Exposing culprit organic pollutants: a review

Current status of water environment and their microbial biosensor techniques - Part II: Recent trends in microbial biosensor development

In Part I of the present review series, I presented the current state of the water environment by focusing on Japanese cases and discussed the need to further develop microbial biosensor technologies for the actual water environment. I comprehensively present trends after approximately 2010 in microbial biosensor development for the water environment. In the first section, after briefly summarizing historical studies, recent studies on microbial biosensor principles are introduced. In the second section, recent application studies for the water environment are also introduced. Finally, I conclude the present review series by describing the need to further develop microbial biosensor technologies. Graphical abstract Current water pollution indirectly occurs by anthropogenic eutrophication (Part I). Recent trends in microbial biosensor development for water environment are described in part II of the present review series.

Construction and application of an Escherichia coli bioreporter for aniline and chloroaniline detection

Aniline and chlorinated anilines (CAs) are classified as priority pollutants; therefore, an effective method for detection and monitoring is required. In this study, a green-fluorescence protein-based bioreporter for the detection of aniline and CAs was constructed in Escherichia coli DH5α, characterized and tested with soil and wastewater. The sensing capability relied on the regulatory control between a two-component regulatory protein, TodS/TodT, and the P( todX ) promoter of Pseudomonas putida T-57 (PpT57), since the gene expression of todS, todT, and todC2 are positively induced with 4-chloroaniline. The bioreporter system (DH5α/pPXGFP-pTODST) is markedly unique with the two co-existing plasmids. The inducibility of the fluorescence response was culture-medium- and time-dependent. Cells grown in M9G medium exhibited a low background fluorescence level and were readily induced by 4CA after 3-h exposure, reaching the maximum induction level at 9 h. When tested with benzene, toluene, ethyl-benzene and xylene, aniline and CAs, the response data were best fit by a sigmoidal dose-response relationship, from which the K(½) value was determined for the positive effectors. 3CA and 4CA were relatively powerful inducers, while some poly-chlorinated anilines could also induce green fluorescence protein expression. The results indicated a broader recognition range of PpT57'sTodST than previously reported for P. putida. The test results with environmental samples were reliable, indicating the potential application of this bioreporter in the ecotoxicology assessment and bioremediation of areas contaminated with aniline- and/or CAs.

Are luminescent bacteria suitable for online detection and monitoring of toxic compounds in drinking water and its sources?

Biosensors based on luminescent bacteria may be valuable tools to monitor the chemical quality and safety of surface and drinking water. In this review, an overview is presented of the recombinant strains available that harbour the bacterial luciferase genes luxCDABE, and which may be used in an online biosensor for water quality monitoring. Many bacterial strains have been described for the detection of a broad range of toxicity parameters, including DNA damage, protein damage, membrane damage, oxidative stress, organic pollutants, and heavy metals. Most lux strains have sensitivities with detection limits ranging from milligrams per litre to micrograms per litre, usually with higher sensitivities in compound-specific strains. Although the sensitivity of lux strains can be enhanced by various molecular manipulations, most reported detection thresholds are still too high to detect levels of individual contaminants as they occur nowadays in European drinking waters. However, lux strains sensing specific toxic effects have the advantage of being able to respond to mixtures of contaminants inducing the same effect, and thus could be used as a sensor for the sum effect, including the effect of compounds that are as yet not identified by chemical analysis. An evaluation of the suitability of lux strains for monitoring surface and drinking water is therefore provided.

Escherichia coli as a bioreporter in ecotoxicology

Ecotoxicological assessment relies to a large extent on the information gathered with surrogate species and the extrapolation of test results across species and different levels of biological organisation. Bacteria have long been used as a bioreporter for genotoxic testing and general toxicity. Today, it is clear that bacteria have the potential for screening of other toxicological endpoints. Escherichia coli has been studied for years; in-depth knowledge of its biochemistry and genetics makes it the most proficient prokaryote for the development of new toxicological assays. Several assays have been designed with E. coli as a bioreporter, and the recent trend to develop novel, better advanced reporters makes bioreporter development one of the most dynamic in ecotoxicology. Based on in-depth knowledge of E. coli, new assays are being developed or existing ones redesigned, thanks to the availability of new reporter genes and new or improved substrates. The technological evolution towards easier and more sensitive detection of different gene products is another important aspect. Often, this requires the redesign of the bacterium to make it compatible with the novel measuring tests. Recent advances in surface chemistry and nanoelectronics open the perspective for advanced reporter based on novel measuring platforms and with an online potential. In this article, we will discuss the use of E. coli-based bioreporters in ecotoxicological applications as well as some innovative sensors awaited for the future.

Advances in molecular and "-omics" technologies to gauge microbial communities and bioremediation at xenobiotic/anthropogen contaminated sites

Microbial bioremediation has been well-demonstrated as an ecofriendly and cost-competitive strategy for elimination of xenobiotic and or anthropogenic compounds from the polluted environments. However, successful execution of these versatile bioremediation strategies requires a thorough understanding of factors governing the growth, metabolism, dynamics and functions of indigenous microbial communities at contaminated sites. Recent innovative breakthroughs in genotypic profiling, ultrafast genome pyrosequencing, metagenomics, metatranscriptomics, metaproteomics and metabolomics along with bioinformatics tools have provided crucial in-sights of microbial communities and their mechanisms in bioremediation of environmental pollutants. Moreover, advances in these technologies have significantly improved the process of efficacy determination and implementation of microbial bioremediation strategies. The current review is focused on application of these molecular and "-omics" technologies in gauging the innate microbial community structures, dynamics and functions at contaminated sites or pollution containment facilities.

