Ion-coupling determinants of Na+-driven and H+-driven flagellar motors

Hybrid Exb/Mot stators require substitutions distant from the chimeric pore to power flagellar rotation

Powered by ion transport across the cell membrane, conserved ion-powered rotary motors (IRMs) drive bacterial motility by generating torque on the rotor of the bacterial flagellar motor. Homologous heteroheptameric IRMs have been structurally characterized in ion channels such as Tol/Ton/Exb/Gld, and most recently in phage defense systems such as Zor. Functional stator complexes synthesized from chimeras of PomB/MotB (PotB) have been used to study flagellar rotation at low ion-motive force achieved via reduced external sodium concentration. The function of such chimeras is highly sensitive to the location of the fusion site, and these hybrid proteins have thus far been arbitrarily designed. To date, no chimeras have been constructed using interchange of components from Tol/Ton/Exb/Gld and other ion-powered motors with more distant homology. Here, we synthesized chimeras of MotAB, PomAPotB, and ExbBD to assess their capacity for cross-compatibility. We generated motile strains powered by stator complexes with B-subunit chimeras. This motility was further optimized by directed evolution. Whole-genome sequencing of these strains revealed that motility-enhancing residue changes occurred in the A-subunit and at the peptidoglycan binding domain of the B-unit, which could improve motility. Overall, our work highlights the complexity of stator architecture and identifies the challenges associated with the rational design of chimeric IRMs.

IMPORTANCE

Ion-powered rotary motors (IRMs) underpin the rotation of one of nature's oldest wheels, the flagellar motor. Recent structures show that this complex appears to be a fundamental molecular module with diverse biological utility where electrical energy is coupled to torque. Here, we attempted to rationally design chimeric IRMs to explore the cross-compatibility of these ancient motors. We succeeded in making one working chimera of a flagellar motor and a non-flagellar transport system protein. This had only a short hybrid stretch in the ion-conducting channel, and function was subsequently improved through additional substitutions at sites distant from this hybrid pore region. Our goal was to test the cross-compatibility of these homologous systems and highlight challenges arising when engineering new rotary motors.

Bacterial Electrophysiology

Bacterial ion fluxes are involved in the generation of energy, transport, and motility. As such, bacterial electrophysiology is fundamentally important for the bacterial life cycle, but it is often neglected and consequently, by and large, not understood. Arguably, the two main reasons for this are the complexity of measuring relevant variables in small cells with a cell envelope that contains the cell wall and the fact that, in a unicellular organism, relevant variables become intertwined in a nontrivial manner. To help give bacterial electrophysiology studies a firm footing, in this review, we go back to basics. We look first at the biophysics of bacterial membrane potential, and then at the approaches and models developed mostly for the study of neurons and eukaryotic mitochondria. We discuss their applicability to bacterial cells. Finally, we connect bacterial membrane potential with other relevant (electro)physiological variables and summarize methods that can be used to both measure and influence bacterial electrophysiology.

Ion selectivity and rotor coupling of the Vibrio flagellar sodium-driven stator unit

Bacteria swim using a flagellar motor that is powered by stator units. Vibrio spp. are highly motile bacteria responsible for various human diseases, the polar flagella of which are exclusively driven by sodium-dependent stator units (PomAB). However, how ion selectivity is attained, how ion transport triggers the directional rotation of the stator unit, and how the stator unit is incorporated into the flagellar rotor remained largely unclear. Here, we have determined by cryo-electron microscopy the structure of Vibrio PomAB. The electrostatic potential map uncovers sodium binding sites, which together with functional experiments and molecular dynamics simulations, reveal a mechanism for ion translocation and selectivity. Bulky hydrophobic residues from PomA prime PomA for clockwise rotation. We propose that a dynamic helical motif in PomA regulates the distance between PomA subunit cytoplasmic domains, stator unit activation, and torque transmission. Together, our study provides mechanistic insights for understanding ion selectivity and rotor incorporation of the stator unit of the bacterial flagellum.

Ion-Powered Rotary Motors: Where Did They Come from and Where They Are Going?

Molecular motors are found in many living organisms. One such molecular machine, the ion-powered rotary motor (IRM), requires the movement of ions across a membrane against a concentration gradient to drive rotational movement. The bacterial flagellar motor (BFM) is an example of an IRM which relies on ion movement through the stator proteins to generate the rotation of the flagella. There are many ions which can be used by the BFM stators to power motility and different ions can be used by a single bacterium expressing multiple stator variants. The use of ancestral sequence reconstruction (ASR) and functional analysis of reconstructed stators shows promise for understanding how these proteins evolved and when the divergence in ion use may have occurred. In this review, we discuss extant BFM stators and the ions that power them as well as recent examples of the use of ASR to study ion-channel selectivity and how this might be applied to further study of the BFM stator complex.

The rapid evolution of flagellar ion selectivity in experimental populations of E. coli

Determining which cellular processes facilitate adaptation requires a tractable experimental model where an environmental cue can generate variants that rescue function. The bacterial flagellar motor (BFM) is an excellent candidate-an ancient and highly conserved molecular complex for bacterial propulsion toward favorable environments. Motor rotation is often powered by H⁺ or Na⁺ ion transit through the torque-generating stator subunit of the motor complex, and ion selectivity has adapted over evolutionary time scales. Here, we used CRISPR engineering to replace the native Escherichia coli H⁺-powered stator with Na⁺-powered stator genes and report the spontaneous reversion of our edit in a low-sodium environment. We followed the evolution of the stators during their reversion to H⁺-powered motility and used both whole-genome and RNA sequencing to identify genes involved in the cell's adaptation. Our transplant of an unfit protein and the cells' rapid response to this edit demonstrate the adaptability of the stator subunit and highlight the hierarchical modularity of the flagellar motor.

The Periplasmic Domain of the Ion-Conducting Stator of Bacterial Flagella Regulates Force Generation

The bacterial flagellar stator is a unique ion-conducting membrane protein complex composed of two kinds of proteins, the A subunit and the B subunit. The stator couples the ion-motive force across the membrane into rotational force. The stator becomes active only when it is incorporated into the flagellar motor. The periplasmic region of the B subunit positions the stator by using the peptidoglycan-binding (PGB) motif in its periplasmic C-terminal domain to attach to the cell wall. Functional studies based on the crystal structures of the C-terminal domain of the B subunit (MotB_C or PomB_C) reveal that a dramatic conformational change in a characteristic α-helix allows the stator to conduct ions efficiently and bind to the PG layer. The plug and the following linker region between the transmembrane (TM) and PG-binding domains of the B subunit function in regulating the ion conductance. In Vibrio spp., the transmembrane protein FliL and the periplasmic MotX and MotY proteins also contribute to the motor function. In this review, we describe the functional and structural changes which the stator units undergo to regulate the activity of the stator to drive flagellar rotation.

