Use of synthetic peptide libraries and phosphopeptide-selective mass spectrometry to probe protein kinase substrate specificity

Affinity Selection from Synthetic Peptide Libraries Enabled by De Novo MS/MS Sequencing

Recently, de novo MS/MS peptide sequencing has enabled the application of affinity selections to synthetic peptide mixtures that approach the diversity of phage libraries (> 108 random peptides). In conjunction with ‘split-mix’ solid phase synthesis to access equimolar peptide mixtures, this approach provides a straightforward means to examine synthetic peptide libraries of considerably higher diversity than has been feasible historically. Here, we offer a critical perspective on this work, report emerging data, and highlight opportunities for further methods refinement. With continued development, ‘affinity selection–mass spectrometry’ may become a complimentary approach to phage display, in vitro selection, and DNA-encoded libraries for the discovery of synthetic ligands that modulate protein function.

PLDMS: Phosphopeptide Library Dephosphorylation Followed by Mass Spectrometry Analysis to Determine the Specificity of Phosphatases for Dephosphorylation Site Sequences

A detailed understanding of the sequence preference surrounding phosphorylation sites is essential for deciphering the function of the human phosphoproteome . Whereas the mechanisms for substrate site recognition by kinases are relatively well understood, the selection mechanisms for the corresponding phosphatases pose several obstacles. However, multiple pieces of evidence point towards a role of the amino acid sequence in the direct vicinity of the phosphorylation site for recognition by phosphatase enzymes. Peptide library-based studies for enzymes attaching posttranslational modifications (PTMs) are relatively straight forward to carry out. However, studying enzymes removing PTMs pose a challenge in that libraries with a PTM attached are needed as a starting point. Here, we present our methodology using large synthetic phosphopeptide libraries to study the preferred sequence context of protein phosphatases. The approach, termed "phosphopeptide library dephosphorylation followed by mass spectrometry" (PLDMS), allows for the exact control of phosphorylation site incorporation and the synthetic route is capable of covering several thousand peptides in a single tube reaction. Furthermore, it enables the user to analyze MS data tailored to the needs of a specific library and thereby increase data quality. We therefore expect a wide applicability of this technique for a range of enzymes catalyzing the removal of PTMs.

Fine-tuning of substrate preferences of the Src-family kinase Lck revealed through a high-throughput specificity screen

The specificity of tyrosine kinases is attributed predominantly to localization effects dictated by non-catalytic domains. We developed a method to profile the specificities of tyrosine kinases by combining bacterial surface-display of peptide libraries with next-generation sequencing. Using this, we showed that the tyrosine kinase ZAP-70, which is critical for T cell signaling, discriminates substrates through an electrostatic selection mechanism encoded within its catalytic domain (Shah et al., 2016). Here, we expand this high-throughput platform to analyze the intrinsic specificity of any tyrosine kinase domain against thousands of peptides derived from human tyrosine phosphorylation sites. Using this approach, we find a difference in the electrostatic recognition of substrates between the closely related Src-family kinases Lck and c-Src. This divergence likely reflects the specialization of Lck to act in concert with ZAP-70 in T cell signaling. These results point to the importance of direct recognition at the kinase active site in fine-tuning specificity.

Multiplex Substrate Profiling by Mass Spectrometry for Kinases as a Method for Revealing Quantitative Substrate Motifs

The more than 500 protein kinases comprising the human kinome catalyze hundreds of thousands of phosphorylation events to regulate a diversity of cellular functions; however, the extended substrate specificity is still unknown for many of these kinases. We report here a method for quantitatively describing kinase substrate specificity using an unbiased peptide library-based approach with direct measurement of phosphorylation by tandem liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) peptide sequencing (multiplex substrate profiling by mass spectrometry, MSP-MS). This method can be deployed with as low as 10 nM enzyme to determine activity against S/T/Y-containing peptides; additionally, label-free quantitation is used to ascertain catalytic efficiency values for individual peptide substrates in the multiplex assay. Using this approach we developed quantitative motifs for a selection of kinases from each branch of the kinome, with and without known substrates, highlighting the applicability of the method. The sensitivity of this approach is evidenced by its ability to detect phosphorylation events from nanogram quantities of immunoprecipitated material, which allows for wider applicability of this method. To increase the information content of the quantitative kinase motifs, a sublibrary approach was used to expand the testable sequence space within a peptide library of approximately 100 members for CDK1, CDK7, and CDK9. Kinetic analysis of the HIV-1 Tat (transactivator of transcription)-positive transcription elongation factor b (P-TEFb) interaction allowed for localization of the P-TEFb phosphorylation site as well as characterization of the stimulatory effect of Tat on P-TEFb catalytic efficiency.

Phosphorylation-mediated RNA/peptide complex coacervation as a model for intracellular liquid organelles

Biological cells are highly organized, with numerous subcellular compartments. Phosphorylation has been hypothesized as a means to control the assembly/disassembly of liquid-like RNA- and protein-rich intracellular bodies, or liquid organelles, that lack delimiting membranes. Here, we demonstrate that charge-mediated phase separation, or complex coacervation, of RNAs with cationic peptides can generate simple model liquid organelles capable of reversibly compartmentalizing biomolecules. Formation and dissolution of these liquid bodies was controlled by changes in peptide phosphorylation state using a kinase/phosphatase enzyme pair. The droplet-generating phase transition responded to modification of even a single serine residue. Electrostatic interactions between the short cationic peptides and the much longer polyanionic RNAs drove phase separation. Coacervates were also formed on silica beads, a primitive model for localization at specific intracellular sites. This work supports phosphoregulation of complex coacervation as a viable mechanism for dynamic intracellular compartmentalization in membraneless organelles.

