The nature of Cux in cytochrome c oxidase

Walking the seven lines: binuclear copper A in cytochrome c oxidase and nitrous oxide reductase

The enzymes nitrous oxide reductase (N2OR) and cytochrome c oxidase (COX) are constituents of important biological processes. N2OR is the terminal reductase in a respiratory chain converting N₂O to N₂ in denitrifying bacteria; COX is the terminal oxidase of the aerobic respiratory chain of certain bacteria and eukaryotic organisms transforming O₂ to H₂O accompanied by proton pumping. Different spectroscopies including magnetic resonance techniques, were applied to show that N2OR has a mixed-valent Cys-bridged [Cu^1.5+(CyS)₂Cu^1.5+] copper site, and that such a binuclear center, called CuA, does also exist in COX. A sequence motif shared between the CuA center of N2OR and the subunit II of COX raises the issue of a putative evolutionary relationship of the two enzymes. The suggestion of a binuclear CuA in COX, with one unpaired electron delocalized between two equivalent Cu nuclei, was difficult to accept originally, even though regarded as a clever solution to many experimental observations. This minireview in honor of Helmut Sigel traces several of the critical steps forward in understanding the nature of CuA in N2OR and COX, and discusses its unique electronic features to some extent including the contributions made by the development of methodology and the discovery of a novel multi-copper enzyme. Left: X-band (9.130 GHz) and C-band (4.530 GHz, 1st harmonic display of experimental spectrum) EPR spectra of bovine heart cytochrome c oxidase, recorded at 20K. Right: Ribbon presentation of the CuA domain in cytochrome c oxidase and nitrous oxide reductase.

Cytochrome c oxidase: chemistry of a molecular machine

The plethora of proposed chemical models attempting to explain the proton pumping reactions catalyzed by the CcO complex, especially the number of recent models, makes it clear that the problem is far from solved. Although we have not discussed all of the models proposed to date, we have described some of the more detailed models in order to illustrate the theoretical concepts introduced at the beginning of this section on proton pumping as well as to illustrate the rich possibilities available for effecting proton pumping. It is clear that proton pumping is effected by conformational changes induced by oxidation/reduction of the various redox centers in the CcO complex. It is for this reason that the CcO complex is called a redox-linked proton pump. The conformational changes of the proton pump cycle are usually envisioned to be some sort of ligand-exchange reaction arising from unstable geometries upon oxidation/reduction of the various redox centers. However, simple geometrical rearrangements, as in the Babcock and Mitchell models are also possible. In any model, however, hydrogen bonds must be broken and reformed due to conformational changes that result from oxidation/reduction of the linkage site during enzyme turnover. Perhaps the most important point emphasized in this discussion, however, is the fact that proton pumping is a directed process and it is electron and proton gating mechanisms that drive the proton pump cycle in the forward direction. Since many of the models discussed above lack effective electron and/or proton gating, it is clear that the major difficulty in developing a viable chemical model is not formulating a cyclic set of protein conformational changes effecting proton pumping (redox linkage) but rather constructing the model with a set of physical constraints so that the proposed cycle proceeds efficiently as postulated. In our discussion of these models, we have not been too concerned about which electron of the catalytic cycle was entering the site of linkage, but merely whether an ET to the binuclear center played a role. However, redox linkage only occurs if ET to the activated binuclear center is coupled to the proton pump. Since all of the models of proton pumping presented here, with the exception of the Rousseau expanded model and the Wikström model, have a maximum stoichiometry of 1 H+/e-, they inadequately explain the 2 H+/e- ratio for the third and fourth electrons of the dioxygen reduction cycle (see Section V.B). One way of interpreting this shortfall of protons is that the remaining protons are pumped by an as yet undefined indirectly coupled mechanism. In this scenario, the site of linkage could be coupled to the pumping of one proton in a direct fashion and one proton in an indirect fashion for a given electron. For a long time, it was assumed that at least some elements of such an indirect mechanism reside in subunit III. While recent evidence argues against the involvement of subunit III in the proton pump, subunit III may still participate in a regulatory and/or structural capacity (Section II.E). Attention has now focused on subunits I and II in the search for residues intimately involved in the proton pump mechanism and/or as part of a proton channel. In particular, the role of some of the highly conserved residues of helix VIII of subunit I are currently being studied by site directed mutagenesis. In our opinion, any model that invokes heme alpha 3 or CuB as the site of linkage must propose a very effective means by which the presumedly fast uncoupling ET to the dioxygen intermediates is prevented. It is difficult to imagine that ET over the short distance from heme alpha 3 or CuB to the dioxygen intermediate requires more than 1 ns. In addition, we expect the conformational changes of the proton pump to require much more than 1 ns (see Section V.B).

