Thyroid cell apoptosis. A new understanding of thyroid autoimmunity

Possible mechanism of bamboo shoots (Bambusa balcooa) induced thyroid disruption - An in vitro study

Endemic goitre and associated iodine deficiency disorders (IDDs) are a major concern in public health even in the period of post salt iodization in many regions. Among others the consumption of cyanogenic plants found responsible for the persistence of such diseases. Bamboo shoots (BS) is one such cyanogenic plant food that caused disruption of certain thyroid hormone synthesizing regulatory element as has already been reported in our earlier study. In this investigation the possible mechanism of thyrocytes disruption along with interruption of thyroid hormone biosynthesis by BS has been worked out. Commonly consumed BS, Bambusa Balcooa Roxb (BBR) water extract was analysed by GC MS; three doses below IC50 were administered to thyrocytes in culture with and without iodine. Expressions of thyroglobulin (Tg), pendrin (PDS) and monocarboxylate transporter 8 (MCT8) were evaluated in thyrocytes with cell cycle analysis, reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation, DNA oxidation and apoptotic regulation through Bax, Bcl-2 and p53. Phytochemical analysis of BBR extract revealed the presence of precursors and metabolic end products of cyanogenic glycosides. Dose dependent decrease in expression of Tg and PDS with concomitant decrease in gene expression of these with MCT8 were observed. Increased ROS, DNA oxidation and associated imbalance were found through increased Bax and p53 with decreased Bcl-2 that perturbed thyrocytes cell cycle. Cyanogenic constituents of BBR generates ROS associated oxidative changes in thyrocytes with DNA damage and oxidation and cell cycle disruption followed by inhibition of thyroid hormone synthesizing regulatory elements; addition of extra iodine showed partial prevention.

AATF and SMARCA2 are associated with thyroid volume in Hashimoto's thyroiditis patients

Thyroid volume of Hashimoto’s thyroiditis (HT) patients varies in size over the course of disease and it may reflect changes in biological function of thyroid gland. Patients with subclinical hypothyroidism predominantly have increased thyroid volume whereas patients with more pronounced hypothyroidism have smaller thyroid volumes. Suggested mechanism for thyroid atrophy is thyrocyte death due to apoptosis. We performed the first genome-wide association study (GWAS) of thyroid volume in two groups of HT patients, depending on levothyroxine (LT4) therapy, and then meta-analysed across. Study included 345 HT patients in total and 6 007 322 common autosomal genetic variants. Underlying hypothesis was that genetic components that are involved in regulation of thyroid volume display their effect in specific pathophysiologic conditions of thyroid gland of HT patients. We additionally performed immunohistochemical analysis using thyroid tissues and analysed differences in expression levels of identified proteins and apoptotic marker between HT patients and controls. We found genome-wide significant association of two loci, both involved in apoptosis, with thyroid volume of HT patients: rs7212416 inside apoptosis-antagonizing transcription factor AATF (P = 8.95 × 10⁻⁹) and rs10738556 near chromatin-remodeling SMARCA2 (P = 2.83 × 10⁻⁸). In immunohistochemical analysis we observed that HT patients with homozygous AATF risk genotypes have decreased AATF expression (0.46-fold, P < 0.0001) and increased apoptosis (3.99-fold, P = 0.0001) in comparison to controls. HT patients with heterozygous SMARCA2 genotypes have decreased SMARCA2 expression, albeit without reaching statistical significance (1.07-fold, P = 0.5876), and significantly increased apoptosis (4.11-fold, P < 0.0001). By two lines of evidence we show that two highly plausible genetic loci, AATF and SMARCA2, may be involved in determining the thyroid volume of HT patients. The results of our study significantly add to the current knowledge of disturbed biological mechanisms in thyroid gland of HT patients.

[Role of apoptosis in pathogenesis of thyroiditis]

INTRODUCTION

Apoptosis is a highly regulated mechanism of cell death that differs from necrosis and plays an important role in normal tissue development, homeostasis and immune regulation.

DISEASES AND APOPTOSIS

Apoptosis is involved in many diseases. Defective apoptosis can cause systemic autoimmunity by allowing the survival of autoreactive lymphocytes. It may also be involved in the pathogenesis of organ-specific autoimmune diseases such as Hashimoto's thyroiditis and in the pathogenesis of tumors.