Multiple alternative substrate kinetics

The specificity of enzymes for their respective substrates has been a focal point of enzyme kinetics since the initial characterization of metabolic chemistry. Various processes to quantify an enzyme's specificity using kinetics have been utilized over the decades. Fersht's definition of the ratio kcat/Km for two different substrates as the "specificity constant" (ref [7]), based on the premise that the important specificity existed when the substrates were competing in the same reaction, has become a consensus standard for enzymes obeying Michaelis-Menten kinetics. The expansion of the theory for the determination of the relative specificity constants for a very large number of competing substrates, e.g. those present in a combinatorial library, in a single reaction mixture has been developed in this contribution. The ratio of kcat/Km for isotopologs has also become a standard in mechanistic enzymology where kinetic isotope effects have been measured by the development of internal competition experiments with extreme precision. This contribution extends the theory of kinetic isotope effects to internal competition between three isotopologs present at non-tracer concentrations in the same reaction mix. This article is part of a special issue titled: Enzyme Transition States from Theory and Experiment.

A crosslinker based on a tethered electrophile for mapping kinase-substrate networks

Despite the continuing progress made toward mapping kinase signaling networks, there are still many phosphorylation events for which the responsible kinase has not yet been identified. We are interested in addressing this problem through forming covalent crosslinks between a peptide substrate and the corresponding phosphorylating kinase. Previously we reported a dialdehyde-based kinase-binding probe capable of such a reaction with a peptide containing a cysteine substituted for the phosphorylatable ser/thr/tyr residue. Here, we examine the yield of a previously reported dialdehyde-based probe and report that the dialdehyde-based probes possess a significant limitation in terms of crosslinked kinase-substrate product yield. To address this limitation, we developed a crosslinking scheme based on a kinase activity-based probe, and this crosslinker provides an increase in efficiency and substrate specificity, including in the context of cell lysate.

Probing protein kinase (CK2) and alkaline phosphatase with CdSe/ZnS quantum dots

Semiconductor quantum dots (QDs) are used for the optical analysis of casein kinase (CK2) or the hydrolytic activity of alkaline phosphatase (ALP). Two schemes for the analysis of CK2 by a FRET-based mechanism are described. One approach involves the CK2-catalyzed phosphorylation of a serine-containing peptide (1), linked to CdSe/ZnS QDs, with Atto-590-functionalized ATP. The second analytical method involves the specific association of the Atto-590-functionalized antibody to the phosphorylated product. The hydrolytic activity of ALP is followed by the application of phosphotyrosine (4)-modified CdSe/ZnS QDs in the presence of tyrosinase as a secondary reporter biocatalyst. The hydrolysis of (4) yields the tyrosine units that are oxidized by O(2)/tyrosinase to the respective dopaquinone product. The latter quinone units quench the QDs via an electron transfer route, leading to the optical detection of the ALP activity.

Protein tyrosine kinase characterization based on fully automated synthesis of (phospho) peptide arrays in microplates

In view of the importance of information transfer mediated throughout the cell by recognition, phosphorylation or dephosphorylation of kinases, their adapters, or substrates, this method was developed. The method provides a potent research tool for rapidly generating and testing these substrates as modeled by synthetic peptide arrays. The peptides or phosphorylated peptides are automatically generated on the inner surfaces of microplate wells, covalently linked to a polylysine polymer so that they are in a sterically favorable conformation, immediately available for in situ testing. Products up to 18 amino acids long have shown excellent mass spectral homogeneity. Thus, determinate peptide libraries can be ready for testing in as little as 2 days after the conception of an experiment. The process can be easily automated using robotic liquid handlers and is extremely rapid, sensitive, and economical. Optionally, the method can be upgraded to a higher throughput level using more powerful workstations with greater capacity, such as the Biomek FX, or any similar robotics capable of transfer-from-file logic to guide synthesis cycles.

Following protein kinase acivity by electrochemical means and contact angle measurements

The electrochemical analysis of the protein kinase, casein kinase, is accomplished by the voltammetric response of Ag(+) ions associated with the phosphorylated product; the sensing surface is regenerated by the cleavage of the phosphorylated product with alkaline phosphatase, and the phosphorylation/de-phosphorylation processes are monitored by XPS and contact angle measurements.

Signaling properties of a non-metazoan Src kinase and the evolutionary history of Src negative regulation

Choanoflagellates, unicellular organisms that are closely related to metazoans, possess cell adhesion and signaling proteins previously thought to be unique to animals, suggesting that these components may have played roles in the evolution of metazoan multicellularity. We have cloned, expressed, and purified the nonreceptor tyrosine kinase MbSrc1 from the choanoflagellate Monosiga brevicollis. The kinase has the same domain arrangement as mammalian Src kinases, and we find that the individual Src homology 3 (SH3), SH2, and catalytic domains have similar functions to their mammalian counterparts. In contrast to mammalian c-Src, the SH2 and catalytic domains of MbSrc1 do not appear to be functionally coupled. We cloned and expressed the M. brevicollis homolog of c-Src C-terminal kinase (MbCsk) and showed that it phosphorylates the C terminus of MbSrc1, yet this phosphorylation does not inhibit MbSrc to the same degree seen in the mammalian Src/Csk pair. Thus, Src autoinhibition likely evolved more recently within the metazoan lineage, and it may have played a role in the establishment of intercellular signaling in metazoans.

Phosphorylation of the ATP-binding loop directs oncogenicity of drug-resistant BCR-ABL mutants

The success of targeting kinases in cancer with small molecule inhibitors has been tempered by the emergence of drug-resistant kinase domain mutations. In patients with chronic myeloid leukemia treated with ABL inhibitors, BCR-ABL kinase domain mutations are the principal mechanism of relapse. Certain mutations are occasionally detected before treatment, suggesting increased fitness relative to wild-type p210 BCR-ABL. We evaluated the oncogenicity of eight kinase inhibitor-resistant BCR-ABL mutants and found a spectrum of potencies greater or less than p210. Although most fitness alterations correlate with changes in kinase activity, this is not the case with the T315I BCR-ABL mutation that confers clinical resistance to all currently approved ABL kinase inhibitors. Through global phosphoproteome analysis, we identified a unique phosphosubstrate signature associated with each drug-resistant allele, including a shift in phosphorylation of two tyrosines (Tyr253 and Tyr257) in the ATP binding loop (P-loop) of BCR-ABL when Thr315 is Ile or Ala. Mutational analysis of these tyrosines in the context of Thr315 mutations demonstrates that the identity of the gatekeeper residue impacts oncogenicity by altered P-loop phosphorylation. Therefore, mutations that confer clinical resistance to kinase inhibitors can substantially alter kinase function and confer novel biological properties that may impact disease progression.

