The veto mechanism in transplant tolerance

Use of Allogeneic Bone Marrow Labeled with Neomycin Resistance Gene to Examine Bone Marrow-Derived Chimerism in Experimental Organ Transplantation

Posttransplant infusion of viable donor bone marrow cells (DBMC) has been shown in our previous studies to promote acceptance of incompatible kidney allografts in rhesus monkeys after treatment with polyclonal antithymocyte globulin to deplete peripheral T-lymphocytes. In this nonhuman primate model, the infusion of the DBMC is requisite for the induction of functional graft tolerance and specific MLR and CTLp unresponsiveness, although the relevant role and fate of bone marrow-derived chimeric cells is uncertain. Standard immunological and molecular techniques applied to this monkey model are unable to differentiate between chimeric cells derived from the infused DBMC and those derived from allograft-borne passenger leukocyte emigrants. To distinguish chimerism due to infused DBMC, we transduced DBMC with a functional neomycin resistance gene (Neor) using the retroviral vector pHSG-Neo. Neor-Mransduced BMC were infused into recipients approximately 2 wk after kidney transplantation and treatment with rabbit antithymocyte globulin. No maintenance immunosuppressive drugs were given. Genomic DNA isolated from peripheral blood leukocytes was used to monitor the presence of Neor-positive cells. Tissue samples obtained at necropsy also were assessed for Neor-positive chimeric cells. The presence of DBMC-derived chimerism was assessed by polymerase chain reaction using Neor sequence-specific primers (PCR-SSP). Chimerism was detectable in recipient tissues at various times for up to 6 mo after DBMC infusion. These studies using gene transduction methodology indicate that a stable genetic marker can provide capability to examine DBMC-derived chimerism for prolonged periods in a nonhuman primate model. This approach should facilitate future studies in preclinical models to study the role and type of chimeric cell lineages in relation to functional allograft tolerance.

Regulation of alloimmune responses (GvH reactions) in vitro by autologous donor bone marrow cell preparation used in clinical organ transplantation

BACKGROUND

Cadaver donor bone marrow cells (DBMC) are capable of a low-grade response to allogeneic stimulation in vitro, indicating their potential ability to cause graft versus host disease (GvHD). However, at this center, we have observed a lack of GvHD in kidney transplant recipients who received DBMC perioperatively. Therefore, we questioned whether an intrinsic immunoregulatory function of (subpopulations of) DBMC might play a role in this observation.

METHODS

In in vitro assays, DBMC was added to autologous splenic responder cells taking part in allogeneic mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) and cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) reactions.

RESULTS

When compared with autologous donor irradiated spleen cells as control modulators, DBMC significantly inhibited the CML, but to a much lesser extent than MLR, of autologous responding cells stimulated with allogeneic irradiated cells in a dose dependent manner. The down-regulation of CML responses was observed even in the presence of pharmacological concentrations FK506, mycophenolic acid, or cyclosporine-A. The inhibition could not be overcome by the addition of exogenous helper factors. Moreover, in contrast with findings previously reported from this laboratory of the in vitro inhibitory effect of DBMC on allogeneic responding cells in MLR and CML reactions to stimulating cells of the DBMC donor (allogeneic host versus graft inhibition), the following unique observations were made using DBMC inhibiting autologous reactions (GvH): (1) optimal restimulation of autologous responder cells in secondary cultures could not abrogate this inhibition; even activated responder cells could be inhibited by autologous DBMC, and (2) soluble factors were at least partially operative in this autologous (GvH) inhibition as indicated by experiments in transwells and by the CML inhibition caused by 50% supernatants from DBMC cultures.

CONCLUSION

These in vitro results indicate that DBMC treatment brings about a marked down-regulation of autologous immunocompetent cells in cytotoxicity reactions, partially at least through secreted soluble factor(s), (and in presence of immunosuppressive drugs in vivo) thereby preventing overt clinical GvHD.

Rhesus monocyte-derived dendritic cells modified to over-express TGF-beta1 exhibit potent veto activity

BACKGROUND

The tolerogenic activity of allogeneic bone marrow cells (BMCs) associates with functional inactivation of alloreactive T cells and has been attributed to a veto effect. Studies in mice and rhesus monkeys indicated that the CD8alpha molecule expressed on a subpopulation of allogeneic BMCs is necessary to induce signal transduction within the BMCs to increase veto effector molecules such as transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta1. In vitro activation of alloreactive cytotoxic T-lymphocyte precursor enhances their susceptibility to veto-mediated functional inactivation by specific alloantigen-bearing BMCs. Accordingly, we examined a hypothesis that mature rhesus monkey (Rh) monocyte-derived dendritic cells (MDDCs) modified by gene transfer to over-express active TGF-beta1 might mediate veto activity without the need to express CD8alpha.

