The association reaction between hemoglobin and carbon monoxide as studied by the isolation of the intermediates. Implications on the mechanism of cooperativity

Carbon Monoxide as a Potential Therapeutic Agent: A Molecular Analysis of Its Safety Profiles

Carbon monoxide (CO) is endogenously produced in mammals, with blood concentrations in the high micromolar range in the hemoglobin-bound form. Further, CO has shown therapeutic effects in various animal models. Despite its reputation as a poisonous gas at high concentrations, we show that CO should have a wide enough safety margin for therapeutic applications. The analysis considers a large number of factors including levels of endogenous CO, its safety margin in comparison to commonly encountered biomolecules or drugs, anticipated enhanced safety profiles when delivered via a noninhalation mode, and the large amount of safety data from human clinical trials. It should be emphasized that having a wide enough safety margin for therapeutic use does not mean that it is benign or safe to the general public, even at low doses. We defer the latter to public health experts. Importantly, this Perspective is written for drug discovery professionals and not the general public.

Stability and Folding of the Unusually Stable Hemoglobin from Synechocystis is Subtly Optimized and Dependent on the Key Heme Pocket Residues

AIMS

The aim of our study is to understand the biophysical traits that govern the stability and folding of Synechocystis hemoglobin, a unique cyanobacterial globin that displays unusual traits not observed in any of the other globins discovered so far.

BACKGROUND

For the past few decades, classical hemoglobins such as vertebrate hemoglobin and myoglobin have been extensively studied to unravel the stability and folding mechanisms of hemoglobins. However, the expanding wealth of hemoglobins identified in all life forms with novel properties, like heme coordination chemistry and globin fold, have added complexity and challenges to the understanding of hemoglobin stability, which has not been adequately addressed. Here, we explored the unique truncated and hexacoordinate hemoglobin from the freshwater cyanobacterium Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 known as "Synechocystis hemoglobin (SynHb)". The "three histidines" linkages to heme are novel to this cyanobacterial hemoglobin.

OBJECTIVE

Mutational studies were employed to decipher the residues within the heme pocket that dictate the stability and folding of SynHb.

METHODS

Site-directed mutants of SynHb were generated and analyzed using a repertoire of spectroscopic and calorimetric tools.

RESULTS

The results revealed that the heme was stably associated to the protein under all denaturing conditions with His117 playing the anchoring role. The studies also highlighted the possibility of existence of a "molten globule" like intermediate at acidic pH in this exceptionally thermostable globin. His117 and other key residues in the heme pocket play an indispensable role in imparting significant polypeptide stability.

CONCLUSION

Synechocystis hemoglobin presents an important model system for investigations of protein folding and stability in general. The heme pocket residues influenced the folding and stability of SynHb in a very subtle and specific manner and may have been optimized to make this Hb the most stable known as of date. Other: The knowledge gained hereby about the influence of heme pocket amino acid side chains on stability and expression is currently being utilized to improve the stability of recombinant human Hbs for efficient use as oxygen delivery vehicles.

Kinetic inequivalence between α and β subunits of ligand dissociation from ferrous nitrosylated human haptoglobin:hemoglobin complexes. A comparison with O2 and CO dissociation

Haptoglobin (Hp) counterbalances the adverse effects of extra-erythrocytic hemoglobin (Hb) by trapping the αβ dimers of Hb in the bloodstream. In turn, the Hp:Hb complexes display Hb-like reactivity. Here, the kinetics of NO dissociation from ferrous nitrosylated Hp:Hb complexes (i.e., Hp1-1:Hb(II)-NO and Hp2-2:Hb(II)-NO, respectively) are reported at pH 7.0 and 20.0 °C. NO dissociation from Hp:Hb(II)-NO complexes has been followed by replacing NO with CO. Denitrosylation kinetics of Hp1-1:Hb(II)-NO and Hp2-2:Hb(II)-NO are biphasic, the relative amplitude of the fast and slow phase being 0.495 ± 0.015 and 0.485 ± 0.025, respectively. Values of k_off(NO)1 and k_off(NO)2 (i.e., (6.4 ± 0.8) × 10^-5 s^-1 and (3.6 ± 0.6) × 10^-5 s^-1 for Hp1-1:Hb(II)-NO and (5.8 ± 0.8) × 10^-5 s^-1 and (3.1 ± 0.6) × 10^-5 s^-1 for Hp2-2:Hb(II)-NO) are unaffected by allosteric effectors and correspond to those reported for the α and β subunits of tetrameric Hb(II)-NO and isolated α(II)-NO and β(II)-NO chains, respectively. This highlights the view that the conformation of the Hb α₁β₁ and α₂β₂ dimers matches that of the Hb high affinity conformation. Moreover, the observed functional heterogeneity reflects the variation of energy barriers for the ligand detachment and exit pathway(s) associated to the different structural arrangement of the two subunits in the nitrosylated R-state. Noteworthy, the extent of the inequivalence of α and β chains is closely similar for the O₂, NO and CO dissociation in the R-state, suggesting that it is solely determined by the structural difference between the two subunits.