Protein kinase structure and function analysis with chemical tools

Protein kinases are the largest enzyme superfamily involved in cell signal transduction and represent therapeutic targets for a range of diseases. There have been intensive efforts from many labs to understand their catalytic mechanisms, discover inhibitors and discern their cellular functions. In this review, we will describe two approaches developed to analyze protein kinases: bisubstrate analog inhibition and phosphonate analog utilization. Both of these methods have been used in combination with the protein semisynthesis method expressed protein ligation to advance our understanding of kinase-substrate interactions and functional elucidation of phosphorylation. Previous work on the nature of the protein kinase mechanism suggests it follows a dissociative transition state. A bisubstrate analog was designed against the insulin receptor kinase to mimic the geometry of a dissociative transition state reaction coordinate distance. This bisubstrate compound proved to be a potent inhibitor against the insulin receptor kinase and occupied both peptide and nucleotide binding sites. Bisubstrate compounds with altered hydrogen bonding potential as well as varying spacers between the adenine and the peptide demonstrate the importance of the original design features. We have also shown that related bisubstrate analogs can be used to potently block serine/threonine kinases including protein kinase A. Since many protein kinases recognize folded protein substrates for efficient phosphorylation, it was advantageous to incorporate the peptide-ATP conjugates into protein structures. Using expressed protein ligation, a Src-ATP conjugate was produced and shown to be a high affinity ligand for the Csk tyrosine kinase. Nonhydrolyzable mimics of phosphoSer/phosphoTyr can be useful in examining the functionality of phosphorylation events. Using expressed protein ligation, we have employed phosphonomethylene phenylalanine and phosphonomethylene alanine to probe the phosphorylation of Tyr and Ser, respectively. These tools have permitted an analysis of the SH2-phosphatases (SHP1 and SHP2), revealing a novel intramolecular stimulation of catalytic activity mediated by the corresponding phosphorylation events. They have also been used to characterize the cellular regulation of the melatonin rhythm enzyme by phosphorylation.

Screening for the optimal specificity profile of protein kinase C using electrospray mass-spectrometry

A peptide library approach based on electrospray mass-spectrometric (ESI-MS) detection of phosphopeptides was designed for rapid and quantitative characterization of protein kinase specificity. The k(cat)/K(m) values for the protein kinase Cbeta (PKCbeta) were determined for a systematically varied set of individual substrate peptides in library mixtures by the ESI-MS method. The analysis revealed a complex structural specificity profile in positions around the phosphorylated serine with hydrophobic and/or basic residues being mostly preferred. On the basis of the kinetic parameters, a highly efficient peptide substrate for PKCbeta (K(m)value below 100 nM) FRRRRSFRRR and its alanine substituted pseudosubstrate-analog inhibitor (K(i) value of 76 nM) were designed. The quantitative specificity profiles obtained by the new approach contained more information about kinase specificity than the conventional substrate consensus motifs. The new method presents a promising basis for design of substrate-site directed peptide or peptidomimetic inhibitors of protein kinases. Second, highly specific substrates could be designed for novel applications such as high-throughput protein kinase activity screens on protein kinase chips.

Catalytic domains of tyrosine kinases determine the phosphorylation sites within c-Cbl

Catalytic (SH1) domains of protein tyrosine kinases (PTKs) demonstrate specificity for peptide substrates. Whether SH1 domains differentiate between tyrosines in a physiological substrate has not been confirmed. Using purified proteins, we studied the ability of Syk, Fyn, and Abl to differentiate between tyrosines in a common PTK substrate, c-Cbl. We found that each kinase produced a distinct pattern of c-Cbl phosphorylation, which altered the phosphotyrosine-dependent interactions between c-Cbl and CrkL or phosphatidylinositol 3'-kinase (PI3-K). Our data support the concept that SH1 domains determine the final sites of phosphorylation once PTKs reach their target proteins.

Mapping Posttranslational Modifications of Proteins by MS‐Based Selective Detection: Application to Phosphoproteomics

This chapter outlines general principals that apply to the analysis of posttranslational modifications of proteins, with an emphasis on phosphoproteins. Mass spectrometry (MS)-based approaches for selective detection and site-specific analysis of posttranslationally modified peptides are described, and an MS-based method that relies on production and detection of fragment ions specific for the modification(s) of interest and that was developed in the authors' laboratory is described in detail. The method is applicable to selective detection of N- and O-linked carbohydrates in glycoproteins, O-linked sulfate, and N- and O-linked lipids. Detailed procedures for application of this strategy to phosphorylation-site mapping are presented here.

Target Specificity Analysis of the Abl Kinase using Peptide Microarray Data

Protein kinases play an important role in cellular signalling. The reliable prediction of their substrates is of high importance for the deciphering of signalling pathways. A recently developed peptide microarray technology for the charcterisation of protein kinases delivers data on the individual phosphorylation status of each single member of a large peptide library. This data can be used to approximate the substrate specificity of the investigated kinase. We present an approach to process the collected information using a combination of a weight matrix approach and a nearest neighbor approach. Experiments with the protein-tyrosine kinase Abl are conducted to validate the results. Randomly selected peptides (1433) are used to estimate the substrate preferences of the kinase. The obtained prediction results are compared with standard methods. The new approach is tested further on bona fide Abl phosphorylation sites.

