NMR screening in drug discovery

Analysis of metabolome changes in the HepG2 cells of apatinib treatment by using the NMR-based metabolomics

Neovascularization is required for the growth of tumors, vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) and related signal pathways are important in tumor angiogenesis. Apatinib is a highly selective and potent antiangiogenesis drug targeting the receptor of VEGFR2, blocking downstream signal transduction and inhibiting angiogenesis of tumor tissue. Apatinib has a wide range of antitumor activities in vitro and in vivo, but its effect on metabolic changes has not deeply research at present. Nowadays, our research first systematically studied the metabolic changes affected by apatinib in the HepG2 cells at the half-maximal inhibitory concentration value. We used the metabolomics by using ¹ H nuclear magnetic resonance (¹ H-NMR) to analyze the HepG2 cell culture media. Multivariable Statistics was applied to analyze the ¹ H-NMR spectra of the cell media, including principal component analysis, partial least squares discriminant analysis (PLS-DA) and orthogonal PLS-DA (OPLS-DA). Compared with the uncultured and cultured media (negative/positive control), the metabolic phenotypes were changed in the apatinib treatment with a continuous effect over time. The metabolic pathway analysis is shown that the mainly disturbed metabolic pathways pyruvate metabolism, alanine, aspartate, and glutamate metabolism and amino acid metabolism associated with them in the apatinib treatment. The differential metabolites which were identified from the reconstructed OPLS-DA loading plots also reflected in these disturbed metabolic pathways. Our works could allow us to well understand the therapeutic effect of apatinib, especially in metabolism.

Target-based whole-cell screening by ¹H NMR spectroscopy

An NMR-based approach marries the two traditional screening technologies (phenotypic and target-based screening) to find compounds inhibiting a specific enzymatic reaction in bacterial cells. Building on a previous study in which it was demonstrated that hydrolytic decomposition of meropenem in living Escherichia coli cells carrying New Delhi metallo-β-lactamase subclass 1 (NDM-1) can be monitored in real time by NMR spectroscopy, we designed a cell-based NMR screening platform. A strong NDM-1 inhibitor was identified with cellular IC50 of 0.51 μM, which is over 300-fold more potent than captopril, a known NDM-1 inhibitor. This new screening approach has great potential to be applied to targets in other cell types, such as mammalian cells, and to targets that are only stable or functionally competent in the cellular environment.

Integration of small-molecule discovery in academic biomedical research

Rapid advances in biomedical sciences in recent years have drastically accelerated the discovery of the molecular basis of human diseases. The great challenge is how to translate the newly acquired knowledge into new medicine for disease prevention and treatment. Drug discovery is a long and expensive process, and the pharmaceutical industry has not been very successful at it, despite its enormous resources and spending on the process. It is increasingly realized that academic biomedical research institutions ought to be engaged in early-stage drug discovery, especially when it can be coupled to their basic research. To leverage the productivity of new-drug development, a substantial acceleration in validation of new therapeutic targets is required, which would require small molecules that can precisely control target functions in complex biological systems in a temporal and dose-dependent manner. In this review, we describe a process of integration of small-molecule discovery and chemistry in academic biomedical research that will ideally bring together the elements of innovative approaches to new molecular targets, existing basic and clinical research, screening infrastructure, and synthetic and medicinal chemistry to follow up on small-molecule hits. Such integration of multidisciplinary resources and expertise will enable academic investigators to discover novel small molecules that are expected to facilitate their efforts in both mechanistic research and new-drug target validation. More broadly academic drug discovery should contribute new entities to therapy for intractable human diseases, especially for orphan diseases, and hopefully stimulate and synergize with the commercial sector.

Discovery of a novel warhead against beta-secretase through fragment-based lead generation

Fragment-based lead generation was applied to find novel small-molecule inhibitors of beta-secretase (BACE-1), a key target for the treatment of Alzheimer's disease. Fragment hits coming from a 1D NMR screen were characterized by BIAcore, and the most promising compounds were soaked into protein crystals to help the rational design of more potent hit analogues. Problems arising due to our inability to grow BACE-1 crystals at the biologically relevant pH at which the screen was run were overcome by using endothiapepsin as a surrogate aspartyl protease. Among others, we identified 6-substituted isocytosines as a novel warhead against BACE-1, and the accompanying paper in this journal describes how these were optimized to a lead series of nanomolar inhibitors.1.

