Hypotheses about the neural trigger for plasticity in the circuit for the vestibulo-ocular reflex

Cerebellar ataxia

The cerebellum plays an integral role in the control of limb and ocular movements, balance, and walking. Cerebellar disorders may be classified as sporadic or hereditary with clinical presentation varying with the extent and site of cerebellar damage and extracerebellar signs. Deficits in balance and walking reflect the cerebellum's proposed role in coordination, sensory integration, coordinate transformation, motor learning, and adaptation. Cerebellar dysfunction results in increased postural sway, hypermetric postural responses to perturbations and optokinetic stimuli, and postural responses that are poorly coordinated with volitional movement. Gait variability is characteristic and may arise from a combination of balance impairments, interlimb incoordination, and incoordination between postural activity and leg movement. Intrinsic problems with balance lead to a high prevalence of injurious falls. Evidence for pharmacologic management is limited, although aminopyridines reduce attacks in episodic ataxias and may have a role in improving gait ataxia in other conditions. Intensive exercises targeting balance and coordination lead to improvements in balance and walking but require ongoing training to maintain/maximize any effects. Noninvasive brain stimulation of the cerebellum may become a useful adjunct to therapy in the future. Walking aids, orthoses, specialized footwear and seating may be required for more severe cases of cerebellar ataxia.

Timing Rules for Synaptic Plasticity Matched to Behavioral Function

It is widely assumed that the complexity of neural circuits enables them to implement diverse learning tasks using just a few generic forms of synaptic plasticity. In contrast, we report that synaptic plasticity can itself be precisely tuned to the requirements of a learning task. We found that the rules for induction of long-term and single-trial plasticity at parallel fiber-to-Purkinje cell synapses vary across cerebellar regions. In the flocculus, associative plasticity in vitro and in vivo is narrowly tuned for an interval of ∼120 ms, which compensates for the specific processing delay for error signals to reach the flocculus during oculomotor learning. In the vermis, which supports a range of behavioral functions, plasticity is induced by a range of intervals, with individual cells tuned for different intervals. Thus, plasticity at a single, anatomically defined type of synapse can have properties that vary in a way that is precisely matched to function.

Prolonged vestibular stimulation induces homeostatic plasticity of the vestibulo-ocular reflex in larval Xenopus laevis

Vestibulo-ocular reflexes (VOR) stabilise retinal images during head/body motion in vertebrates by generating spatio-temporally precise extraocular motor commands for corrective eye movements. While VOR performance is generally robust with a relatively stable gain, cerebellar circuits are capable of adapting the underlying sensory-motor transformation. Here, we studied cerebellum-dependent VOR plasticity by recording head motion-induced lateral rectus and superior oblique extraocular motor discharge in semi-intact preparations of Xenopus laevis tadpoles. In the absence of visual feedback, prolonged sinusoidal rotation caused either an increase or decrease of the VOR gain depending on the motion stimulus amplitude. The observed changes in extraocular motor discharge gradually saturated after 20 min of constant rotation and returned to baseline in the absence of motion stimulation. Furthermore, plastic changes in lateral rectus and superior oblique motor commands were plane-specific for horizontal and vertical rotations, respectively, suggesting that alterations are restricted to principal VOR connections. Comparison of multi- and single-unit activity indicated that plasticity occurs in all recorded units of a given extraocular motor nucleus. Ablation of the cerebellum abolished motoneuronal gain changes and prevented the induction of plasticity, thus demonstrating that both acquisition and retention of this type of plasticity require an intact cerebellar circuitry. In conclusion, the plane-specific and stimulus intensity-dependent modification of the VOR gain through the feed-forward cerebellar circuitry represents a homeostatic plasticity that likely maintains an optimal working range for the underlying sensory-motor transformation.

