The synthesis of enzyme-bound ATP by soluble chloroplast coupling factor 1

How Do Instructors Explain The Mechanism by which ATP Drives Unfavorable Processes?

Concerns regarding students' difficulties with the concept of energy date back to the 1970s. They become particularly apparent for systems involving adenosine triphosphate (ATP), which plays a central role in maintaining the nonequilibrium state of biological systems and in driving energetically unfavorable processes. One of the most well-documented misconceptions related to ATP is the idea that breaking bonds releases energy, when the opposite is true. This misconception is often attributed to language used in biology referring to the "high-energy bonds" in ATP. We interviewed chemistry, biology, and biochemistry instructors to learn how they think about and teach the mechanism(s) by which ATP is used as an energy source in biological systems. Across 15 interviews, we found that instructors relied primarily on two mechanisms to explain the role of ATP: 1) energy release, focused on ATP hydrolysis and bond energies; and/or 2) energy transfer, focused on phosphorylation and common intermediates. Many instructors shared negative and uncomfortable experiences related to teaching ATP and energy release. Based on these findings, we suggest instructional strategies that: 1) aim to ease the concerns expressed by introductory biology instructors, and 2) emphasize the role of ATP so as to support students' understanding of molecular mechanisms.

Energy-linked binding of Pi is required for continuous steady-state proton-translocating ATP hydrolysis catalyzed by F0.F1 ATP synthase

The presence of medium Pi (half-maximal concentration of 20 microM at pH 8.0) was found to be required for the prevention of the rapid decline in the rate of proton-motive force (pmf)-induced ATP hydrolysis by Fo.F1 ATP synthase in coupled vesicles derived from Paracoccus denitrificans. The initial rate of the reaction was independent of Pi. The apparent affinity of Pi for its "ATPase-protecting" site was strongly decreased with partial uncoupling of the vesicles. Pi did not reactivate ATPase when added after complete time-dependent deactivation during the enzyme turnover. Arsenate and sulfate, which was shown to compete with Pi when Fo.F1 catalyzed oxidative phosphorylation, substituted for Pi as the protectors of ATPase against the turnover-dependent deactivation. Under conditions where the enzyme turnover was not permitted (no ATP was present), Pi was not required for the pmf-induced activation of ATPase, whereas the presence of medium Pi (or sulfate) delayed the spontaneous deactivation of the enzyme which was induced by the membrane de-energization. The data are interpreted to suggest that coupled and uncoupled ATP hydrolysis catalyzed by Fo.F1 ATP synthases proceeds via different intermediates. Pi dissociates after ADP if the coupling membrane is energized (no E.ADP intermediate exists). Pi dissociates before ADP during uncoupled ATP hydrolysis, leaving the E.ADP intermediate which is transformed into the inactive ADP(Mg2+)-inhibited form of the enzyme (latent ATPase).

Rapid hydrolysis of ATP by mitochondrial F1-ATPase correlates with the filling of the second of three catalytic sites

Strong positive catalytic cooperativity is a central feature of the binding change mechanism for F1-ATPases. However, a detail of the mechanism that remains controversial is whether the kinetic enhancement derived from using substrate-binding energy at one catalytic site to promote product release from another site occurs upon the filling of the second or third of three catalytic sites on F1. To address this question, we compare the ATP concentration dependence of the rate of ATP hydrolysis by F1 from beef heart mitochondria to the ATP concentration dependence of the level of occupancy of catalytic sites during steady-state catalysis as measured by a centrifuge filtration assay. A single Km(ATP) is observed at 77 +/- 6 microM. Analysis of the nucleotide-binding data shows that half-maximal occupancy of a second catalytic site occurs at 78 +/- 18 microM ATP. We conclude that ATP binding to a second catalytic site is sufficient to support rapid rates of catalysis.

THECHLOROPLASTATP SYNTHASE: A Rotary Enzyme?