Polyfluorinated Amino Acids for Sensitive 19F NMR-Based Screening and Kinetic Measurements

Two novel series of polyfluorinated amino acids (PFAs) were designed and synthesized according to a very short and scalable synthetic sequence. The advantages and limitations of these moieties for screening purposes are presented and discussed. The potential applications of these PFAs were tested with their incorporation into small arginine-containing peptides that represent suitable substrates for the enzyme trypsin. The enzymatic reactions were monitored by 19F NMR spectroscopy, using the 3-FABS (three fluorine atoms for biochemical screening) technique. The high sensitivity achieved with these PFAs permits a reduction in substrate concentration required for 3-FABS. This is relevant in the utilization of 3-FABS in fragment-based screening for identification of small scaffolds that bind weakly to the receptor of interest. The large dispersion of 19F isotropic chemical shifts allows the simultaneous measurement of the efficiency of the different substrates, thus identifying the best substrate for screening purposes. Furthermore, the knowledge of KM and Kcat for the different substrates allows the identification of the structural motifs responsible for the binding affinity to the receptor and those affecting the chemical steps in enzymatic catalysis. This enables the construction of suitable pharmacophores that can be used for designing nonpeptidic inhibitors with high affinity for the enzyme or molecules that mimic the transition state. The novel PFAs can also find useful application in the FAXS (fluorine chemical shift anisotropy and exchange for screening) experiment, a 19F-based competition binding assay for the detection of molecules that inhibit the interaction between two proteins.

A protein recycling system for nuclear magnetic resonance-based screening of drug candidates

A sample-treating system for nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR)-based interaction screening between drug candidates (small molecules) and a protein of interest was developed by applying high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) technology. The system prepares a test solution by mixing a (15)N-labeled protein solution and a solution of each candidate compound, loads it to a flow cell-type NMR probe, and recycles the protein after the data acquisition. The system was designed to behave differently according to the information obtained in NMR measurements. In a test operation with a 100-compound library, the system could single out known interacting substances properly. Recovery values of the protein and one representative compound were 75 and 71%, respectively, and the recovered protein was found intact as intended.

Target structure-based discovery of small molecules that block human p53 and CREB binding protein association

Lysine acetylation of human tumor suppressor p53 in response to cellular stress signals is required for its function as a transcription factor that regulates cell cycle arrest, senescence, or apoptosis. Here, we report small molecules that block lysine 382-acetylated p53 association with the bromodomain of the coactivator CBP, an interaction essential for p53-induced transcription of the cell cycle inhibitor p21 in response to DNA damage. These chemicals were discovered in target structure-guided nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy screening of a focused chemical library constructed based on the structural knowledge of CBP bromodomain/p53-AcK382 binding. Structural characterization shows that these chemicals inhibit CBP/p53 association by binding to the acetyl-lysine binding site of the bromodomain. Cell-based functional assays demonstrate that the lead chemicals can modulate p53 stability and function in response to DNA damage.

Structures of ubiquitin insertion mutants support site-specific reflex response to insertions hypothesis

We previously concluded that, judging from NMR chemical shifts, the effects of insertions into ubiquitin on its conformation appear to depend primarily on the site of insertion rather than the sequence of the insertion. To obtain a more complete and atomic-resolution understanding of how these insertions modulate the conformation of ubiquitin, we have solved the crystal structures of four insertional mutants of ubiquitin. Insertions between residues 9 and 10 of ubiquitin are minimally perturbing to the remainder of the protein, while larger alterations occur when the insertion is between residues 35 and 36. Further, the alterations in response to insertions are very similar for each mutant at a given site. Two insertions, one at each site, were designed from structurally homologous proteins. Interestingly, the secondary structure within these five to seven amino acid residue insertions is conserved in the new protein. Overall, the crystal structures support the previous conclusion that the conformational effects of these insertions are determined largely by the site of insertion and only secondarily by the sequence of the insert.

Sensitivity improvement in 19F NMR-based screening experiments: theoretical considerations and experimental applications

NMR-based binding and functional screening performed with FAXS (fluorine chemical shift anisotropy and exchange for screening) and 3-FABS (three fluorine atoms for biochemical screening) represents a potential alternative approach to high-throughput screening for the identification of novel potential drug candidates. The major limitation of this method in its current status is its intrinsic low sensitivity that limits the number of tested compounds. One approach for overcoming this problem is the use of a cryogenically cooled (19)F probe that reduces the thermal noise in the receiver circuitry. Sensitivity improvement in the two screening techniques achieved with the novel cryogenic (19)F probe technology permits an increased throughput, detection of weaker binders and inhibitors (relevant in a fragment-based lead discovery program), detection of slow binders, and reduction in protein and substrate consumption. These aspects are analyzed with theoretical simulations and experimental quantitative performance evaluation. Application of 3-FABS combined with the cryogenic (19)F probe technology to rapid screening at very low enzyme concentrations and the current detection limits reached with this approach are also presented.

