Hydralazine-induced lupus: no association with HLA-DR4

Drug-induced lupus

INTRODUCTION

Drug-induced lupus (DIL) refers to an idiosyncratic side effect of numerous, apparently unrelated, medications, in which symptoms overlap with those of systemic lupus erythematosus. DIL is reversible by discontinuation of the medication. The etiological mechanism underlying DIL is linked to the inherent susceptibility of the adaptive immune system to lapse into auto-reactivity.

AREAS COVERED

Clinical and laboratory features of DIL will be compared with those of idiopathic systemic lupus and with other types of drug reactions with overlapping features. Formerly commonly-used drugs conferred very high risk of developing DIL, although the probability of developing DIL has not been established with most lupus-inducing drugs. Pharmacological or physiochemical properties of the parent compounds are uninformative, but the importance of reactive drug metabolites in initiating autoimmunity will be discussed. As with most systemic autoimmune diseases, the pathogenesis of DIL is complex and obscure. The role of complement and human leukocyte allotypes as well as drug acetylator phenotype inform the underlying mechanism, and several of these non-mutually exclusive concepts will be described.

EXPERT OPINION

The pros and cons of proposed mechanisms for DIL will be discussed in the context of current understanding of autoimmunity and immune tolerance to self.

Personalized medicine for HLA-associated drug-hypersensitivity reactions

Multiple genetic and nongenetic factors can modify the action of a drug, resulting in varied responses to a particular drug across different individuals. Personalized medicine incorporates the comprehensive knowledge of these factors to facilitate the selection of optimal therapy, reduce adverse drug reactions, increase patient compliance and increase the efficiency of therapy. Pharmacogenomics, which integrates the knowledge of an individual’s genetic make-up for diagnostic decisions or therapeutic interventions is closely linked to personalized medicine, and is being increasingly used to prevent adverse drug reactions. There are various reports on genetic associations between particular HLA allotypes and drug hypersensitivities and the strongest associations reported thus far, are with the reverse transcriptase inhibitor, abacavir and HLA-B*5701, the gout prophylactic allopurinol and HLA-B*5801 and the antiepileptic carbamazepine and B*1502, providing a defined disease trigger and suggesting a general mechanism for these associations. Recognizing the strong HLA association, the US FDA has recommended genetic testing before starting abacavir and carbamazepine therapies. To incorporate HLA testing for other drug hypersensitivities and life-threatening reactions it is essential first to establish clear HLA associations, and second, to understand the immune-mechanism by which these drugs induce HLA-linked hypersensitivity. The latter will provide insight into the pathologic mechanisms of drug allergy allowing rational immunotherapy for these life-threatening reactions and the development of alternative drug therapies for hypersensitive patients.

Autoimmune diseases associated with drugs, chemicals and environmental factors

Autoimmune connective tissue diseases are complex multisystems and may be life threatening. Their aetiology is unknown but genetic, hormonal and environmental factors are important. In systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), factors such as UV light and drugs, including oestrogen, may trigger the disease; silica exposure may also be important. Scleroderma is associated with silica exposure and drugs such as bleomycin and pentazocine may induce scleroderma-like diseases. Organic solvents such as vinyl chloride and epoxy resins may also be associated with scleroderma-like illnesses. The toxic oil syndrome and eosinophila-myalgia syndrome are best known examples of connective tissue diseases induced by chemical exposure. The systemic vasculitides and in particular cutaneous vasculitis may be induced by drugs and possibly environmental factors. A number of autoimmune connective tissue diseases may therefore be associated with exposure to drugs, chemicals and environmental factors and the risks associated with these should be minimised where possible.

Clinical and immunological study of 7 patients with minocycline-induced autoimmune phenomena

PURPOSE

Prolonged treatment with minocycline for acne vulgaris has been associated with the development of arthralgia, arthritis, and other autoimmune phenomena. We characterized the clinical, laboratory, and immunological profiles of seven patients with this syndrome.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

Clinically the patients were studied with special emphasis on prior minocycline treatment, presenting symptoms, physical findings, course, and outcome. Laboratory tests included fluorescent antinuclear and antineutrophil cytoplasmic (ANCA) antibodies, as well as antibodies to myeloperoxidase, bactericidal permeability increasing protein, elastase, cathepsin G, lactoferrin, cardiolipin, and histone.