Dynamic Hybrid Flagellar Motors-Fuel Switch and More

Flagellar motors are intricate rotating nanomachines that are powered by transmembrane ion gradients. The stator complexes are the powerhouses of the flagellar motor: They convert a transmembrane ion gradient, mainly of H⁺ or Na⁺, into rotation of the helical flagellar filament. They are thus essential for motor function. The number of stators synchronously engaged in the motor is surprisingly dynamic and depends on the load and the environmental concentration of the corresponding coupling ion. Thus, the rotor-stator interactions determine an important part of the properties of the motor. Numerous bacteria have been identified as possessing more than one set of stators, and some species have been demonstrated to use these different stators in various configurations to modify motor functions by dynamic in-flight swapping. Here, we review knowledge of the properties, the functions, and the evolution of these hybrid motors and discuss questions that remain unsolved.

Stator Dynamics Depending on Sodium Concentration in Sodium-Driven Bacterial Flagellar Motors

Bacterial flagellar motor (BFM) is a large membrane-spanning molecular rotary machine for swimming motility. Torque is generated by the interaction between the rotor and multiple stator units powered by ion-motive force (IMF). The number of bound stator units is dynamically changed in response to the external load and the IMF. However, the detailed dynamics of stator unit exchange process remains unclear. Here, we directly measured the speed changes of sodium-driven chimeric BFMs under fast perfusion of different sodium concentration conditions using computer-controlled, high-throughput microfluidic devices. We found the sodium-driven chimeric BFMs maintained constant speed over a wide range of sodium concentrations by adjusting stator units in compensation to the sodium-motive force (SMF) changes. The BFM has the maximum number of stator units and is most stable at 5 mM sodium concentration rather than higher sodium concentration. Upon rapid exchange from high to low sodium concentration, the number of functional stator units shows a rapidly excessive reduction and then resurrection that is different from predictions of simple absorption model. This may imply the existence of a metastable hidden state of the stator unit during the sudden loss of sodium ions.

Achievements in bacterial flagellar research with focus on Vibrio species

In 1980's, the most genes involved in the bacterial flagellar function and formation had been isolated though many of their functions or roles were not clarified. Bacterial flagella are the primary locomotive organ and are not necessary for growing in vitro but are probably essential for living in natural condition and are involved in the pathogenicity. In vitro, the flagella-deficient strains can grow at rates similar to wild-type strains. More than 50 genes are responsible for flagellar function, and the flagellum is constructed by more than 20 structural proteins. The maintenance cost of flagellum is high as several genes are required for its development. The fact that it evolved as a motor organ even with such the high cost shows that the motility is indispensable to survive under the harsh environment of Earth. In this review, we focus on flagella-related research conducted by the authors for about 40 years and flagellar research focused on Vibrio spp. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.

Directing Coupled Motion with Light: A Key Step Toward Machine-Like Function

Molecular photoactuators can control shape and chemical or physical properties of the responsive system they are embedded in. These effects are usually mediated by supramolecular interactions and can be amplified to perform work at the micro- and macroscopic scale, for instance, in materials and biomimetic systems. While many studies focus on the observable outcome of these events, photoresponsive structures can also translate their conformational change to molecular components and perform work against random Brownian motion. Stereochemical cascades can amplify light-generated motion to a distant moiety of the same molecule or molecular assembly, via conformationally restricted stereogenic elements. Being able to control the conformation or motion of molecular systems remotely provides prospects for the design of the smallest machines imaginable. This Focus Review emphasizes the emergence of directed, coupled motion of remote functionalities triggered by light-powered switches and motors as a tool to control molecular topology and function.

Putative Spanner Function of the Vibrio PomB Plug Region in the Stator Rotation Model for Flagellar Motor

Bacterial flagella are the best-known rotational organelles in the biological world. The spiral-shaped flagellar filaments that extend from the cell surface rotate like a screw to create a propulsive force. At the base of the flagellar filament lies a protein motor that consists of a stator and a rotor embedded in the membrane. The stator is composed of two types of membrane subunits, PomA (similar to MotA in Escherichia coli) and PomB (similar to MotB in E. coli), which are energy converters that assemble around the rotor to couple rotation with the ion flow. Recently, stator structures, where two MotB molecules are inserted into the center of a ring made of five MotA molecules, were reported. This structure inspired a model in which the MotA ring rotates around the MotB dimer in response to ion influx. Here, we focus on the Vibrio PomB plug region, which is involved in flagellar motor activation. We investigated the plug region using site-directed photo-cross-linking and disulfide cross-linking experiments. Our results demonstrated that the plug interacts with the extracellular short loop region of PomA, which is located between transmembrane helices 3 and 4. Although the motor stopped rotating after cross-linking, its function recovered after treatment with a reducing reagent that disrupted the disulfide bond. Our results support the hypothesis, which has been inferred from the stator structure, that the plug region terminates the ion influx by blocking the rotation of the rotor as a spanner. IMPORTANCE The biological flagellar motor resembles a mechanical motor. It is composed of a stator and a rotor. The force is transmitted to the rotor by the gear-like stator movements. It has been proposed that the pentamer of MotA subunits revolves around the axis of the B subunit dimer in response to ion flow. The plug region of the B subunit regulates the ion flow. Here, we demonstrated that the ion flow was terminated by cross-linking the plug region of PomB with PomA. These findings support the rotation hypothesis and explain the role of the plug region in blocking the rotation of the stator unit.

