Activation of the phosphosignaling protein CheY. I. Analysis of the phosphorylated conformation by 19F NMR and protein engineering

(2S,4S)-5-Fluoroleucine, (2S,4R)-5-Fluoroleucine, and 5,5'-Difluoroleucine in Escherichia coli PpiB: Protein Production, 19F NMR, and Ligand Sensing Enhanced by the γ-Gauche Effect

Global substitution of leucine for analogues containing CH2F instead of methyl groups delivers proteins with multiple sites for monitoring by 19F nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. The 19 kDa Escherichia coli peptidyl-prolyl cis-trans isomerase B (PpiB) was prepared with uniform high-level substitution of leucine by (2S,4S)-5-fluoroleucine, (2S,4R)-5-fluoroleucine, or 5,5'-difluoroleucine. The stability of the samples toward thermal denaturation was little altered compared to the wild-type protein. 19F nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectra showed large chemical shift dispersions between 6 and 17 ppm. The 19F chemical shifts correlate with the three-bond 1H-19F couplings (3JHF), providing the first experimental verification of the γ-gauche effect predicted by [Feeney, J. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1996, 118, 8700-8706] and establishing the effect as the predominant determinant of the 19F chemical shifts of CH2F groups. Individual CH2F groups can be confined to single rotameric states by the protein environment, but most CH2F groups exchange between different rotamers at a rate that is fast on the NMR chemical shift scale. Interactions between fluorine atoms in 5,5'-difluoroleucine bias the CH2F rotamers in agreement with results obtained previously for 1,3-difluoropropane. The sensitivity of the 19F chemical shift to the rotameric state of the CH2F groups potentially renders them particularly sensitive for detecting allosteric effects.

Mapping allosteric communications within individual proteins

Allostery in proteins influences various biological processes such as regulation of gene transcription and activities of enzymes and cell signaling. Computational approaches for analysis of allosteric coupling provide inexpensive opportunities to predict mutations and to design small-molecule agents to control protein function and cellular activity. We develop a computationally efficient network-based method, Ohm, to identify and characterize allosteric communication networks within proteins. Unlike previously developed simulation-based approaches, Ohm relies solely on the structure of the protein of interest. We use Ohm to map allosteric networks in a dataset composed of 20 proteins experimentally identified to be allosterically regulated. Further, the Ohm allostery prediction for the protein CheY correlates well with NMR CHESCA studies. Our webserver, Ohm.dokhlab.org, automatically determines allosteric network architecture and identifies critical coupled residues within this network.

Protein-Observed Fluorine NMR: A Bioorthogonal Approach for Small Molecule Discovery

The (19)F isotope is 100% naturally abundant and is the second most sensitive and stable NMR-active nucleus. Unlike the ubiquitous hydrogen atom, fluorine is nearly absent in biological systems, making it a unique bioorthogonal atom for probing molecular interactions in biology. Over 73 fluorinated proteins have been studied by (19)F NMR since the seminal studies of Hull and Sykes in 1974. With advances in cryoprobe production and fluorinated amino acid incorporation strategies, protein-based (19)F NMR offers opportunities to the medicinal chemist for characterizing and ultimately discovering new small molecule protein ligands. This review will highlight new advances using (19)F NMR for characterizing small molecule interactions with both small and large proteins as well as detailing NMR resonance assignment challenges and amino acid incorporation approaches.

(19)F-modified proteins and (19)F-containing ligands as tools in solution NMR studies of protein interactions

(19)F solution NMR is a powerful and versatile tool to study protein structure and protein-ligand interactions due to the favorable NMR characteristics of the (19)F atom, its absence in naturally occurring biomolecules, and small size. Protocols to introduce (19)F atoms into both proteins and their ligands are readily available and offer the ability to conduct protein-observe (using (19)F-labeled proteins) or ligand-observe (using (19)F-containing ligands) NMR experiments. This chapter provides two protocols for the (19)F-labeling of proteins, using an Escherichia coli expression system: (i) amino acid type-specific incorporation of (19)F-modified amino acids and (ii) site-specific incorporation of (19)F-modified amino acids using recombinantly expressed orthogonal amber tRNA/tRNA synthetase pairs. In addition, we discuss several applications, involving (19)F-modified proteins and (19)F-containing ligands.

Approaches to the assignment of (19)F resonances from 3-fluorophenylalanine labeled calmodulin using solution state NMR

Traditional single site replacement mutations (in this case, phenylalanine to tyrosine) were compared with methods which exclusively employ (15)N and (19)F-edited two- and three-dimensional NMR experiments for purposes of assigning (19)F NMR resonances from calmodulin (CaM), biosynthetically labeled with 3-fluorophenylalanine (3-FPhe). The global substitution of 3-FPhe for native phenylalanine was tolerated in CaM as evidenced by a comparison of (1)H-(15)N HSQC spectra and calcium binding assays in the presence and absence of 3-FPhe. The (19)F NMR spectrum reveals six resolved resonances, one of which integrates to three 3-FPhe species, making for a total of eight fluorophenylalanines. Single phenylalanine to tyrosine mutants of five phenylalanine positions resulted in (19)F NMR spectra with significant chemical shift perturbations of the remaining resonances, and provided only a single definitive assignment. Although (1)H-(19)F heteronucleclear NOEs proved weak, (19)F-edited (1)H-(1)H NOESY connectivities were relatively easy to establish by making use of the (3)J(FH) coupling between the fluorine nucleus and the adjacent fluorophenylalanine delta proton. (19)F-edited NOESY connectivities between the delta protons and alpha and beta nuclei in addition to (15)N-edited (1)H, (1)H NOESY crosspeaks proved sufficient to assign 4 of 8 (19)F resonances. Controlled cleavage of the protein into two fragments using trypsin, and a repetition of the above 2D and 3D techniques resulted in unambiguous assignments of all 8 (19)F NMR resonances. Our studies suggest that (19)F-edited NOESY NMR spectra are generally adequate for complete assignment without the need to resort to mutational analysis.