The chloroplast adenosine triphosphate (ATP) synthase is located in the thylakoid membrane and synthesizes ATP from adenosine diphosphate and inorganic phosphate at the expense of the electrochemical proton gradient formed by light-dependent electron flow. The structure, activities, and mechanism of the chloroplast ATP synthase are discussed. Emphasis is given to the inherent structural asymmetry of the ATP synthase and to the implication of this asymmetry to the mechanism of ATP synthesis and hydrolysis. A critical evaluation of the evidence in support of and against the notion that one part of the enzyme rotates with respect to other parts during catalytic turnover is presented. It is concluded that although rotation can occur, whether it is required for activity of the ATP synthase has not been established unequivocally.

Does the gamma subunit move to an abortive position of ATP hydrolysis when the F1.ADP.Mg complex isomerizes to the inactive F1*.ADP.Mg complex?

F1-ATPases transiently entrap inhibitory MgADP in a catalytic site during turnover when noncatalytic sites are not saturated with ATP. An initial burst of ATP hydrolysis rapidly decelerates to a slow intermediate rate that gradually accelerates to a final steady-state rate. Transition from the intermediate to the final rate is caused by slow binding of ATP to noncatalytic sites which promotes dissociation of inhibitory MgADP from the affected catalytic site. Evidence from several laboratories suggests that the gamma subunit rotates with respect to alpha/beta subunit pairs of F1-ATPase during ATP hydrolysis. The alpha 3 beta 3 and alpha 3 beta 3 delta subcomplexes of the TF1-ATPase do not entrap inhibitory MgADP in a catalytic site during turnover, suggesting involvement of the gamma subunit in the entrapment process. From these observations, it is proposed that the gamma subunit moves into an abortive position for ATP hydrolysis when inhibitory MgADP is entrapped in a catalytic site during ATP hydrolysis.

Energy-dependent changes in the ATP/ADP ratio at the tight nucleotide binding site of chloroplast ATP synthase

Using DTT-modulated thylakoid membranes we studied tight nucleotide binding and ATP content in bound nucleotides and in the reaction mixture during [(14)C] ADP photophosphorylation. The increasing light intensity caused an increase in the rate of [(14)C] ADP incorporation and a decrease in the steady-state level of tightly bound nucleotides. Within the light intensity range from 11 to 710 w m(-2), ATP content in bound nucleotides was larger than that in nucleotides of the reaction mixture; the most prominent difference was observed at low degrees of ADP phosphorylation. The increasing light intensity was accompanied by a significant increase of the relative ATP content in tightly bound nucleotides. The ratio between substrates and products formed at the tight nucleotide binding site during photophosphorylation was suggested to depend on the light-induced proton gradient across the thylakoid membrane.

Synthesis of a self-contained concept of the molecular mechanism of energy interconversion by H(+)-transporting ATP synthase