Memory in Neuroscience: Rhetoric Versus Reality

The central point of this article is that the concept of memory as information storage in the brain is inadequate for and irrelevant to understanding the nervous system. Beginning from the sensorimotor hypothesis that underlies neuroscience—that the entire function of the nervous system is to connect experience to appropriate behavior—the paper defines memories as sequences of events that connect remote experience to present behavior. Their essential components are (a) persistent events that bridge the time from remote experience to present behavior and (b) junctional events in which connections from remote experience and recent experience merge to produce behavior. The sequences comprising even the simplest memories are complex. This is both necessary—to preserve previously learned behaviors—and inevitable—due to secondary activity-driven plasticity. This complexity further highlights the inadequacy of the information storage concept and the importance of extreme simplicity in models used to study memory.

Loss of Projections, Functional Compensation, and Residual Deficits in the Mammalian Vestibulospinal System of Hoxb1-Deficient Mice

The genetic mechanisms underlying the developmental and functional specification of brainstem projection neurons are poorly understood. Here, we use transgenic mouse tools to investigate the role of the gene Hoxb1 in the developmental patterning of vestibular projection neurons, with particular focus on the lateral vestibulospinal tract (LVST). The LVST is the principal pathway that conveys vestibular information to limb-related spinal motor circuits and arose early during vertebrate evolution. We show that the segmental hindbrain expression domain uniquely defined by the rhombomere 4 (r4) Hoxb1 enhancer is the origin of essentially all LVST neurons, but also gives rise to subpopulations of contralateral medial vestibulospinal tract (cMVST) neurons, vestibulo-ocular neurons, and reticulospinal (RS) neurons. In newborn mice homozygous for a Hoxb1-null mutation, the r4-derived LVST and cMVST subpopulations fail to form and the r4-derived RS neurons are depleted. Several general motor skills appear unimpaired, but hindlimb vestibulospinal reflexes, which are mediated by the LVST, are greatly reduced. This functional deficit recovers, however, during the second postnatal week, indicating a substantial compensation for the missing LVST. Despite the compensatory plasticity in balance, adult Hoxb1-null mice exhibit other behavioral deficits that manifest particularly in proprioception and interlimb coordination during locomotor tasks. Our results provide a comprehensive account of the developmental role of Hoxb1 in patterning the vestibular system and evidence for a remarkable developmental plasticity in the descending control of reflex limb movements. They also suggest an involvement of the lateral vestibulospinal tract in proprioception and in ensuring limb alternation generated by locomotor circuitry.

3'UTR-dependent localization of a Purkinje cell messenger RNA in dendrites

Pcp2(L7) is a Purkinje cell-specific GoLoco domain protein that modulates activation of Galphai/o proteins by G protein-coupled receptors. A likely downstream effector of this pathway is the P-type Ca(2+) channel, and thereby, the intrinsic electrophysiology of Purkinje cells could be modulated by Pcp2(L7). It has long been known that the Pcp2(L7) mRNA is abundantly localized in dendrites, suggesting the possibility of distal synthesis and local changes in levels of the protein. As a first step to uncover the trafficking and translational mechanisms for this mRNA, we have begun identifying the cis-acting sequences important for its localization in dendrites. Using expression of modified transgenes in vivo, we show that the 3'UTR, only 65 bases long, is necessary in this process.

Cerebellar motor learning: when is cortical plasticity not enough?

Classical Marr-Albus theories of cerebellar learning employ only cortical sites of plasticity. However, tests of these theories using adaptive calibration of the vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) have indicated plasticity in both cerebellar cortex and the brainstem. To resolve this long-standing conflict, we attempted to identify the computational role of the brainstem site, by using an adaptive filter version of the cerebellar microcircuit to model VOR calibration for changes in the oculomotor plant. With only cortical plasticity, introducing a realistic delay in the retinal-slip error signal of 100 ms prevented learning at frequencies higher than 2.5 Hz, although the VOR itself is accurate up to at least 25 Hz. However, the introduction of an additional brainstem site of plasticity, driven by the correlation between cerebellar and vestibular inputs, overcame the 2.5 Hz limitation and allowed learning of accurate high-frequency gains. This "cortex-first" learning mechanism is consistent with a wide variety of evidence concerning the role of the flocculus in VOR calibration, and complements rather than replaces the previously proposed "brainstem-first" mechanism that operates when ocular tracking mechanisms are effective. These results (i) describe a process whereby information originally learnt in one area of the brain (cerebellar cortex) can be transferred and expressed in another (brainstem), and (ii) indicate for the first time why a brainstem site of plasticity is actually required by Marr-Albus type models when high-frequency gains must be learned in the presence of error delay.