Molecular structure of the intact bacterial flagellar basal body

The bacterial flagellum is a macromolecular protein complex that enables motility in many species. Bacterial flagella self-assemble a strong, multicomponent drive shaft that couples rotation in the inner membrane to the micrometre-long flagellar filament that powers bacterial swimming in viscous fluids1-3. Here, we present structures of the intact Salmonella flagellar basal body4, encompassing the inner membrane rotor, drive shaft and outer-membrane bushing, solved using cryo-electron microscopy to resolutions of 2.2-3.7 Å. The structures reveal molecular details of how 173 protein molecules of 13 different types assemble into a complex spanning two membranes and a cell wall. The helical drive shaft at one end is intricately interwoven with the rotor component with both the export gate complex and the proximal rod forming interactions with the MS-ring. At the other end, the drive shaft distal rod passes through the LP-ring bushing complex, which functions as a molecular bearing anchored in the outer membrane through interactions with the lipopolysaccharide. The in situ structure of a protein complex capping the drive shaft provides molecular insights into the assembly process of this molecular machine.

The Dynamic Ion Motive Force Powering the Bacterial Flagellar Motor

The bacterial flagellar motor (BFM) is a rotary molecular motor embedded in the cell membrane of numerous bacteria. It turns a flagellum which acts as a propeller, enabling bacterial motility and chemotaxis. The BFM is rotated by stator units, inner membrane protein complexes that stochastically associate to and dissociate from individual motors at a rate which depends on the mechanical and electrochemical environment. Stator units consume the ion motive force (IMF), the electrochemical gradient across the inner membrane that results from cellular respiration, converting the electrochemical energy of translocated ions into mechanical energy, imparted to the rotor. Here, we review some of the main results that form the base of our current understanding of the relationship between the IMF and the functioning of the flagellar motor. We examine a series of studies that establish a linear proportionality between IMF and motor speed, and we discuss more recent evidence that the stator units sense the IMF, altering their rates of dynamic assembly. This, in turn, raises the question of to what degree the classical dependence of motor speed on IMF is due to stator dynamics vs. the rate of ion flow through the stators. Finally, while long assumed to be static and homogeneous, there is mounting evidence that the IMF is dynamic, and that its fluctuations control important phenomena such as cell-to-cell signaling and mechanotransduction. Within the growing toolbox of single cell bacterial electrophysiology, one of the best tools to probe IMF fluctuations may, ironically, be the motor that consumes it. Perfecting our incomplete understanding of how the BFM employs the energy of ion flow will help decipher the dynamical behavior of the bacterial IMF.

Site-directed crosslinking identifies the stator-rotor interaction surfaces in a hybrid bacterial flagellar motor

The bacterial flagellum is the motility organelle powered by a rotary motor. The rotor and stator elements of the motor are located in the cytoplasmic membrane and cytoplasm. The stator units assemble around the rotor, and an ion flux (typically H⁺ or Na⁺) conducted through a channel of the stator induces conformational changes that generate rotor torque. Electrostatic interactions between the stator protein PomA in Vibrio (MotA in Escherichia coli) and the rotor protein FliG have been shown by genetic analyses, but have not been demonstrated biochemically. Here, we used site-directed photo- and disulfide-crosslinking to provide direct evidence for the interaction. We introduced a UV-reactive amino acid, p-benzoyl-L-phenylalanine (pBPA), into the cytoplasmic region of PomA or the C-terminal region of FliG in intact cells. After UV irradiation, pBPA inserted at a number of positions in PomA formed a crosslink with FliG. PomA residue K89 gave the highest yield of crosslinks, suggesting that it is the PomA residue nearest to FliG. UV-induced crosslinking stopped motor rotation, and the isolated hook-basal body contained the crosslinked products. pBPA inserted to replace residues R281 or D288 in FliG formed crosslinks with the Escherichia coli stator protein, MotA. A cysteine residue introduced in place of PomA K89 formed disulfide crosslinks with cysteine inserted in place of FliG residues R281 and D288, and some other flanking positions. These results provide the first demonstration of direct physical interaction between specific residues in FliG and PomA/MotA.ImportanceThe bacterial flagellum is a unique organelle that functions as a rotary motor. The interaction between the stator and rotor is indispensable for stator assembly into the motor and the generation of motor torque. However, the interface of the stator-rotor interaction has only been defined by mutational analysis. Here, we detected the stator-rotor interaction using site-directed photo- and disulfide-crosslinking approaches. We identified several residues in the PomA stator, especially K89, that are in close proximity to the rotor. Moreover, we identified several pairs of stator and rotor residues that interact. This study directly demonstrates the nature of the stator-rotor interaction and suggests how stator units assemble around the rotor and generate torque in the bacterial flagellar motor.

[Flagellar related genes and functions in Vibrio]

Bacteria can move or swim by flagella. On the other hand, the motile ability is not necessary to live at all. In laboratory, the flagella-deficient strains can grow just like the wild-type strains. The flagellum is assembled from more than 20 structural proteins and there are more than 50 genes including the structural genes to regulate or support the flagellar formation. The cost to construct the flagellum is so expensive. The fact that it evolved as a motor organ means even at such the large cost shows that the flagellum is essential for survival in natural condition. In this review, we would like to focus on the flagella-related researches conducted by the authors and the flagellar research on Vibrio spp.

Ancestral Sequence Reconstructions of MotB Are Proton-Motile and Require MotA for Motility

The bacterial flagellar motor (BFM) is a nanomachine that rotates the flagellum to propel many known bacteria. The BFM is powered by ion transit across the cell membrane through the stator complex, a membrane protein. Different bacteria use various ions to run their BFM, but the majority of BFMs are powered by either proton (H+) or sodium (Na+) ions. The transmembrane (TM) domain of the B-subunit of the stator complex is crucial for ion selectivity, as it forms the ion channel in complex with TM3 and TM4 of the A-subunit. In this study, we reconstructed and engineered thirteen ancestral sequences of the stator B-subunit to evaluate the functional properties and ionic power source of the stator proteins at reconstruction nodes to evaluate the potential of ancestral sequence reconstruction (ASR) methods for stator engineering and to test specific motifs previously hypothesized to be involved in ion-selectivity. We found that all thirteen of our reconstructed ancient B-subunit proteins could assemble into functional stator complexes in combination with the contemporary Escherichia coli MotA-subunit to restore motility in stator deleted E. coli strains. The flagellar rotation of the thirteen ancestral MotBs was found to be Na+ independent which suggested that the F30/Y30 residue was not significantly correlated with sodium/proton phenotype, in contrast to what we had reported previously. Additionally, four among the thirteen reconstructed B-subunits were compatible with the A-subunit of Aquifex aeolicus and able to function in a sodium-independent manner. Overall, this work demonstrates the use of ancestral reconstruction to generate novel stators and quantify which residues are correlated with which ionic power source.

