Immunoregulation of Murine and Human Myeloma

Enhancement of Radioprotection and Anti-Tumor Immunity by Yeast-Derived β-Glucan in Mice

Intraperitoneal injection of beta-glucan was shown to greatly delay mortality in mice exposed to whole-body X-ray radiation and tumor growth in tumor-bearing mice. Since the leukocyte and lymphocyte numbers were increased by a single dose of beta-glucan, the radioprotective effect of beta-glucan is probably mediated, at least in part, by a hemopoietic action in irradiated mice. In addition, both natural killer (NK) and lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) activities were significantly increased by repeated doses of beta-glucan. Augmented immunological activity as seen in increased NK and LAK activity by beta-glucan seems to play a role in preventing secondary infections associated with irradiation, and probably contributes to the attenuated tumor growth in tumor-bearing mice through enhanced anti-tumor immunity. These results suggest that beta-glucan may be a promising adjunct treatment for cancer patients receiving radiotherapy.

Natural cytotoxicity to autologous antigen-pulsed dendritic cells in multiple myeloma

To analyse autologous lymphocyte cytolytic activities of potential importance for cell-based immunotherapy in multiple myeloma (MM), in vitro differentiated dendritic cells (DCs) loaded with patient-specific monoclonal immunoglobulin (mIg) were used as autologous target cellsin cytotoxicity assays. Effector populations consisted of purified natural killer (NK) cells (CD56+, CD3-) and T cells (CD3+). The MM patients' NK cells cultured in the presence of interleukin 2 (IL-2) showed pronounced cytotoxic activity towards autologous mature DCs. Autologous MM DC targets displayed similar susceptibility to NK cell lysis, compared with allogeneic control DC targets, despite high surface expression of self major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens. However, some degree of classic MHC class I-mediated negative regulation was implicated in the NK-DC interactions, as indicated by class I blocking experiments. NK-mediated lysis was also discerned towards primary autologous MM cells. The results indicated that the major effector mechanism was mediated through the perforin-granzyme exocytosis pathway. In conclusion, NK cells from MM patients displayed significant and consistent cytotoxicity towards autologous mature DCs, suggesting that innate immunity could be implicated in MM and may influence the outcome of the administration of tumour antigen-pulsed DCs in treatment trials.

Idiotype immunity (natural and vaccine-induced) in early stage multiple myeloma

Idiotypic structures expressed on the myeloma immunoglobulin (Ig) protein (M-component) might be regarded as tumor-specific antigens. Naturally occurring, idiotype-specific type I T-cell immunity has been observed preferentially in patients with early stage myeloma. The idiotypic structures on the clonal myeloma B-cells (B lymphocytes and plasma cells) may serve as targets for active immunization. Vaccination using the autologous monoclonal Ig as a vaccine has conferred resistance to tumor cell challenge in murine myeloma. The autologous myeloma Ig protein was used for immunization in patients with progressive stage I and early stage II multiple myeloma. When the idiotype (emulsified in aluminium phosphate) was used alone for immunization, a weak and transient idiotype-specific T-cell response was observed with no clinical effects. In our second series, the idiotype (in alum) was combined with GM-CSF. In all five patients, a specific T-cell response was induced consisting preferentially of MHC class I restricted (CD8+) T-cells. Ig-specific CD4+ T-cells were also induced. A clinical response ( > 50% reduction of the M-component concentration) was observed in one patient. These results indicate that idiotype-specific T-cell immunity may be induced or enhanced by idiotype Ig vaccination in patients with early stage multiple myeloma, in which the tumor load is relatively low and the immune system is functionally less compromized than in patients with chemotherapy-treated, advanced stages of the disease. The use of GM-CSF seems to be mandatory for the frequency and magnitude of the induced T-cell response. The optimal route, schedule and cytokine combination for idiotype immunization remains to be established.

CD9 expression enhances the susceptibility of myeloma cell lines to cell-mediated cytolysis

