Effect of target gene CpG content on spontaneous mutation in299 transgenic mice

In vivo mutation analysis using the ΦX174 transgenic mouse and comparisons with other transgenes and endogenous genes

The ΦX174 transgenic mouse was first developed as an in vivo Ames test, detecting base pair substitution (bps) at a single bp in a reversion assay. A forward mutational assay was also developed, which is a gain of function assay that also detects bps exclusively. Later work with both assays focused on establishing that a mutation was fixed in vivo using single-burst analysis: determining the number of mutant progeny virus from an electroporated cell by dividing the culture into aliquots before scoring mutants. We review results obtained from single-burst analysis, including testing the hypothesis that high mutant frequencies (MFs) of G:C to A:T mutation recovered by transgenic targets include significant numbers of unrepaired G:T mismatches. Comparison between the ΦX174 and lacI transgenes in mouse spleen indicates that the spontaneous bps mutation frequency per nucleotide (mf(n)) is not significantly lower for ΦX174 than for lacI; the response to ENU is also comparable. For the lacI transgene, the spontaneous bps mf(n) is highly age-dependent up to 12 weeks of age and the linear trend extrapolates at conception to a frequency close to the human bps mf(n) per generation of 1.7 × 10(-8). Unexpectedly, we found that the lacI somatic (spleen) bps mf(n) per cell division at early ages was estimated to be the same as for the human germ-line. The bps mf(n) in bone marrow for the gpt transgene is comparable to spleen for the lacI and ΦX174 transgenes. We conclude that the G:C to A:T transition is characteristic of spontaneous in vivo mutation and that the MFs measured in these transgenes at early ages reflect the expected accumulation of in vivo mutation typical of endogenous mammalian mutation rates. However, spontaneous and induced mf(n)s per nucleotide for the cII gene in spleen are 5-10 times higher than for these other transgenes.

Estimation of DNA sequence context-dependent mutation rates using primate genomic sequences

It is understood that DNA and amino acid substitution rates are highly sequence context-dependent, e.g., C --> T substitutions in vertebrates may occur much more frequently at CpG sites and that cysteine substitution rates may depend on support of the context for participation in a disulfide bond. Furthermore, many applications rely on quantitative models of nucleotide or amino acid substitution, including phylogenetic inference and identification of amino acid sequence positions involved in functional specificity. We describe quantification of the context dependence of nucleotide substitution rates using baboon, chimpanzee, and human genomic sequence data generated by the NISC Comparative Sequencing Program. Relative mutation rates are reported for the 96 classes of mutations of the form 5' alphabetagamma 3' --> 5' alphadeltagamma 3', where alpha, beta, gamma, and delta are nucleotides and beta not equal delta, based on maximum likelihood calculations. Our results confirm that C --> T substitutions are enhanced at CpG sites compared with other transitions, relatively independent of the identity of the preceding nucleotide. While, as expected, transitions generally occur more frequently than transversions, we find that the most frequent transversions involve the C at CpG sites (CpG transversions) and that their rate is comparable to the rate of transitions at non-CpG sites. A four-class model of the rates of context-dependent evolution of primate DNA sequences, CpG transitions > non-CpG transitions approximately CpG transversions > non-CpG transversions, captures qualitative features of the mutation spectrum. We find that despite qualitative similarity of mutation rates among different genomic regions, there are statistically significant differences.

Duplication-Dependent CG Suppression of the Seed Storage Protein Genes of Maize

This study investigates the prevalence of CG and CNG suppression in single- vs. multicopy DNA regions of the maize genome. The analysis includes the single- and multicopy seed storage proteins (zeins), the miniature inverted-repeat transposable elements (MITEs), and long terminal repeat (LTR) retrotransposons. Zein genes are clustered on specific chromosomal regions, whereas MITEs and LTRs are dispersed in the genome. The multicopy zein genes are CG suppressed and exhibit large variations in CG suppression. The variation observed correlates with the extent of duplication each zein gene has undergone, indicating that gene duplication results in an increased turnover of cytosine residues. Alignment of individual zein genes confirms this observation and demonstrates that CG depletion results primarily from polarized C:T and G:A transition mutations from a less to a more extensively duplicated gene. In addition, transition mutations occur primarily in a CG or CNG context suggesting that CG suppression may result from deamination of methylated cytosine residues. Duplication-dependent CG depletion is likely to occur at other loci as duplicated MITEs and LTR elements, or elements inserted into duplicated gene regions, also exhibit CG depletion.