Structures of the stator complex that drives rotation of the bacterial flagellum

The bacterial flagellum is the prototypical protein nanomachine and comprises a rotating helical propeller attached to a membrane-embedded motor complex. The motor consists of a central rotor surrounded by stator units that couple ion flow across the cytoplasmic membrane to generate torque. Here, we present the structures of the stator complexes from Clostridium sporogenes, Bacillus subtilis and Vibrio mimicus, allowing interpretation of the extensive body of data on stator mechanism. The structures reveal an unexpected asymmetric A5B2 subunit assembly where the five A subunits enclose the two B subunits. Comparison to structures of other ion-driven motors indicates that this A5B2 architecture is fundamental to bacterial systems that couple energy from ion flow to generate mechanical work at a distance and suggests that such events involve rotation in the motor structures.

Coupling Ion Specificity of the Flagellar Stator Proteins MotA1/MotB1 of Paenibacillus sp. TCA20

The bacterial flagellar motor is a reversible rotary molecular nanomachine, which couples ion flux across the cytoplasmic membrane to torque generation. It comprises a rotor and multiple stator complexes, and each stator complex functions as an ion channel and determines the ion specificity of the motor. Although coupling ions for the motor rotation were presumed to be only monovalent cations, such as H⁺ and Na⁺, the stator complex MotA1/MotB1 of Paenibacillus sp. TCA20 (MotA1^TCA/MotB1^TCA) was reported to use divalent cations as coupling ions, such as Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺. In this study, we initially aimed to measure the motor torque generated by MotA1^TCA/MotB1^TCA under the control of divalent cation motive force; however, we identified that the coupling ion of MotA1^TCAMotB1^TCA is very likely to be a monovalent ion. We engineered a series of functional chimeric stator proteins between MotB1^TCA and Escherichia coli MotB. E. coli ΔmotAB cells expressing MotA1^TCA and the chimeric MotB presented significant motility in the absence of divalent cations. Moreover, we confirmed that MotA1^TCA/MotB1^TCA in Bacillus subtilis ΔmotABΔmotPS cells generates torque without divalent cations. Based on two independent experimental results, we conclude that the MotA1^TCA/MotB1^TCA complex directly converts the energy released from monovalent cation flux to motor rotation.

Bacterial flagellar motor as a multimodal biosensor

Bacterial Flagellar Motor is one of nature's rare rotary molecular machines. It enables bacterial swimming and it is the key part of the bacterial chemotactic network, one of the best studied chemical signalling networks in biology, which enables bacteria to direct its movement in accordance with the chemical environment. The network can sense down to nanomolar concentrations of specific chemicals on the time scale of seconds. Motor's rotational speed is linearly proportional to the electrochemical gradients of either proton or sodium driving ions, while its direction is regulated by the chemotactic network. Recently, it has been discovered that motor is also a mechanosensor. Given these properties, we discuss the motor's potential to serve as a multifunctional biosensor and a tool for characterising and studying the external environment, the bacterial physiology itself and single molecular motor biophysics.

MotP Subunit is Critical for Ion Selectivity and Evolution of a K+-Coupled Flagellar Motor

The bacterial flagellar motor is a sophisticated nanomachine embedded in the cell envelope. The flagellar motor is driven by an electrochemical gradient of cations such as H⁺, Na⁺, and K⁺ through ion channels in stator complexes embedded in the cell membrane. The flagellum is believed to rotate as a result of electrostatic interaction forces between the stator and the rotor. In bacteria of the genus Bacillus and related species, the single transmembrane segment of MotB-type subunit protein (MotB and MotS) is critical for the selection of the H⁺ and Na⁺ coupling ions. Here, we constructed and characterized several hybrid stators combined with single Na⁺-coupled and dual Na⁺- and K⁺-coupled stator subunits, and we report that the MotP subunit is critical for the selection of K⁺. This result suggested that the K⁺ selectivity of the MotP/MotS complexes evolved from the single Na⁺-coupled stator MotP/MotS complexes. This finding will promote the understanding of the evolution of flagellar motors and the molecular mechanisms of coupling ion selectivity.

Flagellum-mediated motility in Pelotomaculum thermopropionicum SI

The basic functions of a propionate-oxidizing bacterium Pelotomaculum thermopropionicum flagellum, such as motility and chemotaxis, have not been studied. To investigate its motility, we compared with that of Syntrophobacter fumaroxidans, an aflagellar propionate-oxidizing bacterium, in soft agar medium. P. thermopropionicum cells spread, while S. fumaroxidans cells moved downward slightly, indicating flagellum-dependent motility in P. thermopropionicum SI. The motility of P. thermopropionicum was inhibited by the addition of carbonyl cyanide m-chlorophenyl hydrazone, a proton uncoupler, which is consistent with the fact that stator protein, MotB of P. thermopropionicum, shared sequence homology with proton-type stators. In addition, 5-N-ethyl-N-isopropyl amiloride, an Na⁺ channel blocker, showed no inhibitory effect on the motility. Furthermore, motAB of P. thermopropionicum complemented the defective swimming ability of Escherichia coli ∆motAB. These results suggest that the motility of P. thermopropionicum SI depends on the proton-type flagellar motor.

The role of conserved charged residues in the bidirectional rotation of the bacterial flagellar motor

Many bacteria rotate their flagella both counterclockwise (CCW) and clockwise (CW) to achieve swimming toward attractants or away from repellents. Highly conserved charged residues are important for that motility, which suggests that electrostatic interactions are crucial for the rotor-stator function. It remains unclear if those residues contribute equally to rotation in the CCW and CW directions. To address this uncertainty, in this study, we expressed chimeric rotors and stators from Vibrio alginolyticus and Escherichia coli in E. coli, and measured the rotational speed of each motor in both directions using a tethered-cell assay. In wild-type cells, the rotational speeds in both directions were equal, as demonstrated previously. Some charge-neutralizing residue replacements in the stator decreased the rotational speed in both directions to the same extent. However, mutations in two charged residues in the rotor decreased the rotational speed only in the CCW direction. Subsequent analysis and previous results suggest that these amino acid residues are involved in supporting the conformation of the rotor, which is important for proper torque generation in the CCW direction.