RESULTS

All 7 patients presented with polyarthritis or arthralgia, morning stiffness, and fever after 6 to 36 months of minocycline treatment. The skin was involved in five patients (three with livedo reticularis and two with subcutaneous nodules). Two patients had chronic active hepatitis. Increased titers of perinuclear ANCA (p-ANCA) were detected in all seven patients; five patients had fluorescent antinuclear antibodies, two had antihistone autoantibodies and one had anticardiolipin antibodies. Antigenic characterization of p-ANCA disclosed antibodies to bactericidal permeability increasing protein in one patient, to elastase in three patients, and to cathepsin G in five patients. Symptoms resolved in five patients upon discontinuation of minocycline; the other two patients were treated with corticosteroids and also achieved remissions.

CONCLUSION

Minocycline-induced autoimmune syndrome is characterized by reversible polyarthralgia or arthritis, morning stiffness, fever, frequent skin involvement, occasional chronic active hepatitis, and increased titers of p-ANCA with various minor p-ANCA-related antigens.

Genetic and immunologic studies of patients on procainamide

Forty (40) patients with cardiac arrhythmias receiving procainamide (PA) therapy and 24 patients who were receiving other drugs for their cardiac disorders were investigated for class II HLA phenotypes and their DRB1*04 and DQB1*03 subtypes. Other genetic marker evaluations in the PA patients included: 1) class III MHC C4A and C4B null alleles of complement; and, 2) acetylation phenotype. Twenty (20) of the PA patients were also tested for the ability of their stimulated cells to secrete Interleukin-1 (IL-1 beta) and tumor necrosis factor (TNF alpha). We also examined the spontaneous production of these cytokines by peripheral blood leukocytes (PBL) from patients who were receiving chronic PA treatment. The results revealed no association of acetylation phenotypes with the class II HLA phenotypes nor class III MHC C4 allotypes in these patients. The results did show a significant increase in class III C4 complement allotypes in the PA patients when compared to the controls. The results also showed a significant increase in autoantibodies and DQw3 phenotypes in the PA patient group when compared to control populations. Results of spontaneous IL-1 and TNF production suggested there may be an association of select class II HLA phenotypes in some patients and this may be relevant to host responsiveness to PA treatment.

Role of genetic factors in drug-related autoimmunity

Although there is evidence to suggest that genetic factors play a major role in the pathogenesis of many of the rheumatic diseases, far less is known of their role in the induction and expression of human autoimmunity resulting from long-term exposure to drugs, chemicals and environmental agents. Pharmacogenetic factors represent an important source of interindividual variation in response to drugs; most research to date has focused on genetic polymorphism of drug metabolism via N-acetylation, S-methylation or cytochrome P-450-catalyzed oxidation. In drug-related autoimmunity, there is limited evidence that the host's genetic background plays a major role beyond the expression of autoantibodies. More recent prospective studies have concentrated on the association of MHC-genes in the expression of autoimmunity and the susceptibility of patients to develop drug-related clinical syndromes.

HLA and disease

Many human diseases are associated with HLA class I, class II and class III antigens. It appears that the class III antigen disease associations can be explained by a direct defect operating at the level of either the class III gene or its gene product. The mechanism underlying class I and class II antigen disease associations is at present unknown. In this review we have considered thirty diseases which have been ranked according to their relative risk as defined by the frequency of a given HLA antigen in patient and control populations. The chronic inflammatory disorder, ankylosing spondylitis and its association with HLA B27 has been used as a model to study the HLA linked diseases. We have suggested that the disease may be caused by the Gram-negative microorganism Klebsiella which has antigenic similarity to HLA B27. It is proposed that some antibodies made against Klebsiella bind to HLA B27, thereby acting as autoantibodies leading to the pathological sequelae of chronic inflammatory arthritis. This is the crosstolerance hypothesis or molecular mimicry model and it has been compared to the receptor model. It is further suggested that the crosstolerance hypothesis can be utilised as a general theory to explain the association of other diseases with the class I and class II antigens, and offer a possible explanation for the polymorphism of HLA.

Complement system protein C4 and susceptibility to hydralazine-induced systemic lupus erythematosus

21 patients with systemic lupus erythematosus induced by long-term treatment with hydralazine were investigated to see whether susceptibility to this syndrome was associated with deficiency of the classical pathway complement protein, C4. 16 of 21 (76%) patients had one or more C4 null (ie, non-productive) alleles compared with 35 of 82 normal subjects (43%). This difference was significant. The HLA-DR4 antigen, known to be in linkage disequilibrium with the C4B null allele, was also significantly more frequent in the patients (14 of 21 patients compared with 31 of 81 normal subjects). Susceptibility to hydralazine-induced lupus, as in idiopathic systemic lupus erythematosus, may depend partly upon genetically determined C4 levels.