Elevated mutant frequencies and predominance of G:C to A:T transition mutations in Msh6(-/-) small intestinal epithelium

The DNA mismatch repair (MMR) system is primarily responsible for purging newly synthesized DNA of errors incurred during semi-conservative replication. Lesion recognition is initially carried out by one of two heterodimeric protein complexes, MutS(alpha) or MutS(beta). While the former, comprised of MSH2 and MSH6, recognizes mispairs as well as short (1-2 nucleotide) insertions/deletions (IDLs), the latter, made up of MSH2 and MSH3, is primarily responsible for recognizing 2-6 nucleotide IDLs. As most of the functional information on these heterodimers is derived from in vitro studies, it was of interest to study the in vivo consequences of a lack of MutS(alpha). To this end, Big Blue( trade mark ) mice, that carry a lacI(+) transgenic lambda shuttle-phage mutational reporter, were crossed with Msh6(-/-) mice to evaluate the specific contribution of MutS(alpha) to genome integrity. Consistent with the importance of MutS(alpha) in lesion surveillance, small intestine epithelial cell DNA derived from lacI(+) Msh6(-/-) mice exhibited striking increases (average of 41-fold) in spontaneous mutant frequencies. Furthermore, the lacI gene mutation spectrum was dominated by G:C to A:T transitions, highlighting the critical importance of the MutS(alpha) complex in suppressing this frequently observed type of spontaneous mutation.

Characterization of mutant spectra generated by a forward mutational assay for gene A of Phi X174 from ENU-treated transgenic mouse embryonic cell line PX-2

The sensitivity of in vivo transgenic mutation assays benefits from the sequencing of mutations, although the large number of possible mutations hinders high throughput sequencing. A forward mutational assay exists for Phi X174 that requires an altered, functional Phi X174 protein and therefore should have fewer targets (sense, base-pair substitutions) than forward assays that inactivate a protein. We investigated this assay to determine the number of targets and their suitability for detecting a known mutagen, N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea (ENU). We identified 25 target sites and 33 different mutations in Phi X174 gene A after sequencing over 350 spontaneous and ENU-induced mutants, mostly from mouse embryonic cell line PX-2 isolated from mice transgenic for Phi X174 am3, cs70 (line 54). All six types of base-pair substitution were represented among both the spontaneous and ENU-treated mutant spectra. The mutant spectra from cells treated with 200 and 400 microg/ml ENU were both highly different from the spontaneous spectrum (P < 0.000001) but not from each other. The dose trend was significant (P < 0.0001) for a linear regression of mutant frequencies (R(2) = 0.79), with a ninefold increase in mutant frequency at the 400 microg/ml dose. The spontaneous mutant frequency was 1.9 x 10(-5) and the spontaneous spectrum occurred at 11 target base pairs with 15 different mutations. Thirteen mutations at 12 targets were identified only from ENU-treated cells. Seven mutations had highly significant increases with ENU treatment (P < 0.0001) and 15 showed significant increases. The results suggest that the Phi X174 forward assay might be developed into a sensitive, inexpensive in vivo mutagenicity assay.

Spontaneous hepatocellular carcinoma is reduced in transgenic mice overexpressing human O6- methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase

O(6)-methylguanine (O(6)mG) is a potent mutagenic and procarcinogenic DNA lesion. Organisms have evolved with a DNA repair mechanism that largely ameliorates the deleterious effects of O(6)mG through a direct reversal mechanism by a protein termed O(6)-methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase (MGMT). However, the contribution of O(6)mG to carcinogenesis, in the absence of known exposure to agents that produce it, has not been defined. Nontransgenic C3HeB male mice have a high frequency of spontaneous liver tumors. Transgenic CeHeB/FeJ mice expressing human MGMT (hMGMT) were generated that had elevated hepatic MGMT activity. The spontaneous development of hepatocellular carcinoma was significantly reduced in those mice expressing hMGMT compared with nontransgenic C3HeB/FeJ male mice. No differences were detected in spontaneous mutant frequencies in lacI transgenes in mice carrying hMGMT compared with that without hMGMT but the proportion of GC to AT transition mutations was lower in the transgenic mice carrying hMGMT as well as lacI. Tumors that arose in C3HeB/FeJ transgenic mice were largely deficient in hMGMT protein as determined by immunohistochemistry with a monoclonal antibody directed against hMGMT. Together these data indicate that spontaneous O(6)mG lesions induced hepatocellular carcinogenesis in C3HeB/FeJ male mice. These transgenic mice represent a rare example of reduced spontaneous carcinogenesis.