The original aim of the review has been to probe into the validity of the paradigm on the high energy-carrier function of ATP. It seemed to be called into question on the basis of findings with H(+)-transporting ATP synthase suggesting the formation of ATP from ADP and Pi without energy input. Thus, ATP appeared as a low-energy compound. Starting from the current, rich knowledge of the molecular structure and the inviting thinking on the mechanism of H(+)-transporting ATP synthase, we have endeavoured to freshly interpret and integrate the pertinent observations in the light of the comprehensively derived model of the molecular mechanism of energy interconversion by Na+/K(+)-transporting ATPase. In this way, we have uncovered the common mechanistic elements of the two energy-interconverting enzymes. The emerging purpose of the present paper has been the 'synthesis' of a self-contained concept of the molecular mechanism of the interconversion of electrochemical and chemical Gibbs energies by H(+)-transporting ATP synthase. The outcome is reflected in the following tentative evaluations. 1. In ATP hydrolysis, the great Gibbs energy change which is observed in solution, is largely conserved by the F1 sector of ATP synthase as mechanical Gibbs energy in the enzyme's protein fabric, so that it can be utilized in the resynthesis of ATP from enzyme-bound ADP and Pi. The plainly measured low Gibbs energy change results from large compensating enthalpy and entropy changes that reflect the underlying changes in protein conformation. 2. In stoichiometric ATP synthesis by F1 sector from ADP and Pi bound to the catalytic centre, their intrinsic binding energy brings about a loss of peptide chain entropy that makes possible an entropy-driven ATP formation. 3. The driving force for ATP synthesis cannot be the high Gibbs energy change on binding of product ATP; the tight ATP-enzyme complex rather is a low Gibbs energy intermediate from which escape is difficult. 4. The catalytic centre exists either in an open state unable to firmly bind the substrate-product couple, or in a closed state protecting formed ATP from facile hydrolysis by ambient water. 5. The cleft closure, induced by binding of Pi and ADP or ATP, does not necessarily need external energy supply, because the cleft closure proceeds from rigid domain rotations which can occur rather spontaneously. In further analogy to adenylate kinase, the driving force of this domain movement presumably comes from the electrostatic interactions between phosphate moieties and arginine side chains in the catalytic centre.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

The alpha 3 beta 3 and alpha 1 beta 1 complexes of ATP synthase

Two catalytic structures of H(+)-motive ATP synthase (Fig. 1), the alpha 3 beta 3 oligomer (M(r) = 319,581) and alpha 1 beta 1 promoter (M(r) = 106,527) (Fig. 2), were isolated using high pressure liquid chromatography (Fig. 3) and polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (Figs. 4 and 5). These were reconstituted from the alpha and beta subunits of thermophilic F1 (TF1), and the alpha 3 beta 3 oligomer was also crystallized. Common to both F1 and the alpha 3 beta 3 oligomer were the nucleotide specificity, the two Km values, the presence of protomer-oligomer activities, and the one-hit--one-kill phenomenon. A synchrotron experiment on the ATP hydrolysis cycle revealed the dynamic shrinkage and expansion of F1(44) that correspond, respectively, to the ATP-induced association and ADP-induced dissociation of the alpha 3 beta 3 oligomer. The oligomer, like mitochondrial F1 and TF1, exhibited two kinds of ATPase activity: one was cooperative and was inhibited by only one inhibitor per hexamer, and the other was inhibited by three inhibitors per hexamer.

The ATP synthase (F0-F1) complex in oxidative phosphorylation

The transmembrane electrochemical proton gradient generated by the redox systems of the respiratory chain in mitochondria and aerobic bacteria is utilized by proton translocating ATP synthases to catalyze the synthesis of ATP from ADP and P(i). The bacterial and mitochondrial H(+)-ATP synthases both consist of a membranous sector, F0, which forms a H(+)-channel, and an extramembranous sector, F1, which is responsible for catalysis. When detached from the membrane, the purified F1 sector functions mainly as an ATPase. In chloroplasts, the synthesis of ATP is also driven by a proton motive force, and the enzyme complex responsible for this synthesis is similar to the mitochondrial and bacterial ATP synthases. The synthesis of ATP by H(+)-ATP synthases proceeds without the formation of a phosphorylated enzyme intermediate, and involves co-operative interactions between the catalytic subunits.

Changes in the adenine nucleotide content of beef-heart mitochondrial F1 ATPase during ATP synthesis in dimethyl sulfoxide

Beef-heart mitochondrial F1 ATPase can be induced to synthesize ATP from ADP and inorganic phosphate in 30% Me2SO. We have analyzed the adenine nucleotide content of the F1 ATPase during the time-course of ATP synthesis, in the absence of added medium nucleotide, and in the absence and presence of 10 mM inorganic phosphate. The enzyme used in these investigations was either pretreated or not pretreated with ATP to produce F1 with a defined nucleotide content and catalytic or noncatalytic nucleotide-binding site occupancy. We show that the mechanism of ATP synthesis in Me2SO involves (i) an initial rapid loss of bound nucleotide(s), this process being strongly influenced by inorganic phosphate; (ii) a rebinding of lost nucleotide; and (iii) synthesis of ATP from bound ADP and inorganic phosphate.