Haptoglobin: From hemoglobin scavenging to human health

Haptoglobin (Hp) belongs to the family of acute-phase plasma proteins and represents the most important plasma detoxifier of hemoglobin (Hb). The basic Hp molecule is a tetrameric protein built by two α/β dimers. Each Hp α/β dimer is encoded by a single gene and is synthesized as a single polypeptide. Following post-translational protease-dependent cleavage of the Hp polypeptide, the α and β chains are linked by disulfide bridge(s) to generate the mature Hp protein. As human Hp gene is characterized by two common Hp1 and Hp2 alleles, three major genotypes can result (i.e., Hp1-1, Hp2-1, and Hp2-2). Hp regulates Hb clearance from circulation by the macrophage-specific receptor CD163, thus preventing Hb-mediated severe consequences for health. Indeed, the antioxidant and Hb binding properties of Hp as well as its ability to stimulate cells of the monocyte/macrophage lineage and to modulate the helper T-cell type 1 and type 2 balance significantly associate with a variety of pathogenic disorders (e.g., infectious diseases, diabetes, cardiovascular diseases, and cancer). Alternative functions of the variants Hp1 and Hp2 have been reported, particularly in the susceptibility and protection against infectious (e.g., pulmonary tuberculosis, HIV, and malaria) and non-infectious (e.g., diabetes, cardiovascular diseases and obesity) diseases. Both high and low levels of Hp are indicative of clinical conditions: Hp plasma levels increase during infections, inflammation, and various malignant diseases, and decrease during malnutrition, hemolysis, hepatic disease, allergic reactions, and seizure disorders. Of note, the Hp:Hb complexes display heme-based reactivity; in fact, they bind several ferrous and ferric ligands, including O₂, CO, and NO, and display (pseudo-)enzymatic properties (e.g., NO and peroxynitrite detoxification). Here, genetic, biochemical, biomedical, and biotechnological aspects of Hp are reviewed.

Introduction: twenty five years of the Gibbs Conference on Biothermodynamics

In 2011, the Gibbs Conference on Biothermodynamics will celebrate its 25th anniversary. Since the inaugural meeting in 1987, it has brought together laboratories that lived, breathed and argued about the molecular logic of macromolecular machines. The participants have a deep commitment to understanding the nature of physico-chemical forces that govern regulation of biological systems, and share a passion for applying linkage theory. The collective goal is to understand how ligand binding, subunit assembly and conformational change drive what we observe as physiological processes such as regulated transport, enzyme cascades, gene regulation, membrane permeability, viral infection, intracellular trafficking and folding of macromolecules. In this special issue, articles by former organizers of the Gibbs Conference showcase the current breadth and depth of the field of biothermodynamics, and how thoroughly it is integrated with the study of macromolecular structures, computational modeling and physiological studies of human health and disease.

Understanding mechanisms in a cooperative protein: the CO ligation intermediates of hemoglobin

Hemoglobin is a regulatory component of the oxygen transport to the tissues, and for decades has been a prototype to develop new strategies for the study of the structure/function relationships in proteins. One of the most difficult, and so far, unattained objectives of hemoglobin research has been the study of the hemoglobin molecules in a state of partial ligation with oxygen, or intermediates, as a means of testing theories of cooperativity. A cryogenic technique has been developed for the isolation, identification and quantification of the reaction intermediates of hemoglobin and CO, which in many aspects is a close approximation to the physiological ligand. The technical features that are crucial for the evaluation of the significance of the experimental data obtained using this technique and various approaches to the analysis of the data are reported. The discussion points out the importance of accessing direct information on the nature and concentrations of the intermediates in solution to clarify mechanisms of cooperativity as opposed to the less informative studies of the bulk properties of the solution.

