Lactate stress test in the diagnosis of mitochondrial myopathy

Diagnostic accuracy of the lactate stress test for detecting mitochondrial disorders: Systematic review and meta-analysis

Due to their variable phenotypes, mitochondrial disorders (MDs) can be difficult to diagnose. The absolute load lactate stress test (LSTA) and the relative load lactate stress test (LSTR) have been shown to be useful screening tools for the detection of MDs. In this study, we aimed to perform a meta-analysis to evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of these tests in detecting MDs. The study protocol was registered with PROSPERO (no. CRD42022331710). We performed a comprehensive search of PubMed, Web of Science and Scopus from January 10th, 2022 to July 27th, 2022 and included case-control and cohort diagnostic studies that targeted participants with MDs and used LSTA and/or LSTR as index tests. Two reviewers worked separately to compile information from selected articles. Risk of bias and applicability were assessed using the QUADAS-2 tool. Sensitivity and specificity, as well as diagnostic odds ratios (DORs) and area under the curve (AUC) were calculated using Meta-DiSc 2.0 and Stata software. The analysis included 14 studies with a total of 1064 participants, divided into six studies with 793 participants for LSTA and eight studies with 271 participants for LSTR. For LSTA the meta-analysis gave a pooled sensitivity of 0.67 (95 % CI 0.62, 0.72), a specificity of 0.93 (95 % CI 0.85, 0.97), DOR of 26.63 (95 % CI 10.99, 64.52), and AUC of 0.70 (95 % CI 0.66, 0.74). For LSTR, the pooled sensitivity was 0.52 (95 % CI 0.33, 0.70), specificity 0.94 (95 % CI 0.79, 0.99), DOR 18.14 (95 % CI 2.99, 109.85), and the AUC 0.80 (95 % CI 0.76, 0.83). LSTA and LSTR showed as screening tests moderate sensitivity and high specificity for MD diagnosis, particularly for LSTR. The choice of test may depend on the patient's individual aerobic capacity and motor skills and the availability of equipment.

Multilevel evidence of MECP2-associated mitochondrial dysfunction and its therapeutic implications

We present a male patient carrying a pathogenic MECP2 p. Arg179Trp variant with predominant negative psychiatric features and multilevel evidence of mitochondrial dysfunction who responded to the cariprazine treatment. He had delayed speech development and later experienced severe social anxiety, learning disabilities, cognitive slowing, and predominant negative psychiatric symptoms associated with rigidity. Clinical examinations showed multisystemic involvement. Together with elevated ergometric lactate levels, the clinical picture suggested mitochondrial disease, which was also supported by muscle histopathology. Exploratory transcriptome analysis also revealed the involvement of metabolic and oxidative phosphorylation pathways. Whole-exome sequencing identified a pathogenic MECP2 variant, which can explain both the dopamine imbalance and mitochondrial dysfunction in this patient. Mitochondrial dysfunction was previously suggested in classical Rett syndrome, and we detected related phenotype evidence on multiple consistent levels for the first time in a MECP2 variant carrier male. This study further supports the importance of the MECP2 gene in the mitochondrial pathways, which can open the gate for more personalized therapeutic interventions. Good cariprazine response highlights the role of dopamine dysfunction in the complex psychiatric symptoms of Rett syndrome. This can help identify the optimal treatment strategy from a transdiagnostic perspective instead of a classical diagnostic category.

Diagnostic Values of Venous Peak Lactate, Lactate-to-pyruvate Ratio, and Fold Increase in Lactate from Baseline in Aerobic Exercise Tests in Patients with Mitochondrial Diseases