Dependence of kinetic parameters of chloroplast ATP synthase on external pH, internal pH, and delta pH

ATP synthesis by the membrane-bound chloroplast ATPase in the oxidized state of its gamma disulfide bridge was studied as a function of the ADP concentration, delta pH, and external pH values, under conditions where delta pH was clamped and delocalized. At a given pH, the rate of phosphorylation at saturating ADP concentration (Vmax) and the Michaelis constant Km (ADP) depend strictly on delta pH, irrespective of the way the delta pH is generated: there evidently is no specific interaction between the redox carriers and the ATPase. It was also shown that both Km (ADP) and Vmax depend on delta pH, not on the external or internal pH. This suggests that internal proton binding and external proton release are concerted, so that net proton translocation is an elementary step of the phosphorylation process. These results appear to be consistent with a modified "proton substrate" model, provided the delta G0 of the condensation reaction within the catalytic site is low. At least one additional assumption, such as a shift in the pK of bound phosphate or the existence of an additional group transferring protons from or to reactants, is nevertheless required to account for the strict delta pH dependence of the rate of ATP synthesis. A purely "conformational" model, chemically less explicit, only requires constraints on the pK's of the groups involved in proton translocation.

Kinetics and thermodynamics of catalysis by the inorganic pyrophosphatase of Escherichia coli in both directions

Combined evidence obtained from the measurements of pyrophosphate hydrolysis and synthesis, oxygen exchange between phosphate and water, enzyme-bound pyrophosphate formation and Mg2+ binding enabled us to deduce the overall scheme of catalysis by Escherichia coli inorganic pyrophosphatase in the presence of Mg2+. We determined the equilibrium constants for Mg2+ binding to various enzyme species and forward and reverse rate constants for the four steps of the catalytic reaction, namely, binding/release of PPi, hydrolysis/synthesis of PPi and successive binding/release of two Pi molecules. Catalysis by the E. coli enzyme in both directions, in contrast to baker's yeast pyrophosphatase, occurs via a single pathway, which requires the binding of Mg2+ to the sites of four types. Three of them can be filled in the absence of the substrates, and the affinity of one of them to Mg2+ is increased by two orders of magnitude in the enzyme-substrate complexes. The distribution of 18O-labelled phosphate isotopomers during the exchange indicated that hydrolysis of pyrophosphate in the active site is appreciably reversible. The equilibrium constant for this process estimated from direct measurements is 5.0. The ratio of the maximal velocities of pyrophosphate hydrolysis and synthesis is 69. The rate of the synthesis is almost entirely determined by the rate of the release of pyrophosphate from the enzyme. In the hydrolytic reaction, enzyme-bound pyrophosphate hydrolysis and successive release of two phosphate molecules proceed with nearly equal rate constants.

pH dependent changes in ADP and ATP affinity for the tight nucleotide-binding site of chloroplast coupling factor 1

The pH-dependence of ADP and ATP affinity for CF1 tight nucleotide-binding sites was studied under conditions of equilibrium between bound and free labeled nucleotides. With the nucleotide/CF1 ratio>1, the ATP content in tightly bound nucleotides depended only slightly on medium pH. With the nucleotide/CF1 ratio approaching 1, tightly bound ATP content grew rapidly with decreasing pH. Calculations of ADP/ATP ratio in free and tightly bound nucleotides showed that decreasing the pH from 8.0 to 6.0 induced a 150 times greater affinity of the nucleotide-binding site for ATP than for ADP. The data indicates that ATP-ADP equilibrium at the CF1 tight nucleotide-binding site depends on protonation of specific acid-base groups of the enzyme.

