this productive conformation (tau(50)) is 330 +/- 70 ms only. Previously proposed structural and kinetic models are discussed in light of these findings.

A second FMN binding site in yeast NADPH-cytochrome P450 reductase suggests a mechanism of electron transfer by diflavin reductases

NADPH-cytochrome P450 reductase transfers two reducing equivalents derived from a hydride ion of NADPH via FAD and FMN to the large family of microsomal cytochrome P450 monooxygenases in one-electron transfer steps. The mechanism of electron transfer by diflavin reductases remains elusive and controversial. Here, we determined the crystal structure of truncated yeast NADPH-cytochrome P450 reductase, which is functionally active toward its physiological substrate cytochrome P450, and discovered a second FMN binding site at the interface of the connecting and FMN binding domains. The two FMN binding sites have different accessibilities to the bulk solvent and different amino acid environments, suggesting stabilization of different electronic structures of the reduced flavin. Since only one FMN cofactor is required for function, a hypothetical mechanism of electron transfer is discussed that proposes shuttling of a single FMN between these two sites coupled with the transition between two semiquinone forms, neutral (blue) and anionic (red).

Electron transfer by diflavin reductases

Diflavin reductases are enzymes which emerged as a gene fusion of ferredoxin (flavodoxin) reductase and flavodoxin. The enzymes of this family tightly bind two flavin cofactors, FAD and FMN, and catalyze transfer of the reducing equivalents from the two-electron donor NADPH to a variety of one-electron acceptors. Cytochrome P450 reductase (P450R), a flavoprotein subunit of sulfite reductase (SiR), and flavoprotein domains of naturally occurring flavocytochrome fusion enzymes like nitric oxide synthases (NOS) and the fatty acid hydroxylase from Bacillus megaterium are some of the enzymes of this family. In this review the results of the last decade of research are summarized, and some earlier results are reevaluated as well. The kinetic mechanism of cytochrome c reduction is analyzed in light of other results on flavoprotein interactions with nucleotides and cytochromes. The roles of the binding sites of the isoalloxazine rings of the flavin cofactors and conformational changes of the protein in electron transfer are discussed. It is proposed that minor conformational changes during catalysis can potentiate properties of the redox centers during the catalytic turnover. A function of the aromatic residue that shields the isoalloxazine ring of the FAD is also proposed.

JUD COON: 35 YEARS OF P450 RESEARCH, A SYNOPSIS OF P450 HISTORY

The year 2004 marks the 50th anniversary of the discovery of cytochrome P450. Minor J. (Jud) Coon has been a leader in this field for the last 35 years. This review summarizes his contributions to P450 research by discussing six of his most significant publications; not surprisingly, these papers serve as landmarks for the major directions followed in P450 research.

Role of Thr(66) in porcine NADH-cytochrome b5 reductase in catalysis and control of the rate-limiting step in electron transfer

Site-directed mutagenesis of Thr(66) in porcine liver NADH-cytochrome b(5) reductase demonstrated that this residue modulates the semiquinone form of FAD and the rate-limiting step in the catalytic sequence of electron transfer. The absorption spectrum of the T66V mutant showed a typical neutral blue semiquinone intermediate during turnover in the electron transfer from NADH to ferricyanide but showed an anionic red semiquinone form during anaerobic photoreduction. The apparent k(cat) values of this mutant were approximately 10% of that of the wild type enzyme (WT). These data suggest that the T66V mutation stabilizes the neutral blue semiquinone and that the conversion of the neutral blue to the anionic red semiquinone form is the rate-limiting step. In the WT, the value of the rate constant of FAD reduction (k(red)) was consistent with the k(cat) values, and the oxidized enzyme-NADH complex was observed during the turnover with ferricyanide. This indicates that the reduction of FAD by NADH in the WT-NADH complex is the rate-limiting step. In the T66A mutant, the k(red) value was larger than the k(cat) values, but the k(red) value in the presence of NAD(+) was consistent with the k(cat) values. The spectral shape of this mutant observed during turnover was similar to that during the reduction with NADH in the presence of NAD(+). These data suggest that the oxidized T66A-NADH-NAD(+) ternary complex is a major intermediate in the turnover and that the release of NAD(+) from this complex is the rate-limiting step. These results substantiate the important role of Thr(66) in the one-electron transfer reaction catalyzed by this enzyme. On the basis of these data, we present a new kinetic scheme to explain the mechanism of electron transfer from NADH to one-electron acceptors including cytochrome b(5).