Biochemical properties of the Cdc42-associated tyrosine kinase ACK1. Substrate specificity, authphosphorylation, and interaction with Hck

ACK1 (activated Cdc42-associated kinase 1) is a nonreceptor tyrosine kinase and the only tyrosine kinase known to interact with Cdc42. To characterize the enzymatic properties of ACK, we have expressed and purified active ACK using the baculovirus/Sf9 cell system. This ACK1 construct contains (from N to C terminus) the kinase catalytic domain, SH3 domain, and Cdc42-binding Cdc42/Rac interactive binding (CRIB) domain. We characterized the substrate specificity of ACK1 using synthetic peptides, and we show that the specificity of the ACK1 catalytic domain most closely resembles that of Abl. Purified ACK1 undergoes autophosphorylation, and autophosphorylation enhances kinase activity. We identified Tyr284 in the activation loop of ACK1 as the primary autophosphorylation site using mass spectrometry. When expressed in COS-7 cells, the Y284F mutant ACK1 showed dramatically reduced levels of tyrosine phosphorylation. Although the SH3 and CRIB domains of purified ACK1 are able to bind ligands (a polyproline peptide and Cdc42, respectively), the addition of ligands did not stimulate tyrosine kinase activity. To characterize potential interacting partners for ACK1, we screened several SH2 and SH3 domains for their ability to bind to full-length ACK1 or to the catalytic-SH3-CRIB construct. ACK1 interacts most strongly with the SH3 domains of Src family kinases (Src or Hck) via its C-terminal proline-rich domain. Co-expression of Hck with kinase-inactive ACK1(K158R) in mammalian cells resulted in tyrosine phosphorylation of ACK1, suggesting that ACK1 is a substrate for Hck. Our data suggest that Hck is a novel binding partner for ACK1 that can regulate ACK1 activity by phosphorylation.

Processive phosphorylation of p130Cas by Src depends on SH3-polyproline interactions

Many in vivo substrates of Src family tyrosine kinases possess sequences conforming to Src homology 2 and 3 (SH2 and SH3) domain-binding motifs. One such substrate is p130Cas, a protein that is hyperphosphorylated in v-Src transformed cells. Cas contains a substrate domain consisting of 15 potential tyrosine phosphorylation sites, C- and N-terminal polyproline regions fitting the consensus sequence for SH3 domain ligands, and a YDYV motif that binds the Src SH2 domain when phosphorylated. In an effort to understand the mechanisms of processive phosphorylation, we have explored the regions of Cas necessary for interaction with Src using the yeast two-hybrid system. Mutations in the SH2 domain-binding region of Cas or the Src SH2 domain have little effect in Cas-Src complex formation or phosphorylation. However, disruption of the C-terminal polyproline region of Cas completely abolishes interaction between the two proteins and results in impaired phosphorylation of Cas. Kinetic analyses using purified proteins indicated that multisite phosphorylation of Cas by Src follows a processive rather than a distributive mechanism. Furthermore, the kinetic studies show that there are two properties of the polyproline region of Cas that are important in enhancing substrate phosphorylation. First, the C-terminal polyproline serves to activate Src kinases through the process of SH3 domain displacement. Second, this region aids in anchoring the kinase to Cas to facilitate processive phosphorylation of the substrate domain. The two processes combine to ensure phosphorylation of Cas with high efficiency.

Quadrupole time-of-flight versus triple-quadrupole mass spectrometry for the determination of phosphopeptides by precursor ion scanning

An API 3000 triple-quadrupole instrument and a QSTAR Pulsar quadrupole time-of-flight (TOF) mass spectrometer were compared for the determination of phosphopeptides by precursor ion scanning in both the positive and negative nanoelectrospray ionization modes. The limits of detection for synthetic phosphopeptides were similar (500 amol microl(-1)) for both types of instruments when monitoring precursors of -79 Da (PO(3)(-)). However, the quadrupole TOF system was approximately fivefold more sensitive (1 fmol microl(-1)) than the triple-quadrupole instrument (5 fmol microl(-1)) when monitoring precursors of 216 Da (immonium ion of phosphotyrosine). The recently introduced Q(2)-pulsing function, which enhances the transmission of fragment ions of a selected m/z window from the collision cell into the TOF part, improved the sensitivity of precursor ion scans on a quadrupole TOF instrument. The selectivity of precursor ion scans is much better on quadrupole TOF systems than on triple quadrupoles because the high resolving power of the reflectron-TOF mass analyzer permits high-accuracy fragment ion selection at no expense of sensitivity. This minimizes interferences from other peptide fragment ions (a-, b-, and y- type) of the same nominal mass but with sufficient differences in their exact masses. As a result, the characteristic immonium ion of phosphotyrosine at m/z 216.043 can be utilized for the selective detection of tyrosine phosphorylated peptides. Our data suggest that, in addition to their superior performance for peptide sequencing, quadrupole TOF instruments also offer a very viable alternative to triple quadrupoles for precursor ion scanning, thus combining high sensitivity and selectivity for both MS and MS/MS experiments in one instrument.

Kinase chips hit the proteomics era

Protein kinase chips, in which kinases are tested for their ability to phosphorylate immobilized substrates, have been developed and used to evaluate the protein kinases encoded by the yeast genome. This new technology promises to be a valuable addition to the biochemists' and cell biologists' arsenal for evaluating the substrate selectivity and function of protein kinases in cell signaling.

Investigating the substrate specificity of the HER2/Neu tyrosine kinase using peptide libraries

The product of the HER2/Neu oncogene is a receptor tyrosine kinase that is amplified in 25-30% of human primary breast tumors. In this project, we have isolated the HER2/Neu kinase from Sf9 cells infected with a baculovirus expression vector. We probed the substrate specificity of the HER2/Neu kinase using two peptide libraries: (1) a soluble peptide library containing three degenerate positions N-terminal to tyrosine; and (2) a bead-supported combinatorial library possessing six degenerate positions at P-1, P-2, P-3, P+1, P+2, and P+3. We identified four novel substrate sequences for HER2/Neu from the two peptide libraries. We synthesized these peptides as individual sequences and measured steady-state kinetic properties for phosphorylation by HER2/Neu. One of the peptides, AAEEIYAARRG, is the best synthetic peptide substrate reported to date for HER2/Neu. All of the sequences bear a resemblance to sites of autophosphorylation on HER2/Neu and related epidermal growth factor (EGF) receptor family tyrosine kinases.

