Electron-microscopic peritubular capillary lesion is a specific and useful diagnostic indicator for chronic rejection of renal allografts showing less specific morphologic lesions in the cyclosporine era

Regardless of etiology, progressive renal disease causes ultrastructural and functional alterations of peritubular capillaries

Progressive renal diseases are associated with rarefaction of peritubular capillaries, but the ultrastructural and functional alterations of the microvasculature are not well described. To study this, we analyzed different time points during progressive kidney damage and fibrosis in 3 murine models of different disease etiologies. These models were unilateral ureteral obstruction, unilateral ischemia-reperfusion injury, and Col4a3-deficient mice, we analyzed ultrastructural alterations in patient biopsy specimens. Compared with kidneys of healthy mice, we found a significant and progressive reduction of peritubular capillaries in all models analyzed. Ultrastructurally, compared with the kidneys of control mice, focal widening of the subendothelial space and higher numbers of endothelial vacuoles and caveolae were found in fibrotic kidneys. Quantitative analysis showed that peritubular capillary endothelial cells in fibrotic kidneys had significantly and progressively reduced numbers of fenestrations and increased thickness of the cell soma and lamina densa of the capillary basement membrane. Similar ultrastructural changes were also observed in patient's kidney biopsy specimens. Compared with healthy murine kidneys, fibrotic kidneys had significantly increased extravasation of Evans blue dye in all 3 models. The extravasation could be visualized using 2-photon microscopy in real time in living animals and was mainly localized to capillary branching points. Finally, fibrotic kidneys in all models exhibited a significantly greater degree of interstitial deposition of fibrinogen. Thus, peritubular capillaries undergo significant ultrastructural and functional alterations during experimental progressive renal diseases, independent of the underlying injury. Analyses of these alterations could provide read-outs for the evaluation of therapeutic approaches targeting the renal microvasculature.

Diagnostic significance of peritubular capillary basement membrane multilaminations in kidney allografts: old concepts revisited

BACKGROUND

Injury to peritubular capillaries and capillary basement membrane multilamination (PTCL) is a hallmark of antibody-mediated chronic renal allograft rejection. However, the predictive diagnostic value of PTCL is incompletely studied.

METHODS

We analyzed the diagnostic significance of PTCL and propose diagnostic strategies. We evaluated 360 diagnostic native and 187 transplant kidney specimens by electron microscopy (terminology: PTCL-C, severe; PTCL subgroup C3, very severe multilamination; see Materials and Methods for definitions).

RESULTS

PTCL was not pathognomonic for any specific disease. PTCL-C/C3 was rare in native kidneys (C, 6%; C3, 1%), associated mainly with late thrombotic microangiopathy (C: 78%; C3: 11% of cases). In allografts, PTCL-C/C3 was significantly more common, especially in specimens more than 24 months after transplantation (C, 47%; C3, 31%). PTCL-C/C3 was found in acute (C, 20%; C3, 7%) and chronic T-cell rejection (C, 67%; C3, 29%), calcineurin inhibitor toxicity (C, 36%; C3, 18%), or C4d(+) specimens (C, 61%; C3, 50%) with odds ratios between 4 and 36. PTCL-C3 was more predominant in cases with antibody-mediated injury. Highest odds ratios (81-117) for PTCL-C/C3 were noted in combined injuries, that is, mixed chronic T-cell and concurrent chronic antibody-mediated rejection. Positive predictive values of PTCL-C and C3 are the following: all rejection types, 89% and 93%; all Banff chronic rejection types, 69% and 71%; and chronic presumptive antibody rejection, 37% and 49%, respectively. Corresponding negative predictive values of C and C3 for different Banff rejection categories are between 50% and 94%.

CONCLUSIONS

The presence of PTCL-C3 is a helpful adjunct finding to diagnose rejection-induced tissue injury but cannot precisely predict the Banff rejection category. Conversely, the absence of PTCL-C3 is helpful in excluding chronic, Banff category II antibody-mediated rejection.