Cytokinin regulates type-A Arabidopsis Response Regulator activity and protein stability via two-component phosphorelay

The plant hormone cytokinin regulates many aspects of growth and development. Cytokinin signaling involves His kinase receptors that perceive cytokinin and transmit the signal via a multistep phosphorelay similar to bacterial two-component signaling systems. The final targets of this phosphorelay are a set of Arabidopsis thaliana Response Regulator (ARR) proteins containing a receiver domain with a conserved Asp phosphorylation site. One class of these, the type-A ARRs, are negative regulators of cytokinin signaling that are rapidly transcriptionally upregulated in response to cytokinin. In this study, we tested the role of phosphorylation in type-A ARR function. Our results indicate that phosphorylation of the receiver domain is required for type-A ARR function and suggest that negative regulation of cytokinin signaling by the type-A ARRs most likely involves phosphorylation-dependent interactions. Furthermore, we show that a subset of the type-A ARR proteins are stabilized in response to cytokinin in part via phosphorylation. These studies shed light on the mechanism by which type-A ARRs act to negatively regulate cytokinin signaling and reveal a novel mechanism by which cytokinin controls type-A ARR function.

The use of a generalized born model for the analysis of protein conformational transitions: a comparative study with explicit solvent simulations for chemotaxis Y protein (CheY)

To investigate whether implicit solvent models are appropriate for mechanistic studies of conformational transition in proteins, a recently developed generalized Born model (GBSW) was applied to a small signaling protein, chemotaxis protein Y (CheY), with different combinations of the phosphorylation state and conformation of the system; the results were compared to explicit solvent simulations using a stochastic boundary condition. The subtle but distinct conformational transitions involved in CheY activation makes the system ideally suited for comparing implicit and explicit solvent models because these conformational transitions are potentially accessible in both types of simulations. The structural and dynamical properties analyzed include not only those localized to the active site region but also throughout the protein, such as sidechain methyl group order parameters, backbone hydrogen bonding lifetime and occupancy as well as principal components of the trajectories. Overall, many properties were well reproduced by the GBSW simulations when compared with the explicit solvent calculations, although a number of observations consistently point to the suggestion that the current parameterization of the GBSW model tends to overestimate hydrogen-bonding interactions involving both charged groups and (charge-neutral) backbone atoms. This deficiency led to overstabilization of certain secondary structural motifs and more importantly, qualitatively different behaviors for the active site groups (Thr 87, Ala 88, the beta4-alpha4 loop) in response to phosphorylation, when compared with explicit solvent simulations. The current study highlights the value of carrying out both explicit and implicit solvent simulations for complementary mechanistic insights in the analysis of conformational transition in biomolecules.

Functional dynamics of response regulators using NMR relaxation techniques

A fundamental concept of phosphorylation-mediated signaling is the precise switching between discrete functional conformations. According to the traditional view, phosphorylation induces a new, active conformation. In this chapter, a series of NMR experiments performed on a response regulator are described that challenge this traditional notion. The combination of NMR relaxation experiments with chemical shift data and the linkage to structure/function reveals a fundamentally different activation mechanism. The NMR data for the response regulator NtrC provide kinetic (rates of interconversion), thermodynamic (relative populations), and structural (chemical shift) information for the conformational exchange process. The results demonstrate that both the inactive and active states are present before phosphorylation, and activation occurs via a shift of this preexisting equilibrium. This concept is in accordance with the energy landscape view of proteins that embraces the existence of conformational substates. We conjecture that this population-shift mechanism is a general paradigm for response regulator activation and possibly more universal for phosphorylation-mediated signaling.

Bacterial bioreactors for high yield production of recombinant protein

We developed a new bacterial expression system that utilizes a combination of attributes (low temperature, induction of an mRNA-specific endoribonuclease causing host cell growth arrest, and culture condensation) to facilitate stable, high level protein expression, almost 30% of total cellular protein, without background protein synthesis. With the use of an optimized vector, exponentially growing cultures could be condensed 40-fold without affecting protein yields, which lowered sample labeling costs to a few percent of the cost of a typical labeling experiment. Because the host cells were completely growth-arrested, toxic amino acids such as selenomethionine and fluorophenylalanine were efficiently incorporated into recombinant proteins in the absence of cytotoxicity. Therefore, this expression system using Escherichia coli as a bioreactor is especially well suited to structural genomics, large-scale protein expressions, and the production of cytotoxic proteins.

Structural studies of Bcl-xL/ligand complexes using 19F NMR

Fluorine atoms are often incorporated into drug molecules as part of the lead optimization process in order to improve affinity or modify undesirable metabolic and pharmacokinetic profiles. From an NMR perspective, the abundance of fluorinated drug leads provides an exploitable niche for structural studies using 19F NMR in the drug discovery process. As 19F has no interfering background signal from biological sources, 19F NMR studies of fluorinated drugs bound to their protein receptors can yield easily interpretable and unambiguous structural constraints. 19F can also be selectively incorporated into proteins to obtain additional constraints for structural studies. Despite these advantages, 19F NMR has rarely been exploited for structural studies due to its broad lines in macromolecules and their ligand complexes, leading to weak signals in 1H/19F heteronuclear NOE experiments. Here we demonstrate several different experimental strategies that use 19F NMR to obtain ligand-protein structural constraints for ligands bound to the anti-apoptotic protein Bcl-xL, a drug target for anti-cancer therapy. These examples indicate the applicability of these methods to typical structural problems encountered in the drug development process.

