The embryogenesis of rod photoreceptors in the teleost fish retina, Haplochromis burtoni

Nrl Is Dispensable for Specification of Rod Photoreceptors in Adult Zebrafish Despite Its Deeply Conserved Requirement Earlier in Ontogeny

The transcription factor NRL (neural retina leucine zipper) has been canonized as the master regulator of photoreceptor cell fate in the retina. NRL is necessary and sufficient to specify rod cell fate and to preclude cone cell fate in mice. By engineering zebrafish, we tested if NRL function has conserved roles beyond mammals or beyond nocturnal species, i.e., in a vertebrate possessing a greater and more typical diversity of cone sub-types. Transgenic expression of Nrl from zebrafish or mouse was sufficient to induce rod photoreceptor cells. Zebrafish nrl^−/− mutants lacked rods (and had excess UV-sensitive cones) as young larvae; thus, the conservation of Nrl function between mice and zebrafish appears sound. Strikingly, however, rods were abundant in adult nrl^−/− null mutant zebrafish. Rods developed in adults despite Nrl protein being undetectable. Therefore, a yet-to-be-revealed non-canonical pathway independent of Nrl is able to specify the fate of some rod photoreceptors.

•

Nrl is conserved and sufficient to specify rod photoreceptors in the zebrafish retina

•

Nrl is necessary for rod photoreceptors in early ontogeny of zebrafish larvae

•

Zebrafish Nrl is functionally conserved with mouse and human NRL

•

Remarkably, Nrl is dispensable for rod specification in adult zebrafish

Retinal histogenesis and cell differentiation in an elasmobranch species, the small-spotted catshark Scyliorhinus canicula

Here we present a detailed study of the major events in the retinal histogenesis in a slow-developing elasmobranch species, the small-spotted catshark, during embryonic, postnatal and adult stages using classical histological and immunohistological methods, providing a complete neurochemical characterization of retinal cells. We found that the retina of the small-spotted catshark was fully differentiated prior to birth. The major developmental events in retinal cell differentiation occurred during the second third of the embryonic period. Maturational features described in the present study were first detected in the central retina and, as development progressed, they spread to the rest of the retina following a central-to-peripheral gradient. While the formation of both plexiform layers occurs simultaneously in the retina of the most common fish models, in the small-spotted catshark retina the emergence of the outer plexiform layer was delayed with respect to the inner plexiform layer. According to the expression of the markers used, retinal cell differentiation followed a vitreal-to-scleral gradient, with the exception of Müller cells that were the last cell type generated during retinogenesis. This vitreal-to-scleral progression of neural differentiation seems to be specific to slow-developing fish species.

Cellular expression of midkine-a and midkine-b during retinal development and photoreceptor regeneration in zebrafish

In the retina of adult teleosts, stem cells are sustained in two specialized niches: the ciliary marginal zone (CMZ) and the microenvironment surrounding adult Müller glia. Recently, Müller glia were identified as the regenerative stem cells in the teleost retina. Secreted signaling molecules that regulate neuronal regeneration in the retina are largely unknown. In a microarray screen to discover such factors, we identified midkine-b (mdkb). Midkine is a highly conserved heparin-binding growth factor with numerous biological functions. The zebrafish genome encodes two distinct midkine genes: mdka and mdkb. Here we describe the cellular expression of mdka and mdkb during retinal development and the initial, proliferative phase of photoreceptor regeneration. The results show that in the embryonic and larval retina mdka and mdkb are expressed in stem cells, retinal progenitors, and neurons in distinct patterns that suggest different functions for the two molecules. Following the selective death of photoreceptors in the adult, mdka and mdkb are coexpressed in horizontal cells and proliferating Müller glia and their neurogenic progeny. These data reveal that Mdka and Mdkb are signaling factors present in the retinal stem cell niches in both embryonic and mature retinas, and that their cellular expression is actively modulated during retinal development and regeneration.