A case report of a renal transplant recipient developing chronic glomerular rejection with a weak antibody against anti-donor T-cell, only detected by flow-cytometry crossmatch

The pathogenesis of antibody-mediated rejection has been investigated, but the precise mechanism of chronic glomerular rejection remains unclear. We have followed the clinicopathological course of a patient with pre-existing anti-donor antibody only detected by flow-cytometry crossmatch for over 3 years. Glomerular endothelial injuries and peculiar glomerular lesions were noted in biopsy specimen of postoperative year 3; however, both typical chronic vascular rejection lesions and peritubular capillary multilayered lesions were not revealed. We consider that the presence of weak anti-donor antibody leading early onset of acute humoral rejection played a role in the pathogenesis of early onset of chronic transplant glomerulopathy.

C4d deposition in the glomeruli and peritubular capillaries associated with transplant glomerulopathy

Transplant glomerulopathy (TGP) is a unique disease entity with characteristic pathological findings. Although ultrastructural studies for TGP have been performed, histogenesis of TGP is not fully understood. The present study was designed to investigate the relation of complement fragment C4d to the histogenesis of TGP. Nine cases of isolated TGP were randomly selected. A commercially available monoclonal antibody against complement fragment C4d was used in allograft biopsies. To evaluate the extent and severity of deposition of the C4d complement in the glomerular and peritubular capillaries, indirect immunofluoresce method was performed on frozen sections. Intense deposition of C4d in the glomerular basement membrane and peritubular capillaries was found in association with morphological appearance of TGP. Peritubular capillaries were affected in all the patients, showing splitting and multilayering of peritubular capillary basement membrane. These changes, which diffusely affect most capillaries, and their severity pattern were quite similar in each patient. In early stages of all patients with cellular rejection, C4d was not detected in the glomerular and peritubular capillaries. In addition, no C4d deposition was detected in all zero-hour biopsies without diagnostic abnormality. These findings suggest that C4d deposition in the glomerular and peritubular capillaries might be associated with the pathogenesis of TGP in renal transplantation.

Persistent rejection of peritubular capillaries and tubules is associated with progressive interstitial fibrosis

BACKGROUND

We have reported that a 12-day course of high dose cyclosporine A treatment in thymectomized miniature swine with major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I-mismatched renal allografts results in transient acute rejection followed by either in chronic rejection (progression group) or graft acceptance (recovery group). Here, we examined the differential features between both groups in the peritubular capillaries (PTCs) and tubules to clarify the pathogenesis of the progressive interstitial fibrosis in chronic rejection.

METHODS

Morphometric and immunohistochemical studies were performed on serial renal biopsies (days 0 to 100) obtained from both groups, focusing on the cellular infiltrate, rejection of PTCs and tubules, myofibroblast accumulation, and progressive interstitial fibrosis.

RESULTS

In the progression group, acute rejection occurred by day 8 and progressed to chronic rejection by day 100, with the development of interstitial fibrosis. PTC endothelial cell and tubular epithelial cell death associated with CD3+ cell infiltration was evident, confirmed by nick end-labeling (TUNEL), commencing by day 8 and continuing thereafter. In acute rejection, destruction of PTCs and tubules accompanied by disruption of basement membrane (BM) occurred with capillaritis or tubulitis in areas with a severe cellular infiltrate. During the development of chronic rejection, capillaritis of PTCs and tubulitis continued by day 100, accompanied by persistent T cell infiltration, and the remaining PTCs and tubules exhibited progressive atrophy with thickening and/or lamination of BM. On day 100, identifiable PTCs and tubules were lost in areas of interstitial fibrosis. Proliferating (PCNA+) alpha-actin+ myofibroblasts accumulated around PTCs, tubules and in interstitium, and widespread interstitial fibrosis developed by day 100. In contrast, in the recovery group, injured PTCs and tubules recovered by day 100 based on the resolution of acute rejection, and minimal loss of PTCs and tubules was evident by day 100 with minimal interstitial fibrosis.

CONCLUSIONS

Persistent rejection directed at PTCs and tubules, and proliferation of myofibroblasts are prominent features in the progressive interstitial fibrosis in chronic rejection, and are probably key events in its pathogenesis.