METHODS

Rh MDDCs were modified by recombinant adenovirus (Ad) transduction and characterized by phenotype and functional studies.

RESULTS

Rh MDDC transduction with Ad vectors using conventional methods was remarkably inefficient. However, a single-chain anti-CD40/soluble Coxsackie and adenovirus receptor-fusion protein (G28/sCAR) permitted high-efficiency transduction of Rh MDDCs by retargeting Ad to Rh MDDC CD40. Mature Rh MDDCs that were transduced to overexpress active TGF-beta1 (AdTGF-beta1 Rh MDDC) significantly suppressed alloimmune responses in [ H]thymidine uptake mixed leukocyte reaction assays. We showed by the carboxyfluorescein succinimidyl ester dilution method that allogeneic mature AdTGF-beta1 Rh MDDCs inhibited proliferation of CD4 and CD8 responder T cells. Notably, AdTGF-beta1 Rh MDDC abrogated alloimmune responses induced by control AdGFP Rh MDDC in an antigen-specific manner.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that nonhuman primate mature MDDCs can be genetically engineered to function as alloantigen-specific cellular immunosuppressants, an approach that has potential to facilitate induction of allograft tolerance in vivo.

Immunological tolerance as an adjunct to allogeneic tissue grafting

Since its clinical inception, our group has worked in clinical and experimental transplantation. The exciting early results of composite tissue allografts (CTA) attracted our attention during the 1980s, when some of the first experimental CTA literature appeared. The recent extraordinary results of clinical CTA grafts, primarily the Louisville and Lyon results, have been highlighted at this meeting. Interestingly, this success followed not long after the first International meeting in Louisville in 1997. This is clearly an exciting new application of transplant techniques to one of the newest and most unique types of transplants. Previous studies used immunosuppression for skin allografting. Early results seem quite exciting and we expect to see a rapid growth of interest and activity in this area. We believe that the entire field would benefit from the novel, highly effective and minimally toxic immune tolerance induction using CD3-immunotoxin (CD3-IT) and deoxyspergualin (DSG).

Donor bone marrow-derived chimeric cells present in renal transplant recipients infused with donor marrow. I. Potent regulators of recipient antidonor immune responses

BACKGROUND

Even though a number of transplant centers have adopted donor-specific bone marrow cell (DBMC) infusions to enhance donor cell chimerism, to date there has been no direct evidence linking chimerism with tolerance induction in human organ transplant recipients.

METHODS

Cells of donor phenotype were isolated 1 year postoperatively from the peripheral blood lymphocytes and iliac crest bone marrow of 11 living-related-donor (LRD) renal transplant recipients, who had received perioperative donor bone marrow cell infusions. These recipient-derived donor (RdD) cells were characterized phenotypically by flow cytometric analysis and functionally as modulators in mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) and cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) assays.

RESULTS

The yield of RdD cells ranged from 0.1 to O.9% of the starting material with the majority being TcRalphabeta, CD3 positive T cells, a substantial percentage of which coexpressed CD28. At 1 year posttransplant almost 50% of the LRD-kidney/DBMC recipients tested so far exhibited donor-specific unresponsiveness in MLR (7/17) and CML (6/13) reactions and this trend was further enhanced at 23 years. In the recipients with residual positive antidonor immune responses, the RdD cells inhibited recipient antidonor MLR and CML responses significantly more strongly than freshly isolated and similarly treated iliac crest bone marrow cells from the donor. RdD cells also inhibited the MLR of the recipient to third party allogeneic stimulator cells; however, this nonspecific effect was significantly weaker than specific inhibition. We also established long-term bone marrow cultures stimulated every 2 weeks with irradiated alogeneic feeder cells, that had similar functional properties thus possibly providing us with an in vitro correlate the RdD cells.

CONCLUSIONS

These results clearly support the notion that the infused donor cells play a positive role in the induction and/or maintenance of transplant tolerance.

Involvement of multiple subpopulations of human bone marrow cells in the regulation of allogeneic cellular immune responses

BACKGROUND

The identity of the cells in the human bone marrow that function as effective regulators of in vitro and possibly in vivo cellular immune responses is not well established.