Extent of CpG methylation is not proportional to the in vivo spontaneous mutation frequency at transgenic loci in Big Blue rodents

The lacI transgene used in the Big Blue (BB) mouse and rat mutation assays typically displays spontaneous mutation frequencies in the 5x10(-5) range. Recently, the bone marrow and bladder of the Big Blue rat were reported to have, by an order of magnitude, the lowest spontaneous mutation frequencies ever observed for lacI in a transgenic animal, approaching the value for endogenous targets such as hprt ( approximately 10(-6)). Since spontaneous mutations in transgenes have been attributed in part to deamination of 5-methylcytosine in CpG sequences, we have investigated the methylation status of the lacI transgene in bone marrow of BB rats and compared it to that present in other tissues including liver, spleen, and breast. The first 400 bases of the lacI gene were investigated using bisulfite genomic sequencing since this region contains the majority of both spontaneous and induced mutations. Surprisingly, all the CpG cytosines in the lacI sequence were fully methylated in all the tissues examined from both 2- and 14-week-old rats. Thus, there is no correlation between 5-methylcytosine content at CpG sites in lacI and the frequency of spontaneous mutation at this marker. We also investigated the methylation status of another widely used transgenic mutation target, the cII gene. The CpG sites in cII in BB rats were fully methylated while those in BB mice were partially methylated (each site approximately 50% methylated). Since spontaneous mutation frequency at cII is comparable in rat and mouse, the methylation status of CpG sequences in this gene also does not correlate with spontaneous frequency. We conclude that other mechanisms besides spontaneous deamination of 5-methylcytosine at CpG sites are driving spontaneous mutation at BB transgenic loci.

Spontaneous mutation of the lacI transgene in rodents: absence of species, strain, and insertion-site influence

Comparison of spontaneous mutation spectra derived from different transgenic constructs can provide valuable insights for interpreting the mechanisms of spontaneous mutation. In this study, spontaneous mutation frequencies and spectra of the lacI transgene are compared in the liver of C57BL/6, B6C3F1, and BC-1 mice and F344 rats. Before correction for clonal expansion, the mutant frequency varied from 2.6 +/- 0.45 to 5.0 +/- 2.4 x 10(-5). Correction for potential clonal expansion reduced the range in mutation frequency to between 2.3 +/- 0.45 and 3.5 +/- 2.0 x 10(-5). There is thus no statistical difference in spontaneous mutation frequency between the different strains and species. G:C --> A:T transitions and to a lesser extent, G:C --> T:A transversions dominate the mutational spectra in all of these animals. In three strains of mice, G:C --> A:T transitions account for 50.7-53.3% of mutation, 81.7-83.8% of which involve CpG sites, whereas G:C --> T:A transversions account for 17.8-32.9% of mutations with 43.2-50.0% found at CpG sites. In rats, G:C --> A:T transitions account for 38.0% of the spectra, 70.0% of which involve CpG sites, whereas G:C --> T:A transversions account for 23.0% of the spectra, 70.0% of which involve CpG sites. The distribution of other classes of mutations is also very similar. We conclude that, despite reports about species and strain differences in induced mutation, spontaneous mutations in the lacI transgene appear to be similar, regardless of genomic location, rodent strain, or species. In addition to insights into spontaneous mutation, this study also provides essential data for comparison with and interpretation of induced mutations.

Through a glass, darkly: reflections of mutation from lacI transgenic mice

The study of mutational frequency (Mf) and specificity in aging Big Blue lacI transgenic mice provides a unique opportunity to determine mutation rates (MR) in vivo in different tissues. We found that MR are not static, but rather, vary with the age or developmental stage of the tissue. Although Mf increase more rapidly early in life, MR are actually lower in younger animals than in older animals. For example, we estimate that the changes in Mf are 4.9x10(-8) and 1.1 x 10(-8) mutations/base pair/month in the livers of younger mice (<1. 5 months old) and older mice (> or =1.5 months old), respectively (a 4-fold decrease), and that the MR are 3.9 x 10(-9) and 1.3 x 10(-7) mutations/base pair/cell division, respectively ( approximately 30-fold increase). These data also permit an estimate of the MR of GC --> AT transitions occurring at 5'-CpG-3' (CpG) dinucleotide sequences. Subsequently, the contribution of these transitions to age-related demethylation of genomic DNA can be evaluated. Finally, to better understand the origin of observed Mf, we consider the contribution of various factors, including DNA damage and repair, by constructing a descriptive mutational model. We then apply this model to estimate the efficiency of repair of deaminated 5-methylcytosine nucleosides occurring at CpG dinucleotide sequences, as well as the influence of the Msh2(-/-) DNA repair defect on overall DNA repair efficiency in Big Blue mice. We conclude that even slight changes in DNA repair efficiency could lead to significant increases in mutation frequencies, potentially contributing significantly to human pathogenesis, including cancer.

