Mutation analysis of hBUB1 in aneuploid HNSCC and lung cancer cell lines

Escape from Cellular Senescence Is Associated with Chromosomal Instability in Oral Pre-Malignancy

An escape from cellular senescence through the development of unlimited growth potential is one of the hallmarks of cancer, which is thought to be an early event in carcinogenesis. In this review, we propose that the molecular effectors of senescence, particularly the inactivation of TP53 and CDKN2A, together with telomere attrition and telomerase activation, all lead to aneuploidy in the keratinocytes from oral potentially malignant disorders (OPMD). Premalignant keratinocytes, therefore, not only become immortal but also develop genotypic and phenotypic cellular diversity. As a result of these changes, certain clonal cell populations likely gain the capacity to invade the underlying connective tissue. We review the clinical implications of these changes and highlight a new PCR-based assay to identify aneuploid cell in fluids such as saliva, a technique that is extremely sensitive and could facilitate the regular monitoring of OPMD without the need for surgical biopsies and may avoid potential biopsy sampling errors. We also draw attention to recent studies designed to eliminate aneuploid tumour cell populations that, potentially, is a new therapeutic approach to prevent malignant transformations in OPMD.

A Review of Selected Factors of Salivary Gland Tumour Formation and Malignant Transformation

Salivary gland tumours represent about 6% of head and neck neoplasms and about 0.5% of all malignancies in humans. Tumour growth and malignant transformation are complex processes involving various actions of molecules. Furthermore, some malignant salivary gland tumours are deemed to be caused by dedifferentiation or malignant transformation of benign tumours. The mechanisms of this transformation depend on a variety of different elements, such as cell cycle regulators, oncogenes, proteins, angiogenesis factors, and adipocytokines. The authors used PubMed, Medline, and Google websites to find and review the most significant papers related to malignant transformation in benign salivary gland tumours.

Spindle Assembly Disruption and Cancer Cell Apoptosis with a CLTC-Binding Compound

AK3 compounds are mitotic arrest agents that induce high levels of γH2AX during mitosis and apoptosis following release from arrest. We synthesized a potent AK3 derivative, AK306, that induced arrest and apoptosis of the HCT116 colon cancer cell line with an EC₅₀ of approximately 50 nmol/L. AK306 was active on a broad spectrum of cancer cell lines with total growth inhibition values ranging from approximately 25 nmol/L to 25 μmol/L. Using biotin and BODIPY-linked derivatives of AK306, binding to clathrin heavy chain (CLTC/CHC) was observed, a protein with roles in endocytosis and mitosis. AK306 inhibited mitosis and endocytosis, while disrupting CHC cellular localization. Cells arrested in mitosis by AK306 showed the formation of multiple microtubule-organizing centers consisting of pericentrin, γ-tubulin, and Aurora A foci, without apparent centrosome amplification. Cells released from AK306 arrest were unable to form bipolar spindles, unlike nocodazole-released cells that reformed spindles and completed division. Like AK306, CHC siRNA knockdown disrupted spindle formation and activated p53. A short-term (3-day) treatment of tumor-bearing APC-mutant mice with AK306 increased apoptosis in tumors, but not normal mucosa. These findings indicate that targeting the mitotic CHC complex can selectively induce apoptosis and may have therapeutic value.Implication: Disruption of clathrin with a small-molecule inhibitor, AK306, selectively induces apoptosis in cancer cells by disrupting bipolar spindle formation. Mol Cancer Res; 16(9); 1361-72. ©2018 AACR.

Cytosolic Levels of Neuron-Specific Enolase in Squamous Cell Carcinomas of the Lung

To study the behavior and possible correlations of neuron-specific enolase (NSE) with other clinicobiological parameters, we measured the cytosolic levels of this marker by means of an immunoradiometric assay (IRMA) in 95 squamous cell lung carcinoma samples. We also analyzed the levels of pS2, tissue-type plasminogen activator (t-PA), hyaluronic acid (HA), free beta subunit of human chorionic gonadotropin (β-HCG), CYFRA 21.1 and CA 125 in cytosol. On the cell surface we analyzed the concentrations of epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR), HA, erbB-2 oncoprotein, CD44s, CD44v5 and CD44v6. Other parameters considered were clinical stage, lymph node involvement, histological grade (HG), ploidy and the cellular S-phase fraction measured by flow cytometry on nuclei obtained from fresh tissues.

In the 95 squamous cell carcinomas the cytosolic levels of NSE varied from 4.5 to 2235 ng/mg protein (median: 267) and were significantly higher (p<0.001) than those observed in 38 samples of normal pulmonary tissue obtained from the same patients (range: 56–657; median: 141.5). When classifying tumors according to the different parameters analyzed, we observed that the levels of NSE were higher in aneuploid than in diploid cases (p=0.046) and in those that were HG3 than in those that were HG2 (p<0.001). Tumors with high NSE levels (>422 ng/mg protein; 75th percentile) were more likely to have high S-phase values (p=0.012) and were more frequently aneuploid (p=0.038) and HG3 (p<0.001) than those with low levels of NSE (<180 ng/mg protein; 25th percentile).

These results lead us to the following conclusions: 1) the cytosolic concentrations of NSE are significantly higher in squamous cell carcinomas than in healthy pulmonary tissue, and 2) the cytosolic concentrations of NSE are not correlated with clinical stage or nodal involvement. However, in our study higher levels of the enzyme were statistically correlated with aneuploidy, histological grade 3 and S-phase. This may explain its association with poorer outcome and progression, but also the more favorable response of tumors with elevated NSE to chemotherapy, as suggested by other groups.

Affected chromosome homeostasis and genomic instability of clonal yeast cultures

Yeast cells originating from one single colony are considered genotypically and phenotypically identical. However, taking into account the cellular heterogeneity, it seems also important to monitor cell-to-cell variations within a clone population. In the present study, a comprehensive yeast karyotype screening was conducted using single chromosome comet assay. Chromosome-dependent and mutation-dependent changes in DNA (DNA with breaks or with abnormal replication intermediates) were studied using both single-gene deletion haploid mutants (bub1, bub2, mad1, tel1, rad1 and tor1) and diploid cells lacking one active gene of interest, namely BUB1/bub1, BUB2/bub2, MAD1/mad1, TEL1/tel1, RAD1/rad1 and TOR1/tor1 involved in the control of cell cycle progression, DNA repair and the regulation of longevity. Increased chromosome fragility and replication stress-mediated chromosome abnormalities were correlated with elevated incidence of genomic instability, namely aneuploid events—disomies, monosomies and to a lesser extent trisomies as judged by in situ comparative genomic hybridization (CGH). The tor1 longevity mutant with relatively balanced chromosome homeostasis was found the most genomically stable among analyzed mutants. During clonal yeast culture, spontaneously formed abnormal chromosome structures may stimulate changes in the ploidy state and, in turn, promote genomic heterogeneity. These alterations may be more accented in selected mutated genetic backgrounds, namely in yeast cells deficient in proper cell cycle regulation and DNA repair.

