Investigation of S-farnesyl transferase substrate specificity with combinatorial tetrapeptide libraries

A comprehensive in vivo screen of yeast farnesyltransferase activity reveals broad reactivity across a majority of CXXX sequences

The current understanding of farnesyltransferase (FTase) specificity was pioneered through investigations of reporters like Ras and Ras-related proteins that possess a C-terminal CaaX motif that consists of 4 amino acid residues: cysteine-aliphatic1-aliphatic2-variable (X). These studies led to the finding that proteins with the CaaX motif are subject to a 3-step post-translational modification pathway involving farnesylation, proteolysis, and carboxylmethylation. Emerging evidence indicates, however, that FTase can farnesylate sequences outside the CaaX motif and that these sequences do not undergo the canonical 3-step pathway. In this work, we report a comprehensive evaluation of all possible CXXX sequences as FTase targets using the reporter Ydj1, an Hsp40 chaperone that only requires farnesylation for its activity. Our genetic and high-throughput sequencing approach reveals an unprecedented profile of sequences that yeast FTase can recognize in vivo, which effectively expands the potential target space of FTase within the yeast proteome. We also document that yeast FTase specificity is majorly influenced by restrictive amino acids at a2 and X positions as opposed to the resemblance of CaaX motif as previously regarded. This first complete evaluation of CXXX space expands the complexity of protein isoprenylation and marks a key step forward in understanding the potential scope of targets for this isoprenylation pathway.

Further assessments of ligase LplA-mediated modifications of proteins in vitro and in cellulo

BACKGROUND

Posttranslational modifications of proteins are catalyzed by a large family of enzymes catalyzing many chemical modifications. One can hijack the natural use of those enzymes to modify targeted proteins with synthetic chemical moieties. The lipoic acid ligase LplA mutants can be used to introduce onto the lysine sidechain lipoic acid moiety synthetic analogues. Substrate protein candidates of the ligase must obey a few a priori rules.

METHODS AND RESULTS

In the present report, we technically detailed the use of a cell line stably expressing both the ligase and a model protein (thioredoxin). Although the goal can be reach, and the protein visualized in situ, many experimental difficulties must be fixed. The sequence of events comprises (i) in cellulo labeling of the target protein with a N₃-lipoic acid derivative catalyzed by the mutant ligase, (ii) the further introduction by click chemistry onto this lysine sidechain of a fluorophore and (iii) the following of the labeled protein in living cells. One of the main difficulties was to assess the click chemistry step onto the living cells, because images from both control and experimental cells were similar. Alternatively, we describe at that stage, the preferred use of another technique: the Halo-Tag one that led to the obtention of clear images of the targeted protein in its cellular context. Although the ligase-mediated labeling of protein in situ is a rich domain for which many cellular tools must be developed, many difficulties must be considered before entering a systematic use of this approach.

CONCLUSIONS

In the present contribution, we added several steps of analytical characterization, both in vitro and in cellulo that were previously lacking. Furthermore, we show that the use of the click chemistry should be manipulated with care, as the claimed specificity might be not complete whenever living cells are used. Finally, we added another approach-the Halo Tag-to complete the previously suggested approaches for labelling proteins in cells, as we found difficult to strictly apply the previously reported methodology.

Protein prenylation: enzymes, therapeutics, and biotechnology applications

Protein prenylation is a ubiquitous covalent post-translational modification found in all eukaryotic cells, comprising attachment of either a farnesyl or a geranylgeranyl isoprenoid. It is essential for the proper cellular activity of numerous proteins, including Ras family GTPases and heterotrimeric G-proteins. Inhibition of prenylation has been extensively investigated to suppress the activity of oncogenic Ras proteins to achieve antitumor activity. Here, we review the biochemistry of the prenyltransferase enzymes and numerous isoprenoid analogs synthesized to investigate various aspects of prenylation and prenyltransferases. We also give an account of the current status of prenyltransferase inhibitors as potential therapeutics against several diseases including cancers, progeria, aging, parasitic diseases, and bacterial and viral infections. Finally, we discuss recent progress in utilizing protein prenylation for site-specific protein labeling for various biotechnology applications.