Involvement of 5-methylcytosine in sunlight-induced mutagenesis

In human skin cancers, more than 30 % of all mutations in the p53 gene are transitions at dipyrimidines within the sequence context CpG, i.e. 5'-TCG and 5'-CCG, found at several mutational hotspots. Since CpGs are methylated along the p53 gene, these mutations may be derived from solar UV-induced pyrimidine dimers forming at sequences that contain 5-methylcytosine. In Xorder to define the contribution of 5-methylcytosine to sunlight-induced mutations, we have used mouse fibroblasts containing the CpG-methylated lacI transgene as a mutational target. We sequenced 182 UVC (254 nm UV)-induced mutations and 170 mutations induced by a solar UV simulator, along with 75 mutations in untreated cells. Only a few of the mutations in untreated cells were transitions at dipyrimidines, but more than 95% of the UVC and solar irradiation-induced mutations were targeted to dipyrimidine sites, the majority being transitions. After UVC irradiation, 6% of the base substitutions were at dipyrimidines containing 5-methylcytosine and only 2.2% of all mutations were transitions within this sequence context. However, 24% of the solar light-induced mutations were at dipyrimidines that contain 5-methylcytosine and most of them were transitions. Two sunlight-induced mutational hotspots at methylated CpGs correlated with sequences that form the highest levels of cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers after irradiation with sunlight but not with UVC. The data indicate that dipyrimidines that contain 5-methylcytosine are preferential targets for sunlight-induced mutagenesis in cultured mammalian cells, thus explaining the large proportion of p53 mutations at such sites in skin tumors in vivo.

Methylation of CpG dinucleotides in the lacI gene of the Big Blue transgenic mouse

Cytosine residues at CpG dinucleotides can be methylated by endogenous methyltransferases in mammalian cells. The resulting 5-methylcytosine base may undergo spontaneous deamination to form thymine causing G/C to A/T transition mutations. Methylated CpGs also can form preferential targets for environmental mutagens and carcinogens. The Big Blue(R) transgenic mouse has been used to investigate tissue and organ specificity of mutations and to deduce mutational mechanisms in a mammal in vivo. The transgenic mouse contains approximately 40 concatenated lambda-like shuttle vectors, each of which contains one copy of an Escherichia coli lacI gene as a mutational target. lacI mutations in lambda transgenic mice are characterized by a high frequency of spontaneous mutations targeted to CpG dinucleotides suggesting an important contribution from methylation-mediated events. To study the methylation status of CpGs in the lacI gene, we have mapped the distribution of 5-methylcytosines along the DNA-binding domain and flanking sequences of the lacI gene of transgenic mice. We analyzed genomic DNA from various tissues including thymus, liver, testis, and DNA derived from two thymic lymphomas. The mouse genomic DNAs and methylated and unmethylated control DNAs were chemically cleaved, then the positions of 5-methylcytosines were mapped by ligation-mediated PCR which can be used to distinguish methylated from unmethylated cytosines. Our data show that most CpG dinucleotides in the DNA binding domain of the lacI gene are methylated to a high extent (>98%) in all tissues tested; only a few sites are partially (70-90%) methylated. We conclude that tissue-specific methylation is unlikely to contribute significantly to tissue-specific mutational patterns, and that the occurrence of common mutation sites at specific CpGs in the lacI gene is not related to selective methylation of only these sequences. The data confirm previous suggestions that the high frequency of CpG mutations in lacI transgenes is related to the presence of 5-methylcytosine bases.

A comparative study of in vivo mutation assays: analysis of hprt, lacI, cII/cI and as mutational targets for N-nitroso-N-methylurea and benzo[a]pyrene in Big Blue mice

We have compared the response of the native hprt gene and the lacI, cII, and cI transgenes in Big Blue B6C3F1 mice following treatment with either N-nitroso-N-methylurea (MNU) or benzo[a]pyrene (BaP). Three weeks after mutagen treatment splenic T cells were isolated from the animals, and samples were either cultured to measure mutation at the native hprt locus or used to extract genomic DNA for transgene mutation analysis. Phage rescued from extracted DNA were plated in the presence of 5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indolyl-beta-d-galactopyranoside (X-gal) to score lacI mutations, or plated on a hflAB lawn to score cII and cI mutants. With MNU hprt mutant frequency increased in a dose-related, sublinear manner up to 78-fold above background at the highest dose tested (20 mg/kg). In comparison, the lacI transgene yielded only a 3.1-fold increase at this dose, and the cII and cI transgenes did not show any increase. With 150 mg/kg BaP a 5.8- and 8.7-fold increase in mutant frequency was observed at hprt and lacI, respectively, while only a 1.3-fold increase was observed at cII. DNA sequencing revealed an increase in GC-->TA transversions among the cII mutants, suggesting that the increase was related to BaP exposure. No significant increase in cI mutant frequency was observed. Therefore, the order of mutation assay sensitivity was hprt>lacI>cII/cI with MNU, and hprt approximately lacI> cII/cI with BaP. While the hflAB selection system offers significant advantages with respect to cost and effort when compared to the lacI assay, additional evaluation of its sensitivity is warranted.