Site-specific Reflex Response of Ubiquitin to Loop Insertions

Predicting the structural effects of insertions in proteins by homology modeling remains a challenge. To investigate the molecular basis for conformational adaptations to insertions, ten mutants of ubiquitin were generated by introducing five different inserts, varying from five to 11 residues in size, at two different sites. Most insertion sequences were derived from homologous positions in structurally homologous ubiquitin-like proteins; to test sequence specificity, insertions were made into both homologous and non-homologous sites in ubiquitin. Structural inferences from NMR data suggest that each insertion site shows a reflex response to insertions: the sequence of the insertion has much less impact on structural adaptations than does the site of the insertion. Further, each site responds to insertions in a unique but consistent manner. For a given insertion site, different inserted sequences give rise to different stabilities, but the relationship between stability and sequence is not yet clear. However, the change in stability is similar for all insertions in a given site.

A Profile of the Residues in the First Intracellular Loop Critical for Gs-Mediated Signaling of Human Prostacyclin Receptor Characterized by an Integrative Approach of NMR-Experiment and Mutagenesis

The first intracellular loop (iLP1, residues 39-51) of human prostacyclin receptor (IP) was proposed to be involved in signaling via its interaction with the Galphas protein. First, evidence of the IP iLP1 interaction with the C-terminus of the Galphas protein was observed by the fluorescence and NMR spectroscopy using the synthetic peptide (Galphas-Ct) mimicking the C-terminal 11 residues of the Galphas protein in the presence of a constrained synthetic peptide mimicking the IP iLP1. Then, the residues (Arg42, Ala44, and Arg45) in the IP iLP1 peptide possibly involved in contacting the Galphas-Ct peptide were initially assigned by observation of the significant proton resonance shifts of the side chains of the constrained IP iLP1 peptide using 2D (1)H NMR spectroscopy. The results of the NMR studies were used as a guide for further identification of the residues in the IP important to the receptor signaling using a recombinant protein approach. A profile of the residues in the IP iLP1, including the residues observed from the NMR studies involved in the Galphas mediated signaling, was mapped out by mutagenesis. According to our results, it can be predicted that the seven residues (Arg42-Ala48) with the conserved Arg45 at the center will form an epitope with a specific conformation involved in the Galphas mediated signaling. The conservation of the basic residues (Arg45 in the IP) in all of the prostanoid receptors suggests that the iLP1 regions of the other prostanoid receptors may also contain the epitopes important to their signaling.

Selective small molecules blocking HIV-1 Tat and coactivator PCAF association

Development of drug resistance from mutations in the targeted viral proteins leads to continuation of viral production by chronically infected cells, contributing to HIV-mediated immune dysfunction. Targeting a host cell protein essential for viral reproduction, rather than a viral protein, may minimize the viral drug resistance problem as observed with HIV protease inhibitors. We report here the development of a novel class of N1-aryl-propane-1,3-diamine compounds using a structure-based approach that selectively inhibit the activity of the bromodomain of the human transcriptional co-activator PCAF, of which association with the HIV trans-activator Tat is essential for transcription and replication of the integrated HIV provirus.

Determining the optimal size of small molecule mixtures for high throughput NMR screening

High-throughput screening (HTS) using NMR spectroscopy has become a common component of the drug discovery effort and is widely used throughout the pharmaceutical industry. NMR provides additional information about the nature of small molecule-protein interactions compared to traditional HTS methods. In order to achieve comparable efficiency, small molecules are often screened as mixtures in NMR-based assays. Nevertheless, an analysis of the efficiency of mixtures and a corresponding determination of the optimum mixture size (OMS) that minimizes the amount of material and instrumentation time required for an NMR screen has been lacking. A model for calculating OMS based on the application of the hypergeometric distribution function to determine the probability of a "hit" for various mixture sizes and hit rates is presented. An alternative method for the deconvolution of large screening mixtures is also discussed. These methods have been applied in a high-throughput NMR screening assay using a small, directed library.