Metal-metal bonding in biology: EXAFS evidence for a 2.5 A copper-copper bond in the CuA center of cytochrome oxidase

Evidence for a direct Cu-Cu bond in the CuA center of cytochrome oxidase is reported. Simulation of the X-ray absorption spectrum of a recombinant CuA-binding domain of Bacillus subtilis cytochrome oxidase, and comparison with a structurally characterized directly-bonding Cu(1.5) ... Cu(1.5) inorganic complex, suggests that a Cu-Cu interaction of 2.5 +/- 0.1 A together with a short 2.2 A Cu-S interaction may be present in the CuA site. In light of these data, previous interpretations of the EXAFS of a number of cytochrome oxidase and nitrous oxide reductase enzymes which modeled the 2.6 A interaction as a long Cu-S(methionine) bond are possibly incorrect. A structural model based on the new data is presented which suggests that the CuA sites in cytochrome oxidase and N2O reductase are likely composed of a pair of modified type 1 copper centers with one histidine, one cysteine, and one weakly bound ligand (Met and/or Gln) joined by a Cu-Cu bond.

The nature of the CuA center in cytochrome c oxidase

The merits of the suggestion that CuA in cytochrome oxidase is a mixed-valence binuclear site is reviewed on the basis of recent analytical and spectroscopic studies. First an alternative mononuclear model is presented. Metal analyses indicate that homogeneous oxidase preparations with high activity contain 3Cu/2Fe. Multifrequency EPR measurements demonstrate a close similarity with a copper site in nitrous oxide reductase, and this is also supported by optical and MCD spectra. Strong evidence for a binuclear site is provided by a 7-line hyperfine structure in the EPR spectra of both enzymes. A binuclear model consistent with amino acid sequence data can be formulated.

Stoichiometry and redox behaviour of metals in cytochrome-c oxidase

The early observation of extra copper in preparations of cytochrome-c oxidase has recently lead to a renewed interest in its stoichiometry and possible redox function. In various, pure preparations (heme A contents close to the theoretical value of 9.79 nmol/mg protein for the 13-subunit bovine enzyme) protein-related metal stoichiometries of 3 Cu, 2 Fe, 1 Zn, 1 Mg/monomer with M(r) 204266 were determined. Despite the presence of five potential redox metal ions, reductive and reoxidative titrations indicate the presence of only four one-electron-accepting/donating species in the ligand-free enzyme. Participation of two copper ions in a binuclear copper site acting as one-electron acceptor may explain both the observed copper stoichiometry and the redox behaviour. The homology of the C-terminal sequence of subunit II with one of the copper-binding sites in nitrous-oxide reductases provides possible ligands for complexing two copper ions in a binuclear center.

Current issues in the chemistry of cytochrome c oxidase

Some contemporary issues relevant to the chemistry of mammalian cytochrome c oxidase are discussed. These include the optical properties of heme A and the spectroscopic consequences of the differences in side-chain substitution compared to heme B; a common fallacy concerning the electrostatic exchange interaction between cytochrome a3 and CuB; the question of the number and location of the copper components of the enzyme; and the mode of binding of ligands such as cyanide and azide.

A comparative EPR investigation of the multicopper proteins nitrous-oxide reductase and cytochrome c oxidase

The multicopper proteins, nitrous-oxide reductase (N2OR) and cytochrome c oxidase (COX), were investigated by EPR spectroscopy at microwave frequencies 2.4-35 GHz. Our results support a Cu-Cu interaction in COX and N2OR. At least 10 lines in the 2.7-GHz, 12 lines in the 4.6-GHz and 14 lines in the 9.2 GHz spectra were resolved for N2OR. Eight copper lines at 2.7 GHz, about nine lines at 4.6 GHz and about six lines at 9.2 GHz were resolved for COX. Simulations of the EPR spectra were consistent with most of the resonances of the multiline spectra, including regions in the center of the spectra where overlap of the three seven-line patterns is proposed. These simulations indicated that Cu-Cu interaction, in a mixed-valence [Cu(1.5) ... Cu(1.5)], S = 1/2 site is consistent with, if not proof of, the unusual spectral features observed for N2OR and COX.

Copper in biological systems. A report from the 6th Manziana Conference, September 23-27, 1990

Enzymes and proteins: AO, amine oxidase; and as proposed in reference 3, BSAO, bovine serum AO; SSAO, swine serum AO; SKDAO, swine kidney AO; PSAO, pea seedling AO; APAO, arthrobacter P1AO; MADH, methylamine dehydrogenase; AAO, ascorbic acid oxidase; alpha-AE, alpha-amidating enzyme; Az, azurin; COX, cytochrome c oxidase; CP, ceruloplasmin; DBH, dopamine beta-hydroxylase; GO, galactose oxidase; Hc, hemocyanin; MT, metallotheonein; NIR, nitrite reductase; SOD, superoxide dismutase. Cofactors: Dopa, 3,4 dihydroxyphenylalanine; Topa, 3,4,6 trihydroxyphenyl-alanine; PLP, pyridoxal-phosphate; PQQ, pyrroloquinolinequinone. Reagents: DDC, diethyldithiocarbamate; DMG, diaminoguanidine; DMSA, dimercaptosuccinic acid; NTA, nitrilotriacetic acid. Technique-related: XANES, x-ray absorption near edge spectroscopy; EXAFS, extended x-ray absorption fine structure; ENDOR, electron-nuclear double resonance; ESEEM, electron spin echo envelope modulation; CD, circular dichroism; MCD, magnetic circular dichroism; NMRD, nuclear magnetic resonance dispersion; nqi, nuclear quadrupole interaction; DSC, differential scanning calorimetry.