Objective Although aerobic exercise tests on cycle ergometry have long been used for initial assessments of cases of suspected mitochondrial disease, the test parameters in patients with final diagnoses of other diseases via the widely used 15 W for 15 minutes exercise protocol have not been fully characterized. Methods We retrospectively reviewed all patients who underwent the test at our institution. We classified the patients with genetic diagnoses or those who met previously reported clinical criteria as having mitochondrial diseases and those with a final diagnosis of another disease as having other diseases. Results were available from 6 patients with mitochondrial disease and 15 with other diseases. Results During the test, elevated venous peak lactate above the upper normal limit of healthy controls at rest [19.2 mg/dL (2.13 mM)] was observed in 3 patients with mitochondrial diseases (50.0%) and 5 with other diseases (33.3%). In the group of patients with elevated venous peak lactate, a lactate-to-pyruvate ratio of >20 was observed in all 3 patients with mitochondrial disease but in only 1 of the 5 with other diseases. More than a 2-fold increase in venous lactate from baseline was observed in 4 patients with mitochondrial disease (66.7%) and 1 with another disease (6.7%). Conclusion Elevated venous peak lactate levels were observed in patients with final diagnoses of other diseases, even under a low 15-minute workload at 15 W. The lactate-to-pyruvate ratio and increase in lactate level from baseline may add diagnostic value to venous peak lactate levels alone.

Plasma lactate responses during and after submaximal handgrip exercise are not diagnostically helpful in mitochondrial myopathy

INTRODUCTION/BACKGROUND

Mitochondrial myopathy (MM) encompasses a clinical heterogenous group of patients that can be difficult to diagnose. The aim of this study was to investigate if changes in plasma lactate concentration during a 6-minute submaximal handgrip test (6MHGT) and a 20-minute post-exercise recovery period can be used as a diagnostic test for MM.

METHODS

Twenty-nine patients with MM and nineteen healthy controls (HC) performed an intermittent handgrip exercise test at ½ Hz for 6 min at 50% of maximal voluntary contraction force. We calculated the area under the curve (AUC) of change in plasma lactate during exercise and recovery and compared AUC between groups (MM vs. HC, and between MM subgroups based on disease severity).

RESULTS

The change in plasma lactate during exercise and recovery was similar in MM and HC (p = 0.65 and p = 0.57) and similar between MM subgroups (p ≥ 0.24).

CONCLUSION

Plasma lactate measured during and after a submaximal 6MHGT cannot be used as a diagnostic variable for MM.

Exercise Testing, Physical Training and Fatigue in Patients with Mitochondrial Myopathy Related to mtDNA Mutations

Mutations in mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) cause disruption of the oxidative phosphorylation chain and impair energy production in cells throughout the human body. Primary mitochondrial disorders due to mtDNA mutations can present with symptoms from adult-onset mono-organ affection to death in infancy due to multi-organ involvement. The heterogeneous phenotypes that patients with a mutation of mtDNA can present with are thought, at least to some extent, to be a result of differences in mtDNA mutation load among patients and even among tissues in the individual. The most common symptom in patients with mitochondrial myopathy (MM) is exercise intolerance. Since mitochondrial function can be assessed directly in skeletal muscle, exercise studies can be used to elucidate the physiological consequences of defective mitochondria due to mtDNA mutations. Moreover, exercise tests have been developed for diagnostic purposes for mitochondrial myopathy. In this review, we present the rationale for exercise testing of patients with MM due to mutations in mtDNA, evaluate the diagnostic yield of exercise tests for MM and touch upon how exercise tests can be used as tools for follow-up to assess disease course or effects of treatment interventions.

Increased blood lactate levels during exercise and mitochondrial DNA alterations converge on mitochondrial dysfunction in schizophrenia

BACKGROUND

Mitochondrial dysfunction and an elevation of lactate are observed in patients with schizophrenia (SZ). However, it is unknown whether mitochondrial dysfunction is associated with the presence of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) alterations and comorbid clinical conditions. We aimed to identify systemic mitochondrial abnormalities in blood samples of patients with SZ that may have a high impact on the brain due to its high bioenergetic requirements.

METHODS

Case/control study between 57 patients with SZ and 33 healthy controls (HCs). We measured lactate levels at baseline, during 15 min of exercise (at 5, 10 and 15 min) and at rest. We also evaluated the presence of clinical conditions associated with mitochondrial disorders (CAMDs), measured the neutrophil to lymphocyte ratio (NLR, a subclinical inflammatory marker), and analyzed mtDNA variation and copy number.