Asymmetric (deoxy dimer/azido-met dimer) hemoglobin hybrids dissociate within seconds

Double mixing stopped-flow experiments have been performed to study the stability of asymmetric hemoglobin (Hb) hybrids, consisting of a deoxy and a liganded dimer. The doubly liganded [deoxy/cyano-met] hybrid (species 21) was reported to have an enhanced stability, with tetramer to dimer dissociation requiring over 100 seconds, based on a method that required an incubation of over two days. However, kinetic experiments revealed rapid ligand binding to species 21, as for triply liganded tetramers, which dissociate within a few seconds. For the present study, [deoxy dimer/azido-met dimer] hybrids are formed within 200 ms by stopped-flow mixing of dithionite with a solution containing oxyHb and azido-metHb. The dithionite scavenges oxygen, thus transforming oxyHb to deoxyHb, and the [oxy dimer/azido-met dimer] hybrid to the asymmetric [deoxy/azido-met] hybrid (species 21). After a variable aging time of the asymmetric hybrids, their allosteric state is probed by CO binding in a second mixing. As previously observed the freshly produced asymmetric hybrids bind CO rapidly as for R-state Hb. As the hybrids are aged from 0.1 to 10 seconds, the fraction of slow CO binding increases, consistent with a dissociation of the asymmetric hybrid to form the more stable deoxy Hb tetramer which reacts slowly with CO. Control experiments showed a predominantly slow phase for deoxy Hb, and fast rebinding for the symmetric hybrids. The kinetic data can be simulated with a tetramer to dimer dissociation rate for species 21 of 1.5/second at 100 mM NaCl (pH 7.2) and 1.9/second at 180 mM NaCl (pH 7.4). These values are similar to those reported for liganded Hb, as opposed to deoxy (T-state) tetramers which dissociate over four orders of magnitude more slowly. As expected from simulations of dimer exchange, the observed transition rate depends on the initial fractions of oxy- and metHb; this effect is not consistent with a slow R to T transition. These results, showing a lifetime of about one second for species 21, do not support the symmetry rule which is based on an enhanced stability of the asymmetric hybrid.

Molecular dynamics of human methemoglobin: the transmission of conformational information between subunits in an alpha beta dimer

Spectroscopic studies indicate an interaction of the distal histidine with the heme iron as well as the transmission of distal heme perturbations across the alpha1beta1 interface. Molecular dynamics simulations have been used to explain the molecular basis for these processes. Using a human methemoglobin alpha beta dimer, it has been shown that at 235 K after 61 ps, a rearrangement occurs in the alpha-chain corresponding to the formation of a bond with the distal histidine. This transition does not take place in the beta-chain during a 100-ps simulation and is reversed at 300 K. The absence of the distal histidine transition in the isolated chains and with the interface frozen indicate the involvement of the alphabeta interface. A detailed analysis of the simulation has been performed in terms of RMS fluctuations, domain cross-correlation maps, the disruption of helix hydrogen bonds, as well changes in electrostatic interactions and dihedral angles. This analysis shows that the rearrangements in the alpha-chain necessary to bring the histidine closer to the iron involve alterations primarily in the CD loop and at the interface. Communication to the beta-chain distal pocket is propagated by increased interactions of the alpha-chain B helix with the beta-chain G-GH-H segment and the flexibility in the EF loop. The G helices shown to be involved in propagation of perturbation across the alpha1beta1 interface extend into the alpha1beta2 interfaces, providing a mechansim whereby distal interactions can modulate the T<==>R transition in hemoglobin.

Heterotropic effectors exert more significant strain on monoligated than on unligated hemoglobin

The effect of allosteric effectors, such as inositol hexakisphosphate and/or bezafibrate, has been investigated on the unliganded human adult hemoglobin both spectroscopically (employing electronic absorption, circular dichroism, resonance Raman, and x-ray absorption near-edge spectroscopies) and functionally (following the kinetics of the first CO binding step up to a final 4% ligand saturation degree). All data indicate that the unliganded T-state is not perturbed by the interaction with either one or both effectors, suggesting that their functional influence is only exerted when a ligand molecule is bound to the heme. This is confirmed by the observation that CO dissociation from partially liganded hemoglobin ( </= 0.04) is strongly altered by the presence of either effector, and the effect is enhanced whenever the two effectors are simultaneously present. Altogether, these data are a direct demonstration of the occurrence of a strain induced by the presence of a ligand molecule bound to the heme, and for the first time there is a clear indication that the expression of the functional heterotropic effect by these non-heme ligands requires this strain, which is not present in the unliganded molecule.