Fibrosis and atrophy in the renal allograft: interim report and new directions

The topic of chronic allograft nephropathy/chronic rejection is reviewed, with focus on fibrosing/sclerosing changes and late loss of function in renal allografts. Discussion includes a review of the problem, pathological and clinical findings, and new directions. Emphasis is placed on definition of specific diagnostic entities in these allografts, and identification of ongoing/active processes in this setting that might be amenable to direct intervention. A schema for categorizing these cases is proposed.

Loss of direct and maintenance of indirect alloresponses in renal allograft recipients: implications for the pathogenesis of chronic allograft nephropathy

Chronic allograft nephropathy (CAN) is the principal cause of late renal allograft failure. This complex process is multifactorial in origin, and there is good evidence for immune-mediated effects. The immune contribution to this process is directed by CD4(+) T cells, which can be activated by either direct or indirect pathways of allorecognition. For the first time, these pathways have been simultaneously compared in a cohort of 22 longstanding renal allograft recipients (13 with good function and nine with CAN). CD4(+) T cells from all patients reveal donor-specific hyporesponsiveness by the direct pathway according to proliferation or the secretion of the cytokines IL-2, IL-5, and IFN-gamma. Donor-specific cytotoxic T cell responses were also attenuated. In contrast, the frequencies of indirectly alloreactive cells were maintained, patients with CAN having significantly higher frequencies of CD4(+) T cells indirectly activated by allogeneic peptides when compared with controls with good allograft function. An extensive search for alloantibodies has revealed significant titers in only a minority of patients, both with and without CAN. In summary, this study demonstrates widespread donor-specific hyporesponsiveness in directly activated CD4(+) T cells derived from longstanding recipients of renal allografts, whether they have CAN or not. However, patients with CAN have significantly higher frequencies of CD4(+) T cells activated by donor Ags in an indirect manner, a phenomenon resembling split tolerance. These findings provide an insight into the pathogenesis of CAN and also have implications for the development of a clinical tolerance assay.

The value of electron microscopy in the diagnosis of chronic renal allograft rejection

The main causes of the late dysfunction of renal allografts are chronic rejection and chronic transplant nephropathy. Both are clinicopathologic entities, with a similar clinical presentation, but different histologic appearances. Chronic rejection is characterized by the presence of alloantigen-induced lesions (transplant arteriopathy and transplant glomerulopathy), and chronic transplant nephropathy by nonspecific sclerosing changes. The incidence of transplant arteriopathy and transplant glomerulopathy is relatively low. Electron microscopy (EM) may overcome the limitations in the histologic diagnosis of chronic rejection, because it verifies alloantigen-induced chronic microvasculopathy in the peritubular capillaries (transplant capillaropathy), and identifies transplant glomerulopathy more precisely than does light microscopy. To assess the value of EM in chronic rejection diagnosis, a retrospective search for transplant capillaropathy and transplant glomerulopathy was performed in a consecutive series of 91 biopsies performed > or = 6 months after implantation (median: 26 months, range 6-186) and the diagnoses were reclassified on the basis of the ultrastructural findings. The definitions used were: transplant capillaropathy: a peritubular capillary profile with seven or more circumferential basement membrane layers, or at least three profiles with five or six circumferential layers; ultrastructurally verified transplant glomerulopathy: thickening of the capillary wall in at least three loops in consequence of the widening of the subendothelial space by abnormal basement membrane material, and the formation of a new layer(s) of basal lamina; and chronic rejection: the presence of transplant capillaropathy and/or transplant glomerulopathy and/or transplant arteriopathy. Histologically, chronic transplant nephropathy, chronic rejection, chronic cyclosporine nephrotoxicity, glomerulonephritis, acute rejection, "suspicious" for acute rejection, and "others" were diagnosed in 37%, 34%, 21%, 19%, 57%, 30%, and 5% of the specimens, respectively. The results of EM increased the diagnosis of chronic rejection to 69% of the cases, and decreased chronic transplant nephropathy to 15%. The individual incidence of transplant capillaropathy and transplant glomerulopathy was 79% and 57%, respectively, and their cumulative incidence was 92%. Five biopsies exhibited merely transplant arteriopathy. A late dysfunction typically had more than one cause; the most frequent combination was chronic rejection and acute rejection. In conclusion, the EM search for transplant capillaropathy and transplant glomerulopathy doubled the frequency of the diagnosis of chronic rejection. Currently, the evaluation of renal allograft biopsies from recipients with a late dysfunction relies on standard light microscopy. Because light microscopy per se proved to be insensitive in the diagnosis of chronic rejection, incorporation of EM into the evaluation of late dysfunction biopsies is strongly recommended.

