In vitro assays to predict the severity of hemolytic disease of the newborn

Identification and management of fetal anemia due to hemolytic disease

INTRODUCTION

Hemolytic disease of the fetus and newborn (HDFN) is a condition caused by maternal alloantibodies against fetal red blood cells (RBCs) that can cause severe morbidity and mortality in the fetus and newborn. Adequate screening programs allow for timely prevention and intervention resulting in significant reduction of the disease over the last decades. Nevertheless, HDFN still occurs and with current treatment having reached an optimum, focus shifts toward noninvasive therapy options.

AREAS COVERED

This review focusses on the timely identification of high risk cases and antenatal management. Furthermore, we elaborate on future perspectives including improvement of screening, identification of high risk cases and promising treatment options.

EXPERT OPINION

In high-income countries mortality and morbidity rates due to HDFN have drastically been reduced over the last decades, yet worldwide anti-D mediated HDFN still accounts for 160,000 perinatal deaths and 100,000 patients with disabilities every year. Much of these deaths and disabilities could have been avoided with proper identification and prophylaxis. By implementing sustainable prevention, screening, and disease treatment measures in all countries this will systemically reduce unnecessary perinatal deaths. There is a common responsibility to engage in this cause.

Title: Effect of multiple maternal red cell alloantibodies on the occurrence and severity of Hemolytic Disease of the Fetus and Newborn

INTRODUCTION

Antenatal antibody screening in India is focused on the detection of anti-D in RhD-negative mothers. HDFN outcome can also be affected by the presence of antibodies other than anti-D. We planned this study to find the impact of 'anti-D in combination with additional antibodies' on the development and severity of HDFN compared with 'anti-D alone'.

METHODS

This is a retrospective study performed at a referral center in northern India from October 2015 to March 2018. Antibody screening was performed on women with complicated obstetric history. Women with anti-D antibody were included in the study and categorized on the basis of presence of additional antibody (anti-D alone or in combination with other antibody). Various clinical, laboratory & interventional parameters were used to define HDFN and severe HDFN. Perinatal outcome was then compared between the two groups.

RESULTS

A total of 176 women with anti-D antibody were included in the study. Of these, 136 cases (77.3%) had anti-D alone while at least one additional antibody was present in 40 (22.7 %) cases. Most common additional antibodies were anti-C, anti-E and anti-c. After excluding 46 women for various reasons, 130 women were left for final analysis. Approximately 57% and 78% of cases were affected by severe HDFN amongst women with anti-D alone and in combination, respectively. Relative risk of developing severe HDFN was 1.7 times higher in women with additional antibody.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with combination antibodies were found to have more severe HDFN compared to the ones with anti-D alone.

Specificity and isotype of Rh specific antibodies produced by human B-cell lines established from alloimmunized Rh negative women

Despite the successful outcome of anti-D prophylaxis program, alloimmunization still occurs. The aim of this study was to examine the specificity and isotype of anti-Rh antibodies in plasma samples of Rh negative alloimmunized individuals and to study the same parameters in lymphoblastoid cell lines (LCLs) generated from the same donors. Specificity of anti-Rh antibodies was determined in plasma of nine alloimmunized subjects by direct hemagglutination using a panel of known RBC genotypes and isotype of specific antibodies were identified by an antigen specific ELISA. Similar methods were employed to determine specificity and isotype of antibodies produced by Rh specific LCLs established from four donors. LCLs were generated by Epstein-Barr virus transformation of peripheral blood mononuclear cells isolated from each donor followed by their culture over a feeder of human fetal fibroblasts. Upon emergence of lymphoblastoid cells, culture supernatants were assayed for presence of Rh specific antibody by hemagglutination assay. Anti-D was the predominant antibody in both plasma samples and among the 128 established LCLs; however, antibodies to other Rh specificities namely C and E were also produced. The isotype of anti-Rh antibody in all plasma samples was found to be IgG, predominantly IgG1, combined in 7 samples with IgM. Similarly 76%, 9.2% and 14.8% of LCLs were determined to produce antibody of IgG, IgM and of both isotypes, respectively. The data supported that the D antigen is the immunodominant component of the Rh system as indicated by the in vitro and in vivo profiles of Rh specificities in our alloimmunized subjects.