Context-dependent substrate recognition by protein farnesyltransferase

Prenylation is a posttranslational modification whereby C-terminal lipidation leads to protein localization to membranes. A C-terminal "Ca(1)a(2)X" sequence has been proposed as the recognition motif for two prenylation enzymes, protein farnesyltransferase (FTase) and protein geranylgeranyltransferase type I. To define the parameters involved in recognition of the a(2) residue, we performed structure-activity analysis which indicates that FTase discriminates between peptide substrates based on both the hydrophobicity and steric volume of the side chain at the a(2) position. For nonpolar side chains, the dependence of the reactivity on side chain volume at this position forms a pyramidal pattern with a maximal activity near the steric volume of valine. This discrimination occurs at a step in the kinetic mechanism that is at or before the farnesylation step. Furthermore, a(2) selectivity is also affected by the identity of the adjacent X residue, leading to context-dependent substrate recognition. Context-dependent a(2) selectivity suggests that FTase recognizes the sequence downstream of the conserved cysteine as a set of two or three cooperative, interconnected recognition elements as opposed to three independent amino acids. These findings expand the pool of proposed FTase substrates in cells. A better understanding of the molecular recognition of substrates performed by FTase will aid in both designing new FTase inhibitors as therapeutic agents and characterizing proteins involved in prenylation-dependent cellular pathways.

Identification of novel peptide substrates for protein farnesyltransferase reveals two substrate classes with distinct sequence selectivities

Prenylation is a posttranslational modification essential for the proper localization and function of many proteins. Farnesylation, the attachment of a 15-carbon farnesyl group near the C-terminus of protein substrates, is catalyzed by protein farnesyltransferase (FTase). Farnesylation has received significant interest as a target for pharmaceutical development, and farnesyltransferase inhibitors are in clinical trials as cancer therapeutics. However, as the total complement of prenylated proteins is unknown, the FTase substrates responsible for farnesyltransferase inhibitor efficacy are not yet understood. Identifying novel prenylated proteins within the human proteome constitutes an important step towards understanding prenylation-dependent cellular processes. Based on sequence preferences for FTase derived from analysis of known farnesylated proteins, we selected and screened a library of small peptides representing the C-termini of 213 human proteins for activity with FTase. We identified 77 novel FTase substrates that exhibit multiple-turnover (MTO) reactivity within this library; our library also contained 85 peptides that can be farnesylated by FTase only under single-turnover (STO) conditions. Based on these results, a second library was designed that yielded an additional 29 novel MTO FTase substrates and 45 STO substrates. The two classes of substrates exhibit different specificity requirements. Efficient MTO reactivity correlates with the presence of a nonpolar amino acid at the a(2) position and a Phe, Met, or Gln at the terminal X residue, consistent with the proposed Ca(1)a(2)X sequence model. In contrast, the sequences of the STO substrates vary significantly more at both the a(2) and the X residues and are not well described by current farnesylation algorithms. These results improve the definition of prenyltransferase substrate specificity, test the efficacy of substrate algorithms, and provide valuable information about therapeutic targets. Finally, these data illuminate the potential for in vivo regulation of prenylation through modulation of STO versus MTO peptide reactivity with FTase.

Evaluation of protein farnesyltransferase substrate specificity using synthetic peptide libraries

Farnesylation, catalyzed by protein farnesyltransferase (FTase), is an important post-translational modification guiding cellular localization. Recently predictive models for identifying FTase substrates have been reported. Here we evaluate these models through screening of dansylated-GCaaS peptides, which also provides new insights into the protein substrate selectivity of FTase.

Protein farnesyl transferase target selectivity is dependent upon peptide stimulated product release

Protein farnesyl transferase (FTase) catalyzes transfer of a 15 carbon farnesyl lipid to cysteine in the C-terminal Ca1a2X sequence of numerous proteins including Ras. Previous studies have shown that product release is rate limiting and is dependent on binding of either a new peptide or isoprenoid diphosphate substrate. While considerable progress has been made in understanding how FTase distinguishes between related target proteins, the relative importance of the two pathways for product release on substrate selectivity is unclear. A detailed analysis of substrate stimulated product release has now been performed and provides new insights into the mechanism of FTase target selectivity. To clarify how FTase selects between different Ca1a2X sequences, we have examined the competition of various peptide substrates for modification with the isoprenoids farnesyl diphosphate (FPP) and anilinogeranyl diphosphate (AGPP). We find that reactivity of some competing peptides is correlated with apparent Kmpeptide, while the reactivity of others is predicted by the selectivity factor apparent kcat/Kmpeptide. The peptide target selectivity also depends on the structure of the isoprenoid donor. Additionally, we observe two peptide substrate concentration dependent maxima and substrate inhibition in the steady-state reaction which require a minimum of three peptide binding states for the steady-state FTase reaction mechanism. We propose a model for the FTase reaction mechanism that, in addition to FPP stimulated product release, incorporates peptide binding to the FTase-FPP complex and the formation of an FTase-product-peptide complex followed by product release leading to an inhibitory FTase-peptide complex as a natural consequence of catalysis to explain these results.