The cerebellum in maintenance of a motor skill: a hierarchy of brain and spinal cord plasticity underlies H-reflex conditioning

Operant conditioning of the H-reflex, the electrical analog of the spinal stretch reflex, is a simple model of skill acquisition and involves plasticity in the spinal cord. Previous work showed that the cerebellum is essential for down-conditioning the H-reflex. This study asks whether the cerebellum is also essential for maintaining down-conditioning. After rats decreased the soleus H-reflex over 50 d in response to the down-conditioning protocol, the cerebellar output nuclei dentate and interpositus (DIN) were ablated, and down-conditioning continued for 50-100 more days. In naive (i.e., unconditioned) rats, DIN ablation itself has no significant long-term effect on H-reflex size. During down-conditioning prior to DIN ablation, eight Sprague-Dawley rats decreased the H-reflex to 57% (+/-4 SEM) of control. It rose after ablation, stabilizing within 2 d at about 75% and remaining there until approximately 40 d after ablation. It then rose to approximately 130%, where it remained through the end of study 100 d after ablation. Thus, DIN ablation in down-conditioned rats caused an immediate increase and a delayed increase in the H-reflex. The final result was an H-reflex significantly larger than that prior to down-conditioning. Combined with previous work, these remarkable results suggest that the spinal cord plasticity directly responsible for down-conditioning, which survives only 5-10 d on its own, is maintained by supraspinal plasticity that survives approximately 40 d after loss of cerebellar output. Thus, H-reflex conditioning seems to depend on a hierarchy of brain and spinal cord plasticity to which the cerebellum makes an essential contribution.

Dominant-negative effects of human P/Q-type Ca2+ channel mutations associated with episodic ataxia type 2

Episodic ataxia type 2 (EA2) is an inherited autosomal dominant disorder related to cerebellar dysfunction and is associated with mutations in the pore-forming alpha(1A)-subunits of human P/Q-type Ca(2+) channels (Cav2.1 channels). The majority of EA2 mutations result in significant loss-of-function phenotypes. Whether EA2 mutants may display dominant-negative effects in human, however, remains controversial. To address this issue, five EA2 mutants in the long isoform of human alpha(1A)-subunits were expressed in Xenopus oocytes to explore their potential dominant-negative effects. Upon coexpressing the cRNA of alpha(1A)-WT with each alpha(1A)-mutant in molar ratios ranging from 1:1 to 1:10, the amplitude of Ba(2+) currents through wild-type (WT)-Cav2.1 channels decreased significantly as the relative molar ratio of alpha(1A)-mutants increased, suggesting the presence of an alpha(1A)-mutant-specific suppression effect. When we coexpressed alpha(1A)-WT with proteins not known to interact with Cav2.1 channels, we observed no significant suppression effects. Furthermore, increasing the amount of auxiliary subunits resulted in partial reversal of the suppression effects in nonsense but not missense EA2 mutants. On the other hand, when we repeated the same coinjection experiments of alpha(1A)-WT and mutant using a splice variant of alpha(1A)-subunit that contained a considerably shorter COOH terminus (i.e., the short isoform), no significant dominant-negative effects were noted until we enhanced the relative molar ratio to 1:10. Altogether, these results indicate that for human WT-Cav2.1 channels comprising the long-alpha(1A)-subunit isoform, both missense and nonsense EA2 mutants indeed display prominent dominant-negative effects.