Use of red cells preserved in extended storage media for exchange transfusion in anti-k haemolytic disease of the newborn

Anti-k is a Kell-related antibody. There is little correlation between the maternal antibody titre and the severity of haemolytic disease of the foetus and newborn, and anaemia is usually associated with low bilirubin levels. Severe erythroblastosis has been reported with a low titre anti-k (IAT 8-16). We report a case of severe haemolytic disease of the newborn (HDN) due to anti-k. HDN was associated with a normal bilirubin level and reticulocytopenia. The foetus was monitored by ultrasound, and delivery by elective caesarean section (CS) was planned. The mother was admitted 1 week before the expected date of delivery, and the infant was delivered by urgent CS. The infant required exchange transfusion. As suitable plasma-reduced (k antigen(-)) red cell units were not readily available, k- SAGM red cell units (preserved in extended storage media: SAGM sodium chloride, adenine, glucose and mannitol) were provided. The post-transfusion Hb remained stable, and the infant did not require further transfusion support. Our findings (reticulocytopenia and normal bilirubin levels) support the hypothesis that the pathogenesis of anaemia and haemolysis in anti-k HDN may be similar to that in anti-K (suppression of erythropoesis and immune destruction of K+ erythroid progenitor cells by macrophages in the foetal liver). The ideal product for exchange transfusion is plasma-reduced RBC, less than 5-days old. We provided a 4-day-old SAGM red cell unit for exchange transfusion in a term infant, and this was uneventful. Caution should be taken, however, and renal function and electrolyte levels should be monitored closely. More information is required regarding the safety of SAGM units for exchange transfusion.

Étude quantitative des sous-classes d’IgG anti-D par Élisa au cours de la maladie hémolytique néonatale

The quantification of IgG anti-D subclasses is one of the most important parameters considered in the assessment of the severity of hemolytic disease of the newborn. Traditionally IgG subclassing is performed using qualitative haemagglutination methods, difficult to interpret. A quantitative enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (Elisa) was implemented for measuring IgG anti-D subclasses in 20 sera collected from 14 RhD-immunized pregnant women. All 4 IgG subclasses were detected in the 20 sera tested. The mean proportion of IgG1 was 52.8%. The mean proportion of IgG3 was 30.7%. The mean proportions of IgG2 and IgG4 were 14.5 and 1.9% respectively. A good correlation between the sum of IgG subclasses and the severity of HDN was found. Severe HDN occurred when both IgG1 and IgG3 were present. IgG1 anti-D was the predominant subclass in 4 of the 8 severe cases.

Laboratory assays for predicting the severity of haemolytic disease of the fetus and newborn

Haemolytic disease of the fetus and newborn (HDFN) is characterised by the presence of IgG antibodies in the maternal circulation which cause haemolysis in the fetus by crossing the placenta and sensitising red cells for destruction by macrophages in the fetal spleen. Serological, quantitative and cellular assays have all been developed to predict the severity of HDFN. These assays measure and/or characterise alloantibodies in the maternal circulation. Quantitative assays which accurately measure antibody levels correlate with disease severity better than serological assays which are inherently less precise. Nevertheless, high antibody levels are found in some cases of mild HFDN and relatively low antibody levels are found in some severe cases. This suggests that disease severity is influenced by factors in addition to antibody concentration. These factors remain to be fully elucidated but may include: the subclass and glycosylation of maternal antibodies; the structure, site density, maturational development and tissue distribution of blood group antigens; the efficiency of IgG transport to the fetus; the functional maturity of the fetal spleen; polymorphisms which affect Fc receptor function; and the presence of HLA-related inhibitory antibodies. Cellular assays which are sensitive to factors affecting antibody function have, therefore, been developed in an attempt to improve the prediction of disease severity. Although these assays are cumbersome, there are now sufficient data to suggest that some cellular assays provide clinically useful information to complement serological and quantitative assays.

Kell expression on myeloid progenitor cells

Kell is one of the major human red blood cell groups and comprises 22 antigens. These antigens are produced by alleles located on chromosome 7, including sets of antithetical antigens such as Kell (K, K1) and cellano (k, K2), which differ in a single amino acid change (T193M). It consists of a 93-Kd transmembrane glycoprotein that is surface-exposed and shares sequence and structural homology with zinc endopeptidases, which are involved in regulating bioactive peptides. Anti-Kell antibodies have been shown to suppress fetal erythropoiesis. Recently published data indicate a similar effect on myeolopoiesis and megakaryopoiesis. Substantial thrombocytopenia in fetuses affected with HDN due to anti-K antibodies led to the discovery of the inhibitory effect of Kell-related antibodies on CFU-MK growth. In addition to its inhibitory effect on BFU-E growth, anti-Kell antibodies significantly reduced CFU-GM colony formation from haematologically normal individuals. Moreover, anti-cellano and anti-Kp(b) antibodies also inhibited the growth of CFU-GM from antigen positive MNC. These data indicate that Kell is not restricted to erythroid blood cells, but is expressed on a broader spectrum of haematopoietic cells than previously believed.