RESULTS

Linear models adjusting for covariates showed that patients with SZ exhibited higher elevation of lactate than HCs during exercise but not at baseline or at rest. In accordance, patients showed higher number of CAMDs and lower mtDNA copy number. Interestingly, CAMDs correlated with both lactate levels and mtDNA copy number, which in turn correlated with the NLR. Finally, we identified 13 putative pathogenic variants in the mtDNA of 11 participants with SZ not present in HCs, together with a lactate elevation during exercise that was significantly higher in these 11 carriers than in the noncarriers.

CONCLUSIONS

These results are consistent with systemic mitochondrial malfunctioning in SZ and pinpoint lactate metabolism and mtDNA as targets for potential therapeutic treatments.

Aerobic Exercise Training in Patients With mtDNA-Related Mitochondrial Myopathy

In patients with mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) mutation, a pathogenic mtDNA mutation is heteroplasmically distributed among tissues. The ratio between wild-type and mutated mtDNA copies determines the mtDNA mutation load of the tissue, which correlates inversively with oxidative capacity of the tissue. In patients with mtDNA mutation, the mutation load is often very high in skeletal muscle compared to other tissues. Additionally, skeletal muscle can increase its oxygen demand up to 100-fold from rest to exercise, which is unmatched by any other tissue. Thus, exercise intolerance is the most common symptom in patients with mtDNA mutation. The impaired oxidative capacity in skeletal muscle in patients with mtDNA mutation results in limitation in physical capacity that interferes with daily activities and impairs quality of life. Additionally, patients with mitochondrial disease due to mtDNA mutation often live a sedentary lifestyle, which further impair oxidative capacity and exercise tolerance. Since aerobic exercise training increase mitochondrial function and volume density in healthy individuals, studies have investigated if aerobic training could be used to counteract the progressive exercise intolerance in patients with mtDNA mutation. Overall studies investigating the effect of aerobic training in patients with mtDNA mutation have shown that aerobic training is an efficient way to improve oxidative capacity in this condition, and aerobic training seems to be safe even for patients with high mtDNA mutation in skeletal muscle.

New Variant of MELAS Syndrome With Executive Dysfunction, Heteroplasmic Point Mutation in the MT-ND4 Gene (m.12015T>C; p.Leu419Pro) and Comorbid Polyglandular Autoimmune Syndrome Type 2

Background: Mitochondrial diseases are caused by dysfunctions in mitochondrial metabolic pathways. MELAS syndrome is one of the most frequent mitochondrial disorders; it is characterized by encephalopathy, myopathy, lactic acidosis, and stroke-like episodes. Typically, it is associated with a point mutation with an adenine-to-guanine transition at position 3243 of the mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA; m.3243A>G) in the mitochondrially encoded tRNA leucine 1 (MT-TL1) gene. Other point mutations are possible and the association with polyglandular autoimmune syndrome type 2 has not yet been described.

Case presentation: We present the case of a 25-year-old female patient with dysexecutive syndrome, muscular fatigue, and continuous headache. Half a year ago, she fought an infection-triggered Addison crisis. As the disease progressed, she had two epileptic seizures and stroke-like episodes with hemiparesis on the right side. Cerebral magnetic resonance imaging showed a substance defect of the parieto-occipital left side exceeding the vascular territories with a lactate peak. The lactate ischemia test was clearly positive, and a muscle biopsy showed single cytochrome c oxidase-negative muscle fibers. Genetic testing of blood mtDNA revealed a heteroplasmic base exchange mutation in the mitochondrially encoded NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase core subunit 4 (MT-ND4) gene (m.12015T>C; p.Leu419Pro; heteroplasmy level in blood 12%, in muscle tissue: 15%). The patient suffered from comorbid autoimmune polyglandular syndrome type 2 with Hashimoto's thyroiditis, Addison's disease, and autoimmune gastritis. In addition, we found increased anti-glutamic acid decarboxylase 65, anti-partial cell, anti-intrinsic factor, and anti-nuclear antibodies.