MECHANISM PROGRAMMED DEATH CELL

Apoptosis is regulated at multiple levels, including death receptor and ligand expression, adapter protein, cascades of caspases, mitochondria and the expression of anti apoptotic and pro apoptotic proteins. Apoptotic cell death can occur by two different pathways. Type I is initiated by the activation of death receptors (Fas, TNF-receptor-family) on the plasma membrane followed by activation of caspase 8. Type II involves changes in mitochondrial integrity initiated by various effectors, leading to the release of cytochrome c and activation of caspase 9.

MECHANISM OF APOPTOSIS IN HASHIMOTO THYROIDITIS

The thyroid cell destruction characteristic of autoimmune thyroiditis can be seen as the consequence of inappropriate expression of Fas or TRAIL death pathway molecules and down-regulation of the apoptosis controlling protein Bcl-2, which may be induced by cytokines released locally by infiltrating lymphocytes. Thyroid cell destruction in autoimmune hypothyroidism is dependent on T cell-mediated cytotoxicity with the likely additional effect of death receptor-mediated apoptosis. Modulation of apoptosis-related proteins by T helper 1 and T helper 2 cytokines controls thyrocyte survival in thyroid autoimmunity.

Apoptotic study in Graves disease treated with thyroid arterial embolization

OBJECTIVE

To investigate apoptosis in the thyroid of Graves disease (GD) induced by thyroid arterial embolization.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Forty one patients with clinically and laboratorily ascertained GD were treated with thyroid arterial embolization and followed up for 3-54 months following embolization. Prior to embolization and at 1, 3, 6, 12 and 36 months following embolization, thyroid autoimmunue antibodies were tested respectively, including thyroid stimulating antibody (TSAb), thyroglobulin antibody (TGAb) and thyroid microsomal antibody (TMAb). Thyroid biopsy was performed under the guidance of computed tomography for immunohistochemistry examination using semi-quantity analysis.

RESULTS

The positive staining of Fas and FasL was mostly in the cytoplasma and cell membrane, the positive expression of Bax was mainly in the cytoplasma, and no positive expression of P53 was detected in the thyroid cells before embolization. After arterial embolziation, the positive cell number and staining degree of these genes were both greater than before embolization.

CONCLUSION

The treatment method of thyroid arterial embolization can effectively enhance the positive expression of pro-apoptotic genes of Fas, FasL, Bax, Bcl-2 and P53 in GD thyroid, thus promoting apoptosis of GD thyroid and helping restore the thyroid size and function to normal conditions.

Differential expression of Fas system apoptotic molecules in peripheral lymphocytes from patients with Graves' disease and Hashimoto's thyroiditis

OBJECTIVE

To examine whether the Fas system apoptotic molecules are differentially expressed in Graves' disease (GD) and Hashimoto's thyroiditis (HT), the two opposite phenotypes of autoimmune thyroid disease (AITD).

DESIGN

The expression of Fas and Fas ligand (FasL) on peripheral CD4 and CD8 lymphocytes, and non-lymphoid immune cells as well as their soluble forms in serum from untreated patients with GD and HT were evaluated.

METHODS

Flow cytometry was performed for the study of peripheral immune cells from 70 newly diagnosed patients with AITD (55 with HT and 15 with GD) and 20 controls. ELISA was used for the measurement of soluble Fas (sFas) in serum samples from a subgroup of 35 AITD patients.

RESULTS

An increase in the proportion of CD4 and CD8 cells expressing Fas was found in both GD and HT, albeit with some differences, when compared with controls. Importantly, in GD patients, the intensity of Fas expression on CD4 and CD8 lymphocytes was reduced and sFas levels in serum were simultaneously increased when compared with HT patients and controls.

CONCLUSIONS

The Fas system apoptotic molecules appear to be differentially expressed on peripheral lymphocytes in the two opposite phenotypes of AITD.

The significance of FDG uptake in bilateral thyroid glands

AIM

To evaluate the significance of bilateral fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG) uptake in the thyroid glands.

METHODS

Bilateral thyroid FDG uptake, defined as visualization of thyroid glands, was found in 66 (3.4%) of 1925 subjects who underwent our FDG PET cancer-screening program. Additionally, 16 of the 41 patients with Graves' disease and hyperthyroidism (GD(H)) and six of the 20 subjects with Graves' disease and euthyroidism (GD(E)), who had FDG uptake in thyroid glands, were enrolled in this study.