MyD88 adapter-like (Mal) is phosphorylated by Bruton's tyrosine kinase during TLR2 and TLR4 signal transduction

Members of the Toll-like receptor (TLR) family are essential players in activating the host innate immune response against infectious microorganisms. All TLRs signal through Toll/interleukin 1 receptor domain-containing adapter proteins. MyD88 adapter-like (Mal) is one such adapter that specifically is involved in TLR2 and TLR4 signaling. When overexpressed we have found that Mal undergoes tyrosine phosphorylation. Three possible phospho-accepting tyrosines were identified at positions 86, 106, and 187, and two mutant forms of Mal in which tyrosines 86 and 187 were mutated to phenylalanine acted as dominant negative inhibitors of NF-kappaB activation by lipopolysaccharide (LPS). Activation of THP-1 monocytic cells with the TLR4 agonist LPS and the TLR2 agonist macrophage-activating lipopeptide-2 induced phosphorylation of Mal on tyrosine residues. We found that the Bruton's tyrosine kinase (Btk) inhibitor LFM-A13 could block the endogenous phosphorylation of Mal on tyrosine in cells treated with macrophage-activating lipopeptide-2 or LPS. Furthermore, Btk immunoprecipitated from THP-1 cells activated by LPS could phosphorylate Mal. Our study therefore provides the first demonstration of the key role of Mal phosphorylation on tyrosine during signaling by TLR2 and TLR4 and identifies a novel function for Btk as the kinase involved.

The acetate switch

To succeed, many cells must alternate between life-styles that permit rapid growth in the presence of abundant nutrients and ones that enhance survival in the absence of those nutrients. One such change in life-style, the "acetate switch," occurs as cells deplete their environment of acetate-producing carbon sources and begin to rely on their ability to scavenge for acetate. This review explains why, when, and how cells excrete or dissimilate acetate. The central components of the "switch" (phosphotransacetylase [PTA], acetate kinase [ACK], and AMP-forming acetyl coenzyme A synthetase [AMP-ACS]) and the behavior of cells that lack these components are introduced. Acetyl phosphate (acetyl approximately P), the high-energy intermediate of acetate dissimilation, is discussed, and conditions that influence its intracellular concentration are described. Evidence is provided that acetyl approximately P influences cellular processes from organelle biogenesis to cell cycle regulation and from biofilm development to pathogenesis. The merits of each mechanism proposed to explain the interaction of acetyl approximately P with two-component signal transduction pathways are addressed. A short list of enzymes that generate acetyl approximately P by PTA-ACKA-independent mechanisms is introduced and discussed briefly. Attention is then directed to the mechanisms used by cells to "flip the switch," the induction and activation of the acetate-scavenging AMP-ACS. First, evidence is presented that nucleoid proteins orchestrate a progression of distinct nucleoprotein complexes to ensure proper transcription of its gene. Next, the way in which cells regulate AMP-ACS activity through reversible acetylation is described. Finally, the "acetate switch" as it exists in selected eubacteria, archaea, and eukaryotes, including humans, is described.

Receptor conformational changes enhance methylesterase activity during chemotaxis by Bacillus subtilis

Addition and removal of the attractant asparagine causes methanol formation as a consequence of methylation and demethylation of conserved glutamate residues in the Bacillus subtilis chemotaxis receptor McpB C-terminal domain. We found that methanol was released on both addition and removal of asparagine even when the response regulator domain of CheB was removed (to produce CheB(141-357)). Thus, in undergoing the transition from unbound receptor to ligand-bound adapted receptor, the receptor must pass through a state of heightened susceptibility to demethylation by CheB that is independent of phosphorylation. The same result occurred when the aspartate phosphorylation site of CheB, Asp54, had been mutated to an asparagine residue, provided the enzyme was sufficiently induced. However, no methanol release was observed for an active site point mutant, cheB(S173C), in response to addition or removal of asparagine even when induced. Finally, methanol release was observed only for attractant addition in a mutant background lacking the coupling proteins, CheW and CheV, provided CheB(141-357) was present. Thus, on attractant addition, methanol must arise from a transient conformation of the receptor C-terminal domain that is an intrinsic property of the receptor; on attractant removal, however, methanol must arise from a different transient conformation, one dependent on the presence of coupling proteins.

Investigation of the role of electrostatic charge in activation of the Escherichia coli response regulator CheY

In a two-component regulatory system, an important means of signal transduction in microorganisms, a sensor kinase phosphorylates a response regulator protein on an aspartyl residue, resulting in activation. The active site of the response regulator is highly charged (containing a lysine, the phosphorylatable aspartate, two additional aspartates involved in metal binding, and an Mg(2+) ion), and introduction of the dianionic phosphoryl group results in the repositioning of charged moieties. Furthermore, substitution of one of the Mg(2+)-coordinating aspartates with lysine or arginine in the Escherichia coli chemotaxis response regulator CheY results in phosphorylation-independent activation. In order to examine the consequences of altered charge distribution for response regulator activity and to identify possible additional amino acid substitutions that result in phosphorylation-independent activation, we made 61 CheY mutants in which residues close to the site of phosphorylation (Asp57) were replaced by various charged amino acids. Most substitutions (47 of 61) resulted in the complete loss of CheY activity, as measured by the inability to support clockwise flagellar rotation. However, 10 substitutions, all introducing a new positive charge, resulted in the loss of chemotaxis but in the retention of some clockwise flagellar rotation. Of the mutants in this set, only the previously identified CheY13DK and CheY13DR mutants displayed clockwise activity in the absence of the CheA sensor kinase. The absence of negatively charged substitution mutants with residual activity suggests that the introduction of additional negative charges into the active site is particularly deleterious for CheY function. Finally, the spatial distribution of positions at which amino acid substitutions are functionally tolerated or not tolerated is consistent with the presently accepted mechanism of response regulator activation and further suggests a possible role for Met17 in signal transduction by CheY.