Reaction engineering analysis of the autotrophic energy metabolism of Clostridium aceticum

Acetogenesis with CO2:H2 or CO via the reductive acetyl-CoA pathway does not provide any net ATP formation in homoacetogenic bacteria. Autotrophic energy conservation is coupled to the generation of chemiosmotic H+ or Na+ gradients across the cytoplasm membrane using either a ferredoxin:NAD+ oxidoreductase (Rnf), a ferredoxin:H+ oxidoreductase (Ech) or substrate-level phosphorylation via cytochromes. The first isolated acetogenic bacterium Clostridium aceticum shows both cytochromes and Rnf complex, putting it into an outstanding position. Autotrophic batch processes with continuous gas supply were performed in fully controlled stirred-tank bioreactors to elucidate energy metabolism of C. aceticum. Varying the initial Na+ concentration in the medium showed sodium-dependent growth of C. aceticum with a growth optimum between 60 and 90 mM Na+. The addition of the Na+-selective ionophore ETH2120 or the protonophore CCCP or the H+/cation-antiporter monensin revealed that an H+ gradient is used as primary energy conservation mechanism, which strengthens the exceptional position of C. aceticum as acetogenic bacterium showing an H+-dependent energy conservation mechanism as well as Na+-dependent growth.

Molecular dynamics simulation of bacterial flagella

The bacterial flagellum is a biological nanomachine for the locomotion of bacteria, and is seen in organisms like Salmonella and Escherichia coli. The flagellum consists of tens of thousands of protein molecules and more than 30 different kinds of proteins. The basal body of the flagellum contains a protein export apparatus and a rotary motor that is powered by ion motive force across the cytoplasmic membrane. The filament functions as a propeller whose helicity is controlled by the direction of the torque. The hook that connects the motor and filament acts as a universal joint, transmitting torque generated by the motor to different directions. This report describes the use of molecular dynamics to study the bacterial flagellum. Molecular dynamics simulation is a powerful method that permits the investigation, at atomic resolution, of the molecular mechanisms of biomolecular systems containing many proteins and solvent. When applied to the flagellum, these studies successfully unveiled the polymorphic supercoiling and transportation mechanism of the filament, the universal joint mechanism of the hook, the ion transfer mechanism of the motor stator, the flexible nature of the transport apparatus proteins, and activation of proteins involved in chemotaxis.

Speed of the bacterial flagellar motor near zero load depends on the number of stator units

The bacterial flagellar motor (BFM) rotates hundreds of times per second to propel bacteria driven by an electrochemical ion gradient. The motor consists of a rotor 50 nm in diameter surrounded by up to 11 ion-conducting stator units, which exchange between motors and a membrane-bound pool. Measurements of the torque-speed relationship guide the development of models of the motor mechanism. In contrast to previous reports that speed near zero torque is independent of the number of stator units, we observe multiple speeds that we attribute to different numbers of units near zero torque in both Na⁺- and H⁺-driven motors. We measure the full torque-speed relationship of one and two H⁺ units in Escherichia coli by selecting the number of H⁺ units and controlling the number of Na⁺ units in hybrid motors. These experiments confirm that speed near zero torque in H⁺-driven motors increases with the stator number. We also measured 75 torque-speed curves for Na⁺-driven chimeric motors at different ion-motive force and stator number. Torque and speed were proportional to ion-motive force and number of stator units at all loads, allowing all 77 measured torque-speed curves to be collapsed onto a single curve by simple rescaling.

Outer membrane vesicles secreted by pathogenic and nonpathogenic Bacteroides fragilis represent different metabolic activities

Numerous studies are devoted to the intestinal microbiota and intercellular communication maintaining homeostasis. In this regard, vesicles secreted by bacteria represent one of the most popular topics for research. For example, the outer membrane vesicles (OMVs) of Bacteroides fragilis play an important nutritional role with respect to other microorganisms and promote anti-inflammatory effects on immune cells. However, toxigenic B. fragilis (ETBF) contributes to bowel disease, even causing colon cancer. If nontoxigenic B. fragilis (NTBF) vesicles exert a beneficial effect on the intestine, it is likely that ETBF vesicles can be utilized for potential pathogenic implementation. To confirm this possibility, we performed comparative proteomic HPLC-MS/MS analysis of vesicles isolated from ETBF and NTBF. Furthermore, we performed, for the first time, HPLC-MS/MS and GS-MS comparative metabolomic analysis for the vesicles isolated from both strains with subsequent reconstruction of the vesicle metabolic pathways. We utilized fluxomic experiments to validate the reconstructed biochemical reaction activities and finally observed considerable difference in the vesicle proteome and metabolome profiles. Compared with NTBF OMVs, metabolic activity of ETBF OMVs provides their similarity to micro reactors that are likely to be used for long-term persistence and implementing pathogenic potential in the host.

Structure of the MotA/B Proton Channel

Flagellar motors utilize the motive force of protons and other ions as an energy source. To elucidate the mechanisms of ion permeation and torque generation, it is essential to investigate the structure of the motor stator complex; however, the atomic structure of the transmembrane region of the stator has not been determined experimentally. We recently constructed an atomic model structure of the transmembrane region of the Escherichia coli MotA/B stator complex based on previously published disulfide cross-linking and tryptophan scanning mutations. Dynamic permeation by hydronium ions, sodium ions, and water molecules was then observed using steered molecular dynamics simulations, and free energy profiles for ion/water permeation were calculated using umbrella sampling. We also examined the possible ratchet motion of the cytoplasmic domain induced by the protonation/deprotonation cycle of the MotB proton binding site, Asp32. In this chapter, we describe the methods used to conduct these analyses, including atomic structure modeling of the transmembrane region of the MotA/B complex; molecular dynamics simulations in equilibrium and in ion permeation processes; and ion permeation-free energy profile calculations.