Recombinant human IgG molecules lacking Fcgamma receptor I binding and monocyte triggering activities

Subclasses of human IgG have a range of activity levels with different effector systems but each triggers at least one mechanism of cell destruction. We are aiming to engineer non-destructive human IgG constant regions for therapeutic applications where depletion of cells bearing the target antigen is undesirable. The attributes required are a lack of killing via Fcgamma receptors (R) and complement but retention of neonatal FcR binding to maintain placental transport and the prolonged half-life of IgG. Eight variants of human IgG constant regions were made with anti-RhD and CD52 specificities. The mutations, in one or two key regions of the CH2 domain, were restricted to incorporation of motifs from other subclasses to minimize potential immunogenicity. IgG2 residues at positions 233 - 236, substituted into IgG1 and IgG4, reduced binding to FcgammaRI by 10(4)-fold and eliminated the human monocyte response to antibody-sensitized red blood cells, resulting in antibodies which blocked the functions of active antibodies. If glycine 236, which is deleted in IgG2, was restored to the IgG1 and IgG4 mutants, low levels of activity were observed. Introduction of the IgG4 residues at positions 327, 330 and 331 of IgG1 and IgG2 had no effect on FcgammaRI binding but caused a small decrease in monocyte triggering.

Evaluation by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay of IgG anti-D and IgG subclass concentrations in immunoglobulin preparations

BACKGROUND

Anti-D immunoglobulin preparations are injected to prevent hemolytic disease of the newborn. The concentration of IgG anti-D in these preparations is usually determined by an automated hemagglutination technique using as a reference a calibrated preparation of anti-D, but the method requires special equipment and cannot be routinely applied to measure the IgG subclasses of anti-D in these preparations.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

Taking advantage of a recently described enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for the determination of the anti-D concentration in sera of alloimmunized pregnant women, IgG anti-D and IgG subclass concentrations were measured in the international reference preparation (IRP) coded 68/419, 10 anti-D immunoglobulin preparations, and sera of 15 D-immunized volunteers.

RESULTS

An IgG anti-D concentration of 61.5 +/- 4.8 microg per ampoule (mean +/- SD) was found by ELISA in IRP 68/419. This result was in agreement with previous determinations obtained by radioimmunoassay (60 microg/ampoule). The IgG subclass concentration of anti-D in this preparation was 48.4 microg of IgG1 (78.6%), 3.0 microg of IgG2 (4.8%), 9.7 microg of IgG3 (15.8%), and 0.4 microg of IgG4 (0.7%). The mean proportion of IgG subclasses of anti-D in 10 immunoglobulin preparations was similar (81.7% for IgG1, 5.0% for IgG2, 12.7% for IgG3, and 0.6% for IgG4). In the sera of 15 immunized volunteers, the IgG anti-D concentration varied from 3.1 to 68.4 microg per mL. The mean IgG subclass composition of anti-D was 79.3 percent for IgG1, 2.2 percent for IgG2, 18.1 percent for IgG3, and 0.4 percent for IgG4. The proportions of IgG3 anti-D in these sera were found to range between 1 percent and 87 percent, as in the sera of D-alloimmunized pregnant women.

CONCLUSION

ELISA provides an alternative to the radioimmunoassay and the automated hemagglutination technique. In addition, it allows the evaluation of the absolute concentration of each IgG subclass of anti-D in immunoglobulin preparations and necessitates only the conventional equipment required for an immunoenzymatic assay.

A comparison of in vitro tests for predicting the severity of haemolytic disease of the fetus and newborn

Haemolytic disease of the newborn (HDN) is characterized by the presence of IgG antibodies in the maternal circulation which cause haemolysis in the fetus by crossing the placenta and sensitizing red cells for destruction by macrophages in the fetal spleen. Numerous serological, quantitative and cellular assays have been developed to predict the severity of HDN. These assays all measure and/or characterize alloantibodies in the maternal circulation. Quantitative assays which accurately measure antibody levels correlate with disease severity better than serological assays which are inherently less precise. Nevertheless, high antibody levels are found in some cases of mild HDN and relatively low antibody levels are found in some severe cases. This suggests that disease severity is influenced by factors in addition to antibody concentration. These factors remain to be fully elucidated but may include the subclass and glycosylation of maternal antibodies, the structure, site density, maturational development and tissue distribution of blood group antigens, the efficiency of IgG transport to the fetus, the functional maturity of the fetal spleen, polymorphisms which affect Fc receptor function, and the presence of HLA-related inhibitory antibodies. Cellular assays which are sensitive to factors affecting antibody function have therefore been developed in an attempt to improve the prediction of disease severity. Although these assays are cumbersome, there are now sufficient data to suggest that some cellular assays, when used as part of a structured approach to diagnostic testing, may provide clinically-useful information to complement serological and quantitative assays.