METHODS

Cell subpopulations were isolated from cadaver donor vertebral-body bone marrow cells (DBMC) by using immuno-magnetic microbeads and were tested as inhibitors (modulators) in cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) and mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) responses of normal peripheral blood lymphocytes stimulated with irradiated cadaver donor spleen cells.

RESULTS

Compared with spleen cells as controls, un-irradiated T-cell depleted DBMC inhibited both the MLR and CML responses of allogeneic responder cells in a dose dependent manner (as in our previous reports). The inhibition was also mediated by a number of purified subpopulations including pluripotent CD34+ stem cells, and their CD34 negative early progeny of both lymphoid and myeloid lineages. These included DBMC enriched for non-T-cell lymphoid precursors (NT-LP/DBMC; i.e., DBMC depleted of CD3, CD15, and glycophorin-A positive cells) and DBMC positively selected for CD38+, CD2+, CD5+, and CD1+ lymphoid cells (all were depleted of CD3+ cells) as well as CD33+ (but CD15 negative) myeloid precursors. However, positively selected CD19+ B-cells and CD15+ myeloid cells did not inhibit the MLR and CML responses. The NT-LP/DBMC that had been repeatedly stimulated with irradiated allogeneic peripheral blood lymphocytes caused the strongest inhibition of the MLR and CML responses of the same allogeneic cells with 200 times fewer modulator cells needed than uncultured DBMC (P<0.001). Flow cytometric analysis revealed that majority of cells in these cell lines had become CD3+ TcR-alphabeta+ CD4+ and CD28+ cells.

CONCLUSION

A variety of less differentiated cells of various lineages residing in the human bone marrow are immunoregulatory in vitro. Among them, there is at least one subset that can undergo differentiation in vitro into regulatory T cells that can be maintained in long-term cultures.

Requirement for early donor cell chimerism during prolonged survival of murine skin allografts

BACKGROUND

Posttransplantation infusion of donor bone marrow cells (BMC) can prolong allograft survival in antilymphocyte antibody- (ALA) treated recipients. This study examined the hypothesis that chimerism of donor BMC origin contributes to allograft unresponsiveness.

METHODS

Survival of day 0 skin grafts from C3H (H2k) donors was prolonged on ALA-treated B6AF1 mice by day +7 infusion of BMC from C3H or C3H-H2o2 (H2K(d)I(d)D(k)) mice. To test for functional chimerism, depletional anti-H2Kd antibody was injected at intervals after C3H-H2o2 BMC infusion. To confirm the persistence of active cells in the recipients, cells harvested from bone marrow of ALA- and C3H BMC-treated primary recipients were transferred to secondary ALA-treated recipients. Other recipients were infused on day +21 with additional donor BMC or light-density BMC that had been cultured in the presence of granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF) and interleukin-4 (IL-4) to promote the differentiation of dendritic cells (DC).

RESULTS

Injection of depletional antibody targeting infused BMC interrupted skin graft survival, whether the injection was made on day +7, 2 hr after BMC injection, or as late as day +28. Prolonged graft survival was transferred to secondary recipients with cells recovered from primary recipient marrow as long as 4 weeks after initial donor BMC treatment. Graft survival prolonged by day +7 BMC was further enhanced by infusion on day +21 of light density cultured BMC, although a second dose of unfractionated BMC was inactive. Repeated injection of cultured BMC at 2-week intervals after day +21 prolonged graft survival even further.

CONCLUSIONS

These data directly demonstrate that at least short-term donor BMC-derived microchimerism is required for prolonged allograft survival. The data further suggest that the active chimeric cells persist in recipient marrow. Finally, the beneficial effect of late infusion of cultured cells containing partially differentiated DC suggest that DC may be the active chimeric cells.

In vitro immunogenicity of cadaver donor bone marrow cells used for the induction of allograft acceptance in clinical transplantation

BACKGROUND

The cascade of immunological effects brought about by donor bone marrow cell (DBMC) infusions to induce allograft acceptance in clinical transplantation is not fully understood. Aside from acting as immune responding and regulatory cells, the infused DBMC also may sensitize the recipient to the donor antigens.

METHODS

To analyze this stimulatory activity of DBMC, in vitro mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC) and cell-mediated lymphocytotoxicity (CML) culture systems analogous to the transplant model with DBMC infusion were used.