Improving the sensitivity of bacterial bioreporters for heavy metals

Whole-cell bacterial bioreporters represent a convenient testing method for quantifying the bioavailability of contaminants in environmental samples. Despite the fact that several bioreporters have been constructed for measuring heavy metals, their application to environmental samples has remained minimal. The major drawbacks of the available bioreporters include a lack of sensitivity and specificity. Here, we report an improvement in the limit of detection of bacterial bioreporters by interfering with the natural metal homeostasis system of the host bacterium. The limit of detection of a Pseudomonas putida KT2440-based Zn/Cd/Pb-biosensor was improved by a factor of up to 45 by disrupting four main efflux transporters for Zn/Cd/Pb and thereby causing the metals to accumulate in the cell. The specificity of the bioreporter could be modified by changing the sensor element. A Zn-specific bioreporter was achieved by using the promoter of the cadA1 gene from P. putida as a sensor element. The constructed transporter-deficient P. putida reporter strain detected Zn(2+) concentrations about 50 times lower than that possible with other available Zn-bioreporters. The achieved detection limits were significantly below the permitted limit values for Zn and Pb in water and in soil, allowing for reliable detection of heavy metals in the environment.

Bacterial biosensors for rapid and effective monitoring of biodegradation of organic pollutants in wastewater effluents

Significant amounts of toxic substances which are hazardous to animals, plants, microorganisms, and other living organisms including humans are released annually into aquatic and terrestrial environments, mostly from improper wastewater discharges. Early detection of such pollutants in wastewater effluents and proper monitoring before their final release into the environment is therefore necessary. In this study, two whole-cell bacterial biosensors were constructed by transforming competent cells of Shigella flexneri and Shigella sonnei with pLUX plasmids and evaluated for their potential to monitor wastewater samples undergoing degradation by measuring bioluminescence response using a microplate luminometer. Both bacterial biosensors were found to be extremely sensitive to the wastewater samples, with different patterns, concomitant with those of the COD removals demonstrated at the different days of the degradation. Generally higher bioluminescence values were obtained at the later days of the degradation period compared to the initial values, with up to 571.76% increase in bioluminescence value obtained at day 5 for 0.1% (v/v) effluent concentration. Also, a steady decrease in bioluminescence was observed for the bacterial biosensors with increasing time of exposure to the wastewater effluent for all the sampling days. These biosensor constructs could therefore be applicable to indicate the bioavailability of pollutants in a way that chemical analysis cannot, and for in situ monitoring of biodegradation. This has great potential to offer a risk assessment strategy in predicting the level of bioremediation required during municipal wastewater treatment before their final discharge into the aquatic milieu.

Use of a whole-cell biosensor to assess the bioavailability enhancement of aromatic hydrocarbon compounds by nonionic surfactants

The whole-cell bioluminescent biosensor Pseudomonas putida F1G4 (PpF1G4), which contains a chromosomally-based sep-lux transcriptional fusion, was used as a tool for direct measurement of the bioavailability of hydrophobic organic compounds (HOCs) partitioned into surfactant micelles. The increased bioluminescent response of PpF1G4 in micellar solutions (up to 10 times the critical micellar concentration) of Triton X-100 and Brij 35 indicated higher intracellular concentrations of the test compounds, toluene, naphthalene, and phenanthrene, compared to control systems with no surfactants present. In contrast, Brij 30 caused a decrease in the bioluminescent response to the test compounds in single-solute systems, without adversely affecting cell growth. The decrease in bioluminescent response in the presence of Brij 30 did not occur in the presence of multiple HOCs extracted into the surfactant solutions from crude oil and creosote. The effect of the micellar solutions on the toluene biodegradation rate was consistent with the bioluminescent response in single-solute systems. None of the surfactants were toxic to PpF1G4 at the doses employed in this study, and PpF1G4 did not produce a bioluminescent response to the surfactants nor utilize them as growth substrates. TEM images suggest that the surfactants did not rupture the cell membranes. The results demonstrate that for Pseudomonas putida F1, nonionic surfactants such as Triton X-100 and Brij 35, at doses between 2 and 10 CMC, may increase the bioavailability and direct uptake of micellar phase HOCs that are common pollutants at contaminated sites.

Application of luminescent biosensors for monitoring the degradation and toxicity of BTEX compounds in soils

AIMS

To assess the changes in acute toxicity and biodegradation of benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene and xylene (collectively referred to as BTEX) compounds in soil over time and compare the performances of biological and chemical techniques.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Biological methods (lux-based bacterial biosensors, basal respiration and dehydrogenase activity) were related to changes in the concentration of the target compounds. There was an initial increase in toxicity determined by the constitutively expressed biosensor, followed by a continual reduction as degradation proceeded. The biosensor with the BTEX-specific promoter was most induced when BTEX concentrations were highest. The treatment with nutrient amendment had a significant increase in microbial activity, while the sterile control produced the lowest level of degradation.

SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY

Luminescent biosensors were able to monitor changes in contaminant toxicity and bioavailability in aqueous extracts from BTEX-impacted soils as degradation proceeded. The integration of biological tests with chemical analysis enables a fuller understanding of the biodegradation processes occurring at their relative rates.