Effects of chromosomal deletion of the operon encoding the multiple resistance and pH-related antiporter in Vibrio cholerae

To examine the possible physiological significance of Mrp, a multi-subunit cation/proton antiporter from Vibrio cholerae, a chromosomal deletion Δmrp of V. cholerae was constructed and characterized. The resulting mutant showed a consistent early growth defect in LB broth that became more evident at elevated pH of the growth medium and increasing Na+ or K+ loads. After 24 h incubation, these differences disappeared likely due to the concerted effort of other cation pumps in the mrp mutant. Phenotype MicroArray analyses revealed an unexpected systematic defect in nitrogen utilization in the Δmrp mutant that was complemented by using the mrpA'-F operon on an arabinose-inducible expression vector. Deletion of the mrp operon also led to hypermotility, observable on LB and M9 semi-solid agar. Surprisingly, Δmrp mutation resulted in wild-type biofilm formation in M9 despite a growth defect but the reverse was true in LB. Furthermore, the Δmrp strain exhibited higher susceptibility to amphiphilic anions. These pleiotropic phenotypes of the Δmrp mutant demonstrate how the chemiosmotic activity of Mrp contributes to the survival potential of V. cholerae despite the presence of an extended battery of cation/proton antiporters of varying ion selectivity and pH profile operating in the same membrane.

Mutations targeting the plug-domain of the Shewanella oneidensis proton-driven stator allow swimming at increased viscosity and under anaerobic conditions

Shewanella oneidensis MR-1 possesses two different stator units to drive flagellar rotation, the Na⁺ -dependent PomAB stator and the H⁺ -driven MotAB stator, the latter possibly acquired by lateral gene transfer. Although either stator can independently drive swimming through liquid, MotAB-driven motors cannot support efficient motility in structured environments or swimming under anaerobic conditions. Using ΔpomAB cells we isolated spontaneous mutants able to move through soft agar. We show that a mutation that alters the structure of the plug domain in MotB affects motor functions and allows cells to swim through media of increased viscosity and under anaerobic conditions. The number and exchange rates of the mutant stator around the rotor were not significantly different from wild-type stators, suggesting that the number of stators engaged is not the cause of increased swimming efficiency. The swimming speeds of planktonic mutant MotAB-driven cells was reduced, and overexpression of some of these stators caused reduced growth rates, implying that mutant stators not engaged with the rotor allow some proton leakage. The results suggest that the mutations in the MotB plug domain alter the proton interactions with the stator ion channel in a way that both increases torque output and allows swimming at decreased pmf values.

How Biophysics May Help Us Understand the Flagellar Motor of Bacteria Which Cause Infections

Motor proteins are molecules which convert chemical energy to mechanical work and are responsible for motility across all levels: for transport within a cell, for the motion of an individual cell in its surroundings, and for movement in multicellular aggregates, such as muscles. The bacterial flagellar motor is one of the canonical examples of a molecular complex made from several motor proteins, which self-assembles on demand and provides the locomotive force for bacteria. This locomotion provides a key aspect of bacteria's prevalence. Here, we outline the biophysics behind the assembly, the energetics, the switching and the rotation of this remarkable nanoscale electric motor that is Nature's first wheel.

Respiratory complex I: A dual relation with H(+) and Na(+)?

Respiratory complex I couples NADH:quinone oxidoreduction to ion translocation across the membrane, contributing to the buildup of the transmembrane difference of electrochemical potential. H(+) is well recognized to be the coupling ion of this system but some studies suggested that this role could be also performed by Na(+). We have previously observed NADH-driven Na(+) transport opposite to H(+) translocation by menaquinone-reducing complexes I, which indicated a Na(+)/H(+) antiporter activity in these systems. Such activity was also observed for the ubiquinone-reducing mitochondrial complex I in its deactive form. The relation of Na(+) with complex I may not be surprising since the enzyme has three subunits structurally homologous to bona fide Na(+)/H(+) antiporters and translocation of H(+) and Na(+) ions has been described for members of most types of ion pumps and transporters. Moreover, no clearly distinguishable motifs for the binding of H(+) or Na(+) have been recognized yet. We noticed that in menaquinone-reducing complexes I, less energy is available for ion translocation, compared to ubiquinone-reducing complexes I. Therefore, we hypothesized that menaquinone-reducing complexes I perform Na(+)/H(+) antiporter activity in order to achieve the stoichiometry of 4H(+)/2e(-). In agreement, the organisms that use ubiquinone, a high potential quinone, would have kept such Na(+)/H(+) antiporter activity, only operative under determined conditions. This would imply a physiological role(s) of complex I besides a simple "coupling" of a redox reaction and ion transport, which could account for the sophistication of this enzyme. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled Respiratory complex I, edited by Volker Zickermann and Ulrich Brandt.

H(+) and Na(+) are involved in flagellar rotation of the spirochete Leptospira

Leptospira is a spirochete possessing intracellular flagella. Each Leptospira flagellar filament is linked with a flagellar motor composed of a rotor and a dozen stators. For many bacterial species, it is known that the stator functions as an ion channel and that the ion flux through the stator is coupled with flagellar rotation. The coupling ion varies depending on the species; for example, H(+) is used in Escherichia coli, and Na(+) is used in Vibrio spp. to drive a polar flagellum. Although genetic and structural studies illustrated that the Leptospira flagellar motor also contains a stator, the coupling ion for flagellar rotation remains unknown. In the present study, we analyzed the motility of Leptospira under various pH values and salt concentrations. Leptospira cells displayed motility in acidic to alkaline pH. In the presence of a protonophore, the cells completely lost motility in acidic to neutral pH but displayed extremely slow movement under alkaline conditions. This result suggests that H(+) is a major coupling ion for flagellar rotation over a wide pH range; however, we also observed that the motility of Leptospira was significantly enhanced by the addition of Na(+), though it vigorously moved even under Na(+)-free conditions. These results suggest that H(+) is preferentially used and that Na(+) is secondarily involved in flagellar rotation in Leptospira. The flexible ion selectivity in the flagellar system could be advantageous for Leptospira to survive in a wide range of environment.

Sodium-driven energy conversion for flagellar rotation of the earliest divergent hyperthermophilic bacterium

Aquifex aeolicus is a hyperthermophilic, hydrogen-oxidizing and carbon-fixing bacterium that can grow at temperatures up to 95 °C. A. aeolicus has an almost complete set of flagellar genes that are conserved in bacteria. Here we observed that A. aeolicus has polar flagellum and can swim with a speed of 90 μm s⁻¹ at 85 °C. We expressed the A. aeolicus mot genes (motA and motB), which encode the torque generating stator proteins of the flagellar motor, in a corresponding mot nonmotile mutant of Escherichia coli. Its motility was slightly recovered by expression of A. aeolicus MotA and chimeric MotB whose periplasmic region was replaced with that of E. coli. A point mutation in the A. aeolicus MotA cytoplasmic region remarkably enhanced the motility. Using this system in E. coli, we demonstrate that the A. aeolicus motor is driven by Na⁺. As motor proteins from hyperthermophilic bacteria represent the earliest motor proteins in evolution, this study strongly suggests that ancient bacteria used Na⁺ for energy coupling of the flagellar motor. The Na⁺-driven flagellar genes might have been laterally transferred from early-branched bacteria into late-branched bacteria and the interaction surfaces of the stator and rotor seem not to change in evolution.