Role of energy in oxidative phosphorylation

This article reviews the current status of information regarding the role of energy in the process of oxidative phosphorylation by mitochondria. The available data suggest that in submitochondrial particles (SMP) energy is utilized for the binding of ADP and Pi and for the release of ATP bound at the catalytic sites of F1-ATPase. The process of ATP synthesis on the surface of F1 from F1-bound ADP and Pi appears to be associated with negligible free energy change. The rate of energy production by the respiratory chain modulates the kinetics of ATP synthesis between a low Km (for ADP and Pi)-low Vmax mode and a high Km-high Vmax mode. The Km extremes for ADP are 2-3 microM and 120-150 microM, and Vmax for ATP synthesis at high rates of energy production by bovine-heart SMP is about 440 S-1 (mole F1)-1 at 30 degrees C, which corresponds to 11 mumol ATP (min.mg of protein)-1. The interaction of dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (DCCD) or oligomycin at the proteolipid (subunit c) of the membrane sector (F0) of the ATP synthase complex alters the mode of ATP binding at the catalytic sites of F1, probably to one of lower affinity. It has been suggested that protonic energy might be conveyed to the catalytic sites of F1 in an analogous manner, i.e., via conformation changes in the ATP synthase complex initiated by proton-induced alterations in the structure of the DCCD-binding proteolipid. Finally, the relationship between the steady-state membrane potential (delta psi) and the rates of electron transfer and ATP synthesis has been discussed. It has been shown, in agreement with the delocalized chemiosmotic mechanism, that under appropriate conditions delta psi is exquisitely sensitive to changes in the rates of energy production and consumption.

Molecular genetics of F1-ATPase from Escherichia coli

We have reviewed recent molecular biological studies on F1-ATPase of Escherichia coli and emphasized the advantages of using the bacterium in studies on this important enzyme. All subunits had homologies of varied degrees with those from other organisms. Mutations of F1 subunits caused defects in catalysis and assembly. Defects of the mutant enzymes were studied extensively together with the determination of the amino acid substitutions. Extensive molecular biological studies may help greatly in understanding the normal mechanism and assembly of the complex.

Characteristics of the formation of enzyme-bound ATP from medium inorganic phosphate by mitochondrial F1 adenosinetriphosphatase in the presence of dimethyl sulfoxide

Addition of dimethyl sulfoxide promotes the formation of enzyme-bound ATP from medium Pi by mitochondrial F1 adenosinetriphosphatase that has tightly bound ADP present. Measurements are reported of medium Pi in equilibrium H18OH exchange and of the dependence of formation of enzyme-bound ATP on Pi concentration. Attainment of an apparent equilibrium between medium Pi and bound ATP requires longer than 30 min, even though the rates of Pi binding and release after apparent equilibrium is reached would suffice for a faster approach to equilibrium. Slow protein conformational changes or other unknown modulating factors may be responsible for the slow rate of bound ATP formation. After apparent equilibrium is reached, each Pi that binds to the enzyme reversibly forms ATP about 50 times before being released to the medium. The rate of interconversion of bound ATP to bound ADP and Pi is much slower than that in the absence of dimethyl sulfoxide as measured with sufficiently low ATP concentrations so that single-site catalysis is favored. Although the interconversion rate is slowed, the equilibrium constant for bound ATP formation from bound ADP and Pi is not far from unity. Dimethyl sulfoxide favors the formation of enzyme-bound ATP by promoting the competent binding of Pi to enzyme with ADP bound at a catalytic site rather than by promoting formation of bound ATP from bound ADP and Pi.