CONCLUSIONS

The biological methods were successfully used in assessing the performance of different treatments for enhancing natural attenuation of BTEX from contaminated soils. While, chemical analysis showed biodegradation of parent BTEX compounds in biologically active soils, the biosensor assays reported on changes in bioavailability and potentially toxic intermediate fractions as they estimated the integrative effect of contaminants.

Advantages and limitations of on-line solid phase extraction coupled to liquid chromatography–mass spectrometry technologies versus biosensors for monitoring of emerging contaminants in water

On-line solid phase extraction (SPE) coupled to liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS) and biosensors are advanced technologies that have found increasing application in the analysis of environmental contaminants although their application to the determination of emerging contaminants (previously unknown or unrecognized pollutants) has been still limited. This review covers the most recent advances occurred in the areas of on-line SPE-LC-MS and biosensors, discusses and compares the main strengths and limitations of the two approaches, and examines their most relevant applications to the analysis of emerging contaminants in environmental waters. So far, the on-line configuration most frequently used has been SPE coupled to liquid chromatography-(tandem) mass spectrometry. Sorbents used for on-line SPE have included both traditional (alkyl-bonded silicas and polymers) and novel (restricted access materials (RAMs), molecularly imprinted synthetic polymers (MIPs), and immobilized receptors or antibodies (immunosorbents) materials. The biosensor technologies most frequently applied have been based on the use of antibodies and, to a lesser extent, enzymes, bacteria, receptors and DNA as recognition elements, and the use of optical and electrochemical transducing elements. Emerging contaminants investigated by means of these two techniques have included pharmaceuticals, endocrine disrupting compounds such as estrogens, alkylphenols and bisphenol A, pesticides transformation products, disinfection by-products, and bacterial toxins and mycotoxins, among others. Both techniques offer advantageous, and frequently comparable, features such as high sensitivity and selectivity, minimum sample manipulation, and automation. Biosensors are, in addition, relatively cheap and fast, which make them ideally suited for routine testing and screening of samples; however, in most cases, they can not compete yet with on-line SPE procedures in terms of accuracy, reproducibility, reliability (confirmation) of results, and capacity for multi-analyte determination.

A preliminary investigation into the use of biosensors to screen stomach contents for selected poisons and drugs

The bioluminescence response of two genetically modified (lux-marked) bacteria to potentially toxic compounds (PTCs) in stomach contents was monitored using an in vitro assay. Cells of Escherichia coli HB101 and Salmonella typhimurium both carrying the lux light producing gene on a plasmid (pUDC607) were added to stomach contents containing various concentrations of organic and inorganic compounds. There was some variability in the response of the two biosensors, but both were sensitive to the herbicides glyphosate, 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D), 2,4,5-trichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4,5-T); pentachlorophenol (PCP), and inorganic poisons arsenic and mercury at a concentration range likely to be found in stomach contents samples submitted for toxicological analysis. This study demonstrates that biosensor bioassays could be a useful preliminary screening tool in forensic toxicology and that such a toxicological screening should include more than one test organism to maximise the number of PTC's detected. The probability of false positive results from samples containing compounds that may interfere with the assay such as over-the-counter (OTC) drugs and caffeine in tea and coffee was also investigated. Of the substances tested only coffee has the potential to cause false positive results.

Use of protoplasts from paired heterogenic bacterial species to detect tin contaminants: Prospects for biosensor development

Two different bacteria gave different respiratory responses to the test analytes, tributyl tin (TBT) and cadmium as expressed by positive sigmoid responses by Halomonas sp. (slope, +1.71 [TBT]; +1.76 [Cd]) and negative sigmoid responses by Bacillus pumilis (slope, -1.06 [TBT]; -0.59 [Cd]). The EC50 values determined from Hill plots for the response of Halomonas sp. to the TBT and Cd were 1 and 8.5 mM, respectively, which were lower by a factor of 10 than the corresponding values for B. pumilis. With protoplasts of B. pumilis there was a major shift in the signal from sigmoid negative to positive with TBT (+1.35) but not Cd (-0.5), while the signals with the remaining protoplast-analyte combinations remained unchanged. For all four protoplast-analyte combinations the EC50 values were in the order of 10-100-fold lower than those for their whole cell counterparts. When other analytes were tested the protoplasts gave a similar response to tin as for TBT, but detected copper and 2,4-dichlorophenol with similar signal profiles to Cd and with lower sensitivity. The difference in signal and higher sensitivity of the two species protoplast system towards TBT/tin compared to the other analytes tested, suggests that it may feasible to develop this approach for the detection of tin residues.

A resazurin-based biosensor for organic pollutants

A new rapid biosensor method employing the dye resazurin as an indicator of bacterial respiration has been developed to provide a rapid, facile and specific biosensor for environmental contaminants that does not rely on genetic modification techniques, is suitable for a high-throughput multiwell format, and is ideally suited to resource-constrained environmental monitoring situations. This whole-cell biosensor has been applied to the test analyte toluene using natural toluene-degrading bacteria as the biological component and is competitive with more complex recombinant approaches. The redox-driven biosensor is dependent on the catabolism of a specific compound, concomitantly reducing the redox indicator resazurin to provide the analytical signal in a whole-cell biosensor assay.