Genetic analysis of response regulator activation in bacterial chemotaxis suggests an intermolecular mechanism

Response regulator proteins of two-component systems are usually activated by phosphorylation. The phosphorylated response regulator protein CheY-P mediates the chemotaxis response in Escherichia coli. We performed random mutagenesis and selected CheY mutants that are constitutively active in the absence of phosphorylation. Although a single amino acid substitution can lead to constitutive activation, no single DNA base change can effect such a transition. Numerous different sets of mutations that activate in synergy were selected in several different combinations. These mutations were all located on the side of CheY defined by alpha4, beta5, alpha5, and alpha1. Our findings argue against the two-state hypothesis for response regulator activation. We propose an alternative intermolecular mechanism that involves a dynamic interplay between response regulators and their effector targets.

Using O2 to probe membrane immersion depth by 19F NMR

A fluorinated detergent, CF(3)(CF(2))(5)C(2)H(4)-O-maltose, was reconstituted into a lipid bilayer model membrane system to demonstrate the feasibility of determining solvent accessibility and membrane immersion depth of each fluorinated group by (19)F NMR. Apolar oxygen, which is known to partition with an increasing concentration gradient toward the hydrophobic membrane interior, exhibits a range of paramagnetic relaxation effects on (19)F nuclei, depending on its depth in the membrane. This effect, which is predominately associated with spin-lattice relaxation rates (R(1)) and chemical shifts, can be amplified greatly with minimal line broadening by increasing the partial pressure of O(2) at least 100-fold (i.e., P(O(2)) greater than 20 bar). The differences of longitudinal relaxation rates at 20 bar of oxygen pressure to those under ambient pressure (R(1)(20bar) - R(1)(0)) are largest for those fluorine groups expected to be most deeply buried in the membrane bilayer. This result contrasts with the reverse trend, which is observed on addition of a membrane surface-associated paramagnetic species, 4-(N,N-dimethyl-N-hexadecyl) ammonium-2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine-1-oxyl iodide (CAT-16) at ambient pressures. Thus, differential relaxation rates may be observed in (19)F-labeled membrane-associated molecules resulting from the addition of apolar oxygen under high pressure. The results demonstrate that the degree of solvent accessibility and membrane immersion depth of specific fluorinated species in membrane-associated macromolecules can be probed by (19)F NMR.

NMR structure of activated CheY

The CheY protein is the response regulator in bacterial chemotaxis. Phosphorylation of a conserved aspartyl residue induces structural changes that convert the protein from an inactive to an active state. The short half-life of the aspartyl-phosphate has precluded detailed structural analysis of the active protein. Persistent activation of Escherichia coli CheY was achieved by complexation with beryllofluoride (BeF(3)(-)) and the structure determined by NMR spectroscopy to a backbone r.m.s.d. of 0.58(+/-0.08) A. Formation of a hydrogen bond between the Thr87 OH group and an active site acceptor, presumably Asp57.BeF(3)(-), stabilizes a coupled rearrangement of highly conserved residues, Thr87 and Tyr106, along with displacement of beta4 and H4, to yield the active state. The coupled rearrangement may be a more general mechanism for activation of receiver domains.

Structure of a transiently phosphorylated switch in bacterial signal transduction

Receiver domains are the dominant molecular switches in bacterial signalling. Although several structures of non-phosphorylated receiver domains have been reported, a detailed structural understanding of the activation arising from phosphorylation has been impeded by the very short half-lives of the aspartylphosphate linkages. Here we present the first structure of a receiver domain in its active state, the phosphorylated receiver domain of the bacterial enhancer-binding protein NtrC (nitrogen regulatory protein C). Nuclear magnetic resonance spectra were taken during steady-state autophosphorylation/dephosphorylation, and three-dimensional spectra from multiple samples were combined. Phosphorylation induces a large conformational change involving a displacement of beta-strands 4 and 5 and alpha-helices 3 and 4 away from the active site, a register shift and an axial rotation in helix 4. This creates an exposed hydrophobic surface that is likely to transmit the signal to the transcriptional activation domain.

Beryllofluoride mimics phosphorylation of NtrC and other bacterial response regulators

Two-component systems, sensor kinase-response regulator pairs, dominate bacterial signal transduction. Regulation is exerted by phosphorylation of an Asp in receiver domains of response regulators. Lability of the acyl phosphate linkage has limited structure determination for the active, phosphorylated forms of receiver domains. As assessed by both functional and structural criteria, beryllofluoride yields an excellent analogue of aspartyl phosphate in response regulator NtrC, a bacterial enhancer-binding protein. Beryllofluoride also appears to activate the chemotaxis, sporulation, osmosensing, and nitrate/nitrite response regulators CheY, Spo0F, OmpR, and NarL, respectively. NMR spectroscopic studies indicate that beryllofluoride will facilitate both biochemical and structural characterization of the active forms of receiver domains.