The ability of the chemiluminescence test to predict clinical outcome and the necessity for amniocenteses in pregnancies at risk of haemolytic disease of the newborn

The chemiluminescence test measures the ability of anti-D to sensitise red cells for recognition by monocytes. It predicts clinical outcome in haemolytic disease of the newborn with greater precision than quantification of anti-D levels by AutoAnalyzer. However, whether or not the chemiluminescence test can, or should, affect clinical management is not clear. Of 56 alloimmunised women referred to a single fetal medicine unit, 30 underwent a total 63 amniocenteses to establish the extent of fetal haemolysis. Overall, chemiluminescence test results were a better predictor of amniocenteses with elevated bilirubin levels than the AutoAnalyzer (P < 0.01). Chemiluminescence results > 30% were always associated with elevated bilirubin levels. The chemiluminescence test might be used to prompt the direct evaluation of fetal haemolysis in patients with borderline levels of anti-D (5-15 IU/mL). However, the ability of the test to predict amniocenteses with normal bilirubin levels was less clear.

The management of hemolytic disease in the fetus and newborn

Rh hemolytic disease (HDN) is the prototype of maternal alloimmunization and fetal hemolytic disease. There are other antigens capable of causing alloimmunization and hemolytic disease such as c, Kell, and Fya. Rh immunization is usually caused by a prior Rh positive fetal maternal transplacental hemorrhage, which occurs in at least 75% of pregnancies. Unless treated, hemolytic disease will result in kernicterus or fetal hydrops in 25% of cases, respectively. Neonatal exchange transfusion has eradicated kernicterus. Measures available to predict severity of fetal hemolytic disease are maternal antibody titers, prior history of hemolytic disease, in vitro cell-mediated maternal antibody functional assays, amniotic fluid spectrophotometry, ultrasound fetal assessment, and fetal blood sampling. The Rh or Kell antigen status of the fetus may be determined by amniotic fluid PCR testing. The management of the severely affected fetus consists of early delivery, with or without fetal transfusions, depending on the gestation of the fetus. With the use of these diagnostic and treatment measures, perinatal mortality from hemolytic disease of the fetus and newborn has been reduced in Manitoba, population one million, from 100 per year in the early 1940s to 1 every 3 years in the mid 1990s.

Human Rh monoclonal antibodies: assessment of functional activity by chemiluminescence and RhD antibody quantitation

In vitro cellular assays have been described which are capable of evaluating the interactions between sensitised red cells and monocyte or K cells. The chemiluminescence assay (CL) has several advantages over other cellular assays used to assess functional activity. The CL assay unlike the ADCC assays does not require the use of radioisotopes and therefore can be easily integrated into the work of a Reference Serology laboratory. The CL assay is an objective test and not labour intensive which is the main criticism of the monocyte monolayer assay. Seventy-four monoclonal anti-Ds and 29 other Rh specificities have been evaluated by a CL assay. The use of the chemiluminescent response produced by erythrophagocytosis of sensitised red cells has been shown to correlate well with the in vivo response to red cells sensitized with polyclonal IgG antibodies. This study aimed at investigating whether the CL assay could identify and differentiate monoclonal antibodies that are capable of eliciting a response from human monocytes. Poor correlation was obtained between the CL assay results and anti-D quantitation (r = 0.236). The chemiluminescence assay discriminated between anti-D's with high quantitation levels but low predicted functional activity and anti-Ds of low quantitation levels which produced elevated CL responses. Only 3 of the 29 non-Rh D specificities tested produced a response in the CL assay emphasising the importance of specificity in the functional activity of monoclonal antibodies. The demonstration of significant differences in the functional capabilities of monoclonal antibodies has important implications for reviewing the possible use of monoclonal anti-D preparations for Rh immune prophylaxis and highlights the requirement for factors other than the antibody concentration to be examined.