Analysis of bioavailable phenols from natural samples by recombinant luminescent bacterial sensors

A whole-cell recombinant bacterial sensor for the detection of phenolic compounds was constructed and used for the analysis of bioavailable phenols in natural samples. The sensor Pseudomonas fluorescens OS8(pDNdmpRlux) contains luxCDABE operon as a reporter under the control of phenol-inducible Po promoter from Pseudomonas sp. CF600. Expression of lux genes from the Po promoter, and thus the production of bioluminescence is controlled by the transcriptional activator DmpR, which initiates transcription in the presence of phenolic compounds. To take into account possible quenching (turbidity, toxicity) and/or stimulating effects of the environmental samples on the bacterial luminescence, control bacteria comparable to the sensors but lacking the phenol recognising elements were constructed and used in parallel in assays. The sensor bacteria were inducible with phenol, methylphenols, 2,3-, 2,4-, 2,6- and 3,4-dimethylphenol, resorcinol and 5-methylresorcinol but not with 2,5-dimethylresorcinol. The detection limits for different phenols varied from 0.03 mg/l (2-methylphenol) to 42.7 mg/l (5-methylresorcinol), being 0.08 mg/l for phenol, the most abundant phenolic contaminant in the environment. Different phenolic compounds had an additive effect on the inducibility of the sensor. The constructed sensor bacteria were applied on groundwaters and semi-coke leachates to estimate the bioavailable fraction of phenols. The sensor-determined amount of phenols in different samples varied from 6% to 95% of total phenol content depending on the nature of the sample. As the phenol-recognising unit in the sensor originates from a natural phenol biodegradation pathway, the sensor-determined amount of phenols corresponds to the biodegradable amount of phenolic pollutants in the samples and therefore this sensor could be used to estimate the natural biodegradation potential of phenolic compounds in the complex environmental mixtures and matrixes.

Biosensors as useful tools for environmental analysis and monitoring

Recent advances in the development and application of biosensors for environmental analysis and monitoring are reviewed in this article. Several examples of biosensors developed for relevant environmental pollutants and parameters are briefly overviewed. Special attention is paid to the application of biosensors to real environmental samples, taking into consideration aspects such as sample pretreatment, matrix effects and validation of biosensor measurements. Current trends in biosensor development are also considered and commented on in this work. In this context, nanotechnology, miniaturisation, multi-sensor array development and, especially, biotechnology arise as fast-growing areas that will have a marked influence on the development of new biosensing strategies in the near future.

Whole-cell living biosensors—are they ready for environmental application?

Since the development of the first whole-cell living biosensor or bioreporter about 15 years ago, construction and testing of new genetically modified microorganisms for environmental sensing and reporting has proceeded at an ever increasing rate. One and a half decades appear as a reasonable time span for a new technology to reach the maturity needed for application and commercial success. It seems, however, that the research into cellular biosensors is still mostly in a proof-of-principle or demonstration phase and not close to extensive or commercial use outside of academia. In this review, we consider the motivations for bioreporter developments and discuss the suitability of extant bioreporters for the proposed applications to stimulate complementary research and to help researchers to develop realistic objectives. This includes the identification of some popular misconceptions about the qualities and shortcomings of bioreporters.

Linking bacteriophage infection to quorum sensing signalling and bioluminescent bioreporter monitoring for direct detection of bacterial agents

AIM

To incorporate into the lambda phage genome, a luxI-based acyl-homoserine lactone (AHL) synthase genetic construct and exploit the autoamplified power of quorum sensing to translate a phage infection event into a chemical signature detectable by a lux-based bioluminescent bioreporter, with focus towards facile detection of microbial pathogens.

METHODS AND RESULTS

The luxI gene from Vibrio fischeri was inserted into the lambda phage genome to construct a model phage-based biosensor system for the general detection of Escherichia coli. The AHL signalling molecules synthesized upon phage infection are detected by an AHL-specific bioluminescent bioreporter based on the luxCDABE gene cassette of V. fischeri. The assay generates target-specific visible light signals with no requisite addition of extraneous substrate. This binary reporter system was able to autonomously respond to lambda phage infection events at target E. coli concentrations ranging from 1 x 10(8) to 1 CFU ml(-1) within 1.5-10.3 h, respectively, in pure culture. When assayed against artificially contaminated lettuce leaf washings, detection within an E. coli inoculum range from 1 x 10(8) to 130 CFU ml(-1) was achieved within 2.6-22.4 h, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

The initial feasibility of binary phage-based reporter assays indicates that quorum sensing can be used to translate a phage infection event into an autoamplified chemical signature.

SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF STUDY

With further modification, binary phage-based reporter assays may be capable of rapidly and cost effectively detecting pathogenic agents at very low population densities.

Controlling bacterial physiology for optimal expression of gene reporter constructs

Bacterial biosensors for the detection of pollutants are based on the regulatory elements that control the corresponding degradation pathways. An increasing number of catabolic pathways under the control of specific regulators are now known to be influenced by the presence of alternative carbon sources, which to different extents repress expression of the pathway despite the presence of the inducer. The molecular basis underlying the control of each catabolic pathway is different, although all sense a high energy state of the cell resulting from the presence of more favourable carbon sources. Biosensor tests mimicking field conditions point to global regulation being relevant for biosensor performance; thus, this global regulation must be taken into account when designing whole-cell biosensors.