Rapid Assessment of Protein Structural Stability and Fold Validation via NMR

In structural proteomics, it is necessary to efficiently screen in a high-throughput manner for the presence of stable structures in proteins that can be subjected to subsequent structure determination by X-ray or NMR spectroscopy. Here we illustrate that the (1)H chemical distribution in a protein as detected by (1)H NMR spectroscopy can be used to probe protein structural stability (e.g., the presence of stable protein structures) of proteins in solution. Based on experimental data obtained on well-structured proteins and proteins that exist in a molten globule state or a partially folded alpha-helical state, a well-defined threshold exists that can be used as a quantitative benchmark for protein structural stability (e.g., foldedness) in solution. Additionally, in this chapter we describe a largely automated strategy for rapid fold validation and structure-based backbone signal assignment. Our methodology is based on a limited number of NMR experiments (e.g., HNCA and 3D NOESY-HSQC) and performs a Monte Carlo-type optimization. The novel feature of the method is the opportunity to screen for structural fragments (e.g., template scanning). The performance of this new validation tool is demonstrated with applications to a diverse set of proteins.

Improved mapping of protein binding sites

Computational mapping methods place molecular probes--small molecules or functional groups--on a protein surface in order to identify the most favorable binding positions by calculating an interaction potential. Mapping is an important step in a number of flexible docking and drug design algorithms. We have developed improved algorithms for mapping protein surfaces using small organic molecules as molecular probes. The calculations reproduce the binding of eight organic solvents to lysozyme as observed by NMR, as well as the binding of four solvents to thermolysin, in good agreement with x-ray data. Application to protein tyrosine phosphatase 1B shows that the information provided by the mapping can be very useful for drug design. We also studied why the organic solvents bind in the active site of proteins, in spite of the availability of alternative pockets that can very tightly accommodate some of the probes. A possible explanation is that the binding in the relatively large active site retains a number of rotational states, and hence leads to smaller entropy loss than the binding elsewhere else. Indeed, the mapping reveals that the clusters of the ligand molecules in the protein's active site contain different rotational-translational conformers, which represent different local minima of the free energy surface. In order to study the transitions between different conformers, reaction path and molecular dynamics calculations were performed. Results show that most of the rotational states are separated by low free energy barriers at the experimental temperature, and hence the entropy of binding in the active site is expected to be high.

A general NMR method for rapid, efficient, and reliable biochemical screening

High-throughput screening is usually the method of drug-lead discovery. It is now well accepted that, for a functional assay, quality is more important than quantity. The ligand-based or protein-based NMR screening methodologies for detecting compounds binding to the macromolecular target of interest are now well established. A novel and sensitive NMR method for rapid, efficient, and reliable biochemical screening is presented. The method named 3-FABS (three fluorine atoms for biochemical screening) requires the labeling of the substrate with a CF(3) moiety and utilizes (19)F NMR spectroscopy for the detection of the starting and enzymatically modified substrates. The method allows for high-quality screening of large compound or natural product extract collections and for measuring their IC(50) values. Applications of this technique to the screening of inhibitors of the Ser/Thr kinase AKT1 and the protease trypsin are presented. In addition, an interesting application of 3-FABS to functional genomics is also presented.

NMR Probing of Protein−Protein Interactions Using Reporter Ligands and Affinity Tags

A novel method is proposed for the detection and quantification of protein-protein interactions in solution. In this approach, one protein binding partner is tagged with a ligand binding domain, and protein-protein interaction is monitored via changes in the NMR relaxation of a reporter ligand which reversibly binds to the ligand binding domain. The particular benefit of the method is that only minute amounts of protein material and no isotope labeling are required. Its ease of implementation and the high-throughput capabilities make the method an attractive complement to existing proteomic methodology.

