Identification of sequence requirement for the origin of DNA replication in human papillomavirus type 18

E2 protein is the major determinant of specificity at the human papillomavirus origin of replication

The replication of human papillomavirus (HPV) genomes requires E1 and E2 proteins as the viral trans-factors and the replication origin, located in the URR, as a cis-element. The minimal requirements for an HPV replication origin vary among different virus types but always include one or more binding sites for the E2 protein. The requirements for an E1 binding site seem to vary among different HPV genera, with alpha-HPV11 and -18 minimal origins able to replicate without E1 binding site in contrast to beta-HPV8. In the present article, we analysed the sequence requirements for the beta-HPV5 minimal origin of replication. We show that the HPV5 URR is able to replicate in U2OS cells without the sequence proposed as an E1 binding site, albeit at lower levels than wt URR, given that three E2 binding sites are intact and both viral replication proteins are present. The lack of an absolute requirement of the E1 binding site for the origin of replication of HPV5 led us to analyse whether the viral E1 and E2 proteins from other HPV types are competent to support replication from this origin. Surprisingly, the E1 and E2 proteins from beta-HPV types support replication from the origin in contrast to proteins from alpha-HPV types 11, -16, or -18. Furthermore, the replication proteins E1 and E2 of these alpha-HPV types are unable to support the replication of HPV5 URR, even if the E1 binding site is intact. In light of these results, we performed a detailed analysis of the ability of different combinations of E1 and E2 proteins from various alpha- and beta-HPV types to support the replication of URR sequences from the respective HPV types in the U2OS cell line.

Genetic variations in the DNA replication origins of human papillomavirus family correlate with their oncogenic potential

Human papillomaviruses (HPVs) encompass a large family of viruses that range from benign to highly carcinogenic. The crucial differences between benign and carcinogenic types of HPV remain unknown, except that the two HPV types differ in the frequency of DNA replication. We have systematically analyzed the mechanism of HPV DNA replication initiation in low-risk and high-risk HPVs. Our results demonstrate that HPV-encoded E2 initiator protein and its four binding sites in the replication origin play pivotal roles in determining the destiny of the HPV-infected cell. We have identified strain-specific single nucleotide variations in E2 binding sites found only in the high-risk HPVs. We have demonstrated that these variations result in attenuated formation of the E2-DNA complex. E2 binding to these sites is linked to the activation of the DNA replication origin as well as initiation of DNA replication. Both electrophoretic mobility shift assay and atomic force microscopy studies demonstrated that binding of E2 from either low- or high-risk HPVs with variant binding sequences lacked multimeric E2-DNA complex formation in vitro. These results provided a molecular basis of differential DNA replication in the two types of HPVs and pointed to a correlation with the development of cancer.

Persistence of an Oncogenic Papillomavirus Genome Requires cis Elements from the Viral Transcriptional Enhancer

Human papillomavirus (HPV) genomes are replicated and maintained as extrachromosomal plasmids during persistent infection. The viral E2 proteins are thought to promote stable maintenance replication by tethering the viral DNA to host chromatin. However, this has been very difficult to prove genetically, as the E2 protein is involved in transcriptional regulation and initiation of replication, as well as its assumed role in genome maintenance. This makes mutational analysis of viral trans factors and cis elements in the background of the viral genome problematic and difficult to interpret. To circumvent this problem, we have developed a complementation assay in which the complete wild-type HPV18 genome is transfected into primary human keratinocytes along with subgenomic or mutated replicons that contain the minimal replication origin. The wild-type genome provides the E1 and E2 proteins in trans, allowing us to determine additional cis elements that are required for long-term replication and partitioning of the replicon. We found that, in addition to the core replication origin (and the three E2 binding sites located therein), additional sequences from the transcriptional enhancer portion of the URR (upstream regulatory region) are required in cis for long-term genome replication.