Myeloma tumor cells, both freshly excised and cultured, are extremely resistant to cell-mediated cytolysis. As evidence suggests that B-cell susceptibility to lysis is dependent upon its state of differentiation and activation, we tested the ability of a variety of B-cell proliferation and differentiation agents, including pokeweed mitogen (PWM), to enhance the sensitivity of myeloma cells to cell-mediated lysis. PWM was found to significantly enhance the susceptibility of myeloma cell lines and freshly isolated myeloma cells to interleukin-2 (IL-2)–activated cell-mediated cytolysis. This effect was seen with the use of both IL-2–stimulated natural killer (NK) cells and T cells as effectors. The enhanced sensitivity of myeloma cells to cytolysis correlated with an increase in their cell surface expression of CD9, a pre-B cell marker and member of the transmembrane 4 superfamily. Incubation of PWM-stimulated myeloma cells with either monoclonal antibodies or antisense oligonucleotides directed against CD9 abrogated the effect of PWM. In order to determine whether there was a direct relationship between the expression of CD9 and enhanced sensitivity to cytolysis, myeloma cell lines that lacked CD9 expression were transfected with the CD9 gene. The level of cell surface CD9 expression correlates with enhanced susceptibility to lysis. Therefore, CD9 appears to be an important component in enhancing the sensitivity of myeloma cells to lysis mediated by IL-2–activated T cells and NK cells.

CD9 expression enhances the susceptibility of myeloma cell lines to cell-mediated cytolysis

Myeloma tumor cells, both freshly excised and cultured, are extremely resistant to cell-mediated cytolysis. As evidence suggests that B-cell susceptibility to lysis is dependent upon its state of differentiation and activation, we tested the ability of a variety of B-cell proliferation and differentiation agents, including pokeweed mitogen (PWM), to enhance the sensitivity of myeloma cells to cell-mediated lysis. PWM was found to significantly enhance the susceptibility of myeloma cell lines and freshly isolated myeloma cells to interleukin-2 (IL-2)–activated cell-mediated cytolysis. This effect was seen with the use of both IL-2–stimulated natural killer (NK) cells and T cells as effectors. The enhanced sensitivity of myeloma cells to cytolysis correlated with an increase in their cell surface expression of CD9, a pre-B cell marker and member of the transmembrane 4 superfamily. Incubation of PWM-stimulated myeloma cells with either monoclonal antibodies or antisense oligonucleotides directed against CD9 abrogated the effect of PWM. In order to determine whether there was a direct relationship between the expression of CD9 and enhanced sensitivity to cytolysis, myeloma cell lines that lacked CD9 expression were transfected with the CD9 gene. The level of cell surface CD9 expression correlates with enhanced susceptibility to lysis. Therefore, CD9 appears to be an important component in enhancing the sensitivity of myeloma cells to lysis mediated by IL-2–activated T cells and NK cells.

CD34+-selected peripheral blood progenitor cell transplantation in patients with multiple myeloma: tumour cell contamination and outcome

Thirty-six patients with multiple myeloma (23 PR1, nine PR2, four stable disease) were entered into a pilot study evaluating the use of CD34+-selected peripheral blood progenitor cell transplantation (PBPCT) following high-dose melphalan alone or high-dose melphalan and total body irradiation. Peripheral blood progenitor cells (PBPCs) were mobilized with cyclophosphamide and granulocyte colony stimulating factor (G-CSF). CD34+ selection using the Cellpro Ceprate-SC system was performed in 22 cases with an adequate yield in 20. 10 patients failed to mobilize sufficient cells to permit selection and in four cases selection was not performed for other reasons. 16 patients therefore received unselected PBPC. Tumour cell contamination was evaluated by IgH gene fingerprinting (fpPCR). Harvested PBPC were fpPCR positive in 13/20 CD34+-selected cases and remained positive after selection in seven. Harvested PBPC were studied in 9/16 patients receiving unselected cells; fpPCR was positive in five and negative in four. There was no difference in event-free survival (EFS) between the CD34+-selected group and the unselected group (median 21 and 26 months, respectively, P=ns). The CD34+-selection process therefore reduced contamination but did not eliminate it completely, and in this small non-randomized study there was no apparent clinical benefit of CD34+ selection.

Idiotype Immunization Combined With Granulocyte-Macrophage Colony-Stimulating Factor in Myeloma Patients Induced Type I, Major Histocompatibility Complex–Restricted, CD8- and CD4-Specific T-Cell Responses

Idiotypic structures expressed on the myeloma Ig protein might be regarded as a tumor-specific antigen. Five patients with IgG myeloma were immunized with the purified serum M-component by repeated intradermal injections together with soluble granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF). All patients developed an idiotype (Id)-specific T-cell immunity, defined as blood T cells predominantly secreting interferon-γ (IFN-γ) and interleukin-2 (IL-2) (type I cells). Id-specific DNA synthesis was induced in one patient. Delayed-type hypersensitivity against the Id was not evoked. The specific IFN-γ/IL-2 T-cell response was inhibited (46% to 100%) by a major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I monoclonal antibody (MoAb) in all five patients. A 5% to 37% inhibition by an MHC class II MoAb was seen in four patients. CD4+ as well as CD8+ T cells enriched by magnetic microbeads contained Id-specific cells. The T cells recognized peptides corresponding to the complementarity-determining regions 1, 2, and 3 of the heavy chain of the Id. There was a transient rise of B cells producing IgM anti-idiotypic antibodies in all patients. The results indicate that immunization of myeloma patients using the autologous M-component and soluble GM-CSF may evoke an Id-specific predominantly MHC class I–restricted type I T-cell response.