RESULTS

When responding peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) from normal volunteers were placed in culture with suspensions of Ficoll-purified, T cell-depleted, un-irradiated allogeneic DBMC (NT-DBMC), a reaction was seen in both MLC and CML. However, when compared to allogeneic spleen cells as stimulating cells, the responses to NT-DBMC were of markedly lower magnitude and were not seen when the NT-DBMC was irradiated (3000 R). When responding PBL were stimulated with either NT-DBMC that had been previously cultured with irradiated cells from the responders for 1 week (activated NT-DBMC), NT-DBMC further depleted of CD15+ and glycophorin A-positive cells (NT-LP/DBMC), or purified CD34+ and CD2+ DBMC subsets, stronger lymphoproliferative and cytotoxic responses were observed. Moreover, these responses were not abrogated by irradiation of the stimulating DBMC subpopulations. Depletion of antigen-presenting cells by positive selection of CD3+ cells from the responding PBL abrogated MLC and CML reactivity, even when purified NT-LP/DBMC, the most stimulatory cells, were used. This latter observation was in contrast to the responses seen with cultures containing allogeneic stimulating spleen cell populations. This indicated the requirement for indirect alloantigen presentation, i.e., the failure of these DBMC to stimulate by direct alloantigen presentation. NT-DBMC was able to stimulate responding PBL in secondary MLC and CML responses with an equivalent magnitude, irrespective of whether the stimulators were spleen cells or NT-DBMC. Finally, the MLC and CML responses were inhibited by tacrolimus (FK506), mycophenolic acid (MPA), and cyclosporine (CsA) in a dose dependent manner, in contrast to previously observed refractoriness of DBMC preparations to these agents if DBMC was tested as responder cells or in modulatory assays.

CONCLUSIONS

These results indicate that DBMC are able to function as effective in vitro stimulators, but only by indirect antigen presentation, and that the immune responses mediated by them can be down-regulated by their own inherent suppressive nature, an effect that can be enhanced by the presence of immunosuppressive drugs.

Myoblast cell grafting into heart muscle: cellular biology and potential applications

This review surveys a wide range of cellular and molecular approaches to strengthening the injured or weakened heart, focusing on strategies to replace dysfunctional, necrotic, or apoptotic cardiomyocytes with new cells of mesodermal origin. A variety of cell types, including myogenic cell lines, adult skeletal myoblasts, immoratalized atrial cells, embryonic and adult cardiomyocytes, embryonic stem cells, tetratoma cells, genetically altered fibroblasts, smooth muscle cells, and bone marrow-derived cells have all been proposed as useful cells in cardiac repair and may have the capacity to perform cardiac work. We focus on the implantation of mesodermally derived cells, the best developed of the options. We review the developmental and cell biology that have stimulated these studies, examine the limitations of current knowledge, and identify challenges for the future, which we believe are considerable.

Immunoregulatory role of CD8alpha in the veto effect

BACKGROUND

Allogeneic bone marrow cell (allo-BMC) infusion induces tolerance to incompatible renal allografts in rhesus macaques after depletion of peripheral T lymphocytes with cytolytic anti-T cell antibodies. The tolerogenic effect of allo-BMC, ascribed to a veto mechanism, associates with specific functional deletion of antidonor cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursor (CTLp), and is dependent on a CD8+ donor BMC subset. In previous studies, the CD8 molecule was implicated by loss of suppression after blocking interaction between CD8 on allo-BMC and major histocompatibility complex class Ialpha3 domain on CTLp. CD8 cross-linking on BMC induced secretion of active transforming growth factor-beta1 (TGF-beta1), suggesting a regulatory mechanism(s) operating via a CD8-mediated signaling pathway.

METHODS

CD8 on rhesus cells was cross-linked using IgG-conjugated beads, and TGF-beta1 mRNA and protein were quantified. CD8+ cells were tested for veto activity by mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR)-induced cell-mediated lymphocytotoxicity (CML) assay. Activated rhesus T cells exposed to TGF-beta1 were examined for apoptosis by TdT-mediated end-labeling and annexin staining.

RESULTS

CD8 cross-linking induces accumulation of TGF-beta1 mRNA and protein. Both CD3- CD8+CD16+ and CD3+ CD8+CD16- subsets of allo-BMC up-regulate TGF-beta1 mRNA after CD8 cross-linking, and exhibit veto activity. The CD3-CD8+CD16+ subset expresses more TGF-beta1 mRNA and increased veto activity at low BMC/CTLp ratios. Exposure of activated T cells to TGF-beta1 induces apoptosis.

CONCLUSIONS

CD8+ allo-BMC are enriched for veto activity and activation via CD8 induces TGF-beta1 mRNA and protein accumulation. These results agree with the hypothesis that paracrine TGF-beta1 may be involved in peripheral deletion of alloreactive CTLp by CD8+ allo-BMC. We suggest that TGF-beta1 overexpression by donor lymphohematopoietic cells may enhance tolerance induction.