Conformational changes induced by phosphorylation of the FixJ receiver domain

BACKGROUND

A variety of bacterial adaptative cellular responses to environmental stimuli are mediated by two-component signal transduction pathways. In these phosphorelay cascades, histidine kinases transphosphorylate a conserved aspartate in the receiver domain, a conserved module in the response regulator superfamily. The main effect of this phosphorylation is to alter the conformation of the response regulator in order to modulate its biological function. The response regulator FixJ displays a typical modular arrangement, with a phosphorylatable N-terminal receiver domain and a C-terminal DNA-binding domain. In the symbiotic bacterium Sinorhizobium meliloti, phosphorylation of this response regulator activates transcription of nitrogen-fixation genes.

RESULTS

The crystal structures of the phosphorylated and of the unphosphorylated N-terminal receiver domain of FixJ (FixJN) were solved at 2.3 A and 2.4 A resolution, respectively. They reveal the environment of the phosphoaspartate in the active site and the specific conformational changes leading to activation of the response regulator. Phosphorylation of the conserved aspartate induces major structural changes in the beta 4-alpha 4 loop, and in the signaling surface alpha 4-beta 5 that mediates dimerization of the phosphorylated full-length response regulator. A site-directed mutant at this protein-protein interface decreases the affinity of the phosphorylated response regulator for the fixK promoter tenfold.

CONCLUSIONS

The cascade of phosphorylation-induced conformational changes in FixJN illustrates the role of conserved residues in stabilizing the phosphoryl group in the active site, triggering the structural transition and achieving the post-phosphorylation signaling events. We propose that these phosphorylation-induced conformational changes underly the activation of response regulators in general.

Throwing the switch in bacterial chemotaxis

In Escherichia coli chemotaxis, the switch from counterclockwise to clockwise rotation of the flagella occurs as a result of binding of the phosphorylated CheY protein to the base of the flagellum. Analysis of CheY variants has provided a picture of the surface of CheY that undergoes conformational shifts, as a result of phosphorylation, to interact directly with the flagellum. Whether phospho-CheY binding and flagellar switching are sequential steps or can occur in a concerted fashion has yet to be determined.

Structural analysis of bacterial chemotaxis proteins: components of a dynamic signaling system

Most motile bacteria are capable of directing their movement in response to chemical gradients, a behavior known as chemotaxis. The signal transduction system that mediates chemotaxis in enteric bacteria consists of a set of six cytoplasmic proteins that couple stimuli sensed by a family of transmembrane receptors to behavioral responses generated by the flagellar motors. Signal transduction occurs via a phosphotransfer pathway involving a histidine protein kinase, CheA, and a response regulator protein, CheY, that in its phosphorylated state, modulates the direction of flagellar rotation. Two auxiliary proteins, CheW and CheZ, and two receptor modification enzymes, methylesterase CheB and methyltransferase CheR, influence the flux of phosphoryl groups within this central pathway. This paper focuses on structural characteristics of the four signaling proteins (CheA, CheY, CheB, and CheR) for which NMR or x-ray crystal structures have been determined. The proteins are examined with respect to their signaling activities that involve reversible protein modifications and transient assembly of macromolecular complexes. A variety of data suggest conformational flexibility of these proteins, a feature consistent with their multiple roles in a dynamic signaling pathway.

Flagellar motor-switch binding face of CheY and the biochemical basis of suppression by CheY mutants that compensate for motor-switch defects in Escherichia coli

CheY is a response regulator protein of Escherichia coli that interacts with the flagellar motor-switch complex to modulate flagellar rotation during chemotaxis. The switch complex is composed of three proteins, FliG, FliM, and FliN. Recent biochemical data suggest a direct interaction of CheY with FliM. In order to determine the FliM binding face of CheY, we isolated dominant suppressors of fliM mutations in cheY with limited allele specificity. The protein products of suppressor cheY alleles were purified and assayed for FliM binding. Six out of nine CheY mutants were defective in FliM binding. Suppressor amino acid substitutions were mapped on the crystal structure of CheY showing clustering of reduced binding mutations on a solvent-accessible face of CheY, thus revealing a FliM binding face of CheY. To examine the basis of genetic suppression, we cloned, purified, and tested FliM mutants for CheY binding. Like the wild-type FliM, the mutants were also defective in binding to various CheY suppressor mutants. This was not expected if CheY suppressors were compensatory conformational suppressors. Furthermore, a comparison of flagellar rotation patterns indicated that the cheY suppressors had readjusted the clockwise bias of the fliM strains. However, a chemotaxis assay revealed that the readjustment of the clockwise bias was not sufficient to make cells chemotactic. Although the suppressors did not restore chemotaxis, they did increase swarming on motility plates by a process called "pseudotaxis." Therefore, our genetic selection scheme generated suppressors of pseudotaxis or switch bias adjustment. The binding results suggest that the mechanism for this adjustment is the reduction in binding affinity of activated CheY. Therefore, these suppressors identified the switch-binding surface of CheY by loss-of-function defects rather than gain-of-function compensatory conformational changes.

Two binding modes reveal flexibility in kinase/response regulator interactions in the bacterial chemotaxis pathway

The crystal structure at 2.0-A resolution of the complex of the Escherichia coli chemotaxis response regulator CheY and the phosphoacceptor-binding domain (P2) of the kinase CheA is presented. The binding interface involves the fourth and fifth helices and fifth beta-strand of CheY and both helices of P2. Surprisingly, the two heterodimers in the asymmetric unit have two different binding modes involving the same interface, suggesting some flexibility in the binding regions. Significant conformational changes have occurred in CheY compared with previously determined unbound structures. The active site of CheY is exposed by the binding of the kinase domain, possibly to enhance phosphotransfer from CheA to CheY. The conformational changes upon complex formation as well as the observation that there are two different binding modes suggest that the plasticity of CheY is an essential feature of response regulator function.