Functional comparison of specifically cross-linked hemoglobins biased toward the R and T states

Selected functional and spectroscopic properties of two human hemoglobin (HbA0) derivatives that were site-specifically cross-linked in the cleft between beta-chains where 2, 3-bisphosphoglycerate normally binds have been determined to assess the effects of the cross-linking on the behavior of the protein. Trimesoyl tris(3,5-dibromosalicylate) (TTDS) cross-links Hb between beta82Lys residues. The resulting TTDS-Hb exhibits a slower rate of oxygen dissociation and an increased rate of carbon monoxide association than observed for HbA0. The electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectrum of TTDS-HbNO does not exhibit the hyperfine structure that is indicative of significant conformational change despite the fact that the 2,3-bisphosphoglycerate binding site is occupied by the cross-linking reagent. The reactivity of the beta93Cys residues of TTDS-Hb is only slightly decreased relative to that of HbA0. On the other hand, cross-linking Hb between Lys82 and the amino-terminal beta1Val group with trimesoyl tris(methyl phosphate) (TMMP) increases the rate of oxygen dissociation and reduces the rate of CO association relative to the rates observed for HbA0. In addition, the EPR spectrum of the TMMP-HbNO exhibits the three-line hyperfine structure that results from disruption of the proximal His-Fe bond of the alpha-chains, and the accessibility of the betaCys93 residues in this derivative is decreased fourfold. The present results are consistent with the conclusion that the quaternary structure of TTDS-Hb is shifted toward the R state whereas the quaternary structure of TMMP-Hb is shifted toward the T state and provides additional evidence that the identity of the residues involved in intramolecular cross-linking of hemoglobin within the 2,3-bisphosphoglycerate binding site between beta-chains can have a significant influence on the conformational and functional properties of the protein.

Rate constants for O2 and CO binding to the alpha and beta subunits within the R and T states of human hemoglobin

Despite a large amount of work over the past 30 years, there is still no universal agreement on the differential reactivities of the individual alpha and beta subunits in human hemoglobin. To address this question systematically, we prepared a series of hybrid hemoglobins in which heme was replaced by chromium(III), manganese(III), nickel(II), and magnesium(II) protoporphyrin IXs in either the alpha or beta subunits to produce alpha2(M)beta2(Fe)1 and alpha2(Fe)beta2(M) tetramers. None of the abnormal metal complexes react with dioxygen or carbon monoxide. The O2 affinities of the resultant hemoglobins vary from 3 microM-1 (Cr(III)/Fe(II) hybrids) to 0.003 microM-1 (Mg(II)/Fe(II) hybrids), covering the full range expected for the various high (R) and low (T) affinity quaternary conformations, respectively, of human hemoglobin A0. The alpha and beta subunits in hemoglobin have similar O2 affinities in both quaternary states, despite the fact that the R to T transition causes significantly different structural changes in the alpha and beta heme pockets. This functional equivalence almost certainly evolved to maintain high n values for efficient O2 transport.

Chimeric beta-EF3-alpha hemoglobin (Psi): energetics of subunit interaction and ligand binding