Molecular cloning, expression and characterization of rhesus macaque Fas ligand cDNA

The Fas/Fas ligand (FasL) interaction is pivotal in apoptosis-mediated regulation of the immune system. As such, it has relevance in areas of transplantation, gene therapy, AIDS, etc., all of which utilize the rhesus macaque as a preclinical animal model. In order to examine rhesus Fas/FasL, we cloned the rhesus FasL cDNA and have analyzed the function of the cloned gene. Our findings indicate that the rhesus FasL is highly homologous to the human but not the mouse (97% for human, 85% for mouse). In addition, soluble rhesus FasL can induce apoptosis, a property shared with the human soluble protein but not the mouse protein. The deduced protein sequence is 280 amino acids with a calculated Mr. of 31,646. Transfection of COS cells with the full-length cDNA yielded a 40 KD protein, which is in agreement with the size of human FasL. COS cells expressing rhesus FasL induced apoptosis in rhesus PHA blasts and human Fas+ CEM-6 cells. Thus, the cloned rhesus macaque FasL is functional and cross-reacts with human Fas. The cloned functional rhesus FasL cDNA will enable studies of its regulatory role in the nonhuman primate immune system.

Exposure of hepatic sinusoidal mononuclear cells to UW solution in situ but not ex vivo induces apoptosis

BACKGROUND/AIMS

We have previously reported that human hepatic sinusoidal mononuclear cells may have a higher sensitivity to induction of apoptosis than peripheral blood mononuclear cells. In this study, the effects of two different preservation solutions on the functions of those hepatic mononuclear cells were evaluated in living-related liver transplantation.

METHODS

Ten and 11 liver grafts were perfused via the portal vein with University of Wisconsin solutions (UW group) and Bretschneider's Histidine-Tryptophan-Ketoglutarate solutions (HTK group), respectively. Hepatic mononuclear cells were isolated from the effluent preservation solution passing through the graft livers. Cytofluorometry, cytotoxic assay, and DNA analysis were performed.

RESULTS

There were no significant differences in surface antigens and natural killer activity of hepatic sinusoidal mononuclear cells between the UW and HTK groups. At the time of isolation, the viability of hepatic sinusoidal mononuclear cells in both groups was more than 99%. In the UW group, the viability of hepatic sinusoidal mononuclear cells decreased to 30% through apoptosis in in vitro culture at 48 h after isolation. In the HTK group, however, their viability was maintained at more than 90% at 48 h in the same culture conditions, and additional exposure to UW solution ex vivo for 30 min did not induce apoptosis.

CONCLUSION

Hepatic sinusoidal mononuclear cells isolated from the UW solution, not from the HTK solution, passing through the liver died through apoptosis, which was not induced by each component of the UW solution, but by exposure in situ.

Cellular immune responses of human cadaver donor bone marrow cells and their susceptibility to commonly used immunosuppressive drugs in transplantation

BACKGROUND

The cascade of immunological effects brought about by donor bone marrow cell (DBMC) infusions in human organ transplantation, especially in the context of continuous pharmacologic immunosuppression, is not fully understood. Yet, in inbred rodents and even primates, administration of specific bone marrow cells has caused a state of acquired immunologic tolerance.

METHODS

In vitro mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) and cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) culture systems were used to compare the responding and regulatory properties of DBMC and individual bone marrow cell subsets versus spleen cells in the presence or absence of pharmacologic immunosuppression.

RESULTS

In the absence of immunosuppressive drugs, the DBMC proliferated in MLC and in response to phytohemagglutinin, but to a lower magnitude than donor spleen cells. In CML assays, DBMC failed to function as cytotoxic cells. Removal of both CD3+ and CD34+ cells together (not just singly) had to occur for complete abrogation of the proliferative response of DBMC evoked in the presence of allogeneic stimulating cells. Testing several experimental variables using flow cytometric analysis led to the conclusion that when purified DBMC CD34+ cells were placed in coculture with irradiated allogeneic peripheral blood mononuclear cells, such CD34+ cells give rise both to CD3- TCRalphabeta+ as well as to dimly staining CD3+ TCRalphabeta+ cells. Low pharmacologic concentrations of tacrolimus/cyclosporine (CsA) and mycophenolic acid (MPA) singly or in combination had no effect on the spontaneous proliferation of DBMC and had significantly less inhibitory activity on MLC responses of DBMC and its purified CD3+ or CD34+ subpopulations, compared with the responses of spleen cells. Moreover, the previously described regulatory effects of DBMC on the MLC responses of peripheral blood or splenic responding cells were not inhibited by these immunosuppressive drugs.