Gate-controlled proton diffusion and protonation-induced ratchet motion in the stator of the bacterial flagellar motor

The proton permeation process of the stator complex MotA/B in the flagellar motor of Escherichia coli was investigated. The atomic model structure of the transmembrane part of MotA/B was constructed based on the previously published disulfide cross-linking and tryptophan scanning mutations. The dynamic permeation of hydronium/sodium ions and water molecule through the channel formed in MotA/B was observed using a steered molecular dynamics simulation. During the simulation, Leu46 of MotB acts as the gate for hydronium ion permeation, which induced the formation of water wire that may mediate the proton transfer to Asp32 on MotB. Free energy profiles for permeation were calculated by umbrella sampling. The free energy barrier for H3O(+) permeation was consistent with the proton transfer rate deduced from the flagellar rotational speed and number of protons per rotation, which suggests that the gating is the rate-limiting step. Structure and dynamics of the MotA/B with nonprotonated and protonated Asp32, Val43Met, and Val43Leu mutants in MotB were investigated using molecular dynamics simulation. A narrowing of the channel was observed in the mutants, which is consistent with the size-dependent ion selectivity. In MotA/B with the nonprotonated Asp32, the A3 segment in MotA maintained a kink whereas the protonation induced a straighter shape. Assuming that the cytoplasmic domain not included in the atomic model moves as a rigid body, the protonation/deprotonation of Asp32 is inferred to induce a ratchet motion of the cytoplasmic domain, which may be correlated to the motion of the flagellar rotor.

Serine 26 in the PomB subunit of the flagellar motor is essential for hypermotility of Vibrio cholerae

Vibrio cholerae is motile by means of its single polar flagellum which is driven by the sodium-motive force. In the motor driving rotation of the flagellar filament, a stator complex consisting of subunits PomA and PomB converts the electrochemical sodium ion gradient into torque. Charged or polar residues within the membrane part of PomB could act as ligands for Na⁺, or stabilize a hydrogen bond network by interacting with water within the putative channel between PomA and PomB. By analyzing a large data set of individual tracks of swimming cells, we show that S26 located within the transmembrane helix of PomB is required to promote very fast swimming of V. cholerae. Loss of hypermotility was observed with the S26T variant of PomB at pH 7.0, but fast swimming was restored by decreasing the H⁺ concentration of the external medium. Our study identifies S26 as a second important residue besides D23 in the PomB channel. It is proposed that S26, together with D23 located in close proximity, is important to perturb the hydration shell of Na⁺ before its passage through a constriction within the stator channel.

Functional chimeras of flagellar stator proteins between E. coli MotB and Vibrio PomB at the periplasmic region in Vibrio or E. coli

The bacterial flagellar motor has a stator and a rotor. The stator is composed of two membrane proteins, MotA and MotB in Escherichia coli and PomA and PomB in Vibrio alginolyticus. The Vibrio motor has a unique structure, the T ring, which is composed of MotX and MotY. Based on the structural information of PomB and MotB, we constructed three chimeric proteins between PomB and MotB, named PotB₉₁ , PotB_129, and PotB₁₃₈ , with various chimeric junctions. When those chimeric proteins were produced with PomA in a ΔmotAB strain of E. coli or in ΔpomAB and ΔpomAB ΔmotX strains of Vibrio, all chimeras were functional in E. coli or Vibrio, either with or without the T ring, although the motilities were very weak in E. coli. Furthermore, we could isolate some suppressors in E. coli and identified the mutation sites on PomA or the chimeric B subunit. The weak function of chimeric PotBs in E. coli is derived mainly from the defect in the rotational switching of the flagellar motor. In addition, comparing the motilities of chimera strains in ΔpomAB, PotB₁₃₈ had the highest motility. The difference between the origin of the α1 and α2 helices, E. coli MotB or Vibro PomB, seems to be important for motility in E. coli and especially in Vibrio.

Hybrid-fuel bacterial flagellar motors in Escherichia coli

The bacterial flagellar motor rotates driven by an electrochemical ion gradient across the cytoplasmic membrane, either H(+) or Na(+) ions. The motor consists of a rotor ∼50 nm in diameter surrounded by multiple torque-generating ion-conducting stator units. Stator units exchange spontaneously between the motor and a pool in the cytoplasmic membrane on a timescale of minutes, and their stability in the motor is dependent upon the ion gradient. We report a genetically engineered hybrid-fuel flagellar motor in Escherichia coli that contains both H(+)- and Na(+)-driven stator components and runs on both types of ion gradient. We controlled the number of each type of stator unit in the motor by protein expression levels and Na(+) concentration ([Na(+)]), using speed changes of single motors driving 1-μm polystyrene beads to determine stator unit numbers. De-energized motors changed from locked to freely rotating on a timescale similar to that of spontaneous stator unit exchange. Hybrid motor speed is simply the sum of speeds attributable to individual stator units of each type. With Na(+) and H(+) stator components expressed at high and medium levels, respectively, Na(+) stator units dominate at high [Na(+)] and are replaced by H(+) units when Na(+) is removed. Thus, competition between stator units for spaces in a motor and sensitivity of each type to its own ion gradient combine to allow hybrid motors to adapt to the prevailing ion gradient. We speculate that a similar process may occur in species that naturally express both H(+) and Na(+) stator components sharing a common rotor.