Links between nucleolar activity, rDNA stability, aneuploidy and chronological aging in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae

The nucleolus is speculated to be a regulator of cellular senescence in numerous biological systems (Guarente, Genes Dev 11(19):2449–2455, 1997; Johnson et al., Curr Opin Cell Biol 10(3):332–338, 1998). In the budding yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, alterations in nucleolar architecture, the redistribution of nucleolar protein and the accumulation of extrachromosomal ribosomal DNA circles (ERCs) during replicative aging have been reported. However, little is known regarding rDNA stability and changes in nucleolar activity during chronological aging (CA), which is another yeast aging model used. In the present study, the impact of aberrant cell cycle checkpoint control (knock-out of BUB1, BUB2, MAD1 and TEL1 genes in haploid and diploid hemizygous states) on CA-mediated changes in the nucleolus was studied. Nucleolus fragmentation, changes in the nucleolus size and the nucleolus/nucleus ratio, ERC accumulation, expression pattern changes and the relocation of protein involved in transcriptional silencing during CA were revealed. All strains examined were affected by oxidative stress, aneuploidy (numerical rather than structural aberrations) and DNA damage. However, the bub1 cells were the most prone to aneuploidy events, which may contribute to observed decrease in chronological lifespan. We postulate that chronological aging may be affected by redox imbalance-mediated chromosome XII instability leading to both rDNA instability and whole chromosome aneuploidy. CA-mediated nucleolus fragmentation may be a consequence of nucleolus enlargement and/or Nop2p upregulation. Moreover, the rDNA content of chronologically aging cells may be a factor determining the subsequent replicative lifespan. Taken together, we demonstrated that the nucleolus state is also affected during CA in yeast.

Cancer karyotypes: survival of the fittest

Cancer cells are typically characterized by complex karyotypes including both structural and numerical changes, with aneuploidy being a ubiquitous feature. It is becoming increasingly evident that aneuploidy per se can cause chromosome mis-segregation, which explains the higher rates of chromosome gain/loss observed in aneuploid cancer cells compared to normal diploid cells, a phenotype termed chromosomal instability (CIN). CIN can be caused by various mechanisms and results in extensive karyotypic heterogeneity within a cancer cell population. However, despite such karyotypic heterogeneity, cancer cells also display predominant karyotypic patterns. In this review we discuss the mechanisms of CIN, with particular emphasis on the role of aneuploidy on CIN. Further, we discuss the potential functional role of karyotypic patterns in cancer.

How mitotic errors contribute to karyotypic diversity in cancer

Aneuploidy is a common feature of cancer cells, and is believed to play a critical role in tumorigenesis and cancer progression. Most cancer cells also exhibit high rates of mitotic chromosome mis-segregation, a phenomenon known as chromosomal instability, which leads to high variability of the karyotype. Here, we describe the nature, nuances, and implications of cancer karyotypic diversity. Moreover, we summarize recent studies aimed at identifying the mitotic defects that may be responsible for inducing chromosome mis-segregation in cancer cells. These include kinetochore attachment errors, spindle assembly checkpoint dysfunction, mitotic spindle defects, and other cell division inaccuracies. Finally, we discuss how such mitotic errors generate karyotypic diversity in cancer cells.

Establishment and Molecular Cytogenetic Characterization of a Cell Culture Model of Head and Neck Squamous Cell Carcinoma (HNSCC)

Cytogenetic analysis of head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC) established several biomarkers that have been correlated to clinical parameters during the past years. Adequate cell culture model systems are required for functional studies investigating those potential prognostic markers in HNSCC. We have used a cell line, CAL 33, for the establishment of a cell culture model in order to perform functional analyses of interesting candidate genes and proteins. The cell line was cytogenetically characterized using array CGH, spectral karyotyping (SKY) and fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). As a starting point for the investigation of genetic markers predicting radiosensitivity in tumor cells, irradiation experiments were carried out and radiation responses of CAL 33 have been determined. Radiosensitivity of CAL 33 cells was intermediate when compared to published data on tumor cell lines.

Deficiencies in Chfr and Mlh1 synergistically enhance tumor susceptibility in mice

Genetic instability, which leads to an accumulation of various genetic abnormalities, has been considered an essential component of the human neoplasic transformation process. However, the molecular basis of genomic instability during tumorigenesis remains incompletely understood. Growing evidence indicates that checkpoint with forkhead and ring finger domains (CHFR), a recently identified mitotic checkpoint protein, plays an important role in maintaining chromosome integrity and functions as a tumor suppressor. In this study, we used high-throughput technology to conduct gene expression profiling of human colon cancers and found that loss of CHFR expression frequently occurred in colon cancers with high microsatellite instability (MSI-H). Downregulation of CHFR expression was closely associated with overexpression of Aurora A, an important mitotic kinase. Mice with deficiencies in both Chfr and Mlh1 (the gene that encodes the DNA mismatch-repair protein Mlh1) displayed dramatically higher incidence of spontaneous tumors relative to mice deficient for only one of these genes. These results suggest that defects in both Chfr and Mlh1 synergistically increase predisposition to tumorigenesis.

Misorientation and reduced stretching of aligned sister kinetochores promote chromosome missegregation in EB1- or APC-depleted cells

The correct formation of stable but dynamic links between chromosomes and spindle microtubules (MTs) is essential for accurate chromosome segregation. However, the molecular mechanisms by which kinetochores bind MTs and checkpoints monitor this binding remain poorly understood. In this paper, we analyze the functions of six kinetochore-bound MT-associated proteins (kMAPs) using RNAi, live-cell microscopy and quantitative image analysis. We find that RNAi-mediated depletion of two kMAPs, the adenomatous polyposis coli protein (APC) and its binding partner, EB1, are unusual in affecting the movement and orientation of paired sister chromatids at the metaphase plate without perturbing kinetochore-MT attachment per se. Quantitative analysis shows that misorientation phenotypes in metaphase are uniform across chromatid pairs even though chromosomal loss (CIN) during anaphase is sporadic. However, errors in kinetochore function generated by APC or EB1 depletion are detected poorly if at all by the spindle checkpoint, even though they cause chromosome missegregation. We propose that impaired EB1 or APC function generates lesions invisible to the spindle checkpoint and thereby promotes low levels of CIN expected to fuel aneuploidy and possibly tumorigenesis.

