Copolymerization of normal type I collagen with three mutated type I collagens containing substitutions of cysteine at different glycine positions in the alpha 1 (I) chain

Potential implications of the glycosylation patterns in collagen α1(I) and α2(I) chains for fibril assembly and growth

O-Glycosylation of hydroxylysine (Hyl) in collagen occurs at an early stage of biosynthesis before the triple-helix has formed. This simple post-translational modification (PTM) of lysine by either a galactosyl or glucosylgalactosyl moiety is highly conserved in collagens and depends on the species, type of tissue and the collagen amino acid sequence. The structural/functional reason why only specific lysines are modified is poorly understood, and has led to increased efforts to map the sites of PTMs on collagen sequences from different species and to ascertain their potential role in vivo. To investigate this, we purified collagen type I (Col1) from the skins of four animals, then used mass spectrometry and proteomic techniques to identify lysines that were oxidised, galactosylated, glucosylgalactosylated, or glycated in its mature sequence. We found 18 out of the 38 lysines in collagen type Iα1, (Col1A1) and 7 of the 30 lysines in collagen type Iα2 (Col1A2) were glycosylated. Six of these modifications had not been reported before, and included a lysine involved in crosslinking collagen molecules. A Fourier transform analysis of the positions of the glycosylated hydroxylysines showed they display a regular axial distribution with the same d-period observed in collagen fibrils. The significance of this finding in terms of the assembly of collagen molecules into fibrils and of potential restrictions on the growth of the collagen fibrils is discussed.

Collagen fibril formation in vitro: From origin to opportunities

Sometimes, to move forward, it is necessary to look back. Collagen type I is one of the most commonly used biomaterials in tissue engineering and regenerative medicine. There are a variety of collagen scaffolds and biomedical products based on collagen have been made, and the development of new ones is still ongoing. Materials, where collagen is in the fibrillar form, have some advantages: they have superior mechanical properties, higher degradation time and, what is most important, mimic the structure of the native extracellular matrix. There are some standard protocols for the formation of collagen fibrils in vitro, but if we look more carefully at those methods, we can see some controversies. For example, why is the formation of collagen gel commonly carried out at 37 ​°C, when it was well investigated that the temperature higher than 35 ​°C results in a formation of not well-ordered fibrils? Biomimetic collagen materials can be obtained both using culture medium or neutralizing solution, but it requires a deep understanding of all of the crucial points. One of this point is collagen extraction method, since not every method retains the ability of collagen to reconstitute native banded fibrils. Collagen polymorphism is also often overlooked in spite of the appearance of different polymorphic forms during fibril formation is possible, especially when collagen blends are utilized. In this review, we will not only pay attention to these issues, but we will overview the most prominent works related to the formation of collagen fibrils in vitro starting from the first approaches and moving to the up-to-date recipes.

Predicting the clinical lethality of osteogenesis imperfecta from collagen glycine mutations

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI), or brittle bone disease, often results from missense mutation of one of the conserved glycine residues present in the repeating Gly-X-Y sequence characterizing the triple-helical region of type I collagen. A composite model was developed for predicting the clinical lethality resulting from glycine mutations in the alpha1 chain of type I collagen. The lethality of mutations in which bulky amino acids are substituted for glycine is predicted by their position relative to the N-terminal end of the triple helix. The effect of a Gly --> Ser mutation is modeled by the relative thermostability of the Gly-X-Y triplet on the carboxy side of the triplet containing the substitution. This model also predicts the lethality of Gly --> Ser and Gly --> Cys mutations in the alpha2 chain of type I collagen. The model was validated with an independent test set of six novel Gly --> Ser mutations. The hypothesis derived from the model of an asymmetric interaction between a Gly --> Ser mutation and its neighboring residues was tested experimentally using collagen-like peptides. Consistent with the prediction, a significant decrease in stability, calorimetric enthalpy, and folding time was observed for a peptide with a low-stability triplet C-terminal to the mutation compared to a similar peptide with the low-stability triplet on the N-terminal side. The computational and experimental results together relate the position-specific effects of Gly --> Ser mutations to the local structural stability of collagen and lend insight into the etiology of OI.