Early development of GABAergic cells of the retina in sharks: an immunohistochemical study with GABA and GAD antibodies

We studied the ontogeny and organization of GABAergic cells in the retina of two elasmobranches, the lesser-spotted dogfish (Scyliorhinus canicula) and the brown shyshark (Haploblepharus fuscus) by using immunohistochemistry for gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) and glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD). Both antibodies revealed the same pattern of immunoreactivity and both species showed similar organization of GABAergic cells. GABAergic cells were first detected in neural retina of embryos at stage 26, which showed a neuroepithelial appearance without any layering. In stages 27-29 the retina showed similar organization but the number of neuroblastic GABAergic cells increased. When layering became apparent in the central retina (stage-30 embryos), GABAergic cells mainly appeared organized in the outer and inner retina, and GABAergic processes and fibres were seen in the primordial inner plexiform layer (IPL), optic fibre layer and optic nerve stalk. In stage-32 embryos, layering was completed in the central retina, where immunoreactivity appeared in perikarya of the horizontal cell layer, inner nuclear layer and ganglion cell layer, and in numerous processes coursing in the IPL, optic fibre layer and optic nerve. From stage 32 to hatching (stage 34), the layered retina extends from centre-to-periphery, recapitulating that observed in the central retina at earlier stages. In adults, GABA/GAD immunoreactivity disappears from the horizontal cell layer except in the marginal retina. Our results indicate that the source of GABA in the shark retina can be explained by its synthesis by GAD. Such synthesis precedes layering and synaptogenesis, thus supporting a developmental role for GABA in addition to act as neurotransmitter and neuromodulator.

The teleost retina as a model for developmental and regeneration biology

Retinal development in teleosts can broadly be divided into three epochs. The first is the specification of cellular domains in the larval forebrain that give rise to the retinal primordia and undergo early morphogenetic movements. The second is the neurogenic events within the retina proper-proliferation, cell fate determination, and pattern formation-that establish neuronal identities and form retinal laminae and cellular mosaics. The third, which is unique to teleosts and occurs in the functioning eye, is stretching of the retina and persistent neurogenesis that allows the growth of the retina to keep pace with the growth of the eye and other tissues. The first two events are rapid, complete by about 3 days postfertilization in the zebrafish embryo. The third is life-long and accounts for the bulk of retinal growth and the vast majority of adult retinal neurons. In addition, but clearly related to the retina's developmental history, lesions that kill retinal neurons elicit robust neuronal regeneration that originates from cells intrinsic to the retina. This paper reviews recent studies of retinal development in teleosts, focusing on those that shed light on the genetic and molecular regulation of retinal specification and morphogenesis in the embryo, retinal neurogenesis in larvae and adults, and injury-induced neuronal regeneration.

Annotation of expressed sequence tags for the East African cichlid fish Astatotilapia burtoni and evolutionary analyses of cichlid ORFs

Background

The cichlid fishes in general, and the exceptionally diverse East African haplochromine cichlids in particular, are famous examples of adaptive radiation and explosive speciation. Here we report the collection and annotation of more than 12,000 expressed sequence tags (ESTs) generated from three different cDNA libraries obtained from the East African haplochromine cichlid species Astatotilapia burtoni and Metriaclima zebra.

Results

We first annotated more than 12,000 newly generated cichlid ESTs using the Gene Ontology classification system. For evolutionary analyses, we combined these ESTs with all available sequence data for haplochromine cichlids, which resulted in a total of more than 45,000 ESTs. The ESTs represent a broad range of molecular functions and biological processes. We compared the haplochromine ESTs to sequence data from those available for other fish model systems such as pufferfish (Takifugu rubripes and Tetraodon nigroviridis), trout, and zebrafish. We characterized genes that show a faster or slower rate of base substitutions in haplochromine cichlids compared to other fish species, as this is indicative of a relaxed or reinforced selection regime. Four of these genes showed the signature of positive selection as revealed by calculating K_a/K_s ratios.