Conclusion: We present an atypical case of MELAS syndrome with predominant symptoms of a dysexecutive syndrome, two stroke-like episodes, and fast-onset fatigue. The symptoms were associated with a not yet described base and aminoacid exchange mutation in the MT-ND4 gene (m.12015T>C to p.Leu419Pro). The resulting changed protein complex in our patient is part of the respiratory chain multicomplex I and might be the reason for the mitochondriopathy. However, different simulations for pathogenetic relevance are contradictory and rather speak for a benign variant. To our knowledge this case report is the first reporting MELAS syndrome with comorbid polyglandular autoimmune syndrome type 2. Screening for autoimmune alterations in those patients is important to prevent damage to end organs.

Combination of mitochondrial myopathy and biventricular hypertrabeculation/noncompaction

Left ventricular hypertrabeculation/noncompaction (LVHT/LVNC), characterized by prominent trabeculations and intertrabecular recesses within the left ventricle, is a cardiac abnormality of unclear etiology. Although the left ventricle is the most commonly affected site, a few cases of biventricular involvement have also been reported. We report a 31-year-old woman who presented with mild cardiac symptoms and progressive bilateral limb muscle weakness following exercise which she had also been experiencing for about 5 years. Abnormal serum levels of creatine kinase, lactic acid and pyruvic acid, combined with the results of modified lactate stress test, needle EMG and muscle biopsy indicated that she had mitochondrial myopathy. The transthoracic echocardiography, together with magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), revealed biventricular hypertrabeculation.

Lactate metabolism during exercise in patients with mitochondrial myopathy

Patients with mitochondrial DNA mutations often have elevated plasma lactate at rest and during exercise, but it is unknown whether the high lactate levels are caused by a high production, an impaired oxidation or a combination. We studied lactate kinetics in 10 patients with mtDNA mutations and 10 matched healthy control subjects at rest and during cycle exercise with a combination of femoral arterio-venous differences of lactate, and lactate tracer dilution methodology. During exercise, lactate concentration and production rates were several-fold higher in patients, but despite mitochondrial dysfunction, lactate was oxidized in muscle to the same extent as in healthy control subjects. This surprisingly high ability to burn lactate in working muscle with defective mitochondria, probably relates to the variability of oxidative capacity among muscle fibers. The data suggests that lactate is not solely an indicator of impaired oxidative capacity, but an important fuel for oxidative metabolism, even in muscle with severely impaired mitochondrial function.

Conditional knockout of Mn-SOD targeted to type IIB skeletal muscle fibers increases oxidative stress and is sufficient to alter aerobic exercise capacity

In vitro studies of isolated skeletal muscle have shown that oxidative stress is limiting with respect to contractile function. Mitochondria are a potential source of muscle function-limiting oxidants. To test the hypothesis that skeletal muscle-specific mitochondrial oxidative stress is sufficient to limit muscle function, we bred mice expressing Cre recombinase driven by the promoter for the inhibitory subunit of troponin (TnIFast-iCre) with mice containing a floxed Sod2 (Sod2(fl/fl)) allele. Mn-SOD activity was reduced by 82% in glycolytic (mainly type II) muscle fiber homogenates from young TnIFastCreSod2(fl/fl) mice. Furthermore, Mn-SOD content was reduced by 70% only in type IIB muscle fibers. Aconitase activity was decreased by 56%, which suggests an increase in mitochondrial matrix superoxide. Mitochondrial superoxide release was elevated more than twofold by mitochondria isolated from glycolytic skeletal muscle in TnIFastCreSod2(fl/fl) mice. In contrast, the rate of mitochondrial H(2)O(2) production was reduced by 33%, and only during respiration with complex II substrate. F(2)-isoprostanes were increased by 36% in tibialis anterior muscles isolated from TnIFastCreSod2(fl/fl) mice. Elevated glycolytic muscle-specific mitochondrial oxidative stress and damage in TnIFastCreSod2(fl/fl) mice were associated with a decreased ability of the extensor digitorum longus and gastrocnemius muscles to produce contractile force as a function of time, whereas force production by the soleus muscle was unaffected. TnIFastCreSod2(fl/fl) mice ran 55% less distance on a treadmill than wild-type mice. Collectively, these data suggest that elevated mitochondrial oxidative stress and damage in glycolytic muscle fibers are sufficient to reduce contractile muscle function and aerobic exercise capacity.