Chemotactic response regulator mutant CheY95IV exhibits enhanced binding to the flagellar switch and phosphorylation-dependent constitutive signalling

CheY, a response regulator protein in bacterial chemotaxis, mediates swimming behaviour through interaction with the flagellar switch protein, FliM. In its active, phosphorylated state, CheY binds to the motor switch complex and induces a change from counterclockwise (CCW) to clockwise (CW) flagellar rotation. The conformation of a conserved aromatic residue, tyrosine 106, has been proposed to play an important role in this signalling process. Here, we show that an isoleucine to valine substitution in CheY at position 95--in close proximity to residue 106--results in an extremely CW, hyperactive phenotype that is dependent on phosphorylation. Further biochemical characterization of this mutant protein revealed phosphorylation and dephosphorylation rates that were indistinguishable from those of wild-type CheY. CheY95IV, however, exhibited an increased binding affinity to FliM. Taken together, these results show for the first time a correlation between enhanced switch binding and constitutive signalling in bacterial chemotaxis. Considering present structural information, we also propose possible models for the role of residue 95 in the mechanism of CheY signal transduction.

Structural and functional analyses of activating amino acid substitutions in the receiver domain of NtrC: evidence for an activating surface

The bacterial enhancer-binding protein NtrC activates transcription when phosphorylated on aspartate 54 in its amino (N)-terminal regulatory domain or when altered by constitutively activating amino acid substitutions. The N-terminal domain of NtrC, which acts positively on the remainder of the protein, is homologous to a large family of signal transduction domains called receiver domains. Phosphorylation of an aspartate residue in a receiver domain modulates the function of a downstream target, but the accompanying structural changes are not clear. In the present work we examine structural and functional differences between the wild-type receiver domain of NtrC and mutant forms carrying constitutively activating substitutions. Combinations of such substitutions resulted in both increased structural changes in the N-terminal domain, monitored by NMR chemical shift differences, and increased transcriptional activation by the full-length protein. Structural changes caused by substitutions outside the active site (D86N and A89T) were not only local but extended over a substantial portion of the N-terminal domain including the region from alpha-helix 3 to beta-strand 5 ("3445 face") and propagating to the active site. Interestingly, the activating substitution of glutamate for aspartate at the site of phosphorylation (D54E) also triggered structural changes in the 3445 face. Thus, the active site and the 3445 face appear to interact. Implications with respect to how phosphorylation may affect the structure of receiver domains and how structural changes may be communicated to the remainder of NtrC are discussed.

Uncoupled phosphorylation and activation in bacterial chemotaxis. The 2.3 A structure of an aspartate to lysine mutant at position 13 of CheY

An aspartate to lysine mutation at position 13 of the chemotaxis regulatory protein CheY causes a constitutive tumbly phenotype when expressed at high copy number in vivo even though the mutant protein is not phosphorylatable. These properties suggest that the D13K mutant adopts the active, signaling conformation of CheY independent of phosphorylation, so knowledge of its structure could explain the activation mechanism of CheY. The x-ray crystallographic structure of the CheY D13K mutant has been solved and refined at 2.3 A resolution to an R-factor of 14.3%. The mutant molecule shows no significant differences in backbone conformation when compared with the wild-type, Mg2+-free structure, but there are localized changes within the active site. The side chain of lysine 13 blocks access to the active site, whereas its epsilon-amino group has no bonding interactions with other groups in the region. Also in the active site, the bond between lysine 109 and aspartate 57 is weakened, and the solvent structure is perturbed. Although the D13K mutant has the inactive conformation in the crystalline form, rearrangements in the active site appear to weaken the overall structure of that region, potentially creating a metastable state of the molecule. If a conformational change is required for signaling by CheY D13K, then it most likely proceeds dynamically, in solution.

Crystal structures of CheY mutants Y106W and T87I/Y106W. CheY activation correlates with movement of residue 106

Position 106 in CheY is highly conserved as an aromatic residue in the response regulator superfamily. In the structure of the wild-type, apo-CheY, Tyr106 is a rotamer whose electron density is observed in both the inside and the outside positions. In the structure of the T87I mutant of CheY, the threonine to isoleucine change at position 87 causes the side chain of Tyr106 to be exclusively restricted to the outside position. In this report we demonstrate that the T87I mutation causes cells to be smooth swimming and non-chemotactic. We also show that another CheY mutant, Y106W, causes cells to be more tumbly than wild-type CheY, and impairs chemotaxis. In the structure of Y106W, the side chain of Trp106 stays exclusively in the inside position. Furthermore, a T87I/Y106W double mutant, which confers the same phenotype as T87I, restricts the side chain of Trp106 to the outside position. The results from these behavioral and structural studies indicate that the rotameric nature of the Tyr106 residue is involved in activation of the CheY molecule. Specifically, CheY's signaling ability correlates with the conformational heterogeneity of the Tyr106 side chain. Our data also suggest that these mutations affect the signal at an event subsequent to phosphorylation.