Among the numerous strategies to design an oxygen carrier, we outline in this work the engineering of a stable homotetrameric hemoglobin, expressed in Escherichia coli. The chimeric globin (Psi) consists of the first 79 residues of human beta globin (corresponding to positions NA1 --> EF3) followed by the final 67 residues of human alpha globin (corresponding to positions EF3 --> HC3). The molecular mass for beta-EF3-alpha (Psi) globin was measured using mass spectrometry to be equal to its theoretical value: 15782 Da. Correct protein folding was assessed by UV/visible and fluorescence spectra. The subunit interaction free energies were estimated by HPLC gel filtration. In the cyanometHb species, the formation of the dimer-tetramer interface is 2 kcal/mol less favorable (Delta G = -7 kcal/mol) than that of Hb A (Delta G = -9 kcal/mol), whereas the dimer-monomer interface is tightly assembled (< -10 kcal/mol) as for the Hb A alpha 1 beta 1 interface. In contrast to Hb A, oxygen binding to Psi Hb is not cooperative. The free energy for binding four oxygen molecules to a Psi homotetramer is slightly increased compared to a Hb A heterotetramer (-28 and -27.5 kcal/4 mol of O2, respectively). The intrinsic O2 affinity of a Psi homodimer is 6-fold higher than that of a homotetramer. The linkage scheme between dimer-tetramer subunit assembly and the noncooperative oxygenation of Psi Hb predicts a stabilization of the tetramer after ligand release. This protein mechanism resembles that of Hb A for which the dimers exhibit a 100-fold higher O2 affinity relative to deoxy tetramers (which are 10(5) times more stable than oxy tetramers). A potent allosteric effector of Hb A, RSR4, binds to Psi Hb tetramers, inducing a decrease of the overall O2 affinity. Since RSR4 interacts specifically with two binding sites of deoxy Hb A, we propose that the chimeric tetramer folding is close to this native structure.

Preparation and kinetic characterization of a series of betaW37 variants of human hemoglobin A: evidence for high-affinity T quaternary structures

Four variants of human beta globin in which the Trp at position 37 has been replaced with a Tyr, Ala, Gly, or Glu have been expressed in Escherichia coli. These globins have been combined with normal human alpha chains and heme to form tetrameric hemoglobin molecules. A technique for the preparation of alpha chain dimers, which are cross-linked between their alpha99 lysine residues, has been developed, and these alpha dimers were combined with two of the beta globins, betaW37G and betaW37E, to form the corresponding cross-linked variants. The kinetics of CO binding to the deoxygenated derivatives following rapid mixing and of CO rebinding following flash photolysis have been examined as functions of pH in the presence and absence of the organic phosphate inositol hexaphosphate, IHP. The kinetic measurements indicate that replacement of the tryptophan with other residues destabilizes the hemoglobin tetramer, resulting in considerable dissociation of even the deoxygenated hemoglobins into alphabeta dimers at micromolar protein concentrations. Substitutions at beta37 also alter the properties of the deoxygenated hemoglobin tetramer. The alteration of the functional properties of the T states of these variants as well as the tendency of the deoxygenated derivatives to dissociate into alphabeta dimers increases in the order HbA < betaW37Y < betaW37A < betaW37G < betaW37E. Stabilizing the betaW37G or betaW37E tetramers by addition of IHP or by cross-linking does not restore the normal functional properties of the T state. Measurements of the geminate rebinding of CO establish a kinetic difference between the normal R state tetramer and the alphabeta dimer consistent with quaternary enhancement, the greater affinity of oxygen for the R state tetramer than for the alphabeta dimer. Kinetics of geminate rebinding also suggest that quaternary enhancement may be altered by substitutions at the beta37 position.

Modulation of the association reaction between hemoglobin and carbon monoxide by proton and chloride

A cryogenic technique for the isolation of the ligation intermediates in the association reaction between hemoglobin and carbon monoxide at 20 degrees C [Perrella, M., Davids, N., and Rossi-Bernardi, L. (1992) J. Biol. Chem. 267, 8744-8751] was used to study the effects of proton and chloride concentrations on the rates of the stepwise reactions. The reaction rate was observed to increase continuously in the course of the ligation process, yet the acceleration of the reaction after the binding of two ligand molecules, observed previously in 100 mM KCl, pH 7, was not observed at other pH values. At pH 6.3, such an acceleration occurred after the binding of three ligands, and at pH 8.5, a large acceleration was observed after the binding of the first ligand molecule. Greater CO binding to the beta chains was observed under all conditions, as in the previous study. The functional heterogeneity of the chains in the first ligation step increased with pH. The chloride concentration did not influence the distribution of the ligand between the alpha and beta chains at pH 6.3 and 8.5. At pH 7, less binding to the alpha chains was observed at 7 mM chloride with respect to 100 mM. The nature of the biliganded component isolated at pH 7 in 100 mM KCl and unresolved by the cryogenic technique was studied using a combination of cryogenic and noncryogenic isoelectric focusing. This component was a mixture of intermediates (alpha beta) (alpha CO beta CO), about 65%, and (alpha beta CO) (alpha CO beta), about 35%. The experimental data were compared with the distributions of intermediates calculated according to the Monod kinetic model assuming rapid and concerted transitions between two quaternary structures at each ligation step. The model provided a qualitative fit of the observed distributions of intermediates at acidic and neutral pH. A large discrepancy between the experimental observations and the predictions of the model was found at alkaline pH. The mechanism of the association reaction is discussed in the light of the available information on the tertiary/quaternary structures of the intermediates, as obtained from the studies of the deoxy/cyanomet model of ligation.