CONCLUSIONS

Taken together, these results support the notion that in vitro DBMC subpopulations, which proliferate as responding cells in co-culture with x-irradiated allogeneic cells and which cause regulatory effects when added as a third component to MLC reactions, seem to be culture-generated lymphoid cell lineage(s) progeny of CD34+ cells. This possibly includes unique CD3+ "primitive" (dimly staining) T cells, which are not as inhibited in their function by tacrolimus/CsA and MPA, as are postthymic (splenic) T cells.

Use of allogeneic bone marrow labeled with neomycin resistance gene to examine bone marrow-derived chimerism in experimental organ transplantation

Posttransplant infusion of viable donor bone marrow cells (DBMC) has been shown in our previous studies to promote acceptance of incompatible kidney allografts in rhesus monkeys after treatment with polyclonal antithymocyte globulin to deplete peripheral T-lymphocytes. In this nonhuman primate model, the infusion of the DBMC is requisite for the induction of functional graft tolerance and specific MLR and CTLp unresponsiveness, although the relevant role and fate of bone marrow-derived chimeric cells is uncertain. Standard immunological and molecular techniques applied to this monkey model are unable to differentiate between chimeric cells derived from the infused DBMC and those derived from allograft-borne passenger leukocyte emigrants. To distinguish chimerism due to infused DBMC, we transduced DBMC with a functional neomycin resistance gene (Neo(r)) using the retroviral vector pHSG-Neo.Neo(r)-transduced BMC were infused into recipients approximately 2 wk after kidney transplantation and treatment with rabbit antithymocyte globulin. No maintenance immunosuppressive drugs were given. Genomic DNA isolated from peripheral blood leukocytes was used to monitor the presence ofNeo(r)-positive cells. Tissue samples obtained at necropsy also were assessed forNeo(r)-positive chimeric cells. The presence of DBMC-derived chimerism was assessed by polymerase chain reaction usingNeo(r) sequence-specific primers (PCR-SSP). Chimerism was detectable in recipient tissues at various times for up to 6 mo after DBMC infusion. These studies using gene transduction methodology indicate that a stable genetic marker can provide capability to examine DBMC-derived chimerism for prolonged periods in a nonhuman primate model. This approach should facilitate future studies in preclinical models to study the role and type of chimeric cell lineages in relation to functional allograft tolerance.

Will tolerance become a clinical reality?

The goal of transplant physicians is to create a state of antigen-specific tolerance in the recipient, whereby the graft is not rejected and the patient will not need a lifetime of medical therapy. Although the immunosuppressive medications used are effective in lowering the incidence of rejection, they produce significant side effects and do not induce a state of transplantation tolerance. Progress toward inducing transplantation tolerance has been made in animal models, primarily by the exploitation of the natural mechanisms that vertebrates have to maintain self-tolerance. These same strategies are being employed in clinical trials and consequently are promising and challenging for the future.

Modulatory effects of human donor bone marrow cells on allogeneic cellular immune responses

BACKGROUND

In order to evaluate whether immunoregulatory mechanisms are brought about by human donor bone marrow cell infusions accompanying organ transplantation, we established in vitro culture systems analogous to the transplant model.

METHODS

Cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) and mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) responses of peripheral blood lymphocytes or spleen cells stimulated with irradiated cadaver donor spleen cells in the presence of specific donor vertebral-body bone marrow cell (DBMC) modulators were tested.

RESULTS

When compared with spleen cells as modulator controls, DBMC inhibited both the proliferative and cytotoxic responses in a dose-dependent manner. Use of unirradiated and T cell-depleted DBMC was required for detection of the inhibitory activity. Furthermore, DBMC had to be added within the first 2 days after the initiation of the cultures for the down-regulation of CML (MLC) to occur. The down-regulation of MLC responses could not be shown to be antigen (donor) specific. Physical separation of DBMC from the responder-stimulator cells using the transwell system abrogated modulation of the CML (and MLC) reactions, suggesting the requirement of cell-cell contact for modulatory effect. The inhibitory activity by DBMC could not be overcome by addition of up to 200 U/ml of exogenous recombinant interleukin 2 to the cultures. However, it could be abrogated by restimulation with donor spleen cells, indicating that donor reactive cells were not deleted by DBMC in short-term cultures.