Conclusion

About 22% of the surveyed ESTs were found to have cichlid specific rate differences suggesting that these genes might play a role in lineage specific characteristics of cichlids. We also conclude that the four genes with a K_a/K_s ratio greater than one appear as good candidate genes for further work on the genetic basis of evolutionary success of haplochromine cichlid fishes.

Morphogenesis in the retina of a slow-developing teleost: emergence of the GABAergic system in relation to cell proliferation and differentiation

Gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) has been implicated in cell proliferation and differentiation during development. In the present study, immunohistochemical techniques were used to investigate the development of the GABAergic system in the retina of the trout and its relation to markers of differentiation [calretinin (CR), and tyrosine hydroxylase (TH)]. The expression of Pax6, an eye-patterning protein involved in the proliferation and emergence of specific retinal cell types, was also studied. Retinal layering was observed to begin centrally in prehatching embryos, as the first GABAergic cells appeared in the ganglion cell layer (GCL) and inner part of the inner nuclear layer (INL). At hatching, GABAergic cells were also observed in the horizontal cell layer (HCL). In alevins, GABAergic cells and processes spread laterally following retinal growth although they did not invade neuroblastic retinal regions. CR- and Pax6-immunoreactive (ir) cells were first seen in the GCL and the inner part of the INL, whereas sparse TH-ir cells appeared in the INL. In juveniles, GABAergic cells were observed in the GCL, inner part of the INL and HCL, whereas CR-ir cells spread to the outer part of the INL and HCL. A subset of CR-ir in the GCL and of Pax6-ir cells in the GCL and INL showed colocalization with GABAergic markers. This study provides further comparative knowledge about the development of GABAergic system of the retina in teleosts and shows differences and similarities with that reported in fast-developing species such as zebrafish, in which retinal expression of GABA was transient in some populations.

IGF-1 produced by cone photoreceptors regulates rod progenitor proliferation in the teleost retina

Teleost eyes grow throughout life by adding neurons and stretching extant tissue. New retinal neurons of all types are added at the ciliary margin and new rod photoreceptors are inserted throughout retina in the outer nuclear layer (ONL). New rod photoreceptors result from the division of progenitor cells located in the ONL amidst functioning rod photoreceptor cell nuclei, but it is not known how new rod addition is regulated. Previous experiments using an organotypic retinal slice preparation revealed that insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1) up-regulates the division of the rod progenitor cells [Dev. Brain Res. 76 (1993) 183], but the site of IGF-1 action was unknown. Here, we show where in the retina IGF-1 is made, where IGF receptors are located, and we identify the role of IGF-1 in adult retinal rod neurogenesis with both gain-and loss-of-function experiments. We found that IGF-1 is expressed by cone photoreceptor cells and its abundance varies with a daily rhythm, being significantly higher at night. In vivo application of exogenous IGF-1 increases rod progenitor cell division, an effect that is greater at night than during the day. We also show that inhibiting the function of IGF receptors decreases proliferation of rod progenitor cells. Finally, we show that IGF receptors are located on rod progenitor cells as well as on cone and rod photoreceptors. Taken together, these data suggest that the rhythmic production and release of IGF-1 plays a role in regulating the insertion of new rod photoreceptors into the retina. The diurnal change in IGF-1 abundance and effects of exogenous IGF-1 are consistent with the previous demonstration that rod progenitor cell division is threefold greater at night than in the day [Brain Res. 673 (1995) 119; Brain Res. 712 (1996) 40]. We also show that the insertion of new rod photoreceptors at the central edge of the ciliary neurogenic zone very likely also depends on IGF-1 production by cone photoreceptors. We propose that addition of new rod photoreceptors into the functioning retina is regulated through a feedback mechanism mediated at least in part via the IGF-1 produced in the cone photoreceptors.

