Neurologic complications in oral polio vaccine recipients

Immunodeficiency-related vaccine-derived poliovirus (iVDPV) cases: a systematic review and implications for polio eradication

BACKGROUND

Vaccine-derived polioviruses (VDPVs), strains of poliovirus mutated from the oral polio vaccine, pose a challenge to global polio eradication. Immunodeficiency-related vaccine-derived polioviruses (iVDPVs) are a type of VDPV which may serve as sources of poliovirus reintroduction after the eradication of wild-type poliovirus. This review is a comprehensive update of confirmed iVDPV cases published in the scientific literature from 1962 to 2012, and describes clinically relevant trends in reported iVDPV cases worldwide.

METHODS

We conducted a systematic review of published iVDPV case reports from January 1960 to November 2012 from four databases. We included cases in which the patient had a primary immunodeficiency, and the vaccine virus isolated from the patient either met the sequencing definition of VDPV (>1% divergence for serotypes 1 and 3 and >0.6% for serotype 2) and/or was previously reported as an iVDPV by the World Health Organization.

RESULTS

We identified 68 iVDPV cases in 49 manuscripts reported from 25 countries and the Palestinian territories. 62% of case patients were male, 78% presented clinically with acute flaccid paralysis, and 65% were iVDPV2. 57% of cases occurred in patients with predominantly antibody immunodeficiencies, and the overall all-cause mortality rate was greater than 60%. The median age at case detection was 1.4 years [IQR: 0.8, 4.5] and the median duration of shedding was 1.3 years [IQR: 0.7, 2.2]. We identified a poliovirus genome VP1 region mutation rate of 0.72% per year and a higher median percent divergence for iVDPV1 cases. More cases were reported from high income countries, which also had a larger age variation and different distribution of immunodeficiencies compared to upper and lower middle-income countries.

CONCLUSION

Our study describes the incidence and characteristics of global iVDPV cases reported in the literature in the past five decades. It also highlights the regional and economic disparities of reported iVDPV cases.

Pediatric immunizations

The record of disease prevention in children is an impressive testament to our universal immunization program. However, these successes are being threatened by rates of vaccination in some areas of the country that are substantially less than those seen in the developing world. Unless the pediatric immunization rates are improved, epidemics of other vaccine-preventable diseases will recur, as evidenced by the measles outbreaks. Although the tools needed for disease prevention are available, the means for their delivery are lacking. It is the obligation of us all to immunize the nation's children.

Poliovirus vaccines. A continuing challenge

The control of poliomyelitis remains a provocative challenge. Alternative vaccination schedules, continuing research toward better vaccines, and ongoing international scientific, epidemiologic, and economic collaboration may make it possible to provide effective immunization for all children of the world and eventually may eradicate poliomyelitis worldwide, a goal set forward by the Expanded Programme on Immunization of the World Health Organization.

Poliovaccine virus in the cerebrospinal fluid after oral polio vaccination

In February-March 1985 an oral poliovirus vaccine campaign was launched in Finland in a population vaccinated earlier with inactivated poliovaccine. During this campaign a strain of poliovirus was isolated from the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) of a 7-year-old girl 34 days after she had received oral poliovirus vaccine. She had long-lasting headache, vomiting and fever but no paralysis. This case demonstrates that poliovaccine virus can invade the central nervous system even after a complete course of inactivated poliovirus vaccine if the inactivated vaccine has been poorly antigenic against one of the three types of virus.

Vaccine-induced polioencephalomyelitis in Scotland

A six-month-old British female, living in Glasgow was admitted in June 1986 with a four-day history of fever and lower limb weakness following immunisation with oral polio and triple (DTP) vaccines. Examination revealed paralysis of all limbs, facial muscles and right diaphragm, scoliosis, opsoclonus and ocular flutter. Poliovirus types 1, 2 and 3, isolated from her stool specimens were all vaccine-like strains. Her serial serum IgA levels were persistently low and salivary IgA was undetectable. This appears to be the first fully authenticated case of poliovaccine damage in Scotland. It is unclear whether the selective IgA deficiency contributed to her vulnerability. It is essential to investigate elaborately and process viral isolates in every suspected case of acute poliomyelitis so as to determine the dimension and ramifications of poliovaccine damage in the UK population which is known to be rather apprehensive about vaccine dangers.

Inadequacy of mucosal IgM antibodies in selective IgA deficiency: excretion of attenuated polio viruses is prolonged

A nationwide vaccination campaign with oral poliovirus vaccine was organized in Finland in 1985 in order to cease an outbreak of poliomyelitis. We followed eight IgA-deficient individuals and nine controls for poliovirus excretion in feces and for antibody responses in serum and saliva. Five weeks after oral poliovirus vaccination all eight IgA-deficient individuals were still excreting polioviruses, in contrast to one of nine controls. The concentration of polioviruses, as estimated by a semi-quantitative immunofluorescent assay, was generally higher and the test was significantly more often positive in the samples from the IgA-deficient individuals. Although serum levels of antibodies to poliovirus type 3 were lower in IgA-deficient individuals before vaccination, both measurements showed that the two groups had similar antibody levels 4 weeks after vaccination. IgA-deficient individuals lacked salivary IgA antibodies to poliovirus types 1 and 3 but had increased levels of IgM antipolio antibodies, which were shown to carry secretory component. We conclude that the mucosal IgM antibodies of IgA-deficient individuals eliminate polioviruses less efficiently than do the IgA antibodies of normal individuals.

Neurologic complications of immunizations

Although there does appear to be at least a temporal relationship between pertussis immunization and serious acute neurologic illness, data to suggest that children with stable preexisting neurologic disease or positive family history of neurologic disease are at increased risk for complications of pertussis immunizations are inconclusive. Furthermore, there are no firm statistical data concerning the incidence of pertussis vaccine-related encephalopathy. Rather, the literature on pertussis vaccine complications is replete with anecdotal reports and retrospective studies with a number of questionable conclusions drawn from this inadequate data base. Unfortunately, these conclusions have been sensationalized and exploited with litigious fervor to the point that the practice of pertussis immunization is being questioned in the United States. A number of points should be reiterated: pertussis is a dangerous and deadly disease, as seen in the epidemic in Great Britain; pertussis immunization is effective in protecting against the disease; and there is no conclusive proof that the incidence of complications from pertussis vaccination of children with seizure disorders or other preexisting stable neurologic abnormalities is higher, because appropriate studies have not been done to define such a risk. We would do well to keep these facts in mind in order to avoid a disaster similar to the pertussis epidemic in Great Britain. Pertussis vaccination should be given to all children except those with allergic hypersensitivity, a progressive neurologic disorder, or an adverse reaction to a previous pertussis dose.