CONCLUSIONS

These results showed a regulatory role for DBMC in cellular immune responses against donor cell alloantigens, supporting the rationale for DBMC for facilitating clinical allograft acceptance.

Liver allograft rejection in rats depleted of CD8+ cells

The mechanism(s) of rejection or tolerance induction is a competitive, complex process that presumably involves interactions between multiple subpopulations of T lymphocytes. We investigated the roles of CD8+ cytolytic and CD4+ helper T cells in rat strains that tolerate liver allografts and that differ at both the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) (RT1) and minor histocompatibility genes. Orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) with arterial reconstruction was performed with Brown Norway (BN) (RT1n) donors and Lewis (RT1(1)) recipients, some of which were untreated, others treated with anti-CD8 antibody, and still others treated with anti-CD4 antibody. Liver graft rejection was monitored for 28 days on the basis of two criteria: (1) serum levels of AST enzyme at 3-day intervals and (2) liver biopsies at weekly intervals and at the time of sacrifice at the end of the study period. In the untreated control group, an elevation of AST was found to peak at day 6 after grafting, and it remained elevated until day 28 (AST 542 +/- 72 U/l). Histologically, signs of severe rejection were first observed on day 9; these changed to moderate rejection about day 21 and to mild rejection by day 28, when the animals were sacrificed. Recipients pre-treated with anti-CD8 demonstrated a significant elevation of AST within 6 days that, unlike in the control recipients, continued to rise sharply through the observation period (AST 1127 +/- 181 U/l, P = 0.009 vs control group). Liver biopsies showed mild rejection at day 9 and moderate rejection at days 21 through 28. Recipients pretreated with anti-CD4 showed a time course of enzyme elevation and severity of rejection that was not significantly different from that observed in the control group. However, anti-CD4 treatment resulted in only 75% depletion of CD4+ cells in peripheral blood as compared to complete elimination of CD8+ cells following anti-CD8 treatment. Functional studies of spleen and liver-infiltrating lymphocytes obtained after 28 days showed low proliferative response in mixed lymphocyte culture with both BN and PVG stimulator spleen and lymph node cells. These results suggest that in this donor/recipient combination, removal of CD8+ cells increases the severity of rejection as demonstrated by a progressive rise in AST and histology. Moreover, OLT in this combination results in a profound, nonspecific inhibition of proliferative T-cell responses to MHC alloantigens.

Pancreatic islet allograft immunity and tolerance: the two-signal hypothesis revisited

The principle assumption of this discussion is that costimulation (CoS) forms the primary stimulus that compels T cells to mount a response to their specific antigen. However, this response can be either positive or negative, depending on the developmental stage of the T cell and the microenvironment in which the antigen and CoS are received. Thus, both immunity and tolerance may represent different outcomes of a two-signal process. We would emphasize that CoS is a functional term and not a strict molecular definition. While many molecular interactions have been described as providing CoS activity, notably those involving the B-7 family of cell surface molecules, it is not yet clear what combination(s) of non-antigen-specific signals may fulfil this function. This point is important because many studies have achieved tolerance through strategies designed to inhibit specific CoS molecules. However, it may be that differential signaling through distinct CoS molecules, rather than a global inhibition of CoS per se, plays a role in the generation of active tolerance in such studies (Bluestone 1995). A corollary of this notion is that antigen (signal 1) delivery to T cells is a null event and so is not an inherently paralysing signal. Of course, if signal 1 is not itself a tolerogenic signal, then other mechanisms are necessary to explain many empirical observations of tolerance to allogeneic or self antigens. This is best illustrated by those forms of functional tolerance to either alloantigens or self antigens that do not appear to be the result of clonal deletion/inactivation. It would be relatively simple to invoke a model of tolerance whereby the relevant tissue-destructive cell is eliminated or inactivated; such a model would preclude the necessity to suggest active regulatory mechanisms of tolerance. However, in several model systems, including our own observations concerning tolerance induction to APC-depleted islet allografts, tissue-destructive T cells can persist in recipients tolerant to allogeneic or self antigens. Furthermore, there are key examples in which tolerance demonstrates a dominant phenotype; that is, tolerant cells can regulate the activity of naive, non-tolerant cells. This latter observation points to the function of an active, regulatory form of tolerance. As such, we would emphasize that tolerance should not be defined as unresponsiveness since the tolerant state is the consequence of very active immune reactions.