Idiotype Immunization Combined With Granulocyte-Macrophage Colony-Stimulating Factor in Myeloma Patients Induced Type I, Major Histocompatibility Complex–Restricted, CD8- and CD4-Specific T-Cell Responses

Idiotypic structures expressed on the myeloma Ig protein might be regarded as a tumor-specific antigen. Five patients with IgG myeloma were immunized with the purified serum M-component by repeated intradermal injections together with soluble granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF). All patients developed an idiotype (Id)-specific T-cell immunity, defined as blood T cells predominantly secreting interferon-γ (IFN-γ) and interleukin-2 (IL-2) (type I cells). Id-specific DNA synthesis was induced in one patient. Delayed-type hypersensitivity against the Id was not evoked. The specific IFN-γ/IL-2 T-cell response was inhibited (46% to 100%) by a major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I monoclonal antibody (MoAb) in all five patients. A 5% to 37% inhibition by an MHC class II MoAb was seen in four patients. CD4+ as well as CD8+ T cells enriched by magnetic microbeads contained Id-specific cells. The T cells recognized peptides corresponding to the complementarity-determining regions 1, 2, and 3 of the heavy chain of the Id. There was a transient rise of B cells producing IgM anti-idiotypic antibodies in all patients. The results indicate that immunization of myeloma patients using the autologous M-component and soluble GM-CSF may evoke an Id-specific predominantly MHC class I–restricted type I T-cell response.

Immunoregulatory mechanisms in multiple myeloma

This review presents current experimental data regarding immunologic changes associated with multiple myeloma (Table 1). It is becoming increasingly clear that some of the immunologic changes are host responses to the malignant plasma cell clone and monoclonal immunoglobulin. In the last 2 to 3 years an anti-idiotypic response has been clearly documented, and cells expressing CD16 and soluble CD16 have been identified as modulators of myeloma cell growth and differentiation. Abnormalities in B- and T-cell differentiation have been observed, most consistently the deficiency of T4 helper cells. Differences in the immunologic changes point to the provocative hypothesis that, in MGUS and the initial stages of myeloma, immunologic responses play an important role in controlling proliferation of the malignant clone, and at some point the system is overwhelmed or fails, leading to an overt or more aggressive disease. The quest is to understand the genesis of the autoregulatory circuits operative in myeloma. Novel strategies for immunotherapy in management of myeloma will arise through improved understanding of host immune response and its cause-and-effect relationship with myeloma cell growth.

Biological aspects of multiple myeloma

Although considerable progress has been made towards understanding many aspects of myeloma, the myeloma stem cell and the factors that drive the disease remain elusive. Recent developments in the molecular analysis of clonality have helped to confirm the presence of pre-switch B cells that are of the same clone as the myeloma plasma cells. The role of these cells in myelomagenesis has not been demonstrated, and the isotypic heterogeneity of the clonally-relevant cells suggests that the pre-switch B cells are pre-malignant progenitors of the tumour cells. Thus, the circulating clonal B cells appear to be the earliest progenitors of the mature, monoclonal plasma cells. IL-6, and possibly other cytokines, are involved in driving this process. The role of IL-6 in myeloma is complex and more involved than its proposed growth factor function. In the absence of IL-6, dependent cells become apoptotic. Increased IL-6 signalling also leads to apoptosis of myeloma cells, possibly as a result of terminal differentiation. In the presence of exogenous IL-6, the IL-6 receptor appears to be the rate-limiting factor in the pathway's activity. IL-6 may regulate the survival of myeloma cells by stimulating c-myc transcription, possibly from the P0 promoter. The high levels of c-myc transcripts and protein could regulate myeloma cell proliferation and apoptotic death by controlling p53 expression and, through it, the expression of the Rb and BAX genes. Proliferative signalling in myeloma cells is likely to be intrinsic, within the tumour cell compartment. Molecules such as CD28 and B7, both expressed by less mature myeloma cells, could represent one such self-self stimulatory mechanism, with IL-6, possibly through stimulation of c-myc expression, providing the signals for survival and differentiation.