Spindle checkpoint protein Bub1 corrects mitotic aberrancy induced by human T-cell leukemia virus type I Tax

Bub1 is a component of the mitotic spindle checkpoint apparatus. Abnormality of this apparatus is known to cause multinuclei formation, a hallmark of chromosomal instability (CIN). A549, aneuploid cell line, aberrantly passed through the mitotic phase and became multinuclei morphology in the presence of nocodazole. Time-lapse videomicroscopy showed unreported bizarre morphology, which we named 'mitotic lobulation' in A549 cells just before the exit from mitosis and multinuclei formation. External expression of wild-type Bub1-EGFP clearly suppressed the multinuclei formation by retaining A549 cells at the mitotic phase during 48 h of time-lapse observation. This suppressive effect on mitotic aberrancy should not be mere restoration of normal Bub1 function, because A549 cells express proper amount of Bub1, which distributed cytoplasm during interphase and concentrated at kinetochore in metaphase. Furthermore, external expression of wild-type Bub1-EGFP suppressed multinuclei formation induced by Tax both in A549 and HeLa cells. Tax is known to induce mitotic abnormality by binding and inactivating Mad1. These observations, therefore, suggest functional redundancy between Bub1 and other mitotic checkpoint protein(s) and a possibility of correction of mitotic aberrancy by external Bub1 expression.

Molecular mechanisms of human carcinogenesis

Intensive research efforts during the last several decades have increased our understanding of carcinogenesis, and have identified a genetic basis for the multi-step process of cancer development. Tumors grow through a process of clonal expansion driven by mutation. Several forms of molecular alteration have been described in human cancers, and these can be generally classified as chromosomal abnormalities and nucleotide sequence abnormalities. Most cancer cells display a phenotype characterized by genomic hypermutability, suggesting that genomic instability may precede the acquisition of transforming mutations in critical target genes. Reduced to its essence, cancer is a disease of abnormal gene expression, and these genetic abnormalities contribute to cancer pathogenesis through inactivation of negative mediators of cell proliferation (including tumor suppressor genes) and activation of positive mediators of cell proliferation (including proto-oncogenes). In several human tumor systems, specific genetic alterations have been shown to correlate with well-defined histopathological stages of tumor development and progression. Although the significance of mutations to the etiological mechanisms of tumor development has been debated, a causal role for such genetic lesions is now commonly accepted for most human cancers. Thus, genetic lesions represent an integral part of the processes of neoplastic transformation, tumorigenesis, and tumor progression, and as such represent potentially valuable markers for cancer detection and staging.

A dominant interfering Bub1 mutant is insufficient to induce or alter thymic tumorigenesis in vivo, even in a sensitized genetic background

Aneuploidy is a common feature of human tumors, often correlating with poor prognosis. The mitotic spindle checkpoint is thought to play a major role in aneuploidy suppression. To investigate the role of the spindle checkpoint in tumor suppression in vivo, we developed transgenic mice in which thymocytes express a dominant interfering fragment of Bub1, a kinase regulator of the spindle checkpoint. We report that, despite high-level expression of dominant-negative Bub1 (Bub1DN), a protein known to inhibit spindle checkpoint activity in cultured cells, thymocytes show no evidence of spindle checkpoint impairment. Transgenic animals also failed to show an increased predisposition to spontaneous tumors. Moreover, the Bub1DN transgene failed to alter the timing or characteristics of thymic lymphoma development in p53 heterozygous or homozygous null backgrounds, indicating that the lack of tumorigenesis is not due to suppression by p53-dependent checkpoints. These results indicate that overexpression of a Bub1 N-terminal fragment is insufficient to impair the spindle checkpoint in vivo or to drive tumorigenesis in the highly susceptible murine thymocyte system, either alone or in combination with G(1) checkpoint disruption.

Elevated level of spindle checkprotein MAD2 correlates with cellular mitotic arrest, but not with aneuploidy and clinicopathological characteristics in gastric cancer

AIM: To study the relevance of spindle assembly checkprotein MAD2 to cellular mitotic status, aneuploidy and other clinicopathological characteristics in gastric cancer.

METHODS: Western blot analyses were performed to analyze the protein levels of MAD2 and cyclin B1 in the tumorous and adjacent nontumorous tissues of 34 gastric cancer patients. Cell cycle distribution and DNA ploidy of cancer tissues were also determined by flow cytometry. Conventional statistical methods were adopted to determine the relevance of abnormal MAD2 level to mitotic status, aneuploidy and clinicopathological parameters.

RESULTS: Out of 34 gastric cancer patients 25 (74%) exhibited elevated MAD2 levels in their tumorous tissues compared with the corresponding nontumorous tissues. Elevation of MAD2 levels significantly correlated with the increased levels of cyclin B1 expression and G₂/M-phase distribution (P = 0.038 and P = 0.033, respectively), but was not relevant to aneuploidy. The gastric cancer patients with elevated MAD2 levels showed a tendency toward better disease-free and overall survival (P > 0.05). However, no association was found between elevated MAD2 levels and patients’ clinicopathological characteristics.

CONCLUSION: Elevation of MAD2 level is present in 74% of gastric cancer patients, and correlates with increased mitotic checkpoint activity. However, elevation of MAD2 level is not associated with patients aneuploidy and any of the clinicopathological characteristics.

The spindle checkpoint: from normal cell division to tumorigenesis

Faithful chromosome segregation during each cell division is regulated by the spindle checkpoint. This surveillance mechanism monitors kinetochore-microtubule attachment and the integrity of the mitotic apparatus, delaying mitotic exit until all chromosomes are properly aligned at the metaphase plate. Failure of this mechanism can generate gross aneuploidy. Since its discovery, mutations in genes involved in the spindle checkpoint response were predicted to be serious candidates for the chromosomal instability phenotype observed in many tumors. During the last few years, significant advances have been made in understanding the molecular basis of the spindle checkpoint. However, many studies of tumor cell lines and primary cancer isolates have failed to show a direct correlation with mutations in spindle checkpoint components. Nevertheless, it was shown that many tumor cells have an abnormal spindle checkpoint. Therefore, better understanding of the molecular mechanisms involved in regulation of spindle checkpoint response are expected to provide important clues regarding the mechanisms underlying the emergence of neoplasia.