Selective modification of CaaX peptides with ortho-substituted anilinogeranyl lipids by protein farnesyl transferase: competitive substrates and potent inhibitors from a library of farnesyl diphosphate analogues

Protein farnesyl transferase (FTase) catalyzes transfer of a 15-carbon farnesyl group from farnesyl diphosphate (FPP) to a conserved cysteine in the C-terminal Ca1a2X motif of a range of proteins ("C" refers to the cysteine, "a" to any aliphatic amino acid, and "X" to any amino acid), and the lipid chain interacts with, and forms part of, the Ca1a2X peptide binding site. Here, we employed a library of anilinogeranyl diphosphate (AGPP) derivatives to examine whether altering the interacting surface between the two substrates could be exploited to generate Ca1a2X peptide selective FPP analogues. Analysis of transfer kinetics to dansyl-GCVLS peptide revealed that AGPP analogues with substituents smaller than or equal in size to a thiomethyl group supported FTase function, while analogues with larger substituents did not. Analogues with small meta-substitutions on the aniline ring such as iodo and cyano increased reactivity with dansyl-GCVLS and provided analogues that were effective FPP competitors. Other analogues with ortho-substitutions on the aniline were potent dansyl-GCVLS modification FTase inhibitors (Ki in the 2.4-18 nM range). Both meta- and para-trifluoromethoxy-AGPP are transferred to dansyl-GCVLS while the ortho-substituted isomer was a potent farnesyl transferase inhibitor (FTI) with an inhibition constant Ki = 3.0 nM. In contrast, ortho-trifluoromethoxy-AGPP was efficiently transferred to dansyl-GCVIM. Competition for dansyl-GCVLS and dansyl-GCVIM peptides by FPP and ortho-trifluoromethoxy-AGPP gave both analogue and farnesyl modified dansyl-GCVIM but only farnesylated dansyl-GCVLS. We provide evidence that competitive modification of dansyl-GCVIM by ortho-trifluoromethoxy-AGPP stems from a prechemical step discrimination between the competing peptides by the FTase-analogue complex. These results show that subtle changes engineered into the isoprenoid structure can alter the reactivity and FPP competitiveness of the analogues, which may be important for the development of prenylated protein function inhibitors.

Upstream polybasic region in peptides enhances dual specificity for prenylation by both farnesyltransferase and geranylgeranyltransferase type I

Protein farnesyltransferase (FTase) and protein geranylgeranyltransferase type I (GGTase I) catalyze the attachment of a farnesyl or geranylgeranyl lipid, respectively, near the C-terminus of their protein substrates. FTase and GGTase I differ in both their substrate specificity and magnesium dependence, where the activity of FTase, but not GGTase I, is activated by magnesium. Many protein substrates of these enzymes contain an upstream polybasic region that is proposed to increase the affinity of the substrate and aid in plasma membrane association. Here, we demonstrate that the addition of an upstream polybasic region to a peptide substrate enhances the binding affinity of FTase approximately 4-fold for the peptide but diminishes the catalytic efficiency of the reaction, reflected by decreases in both the prenylation rate constant and kcat/KM. Specifically, the prenylation rate constant decreases 7-fold at 5 mM MgCl2 for the peptide KKKSKTKCVIM (C-terminal sequence of K-Ras4B) in comparison to TKCVIM. This decrease is accompanied by an alteration in the dependence on magnesium, as the K(Mg) increases from 2.2 +/- 0.1 mM for TKCVIM to 11.5 +/- 0.1 mM for KKKSKTKCVIM. The presence of an upstream polybasic region does not significantly affect GGTase I-catalyzed reactions, as only minimal changes are seen in Kd, kcat/KM, and k(chem) values. Thus, the presence of an upstream polybasic region enhances the dual prenylation of these substrates, by decreasing the catalytic efficiency of farnesylation catalyzed by FTase to a level comparable to that of geranylgeranylation catalyzed by GGTase I.

Refinement and prediction of protein prenylation motifs

Three prenylation motif predictors are presented that allow discrimination between proteins that are unique substrates of farnesyltransferase (FT) and those that can be alternatively processed by geranylgeranyltransferase I (GGT1).