Technological Advances in High-Throughput Screening

High-throughput screening (HTS) is the process of testing a large number of diverse chemical structures against disease targets to identify 'hits'. Compared to traditional drug screening methods, HTS is characterized by its simplicity, rapidness, low cost, and high efficiency, taking the ligand-target interactions as the principle, as well as leading to a higher information harvest. As a multidisciplinary field, HTS involves an automated operation-platform, highly sensitive testing system, specific screening model (in vitro), an abundant components library, and a data acquisition and processing system. Various technologies, especially the novel technologies such as fluorescence, nuclear-magnetic resonance, affinity chromatography, surface plasmon resonance, and DNA microarray, are now available, and the screening of more than 100,000 samples per day is already possible. Fluorescence-based assays include the scintillation proximity assay, time-resolved energy transfer, fluorescence anisotropy, fluorescence correlation spectroscopy, and fluorescence fluctuation spectroscopy. Fluorescence-based techniques are likely to be among the most important detection approaches used for HTS due to their high sensitivity and amenability to automation, giving the industry-wide drive to simplify, miniaturize, and speed up assays. The application of NMR technology to HTS is another recent trend in drug research. One advantage afforded by NMR technology is that it can provide direct information on the affinity of the screening compounds and the binding location of protein. The structure-activity relationship acquired from NMR analysis can sharpen the library design, which will be very important in furnishing HTS with well-defined drug candidates. Affinity chromatography used for library screening will provide the information on the fundamental processes of drug action, such as absorption, distribution, excretion, and receptor activation; also the eluting curve can give directly the possibility of candidate drug. SPR can measure the quantity of a complex formed between two molecules in real-time without the need for fluorescent or radioisotopic labels. SPR is capable of characterizing unmodified biopharmaceuticals, studying the interaction of drug candidates with macromolecular targets, and identifying binding partners during ligand fishing experiments. DNA microarrays can be used in HTS be used to further investigate the expression of biological targets associated with human disease, which then opens new and exciting opportunities for drug discovery. Without doubt, the addition of new technologies will further increase the application of HTS in drug screening and its related fields.

Structure-based rational design of chemical ligands for AMPA-subtype glutamate receptors

Ionotropic glutamate receptors (GluRs) function as an excitatory transmitter system in human brain, particularly in learning and memory. Development of small-molecule chemical ligands that selectively potentiate the ion channel activity of AMPA-subtype GluRs would hold promise for treating an exceptionally wide range of disorders including neurodegenerative diseases such as Alzheimer's. Toward this goal, we have obtained nearly complete main-chain NMR resonance assignments of the extracellular ligand-binding domain of GluR2, which enables us to investigate receptor-ligand interactions in physiological conditions at atomic detail. With our NMR structure-based methods, we have discovered several chemical compounds that bind specifically to the GluR2 protein. Notably, our initial lead compounds interact with GluR2 at sites near the interface of receptor dimerization, which plays a pivotal role in controlling receptor gating and desensitization. Our NMR structural analysis further reveals that the regions of GluR2 at the dimer interface exhibit distinct conformational dynamics as compared to the rest of the protein, which we hypothesize to be linked to the mechanisms by which the protein interacts with its ligand, either an agonist or antagonist. This newly discovered relationship of possibly coupling of ligand binding to receptor dimerization, gating and desensitization, which is being further validated, could serve as an excellent in vitro biophysical parameter to evaluate the potential biological effects of the chemical ligands being developed and optimized in our study.

NMR-based screening technologies

NMR-based ligand screening is now an established field in its own right. In recent years, advances in both methodology and hardware have broadened its range of applications and pushed back practical limitations, leading to the growing importance of NMR screening as a tool in industrial drug research. An overview of new screening methods and applications is presented here, and ways in which NMR-screening is being used in cooperation with other screening techniques are discussed.

Automated MALDI-TOF-MS sample preparation in combinatorial polymer research

A new automated matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF-MS) sample spotting technique that allows the integration of MALDI sample preparation in the workflow of combinatorial polymer research is described. The technique is performed utilizing a commercially available synthetic robot and was first evaluated with polymer standards of known composition and later on used for the monitoring of the living cationic ring-opening polymerization of 2-ethyl-2-oxazoline. The spotting was carried out as a multiple layer approach, which offers the ability of complex sample preparation without the requirement of premixing the different components. The described technique reduces the time required for sample preparation and offers the possibility of automated sample spotting during polymerization reactions performed in a synthetic robot. This allows the integration of molecular weight screening and polymer end/group determination utilizing MALDI-TOF-MS as a high-throughput tool in combinatorial polymer research.

Fluorine-NMR experiments for high-throughput screening: theoretical aspects, practical considerations, and range of applicability

Competition ligand-based NMR screening experiments have recently been introduced to overcome most of the problems associated with traditional ligand-based NMR screening. Molecules with marginal solubility and high affinity for a given target can be easily identified in a high-throughput manner by screening chemical mixtures against the target in the presence of a weak- to medium-affinity ligand of known binding constant. While the original competition-based approaches utilized (1)H detection, significant advantages are obtained using (19)F detection. The absence of spectral overlap permits the screening of large chemical mixtures and allows for automated analysis of the spectra, even in the presence of protonated buffers, solvents, and detergents. The large chemical shift anisotropy of fluorine and the significant exchange contribution allow for the selection of a weak-affinity spy molecule, thus resulting in a lower binding affinity threshold for the identified NMR hits. The method, labeled FAXS (fluorine chemical shift anisotropy and exchange for screening) is rapid and requires only a limited amount of protein and, therefore, compares favorably with the other established non-NMR techniques used in high-throughput screening. Herein the theoretical aspects of this powerful (19)F-based approach are presented and discussed in detail. The experimental conditions together with the detection limits and binding constant measurements are investigated using human serum albumin as the target.