Epigenetic inactivation of CHFR in human tumors

Cell-cycle checkpoints controlling the orderly progression through mitosis are frequently disrupted in human cancers. One such checkpoint, entry into metaphase, is regulated by the CHFR gene encoding a protein possessing forkhead-associated and RING finger domains as well as ubiquitin-ligase activity. Although defects in this checkpoint have been described, the molecular basis and prevalence of CHFR inactivation in human tumors are still not fully understood. To address this question, we analyzed the pattern of CHFR expression in a number of human cancer cell lines and primary tumors. We found CpG methylation-dependent silencing of CHFR expression in 45% of cancer cell lines, 40% of primary colorectal cancers, 53% of colorectal adenomas, and 30% of primary head and neck cancers. Expression of CHFR was precisely correlated with both CpG methylation and deacetylation of histones H3 and H4 in the CpG-rich regulatory region. Moreover, CpG methylation and thus silencing of CHFR depended on the activities of two DNA methyltransferases, DNMT1 and DNMT3b, as their genetic inactivation restored CHFR expression. Finally, cells with CHFR methylation had an intrinsically high mitotic index when treated with microtubule inhibitor. This means that cells in which CHFR was epigenetically inactivated constitute loss-of-function alleles for mitotic checkpoint control. Taken together, these findings shed light on a pathway by which mitotic checkpoint is bypassed in cancer cells and suggest that inactivation of checkpoint genes is much more widespread than previously suspected.

Overexpression of the mitotic checkpoint genes BUB1, BUBR1, and BUB3 in gastric cancer--association with tumour cell proliferation

The mitotic spindle assembly checkpoint modulates the timing of anaphase initiation in response to improper alignment of chromosomes at the metaphase plate. The BUB gene family encodes proteins which are part of a large multi-protein kinetochore complex and which are believed to be key components of the checkpoint regulatory pathway. Failure of this surveillance system can lead to genomic instability and could be responsible for the increased incidence of aneuploidy in gastric cancer. Since mutations of BUB genes have not been identified in gastric cancer to date, altered BUB expression levels may significantly impair mitotic checkpoint function. To explore this possibility, the expression levels of BUB1, BUBR1, and BUB3 were determined in 43 gastric carcinomas and corresponding normal gastric mucosa by reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). Gene expression levels were compared with histopathological parameters and DNA ploidy, as well as with proliferative activity, measured by Ki-67 mRNA expression. To the authors' knowledge, this is the first study to investigate the expression levels of mitotic checkpoint genes together with DNA ploidy in gastric cancer. BUB1 was overexpressed in 84%, BUBR1 in 68%, and BUB3 in 79% of gastric cancers. This study also revealed that all three genes were simultaneously overexpressed in 61% of the tumours and that there was a statistically significant positive correlation between overexpression of BUB1, BUBR1 or BUB3 and Ki-67 expression (p < 0.001). Eighty-one per cent of the tumours were classified as aneuploid. However, no correlation was found between ploidy and BUB transcript expression levels. These results suggest that inactivation of the mitotic checkpoint genes BUB1, BUBR1, and BUB3 by epigenetic silencing does not seem to play a role in gastric carcinogenesis. The strong correlation of BUB expression level and tumour cell proliferation suggests that BUB overexpression is a proliferation-dependent phenomenon in gastric cancer. However, overexpression due to lack of normal BUB protein function or due to a yet unknown additional BUB function has to be considered.

Requirement of Skp1-Bub1 interaction for kinetochore-mediated activation of the spindle checkpoint

The spindle checkpoint transiently prevents cell cycle progression of cells that have incurred errors or failed to complete steps during mitosis, including those involving kinetochore function. The molecular nature of the primary signal transmitted from defective kinetochores and how it is detected by the spindle checkpoint are unknown. We report biochemical evidence that Bub1, a component of the spindle checkpoint, associates with centromere (CEN) DNA via Skp1, a core kinetochore component in budding yeast. The Skp1's interaction with Bub1 is required for the mitotic delay induced by kinetochore tension defects, but not for the arrest induced by spindle depolymerization, kinetochore assembly defects, or Mps1 overexpression. We propose that the Skp1-Bub1 interaction is important for transmitting a signal to the spindle checkpoint pathway when insufficient tension is present at kinetochores.

Genetic and transcriptional analysis of spindle checkpoint genes in bone marrow failure patients

The evolution of bone marrow failure syndromes such as aplastic anemia (AA) to clonal hematologic diseases such as myelodysplastic syndrome is well recognized. Cytogenetic abnormalities are commonly seen late events, particularly aneuploidy of chromosomes 7 and 8. A proportion of bone marrow failure patients may also develop aneuploidy that is detectable by fluorescence in situ hybridization but not by standard cytogenetic analysis. The molecular basis for aneuploidy in this setting is currently unknown but may include abnormalities in the mitotic spindle checkpoint. For this reason, we searched for mutations in the mitotic spindle checkpoint genes hBUB1 and hMAD2, and also examined the expression of hBUB1 in cells of bone marrow failure patients. No pathogenic mutations were found in 59 patients. Of 170 bone marrow failure patients, less than one-third expressed hBUB1 transcript. Gene expression profiling confirmed a significant down-regulation of hBUB1 message in patients. We conclude that mutations in mitotic spindle checkpoint genes do not account for aneuploidy in marrow failure states. However, we cannot exclude epigenetic inactivation of hBUB1 as a potential mechanism in some patients.

AURORA-A amplification overrides the mitotic spindle assembly checkpoint, inducing resistance to Taxol

The serine-threonine kinase gene AURORA-A is commonly amplified in epithelial malignancies. Here we show that elevated Aurora-A expression at levels that reflect cancer-associated gene amplification overrides the checkpoint mechanism that monitors mitotic spindle assembly, inducing resistance to the chemotherapeutic agent paclitaxel (Taxol). Cells overexpressing Aurora-A inappropriately enter anaphase despite defective spindle formation, and the persistence of Mad2 at the kinetochores, marking continued activation of the spindle assembly checkpoint. Mitosis is subsequently arrested by failure to complete cytokinesis, resulting in multinucleation. This abnormality is relieved by an inhibitory mutant of BUB1, linking the mitotic abnormalities provoked by Aurora-A overexpression to spindle checkpoint activity. Consistent with this conclusion, elevated Aurora-A expression causes resistance to apoptosis induced by Taxol in a human cancer cell line.