Energy-dependent formation of free ATP in yeast submitochondrial particles, and its stimulation by oligomycin

Yeast submitochondrial particles, in a Pi- and NADH-dependent reaction, produced low concentrations of free ATP in the absence of added ADP. This formation of free ATP, as measured by the luciferin-luciferase method, was strongly stimulated by oligomycin. For maximal stimulation, oligomycin was to be added not earlier than 5-10 min after the addition of NADH. Upon addition of antimycin or FCCP the system was completely inhibited. The amount of free ATP formed corresponded to one-third of the amount of bound ATP in submitochondrial particles. The stimulatory effect of oligomycin disappeared if the submitochondrial particles were spun down after oligomycin stimulation and then resuspended in the reaction medium, whereas submitochondrial particles with no oligomycin added initially were stimulated by oligomycin after the same procedure. A different picture emerged with addition of ADP. If the submitochondrial particles were preenergized with NADH in the presence of oligomycin before the addition of ADP the formation of free ATP upon subsequent addition of ADP was inhibited by oligomycin. In the presence of oligomycin, but lacking preenergization with NADH, a stimulation of free ATP formation was achieved with added ADP. A possible explanation for the stimulating effect of oligomycin on ATP formation in the absence of added ADP is that it enhances the release of bound ATP in an energy-requiring process. The release of only about one-third of the bound ATP could indicate that one of three nucleotide-binding subunits involved in the mechanism of ATP formation by ATP synthase is in a state suitable for such an energy-dependent release of ATP.

Kinetics of ATP hydrolysis catalyzed by isolated TF1 and reconstituted TF0F1 ATPase

The rate of ATP hydrolysis catalyzed by isolated TF1 and reconstituted TF0F1 was measured as a function of the ATP concentration in the presence of inhibitors [ADP, Pi and 3'-O-(1-naphthoyl)ATP]. ATP hydrolysis can be described by Michaelis-Menten kinetics with Km(TF1) = 390 microM and Km (TF0F1) = 180 microM. The inhibition constants are for ADP Ki(TF1) = 20 microM and Ki(TF0F1) = 100 microM, for 3'-O-(1-naphthoyl)ATP Ki(TF1) = 150 microM and Ki(TF0F1) = 3 microM, and for Pi Ki(TF1) = 60 mM. From these results it is concluded that upon binding of TF0 to TF1 the mechanism of ATP hydrolysis catalyzed by TF1 is not changed qualitatively; however, the kinetic constants differ quantitatively.

Synthesis of ATP by soluble mitochondrial F1 ATPase and F1-inhibitor-protein complex in the presence of organic solvents

The F1 and F1-inhibitor-protein complex synthesized tightly bound ATP from ADP and Pi when the organic solvents dimethylsulfoxide (20-50% v/v), ethylene glycol (20-60% v/v) or poly(ethylene glycol) 4000 and 8000 (30-50% w/v) were included in the assay media. There was no synthesis of tightly bound ATP in the absence of organic solvents. In the presence of 50% dimethylsulfoxide, maximal synthesis of ATP was obtained at pH values between 6.5 and 7.7. In both F1 and F1-inhibitor-protein there was no synthesis of ATP in the absence of MgCl2. The rate of ATP synthesis became faster as the MgCl2 concentration in the medium was raised from 0.1-10 mM. The Km for Pi of F1 was in the range of 0.8-1.5 mM. The Km for Pi of the F1-inhibitor-protein was much higher than that of F1 and could not be measured. In the presence of 10 mM MgCl2 and 2 mM Pi, the rate constants of ATP synthesis by F1 and F1-inhibitor-protein were 5.2-10.4 h-1 and 3.5-5.9 h-1 respectively. For both enzymes the rate constant of ATP hydrolysis was 0.69 h-1. The tightly bound ATP of F1 and F1-inhibitor-protein were hydrolyzed at a much slower rate when either the Pi concentration or the MgCl2 concentration was suddenly decreased. Both in presence and absence of Mg2+, 40-60% of the radioactive tightly bound ATP synthesized by F1 was hydrolyzed when non-radioactive ATP was added to the assay medium. This was not observed when F1-inhibitor-protein was used.