The substrate specificity of the catalytic domain of Abl plays an important role in directing phosphorylation of the adaptor protein Crk

c-Abl preferentially phosphorylates peptide substrates that contain proline at the P+3 site (relative to the phosphorylated tyrosine). We previously described a mutant form of the Abl catalytic domain (Y569W) with altered substrate specificity at the P+3 position, as measured using synthetic peptides. In this study, we examine the phosphorylation of Crk, a protein substrate of Abl that is phosphorylated in the sequence Tyr221-Ala-Gln-Pro. In vitro, phosphorylation of Crk by Y569W Abl is greatly reduced relative to wild-type Abl. Overexpression of Y569W mutant Abl in 293T kidney cells produces a similar overall pattern of tyrosine phosphorylation as wild-type Abl, indicating that not all cellular proteins depend on Pro at P+3 for Abl recognition. However, phosphorylation of Crk by Y569W Abl in these cells is markedly reduced relative to wild-type Abl. A truncated form of Abl lacking the C-terminal polyproline region is not able to phosphorylate Crk in these assay conditions. Thus, proper phosphorylation of Crk by Abl depends not only on the interaction of the Crk SH3 domain with the Abl polyproline region, but also on the recognition of amino acids surrounding tyrosine by the Abl catalytic domain.

Dab1 tyrosine phosphorylation sites relay positional signals during mouse brain development

BACKGROUND

The extracellular protein Reln controls neuronal migrations in parts of the cortex, hippocampus and cerebellum. In vivo, absence of Reln correlates with up-regulation of the docking protein Dab1 and decreased Dab1 tyrosine phosphorylation. Loss of the Reln receptor proteins, apolipoprotein receptor 2 and very low density lipoprotein receptor, results in a Reln-like phenotype accompanied by increased Dab1 protein expression. Complete loss of Dab1, however, recapitulates the Reln phenotype.

RESULTS

To determine whether Dab1 tyrosine phosphorylation affects Dab1 protein expression and positioning of embryonic neurons, we have identified Dab1 tyrosine phosphorylation sites. We then generated mice in which the Dab1 protein had all the potential tyrosine phosphorylation sites mutated. This mutant protein is not tyrosine phosphorylated during brain development and is not upregulated to the extent observed in the Reln or the apoER2 and VLDLR receptor mutants. Animals expressing the non-phosphorylated Dab1 protein have a phenotype similar to the dab1-null mutant.

CONCLUSIONS

Dab1 is downregulated by the Reln signal in neurons in the absence of tyrosine phosphorylation. Dab1 tyrosine phosphorylation sites and not downregulation of Dab1 protein are required for Reln signaling.

Identification of residues involved in v-Src substrate recognition by site-directed mutagenesis

To study the role of the catalytic domain in v-Src substrate specificity, we engineered three site-directed mutants (Leu-472 to Tyr or Trp and Thr-429 to Met). The mutant forms of Src were expressed in Sf9 cells and purified. We analyzed the substrate specificities of wild-type v-Src and the mutants using two series of peptides that varied at residues C-terminal to tyrosine. The peptides contained either the YMTM motif found in insulin receptor substrate-1 (IRS-1) or the YGEF motif identified from peptide library experiments to be the optimal sequence for Src. Mutations at positions Leu-472 or Thr-429 caused changes in substrate specificity at positions P+1 and P+3 (i.e. one or three residues C-terminal to tyrosine). This was particularly evident in the case of the L-472W mutant, which had pronounced alterations in its preferences at the P+1 position. The results suggest that residue Leu-472 plays a role in P+1 substrate recognition by Src. We discuss the results in the light of recent work on the roles of the SH2, SH3 and catalytic domains of Src in substrate specificity.

Applications of mass spectrometry to signal transduction

Advances in mass spectrometry instrumentation, protocols for sample handling, and computational methods provide powerful new approaches to solving problems in analytical biochemistry. This review summarizes recent work illustrating ways in which mass spectrometry has been used to address questions relevant to signal transduction. Rather than encompass all of the instruments or methodologies that might be brought to bear on these problems, we present an overview of commonly used techniques, promising new methodologies, and some applications.

Physico-chemical and biological analysis of true combinatorial libraries

Combinatorial libraries offer new sources of compounds for the research of pharmacological agents such as receptor ligands, enzyme inhibitors or substrates and antibody-binding epitopes. The present review stresses the main roles played by both physico-chemical analysis, particularly when complex mixture of compounds are synthesized as libraries, and biological analysis from which active compounds are identified. After a brief discussion of semantic problems related to the designation of the product mixtures, the physico-chemical analysis of mixtures is reviewed with special emphasis on mass spectrometric techniques. These methods are able both to give a representative view of a library composition and to identify single critical compounds in large libraries. Then the biological screening of such combinatorial libraries is critically discussed with respect to the power and limitations of the methods used for the identification of the active components. Special attention is given to the complex process of library deconvolution. It is pointed out that while combinatorial techniques have evolved towards sophisticated high-tech methods, simple and robust biochemical tests should be used to deconvolute. From a large panel of published examples, a set of trends are identified which should help investigators to choose the most appropriate assay for the discovery of new entities.