Fos responses to short-term adaptation of the horizontal vestibuloocular reflex before and after vestibular compensation in the Mongolian gerbil

Fos expression in vestibular brainstem and cerebellar regions was evaluated during vestibular adaptation in the Mongolian gerbil. In addition, vestibular adaptation was evaluated in both normal and compensated animals, as vestibular compensation reorganizes the vestibular pathway constraining adaptive processes. Behaviorally, discordant optokinetic and vestibular input induced appropriate high and low gain in horizontal angular vestibuloocular reflex responses. In normal animals, low gain adaptation was more complete than high gain. However, in compensated animals, only low gain adaptation produced adaptive responses both toward and away from the lesion with appropriate gain shifts. High gain adaptation in compensated animals failed to result in gain adaptation for head movements toward the side of the lesion. Fos expression during acute vestibular adaptation in normal animals was found in the flocculus/paraflocculus, the dorsal cap of the inferior olive (IOK), and the prepositus hypoglossi (PrH). Floccular Fos labeling was increased under both high and low gain conditions. IOK and PrH labeling was increased and correlated during low gain conditions, but was reduced and uncorrelated during high gain conditions. The pattern of Fos labeling in compensated animals was asymmetric-favoring the ipsilesional flocculus and contralesional vestibular brainstem. Both compensated high and low gain adaptation groups displayed increased floccular and IOK Fos labeling, but only compensated high gain adaptation produced increased Fos labeling in the medial vestibular nucleus. The behavioral and Fos labeling results are consistent with visual-vestibular adaptation requiring direct vestibular input.

Cerebellar AMPA/KA receptor antagonism by CNQX inhibits vestibuloocular reflex adaptation

Vestibuloocular reflex (VOR) performance and adaptation have been investigated during antagonism of cerebellar AMPA/quisqualate and kainate receptors (AMPA/KA) by 6-cyano-7-nitroquinoxaline-2,3-dione (CNQX). Injection of CNQX into the vestibulo-cerebellum of the goldfish before adaptation significantly inhibited and, at the highest dosage, completely prevented acquisition of adaptive reflex gain increases and decreases during a 3-h training period. Injection of CNQX before initiation of VOR adaptive training did not affect pre-adapted baseline performance of the reflex. Injection of CNQX, 1 to 2 h after the initiation of training did not alter the performance of adaptive gain increases that occurred before the injection. If injection of CNQX occurred at the end of adaptive training, there was an accelerated loss of the previously adapted gain changes during the retention period when the animal remained stationary in the dark. CNQX injection did not produce any permanent or long-term deficits, because goldfish could be retrained 48 h later to produce adaptive VOR gain changes similar to control animals. Thus, this work demonstrates that the AMPA/KA receptors located in the vestibulo-cerebellum of the goldfish are necessary for acquisition of short-term adaptive VOR gain increases and decreases. The deficit in adaptive capability was not the result of a deficit in performance, because CNQX did not inhibit an adaptive change that had already occurred as long as the adapting vestibular and visual stimulation continued. This adaptive performance could possibly be maintained by other glutamatergic (metabotropic) receptors located on the Purkinje cells. The retention of adapted gain increases and decreases after CNQX application was inhibited because AMPA/KA antagonism accelerated VOR gain loss after the completion of training when no vestibular or visual stimulation was present. Because the AMPA/KA receptors are located only in the molecular layer of the goldfish cerebellum, these results are, presumably, the result of AMPA/KA receptor antagonism at synapses located on the Purkinje cell dendrite tree.