Genetic alterations of multiple tumor suppressors and oncogenes in the carcinogenesis and progression of lung cancer

Lung cancer has become the leading cause of cancer death in many economically well-developed countries. Recent molecular biological studies have revealed that overt lung cancers frequently develop through sequential morphological steps, with the accumulation of multiple genetic and epigenetic alterations affecting both tumor suppressor genes and dominant oncogenes. Cell cycle progression needs to be properly regulated, while cells have built-in complex and minute mechanisms such as cell cycle checkpoints to maintain genomic integrity. Genes in the p16INK4A-RB and p14ARF-p53 pathways appear to be a major target for genetic alterations involved in the pathogenesis of lung cancer. Several oncogenes are also known to be altered in lung cancer, leading to the stimulation of autocrine/paracrine loops and activation of multiple signaling pathways. It is widely acknowledged that carcinogens in cigarette smoke are deeply involved in these multiple genetic alterations, mainly through the formation of DNA adducts. A current understanding of the molecular mechanisms of lung cancer pathogenesis and progression is presented in relation to cigarette smoking, an absolute major risk factor for lung cancer development, by reviewing genetic alterations of various tumor suppressor genes and oncogenes thus far identified in lung cancer, with brief summaries of their functions and regulation.

Characterization of regions in hsMAD1 needed for binding hsMAD2. A polymorphic change in an hsMAD1 leucine zipper affects MAD1-MAD2 interaction and spindle checkpoint function

In eukaryotes, the mitotic spindle assembly checkpoint provides a monitor for the fidelity of chromosomal segregation. In this context, the mitotic arrest deficiency protein 2 (MAD2) censors chromosomal mis-segregation by monitoring microtubule attachment/tension, a role that requires its attachment to kinetochores. Studies in yeast have shown that binding of MAD1 to MAD2 is important for the checkpoint function of the latter. The interactions between human MAD1 (hsMAD1) and human MAD2 (hsMAD2) have, however, remained poorly characterized. Here we report that two leucine zipper domains (amino acids 501-522 and 557-571) in hsMAD1 are required for its contact with hsMAD2. Interestingly, in several cancer cell lines, we noted the frequent presence of a coding single nucleotide Arg to His polymorphism at codon 558 located within the second leucine zipper of hsMAD1. We found that hsMAD1H558 is less proficient than hsMAD1R558 in binding hsMAD2 and in enforcing mitotic arrest. We also document a first example of loss-of-heterozygosity for a spindle checkpoint gene (at the hsMAD1 558 locus) in a human breast cancer. Based on our findings, it is possible that hsMAD1H558 could be an at-risk polymorphism that contributes to attenuated spindle checkpoint function in human cells.

G(1) and G(2) cell-cycle arrest following microtubule depolymerization in human breast cancer cells

Microtubule-depolymerizing agents are widely used to synchronize cells, screen for mitotic checkpoint defects, and treat cancer. The present study evaluated the effects of these agents on normal and malignant human breast cell lines. After treatment with 1 microM nocodazole, seven of ten breast cancer lines (type A cells) arrested in mitosis, whereas the other three (type B cells) did not. Similar effects were observed with 100 nM vincristine or colchicine. Among five normal mammary epithelial isolates, four exhibited type A behavior and one exhibited type B behavior. Further experiments revealed that the type B cells exhibited a biphasic dose-response curve, with mitotic arrest at low drug concentrations (100 nM nocodazole or 6 nM vincristine) that failed to depolymerize microtubules and a p53-independent p21(waf1/cip1)-associated G(1) and G(2) arrest at higher concentrations (1 microM nocodazole or 100 nM vincristine) that depolymerized microtubules. Collectively, these observations provide evidence for coupling of premitotic cell-cycle progression to microtubule integrity in some breast cancer cell lines (representing a possible "microtubule integrity checkpoint") and suggest a potential explanation for the recently reported failure of some cancer cell lines to undergo nocodazole-induced mitotic arrest despite intact mitotic checkpoint proteins.

Minireview: branded from the start-distinct oncogenic initiating events may determine tumor fate in the thyroid

Thyroid follicular neoplasms commonly have aneuploidy, presumably due to chromosomal instability. This property is associated with a greater malignant potential and worse prognosis. Recently, there has been considerable progress in our understanding of mechanisms that may account for chromosomal instability in cancer cells. Many tumors with chromosomal instability have abnormalities in the cell cycle checkpoint that monitors the fidelity of mitosis. Mutations of Bub1 or BubR1, genes coding for kinases involved in mitotic spindle assembly checkpoint signaling, are found in a small subset of aneuploid tumors. Other components of protein complexes responsible for attachment of kinetochores to microtubules, or for cohesion between sister chromatids, may also be subject to alterations during tumor progression. Here, we also discuss the evidence that certain oncogenic events, such as Ras mutations, may predispose cells to chromosomal instability by favoring inappropriate posttranslational changes in mitotic checkpoint components through activation of upstream kinases during tumor initiation or progression.

Frequent impairment of the spindle assembly checkpoint in hepatocellular carcinoma

BACKGROUND

Chromosomal instability (CI) leading to aneuploidy is one form of genetic instability, a characteristic feature of various types of cancers. Recent work has suggested that CI can be induced by a spindle assembly checkpoint defect. The aim of the current study was to determine the frequency of a defect of the checkpoint in hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) and to establish whether alterations of genes encoding the checkpoint were associated with CI in HCC.

METHODS

Aneuploidy and the function of the spindle assembly checkpoint were examined using DNA flow cytometry and morphologic analysis with microtubule disrupting drugs. To explore the molecular basis, the authors examined the expression and alterations of the mitotic checkpoint gene, BUB1, using Northern hybridization and direct sequencing in 8 HCC cell lines and 50 HCC specimens. Furthermore, the authors examined the alterations of other mitotic checkpoint genes, BUBR1, BUB3, MAD2B, and CDC20, using direct sequencing in HCC cell lines with aneuploidy.

RESULTS

An impaired spindle assembly checkpoint was found in five (62.5%) of the eight aneuploid cell lines. Transcriptional expressions of the BUB1 gene appeared in all cell lines. While some polymorphic base changes were noted in BUB1, BUBR1, and CDC20, no mutations responsible for impairment of the mitotic checkpoint were found in either the HCC cell lines or HCC specimens, which suggests that these genes did not seem to be involved in tumor development in HCC.

CONCLUSIONS

The loss of spindle assembly checkpoint occurred with a high frequency in HCC with CI. However, other mechanisms might also contribute to CI in HCC.

Mechanisms of aneuploidy in thyroid cancer cell lines and tissues: evidence for mitotic checkpoint dysfunction without mutations in BUB1 and BUBR1

OBJECTIVE

Thyroid follicular adenomas (FA) and carcinomas (FC) have a high prevalence of aneuploidy. We examined the contribution of mitotic checkpoint dysfunction and mutations of BUB1 or BUBR1, components of the spindle assembly checkpoint pathway, to chromosomal instability in thyroid cancer.