Stopped-flow kinetic studies of flavin reduction in human cytochrome P450 reductase and its component domains

The reduction by NADPH of the FAD and FMN redox centers in human cytochrome P450 reductase and its component domains has been studied by rapid-mixing, stopped-flow spectroscopy. Reduction of the isolated FAD-domain occurs in three kinetically resolvable steps. The first represents the rapid formation (>500 s(-)(1)) of a charge-transfer species between oxidized FAD and NADPH. This is followed by an isomerization ( approximately 200 s(-)(1)) to a second charge-transfer species, characterized by a more intense absorption in the long-wavelength region. The third step represents hydride transfer from NADPH to FAD and is accompanied by a change in the tryptophan fluorescence of the FAD-domain. Flavin reduction is reversible, and the observed rate of hydride transfer displays a complex dependence on NADPH concentration. Two-electron-reduced FAD-domain is active in electron transfer reactions with the isolated FMN domain through the formation of a weakly associating electron transfer complex. Reduction of the CPR by NADPH occurs without direct spectral evidence for the formation of charge-transfer species, although the presence of such species is inferred indirectly. Transfer of the first hydride ion leads to the accumulation of a blue di-semiquinoid species of the reductase, indicating rapid transfer of one electron to the FMN domain. The di-semiquinoid species decays on transfer of the second hydride ion. A third phase is seen following prolonged incubation with NADPH and is assigned to a series of equilibration reactions between different redox species of the enzyme as the system relaxes to its thermodynamically most stable state. As with the isolated FAD-domain, the first hydride transfer in the reductase shows a complex dependence on NADPH concentration. At high NADPH concentration, the observed rate of hydride transfer is slow (approximately 20 s(-1)), and this attenuated rate is attributed to the reversible formation of an less active complex resulting from the binding of a second molecule of NADPH. The kinetic data are discussed with reference to the potentiometric studies on the enzyme and its component domains presented in the preceding paper in this issue [Munro, A., Noble, M., Robledo, L., Daff, S., and Chapman, S. (2001) Biochemistry 40, 1956-1963].

Functional interactions in cytochrome P450BM3. Evidence that NADP(H) binding controls redox potentials of the flavin cofactors

NADP(H) binding is essential for fast electron transfer through the flavoprotein domain of the fusion protein P450BM3. Here we characterize the interaction of NADP(H) with the oxidized and partially reduced enzyme and the effect of this interaction on the redox properties of flavin cofactors and electron transfer. Measurements by three different approaches demonstrated a relatively low affinity of oxidized P450BM3 for NADP(+), with a K(d) of about 10 microM. NADPH binding is also relatively weak (K(d) approximately 10 microM), but the affinity increases manyfold upon hydride ion transfer so that the active 2-electron reduced enzyme binds NADP(+) with a K(d) in the submicromolar range. NADP(H) binding induces conformational changes of the protein as demonstrated by tryptophan fluorescence quenching. Fluorescence quenching indicated preferential binding of NADPH by oxidized P450BM3, while no catalytically competent binding with reduced P450BM3 could be detected. The hydride ion transfer step, as well as the interflavin electron transfer steps, is readily reversible, as demonstrated by a hydride ion exchange (transhydrogenase) reaction between NADPH and NADP(+) or their analogues. Experiments with FMN-free mutants demonstrated that FAD is the only flavin cofactor required for the transhydrogenase activity. The equilibrium constants of each electron transfer step of the flavoprotein domain during catalytic turnover have been calculated. The values obtained differ from those calculated from equilibrium redox potentials by as much as 2 orders of magnitude. The differences result from the enzyme's interaction with NADP(H).

Interaction of NADP(H) with oxidized and reduced P450 reductase during catalysis. Studies with nucleotide analogues

Previous studies have shown that the interaction of P450 reductase with bound NADP(H) is essential to ensure fast electron transfer through the two flavin cofactors. In this study we investigated in detail the interaction of the house fly flavoprotein with NADP(H) and a number of nucleotide analogues. 1,4,5,6-Tetrahydro-NADP, an analogue of NADPH, was used to characterize the interaction of P450 reductase with the reduced nucleotide. This analogue is inactive as electron donor, but its binding affinity and rate constant of release are very close to those for NADPH. The 2'-phosphate contributes about 5 kcal/mol of the binding energy of NADP(H). Oxidized nicotinamide does not interact with the oxidized flavoprotein, while reduced nicotinamide contributes 1.3 kcal/mol of the binding energy. Oxidized P450 reductase binds NADPH with a K(d) of 0.3 microM, while the affinity of the reduced enzyme is considerably lower, K(d) = 1.9 microM. P450 reductase catalyzes a transhydrogenase reaction between NADPH and oxidized nucleotides, such as thionicotinamide-NADP(+), acetylpyridine-NADP(+), or [(3)H]NADP(+). The reverse reaction, reduction of [(3)H]NADP(+) by the reduced analogues, is also catalyzed by P450 reductase. We define the mechanism of the transhydrogenase reaction as follows: NADPH binding, hydride ion transfer, and release of the NADP(+) formed. An NADP(+) or its analogue binds to the two-electron-reduced flavoprotein, and the electron-transfer steps reverse to transfer hydride ion to the oxidized nucleotide, which is released. Measurements of the flavin semiquinone content, rate constant for NADPH release, and transhydrogenase turnover rates allowed us to estimate the steady-state distribution of P450 reductase species during catalysis, and to calculate equilibrium constants for the interconversion of catalytic intermediates. Our results demonstrate that equilibrium redox potentials of the flavin cofactors are not the sole factor governing rapid electron transfer during catalysis, but conformational changes must be considered to understand P450 reductase catalysis.