Functional heterogeneity of the alpha and beta subunits in the association reaction between hemoglobin and carbon monoxide

A technique is described for the rapid inactivation and removal of excess ferricyanide used for the non-cryogenic oxidation of the unliganded subunits of the intermediates in the association reaction between hemoglobin and carbon monoxide. Under these conditions the asymmetric oxidized intermediates, which dissociate into non-identical dimers, disproportionate into their parent tetramers and four species, Hb+, HbCO, alpha 2+ beta 2CO, alpha 2CO beta 2+, are isolated by non-cryogenic isoelectric focusing. The relative concentrations of species alpha 2CO beta 2+ and alpha 2+ beta 2CO measure the overall distribution of the ligand between the alpha and beta subunits in the association reaction. At 20 degrees C in 0.1 M KCl, pH 7, preferential CO binding to the beta subunits was observed, in agreement with observations made by the cryogenic technique for the isolation of the intermediates [M. Perrella, N. Davids and L. Rossi-Bernardi, J. Biol. Chem. 267 (1992) 8744].

Transformation of cooperative free energies between ligation systems of hemoglobin: resolution of the carbon monoxide binding intermediates

A strategy has been developed for quantitatively "translating" the distributions of cooperative free energy between different oxygenation analogs of hemoglobin (Hb). The method was used to resolve the cooperative free energies of all eight carbon monoxide binding intermediates. These parameters of the FeCOHb system were determined by thermodynamic transformation of corresponding free energies obtained previously for all species of the Co/FeCO system, i.e., where cobalt-substituted hemes comprise the unligated sites [Speros, P. C., et al. (1991) Biochemistry 30, 7254-7262]. Using hybridized combinations of normal and cobalt-substituted Hb, ligation analog systems Co/FeX (X = CO, CN) were constructed and experimentally quantified. Energetics of cobalt-induced structural perturbation were determined for all species of both the "mixed metal" Co/Fe system and also the ligated Co/FeCN system. It was found that major energetic perturbations of the Co/Fe hybrid species originate from a pure cobalt substitution effect on the alpha subunits. These perturbations are transduced to the beta subunit within the same dimeric half-tetramer, resulting in alteration of the free energies for binding at the nonsubstituted (Fe) sites. Using the linkage strategy developed in this study along with the determined energetics of these couplings, the experimental assembly free energies for the Co/FeCO species were transformed into cooperative free energies of the 10 Fe/FeCO species. The resulting values were found to distribute according to predictions of a symmetry rule mechanism proposed previously [Ackers, G. K., et al. (1992) Science 255, 54-63]. Their distribution is consistent with accurate CO binding data of normal Hb [Perrella, M., et al. (1990b) Biophys. Chem. 37, 211-223] and also with accurate O2 binding data obtained under the same conditions [Chu, A. H., et al. (1984) Biochemistry 23, 604-617].

Bohr effects of the partially-ligated (CN-met) intermediates of hemoglobin as probed by quaternary assembly

Free energies of quaternary assembly (dimers to tetramers) were determined for the 10 ligation species of CN-methemoglobin in the region of the alkaline Bohr effect (pH 7.0-9.5). Analysis of this database yielded the following principal findings: (1) At each pH, the nine CN-met species exhibit two distinct values of Bohr proton release and Bohr free energy. The two Bohr effects are found to distribute in a fashion that coincides with predictions of a symmetry rule (Ackers et al., 1992), i.e., the first value reflects a "tertiary Bohr effect" arising from ligation within the quaternary T tetramer and a second Bohr effect arises from the quaternary transition (T-->R) which occurs when both dimeric half-molecules acquire at least one ligated subunit. (2) The Bohr effects for CN-met ligation are in good agreement with previously-established Bohr effects for stepwise O2 binding under identical conditions (Chu et al., 1984). (3) In combination with recent studies which show that CN-met species [21] has a quaternary T structure (Daugherty et al., 1991; Doyle & Ackers, 1992; LiCata et al., 1993), the present results show that the "tertiary Bohr effect" within quaternary T exceeds the Bohr effect of dissociated dimers, as suggested by Lee and Karplus (1983). (4) The tertiary Bohr effect is found to account for the pH dependence of tertiary constraint energy, delta Gtc, which "pays" for ligand-binding cooperativity prior to the quaternary (T-->R) switchover. Possible origins of the tertiary Bohr effect and its relationship to the quaternary Bohr effect are considered.