Effect of monoclonal anti-CD4 and anti-CD8 on skin allograft survival in mice treated with donor bone marrow cells

Allograft unresponsiveness can be induced by donor bone marrow cells (BMC) in antilymphocyte serum (ALS)-treated recipients. The effect of administering monoclonal anti-CD4 and -CD8 at several points has been examined in a mouse skin allograft model of this protocol. Brief peritransplant administration of anti-CD4 and -CD8 was used to replace ALS. Anti-CD4 treatment prolonged graft survival only slightly and conditioned recipients poorly for the effect of posttransplantation donor BMC infusion. Anti-CD8 was ineffective in both capacities. A mixture of anti-CD4 and anti-CD8 was at least as effective as ALS in prolonging graft survival and in promoting the beneficial effects of donor BMC. Like the monoclonal antibodies, ALS also depleted splenic and lymph node CD4+ and CD8+ cells. Injection of ALS, but not the monoclonal antibodies, altered the CD4/CD8 phenotype of thymocytes, although persistent binding of both types of antibody to thymocytes was demonstrated. Abrogation of the positive effect of BMC by reconstitution of normal spleen cells on day +3 after ALS treatment confirmed that cell depletion is a requirement of this system. Monoclonal antibodies were also given to ALS/BMC-treated recipients after their grafts had become established. Anti-CD8 injection at either 2 or 4 weeks after transplantation further prolonged graft survival. In contrast, anti-CD4 injection at 2 or 6 weeks after grafting precipitated rejection, which suggests that continued allograft survival following ALS and donor BMC treatment is due to the activity of a CD4+ cell population.

Donor-specific transfusion and donor bone marrow infusion in renal transplantation tolerance: a review of efficacy and mechanisms

The ultimate goal in transplantation is modulation of the immune response to produce tolerance without immunosuppression. To date only a state of pseudotolerance for the allograft has been achieved through the use of potent pharmacologic and biologic manipulations. Despite these manipulations to prevent acute rejection, chronic rejection eventually results in graft failure. Thus, different strategies have been sought to induce tolerance and prevent acute and chronic rejection. Historically, donor-specific transfusion (DST) was one such strategy attempted. Donor-specific transfusion has been used primarily in living donor organ transplantation. With the concern that DST may sensitize patients, thereby preventing transplantation and introduction of cyclosporine, the use of DST was curtailed. More recently, donor bone marrow (DBM) infusion at the time of cadaveric transplantation has been used to facilitate development of microchimerism and tolerance to abrogate acute and chronic rejection. However, DBM infusion may predispose the recipient to graft-versus-host disease and is not easily accomplished in living donor organ transplantation. The potentially immunomodulating and tolerizing mechanisms of DST and DBM infusion are similar and include induction of anergy, stimulation of anti-anti-HLA antibodies, provision of soluble HLA antigen, suppressor cell and/or veto cell activity, clonal deletion, regulation of cell surface molecules, regulation of cytokines, promotion of microchimerism, or a combination of these. Of these mechanisms, microchimerism with the concomitant persistence of soluble donor HLA antigen is felt by many to be the most important. Although microchimerism is detectable in many patients who are tolerant of their grafts, there is no clear evidence that chimerism is responsible for the induction or maintenance of tolerance.

Allogeneic lymphocyte chimerism after clinical lung transplantation

Donor lungs contain large amounts of passenger leukocytes which are transferred to the recipient by organ transplantation. In this study we have analysed the fate of these cells and have studied the populations of donor leucocytes detectable in the blood circulation of ten lung transplanted patients during the first postoperative weeks. To this aim we have applied immunocytological as well as flow cytometric analyses using monoclonal antibodies against polymorphic HLA class I antigens that differed between donor and recipient as well as antibodies against cell differentiation markers. The results demonstrate that donor cells can be detected in the circulation of all lung transplanted patients but there is a considerable interindividual variability between 0.9% and 17.5% (mean 5.1%) on postoperative day 3. Cells were usually detectable for 2-4 weeks and had disappeared in all patients after 1 month. The circulating donor cells consisted exclusively of lymphocytes. T cells were the predominant population, most of which seemed to be CD45R0+, but B and NK (natural killer) cells were also present. Probably due to the small numbers of patients studied no correlation between clinical parameters and the extent of donor lymphocyte persistence; there were no clinical graft-versus-host reactions. The findings demonstrate the regular existence of a transient (macro)chimerism due to passenger lymphocytes in the early phase after lung transplantation. The immunological function and the relation between this phenomenon and the long-term microchimerism which frequently develops after solid organ transplantation remain unclear.