The two-component signaling pathway of bacterial chemotaxis: a molecular view of signal transduction by receptors, kinases, and adaptation enzymes

The chemosensory pathway of bacterial chemotaxis has become a paradigm for the two-component superfamily of receptor-regulated phosphorylation pathways. This simple pathway illustrates many of the fundamental principles and unanswered questions in the field of signaling biology. A molecular description of pathway function has progressed rapidly because it is accessible to diverse structural, biochemical, and genetic approaches. As a result, structures are emerging for most of the pathway elements, biochemical studies are elucidating the mechanisms of key signaling events, and genetic methods are revealing the intermolecular interactions that transmit information between components. Recent advances include (a) the first molecular picture of a conformational transmembrane signal in a cell surface receptor, (b) four new structures of kinase domains and adaptation enzymes, and (c) significant new insights into the mechanisms of receptor-mediated kinase regulation, receptor adaptation, and the phospho-activation of signaling proteins. Overall, the chemosensory pathway and the propulsion system it regulates provide an ideal system in which to probe molecular principles underlying complex cellular signaling and behavior.

Analysis of phosphorylation and mutation of tyrosine residues of calmodulin on its activation of the erythrocyte Ca(2+)-transporting ATPase

The role played by the phosphorylation sites of calmodulin on its ability to activate the human erythrocyte Ca(2+)-transporting ATPase (Ca(2+)-ATPase) was evaluated. Phosphorylation of mammalian calmodulin on serine/threonine residues by casein kinase II decreased its affinity for Ca(2+)-ATPase by twofold. In contrast, tyrosine phosphorylation of mammalian calmodulin by the insulin-receptor kinase did not significantly alter calmodulin-stimulated Ca(2+)-ATPase activity. Two variant calmodulins, each containing only one tyrosine residue (the second Tyr is replaced by Phe) were also examined: [F138]calmodulin, a mutant containing tyrosine at position 99, and wheat germ calmodulin which has tyrosine at position 139. The concentrations of [F138]calmodulin and wheat germ calmodulin required for half-maximal activation of Ca(2+)-ATPase were tenfold and fourfold higher, respectively, than mammalian calmodulin. Phosphorylation at Tyr99 of [F138]calmodulin shifted its affinity for Ca(2+)-ATPase towards that of mammalian calmodulin. However, phosphorylation at Tyr139 of wheat germ calmodulin had essentially no effect on its interaction with Ca(2+)-ATPase. Thus, all of the observed effects of both phosphorylation and substitution of residues of calmodulin are on its affinity for Ca(2+)-ATPase, not on Vmax. The effects are dependent on the site of phosphate incorporation. Replacement of tyrosine with phenylalanine has a larger effect than phosphorylation of tyrosine, suggesting that the observed functional alterations reflect a secondary conformational change in the C-terminal half of calmodulin, the region that is important in its activation of Ca(2+)-ATPase.

Tyrosine 106 of CheY plays an important role in chemotaxis signal transduction in Escherichia coli

CheY is the response regulator in the signal transduction pathway of bacterial chemotaxis. Position 106 of CheY is occupied by a conserved aromatic residue (tyrosine or phenylalanine) in the response regulator superfamily. A number of substitutions at position 106 have been made and characterized by both behavioral and biochemical studies. On the basis of the behavioral studies, the phenotypes of the mutants at position 106 can be divided into three categories: (i) hyperactivity, with a tyrosine-to-tryptophan mutation (Y106W) causing increased tumble signaling but impairing chemotaxis; (ii) low-level activity, with a tyrosine-to-phenylalanine change (Y106F) resulting in decreased tumble signaling and chemotaxis; and (iii) no activity, with substitutions such as Y106L, Y106I, Y106V, Y106G, and Y106C resulting in no chemotaxis and a smooth-swimming phenotype. All three types of mutants can be phosphorylated by CheA-phosphate in vitro to a level similar to that of wild-type CheY. Autodephosphorylation rates are similar for all categories of mutants. All mutant proteins displayed less than twofold increased rates compared with wild-type CheY. Binding of the mutant proteins to FliM was similar to that of the wild-type CheY in the CheY-FliM binding assays. The combined results from in vivo behavioral and in vitro biochemical studies suggest that the diverse phenotypes of the Y106 mutants are not due to a variation in phosphorylation or dephosphorylation ability nor in affinity for the switch. With reference to the structures of wild-type CheY and the T871 CheY mutant, our results suggest that rearrangements of the orientation of the tyrosine side chain at position 106 are involved in the signal transduction of CheY. These data also suggest that the binding of phosphoryl-CheY to the flagellar motor is a necessary, but not sufficient, event for signal transduction.

Evaluation of Solvent Accessibility to the [Fe(4)S(4)] Binding Pocket in Native and Tyr19 Mutant High Potential Iron Proteins by (1)H-(15)N HMQC and (19)F NMR Experiments

The solvent accessibility of Chromatium vinosumhigh potential iron protein (HiPIP) has been investigated by use of (1)H-(15)N HMQC, and (19)F NMR spectroscopy. These NMR experiments indicate that solvent accessibility to the cluster core is similar, and minimal, for the reduced and oxidized states of native HiPIP, but increases significantly for mutant proteins (Tyr19Leu and Tyr19His). These results support a proposed role [Agarwal, A.; Li, D.; Cowan, J. A. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 1995, 92, 9440-9444] for Tyr19 in maintaining hydrolytic stability of the [Fe(4)S(4)] cluster, and demonstrate a general strategy for mapping out the solvent accessibility of protein-bound metalloredox prosthetic centers.