Investigation of the migration path for new rod photoreceptors in the adult cichlid fish retina

In the retina of adult teleost, precursor cells divide in the outer nuclear layer and give rise to new rod photoreceptors. These new rods migrate from the outer limiting membrane to the inner edge of the outer nuclear layer (ONL) before differentiating. In order to understand which cues these cells use during migration and insertion at the appropriate location we combined cell-specific stains in the retina of the cichlid fish Haplochromis burtoni, viewed with confocal laserscan microscopy: Dividing cells were labeled with bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU), Müller glial cells, cone photoreceptors, and horizontal cells were detected by specific antibodies. During the migration phase (24 to 48 h after BrdU uptake) up to 46% of BrdU-labeled cells were spindle shaped and radially oriented. Most of them were in direct proximity to Müller cell processes. Four days after BrdU-uptake, most labeled cells (91%) were found in the inner portion of the ONL and displayed a spherical shape. This marks the end of the movement of the new rods. At this stage, the labeled cells showed no preference to lie near glial fibers but were often found close to the pedicles of double cones. The leading edge of migrating cells reached into the outer plexiform layer (OPL) but not further than processes of horizontal cells. This is beyond the location of mature rods. We hypothesize that the cells are repelled in the OPL and insert back in the ONL to differentiate as rods.

Development of a rod photoreceptor mosaic revealed in transgenic zebrafish

The number and distribution of neurons within the vertebrate retina are tightly regulated. This is particularly apparent in the highly ordered, crystalline-like arrangement of the cone photoreceptors in the teleost. In this report, using a transgenic line of zebrafish, a novel and developmentally regulated mosaic pattern of the rod photoreceptors is described. The spatial and temporal expression of EGFP, under the control of the Xenopus rhodopsin gene promoter, was nearly identical to the endogenous rhodopsin. EGFP was first detected in the ventral nasal retinal in an area of precocious neurogenesis referred to as the "ventral patch". Subsequent expression of EGFP was observed in isolated cells sporadically distributed across the dorsal and central retina. However, confocal microscopy and spatial analysis of larval eyes or retinal explants from adults revealed a precise arrangement to the rod photoreceptors. The rod terminals were arranged in regularly spaced rows with clearly identifiable telodendria linking neighboring cells. The rod inner segments projected through the cone mosaic in a predictable pattern. In the adult, the rod mosaic originated near the retinal margin where clusters of rods differentiated around the immature short single cone. In the embryo, the sporadic differentiation of the rods led to the gradual formation of the mosaic pattern. With the growing interest in neuronal stem cells, revisiting this model of neurogenesis provides an avenue to uncover mechanisms underlying the precise integration of new neuronal elements into a preexisting neural network.

Stem cells in the teleost retina: persistent neurogenesis and injury-induced regeneration

The retina of the adult teleost fish is an important model for studying persistent and injury-induced neurogenesis in the vertebrate central nervous system. All neurons, with the exception of rod photoreceptors, are continually appended to the extant retina from an annulus of progenitors at the margin. Rod photoreceptors, in contrast, are added to differentiated retina only from a lineage of progenitors dedicated to making rods. Further, when the retina is lesioned, the lineage that produces only rods ceases this activity and regenerates retinal neurons of all types. The progenitors that supply neurons at the retinal margin and rod photoreceptors and regenerated neurons in the mature tissue originate from multipotent stem cells. Recent data suggest that the growth-associated neurogenic activity in the retina is regulated as part of the growth hormone/insulin-like growth factor-I axis. This paper reviews recent evidence for the presence of stem cells in the teleost retina and the molecular regulation of neurogenesis and presents a consensus cellular model that describes persistent and injury-induced neurogenesis in the retinas of teleost fish.