Bohr effect in hemoglobin deoxy/cyanomet intermediates

The Bohr protons released by oxygen exposure of the unliganded subunits of intermediates (alpha +CN-beta) (alpha +CN-beta) and (alpha beta +CN-) (alpha beta +CN-) were obtained by titrations of concentrated solutions of these species. The Bohr protons released by oxygen exposure of the other intermediates were obtained from titrations of equilibrium mixtures of two parental species, (alpha beta) (alpha beta), (alpha +CN-beta) (alpha +CN-beta), (alpha beta +CN-) (alpha beta +CN-), and (alpha +CN-beta +CN-) (alpha +CN-beta +CN-), in which the concentration of the hybrid intermediate was determined by cryogenic electrophoretic techniques. The Bohr effect of the intermediates was calculated by subtracting the Bohr protons released by oxygen exposure of the intermediates from the total Bohr protons of deoxyhemoglobin at the same pH. The Bohr effects of intermediates (alpha +CN-beta) (alpha beta) and (alpha beta +CN-) (alpha beta) were similar and vanished at pH 8 where the total Bohr effect of deoxyhemoglobin is still significant. This suggests that the Bohr effect in these intermediates is tertiary in the quaternary T structure. The curve of the Bohr effect of intermediate (alpha +CN-beta +CN-) (alpha beta), which was close to the curve obtained by adding the Bohr effects of the two monoliganded intermediates at acidic and physiological pH values, was significantly different from the curve obtained by adding the Bohr effects of one liganded subunit of intermediate (alpha +CN-beta) (alpha +CN-beta) and one liganded subunit of intermediate (alpha beta +CN-) (alpha beta +CN-).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Mechanism of the oxidation reaction of deoxyhemoglobin as studied by isolation of the intermediates suggests tertiary structure dependent cooperativity

The intermediates in the oxidation of deoxyhemoglobin by ferricyanide in 0.1 M KCl, at 20 degrees C and three pH values, were studied by cryogenic techniques. Data analysis was carried out according to a simple four rate constant model, ignoring the functional heterogeneity of the subunits, to simulate the time courses of the oxidation reaction, as studied by the stopped-flow technique [Antonini et al., (1965) Biochemistry 4, 345], which show anticooperativity at neutral pH and cooperativity at alkaline pH. Data analysis according to a 12 rate constant model indicated that the rate of oxidation of the beta subunit in the first oxidation reaction was 4 times faster than the rate of oxidation of the alpha subunit at pH 6.2 and 12 times faster at pH 8.5. The reactions involving the alpha subunit were noncooperative except for the last oxidation step at acid and neutral pH, but were cooperative at alkaline pH. The reactions involving the beta subunit were partly noncooperative and partly anticooperative. These complex mechanistic patterns suggest that a simple two-state model requiring the concerted transition of the tertiary structures of the subunits from the T to the R conformation is not adequate to interpret the oxidation reaction and that tertiary structures contribute, positively and negatively, to cooperativity. A structural hypothesis is suggested to explain the difference in the reactivities of the alpha and beta subunits.

Analytic models for nonlinear curve-fitting of forward-rate binding data, with applications to hemoglobin

The experimental procedure of Perrella et al. (1983, J. Biol. Chem. 258, 4511-4517) can reveal most of the intermediate ligation states of hemoglobin either at equilibrium or in a kinetic reaction. In this paper, a model of stepwise ligand binding, under conditions of negligible reverse reaction, is derived with particular attention to hemoglobin. The model leads to a two-phase procedure. First, the ratios of the forward rates are determined by fitting the model to normalized concentrations vs. saturation. Second (optionally), an auxiliary relation is used to deduce the scale factor for the rates that make the model consistent with time information if such is available. The procedure has been applied to hemoglobin binding of the ligands carbon monoxide (this paper) and ferricyanide (manuscript in preparation).