Freeze-dried recombinant bacteria for on-site detection of phenolic compounds by color change

We herein report the development of a recombinant bacterial biosensor for the rapid and easy detection of phenolic compounds in the field. A plasmid was designed to encode a beta-galactosidase reporter gene under the control of capR, an activator involved in phenolic compound degradation. The construct was transformed into Escherichia coli, and transformed cells were stored after being freeze-dried in the presence of sucrose. For detection of phenolic compounds, the cells were rehydrated, and used instantly, without any growth step. In the presence of 0.1 microM-10mM phenol, we observed a red color from hydrolysis of chlorophenol red beta-D-galactopyranoside (CPRG) or an indigo color from hydrolysis of X-galactopyranoside (X-gal). Other phenolic compounds could be detected by this system, including catechol, 2-methylphenol, 2-chlorophenol, 3-methylphenol, 2-nitrophenol, and 4-chlorophenol. These results suggest that this novel bacteria biosensor may be useful for easy, on-site detection of phenolic compounds without the need for unwieldy equipment or sample pretreatment. Indeed, biosensor systems involving beta-galactosidase-expressing freeze-dried recombinant bacteria could prove useful for the in situ detection of many more compounds in the future.

Biosensor-based diagnostics of contaminated groundwater: assessment and remediation strategy

Shallow groundwater beneath a former airfield site in southern England has been heavily contaminated with a wide range of chlorinated solvents. The feasibility of using bacterial biosensors to complement chemical analysis and enable cost-effective, and focussed sampling has been assessed as part of a site evaluation programme. Five different biosensors, three metabolic (Vibrio fischeri, Pseudomonas fluorescens 10568 and Escherichia coli HB101) and two catabolic (Pseudomonas putida TVA8 and E. coli DH5alpha), were employed to identify areas where the availability and toxicity of pollutants is of most immediate environmental concern. The biosensors used showed different sensitivities to each other and to the groundwater samples tested. There was generally a good agreement with chemical analyses. The potential efficacy of remediation strategies was explored by coupling sample manipulation to biosensor tests. Manipulation involved sparging and charcoal treatment procedures to simulate remediative engineering solutions. Sparging was sufficient at most locations.

Analytical methods in environmental effects-directed investigations of effluents

Effluent discharges are released into aquatic environments as complex mixtures for which there is commonly either no knowledge of the toxic components or a lack of understanding of how known toxicants interact with other effluent components. Effects-directed investigations consist of chemical extraction and iterative fractionation steps directed by a biological endpoint that is designed to permit the identification or characterization of the chemical classes or compounds in a complex mixture responsible for the observed biological activity. Our review of the literature on effects-directed analyses of effluents for non-mutagenic as well as mutagenic endpoints showed that common extraction and concentration methods have been used. Since the mid-1980s, the methods have evolved from the use of XAD resins to C18 solid-phase extraction (SPE). Blue cotton, blue rayon, and blue chitin have been used specifically for investigations of mutagenic activity where polycyclic compounds were involved or suspected. After isolation, subsequent fractionations have been accomplished using SPE or a high-pressure liquid chromatography (HPLC) system commonly fitted with a C18 reverse-phase column. Substances in active fractions are characterized by gas chromatography/mass spectrometry (GC-MS) and/or other spectrometric techniques for identification. LC-MS methods have been developed for difficult-to-analyze polar substances identified from effects-directed studies, but the potential for LC-MS to identify unknown polar compounds has yet to be fully realized. Salmonella-based assays (some miniaturized) have been coupled with fractionation methods for most studies aimed at identifying mutagenic fractions and chemical classes in mixtures. Effects-directed investigations of mutagens have focused mostly on drinking water and sewage, whereas extensive investigations of non-mutagenic effects have also included runoff, pesticides, and pulp mill effluents. The success of effects-directed investigations should be based on a realistic initial objective of each project. Identification of chemical classes associated with the measured biological endpoint is frequently achievable; however, confirmation of individual compounds is much more difficult and not always a necessary goal of effects-directed chemical analysis.

Construction and comparison of Escherichia coli whole-cell biosensors capable of detecting aromatic compounds

The XylR regulatory protein is a transcription factor involved in the BTEX (benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene, and xylene) degradation pathway in Pseudomonas species. When XylR-dependent stimulation of transcription from a plasmid containing XylR and its cognate promoters Pr and Pu was monitored as firefly luciferase activities in Escherichia coli, a notably high level of basal activity was observed in the absence of inducers. To improve the response specificity of XylR in this system, two related but different promoters were tested for their activities; the XylS activator promoter Ps and the DmpR activator promoter Po. Po with the deletion of its own upstream activating sequences (UASs; Po') showed a very low level of basal activity compared to Pu and Ps. The maximum level with the addition of inducers was increased 3151-fold by o-xylene with Po', while it was 31.5 and 74.1 fold by m-xylene with Pu and Ps, respectively. Gel mobility shift assay showed that the purified XylR without inducers can bind to Pr/Pu but not to Pr/Po', implying that XylR multimerization with Pr/Pu could be formed for initiation of transcription in this system. The data suggest that Po' can be an excellent alternative in constructing a signal-intensified, whole-cell biosensor in response to the xenobiotics.

Calibration and deployment of custom-designed bioreporters for protecting biological remediation consortia from toxic shock

We have previously described the development of a panel of site-specific lux-based bioreporters from an industrial wastewater treatment system remediating coking effluents. The Pseudomonad strains carry a stable chromosomal copy of the luxCDABE operon from Photorhabdus luminescens and display proportional responses in bioluminescence decay with increasing phenol concentration up to 800 mg l-1. In this work we describe their deployment to provide a strategic sensing network for protecting bacterial communities involved in the biological breakdown of coking effluents. This evaluation demonstrated the utility of strategic placement of reporters around heavy industry treatment systems and the reliability of the reporter strains under normal operational conditions. Mono-phenol or total phenolic variation within the treatment system accounted for>65-80% of the luminescence response. The reporters exhibited stable luminescence output during normal operations with maximum standard deviations of luminescence over time of c. 5-15% depending on the treatment compartment. Furthermore, deployment of the bioreporters over a 5-month period allowed the determination of an operational range (OR) for each reporter for effluent samples from each compartment. The OR allowed a convenient measure of toxicity effects between treatment compartments and accurately reflected a specific pollution event occurring within compartments of the treatment system. This work demonstrates the utility of genetic modification to provide ecologically relevant bioreporters, extends the sensing capabilities currently obtained through marine derived biosensors and significantly enhances the potential for in situ deployment of reporting agents.