RESULTS

Among the 66 subjects, 22 were normal variant, 39 subjects had chronic thyroiditis (35 subjects presented with diffuse goitre and four with multinodular goitre), and five subjects had multinodular goitre (MNG) without chronic thyroiditis. Fourteen of 22 (63.6%) of the subjects with the normal variant had a visual uptake intensity less than that of the liver, while 30 of 39 (76.9%) of the subjects with chronic thyroiditis and 14 of 22 (63.6%) of the subjects with Graves' disease had visual uptake intensity greater than or equal to liver uptake. Two of the five subjects with MNG with focally intense uptake were proven to have thyroid carcinoma. Bilateral loser uptake in thyroids associated with thymus and symmetrical skeletal muscle uptake were found in GD(H). The standard uptake value (SUV) (mean+/-SD) in subjects with chronic thyroiditis (2.76+/-1.24) were higher, while those with GD(H) (1.59+/-0.36) were lower than that of the normal variant (1.99+/-0.63). Subjects with hypothyroidism (3.04+/-1.39) had higher SUV levels than those subjects with euthyroidism (2.44+/-1.11). In addition, patients with GD(H) had lower levels than those with GD(E) (2.0+/-0.38).

CONCLUSION

(1) Bilateral thyroidal uptake of FDG can be found in normal variants and subjects with various thyroid disorders, showing varieties of uptake patterns. (2) Diffuse intense uptake and higher SUV levels are a clue to a diagnosis of chronic thyroiditis, especially for those with hypothyroidism. (3) Focally intense uptake suggests the possibility of a thyroid carcinoma. (4) Sparse uptake associated with the thymus and symmetrical skeletal muscle uptake and lower SUV level raise the possibility of Graves' disease with hyperthyroidism.

In vivo and in vitro effects of statins on lymphocytes in patients with Hashimoto's thyroiditis

BACKGROUND

Statins have apoptotic effects on many cell types. Hashimoto's thyroiditis (HT) is an autoimmune disease in which cell-mediated autoimmune mechanisms are pathogenetically involved.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to evaluate the in vivo effects of Simvastatin on thyroid function, lymphocyte subtypes and also to investigate the apoptotic effects of Simvastatin, Mevastatin, Pravastatin and Cerivastatin on lymphocytes from patients with HT.

METHODS

In the first part of the study, 11 patients with HT and subclinical hypothyroidism (SH) were given Simvastatin (20 mg/day) for 8 weeks. Ten patients with SH and HT served as the control group. No treatment was given to controls. Thyroid function, C-reactive protein (CRP) levels and lymphocyte subtypes of both groups were determined before the study and after 8 weeks. In the second part of the study, the apoptotic effects of statins on lymphocytes were evaluated in patients with HT (n = 10) and normal subjects (n = 10) in vitro. Apoptosis was investigated by using Annexin-V and propidium iodide. Lymphocytes from patients and controls were incubated with different concentrations of Simvastatin, Cerivastatin, Mevastatin and Pravastatin.

RESULTS

An increase in serum free tri-iodothyronine and free thyroxine levels and a decrease in TSH levels were observed (P < 0.05) with Simvastatin treatment. CD4+ cells and B lymphocytes increased whilst CD8+ cells, natural killer cells and activated T lymphocytes decreased significantly in the treatment group (P < 0.05). The CRP level of the group also decreased with Simvastatin but it did not reach significance (P = 0.057). None of parameters was found to be different from the baseline in the control group. In in vitro experiments, apoptosis was observed in CD3 + (both in CD8+ and CD4+ cells) with all statins in both patient and control samples. Mevalonate, which was used in experiments, reversed apoptosis in some but not all samples.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of this study suggested that Simvastatin is an immune modulatory agent and improves thyroid function in patients with HT. This effect is probably mediated via lymphocyte apoptosis as demonstrated with in vitro experiments and is not confined to Simvastatin since Mevastatin, Pravastatin and Cerivastatin also induced apoptosis in lymphocytes.

A population study of the association between thyroid autoantibodies in serum and abnormalities in thyroid function and structure

OBJECTIVE

Patients with autoimmune overt hypothyroidism may present with goitrous Hashimoto's disease or autoimmune atrophic thyroiditis. Little is known about the prevalence of subclinical autoimmune hypothyroidism. The aims of this study were to evaluate the association between thyroid autoantibodies in serum and abnormalities in thyroid function and structure, and to study the thyroid volume in subjects with subclinical autoimmune hypothyroidism.

DESIGN

A population study including 4649 randomly selected subjects.

MEASUREMENTS

Blood tests were used to analyse for thyroid peroxidase autoantibodies (TPO-Ab), thyroglobulin autoantibodies (Tg-Ab), TSH, fT3 and fT4.