Mutations leading to altered CheA binding cluster on a face of CheY

CheY is the response regulator of Escherichia coli chemotaxis and is one of the best studied response regulators of the two-component signaling system. CheY can receive phosphate from the histidine kinase, CheA. Phospho-CheY interacts with the motor-switch complex to induce clockwise flagellar rotation, thus causing the cell to tumble. We used an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay to study the direct interaction between the kinase, CheA, and the regulator, CheY. The products of random, suppressor, and site-specific cheY mutants were assayed for their ability to bind CheA. Nine mutants showed altered binding. We sequenced and mapped these point mutations on the crystal structure of CheY, and a high degree of spatial clustering was revealed, indicating that this region of CheY is involved in CheA binding. Interestingly, five of these altered binding mutants were previously defined as being involved in motor-switch binding interactions. This suggested a possible overlap between the motor-switch binding and CheA binding surfaces of CheY. Using CheY (Trp-58) fluorescence quenching, we determined the equilibrium dissociation constants of CheA (124-257) binding for these CheY mutants. The results from the fluorescence quenching are in close agreement with our initial enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay results. Therefore, we propose that the CheA and the motor binding surfaces on CheY partially overlap and that this overlap allows CheY to interact with either the CheA or the flagellar motor, depending on its signaling (phosphorylation) state.

Response regulators of bacterial signal transduction systems: selective domain shuffling during evolution

Response regulators of bacterial sensory transduction systems generally consist of receiver module domains covalently linked to effector domains. The effector domains include DNA binding and/or catalytic units that are regulated by sensor kinase-catalyzed aspartyl phosphorylation within their receiver modules. Most receiver modules are associated with three distinct families of DNA binding domains, but some are associated with other types of DNA binding domains, with methylated chemotaxis protein (MCP) demethylases, or with sensor kinases. A few exist as independent entities which regulate their target systems by noncovalent interactions. In this study the molecular phylogenies of the receiver modules and effector domains of 49 fully sequenced response regulators and their homologues were determined. The three major, evolutionarily distinct, DNA binding domains found in response regulators were evaluated for their phylogenetic relatedness, and the phylogenetic trees obtained for these domains were compared with those for the receiver modules. Members of one family (family 1) of DNA binding domains are linked to large ATPase domains which usually function cooperatively in the activation of E. coli sigma 54-dependent promoters or their equivalents in other bacteria. Members of a second family (family 2) always function in conjunction with the E. coli sigma 70 or its equivalent in other bacteria. A third family of DNA binding domains (family 3) functions by an uncharacterized mechanism involving more than one sigma factor. These three domain families utilize distinct helix-turn-helix motifs for DNA binding. The phylogenetic tree of the receiver modules revealed three major and several minor clusters of these domains. The three major receiver module clusters (clusters 1, 2, and 3) generally function with the three major families of DNA binding domains (families 1, 2, and 3, respectively) to comprise three classes of response regulators (classes 1, 2, and 3), although several exceptions exist. The minor clusters of receiver modules were usually, but not always, associated with other types of effector domains. Finally, several receiver modules did not fit into a cluster. It was concluded that receiver modules usually diverged from common ancestral protein domains together with the corresponding effector domains, although domain shuffling, due to intragenic splicing and fusion, must have occurred during the evolution of some of these proteins. Multiple sequence alignments of the 49 receiver modules and their various types of effector domains, together with other homologous domains, allowed definition of regions of striking sequence similarity and degrees of conservation of specific residues. Sequence data were correlated with structure/function when such information was available.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Effects of phosphorylation, Mg2+, and conformation of the chemotaxis protein CheY on its binding to the flagellar switch protein FliM

CheY is the response regulator of bacterial chemotaxis. Previously, we showed that CheY binds to the flagellar switch protein FliM and that this binding is increased upon phosphorylation of CheY [Welch, M., Oosawa, K., Aizawa, S.-I., & Eisenbach, M. (1993) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 90, 8787-8791]. Here, we demonstrate that it is the phosphorylated conformation of CheY, rather than the phosphate group itself, that is recognized and bound by FliM. We found that subsequent to the phosphorylation of CheY, Mg2+ was not required for the binding of CheY to FliM. However, phosphorylation of CheY did cause a change in the coordination properties of Mg2+ in the acid pocket of the protein. This change in the coordination of Mg2+ required the presence of the absolutely conserved residue Lys109. When Lys109 was substituted by arginine, the resulting CheY protein was unable to adopt an active conformation upon phosphorylation, and the protein was not bound by FliM. Surprisingly, the CheY13DK mutant protein, which is active in vivo but cannot be phosphorylated in vitro, exhibited only a low level of FliM binding activity, suggesting that its ability to cause clockwise rotation in the cell is not due to a constitutively high level of FliM binding. On the basis of these findings, we propose a mechanism for CheY activation by phosphorylation.

Chemosensing and signal transduction in bacteria

Major advances have been made over the past year in understanding the molecular mechanisms involved in membrane receptor function, and in resolving the global organization of intracellular signaling pathways. Crystallographic and biochemical studies are revealing details of transmembrane signaling mechanisms and the phosphorylation reactions of the two-component regulatory systems. In addition, the discovery of new signal transduction pathways and new inputs into known pathways are providing a clearer view of the basic architecture of the signal transduction networks within the bacterial cell.

Rhizobium meliloti DctD, a sigma 54-dependent transcriptional activator, may be negatively controlled by a subdomain in the C-terminal end of its two-component receiver module

Rhizobium meliloti DctD is believed to have three functional domains: an N-terminal, two-component receiver domain; and like other sigma 54-dependent activators, C-terminal and central domains for DNA binding and transcription activation. We have characterized a progressive series of N-terminal deletions of R. meliloti DctD. The N-terminal domain was not needed for binding the dctA upstream activation sequence. Only 25% of the C-terminal end of the receive domain was needed to significantly inhibit the central domain, and proteins lacking up to 60% of the N-terminal end of the receiver domain were 'inducible' in R. meliloti cells. We hypothesize that the N-terminal two-thirds of the DctD receiver domain augments and controls an adjacent subdomain for inhibiting the central domain.