Design of new promoters and of a dual-bioreporter based on cross-activation by the two regulatory proteins XylR and HbpR

The HbpR protein is the sigma54-dependent transcription activator for 2-hydroxybiphenyl degradation in Pseudomonas azelaica. The ability of HbpR and XylR, which share 35% amino acid sequence identity, to cross-activate the PhbpC and Pu promoters was investigated by determining HbpR- or XylR-mediated luciferase expression and by DNA binding assays. XylR measurably activated the PhbpC promoter in the presence of the effector m-xylene, both in Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas putida. HbpR weakly stimulated the Pu promoter in E. coli but not in P. azelaica. Poor HbpR-dependent activation from Pu was caused by a weak binding to the operator region. To create promoters efficiently activated by both regulators, the HbpR binding sites on PhbpC were gradually changed into the XylR binding sites of Pu by site-directed mutagenesis. Inducible luciferase expression from mutated promoters was tested in E. coli on a two plasmid system, and from mono copy gene fusions in P. azelaica and P. putida. Some mutants were efficiently activated by both HbpR and XylR, showing that promoters can be created which are permissive for both regulators. Others achieved a higher XylR-dependent transcription than from Pu itself. Mutants were also obtained which displayed a tenfold lower uninduced expression level by HbpR than the wild-type PhbpC, while keeping the same maximal induction level. On the basis of these results, a dual-responsive bioreporter strain of P. azelaica was created, containing both XylR and HbpR, and activating luciferase expression from the same single promoter independently with m-xylene and 2-hydroxybiphenyl.

The role of host organism, transcriptional switches and reporter mechanisms in the performance of Hg-induced biosensors

AIMS

The purpose of this study was to comprehensively compare the response of nine biosensors capable of being induced by Hg. Induction by Hg was based upon the insertion of merR, merB, zntA and zntR promoter genes. LuxCDABE or lucFF reporter genes expressed luminescence, and host organisms were Escherichia coli, Vibrio anguillarum and Pseudomonas fluorescens. The role of transcriptional switches, reporter mechanism and host organism was to be investigated.

METHODS AND RESULTS

All biosensors were subjected to the same assay conditions. Sensors had their own individual growth characteristics and response to the doses of Hg tested. Maximum bioluminescence response was induced by concentrations of Hg between 2.5 nm and 5 microM. E. coli pRB28 was found to detect levels of Hg as low as 1.6 nm and yet was capable of operating in a concentration range of up to 12.5 microM.

CONCLUSIONS

The response of the sensors demonstrated their suitability for analysis under environmentally relevant concentrations. The sensitivity of the sensors, the optimum range and the expediency of the assay could not be related to a single sensor trait. It may be concluded that biosensor performance is dependent on more than one of the single factors studied.

SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY

The results show that comparative testing of sensors is an important step in evaluating the relevance and performance of biosensors prior to routine environmental application.

Stress responsive bacteria: biosensors as environmental monitors

The delicate and dynamic balance of the physiological steady state and its maintenance is well characterized by studies of bacterial stress response. Through the use of genetic analysis, numerous stress regulons, their physiological regulators and their biochemical processes have been delineated. In particular, transcriptionally activated stress regulons are subjects of study and application. These regulons include those that respond to macromolecular damage and toxicity as well as to nutrient starvation. The convenience of reporter gene fusions has allowed the creation of biosensor strains, resulting from the fusion of stress-responsive promoters with a variety of reporter genes. Such cellular biosensors are being used for monitoring dynamic systems and can report the presence of environmental stressors in real time. They provide a greater range of sensitivity, e.g. to sub-lethal concentrations of toxicants, than the simple assessment of cell viability. The underlying physiological context of the reporter strains results in the detection of bioavailable concentrations of both toxicants and nutrients. Culture conditions and host strain genotypes can be customized so as to maximize the sensitivity of the strain for a particular application. Collections of specific strains that are grouped in panels are used to diagnose targets or mode of action for unknown toxicants. Further application in massive by parallel DNA and gene fusion arrays greatly extends the information available for diagnosis of modes of action and may lead to development of novel high-throughput screens. Future studies will include more panels, arrays, as well as single reporter cell detection for a better understanding of the population heterogeneity during stress response. New knowledge of physiology gained from further studies of novel systems, or using innovative methods of analysis, will undoubtedly yield still more useful and informative environmental biosensors.

Illuminating the detection chain of bacterial bioreporters

Engineering bacteria for measuring chemicals of environmental or toxicological concern (bioreporter bacteria) has grown slowly into a mature research area. Despite many potential advantages, current bioreporters do not perform well enough to comply with environmental detection standards. Basically, the reasons for this are the lack of engineering principles in the detection chain in the bioreporters. Here, we dissect critical steps in the detection chain and illustrate how bioreporter design could be improved by mutagenizing specificity and selectivity of the sensing and regulatory proteins, by newer expression strategies and application of different signalling networks. Furthermore, we describe how redesigning bioreporter assays with respect to pollutant transport into the cells and application of other detection devices can decrease detection limits and increase the speed of detection.