DESIGN

The integrity of the mitotic checkpoint was studied in 8 aneuploid thyroid tumour cell lines. All cell lines as well as 9 FA, 9 FC, and 1 aneuploid papillary carcinoma were screened for mutations of BUB1 by SSCP and direct sequencing. Cell lines were also examined for mutations of BUBR1.

RESULTS

Neither FRO, NPA nor WRO cells arrested in mitosis after treatment with nocodazole, whereas other aneuploid cell lines paused appropriately following microtubule disruption. One FC had a 2-bp somatic deletion (G2480/A2481) of BUB1 leading to a frameshift, and one FC had a silent polymorphism at nucleotide 1049 (TGT-TGC). There was a silent polymorphism of BUBR1 (G1271A) in one sample.

CONCLUSION

Some, but not all thyroid cancer cell lines with aneuploidy have an abnormal mitotic checkpoint, indicating that chromosomal instability may arise through alternative cell cycle defects. Moreover, mutations of BUB1 or BUBR1 are infrequent in follicular neoplasms, and do not account for aneuploidy in thyroid cancer.

Prevalent loss of mitotic spindle checkpoint in adult T-cell leukemia confers resistance to microtubule inhibitors

Human T-cell leukemia virus type I (HTLV-I) is the causative agent for adult T-cell leukemia (ATL). Molecularly, ATL cells have extensive aneugenic abnormalities that occur, at least in part, from cell cycle dysregulation by the HTLV-I-encoded Tax oncoprotein. Here, we compared six HTLV-I-transformed cells to Jurkat and primary peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) in their responses to treatment with microtubule inhibitors. We found that both Jurkat and PBMCs arrested efficiently in mitosis when treated with nocodazole. By contrast, all six HTLV-I cells failed to arrest comparably in mitosis, suggesting that ATL cells have a defect in the mitotic spindle assembly checkpoint. Mechanistically, we observed that in HTLV-I Tax-expressing cells human spindle assembly checkpoint factors hsMAD1 and hsMAD2 were mislocated from the nucleus to the cytoplasm. This altered localization of hsMAD1 and hsMAD2 correlated with loss of mitotic checkpoint function and chemoresistance to microtubule inhibitors.

Expression of hBUB1 in acute myeloid leukemia

hBUB1 gene is a component of the mitotic checkpoint that monitors proper assembly of the mitotic spindles and the alteration of the hBUB1 gene has been found to be associated with chromosomal instability in some tumor cell lines. We analyzed the coding region of the hBUB1 gene for mutations and its expression in 92 acute myeloid leukemia (AML) specimens and five hematopoietic cell lines. We also used Southern hybridization to analyze the genomic DNA of those cases, which had aberrant transcription to confirm the lesion. A thymine/cytosine polymorphism at 8 bp upstream of the 5' splice acceptor site of exon 10 was observed in Raji cell line and two AML specimens without a resultant change in the expression of hBUB1. Reduced expression and aberrant transcription of the hBUB1 gene, which may affect the control of mitotic checkpoint, were detected in AML specimens by reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) analysis. Our study suggests that the mutation of the hBUB1 gene is a rare event in AML, and further studies are necessary to clarify its role in leukemia.

Expression of Bub1 gene correlates with tumor proliferating activity in human gastric carcinomas

Bub1 plays an important role at the spindle assembly checkpoint to prevent cell cycle progression following spindle damage. We examined the expression of human Bub1 mRNA in 20 gastric carcinoma tissues and corresponding nonneoplastic mucosas by reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction and analyzed the relation with proliferative activity monitored by the expression of proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) on Western blotting as well as Ki-67 labeling index by immunohistochemistry. Increased expression of Bub1 mRNA was detected in 8 (40%) of the gastric carcinomas in comparison with their nonneoplastic counterparts, while 4 (20%) expressed Bub1 at lower levels. The expression of Bub1 mRNA was confirmed by in situ hybridization. The expression levels of Bub1 mRNA were well correlated with the levels of PCNA protein in 16 (80%) gastric carcinoma cases. The examination of Ki-67 labeling indices proved the close correlation between the expression levels of Bub1 and proliferating activity. These findings suggest that mRNA expression of human Bub1 gene is closely associated with the tumor-proliferating activity. Since genetic alterations of human Bub1 rarely occur in gastrointestinal cancers, the functional machinery of Bub1 to prevent cell cycle progression into anaphase might be well preserved in gastric carcinomas even with high proliferative activity.

Increased expression of T-fimbrin gene after DNA damage in CHO cells and inactivation of T-fimbrin by CpG methylation in human colorectal cancer cells

When DNA damage is induced by unprogrammed extrinsic events, activating-cell-cycle checkpoints delay cell-cycle progression in the G1 or G2 phases and allow repair of a damaged template. In this study, we evaluated changes in gene expression upon radiation-induced G2 cell-cycle arrest using Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. T-fimbrin, an actin-binding protein, was overexpressed in CHO cells in which G2 arrest had been induced by X-radiation. Northern blot analysis revealed that T-fimbrin gene expression was induced not only by X-radiation but also by a topoisomerase II inhibitor, etoposide. Transfection of CHO cells with a vector encoding T-fimbrin antisense RNA demonstrated that reduced T-fimbrin expression induced alterations in cell-cycle control; radiation-induced G2 arrest was short and decreased in cells transfected with antisense T-fimbrin. Additionally, T-fimbrin gene expression was suppressed in a human colorectal cancer cell line, SW948, because of promoter-specific DNA methylation. These results suggest that downregulation of T-fimbrin may be involved in cancer development through G2/M cell-cycle control in mammalian cells.