High-affinity binding of the NC1 domain of collagen VII to laminin 5 and collagen IV

Anchoring functions of collagen VII depend on its ability to form homotypic fibrils and to bind to other macromolecules to form heterotypic complexes. Biosensor-based binding assays were employed to analyze the kinetics of the NC1 domain-mediated binding of collagen VII to laminin 5, collagen IV, and collagen I. We showed that collagen VII interacts with laminin 5 and collagen IV with a Kd value of 10(-9) M. In contrast, the NC1-mediated binding to collagen I was weak with a Kd value of 10(-6) M. Binding assays also showed that the NC1 domain utilizes the same region to bind to both laminin 5 and collagen IV. We postulate that the ability of the NC1 domains to bind with high affinities to laminin 5 and collagen IV facilitates stabilization of the structure of the basement membrane itself and that the NC1-collagen I interaction may be less important for stabilization of the dermal-epidermal junction.

Targeted disruption of dermatopontin causes abnormal collagen fibrillogenesis

Gene targeting of a member of small leucine-rich repeat proteoglycans demonstrates that collagen fibrillogenesis is mediated by a set of extracellular matrix components, which interact with collagen. Collagen-associated protein dermatopontin knockout mice were generated in order to analyze the biologic involvement of dermatopontin in the formation of collagen fibrils. Although dermatopontin-null mice did not exhibit any obvious anatomical abnormality, skin elasticity was increased. Skin tensile tests revealed that the initial elastic modulus was 57% lower in dermatopontin-null mice than in wild-type mice, and that maximum tensile strength was similar. Remarkably, light microscopy study showed a significant decrease in the relative thickness of the dermis in dermatopontin-null mice compared with wild-type mice (45.2 +/- 3.09% and 57.8 +/- 4.25%, respectively). The skin collagen content was 40% lower in dermatopontin-null than in wild-type mice. Collagen fibrils in dermatopontin-null mice showed a great variety in diameter and irregular contours under the electron microscope. These data indicate that dermatopontin plays a critical role in elasticity of skin and collagen accumulation attributed to collagen fibrillogenesis in vivo.

Direct quantification of the flexibility of type I collagen monomer

Collagens are the most abundant structural proteins found in the extracellular matrix of vertebrates. Knowledge of the mechanical behavior of collagen monomers is essential for understanding the mechanical properties of collagen fibrils that constitute the main architectural framework of skin, bone, cartilage, and other connective tissues. In this study, the flexibility of type I collagen monomer was studied by stretching type I collagen monomers directly. The force-extension relationship was measured and analyzed by fitting the data into a worm-like chain elasticity model. The persistence length of collagen I monomer was determined to be 14.5 nm and the contour length was 309 nm. The results confirm that type I collagen monomer is flexible rather than rigid, rod-like molecule. Such flexibility may possibly be a consequence of the micro-unfolding of discrete domains of single collagen molecule.

Procollagen with skipping of alpha 1(I) exon 41 has lower binding affinity for alpha 1(I) C-telopeptide, impaired in vitro fibrillogenesis, and altered fibril morphology

Previous in vitro data on type I collagen self-assembly into fibrils suggested that the amino acid 776-796 region of the alpha1(I) chain is crucial for fibril formation because it serves as the recognition site for the telopeptide of a docking collagen monomer. We used a natural collagen mutation with a deletion of amino acids 766-801 to confirm the importance of this region for collagen fibril formation. The proband has type III osteogenesis imperfecta and is heterozygous for a COL1A1 IVS 41 A(+4) --> C substitution. The intronic mutation causes splicing of exon 41, confirmed by sequencing of normal and shorter reverse transcriptase-PCR products. Reverse transcriptase-PCR using RNA from proband dermal fibroblasts and clonal cell lines showed the mutant cDNA was about 15% of total alpha1(I) cDNA. The mutant transcript is translated; structurally abnormal alpha chains are demonstrated in the cell layer of proband fibroblasts by SDS-urea-PAGE. The proportion of mutant chains in the secreted procollagen was determined to be 10% by resistance to digestion with MMP-1, since chains lacking exon 41 are missing the vertebral collagenase cleavage site. Secreted proband collagen was used for analysis of kinetics of binding of alpha1(I) C-telopeptide using an optical biosensor. Telopeptide had slower association and faster dissociation from proband than from normal collagen. Purified proband pC-collagen was used to study fibril formation. The presence of the mutant molecules decreases the rate of fibril formation. The fibrils formed in the presence of 10-15% mutant molecules have strikingly increased length compared with normal collagen, but are well organized, as demonstrated by D-periodicity. These results suggest that some collagen molecules containing the mutant chain are incorporated into fibrils and that the absence of the telopeptide binding region from even a small portion of the monomers interferes with fibril growth. Both abnormal fibrils and slower remodeling may contribute to the severe phenotype.in