Impact of mass spectrometry on combinatorial chemistry

In the past few years, the emergence of combinatorial chemistry has drawn increasing attention and a great deal of analytical research has been centered around this new methodology. These new methods capable of producing vast numbers of samples, which are in many cases highly complex, demand fast and reliable analytical techniques able to provide high quality information concerning sample compositions. Mass spectrometry (MS) is the method of choice to face these analytical challenges. In particular, the introduction of electrospray ionization (ESI and matrix assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) have been the driving forces for many of the recent innovations, not only within the fields of the biosciences, but also in combinatorial chemistry. These ionization techniques are extremely versatile for the characterization of both single compound collections and compound mixture collections. The high-throughput capabilities, as well as many possible couplings with separation techniques (HPLC, CE) have been thus facilitated. However, mass spectrometry is not only limited to use as an instrument for synthesis control, but also plays an increasing role in the identification of active compounds from complex libraries. Recently, new initiatives for library analysis and screening have arisen from the application of the latest developments in mass spectrometry, Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (FTICR).

Engineering the substrate specificity of the Abl tyrosine kinase

c-Abl is a non-receptor tyrosine kinase that is involved in a variety of signaling pathways. Activated forms of c-Abl are associated with some forms of human leukemia. Presently, no high resolution structure of the tyrosine kinase domain of Abl is available. We have developed a structural homology model of the catalytic domain of Abl based on the crystal structure of the insulin receptor tyrosine kinase. Using this model as a guide, we selected residues near the active site predicted to play a role in peptide/protein substrate recognition. We expressed and purified 15 mutant forms of Abl with single amino acid substitutions at these positions and tested their peptide substrate specificity. We report here the identification of seven residues involved in recognition of the P-1, P+1, and P+3 positions of bound peptide substrate. Mutations in these residues cause distinct changes in substrate specificity. The results suggest features of Abl substrate recognition that may be relevant to related tyrosine kinases.

Electrospray tandem mass spectrometric studies of phosphopeptides and phosphopeptide analogues

A set of synthetic phosphopeptides and phosphopeptide analogues was studied by tandem nano-electrospray mass spectrometry. The influence of the collision offset and of the charge state of the molecular ion on phosphate-specific fragmentation processes was investigated in detail. H--D exchange experiments and structural considerations support a six-centered transition being present in the neutral loss of H3PO4 from serine, threonine and homoserine phosphopeptides, where the C-alpha hydrogen of serine or threonine or the C-beta hydrogen of homoserine is transferred to the protonated phosphate group. Neutral loss of H3PO4 at moderate collision offset potential represents a very abundant fragmentation process for serine, threonine and homoserine phosphopeptides. The most specific feature for discrimination of these phosphopeptides from tyrosine phosphopeptides is the m/z 79:97 ratio in the negative ion product spectra, which is consistently elevated in tyrosine phosphopeptides as compared with serine, threonine and homoserine phosphopeptides. The fragment ions of methylphosphono- and H-phosphonopeptides can be explained by the same mechanisms as are applicable to phosphopeptides.

Highly efficient green fluorescent protein-based kinase substrates

We have developed a general strategy for designing efficient protein substrates of protein kinases by attaching a phosphorylatable peptide sequence to the C-terminus of His6-tagged green fluorescent protein (GFP). We found that several C-terminal attachment sites in GFP allow for correct presentation of the phosphorylatable tail to a variety of protein kinases. Using this strategy, we have constructed highly efficient GFP-based substrates for Src, c-Abl, protein kinase A, and protein kinase C betaII protein kinases. The engineered GFP substrate for Src (GFP235IYGEFG) is 300 times more efficient than the protein most commonly used as a Src substrate-rabbit muscle enolase.

Investigation of S-farnesyl transferase substrate specificity with combinatorial tetrapeptide libraries

Using biased tetrapeptide libraries made up of proteinogenic amino acids of the general formula Cys-O2-X3-X4, we searched for new substrates of partly purified rat brain S-farnesyl transferase (FTase). To achieve this task, an assay was developed in which the consumption of the co-substrate (farnesyl pyrophosphate) was measured. After three steps of deconvolution including each synthesis and enzymatic assay, the most efficient substrates found under these particular conditions were Cys-Lys-Gln-Gln (peptide I) and Cys-Lys-Gln-Met (peptide II). As a control, we used another tetrapeptide library (Cys-Val-O3-X4) in which the valine position was arbitrarily fixed, corresponding to Cys-Val-Ile-Met in the CAAX box of K-RasB, although this sublibrary was only marginally active compared with Cys-Lys-X3-X4 in the first round of deconvolution. The best substrate sublibrary was Cys-Val-Thr-X4, threonine being more favourable than the aliphatic amino acids (Val, Ile, Leu, Ala) in this position. Deconvolution finally led to Cys-Val-Thr-Gln, -Met, -Thr and -Ser as the most efficient substrates of FTase. Those tetrapeptides were not substrates of a partly purified geranylgeranyl transferase 1 (GGTase1). We also investigated the influence of the -1 position (at the N-terminus of cysteine) on the specificity of the enzyme, by using a series of pentapeptides constructed on the basis of the best tetrapeptide core (peptide 1). Among this family of analogues, only His-Cys-Lys-Gln-Gln did not behave as a substrate, whereas all the other pentapeptides were measurable substrates, with Gly-, Asn- and Thr-Cys-Lys-Gln-Gln displaying kinetic constants similar to that of Cys-Lys-Gln-Gln. The present work provides strong evidence that the best tetrapeptide substrates of FTase do not necessarily belong to the classical CAAX box, in which A's are lipophilic residues, but rather contain hydrophilic amino acids in the middle of their sequences. Among them, peptides I and II are potent FTase in vitro substrates that are not recognised by GGTase1 and might be new starting points for the design of FTase inhibitors.

Phosphorylation and activation of cGMP-dependent protein kinase by Src

Using information obtained from experiments with peptide substrates of v-Src, a motif within the cGMP-binding domain of cGMP-dependent protein kinase (cGK) was identified as a potential phosphorylation site for v-Src. Here we show that the purified Ialpha isozyme of cGK is phosphorylated stoichiometrically and in a time-dependent manner by purified Src in vitro. The kinase activity of cGK is elevated approximately 4-fold (relative to autophosphorylated cGK) or 10-fold (relative to unphosphorylated cGK) upon tyrosine phosphorylation by Src. Phosphorylation of cGK by v-Src produces modest effects on the cGMP-binding properties and dissociation rates of cGK, and reduces the kact for cGMP. We hypothesize that the mechanism of activation may involve coupling of the cGMP binding domain to the catalytic domain.