Molecular analyses of the mitotic checkpoint components hsMAD2, hBUB1 and hBUB3 in human cancer

During the metaphase-anaphase transition, the spindle checkpoint prevents segregation of chromosomes if the spindle assembly is perturbed. Critical components of this checkpoint are the MAD and BUB families of proteins, which prevent the proteolysis of Pds1 and B cyclins, producing mitotic arrest. In the present study, we first intended to resolve the role of the hsMAD2 gene in human cancer by determining the potential presence of hsMAD2 mutations in 44 primary bladder tumors, 42 soft-tissue sarcomas and 10 hepatocellular carcinomas. The entire coding region of the hsMAD2 gene was analyzed using PCR-SSCP and sequencing. One of the bladder tumor samples showed a point mutation consisting of a transition, ATC-->GTC (Ile-->Val) in codon 190 of hsMAD2. However, no differences were found in the mitotic arrest between cells transfected with mutant and wild-type MAD2 cDNA. We also identified mobility shifts in hsMAD2 in both normal and tumor DNA in 3 bladder tumors, 3 soft-tissue sarcomas and 1 hepatocellular carcinoma, consistent with a polymorphism at codon 143, CCA-->CCG (Pro-->Pro). Another polymorphism was identified in a hepatocellular carcinoma case at codon 22, GAG-->GAA (Glu-->Glu). In addition, a subgroup of 67 primary tumors was analyzed by Southern blot hybridization. No deletion or visible re-arrangements were detected by comparing tumor and normal DNA band signals. Two other important components of the spindle mitotic checkpoint, hBUB1 and hBUB3, were also screened for mutations: hBUB1 in 43 bladder tumors and 9 bladder cell lines and hBUB3 only in the cell lines. Two polymorphisms were found in hBUB1 at positions 144, CAG-->CAA (Gln-->Gln) in 1 primary tumor and 1 bladder cell line, and 913 (ATC-->ATT, Ile-->Ile) in 1 primary tumor. We did not find sequence alterations in hBUB3. These results suggest that mutations of the hsMAD2, hBUB1 and hBUB3 genes are very rare in bladder tumors and that hsMAD2 alterations are also infrequent in soft-tissue sarcomas and hepatocellular carcinomas.

Aneuploid colon cancer cells have a robust spindle checkpoint

Colon cancer cells frequently display minisatellite instability (MIN) or chromosome instability (CIN). While MIN is caused by mismatch repair defects, the lesions responsible for CIN are unknown. The observation that CIN cells fail to undergo mitotic arrest following spindle damage suggested that mutations in spindle checkpoint genes may account for CIN. However, here we show that CIN cells do undergo mitotic arrest in response to spindle damage. Although the maximum mitotic index achieved by CIN lines is diminished relative to MIN lines, CIN cells clearly have a robust spindle checkpoint. Consistently, mutations in spindle checkpoint genes are rare in human tumours. In contrast, the adenomatous polyposis coli (APC) gene is frequently mutated in CIN cells. Significantly, we show here that expression of an APC mutant in MIN cells reduces the mitotic index following spindle damage to a level observed in CIN cells, suggesting that APC dysfunction may contribute to CIN.

Checkpoint genes in cancer

The mammalian cell cycle is exquisitely controlled by a 'machinery' composed of cyclin-dependent kinases and their binding partners, the cyclins. These kinases regulate transitions into DNA synthesis and mitosis, and their inactivity contributes to cellular quiescence, differentiation and senescence. Cell cycle transitions are, in turn, controlled by checkpoints that monitor ribonucleotide pools, oxygen tension, the extracellular environment, growth signalling programmes, the status of DNA replication, and the mitotic spindle apparatus. Genes positively controlling cell cycle checkpoints can be targets for oncogenic activation in cancer, whereas negative regulators, such as tumour suppressor genes, are targeted for inactivation. Understanding the molecular details of cell cycle regulation and checkpoint abnormalities in cancer offers insight into potential therapeutic strategies.

Pleiotropic effects of HTLV type 1 Tax protein on cellular metabolism: mitotic checkpoint abrogation and NF-kappaB activation

Tax protein expressed by human T cell leukemia virus type 1 (HTLV-1) is a strong trans-activator of its own LTR promoter; it also affects the function of multiple cellular genes involved in cell cycle control and transcription. One way in which Tax exerts its pleiotropic effects is through protein-protein interaction with cellular cofactors. By using yeast two-hybrid technology, we have isolated several cellular proteins that bind to Tax. Two of these are MAD1, a mitotic checkpoint control protein, and TXBP151, a suppressor of tumor necrosis factor alpha-induced apoptosis. Here we discuss findings describing the role of MAD1 in exit of cells from mitosis and TXBP151 in NF-kappaB activation.

Somatic mutation of the hBUB1 mitotic checkpoint gene in primary lung cancer

Mutations in mitotic checkpoint genes have been detected in several human cancers, and these cancers exhibit chromosomal instability. Aneuploid stem cells seem to result from chromosomal instability and have been reported in many lung cancers. To determine whether alteration of mitotic checkpoint regulators is involved in carcinogenesis and tumor progression in primary lung cancer, we screened the genomic DNA sequence of 30 human lung cancer cell lines and 30 primary lung cancer tumors for a mutation in the hBUB1 mitotic checkpoint gene. First, we designed 26 sets of intron-based primers to amplify each of the 25 exons of the hBUB1 gene to examine the entire coding region of the hBUB1 gene. Using these primers, we performed polymerase chain reaction-single strand conformation polymorphism (PCR-SSCP) analysis as well as direct sequencing in the mutation analysis of the hBUB1 gene. Three different nucleotide substitutions were detected in the coding region of the hBUB1 gene in some of the cancer cell lines and primary tumors as follows. The hBUB1 gene of one adenocarcinoma tumor contained a somatic missense mutation, a cytosine-to-guanine substitution in codon 51 of exon 5 that resulted in a histidine-to-aspartic acid amino acid substitution. The hBUB1 gene of three lung cancer cell lines contained a thymine-to-cytosine substitution in codon 430 of exon 12, which did not result in an amino-acid substitution. We were unable to determine whether the nucleotide substitution in exon 12 was a polymorphism or a silent mutation because matched normal tissue was not available. A polymorphism in codon 93 of exon 4, a guanine-to-thymine substitution, in hBUB1 was found in one lung cancer cell line and one primary lung tumor. This is the first report of a somatic missense mutation of a gene involved in a mitotic checkpoint in primary lung cancer. The presence of a point mutation in the hBUB1 gene is consistent with the hypothesis that alteration of mitotic checkpoint genes is involved in the development of primary lung cancers. Because the frequency of hBUB1 gene mutations was low, future studies should focus on other mechanisms of inactivation of the hBUB1 gene as well as mutation analysis of other mitotic checkpoint genes in lung cancers.