Immunogenetics of SLE and primary Sjögren's syndrome

SLE is a syndrome defined by clinical criteria and by the presence of autoantibodies reactive with nucleic acids and proteins concerned with transcription and translation. Breeding experiments in mice have illustrated the enormous genetic heterogeneity of this syndrome, of which the final common pathway is a widespread immune complex disease. The causes of SLE in humans are likely to be equally multifactorial. Family studies have demonstrated that genetic factors exist, but each factor appears to be a relatively weak disease-susceptibility gene. The major exceptions to this are the very rare complete deficiencies of classical pathway complement components, which are almost invariably accompanied by the development of SLE. Observations of these patients have led to the formulation of hypotheses relating complement and its receptor, CR1, to the defective removal of immune complexes from the circulation.

Association of antibody to histone complex H2A-H2B with symptomatic procainamide-induced lupus

Antinuclear antibodies develop in most patients who are given prolonged procainamide therapy, but clinical symptoms resembling those of lupus appear in only 15 to 20 percent of such persons. No objective marker for symptomatic procainamide-induced lupus has been described. However, IgG antibodies to the histone complex H2A-H2B have previously been reported in this disorder, and it has been suggested that antiguanosine antibodies may be a marker for major manifestations of procainamide-induced lupus. We therefore tested for these antibodies in 20 symptomatic and 31 asymptomatic patients treated with procainamide. Most of the symptomatic patients had multiple manifestations of drug-induced lupus; resolution of symptoms after the discontinuation of procainamide was required for inclusion in the symptomatic group. All 20 symptomatic patients had elevated IgG antibodies to H2A-H2B, in contrast to only 2 asymptomatic patients (P less than 0.001). This activity was absent in patients not treated with procainamide and in patients with lupus induced by hydralazine or quinidine. IgG antiguanosine was elevated as compared with normal controls in 13 of 20 symptomatic and 19 of 31 asymptomatic patients--a finding that did not distinguish between symptomatic and asymptomatic patients. We conclude that IgG antibodies to H2A-H2B are a sensitive and specific marker for procainamide-induced lupus. The striking correlation between antibodies to H2A-H2B and symptomatic disease suggests a possible association between this antibody and the underlying pathogenic events.

HLA-DR4 and Gm 1;21 haplotypes are associated with pseudolupus induced by venopyronum dragées

The phenotypic frequencies of human major histocompatibility complex class I, II, and III antigens and immunoglobulin allotypes (Gm factors) were determined in 56 patients (55 women, 1 man) who had lupus-like disease induced by venopyronum dragées. The findings in these patients were compared with those of a control group. We found a significant increase of HLA-DR4 (57.1% versus 26.5%, relative risk [RR] 3.7) and a decrease of HLA-DR3 (3.6% versus 19.1%, RR 0.16) in the patient group. In addition, the haplotype Gm 1;21 (60.7% versus 32.9%, RR 3.2), and the phenotype Gm 1,3;5,21 (46.4% versus 25.8%, RR 2.5) were significantly increased. Both the haplotype Gm 1;21 and the phenotype Gm 1,3;5,21 are associated with HLA-DR4 in pseudolupus patients but not in controls. The coincidence of HLA-DR4 and Gm 1;21 markedly increases the risk of acquiring pseudolupus (RR 6.9). We conclude that the pathogenesis of pseudolupus is influenced by at least 2 independent genetic factors. A similar HLA association has been described in hydralazine-induced lupus, and this suggests a common pathogenic mechanism.

Hydralazine binds covalently to complement component C4. Different reactivity of C4A and C4B gene products

Long-term treatment with hydralazine is sometimes associated with deposition of immune complexes and development of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) as an adverse side-effect. Hydralazine inhibits the covalent binding reaction of the complement protein C4. We show that when hydralazine inhibits C4, it becomes covalently bound to the polypeptide chain containing the active site thiol ester. C4 is encoded at 2 adjacent polymorphic loci, C4A and C4B, within the major histocompatibility complex. We show that hydralazine binds more efficiently to the C4A than to the C4B gene product and suggest that C4 type may predispose patients to hydralazine-induced SLE.