Y-position collagen II mutation disrupts cartilage formation and skeletal development in a transgenic mouse model of spondyloepiphyseal dysplasia

Mice were generated by pronuclear injection of a type II collagen transgene harboring an Arg789Cys (R789C) mutation that has been found in patients with spondyloepiphyseal dysplasia (SED). Expression was directed to cartilage by the murine Col2a1 promoter to examine the consequences of mutations involving the Y-position of the collagen helix Gly-X-Y triplet on skeletogenesis. The transgenic mice had very short limbs, short trunk, short snout, and cleft palate; they died at birth. Their growth plates were disorganized and collagen fibrils were sparse in cartilage matrix. When the transgene was expressed in RCS cells, there was no evidence that R789C-bearing collagen chains were incorporated into stable collagen molecules. Molecular modeling of the mutation raised the possibility that it destabilizes the collagen triple helix. Together our results suggest that Y-position mutations, such as R789C, can act in a dominant negative manner to destabilize collagen molecules during assembly, reducing their availability to form fibrils, the deficiency of which profoundly disturbs the template functions of cartilage during skeletogenesis.

Folding defects in fibrillar collagens

Fibrillar collagens have a long triple helix in which glycine is in every third position for more than 1000 amino acids. The three chains of these molecules are assembled with specificity into several different molecules that have tissue-specific distribution. Mutations that alter folding of either the carboxy-terminal globular peptides that direct chain association, or of the regions of the triple helix that are important for nucleation, or of the bulk of the triple helix, all result in identifiable genetic disorders in which the phenotype reflects the region of expression of the genes and their tissue-specific distribution. Mutations that result in changed amino-acid sequences in any of these regions have different effects on folding and may have different phenotypic outcomes. Substitution for glycine residues in the triple helical domains are among the most common effects of mutations, and the nature of the substituting residue and its location in the chain contribute to the effect on folding and also on the phenotype. More complex mutations, such as deletions or insertions of triple helix, also affect folding, probably because of alterations in helical pitch along the triple helix. These mutations all interfere with the ability of these molecules to form the characteristic fibrillar array in the extracellular matrix and many result in intracellular retention of abnormal molecules.

Osteogenesis imperfecta: perspectives and opportunities

The last 2 years have seen additions proposed to the very limited armamentarium of treatments for osteogenesis imperfecta. These include the use of bisphosphonates to decrease bone resorption, growth hormone to augment growth and collagen production, and bone marrow transplantation to create chimeras at the level of the collagen production unit in bone. Although there are optimistic proponents for each strategy, the lack of well-controlled studies and the absence of clearly defined objectives for therapy hinder clear assessment.

Urinary galactosyl-hydroxylysine in postmenopausal osteoporotic women: A potential marker of bone fragility

Alterations of the collagen matrix, e.g., increased hydroxylation and glycosylation of lysyl residues in collagen I, were found in human osteoporotic bone, and it was suggested that they could alter the mechanical properties of skeleton. To test this hypothesis, we evaluated the content of galactosyl-hydroxylysine (GHYL) in bone collagen, as assessed by its urinary excretion, and related it to the occurrence of fracture. Two hundred and fifteen unselected postmenopausal women with osteoporosis were divided in two subgroups (comparable for age, age of menopause, bone mineral density, and biochemical parameters of bone turnover) on the basis of the history of fragility fracture; 115 patients had suffered no fracture and 100 patients had suffered one or more fractures 3 or more years before. Four urinary markers of bone turnover (hydroxyproline, cross-linked N-telopeptide, free deoxypyridoline, and GHYL) were evaluated in all patients. There was no difference between the two groups with regard to all the parameters studied except for GHYL, which was significantly higher in the group with a history of fracture (1.35 +/- 0.82 mmol/mol of creatinine [Cr] versus 1.03 +/- <0.48 mmol/mol Cr, p < 0.001); this marker did not correlate with other markers of bone remodeling in the fracture group, indicating a possible defect in bone collagen. In conclusion, provided that increased levels of urinary GHYL do reflect overglycosylation of hydroxylysine in bone collagen, the GHYL may be considered a marker of bone collagen quality. Our results, showing higher urinary GHYL in osteoporosis patients with fracture, seem to confirm this suggestion.