Measurement of biologically available naphthalene in gas and aqueous phases by use of a Pseudomonas putida biosensor

Genetically constructed microbial biosensors for measuring organic pollutants are mostly applied in aqueous samples. Unfortunately, the detection limit of most biosensors is insufficient to detect pollutants at low but environmentally relevant concentrations. However, organic pollutants with low levels of water solubility often have significant gas-water partitioning coefficients, which in principle makes it possible to measure such compounds in the gas rather than the aqueous phase. Here we describe the first use of a microbial biosensor for measuring organic pollutants directly in the gas phase. For this purpose, we reconstructed a bioluminescent Pseudomonas putida naphthalene biosensor strain to carry the NAH7 plasmid and a chromosomally inserted gene fusion between the sal promoter and the luxAB genes. Specific calibration studies were performed with suspended and filter-immobilized biosensor cells, in aqueous solution and in the gas phase. Gas phase measurements with filter-immobilized biosensor cells in closed flasks, with a naphthalene-contaminated aqueous phase, showed that the biosensor cells can measure naphthalene effectively. The biosensor cells on the filter responded with increasing light output proportional to the naphthalene concentration added to the water phase, even though only a small proportion of the naphthalene was present in the gas phase. In fact, the biosensor cells could concentrate a larger proportion of naphthalene through the gas phase than in the aqueous suspension, probably due to faster transport of naphthalene to the cells in the gas phase. This led to a 10-fold lower detectable aqueous naphthalene concentration (50 nM instead of 0.5 micro M). Thus, the use of bacterial biosensors for measuring organic pollutants in the gas phase is a valid method for increasing the sensitivity of these valuable biological devices.

Characterization of a new solvent-responsive gene locus in Pseudomonas putida F1 and its functionalization as a versatile biosensor

A new gene cluster, designated sepABC and a divergently transcribed sepR, was found downstream of the two-component todST phosphorelay system that regulates toluene degradation (the tod pathway) in Pseudomonas putida F1 (PpF1). The deduced amino acid sequences encoded by sepABC show a high homology to bacterial proteins known to be involved in solvent efflux or multidrug pumps. SepA, SepB and SepC are referred to be periplasmic, inner membrane and outer membrane efflux proteins respectively. Effects on growth of various PpF1 mutants compared to that of the wild type in the presence of toluene indicated a possible protective role of the solvent efflux system in a solvent-stressed environment. Growth tests with the complemented mutants confirmed the involvement of the Sep proteins in conferring solvent tolerance. The sepR gene encodes a 260-residue polypeptide that is a member of the E. coli IclR repressor protein family. The repressor role of SepR was established by conducting tests with a sep-lacZ transcriptional fusion in Escherichia coli and PpF1, expression of SepR as a maltose-binding fusion protein in a DNA binding assay, and mRNA analysis. Southern hybridization experiments and analysis of the P. putida KT2440 genome sequence indicated that sepR is a relatively rare commodity compared to homologues of the sepABC genes. We developed a whole-cell bioluminescent biosensor, PpF1G4, which contains a chromosomally based sep-lux transcriptional fusion. The biosensor showed significant induction of the sepABC genes by a wide variety of aromatic molecules, including benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene, and all three isomers of xylene (BTEX), naphthalene, and complex mixtures of aliphatic and aromatic hydrocarbons. PpF1G4 represents a second-generation biosensor that is not based on a catabolic promoter but is nonetheless inducible by aromatic pollutants and moreover functional under nutrient-rich conditions.

Integrated regulation in response to aromatic compounds: from signal sensing to attractive behaviour

Deciphering the complex interconnecting bacterial responses to the presence of aromatic compounds is required to gain an integrated understanding of how aromatic catabolic processes function in relation to their genome and environmental context. In addition to the properties of the catabolic enzymes themselves, regulatory responses on at least three different levels are important. At a primary level, aromatic compounds control the activity of specific members of many families of transcriptional regulators to direct the expression of the specialized enzymes for their own catabolism. At a second level, dominant global regulation in response to environmental and physiological cues is incorporated to subvert and couple transcription levels to the energy status of the bacteria. Mediators of these global regulatory responses include the alarmone (p)ppGpp, the DNA-bending protein IHF and less well-defined systems that probably sense the energy status through the activity of the electron transport chain. At a third level, aromatic compounds can also impact on catabolic performance by provoking behavioural responses that allow the bacteria to seek out aromatic growth substrates in their environment.

Whole-cell bacterial sensors for the monitoring of phosphate bioavailability

A phosphate sensor plasmid was constructed, in which the inducible promoter of the alkaline phosphatase gene (phoA) from Escherichia coli is fused to the bioluminescence genes from Vibrio fischeri. The reporter construct was introduced into E. coli MG1655 and the rhizosphere coloniser Pseudomonas fluorescens DF57, which produced light in a dose-dependent manner when exogenous phosphate concentrations fell below 60 and 40 microM, respectively. These strains also responded to various organic and inorganic phosphorus compounds. Their ability to distinguish the bioavailable portion of phosphate in standard solution was demonstrated using different phosphate ligands. When applying the bioassay to wastewater samples, luminescence patterns correlated with phosphate concentrations determined by standard chemical procedure. These results indicated that phoA::lux-based bacterial sensors may serve as tools for the assessment of phosphate bioavailability.