Rejection of peritubular capillaries in renal allo- and xeno-graft

The microvasculature plays an important role in the pathogenesis of humoral- and cell-mediated renal allo- and xeno-graft rejection. Peritubular capillary (PTC) endothelium expresses the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I and II antigens in the resting phase, as does the glomerular capillary endothelium, suggesting that these cells may be major immune targets. However, the role of PTCs in renal allo- and xeno-graft rejection is unclear. In this review, we discuss injury and subsequent remodeling of PTCs in both humoral- and cell-mediated rejection in allo- and xeno-grafts. Recent evidence suggests that PTC injury and endothelial cell death occur during both cell- and humoral-mediated rejection. Severe PTC rejection contributes to deterioration of graft function and acute graft loss. The mild but recurrent form of PTC rejection is associated with progressive interstitial fibrosis and chronic rejection. Following endothelial injury, the remaining PTC endothelium activates with up-regulation of allo-antigens and adhesion molecules, and down-regulation of anti-coagulant proteins. Subsequent to this, more severe rejection and graft dysfunction occur. Therefore, a careful analysis of cellular- and antibody-mediated rejection in PTCs is important in the diagnosis of rejection, prediction of graft prognosis, and in further development of new anti-rejection therapies.

Chronic humoral rejection: identification of antibody-mediated chronic renal allograft rejection by C4d deposits in peritubular capillaries

The pathogenesis of chronic renal allograft rejection (CR) remains obscure. The hypothesis that a subset of CR is mediated by antidonor antibody was tested by determining whether C4d is deposited in peritubular capillaries (PTC) and whether it correlates with circulating antidonor antibodies. All cases (from January 1, 1990, to July 31, 1999) that met histologic criteria for CR and had frozen tissue (28 biopsies, 10 nephrectomies) were included. Controls were renal allograft biopsies with chronic cyclosporine toxicity (n = 21) or nonspecific interstitial fibrosis (n = 10), and native kidneys with end-stage renal disease (n = 10) or chronic interstitial fibrosis (n = 5). Frozen sections were stained by two-color immunofluorescence for C4d, type IV collagen and Ulex europaeus agglutinin I. Antidonor HLA antibody was sought by panel-reactive antibody analysis and/or donor cross matching in sera within 7 wk of biopsy. Overall, 23 of 38 CR cases (61%) had PTC staining for C4d, compared with 1 of 46 (2%) of controls (P < 0.001). C4d in PTC was localized at the interface of endothelium and basement membrane. Most of the C4d-positive CR tested had antidonor HLA antibody (15 of 17; 88%); none of the C4d-negative CR tested (0 of 8) had antidonor antibody (P < 0.0002). The histology of C4d-positive CR was similar to C4d-negative CR, and 1-yr graft survival rates were 62% and 25%, respectively (P = 0.05). Since August 1998, five of six C4d-positive CR cases have been treated with mycophenolate mofetil +/- tacrolimus with a 100% 1-yr graft survival, versus 40% before August 1998 (P < 0.03). These data support the hypothesis that a substantial fraction of CR is mediated by antibody (immunologically active). C4d can be used to separate this group of CR from the nonspecific category of chronic allograft nephropathy and may have the potential to guide successful therapeutic intervention.

Quantitation of allograft fibrosis and chronic allograft nephropathy

Despite improvements in the prevention and treatment of acute renal allograft rejection, the long-term survival of renal transplants has not increased. Immunologic and non-immunologic factors contribute to the gradual deterioration of graft function and to the histologic lesion characterized by vascular and interstitial fibrosis ('chronic rejection'). Quantitation of this process has been attempted using various invasive and non-invasive methods. These methods, performed at different times post-transplant, are reviewed in this article. In particular, pathology scoring systems and the potential of using computerized image analysis of biopsy material are discussed.