Human papillomaviruses infect cutaneous and mucosal epithelial cells of the host, and this results in very-long-lived, persistent infection. The viral genomes are small, circular, double-stranded DNA molecules that replicate extrachromosomally in concert with cellular DNA. This replication strategy requires that the virus has a robust mechanism to partition and retain the viral genomes in dividing cells. This has been difficult to study, because viral transcription, replication, and partitioning are regulated by the same viral proteins and involve overlapping elements in the viral genome. We developed a complementation assay that allows us to separate these functions and define the elements required for long-term replication and stable maintenance replication of the HPV genome. This has important implications, as disruption of viral maintenance replication can eliminate viral genomes from infected cells, thus curing persistent HPV infection.

Mechanisms and strategies of papillomavirus replication

Animal and human papillomaviruses (HPVs) replicate persistently in specific types of stratified epithelia of their host. After the initial infection, the viral genome replicates at low levels in the dividing cells of the epithelium, and these cells form a reservoir of infection that can last for decades. When the infected cells differentiate, viral genomes replicate to high levels to form progeny virus that is released from the surface of the epithelium. This complex life cycle requires several different modes of viral DNA replication, but papillomaviruses are masters at hijacking key cellular processes to facilitate their own reproduction.

The E1 proteins

E1, an ATP-dependent DNA helicase, is the only enzyme encoded by papillomaviruses (PVs). It is essential for replication and amplification of the viral episome in the nucleus of infected cells. To do so, E1 assembles into a double-hexamer at the viral origin, unwinds DNA at the origin and ahead of the replication fork and interacts with cellular DNA replication factors. Biochemical and structural studies have revealed the assembly pathway of E1 at the origin and how the enzyme unwinds DNA using a spiral escalator mechanism. E1 is tightly regulated in vivo, in particular by post-translational modifications that restrict its accumulation in the nucleus. Here we review how different functional domains of E1 orchestrate viral DNA replication, with an emphasis on their interactions with substrate DNA, host DNA replication factors and modifying enzymes. These studies have made E1 one of the best characterized helicases and provided unique insights on how PVs usurp different host-cell machineries to replicate and amplify their genome in a tightly controlled manner.

Gene- and protein-delivered zinc finger-staphylococcal nuclease hybrid for inhibition of DNA replication of human papillomavirus

Previously, we reported that artificial zinc-finger proteins (AZPs) inhibited virus DNA replication in planta and in mammalian cells by blocking binding of a viral replication protein to its replication origin. However, the replication mechanisms of viruses of interest need to be disentangled for the application. To develop more widely applicable methods for antiviral therapy, we explored the feasibility of inhibition of HPV-18 replication as a model system by cleaving its viral genome. To this end, we fused the staphylococcal nuclease cleaving DNA as a monomer to an AZP that binds to the viral genome. The resulting hybrid nuclease (designated AZP–SNase) cleaved its target DNA plasmid efficiently and sequence-specifically in vitro. Then, we confirmed that transfection with a plasmid expressing AZP–SNase inhibited HPV-18 DNA replication in transient replication assays using mammalian cells. Linker-mediated PCR analysis revealed that the AZP–SNase cleaved an HPV-18 ori plasmid around its binding site. Finally, we demonstrated that the protein-delivered AZP–SNase inhibited HPV-18 DNA replication as well and did not show any significant cytotoxicity. Thus, both gene- and protein-delivered hybrid nucleases efficiently inhibited HPV-18 DNA replication, leading to development of a more universal antiviral therapy for human DNA viruses.

Development of quantitative and high-throughput assays of polyomavirus and papillomavirus DNA replication

Polyoma- and papillomaviruses genome replication is initiated by the binding of large T antigen (LT) and of E1 and E2, respectively, at the viral origin (ori). Replication of an ori-containing plasmid occurs in cells transiently expressing these viral proteins and is typically quantified by Southern blotting or PCR. To facilitate the study of SV40 and HPV31 DNA replication, we developed cellular assays in which transient replication of the ori-plasmid is quantified using a firefly luciferase gene located in cis to the ori. Under optimized conditions, replication of the SV40 and HPV31 ori-plasmids resulted in a 50- and 150-fold increase in firefly luciferase levels, respectively. These results were validated using replication-defective mutants of LT, E1 and E2 and with inhibitors of DNA replication and cell-cycle progression. These quantitative and high-throughput assays should greatly facilitate the study of SV40 and HPV31 DNA replication and the identification of small-molecule inhibitors of this process.