We refined the motifs for carboxy-terminal protein prenylation by analysis of known substrates for farnesyltransferase (FT), geranylgeranyltransferase I (GGT1) and geranylgeranyltransferase II (GGT2). In addition to the CaaX box for the first two enzymes, we identify a preceding linker region that appears constrained in physicochemical properties, requiring small or flexible, preferably hydrophilic, amino acids. Predictors were constructed on the basis of sequence and physical property profiles, including interpositional correlations, and are available as the Prenylation Prediction Suite (PrePS, ) which also allows evaluation of evolutionary motif conservation. PrePS can predict partially overlapping substrate specificities, which is of medical importance in the case of understanding cellular action of FT inhibitors as anticancer and anti-parasite agents.

Hydrophobicity and functionality maps of farnesyltransferase

Farnesyltransferase (FTase) catalyzes the attachment of a 15-carbon isoprenoid moiety, farnesyl, through a thioether linkage to a cysteine near the C-terminus of oncogenic Ras proteins. These transform animal cells to a malignant phenotype when farnesylated. Hence, FTase is an interesting target for the development of antitumor agents. In this work we first investigate the active site of FTase by mapping its hydrophobic patches. Then the program SEED is used to dock functional groups into the active site by an exhaustive search and efficient evaluation of the binding energy with solvation. The electrostatic energy is SEED is based on the continuum dielectric approximation and consists of screened intermolecular energy and protein and fragment desolvation terms. The results are found to be consistent with the sequence variability of the tetrapeptide substrate. The distribution of functional groups (functionality maps) on the substrate binding site allows for identification of modifications of the tetrapeptide sequence that are consistent with potent peptidic inhibitors. Furthermore, the best minima of benzene match corresponding moieties of an inhibitor in clinical trials. The functionality maps are also used to design a library of disubstituted indoles that might prevent the binding of the protein substrates.

From peptide libraries to optimized nonpeptide ligands in the search for S-farnesyltransferase inhibitors

A complete 331,776-member library of tetrapeptides made of 24 amino acid building blocks was synthesized robotically on solid phase and subjected to a deconvolution based on the inhibitory potency of the sublibraries in a HPLC assay of the S-farnesyltransferase activity in vitro. One of the non-natural peptide and noncysteine-containing leads Nip-Trp-Phe-His (Nip=p-nitrophenyl-L-alanine) was optimized chemically to give a proteolytically stable pseudopeptide with a 200-fold potency compared with the original lead. The final compound was converted to the C-terminal ethyl ester: p-F-C6H4-CO(CH2)2-CO-Bta-D-Phepsi[CH2NH]His-OEt (Bta = benzothienyl-L-alanine) and shown to behave as a prodrug which was hydrolyzed back to the C-terminal acid following cell penetration. The method confirmed that several structurally original leads can be discovered in large libraries when deconvolution relies upon a highly specific assay and that these leads can be optimized by chemical modification to impart the final compound the desired pharmacological and pharmacokinetic properties.

Sorting and function of peroxisomal membrane proteins

Peroxisomes are subcellular organelles and are present in virtually all eukaryotic cells. Characteristic features of these organelles are their inducibility and their functional versatility. Their importance in the intermediary metabolism of cells is exemplified by the discovery of several inborn, fatal peroxisomal errors in man, the so-called peroxisomal disorders. Recent findings in research on peroxisome biogenesis and function have demonstrated that peroxisomal matrix proteins and peroxisomal membrane proteins (PMPs) follow separate pathways to reach their target organelle. This paper addresses the principles of PMP sorting and summarizes the current knowledge of the role of these proteins in organelle biogenesis and function.

Physico-chemical and biological analysis of true combinatorial libraries

Combinatorial libraries offer new sources of compounds for the research of pharmacological agents such as receptor ligands, enzyme inhibitors or substrates and antibody-binding epitopes. The present review stresses the main roles played by both physico-chemical analysis, particularly when complex mixture of compounds are synthesized as libraries, and biological analysis from which active compounds are identified. After a brief discussion of semantic problems related to the designation of the product mixtures, the physico-chemical analysis of mixtures is reviewed with special emphasis on mass spectrometric techniques. These methods are able both to give a representative view of a library composition and to identify single critical compounds in large libraries. Then the biological screening of such combinatorial libraries is critically discussed with respect to the power and limitations of the methods used for the identification of the active components. Special attention is given to the complex process of library deconvolution. It is pointed out that while combinatorial techniques have evolved towards sophisticated high-tech methods, simple and robust biochemical tests should be used to deconvolute. From a large panel of published examples, a set of trends are identified which should help investigators to choose the most appropriate assay for the discovery of new entities.