Absence of the interstitial cell of Cajal network in mitochondrial neurogastrointestinal encephalomyopathy

Mitochondrial neurogastrointestinal encephalomyopathy (MNGIE) is a rare autosomal-recessive multisystemic disorder with predominant gastrointestinal involvement, presenting with variable degrees of gut dysmotility up to frank chronic intestinal pseudoobstruction. Despite major advances in understanding its basic molecular pathogenesis in recent years, the distinct mechanisms and pathoanatomical substrate underlying MNGIE-associated gastrointestinal dysmotility are still widely unknown. As yet, though their critical role in proper gastrointestinal transit in terms of spontaneous pacemaker activity and enteric neurotransmission is well established, the population of the interstitial cells of Cajal (ICC) has not been investigated in MNGIE. Therefore, we examined small bowel samples of a well-characterized MNGIE patient by using conventional histology and immunohistochemistry techniques. The ICC network was studied by immunohistochemistry for the tyrosine kinase Kit (CD117), known to reliably detect ICCs, while mucosal mast cells served as an internal and normal small bowel specimen as external controls. At a light microscopic level, no gross structural alteration of the bowel wall composition and its neuromuscular elements was noted. However, a complete absence of Kit immunoreactive cells could be demonstrated in regions where ICCs are normally abundant, while internal and external controls retained strong Kit positivity. In conclusion, our preliminary results provide a first evidence for an alteration of the ICC network in MNGIE, and support the notion that ICC loss might be an early pathogenetic event in MNGIE-associated gut motor dysfunction before significant myopathic and/or neuropathic structural changes occur.

Lactate increase and oxygen desaturation in mitochondrial disorders – Evaluation of two diagnostic screening protocols

BACKGROUND

Mitochondrial disorders are characterized by an accumulation of lactate and an insufficient oxygen extraction from blood during exercise. Therefore, both parameters (lactate and oxygen saturation) can be used as screening tests in mitochondrial disorders. However, conflicting results regarding sensitivities and specifities of both tests have been reported.

METHOD

We examined 27 patients with genetically defined mitochondrial disorders (single deletions n = 15, multiple deletions n = 5, A3243G mutation n = 7), patients with other neuromuscular disorders, and healthy controls. In the first test subjects performed intermittent isometric handgrip exercise (0.5 Hz) at 80% (3 minutes) and 30% (3 and 15 minutes) of maximal contraction force (MCF). Oxygen saturation and partial pressure in cubital venous blood from the exercising arm were measured. In the second test subjects underwent cycle ergometry at 30 W for 15 minutes. Venous lactate at rest, during and 15 minutes postexercise was determined.

RESULT

Both tests showed specificities of 92-96%. Sensitivities for changes of venous oxygen partial pressure and oxygen saturation ranged from 21-26% at 80% MCF for 3 minutes to 47-58% at 30% MCF for 15 minutes. Sensitivities for venous resting, peak, and post-exercise lactate was 33%, 58%, and 67%, respectively. The degree of deoxygenation, however,was independent of the intensity and duration of the applied forces. Oxygen desaturation and lactate increase in patients with mitochondrial disorders were not different in patients with and without clinical symptoms of myopathy. There were significant correlations between the heteroplasmy and both the degree of oxygen desaturation and lactate increase in patients with single deletions. In patients who performed both protocols (n = 16) a combination of both tests increased sensitivity up to 87%.

CONCLUSION

Oxygen desaturation in forearm exercise tests and lactate increase in cycle ergometry tests show a high specifity but only moderate sensitivity. Combination of the two screening test clearly increases the sensitivity.

Lactate stress testing in 155 patients with mitochondriopathy

OBJECTIVE

Few data are available about the diagnostic yield of the lactate stress test (LST) in a large group of patients with mitochondriopathy (MCP).

METHODS

Serum lactate was determined once before, three times during, and once after a 15-minute, constant 30W workload on a bicycle in 62 controls, aged 17 to 84 years, 155 patients with MCP, aged 17 to 87 years, and 31 patients with neurological disorders other than MCP.