Enhanced phosphorylation of Src family kinase substrates containing SH2 domain binding sites

Src family protein-tyrosine kinases possess several modular domains important for regulation of catalytic activity and interaction with potential substrates. Here, we explore interactions between the SH2 domain of Hck, a Src family kinase, and substrates containing SH2 domain-binding sites. We have synthesized a series of peptide substrates containing a high affinity SH2 domain binding site, (phospho)Tyr-Glu-Glu-Ile. We show that the presence of this sequence in a peptide results in a dramatic increase in the phosphorylation rate of a second tyrosine located at the N terminus. Enhanced phosphorylation is not a consequence of stimulation of enzymatic activity by C-terminal tail displacement but is imparted instead by a 10-fold reduction in the Km of the phosphotyrosine-containing peptide when compared with a control. The isolated catalytic domain of the non-receptor tyrosine kinase Abl does not show a preference for the pYEEI motif-containing peptide; however, the preference is restored when the SH2 domain of Src is introduced into Abl. Furthermore, enhanced phosphorylation is dependent on the distance between SH2 domain-binding site and phosphorylatable tyrosine, with the minimum distance requirement being seven amino acids. Reversing the orientation of the pYEEI motif with respect to the substrate sequence decreases phosphorylation by down-regulated Hck, but both orientations are utilized equally well by activated Hck. We discuss the possible implications of these results for processive phosphorylation of substrates in vivo by Src family kinases.

Protein phosphorylation: technologies for the identification of phosphoamino acids

Protein phosphorylation plays a central role in many biological and biomedical phenomena. In this review, while a brief overview of the occurrence and function of protein phosphorylation is given, the primary focus is on studies related to the detection and analysis of phosphorylation both in vivo and in vitro. We focus on phosphorylation of serine, threonine and tyrosine, the most commonly phosphorylated amino acids in eukaryotes. Technologies such as radiolabelling, antibody recognition, chromatographic methods (HPLC, TLC), electrophoresis, Edman sequencing and mass spectrometry are reviewed. We consider the speed, simplicity and sensitivity of tools for detection and identification of protein phosphorylation, as well as quantitation and site characterisation. The limitations of currently available methods are summarised.

The design, synthesis and activity of pentapeptide pp60c-src inhibitors containing L-phosphotyrosine mimics

Efficient syntheses of 4-(R,S-hydroxyphosphonomethyl)-L-phenylalanine and 4-carboxy-L-phenylalanine within the context of the pentapeptide Ac-Ile-X-Gly-Glu-Phe-NH2 (wherein X = the unnatural amino acid) illustrate the use of a divergent synthetic strategy from an advanced common peptide intermediate to more readily access peptide-based tyrosine kinase inhibitors. The key intermediate, Ac-Ile-Phe(4-formyl)-Gly-Glu(O-tBu)-Phe-NH2, was synthesized by a facile palladium-catalyzed carbonylation of Ac-Ile-Phe(4-iodo)-Gly-Glu(O-tBu)-Phe-NH2. Oxidation of Ac-Ile-Phe(4-formyl)-Gly-Glu(O-tBu)-Phe-NH2 with tetrabutylammonium permanganate or addition of di-t-butylphosphite, both followed by trifluoroacetic acid deprotection, gave the target pentapeptide inhibitors wherein X = 4-carboxy-L-phenylalanine or 4-(R,S-hydroxyphosphonomethyl)-L-phenylalanine, respectively. These two peptides gave somewhat more potent inhibition of the tyrosine kinase pp60c-src than the corresponding pentapeptide wherein X = L-phenylalanine, demonstrating that appended functionalities at the 4-position are accepted and can enhance binding through added interactions within the catalytic region of the active site.

Selection of substrate recognition sequence of protein kinase with ferric chelation affinity chromatography

Protein kinase substrate phage (PKS phage) was constructed by fusing the substrate recognition consensus sequence of CAMP-dependent protein kinase (cAPK) with bacteriophage minor coat protein g3p and by displaying it on the surface of filamentous bacteriophage fd. Phosphorylationin vitro by cAPK showed a unique labelled band of approximately 60 ku, which was consistent with the molecular weight of the PKS-g3p fusion protein. Some weakly phosphorylated bands for both PKS phage and wild-type phage were also observed. Phage display random 15-rner peptide library phosphorylated by cAPK was selected with ferric (Fe(3+)) chelation affinity resin. After 4 rounds of screening, phage clones were picked out to determine the displayed peptide sequences by DNA sequencing. The results showed that 5 of 14 sequenced phages displayed the cAPK recognition sequence motif (R)RXS/T. Theirin vitro phosphorylation analyses revealed the specific labelled bands corresponding to the positive PKS phages with and without the typical (R)RXS/T sequence motif. It suggested that the new method of using ferric (Fe(3+)) chelation affinity chromamraphy to identify the substrate specificity of protein kinase from random peptide library was feasible.

Activation of the Src-family tyrosine kinase Hck by SH3 domain displacement

The protein Hck is a member of the Src family of non-receptor tyrosine kinases which is preferentially expressed in haematopoietic cells of the myeloid and B-lymphoid lineages. Src kinases are inhibited by tyrosine-phosphorylation at a carboxy-terminal site. The SH2 domains of these enzymes play an essential role in this regulation by binding to the tyrosine-phosphorylated tail. The crystal structure of the downregulated form of Hck has been determined and reveals that the SH2 domain regulates enzymatic activity indirectly; intramolecular interactions between the SH3 and catalytic domains appear to stabilize an inactive form of the kinase. Here we compare the roles of the SH2 and SH3 domains in modulating the activity of Hck in an investigation of the C-terminally phosphorylated form of the enzyme. We show that addition of the HIV-1 Nef protein, which is a high-affinity ligand for the Hck SH3 domain, to either the downregulated or activated form of Hck causes a large increase in Hck catalytic activity. The intact SH3-binding motif in Nef is crucial for Hck activation. Our results indicate that binding of the Hck SH3 domain by Nef causes a more marked activation of the enzyme than does binding of the SH2 domain, suggesting a new mechanism for regulation of the activity of tyrosine kinases.