Collagen II containing a Cys substitution for Arg-alpha1-519. Analysis by atomic force microscopy demonstrates that mutated monomers alter the topography of the surface of collagen II fibrils

A recombinant human procollagen II was prepared that contained a substitution of Cys for Arg at alpha1-519 and that was found in five families with early onset generalized osteoarthritis with or without features of a mild chondrodysplasia. Previously, the presence of mutated monomers in mixtures with wildtype collagen II was shown to increase the lag period for fibril assembly. Also, the fibrils were more loosely packed and some thick fibrils lacked a D-periodic banding pattern. Here we re-examined the fibrils using a combination of transmission electron microscopy and atomic force microscopy. The presence of the mutated monomers increased the diameter of the thin filaments that were consistently formed in association with the thick fibrils of collagen II. In addition, the presence of the mutated monomers increased the depth of the gap regions in all fibrils with a distinct D-periodic banding pattern. The results, therefore, may indicate that the mutated monomers formed two or three additional outer layers of monomers in 0D-period staggers on the surface of the fibrils. Apparently, the mutated monomers were bound on the surface through intermolecular disulfide bonds.

Collagen II containing a Cys substitution for arg-alpha1-519. Homotrimeric monomers containing the mutation do not assemble into fibrils but alter the self-assembly of the normal protein

A recombinant system was used to prepare human type II procollagen containing the substitution of Cys for Arg at alpha1-519 found in three unrelated families with early onset generalized osteoarthritis together with features of a mild chondrodysplasia probably best classified as spondyloepiphyseal dysplasia. In contrast to mutated procollagens containing Cys substitutions for obligatory Gly residues, the Cys substitution at alpha1-519 did not generate any intramolecular disulfide bonds. The results were consistent with computer modeling experiments that demonstrated that the alpha carbon distances were shorter with Cys substitutions for obligatory Gly residues than with Cys substitutions in the Y position residues in repeating -Gly-X-Y- sequences of the collagen triple helix. The mutated collagen did not assemble into fibrils under conditions in which the normal monomers polymerized. However, the presence of the mutated monomer in mixtures with normal collagen II increased the lag time for fibril assembly and altered the morphology of the fibrils formed.

Assembly in vitro of thin and thick fibrils of collagen II from recombinant procollagen II. The monomers in the tips of thick fibrils have the opposite orientation from monomers in the growing tips of collagen I fibrils

Human type II procollagen was prepared in a recombinant system and cleaved to pC-collagen II by procollagen N-proteinase. The pC-collagen II was then used as a substrate to generate collagen II fibrils by cleavage with procollagen C-proteinase at 37 degrees C. Electron microscopy of the fibrils demonstrated that, at the early stages of fibril assembly, very thin fibrils were formed. As the system approached equilibrium over 7-12 h, however, the thin fibrils were largely but not completely replaced by thick fibrils that had diameters of about 240 nm and a distinct D-period banding pattern. One typical fibril was photographed and analyzed in its entirety. The fibril was 776 D-periods (52 microM) long. It had a central shaft with a uniform diameter that was about 516 D-periods long and two tips of about 100 D-periods each. Most of the central shaft had a symmetrical banding pattern flanked by two transition regions of about 30 D-periods each. Measurements by scanning transmission electron microscopy demonstrated that the mass per unit length from the tips to the shafts increased linearly over approximately 100 D-periods from the fibril end. The linear increase in mass per unit length was consistent with previous observations for collagen I fibrils and established that the tips of collagen II also had a near paraboloidal shape. However, the orientation of monomers in the tips differed from the tips of collagen I fibrils in that the C termini instead of the N termini were directed toward the tips. The thin fibrils that were present at early stages of assembly and at equilibrium were comparable to the collagen II fibrils seen in embryonic tissues and probably represented intermediates on the pathway of thick fibrils formation. The results indicated that the molecular events in the self-assembly of collagen II fibrils are apparently similar to those in self-assembly of collagen I fibrils, but that there are also important differences in the structural information contained in collagen I and collagen II monomers.