Naphthalene-utilizing and mercury-resistant bacteria isolated from an acidic environment

Soil samples were taken from areas of low pH (2.5-3.5) surrounding an outdoor coal storage pile. These samples were added to medium with naphthalene as the sole carbon source to enrich for organisms capable of degrading polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH) at low pH. Five such bacterial strains were isolated. Sequencing of the 16S rDNA showed them to be members of the genera Clavibacter, Arthrobacter and Acidocella. These organisms were all capable of growth with naphthalene as a sole carbon source at low pH. The genes nahAc, nahAd, phnAc, nahH, xylE or GST, which are known to be associated with PAH degradation were not detected. Isolate 10, the Acidocella strain, tolerated high levels of mercury. PCR amplification and sequencing of genes from the mer operon from isolate 10 DNA suggested that mercury is transported into the bacterial cell and subsequently detoxified since the enzymes encoded by genes in this operon are involved in these processes.

Recent advances in petroleum microbiology

Recent advances in molecular biology have extended our understanding of the metabolic processes related to microbial transformation of petroleum hydrocarbons. The physiological responses of microorganisms to the presence of hydrocarbons, including cell surface alterations and adaptive mechanisms for uptake and efflux of these substrates, have been characterized. New molecular techniques have enhanced our ability to investigate the dynamics of microbial communities in petroleum-impacted ecosystems. By establishing conditions which maximize rates and extents of microbial growth, hydrocarbon access, and transformation, highly accelerated and bioreactor-based petroleum waste degradation processes have been implemented. Biofilters capable of removing and biodegrading volatile petroleum contaminants in air streams with short substrate-microbe contact times (<60 s) are being used effectively. Microbes are being injected into partially spent petroleum reservoirs to enhance oil recovery. However, these microbial processes have not exhibited consistent and effective performance, primarily because of our inability to control conditions in the subsurface environment. Microbes may be exploited to break stable oilfield emulsions to produce pipeline quality oil. There is interest in replacing physical oil desulfurization processes with biodesulfurization methods through promotion of selective sulfur removal without degradation of associated carbon moieties. However, since microbes require an environment containing some water, a two-phase oil-water system must be established to optimize contact between the microbes and the hydrocarbon, and such an emulsion is not easily created with viscous crude oil. This challenge may be circumvented by application of the technology to more refined gasoline and diesel substrates, where aqueous-hydrocarbon emulsions are more easily generated. Molecular approaches are being used to broaden the substrate specificity and increase the rates and extents of desulfurization. Bacterial processes are being commercialized for removal of H(2)S and sulfoxides from petrochemical waste streams. Microbes also have potential for use in removal of nitrogen from crude oil leading to reduced nitric oxide emissions provided that technical problems similar to those experienced in biodesulfurization can be solved. Enzymes are being exploited to produce added-value products from petroleum substrates, and bacterial biosensors are being used to analyze petroleum-contaminated environments.

A new variant activator involved in the degradation of phenolic compounds from a strain of Pseudomonas putida

A new variant type of regulatory activator and relevant promoters (designated capR, Pr and Po) involved in the metabolism of phenolic compounds were cloned from Pseudomonas putida KCTC1452 by using PCR. The deduced amino acid sequence of CapR revealed a difference in nine amino acids from the effector binding domain of DmpR. To measure effector specificity, plasmids were constructed in such a way that the expression of luc gene for firefly luciferase or lacZ for beta-galactosidase as a reporter was under the control of capR. When Escherichia coli transformed with the plasmids was exposed to phenol, dramatic increases in the activity of luciferase or beta-galactosidase were observed in a range of 0.01-1 mM. Among various phenolic compounds tested, other effective compounds included catechol, 2-methylphenol, 3-methylphenol, 4-methylphenol, 2-chlorophenol, 4-chlorophenol, 2-nitrophenol, resorcinol, and 2, 5-dimethylphenol. The results indicate that CapR has effector specificity different from other related activators, CatR and DmpR. Waste water and soil potentially containing phenolic compounds were also tested by this system and the results were compared with chemical and GC data. The present results indicate that the biosensor consisting of capR and the promoters may be utilized for the development of a phenolic compounds-specific biosensor in monitoring the environmental pollutant.

Nanotechnology: convergence with modern biology and medicine

The worldwide emergence of nanoscale science and engineering was marked by the announcement of the National Nanotechnology Initiative (NNI) in January 2000. Recent research on biosystems at the nanoscale has created one of the most dynamic science and technology domains at the confluence of physical sciences, molecular engineering, biology, biotechnology and medicine. This domain includes better understanding of living and thinking systems, revolutionary biotechnology processes, the synthesis of new drugs and their targeted delivery, regenerative medicine, neuromorphic engineering and developing a sustainable environment. Nanobiosystems research is a priority in many countries and its relevance within nanotechnology is expected to increase in the future.

Microbial whole-cell sensing systems of environmental pollutants

The past decade has witnessed the development of a novel class of tools for environmental monitoring: genetically engineered microorganisms 'tailored' to respond in a dose-dependent manner to changes in environmental conditions. Recent advances in the field include the expansion of available reporter functions with multicolored fluorescent proteins, a broadening of the detected chemical effects such as the availability of nutrients and enhancement of the spectrum of reporter microorganisms to include cyanobacteria, yeast and fungi. Most importantly, the stage has been set for the incorporation of such cells into various whole-cell array formats on silicon chips, optic fibres and other configurations. The future of such multiplex detection and analysis systems seems bright.