Mutation analysis of mitotic checkpoint genes (hBUB1 and hBUBR1) and microsatellite instability in adult T-cell leukemia/lymphoma

Adult T-cell leukemia/lymphoma (ATLL) is a neoplasm of T-lymphocytes, and human T-cell lymphotropic virus type-I (HTLV-I) is etiologically considered as the causative virus of ATLL. The karyotypes of ATLL are very complex in both number and structure, although no specific karyotype abnormalities have been identified. HTLV-I is thought to integrate its provirus into random sites in host chromosomal DNA and induces chromosomal instability. The BUB gene is a component of the mitotic checkpoint in budding yeast. Recently, human homologues of the BUB were identified and mutant alleles of hBUB1 and hBUBR1 were detected in two colorectal tumor cell lines, which showed microsatellite instability (MIN). In vitro, BUB proteins form a complex of monomers. These proteins interact with the human MAD1 gene product, a target of the HTLV-1 tax oncogene. We examined the role of checkpoint gene in the chromosomal abnormalities of ATLL by investigating mutations of hBUB1 and hBUBR1, and MIN of replication errors of BAX, insulin-like growth factor, and transforming growth factor beta type II. We analyzed ten cases with ATLL and eight B-cell lymphomas (five diffuse large cell lymphomas, three follicular lymphomas). Complex chromosomal abnormalities were detected in ATLL, while B-cell lymphomas showed only simple or minimal chromosomal abnormalities. Significant mutations/deletion of hBUB1 or hBUBR1 were detected in four of ten cases with ATLL, including two heterozygous point mutations, one homozygous point mutation, and one with a 47 bp deletion. In contrast, only one of eight B-cell lymphomas showed nonsense mutation of hBUBR1. None of the ATLL and B-cell lymphomas showed MIN. In the multistage process of leukemogenesis of ATLL, our findings indicate that mutations of mitotic checkpoint genes may play an important role in the induction of complex chromosomal abnormalities.

Chfr defines a mitotic stress checkpoint that delays entry into metaphase

Chemicals that target microtubules induce mitotic stress by affecting several processes that occur during mitosis. These processes include separation of the centrosomes in prophase, alignment of the chromosomes on the spindle in metaphase and sister-chromatid separation in anaphase. Many human cancers are sensitive to mitotic stress. This sensitivity is being exploited for therapy and implies checkpoint defects. The known mitotic checkpoint genes, which prevent entry into anaphase when the chromosomes are not properly aligned on the mitotic spindle, are, however, rarely inactivated in human cancer. Here we describe the chfr gene, which is inactivated owing to lack of expression or by mutation in four out of eight human cancer cell lines examined. Normal primary cells and tumour cell lines that express wild-type chfr exhibited delayed entry into metaphase when centrosome separation was inhibited by mitotic stress. In contrast, the tumour cell lines that had lost chfr function entered metaphase without delay. Ectopic expression of wild-type chfr restored the cell cycle delay and increased the ability of the cells to survive mitotic stress. Thus, chfr defines a checkpoint that delays entry into metaphase in response to mitotic stress.

Infrequent mutation of the hBUB1 and hBUBR1 genes in human lung cancer

Mitotic checkpoint defects of the cell cycle have been implicated in the development of human cancers. Since hBUB1 and hBUBR1, whose products function in the spindle checkpoint pathway, have been shown to be mutated in a subset of colon cancers with chromosomal instability, we investigated the contribution of these genes to lung cancer development. One hundred and two lung cancer (50 small cell lung cancers and 52 non-small cell lung cancers) and 4 mesothelioma cell line DNAs were analyzed by Southern blot analysis, but no rearrangements or deletions of hBUB1 and hBUBR1 were detected. Using single strand conformation polymorphism analysis, we studied all the 25 exons except exon 1 of the hBUB1 gene in 88 lung cancer DNAs. One lung cancer cell line, NCI-H345, showed a single nucleotide substitution, which resulted in an Arg-to-Gln change at codon 209 (CGA to CAA). Eleven cell line DNAs exhibited a single nucleotide polymorphism in intron 9 of hBUB1, all of which were heterozygous. Similar mutation analysis of hBUBR1 in 47 lung cancer cell line cDNAs revealed a frequent polymorphism at codon 349 (CAA to CGA) leading to a substitution of Gln to Arg but no mutations. Northern blot analyses showed that both hBUB1 and hBUBR1 genes were expressed in all of 31 lung cancer cell lines tested with no significant difference in the expression level. Our results suggest that alterations in hBUB1 and hBUBR1 rarely contributed to the genetic change of lung cancers.

Significance of multiple mutations in cancer

There is increasing evidence that in eukaryotic cells, DNA undergoes continuous damage, repair and resynthesis. A homeostatic equilibrium exists in which extensive DNA damage is counterbalanced by multiple pathways for DNA repair. In normal cells, most DNA damage is repaired without error. However, in tumor cells this equilibrium may be skewed, resulting in the accumulation of multiple mutations. Among genes mutated are those that function in guaranteeing the stability of the genome. Loss of this stability results in a mutator phenotype. Evidence for a mutator phenotype in human cancers includes the frequent occurrence of gene amplification, microsatellite instability, chromosomal aberrations and aneuploidy. Current experiments have centered on two mechanisms for the generation of genomic instability, one focused on mutations in mismatch repair genes resulting in microsatellite instability, and one focused on mutations in genes that are required for chromosomal segregation resulting in chromosomal aberrations. This dichotomy may reflect only the ease by which these manifestations can be identified. Underlying both pathways may be a more general phenomenon involving the selection for mutator genes during tumor progression. During carcinogenesis there is selection for cells harboring mutations that can overcome adverse conditions that limit tumor growth. These mutations are produced by direct DNA damage as well as secondarily as a result of mutations in genes that cause a mutator phenotype. Thus, as tumor progression selects for cells with specific mutations, it also selects for cancer cells harboring mutations in genes that normally function in maintaining genetic instability.

Killing the umpire: cooperative defects in mitotic checkpoint and BRCA2 genes on the road to transformation

Recent findings from mouse models of BRCA2 genetic lesions have provided intriguing insights and important questions concerning modes of tumor development in familial breast and ovarian cancers. Fibroblasts from mice homozygous for the BRCA2Tr allele grow poorly and display an array of chromosomal abnormalities that are consistent with a role for BRCA2 in DNA repair. This growth defect can be overcome and cellular transformation promoted by the expression of defective, dominant negative alleles of p53 and of the mitotic checkpoint gene Bub1, both of which are known to induce chromosome instability. These findings are mirrored in the genetic lesions sustained in tumors found in the rare BRCA2Tr/Trmice that survive to adulthood, which include defects in p53 as well as the mitotic checkpoint proteins Bub1 and Mad3L. Together, these data hint that tumors in these mice evolve from an unusually intense selective pressure to remove DNA damage checkpoints, which in turn might be facilitated by chromosomal abolition of mitotic checkpoints and the consequent increase in shuffling of genetic information. How these genetic lesions co-operate to yield transformed cells and how these data relate to BRCA1 and BRCA2 defects in the human population are important questions raised by this work.