RESULTS

Lactate's upper reference limits at rest, 5, 10, 15 minutes after starting, and 15 minutes after finishing the exercise were 2.0, 2.1, 2.1, 2.1 and 1.8 mmol/l respectively. The test was regarded abnormal if more than two of the five lactate values exceeded the cut-off levels. Among the 103 patients with abnormal LST, 64 (62 %) had normal resting lactate. The sensitivity of the test was 67% and the specificity 94%.

CONCLUSION

The LST proved to have a high sensitivity and specificity in the detection of patients with MCP, being thus a simple but powerful tool to assess the impaired oxidative metabolism in MCP patients.

Diagnostic yield of the lactate stress test in respiratory chain disorders under absolute and relative workload

Usually, the lactate stress test is carried under a constant, low workload maintained for 15 min, although there are indications that the lactate response to exercise is a function of the relative workload, and that a workload for only 5 min does not decrease its sensitivity. Thus, this study compared the diagnostic yield of the lactate stress test when carried out under a constant workload of 30 W (LSTA) and under a workload of 30% of maximum (LSTR), and when the workload was maintained for 5 and 15 min. In 16 patients with respiratory chain disorders, 12 women, four men, aged 27--88 years, the LSTA and LSTR were carried out on 2 different days, within 48 h. For both tests serum lactate was determined before, during and after a 15-min workload on a bicycle. Upper reference limits at rest, 5, 10, 15 min after starting, and 15 min after finishing the exercise were 1.9, 2.0, 2.0, 2.0, and 1.6 mmol/l for the LSTA, and 2.3, 3.0, 3.2, 3.4 and 2.7 mmol/l for the LSTR. The sensitivity was 88% for the LSTA and 63% for the LSTR. The specificity of the LSTA was 94%. The diagnostic yield of both tests was similar when the workload was maintained for 5 or 15 min. In conclusion, the LSTA should be preferred to the LSTR. Three lactate determinations during 15 min have no advantage over a single lactate determination after a 5 min workload of 30 W.

Diagnostic yield of the lactate stress test in 160 patients with suspected respiratory chain disorder

Aim of the present study was to investigate the diagnostic yield of the lactate-stress-test in unselected patients with suspected respiratory-chain disorder (RCD). Serum lactate was determined before, during and after a 15-minute, constant 30W workload on a bicycle in 48 controls and 160 patients with suspected RCD. 122 had definite RCD, 38 neurological disorders other than RCD. The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, negative predictive value and pre-test likelihood of the test was 69, 74, 89, 42 and 76% respectively. In conclusion, the lactate-stress-test proved a powerful tool to assess impaired oxidative metabolism in RCDs.

[The use of cardiopulmonary exercise test in patients with mitochondrial myopathies]

BACKGROUND

Exercise tests has been used in the diagnosis of metabolic myopathies. If there is an abnormal response pattern in mild mitochondrial myopathy (MM) and her role in the initial suspect diagnostic is unknown.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

Prospective study of 26 patients with mitochondrial myopathy (15 men, 11 women) and a control group of 14 sedentary volunteers (9 men, 5 woman) with similar antropometric characteristics. We have made pulmonary function tests and treadmill exercise with serial venous sampling of blood lactate, piruvate, ketone bodies, free fatty acids and creatinkinase.

RESULTS

Patients with MM showed exercise limitation with lower maximal power (MM = 143 [47] vatts, C = 187 [40] vatts, p = 0.006), maximal oxygen uptake (MM = 27 [8] ml/min/kg, C = 40 [7] ml/min/kg, p = 0.001) and maximal oxygen pulse (MM = 11 [3] ml/beat, C = 14 [3] ml/beat, p = 0.006). For the same oxygen uptake the heart rate was higher and the anaerobic threshold was earlier in MM patients (MM = 48% [14], C = 62% [12], p = 0.01). We found a considerable slower maximal oxygen uptake in patients with lipid increase in muscle biopsy (n = 15). Acetoacetate curves, beta-hydroxybutyrate, free fatty acids and creatinkinase were similar in both groups. The exercise test was pathologic in 17/26 of the patients. The sensitivity of the exercise test for maximal oxygen uptake was 0.65.

CONCLUSIONS

The cardiopulmonary exercise test is a useful test in the suspect initial diagnostic of patients with mild mitochondrial myopathy because the majority of patients show a pathologic test.