Ablation of cerebellar nuclei prevents H-reflex down-conditioning in rats

While studies of cerebellar involvement in learning and memory have described plasticity within the cerebellum, its role in acquisition of plasticity elsewhere in the CNS is largely unexplored. This study set out to determine whether the cerebellum is needed for acquisition of the spinal cord plasticity that underlies operantly conditioned decrease in the H-reflex, the electrical analog of the spinal stretch reflex. Rats in which the cerebellar output nuclei dentate and interpositus (DIN) had been ablated were exposed for 50 d to the H-reflex down-conditioning protocol. DIN ablation, which in itself had no significant long-term effect on H-reflex size, entirely prevented acquisition of a smaller H-reflex. Since previous studies show that corticospinal tract (CST) transection also prevents down-conditioning while transection of the rubrospinal tract and other major descending tracts does not, this result implies that DIN output that affects cortex is essential for generation of the CST activity that induces the spinal cord plasticity, which is, in turn, directly responsible for the smaller H-reflex. The result extends the role of the cerebellum in learning and memory to include participation in induction of plasticity elsewhere in the CNS, specifically in the spinal cord. The cerebellum might simply support processes in sensorimotor cortex or elsewhere that change the spinal cord, or the cerebellum itself might undergo plasticity similar to that occurring with vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) or eyeblink conditioning.

Impaired modulation of the vestibulo-ocular reflex in Huntington's disease

The vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) stabilizes gaze during movement, in conjunction with other afferent information: visual, proprioceptive, and somaesthetic. The reflex can either be augmented or suppressed, depending on visual requirements, and undergoes long-term adaptation to compensate for physical changes in the subject. Importantly, over relatively short periods of time, the VOR should function consistently under the same circumstances. This study examines VOR function in patients with Huntington's disease (HD), with a view to investigating cortical influences on the reflex. Horizontal eye movements were recorded in 9 patients with HD and 7 normal subjects, using the scleral search coil technique, in response to high frequency, unpredictable head rotations imposed manually. To establish base VOR function, recordings were made in darkness, without instruction, before and after wearing x2 magnifying lenses for a period of 2 hours to adapt the reflex. Recordings were also made before adaptation, while fixating a stationary visual target (VOR augmentation), and while fixating a target moving with the head (VOR suppression). Although results suggest that the VOR is preserved in HD, with relatively normal gain values and appropriate augmentation and suppression of the reflex with visual input, patients were unable to adapt the VOR to altered visual conditions. This represents a novel finding in HD and suggests that cortical structures compromised in HD exert influences on the long-term adaptation of the VOR.

Adaptive control of pursuit, vergence and eye torsion in humans: basic and clinical implications

Recent research from our laboratory has been directed at understanding the range of capabilities for adaptive control of eye movements in normal human subjects. For smooth pursuit, different motor responses to the same sensory stimulus (horizontal target motion) can be learned, stored and gated in or out, according to context (vertical eye position). The dynamic properties of the 'open-loop' portion of horizontal, disparity-driven vergence eye movements are under adaptive control. Eye torsion is also subject to adaptive control, including torsional 'phoria adaptation' and cross-coupling of torsion into the horizontal vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR). Finally, lesions of the oculomotor vermis in monkeys produce disordered binocular ocular motor function: 'esodeviations' in the absence of disparity cues, and decreased adaptation of the horizontal phoria to a sustained disparity induced by wearing a horizontal prism in front of one eye.

Beyond parallel fiber LTD: the diversity of synaptic and non-synaptic plasticity in the cerebellum

In recent years, it has become clear that motor learning, as revealed by associative eyelid conditioning and adaptation of the vestibulo-ocular reflex, contributes to the well-established cerebellar functions of sensorimotor integration and control. Long-term depression of the parallel fiber-Purkinje cell synapse (which is often called 'cerebellar LTD') is a cellular phenomenon that has been suggested to underlie these forms of learning. However, it is clear that parallel fiber LTD, by itself, cannot account for all the properties of cerebellar motor learning. Here we review recent electrophysiological experiments that have described a rich variety of use-dependent plasticity in cerebellum, including long-term potentiation (LTP) and LTD of excitatory and inhibitory synapses, and persistent modulation of intrinsic neuronal excitability. Finally, using associative eyelid conditioning as an example, we propose some ideas about how these cellular phenomena might function and interact to endow the cerebellar circuit with particular computational and mnemonic properties.