Amino-terminal sequence determinants for substrate recognition by platelet-derived growth factor receptor tyrosine kinase

The specificity of protein kinases has been shown to be influenced by residues near the phosphoaccepting amino acid. To examine the determinants for platelet-derived growth factor receptor (PDGFR) tyrosine kinase specificity, a peptide library with three degenerate positions N-terminal to tyrosine was constructed. After reaction with PDGFR, the most abundant phosphopeptides were isolated by immunoaffinity chromatography on a column containing monoclonal anti-phosphotyrosine antibody. Further separation of bound phosphopeptides with reverse-phase HPLC led to the identification of three optimal substrates for PDGFR: Ala-Ala-Asn-Ile-Thr-Tyr-Ala-Ala-Arg-Arg-Gly, Ala-Ala-Asn-Arg-Thr-Tyr-Ala-Ala-Arg-Arg-Gly and Ala-Ala-Leu-Ile-Thr-Tyr-Ala-Ala-Arg-Arg-Gly, where underlined residues are in the degenerate positions of the peptide library. Kinetic analyses of the three individual peptides (synthesized separately) showed these peptides to be among the best reported substrates for PDGFR. Our results expand the range of amino acid residues that have been shown to serve as recognition elements for receptor tyrosine kinases.

Tyrosine protein kinase assays

Protein kinases form a large family of enzymes that play a major role in a number of live processes. The study of their action is important for the understanding of the transformation mechanisms and of the normal and pathological growth events. The quality of an enzyme assay is often the key point of an enzymatic study. It must be flexible and compatible with various experimental conditions, such as those for the purification process, the screening of inhibitors and the substrate specificity studies. As will be shown in the present review, two categories of substrates, peptidic and proteic, should be distinguished. The use of peptide substrates facilitates the determination of the recognition requirements of the enzyme and of the kinetic effects of even minute variations in their sequence. These linear peptide structures are assumed to mimic a complex interaction between the enzyme and a protein substrate in which distant amino acids in the sequence are vicinal in the folded substrate. Less amenable to a systematic study, but probably more adequate to investigate the natural substrate of a given kinase, are the proteic substrates. Obviously the tools to measure protein kinase activities are not the same in these two cases. The main difficulty in assaying protein kinases is the use of labelled gamma-ATP, mostly at large excess concentration, since the final product of the reaction has to be separated from the non-reacted labelled ATP. In the case of peptide substrates, the difficulty is to separate them from ATP basing on differences of molecular mass. Despite the efforts of many investigators to rely upon differences in solubility, in charges or in "affinity", this separation, which is crucial for the assay, is still an unsolved experimental problem. Chromatographic, as well as electrophoretic assays appeared relatively late in this domain, and more work in assessing new methodologies might bring new breakthroughs in the next few years. Specific, simple and reliable kinase assays are still a major challenge. Their improvement will help to conduct specificity studies, to elucidate complex growth mechanisms in which they are involved and to discover more selective potent inhibitors.

Precision substrate targeting of protein kinases v-Abl and c-Src

The active site substrate specificities of v-Abl and c-Src are compared and contrasted. Both enzymes catalyze the phosphorylation of a broad assortment of peptide-bound aliphatic and aromatic alcohols, such as achiral and simple straight chain residues. In addition, both protein kinases exhibit a "dual specificity" with respect to the ability to utilize D- and L-configurational isomers as substrates. However, c-Src and v-Abl are extremely inefficient as catalysts for certain structural arrangements, including secondary alcohols and primary alcohols containing large substituents in close proximity to the hydroxyl moiety. In addition to these similarities, these enzymes also display noteworthy differences in catalytic behavior. Whereas c-Src exhibits a modest preference for aromatic versus aliphatic alcohols, v-Abl does not. Most dramatic is the ability of c-Src to utilize short chain alcohols as substrates, an activity virtually absent from the catalytic repertoire of v-Abl. The implications of these observations are 2-fold. First, because both enzymes are able to accommodate a wide variety of structural variants within their respective active site regions, there exists a substantial degree of flexibility with respect to inhibitor design. Second, because these enzymes exhibit disparate active site specificities, it is possible that other tyrosine-specific protein kinases will display unique substrate specificities as well. Consequently, it may ultimately be possible to exploit these differences to generate inhibitors that precisely target specific protein kinases.

Exploration of the sequence specificity of pp60c-src tyrosine kinase. Minimal peptide sequence required for maximal activity

The minimum length required for phosphorylation of a peptide by pp60c-src tyrosine kinase (srcTK) was delineated in this work. Budde (M.D. Anderson University of Texas, personal communication) suggested that the peptide (FGE)3Y(GEF)2GD (peptide I) was a "good" srcTK substrate. Peptide I yielded a 251-fold higher kcat/Km than RRLIEDAEYAARRG, a peptide substrate based upon the autophosphorylation site of srcTK. This was due to a 38-fold lower Km and a 6.6-fold increase in kcat.N-terminal truncation of up to 8 residues in a series of peptides yielded only a 3-fold decrease in activity. Removal of the final N-terminal residue resulted in a 10-fold loss in substrate activity, primarily as a result of an increase in the Km. C-terminal truncations ending in the amide yielded no significant loss in activity until the Y + 3 residue was removed, which resulted in a 73-fold decrease in kcat/Km relative to peptide I. The latter was due primarily to an increase in Km. The results from peptides truncated on both termini suggest that subsite recognition N- and C-terminal relative to the site of phosphorylation can be examined independently. In addition, the observation that only 5 residues are required for significant substrate activity suggests that small molecule inhibitors based upon interactions with the phosphoacceptor site may be developed.