The strength of a calcified tissue depends in part on the molecular structure and organization of its constituent mineral crystals in their organic matrix

High-voltage electron-microscopic tomographic (3D) studies of the ultrastructural interaction between mineral and organic matrix in a variety of calcified tissues reveal different crystal structural and organizational features in association with their respective organic matrices. In brittle or weak pathologic or ectopic calcifications, including examples of osteogenesis imperfecta, calciphylaxis, calcergy, and dermatomyositis, hydroxyapatite crystals occur in various sizes and shapes and are oriented and aligned with respect to collagen in a manner which is distinct from that found in normal calcified tissues. A model of collagen-mineral interaction is proposed which may account for the observed crystal structures and organization. The results indicate that the ultimate strength, support, and other mechanical properties provided by a calcified tissue are dependent in part upon the molecular structure and arrangement of its constituent mineral crystals within their organic matrix.

Hydroxylation of collagen type I: evidence that both lysyl and prolyl residues are overhydroxylated in osteogenesis imperfecta

The composition of the collagens secreted into the media of fibroblast cultures of 39 patients with osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) was the same in controls and OI cultures. An abnormal migration pattern of collagens upon SDS-PAGE was evident in one third of the cultures investigated. Lysyl and prolyl hydroxylation of HPLC-purified alpha 1(I) chains was elevated in about 60% of cultures. The degree of hydroxylation was highest in the lethal forms. The extent of lysyl and prolyl hydroxylation showed a strong correlation (r = 0.74, P < 0.001). While high levels of hydroxylation are frequently observed in OI patients, a direct correlation between lysyl or prolyl hydroxylation and fracture rate or growth retardation could not be established.

Tomographic imaging of collagen-mineral interaction: implications for osteogenesis imperfecta

The novel method of high voltage electron microscopic tomography (3D) has been applied for the first time to examine ultrastructural features and spatial relations between collagen fibrils and mineral crystals in a mouse mutant (oim/oim) which replicates a moderate to severe form of osteogenesis imperfecta. The animal produces collagen consisting of the alpha1(I) homotrimer and has a brittle calcified skeleton. Three-dimensional image reconstructions of the Achilles tendons, which were found to mineralize in the mutant mice, revealed that their composite crystals were different in their structural appearance and spatial association with collagen compared to that determined in normal calcified tissues. These results indicate that the nature of the organic matrix of a mineralizing tissue critically influences the formation, structure, and location of the constituent mineral and, further, the data are interpreted as suggesting that the unusual structural and organizational interaction between mineral and collagen underlies the inherent brittleness and weakness of calcification in this model of osteogenesis imperfecta.

Cadmium ions inhibit procollagen C-proteinase and cupric ions inhibit procollagen N-proteinase

Procollagen C- and N-proteinases specifically cleave the C- and N-terminal extension propeptides of type I, II and III procollagen molecules. The collagen molecules generated by the enzymes self-assemble into collagen fibrils. We previously observed the inhibition of these enzymes purified from chick tendons by several divalent metals. Here the inhibitory effects of CdCl2, CuCl2, ZnCl2, NiCl2, CoCl2 and Hg(C2H3O2)2 have been studied in detail using crude or purified C- and N-proteinases from chick tendons and sterna. CdCl2 was a strong inhibitor of C-proteinases from both sources, and the inhibition was independent of enzyme purity (I50 = 10-16 microM). In contrast, CuCl2 and ZnCl2 were inhibitory only of purified C-proteinase. With the N-proteinase, CuCl2 was a strong inhibitor, and the inhibition was independent of the purity of the enzyme preparation used (I50 = 14-40 microM). On the other hand, CdCl2 was a moderate inhibitor, and ZnCl2 was a strong inhibitor only of the purified N-proteinase (I50 = 8-17 microM). NiCl2 inhibited crude and purified N-proteinase from sternum (I50 = 23-29 microM) but not from tendon. These results suggest, therefore, that the accumulation of some of these metals in the body may cause suppression of collagen fibril formation in tissues.