RESULTS

Thyroid volume was categorized as small (< 6.6 ml) in 4.7%, normal (6.6-14.9 ml) in 60.4% and large (> 14.9 ml) in 34.9% of participants. Thyroid nodules were found in 29.7%. Serum TSH was low (< 0.4 mIU/l) in 4.7%, normal (0.4-3.6) in 91.0% and high (> 3.6) in 4.3%. The prevalence rate of subclinical goitrous Hashimoto's disease was 0.62% and of subclinical autoimmune atrophic thyroiditis 0.24%. There was a strong association between large volume and autoantibodies, but only in subjects with elevated TSH (P < 0.001). An association between thyroid nodules and TPO-Ab in univariate analyses (P < 0.001) was due to confounding by sex and age (multivariate model, P = 0.23).

CONCLUSION

We identified a subgroup of the population with subclinical goitrous Hashimoto's disease and a smaller subgroup with subclinical autoimmune atrophic thyroiditis. This relationship between small and large thyroid volume in subclinical disease is opposite to that in overt disease, which may suggest that the period between development of a small volume with circulating autoantibodies and overt hypothyroidism is relatively short.

Thyrotropin effects on ultraviolet radiation-dependent apoptosis in FRTL-5 cells

Apoptosis plays an important role within the endocrine system, particularly in the thyroid gland, although little is known about its regulation in normal thyroids. Because thyrotropin (TSH) regulates many thyroid-specific functions and cell proliferation, we investigated whether TSH can influence such mechanisms. To induce apoptosis we used UV-C radiation. The FRTL-5 rat thyroid cell strain, a cloned strain of differentiated and untransformed cells that reproduces many of the characteristics of the normal thyroid was chosen for this study. The FRTL-5 cells are a particularly suitable model because they actively proliferate when cultured in the presence of TSH (6H medium), while in TSH-free medium (5H medium) cells remain in a physiologic quiescent state for a long period of time. FRTL-5 cells in both culture conditions were irradiated with UV-C radiation (254 nm wavelength). At 48 hours after radiation, 6H cultured cells showed the characteristic signs of apoptosis. However, 5H cultured cells did not present macroscopic signs of damage, DNA fragmentation, or detectable apoptosis. Furthermore, the expression of 23 apoptosis-related genes was compared. Results indicate that Bcl2 and caspase-2 expression is enhanced, while bax, GADD45 and mdm-2 expression is reduced in irradiated cells. These data confirm that TSH plays a major role in regulating UV-induced apoptosis in FRTL-5 cells.

Autoimmune thyroid diseases: etiology, pathogenesis, and dermatologic manifestations

Autoimmune thyroid disease (AITD) including Graves' disease, Hashimoto's thyroiditis, and idiopathic hypothyroidism (atrophic Hashimoto's thyroiditis) is of vital concern to the dermatologist. This article reviews the cutaneous manifestations of Graves' disease and Hashimoto's thyroiditis. Recognition of dermatologic manifestations of AITD may alert practitioners to investigate for these disorders. The immune response involved in the pathogenesis of AITD is detailed. Current understanding of the role of genetic and environmental factors, antigens, and apoptosis are elaborated. The future holds exciting insight into the etiology, pathogenesis, and treatment of AITD.

Methods for detecting apoptosis in thyroid diseases

Over the last few years, the importance of apoptosis in determining the fate of thyrocytes in autoimmune thyroid disease has been the topic of intense investigation. It is now clear that thyrocytes from patients with Hashimoto's thyroiditis are destroyed as a result of an apoptotic process. However, there is no general consensus on whether the intrathyroidal lymphocytes or the thyrocytes themselves are responsible for their death. The use of a wide range of techniques has contributed to the assessment of this process both in situ on thyroid sections and in vitro on thyroid cell preparations. The apoptosis field of research is rapidly evolving and as the pathways to cell death become unravelled, novel methods will emerge. As each technique offers some advantage, it is critical to know the most suitable method for a specific study. Equally, each method also has intrinsic limitations. Thus, to achieve reliable results, it is necessary to use more than one technique per study. In addition, techniques related to the measurement of the expression of pro-apoptotic and anti-apoptotic genes have been contributing to the study of the susceptibility of the cells to apoptosis and/or to their ability to kill themselves or neighbouring cells. In this review we will focus on the most relevant techniques.