Early development of the retina and pineal complex in the sea lamprey: comparative immunocytochemical study

Lampreys have a complex life cycle, with largely differentiated larval and adult periods. Despite the considerable interest of lampreys for understanding vertebrate evolution, knowledge of the early development of their eye and pineal complex is very scarce. Here, the early immunocytochemical organization of the pineal complex and retina of the sea lamprey was studied by use of antibodies against proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA), opsin, serotonin, and gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA). Cell differentiation in the retina, pineal organ, and habenula begins in prolarvae, as shown by the appearance of PCNA-negative cells, whereas differentiation of the parapineal vesicle was delayed until the larval period. In medium-sized to large larvae, PCNA-immunoreactive (-ir) cells were numerous in regions of the lateral retina near the differentiated part of the larval retina (central retina). A late-proliferating region was observed in the right habenula. Opsin immunoreactivity appears in the pineal vesicle of early prolarvae and 3 or 4 days later in the retina. In the parapineal organ, opsin immunoreactivity was observed only in large larvae. In the pineal organ, serotonin immunoreactivity was first observed in late prolarvae in photoreceptive (photoneuroendocrine) cells, whereas only a few of these cells appeared in the parapineal organ of large larvae. No serotonin immunoreactivity was observed in the larval retina. GABA immunoreactivity appeared earlier in the retina than in the pineal complex. No GABA-ir perikaryon was observed in the retina of larval lampreys, although a few GABA-ir centrifugal fibers innervate the inner retina in late prolarvae. First GABA-ir ganglion cells occur in the pineal organ of 15-17 mm larvae, and their number increases during the larval period. The only GABA-ir structures observed in the parapineal ganglion of larvae were afferent fibers, which appeared rather late in development. The time sequence of development in these photoreceptive structures is rather different from that observed in teleosts and other vertebrates. This suggests that the unusual development of the three photoreceptive organs in lampreys reflects specialization for their different functions during the larval and adult periods.

The development of NADPH-diaphorase and nitric oxide synthase in the visual system of the cichlid fish, Tilapia mariae

The pattern of NADPH-diaphorase expression was studied in the retina and optic tectum of the cichlid fish Tilapia mariae during the first developmental stages. NADPH-diaphorase activity was seen early, at hatching. In the retina a few cell bodies of the retinal inner nuclear layer showed a faint labeling. Scattered labeled cells were found in the stratum periventriculare of the optic tectum, while the optic nerve was unlabeled. Two days after hatching, the number of labeled neurons increased in the inner nuclear layer and a few stained cell bodies were also scattered in the ganglion cell layer. Both the inner and outer plexiform layers showed a diffuse staining and the optic nerve was devoid of labeling. In the optic tectum several positive cells in the periventricular layer, with their dendritic trees extending in the superficial fibrous layer, were found. In 1-month-old Tilapia, NADPH-diaphorase staining and nitric oxide synthase immunoreactivity were found to overlap in both the retina and optic tectum. The density of NADPH-diaphorase labeled neurons in the inner nuclear layer of the retina and in the stratum periventriculare of the optic tectum was largely reduced in comparison with 2 days posthatching embryos. These findings indicated an early and transient production of nitric oxide in the retina and optic tectum of Tilapia, suggesting a functional role for nitric oxide in the development of visual structures in aquatic vertebrates.

Nasotemporal asymmetry during teleost retinal growth: preserving an area of specialization

Teleost fish retinas grow throughout adult life through both cell addition and stretching. Cell division occurs at the periphery of the retina, resulting in annular addition of all cell types except rod photoreceptors, which are added in the central retina. Since many teleosts have a region of high cellular density at the temporal pole of the eye, we analyzed whether and how this specialized region of high visual acuity maintained its relative topographical position through asymmetric circumferential growth. To do this, we measured the pattern of long-term retinal growth in the African cichlid Haplochromis burtoni. We found that the retina expands asymmetrically along the nasotemporal axis, with the nasal retina growing at a higher rate than the temporal, dorsal, or ventral retinae, whose growth rates are equal. This nasotemporal asymmetry is produced via significantly greater expansion of retinal tissue at the nasal pole rather than through differential cell proliferation. The mechanisms responsible for this differential retinal enlargement are unknown; however, such asymmetric expansion very likely minimizes disruption in vision during rapid growth.