Immunophenotype and DNA cell content in multiple myeloma

In this paper three different areas of the biology of multiple myeloma (MM) are reviewed: (1) the immunophenotypic characteristics of plasma cells (PC), (2) the changes in the immunoregulatory cells, and (3) the cell DNA content of PC. Myelomatous PC display a heterogeneous phenotype not only between different patients but also within each patient consistent with the fact that the neoplastic clone is able to undergo a certain degree of differentiation. In addition, PC generally lack surface B cell associated antigens and infrequently show reactivity for non-lineage restricted markers. The B-B4 and CD38 are the two best markers for identifying PC which are crucial for the correct assessment of other antigens by multiple staining procedures. Moreover, some of the antigens present in PC such as CD56, CD20, CD10, CD28 and SIg may have prognostic implications. Whether or not normal PC are phenotypically different from myelomatous PC remains controversial although some antigenic combinations such as CD19-/CD56++ could probably help to identify the malignant nature of PC. Both T and NK cells are markedly altered in MM patients probably reflecting a host-tumour immunological interaction. The reduction in CD4 cells correlates both with advanced clinical stage and poor survival. As far as NK cells are concerned, there is an overall increase in peripheral blood and BM in MM patients but the changes observed are heterogeneous, reflecting the existence of different NK cell subsets. This fact could explain the contradictory results observed in the literature. Accumulating evidence exists that the measurement of cell DNA content by flow cytometry is a useful parameter in the clinical evaluation of MM patients. Between 50 and 70% of MM patients display DNA aneuploidy with the majority of them hyperdiploid. Upon comparing hyperdiploid with diploid patients, the former usually display a better prognosis. The possibility of analysing the cell cycle distribution by using a PI/CD38 double staining technique may be an alternative to other more laborious methods of assessing the PC labelling index. In our experience, patients with > 3% S phase PC have an adverse prognosis and this parameter was the most important independent prognostic criteria for predicting survival.

T cells in multiple myeloma: is this a reliable population to count on as antitumor effector cells?

Multiple Myeloma (MM) is still a long way from being cured. Disease evolution has been associated with a number of phenotypic and functional alterations in T cells, indicating that a progressive deterioration of cellular immunity might facilitate the negative outcome. Despite these correlations, specific interactions between tumor and T cells have been demonstrated indicating that a population liable to be exploited as antitumor effector cells exists in vivo. This review aims at recording some evidence obtained in our laboratory demonstrating that MM T cells, despite the variety of their alterations, can still generate potent antitumor activity. Adequate stimulation, however, is required to exploit this ability.

Sequential phenotyping of myeloma patients on chemotherapy: persistence of activated T-cells and natural killer cells

To better detail the status of functional T cell subsets and natural killer cells in multiple myeloma, we undertook a detailed immunophenotypic study of circulating mononuclear cells in myeloma. We studied myeloma patients entered on a large prospective, randomized ECOG chemotherapy trial EST 9486 for patients with newly diagnosed multiple myeloma. All patients were studied prior to entry and then two months after initiation of therapy (e.g. post two cycles of Vincristine, BCNU, melphalan, cyclophosphamide and prednisone (VBMCP)). The chemotherapy protocol was a three-arm protocol utilizing either VBMCP, VBMCP alternating with interferon, or VBMCP with intermittent high dose cyclophosphamide. The major findings in this analysis include significant reductions in the white blood cell count, total lymphocytes, T cell (CD3+), T helper (CD4+), and T suppressor (CD8+) cells, after 2 cycles of VBMCP. However, there was a relative sparing of Natural killer (CD16+) and activated T cell (CD2+, HLADR+) reduction in these same patients. In summary, only two cycles of combination chemotherapy resulted in significant reductions in white blood cell and lymphocyte counts in multiple myeloma patients. All cell types appear to have been reduced by chemotherapy except for activated T cells and natural killer cells. The impact of selective modulation of functional T cells subsets during therapy for patients with multiple myeloma is an important parameter which needs to be addressed in the overall approach to these patients.

Mechanisms of the escape phase of myeloma

In multiple myeloma the duration of plateau is an important clinical and biological determinant of quality of life and survival. During plateau phase, the tumour is in an indolent state, as manifested by a low labelling index of plasma cells and other proliferative markers, e.g. the thymidine kinase level. The mechanism by which plasma cells escape from this indolent phase to a more aggressive phase of this disease is unknown, but a number of possible mechanisms have been postulated. These include loss of immunoregulation, clonal evolution, cytokine dysfunction and oncogene activation or tumour suppressor gene dysfunction. As current chemotherapy protocols do not appear to be able to eradicate the malignant clone, understanding the nature of the indolent phase of the malignant clone and the reasons for its escape from this phase are very important and may provide new options for disease control.