Replication and partitioning of papillomavirus genomes

Papillomaviruses establish persistent infection in the dividing, basal epithelial cells of the host. The viral genome is maintained as a circular, double-stranded DNA, extrachromosomal element within these cells. Viral genome amplification occurs only when the epithelial cells differentiate and viral particles are shed in squames that are sloughed from the surface of the epithelium. There are three modes of replication in the papillomavirus life cycle. Upon entry, in the establishment phase, the viral genome is amplified to a low copy number. In the second maintenance phase, the genome replicates in dividing cells at a constant copy number, in synchrony with the cellular DNA. And finally, in the vegetative or productive phase, the viral DNA is amplified to a high copy number in differentiated cells and is destined to be packaged in viral capsids. This review discusses the cis elements and protein factors required for each stage of papillomavirus replication.

Inhibition of DNA replication of human papillomavirus by artificial zinc finger proteins

Recently, we demonstrated that plant DNA virus replication was inhibited in planta by using an artificial zinc finger protein (AZP) and created AZP-based transgenic plants resistant to DNA virus infection. Here we apply the AZP technology to the inhibition of replication of a mammalian DNA virus, human papillomavirus type 18 (HPV-18). Two AZPs, designated AZP(HPV)-1 and AZP(HPV)-2, were designed by using our nondegenerate recognition code table and were constructed to block binding of the HPV-18 E2 replication protein to the replication origin. Both of the newly designed AZPs had much higher affinities towards the replication origin than did the E2 protein, and they efficiently blocked E2 binding in vitro. In transient replication assays, both AZPs inhibited viral DNA replication, especially AZP(HPV)-2, which reduced the replication level to approximately 10%. We also demonstrated in transient replication assays, using plasmids with mutant replication origins, that AZP(HPV)-2 could precisely recognize the replication origin in mammalian cells. Thus, it was demonstrated that the AZP technology could be applied not only to plant DNA viruses but also to mammalian DNA viruses.

Identification of a novel human papillomavirus (HPV97) related to HPV18 and HPV45

Human papillomavirus (HPV) type 97 was identified and the genome was cloned from cervicovaginal cells of a Costa Rican woman with a normal Pap smear. The HPV97 L1 open reading frame (ORF) was most closely related to HPV45 (84% identity) and HPV18 (79% identity), placing it into the high-risk alpha7 species. Ectopic expression of the HPV97 E6 and E7 proteins significantly decreased steady state p53 and pRb levels using an in vitro cotransfection assay, respectively. These data suggest that HPV97 shares a most recent common ancestor with HPV18 and HPV45 and should be evaluated in cancer specimens from different geographic populations.

Identification of a virus trans-acting regulatory element on the latent DNA replication of Kaposi's sarcoma-associated herpesvirus

Latency-associated nuclear antigen 1 (LANA1) of Kaposi's sarcoma-associated herpesvirus (KSHV) plays a pivotal role in the maintenance of the virus genome in latently infected cells. LANA1 links virus genomes to host chromosomes via a C-terminal DNA-binding domain which interacts with the sequences located in terminal repeats (TRs) of the virus genome and via an N-terminal chromosome-binding sequence which associates with the host chromosomes, respectively. Recent data suggest that LANA1 also actively participates in the replication of KSHV TR-containing plasmid in the transient DNA replication assay. In this report, it was found that C33A and COS-1, but not NIH/3T3, cell lines are permissive for the transient replication of KSHV TR-containing plasmid. Using several LANA1-deletion mutants, the minimum domain of LANA1 required for replication activity was also determined. In addition, the N terminus of LANA1 inhibited the transient replication systems of KSHV and Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) in transiently transfected 293 and 293T cells, but the C terminus of LANA1 specifically inhibited the transient replication system of KSHV in other cell lines. Consistent with previous reports, these data further emphasize the functional importance of the N terminus of LANA1 on replication from the KSHV latent origin of DNA replication.