Clearance of apoptotic beta-cells is reduced in neonatal autoimmune diabetes-prone rats

The kinetics of beta-cell death in neonatal diabetes-prone (BBdp) and diabetes-resistant (BBdr) BioBreeding rats was investigated using both direct (histochemical) and indirect (mathematical modelling) techniques. In both BBdp and BBdr rats, the incidence of TUNEL positive beta-cells increased until 10 days of age before declining. The number of apoptotic beta-cells was significantly higher in BBdp as compared to BBdr neonates from birth until 20 days of age (P<0.05). Using a mathematical model applied to the time course of beta-cell mass and replication rate, a wave of net beta-cell loss was detected between 10 and 20 days of age in both strains. In contrast to the observed difference in the incidence of TUNEL positive beta-cells, with the model-based approach we found no difference in the rate of beta-cell apoptosis between BBdp and BBdr rats prior to weaning. As the number of apoptotic cells present in a tissue depends on the rate at which cells die and the rate at which the apoptotic cell debris is cleared, we compared in vitro phagocytosis of apoptotic thymocytes by peritoneal macrophages from 2-week-old BBdp and BBdr rats. Macrophages from BBdp neonates engulfed significantly less apoptotic cells as compared to BBdr neonates (P<0.0005). Taken together, these findings suggest that there is impaired clearance of apoptotic beta-cells in diabetes-prone BB rats during the neonatal period.

Apoptosis: life through planned cellular death regulating mechanisms, control systems, and relations with thyroid diseases

Apoptosis is an active biologic process that represents a form of programmed cellular suicide, activated either by genetic factors or by cellular lesions caused by various extracellular traumatic agents. The alterations of its functional mechanisms control cellular homeostasis are involved in the genesis of many illnesses. There are different control systems that can both stimulate and inhibit apoptosis, such as the p53 and Bcl-2 proteins. Different injuries may cause a rapid increase in the levels of p53 and the activation of the complex mechanism which leads either to damage repair or cellular apoptosis. The concept of tumor growth as a dynamic balance between cellular development and death is well applicable to differentiated thyroid carcinomas, which are generally not highly invasive and present excellent prognosis. On the contrary, in aggressive anaplastic thyroid carcinoma there is an increase in p53, whereas in normal thyroid cells there is a high expression of Bcl-2, so as to interfere with apoptosis when physiologic hormone levels are normal. However, only some of the biomolecular mechanisms behind the genesis of thyroid tumors have been explained, and the role of apoptosis in thyroid diseases has not been well defined. This review provides information about relationship between apoptosis and thyroid diseases.

Apoptosis: the quiet death silences the immune system

Apoptosis plays an essential role in maintaining cellular homeostasis during development, differentiation, and pathophysiological processes. In the immune system, recent investigations reveal that during the course of T-cell development in the thymus, negative selection of autoreactive immature T-cells is a typical apoptotic process. In addition, apoptosis is also involved in cytotoxic killing of target cells and the regulation of lymphocyte homeostasis during immune responses. Interestingly, recent evidence has suggested that cells dying by apoptosis are actively involved in immunosuppression in various circumstances. We have shown that apoptotic cells could inhibit the expression of CD69 during T-cell activation. Furthermore, apoptotic cells phagocytosed by macrophages and/or dendritic cells are immunosuppressive, a process likely mediated by the production of transforming growth factor-beta1. Since apoptosis is a common mechanism by which excessive cells in many tissues and organs are eliminated in various pathophysiological processes, we believe that further investigation into the mechanisms by which apoptotic cells affect the immune system will not only lead to a better understanding of the significance of apoptosis during immune responses, but will also provide novel strategies for the management of autoimmune diseases and transplantation.

In vivo imaging of acute cardiac rejection in human patients using (99m)technetium labeled annexin V

Annexin V binds phosphatidylserine moieties on apoptotic cells. This study reports the initial experience at Stanford University Medical Center with 99mTc-labeled annexin V imaging as a noninvasive measure of apoptosis in acute cardiac rejection. Ten cardiac transplant patients had 99mTc Annexin V imaging and endomyocardial biopsy (EMB) performed within 24 h. No complications related to 99mTc annexin V administration occurred. Eight patients had ISHLT grade of acute rejection of 1A or less. Five patients had two or more areas of uptake noted in the right ventricle on imaging studies. Two of these patients had positive biopsies: one patient had grade 2 rejection with two focal uptake areas and another had grade 3A rejection with three foci. An additional five patients had either one or zero hot spot areas and corresponding negative EMBs. 99mTc-annexin V appears to be well tolerated and may identify patients with acute cardiac rejection.