Mutations in type 1 procollagen that cause osteogenesis imperfecta: effects of the mutations on the assembly of collagen into fibrils, the basis of phenotypic variations, and potential antisense therapies

Work by a large number of investigators over the last decade has established that over 90% of patients with osteogenesis imperfecta have mutations in one of the two genes for type I procollagen, that most unrelated probands have different mutations in the genes, and that the mutations found in most of the serious variants of the disease cause synthesis of abnormal pro alpha chains of the protein. The results have demonstrated that synthesis of structurally abnormal but partially functional pro alpha chains can interfere with folding of the central region of the protein into a triple-helical conformation, prevent processing of the N-terminal propeptides of procollagen, or produce subtle alterations in conformation that interfere with the self-assembly of the protein into collagen fibrils. One of the unsolved mysteries about the disease is why some mutations produce severe phenotypes, whereas very similar mutations produce mild phenotypes. Recent studies in transgenic mice suggest that nongenetic factors, such as stochastic events during development, may determine the severity of the disease phenotype produced by a specific mutation. Also, recent results raised the possibility that strategies of antisense gene therapy may be effective in treating the disease some time in the future. Specific inhibition of expression of a mutated collagen gene has been obtained with antisense oligonucleotides in cell culture experiments. However, there is no means of selective delivery of antisense oligonucleotides to the appropriate tissues.

Gly85 to Val substitution in pro alpha 1(I) chain causes mild osteogenesis imperfecta and introduces a susceptibility to protease digestion

In this paper we describe a mild moderate form of osteogenesis imperfecta caused by a point mutation in COL1A1 which converted glycine 85 to valine. The valine substitution introduced into the triple-helical domain of type-I collagen a conformational perturbation causing susceptibility to digestive proteases. In fact, SDS/PAGE of pepsin-treated collagen showed the presence of a faint band, migrating between alpha 1(I) and alpha 2(I), both in the medium and in the cell layer. On trypsin digestion the band, a shortened form of alpha 1(I), had a melting temperature of 39.5 degrees C. If the triple-helical collagen was obtained after trypsin or chymotrypsin digestion of procollagen, two shortened bands were identified; the enzymes cleaved about 40% of the trimers. The mutant procollagen was normally secreted and processed in the extracellular matrix at a normal rate. When native type-I collagen was formed after dextran-sulfate incubation, only chains of normal length were found, suggesting that the fibroblast proteases did not recognize the alteration introduced by the mutation. The effects of glycine 85 to valine substitution are compared with those produced by a previously described arginine substitution of the same residue (Deak et al., 1991).

Extracellular matrix deposition in cultured dermal fibroblasts from four probands affected by osteogenesis imperfecta

Type I procollagen biosynthesis and matrix deposition were studied in cultured fibroblasts of four probands affected by Osteogenesis Imperfecta and in whom the mutations have been characterized. The mutations along the triple helix altered all biochemical parameters considered, i.e. thermal stability, kinetics of procollagen secretion and rate of maturation from procollagen to collagen. The biochemical findings were peculiar for each case considered, but there was no correlation between biochemical parameters and clinical phenotype. In all our probands, regardless of the clinical severity, mutant chains appeared in the insoluble matrix formed by fibroblasts cultured in the presence of dextran sulfate. The densitometric scanning revealed a relative increased amount of fibronectin, suggesting that the matrix contained a lower quantity of type I collagen. Furthermore, the amount of mutant chains found in the insoluble fraction was clearly less than expected, considering that 75% of new synthesized trimers are abnormal. Therefore, in the presence of a mutation, the protein available for extracellular matrix formation is reduced and the mutant trimers incorporated in the matrix probably interfere with normal fibril performance. The abnormal fibril morphology has a dramatic effect in bone, interfering presumably with a correct mineral deposition and interactions with non/collagenous bone proteins.