Microcompartments and protein machines in prokaryotes

The prokaryotic cell was once thought of as a 'bag of enzymes' with little or no intracellular compartmentalization. In this view, most reactions essential for life occurred as a consequence of random molecular collisions involving substrates, cofactors and cytoplasmic enzymes. Our current conception of a prokaryote is far from this view. We now consider a bacterium or an archaeon as a highly structured, nonrandom collection of functional membrane-embedded and proteinaceous molecular machines, each of which serves a specialized function. In this article we shall present an overview of such microcompartments including (1) the bacterial cytoskeleton and the apparati allowing DNA segregation during cell division; (2) energy transduction apparati involving light-driven proton pumping and ion gradient-driven ATP synthesis; (3) prokaryotic motility and taxis machines that mediate cell movements in response to gradients of chemicals and physical forces; (4) machines of protein folding, secretion and degradation; (5) metabolosomes carrying out specific chemical reactions; (6) 24-hour clocks allowing bacteria to coordinate their metabolic activities with the daily solar cycle, and (7) proteinaceous membrane compartmentalized structures such as sulfur granules and gas vacuoles. Membrane-bound prokaryotic organelles were considered in a recent Journal of Molecular Microbiology and Biotechnology written symposium concerned with membranous compartmentalization in bacteria [J Mol Microbiol Biotechnol 2013;23:1-192]. By contrast, in this symposium, we focus on proteinaceous microcompartments. These two symposia, taken together, provide the interested reader with an objective view of the remarkable complexity of what was once thought of as a simple noncompartmentalized cell.

Mechanism and kinetics of a sodium-driven bacterial flagellar motor

The bacterial flagellar motor is a large rotary molecular machine that propels swimming bacteria, powered by a transmembrane electrochemical potential difference. It consists of an ∼50-nm rotor and up to ∼10 independent stators anchored to the cell wall. We measured torque-speed relationships of single-stator motors under 25 different combinations of electrical and chemical potential. All 25 torque-speed curves had the same concave-down shape as fully energized wild-type motors, and each stator passes at least 37 ± 2 ions per revolution. We used the results to explore the 25-dimensional parameter space of generalized kinetic models for the motor mechanism, finding 830 parameter sets consistent with the data. Analysis of these sets showed that the motor mechanism has a "powerstroke" in either ion binding or transit; ion transit is channel-like rather than carrier-like; and the rate-limiting step in the motor cycle is ion binding at low concentration, ion transit, or release at high concentration.

Intragenic suppressor of a plug deletion nonmotility mutation in PotB, a chimeric stator protein of sodium-driven flagella

The torque of bacterial flagellar motors is generated by interactions between the rotor and the stator and is coupled to the influx of H(+) or Na(+) through the stator. A chimeric protein, PotB, in which the N-terminal region of Vibrio alginolyticus PomB was fused to the C-terminal region of Escherichia coli MotB, can function with PomA as a Na(+)-driven stator in E. coli. Here, we constructed a deletion variant of PotB (with a deletion of residues 41 to 91 [Δ41-91], called PotBΔL), which lacks the periplasmic linker region including the segment that works as a "plug" to inhibit premature ion influx. This variant did not confer motile ability, but we isolated a Na(+)-driven, spontaneous suppressor mutant, which has a point mutation (R109P) in the MotB/PomB-specific α-helix that connects the transmembrane and peptidoglycan binding domains of PotBΔL in the region of MotB. Overproduction of the PomA/PotBΔL(R109P) stator inhibited the growth of E. coli cells, suggesting that this stator has high Na(+)-conducting activity. Mutational analyses of Arg109 and nearby residues suggest that the structural alteration in this α-helix optimizes PotBΔL conformation and restores the proper arrangement of transmembrane helices to form a functional channel pore. We speculate that this α-helix plays a key role in assembly-coupled stator activation.

Specificity of motor components in the dual flagellar system of Shewanella putrefaciens CN-32

Bacterial flagellar motors are intricate nanomachines in which the stator units and rotor component FliM may be dynamically exchanged during function. Similar to other bacterial species, the gammaproteobacterium Shewanella putrefaciens CN-32 possesses a complete secondary flagellar system along with a corresponding stator unit. Expression of the secondary system occurs during planktonic growth in complex media and leads to the formation of a subpopulation with one or more additional flagella at random positions in addition to the primary polar system. We used physiological and phenotypic characterizations of defined mutants in concert with fluorescent microscopy on labelled components of the two different systems, the stator proteins PomB and MotB, the rotor components FliM(1) and FliM(2), and the auxiliary motor components MotX and MotY, to determine localization, function and dynamics of the proteins in the flagellar motors. The results demonstrate that the polar flagellum is driven by a Na(+)-dependent FliM(1)/PomAB/MotX/MotY flagellar motor while the secondary system is rotated by a H(+)-dependent FliM(2)/MotAB motor. The components were highly specific for their corresponding motor and are unlikely to be extensively swapped or shared between the two flagellar systems under planktonic conditions. The results have implications for both specificity and dynamics of flagellar motor components.

Mutations targeting the C-terminal domain of FliG can disrupt motor assembly in the Na(+)-driven flagella of Vibrio alginolyticus

The torque of the bacterial flagellar motor is generated by the rotor-stator interaction coupled with specific ion translocation through the stator channel. To produce a fully functional motor, multiple stator units must be properly incorporated around the rotor by an as yet unknown mechanism to engage the rotor-stator interactions. Here, we investigated stator assembly using a mutational approach of the Na(+)-driven polar flagellar motor of Vibrio alginolyticus, whose stator is localized at the flagellated cell pole. We mutated a rotor protein, FliG, which is located at the C ring of the basal body and closely participates in torque generation, and found that point mutation L259Q, L270R or L271P completely abolishes both motility and polar localization of the stator without affecting flagellation. Likewise, mutations V274E and L279P severely affected motility and stator assembly. Those residues are localized at the core of the globular C-terminal domain of FliG when mapped onto the crystal structure of FliG from Thermotoga maritima, which suggests that those mutations induce quite large structural alterations at the interface responsible for the rotor-stator interaction. These results show that the C-terminal domain of FliG is critical for the proper assembly of PomA/PomB stator complexes around the rotor and probably functions as the target of the stator at the rotor side.

Sodium-driven motor of the polar flagellum in marine bacteria Vibrio

The Na(+) -driven bacterial flagellar motor is a molecular machine powered by an electrochemical potential gradient of sodium ions across the cytoplasmic membrane. The marine bacterium Vibrio alginolyticus has a single polar flagellum that enables it to swim in liquid. The flagellar motor contains a basal body and a stator complexes, which are composed of several proteins. PomA, PomB, MotX, and MotY are thought to be essential components of the stator that are required to generate the torque of the rotation. Several mutations have been investigated to understand the characteristics and function of the ion channel in the stator and the mechanism of its assembly around the rotor to complete the motor. In this review, we summarize recent results of the Na(+) -driven motor in the polar flagellum of Vibrio.