Dual role of tumor suppressor p53 in regulation of DNA replication and oncogene E6-promoter activity of epidermodysplasia verruciformis-associated human papillomavirus type 8

Human papillomavirus 8 (HPV8) is a representative of Epidermodysplasia verruciformis (EV)-associated viruses. Transient assays in the human skin keratinocyte cell line RTS3b have shown that its replication depends in trans on expression of the viral proteins E1 and E2, similarly to other HPVs. Using deletion mutants and cloned subfragments of the noncoding region (NCR) of HPV8 we identified a 65-bp sequence in the 3' part of the NCR to be necessary and sufficient to support replication in cis. The origin of replication (ori) of HPV8 is composed of the sequence motifs "CCAAC" (nt 57-73) and M29 (nt 84-112), which are highly conserved among the majority of EV HPVs. Analysis of M29 revealed an unconventional binding site of the E2 protein and an overlapping DNA recognition site of the tumor suppressor protein p53. Both these factors competitively bind to M29. In transient replication assays p53 acted as a potent inhibitor of ori activity, most probably in a DNA-binding-dependent fashion. The minimal ori sequences are also functionally critical for the E6 oncogene promoter P(175). In contrast to its effect on replication, p53 stimulated promoter activity depending on its interaction with M29. Our observations suggest that p53 is involved in controlling the balance between DNA replication and gene expression of HPV8.

Interaction of E1 and hSNF5 proteins stimulates replication of human papillomavirus DNA

Mammalian viruses often use components of the host's cellular DNA replication machinery to carry out replication of their genomes, which enables these viruses to be used as tools for characterizing factors that are involved in cellular DNA replication. The human papillomavirus (HPV) E1 protein is essential for replication of the virus DNA. Here we identify the cellular factor that participates in viral DNA replication by using a two-hybrid assay in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae and E1 protein as bait. Using this assay, we isolated Inil/hSNF5, a component of the SWI/SNF complex which facilitates transcription by altering the structure of chromatin. In vitro binding and immunoprecipitation confirmed that E1 interacts directly with Ini1/hSNF5. Transient DNA-replication assay revealed that HPV DNA replication is stimulated in a dose-dependent manner by addition of Ini1/hSNF5, and that Ini1/hSNF5 antisense RNA blocks the replication of HPV DNA. Amino-acid substitution at residues that are conserved among E1 proteins prevented the E1-Ini1/hSNF5 interaction and reduced DNA replication of HPV in vivo. Our results indicate that Ini1/hSNF5 is required for the efficient replication of papillomavirus DNA and is therefore needed, either alone or in complex with SWI/SNF complex, for mammalian DNA replication as well.

Transcription factor YY1 represses cell-free replication from human papillomavirus origins

We have established cell-free replication for the human papillomavirus type 18 (HPV-18) origin of replication (ori)-containing DNA by using purified HPV-18 E1 and E2 gene products expressed as fusion proteins in Escherichia coli. The transcription factor YY1 has been shown to regulate RNA transcription by binding to a sequence overlapping the putative E1 protein binding site in the HPV-18 ori. We show that exogenously added YY1 fusion protein inhibited HPV-18 ori replication. Cotransfection of YY1 expression vectors also inhibited transient replication in 293 cells. However, inhibition did not appear to be mediated by binding to its cognate site in the ori as YY1 also inhibited the replication of the HPV-11 ori, which does not have a known or suspected YY1 binding site. Moreover, inhibition was not alleviated by the inclusion of YY1 binding oligonucleotides in the replication reaction mixtures. Rather, we demonstrated a direct interaction between purified fusion E2 protein and fusion YY1 protein by the pull-down assay and a partial restoration of replication activity by an elevated E2 protein concentration. These results suggest that YY1 can inhibit HPV ori replication by interfering with E2 protein functions.