NMR-based screening methods for lead discovery

Diversity and robustness of NMR based screening methods make these techniques highly attractive as tools for drug discovery. Although not all screening techniques discussed here may be applicable to any given target, there is however a good chance that at least one of the described methods will prove productive in finding several medium affinity ligands. A comparison of each of the methods is given in Table 1. For drug targets of molecular weight < 30 kDa SAR by NMR appears to be the method of choice since it yields detailed information about the location of the binding site. It remains to be seen whether 15N-1H-TROSY based screening techniques will prove useful for larger protein targets, especially considering the added effort needed for spectral assignment and the increased complexity due to spectral overlap. Nevertheless, with the application of new cryo-cooled NMR probes, 15N-1H-HSQC based screening can now be considered a high throughput method. Ligand-based NMR screening methods can be used for protein targets of virtually any size, but are restricted in the ligand's binding affinity range. Because sufficient ligand-protein dissociation rates are needed, only binding of ligands with low (milimolar) to intermediate (micromolar) affinities is detectable. It is expected that cryo-cooled NMR probe technology will also advance ligand detected NMR screening to the high throughput level. Certainly protein and ligand concentrations can be lowered drastically and experiment times can be shortened with increased sensitivity. However, spectral overlap will be of major concern when mixtures of up to 100 compounds are to be screened. For such applications only techniques for which the signals of bound ligands survive will be useful, and sophisticated software will be needed to deconvolute the spectra of multiple bound ligands. Although only ligands with medium to low affinities can be found, ligand based NMR screening has been used as an effective prescreening tool for assay based high throughput screening. Identifying a large ensemble of medium affinity ligands may not only aid in building a binding site pharmacophore model (see Chapter 11), but also may yield crucial information for overcoming tissue availability, toxicity, or even intellectual property related problems. Although NMR based screening is only one of the more recent additions to the bag of tools used in drug discovery [1, 2], its simplicity and wide range of application (including protein-protein and protein-nucleic acid interactions) has attracted much attention. Advances in NMR instrumentation and methodology have already paved the road for NMR based screening to become a high throughput technique. In addition to this, NMR is exceptional in the amount of detailed structural [table: see text] information it can provide. Not only can NMR readily reveal the binding site (15N-1H-HSQC screening) or the conformation of the bound ligand (transfer NOE), but it can also supply information that enables precise docking of the ligand to the protein's binding pocket (isotope-filtered NOESY). NMR data can therefore provide a natural connection between experimental HTS and combinatorial chemistry techniques with computational methods such as 3D-database searching (see Chapter 10), virtual screening (docking) and structure-based ligand design (see also Chapter 8).

Automated analysis of large sets of heteronuclear correlation spectra in NMR-based drug discovery

Drug discovery procedures based on NMR typically require the analysis of thousands of NMR spectra. For example, in "SAR by NMR", two-dimensional NMR spectra are recorded for a target protein mixed with ligand candidates from a comprehensive library of small molecules and are compared to the corresponding spectrum for the protein alone. We present an automated procedure for the comparative analysis of large sets of heteronuclear single quantum coherence spectra, which is based on three-way decomposition and implemented as the software package MUNIN. In a single step, spectra with differences in the peak positions (indicating ligand binding) and the affected peaks are identified. By omission of peak picking, ad hoc scoring of the quality of doubtful peaks is avoided. The procedure has been tested on the bacterial ribonuclease barnase, with a protein concentration of only 50 microM, using several small molecules including the substrate analogue 3'-GMP. Sets of 51 spectra were processed simultaneously, and it is concluded that spectra with binding ligands can be unambiguously identified from much larger sets of spectra.

Accurate nucleic acid concentrations by nuclear magnetic resonance

Determination of the concentration of biochemical samples often yields values with uncertainties of 10-20% or more. This paper details a protocol for use with 500- to 600-MHz NMR spectrometers to measure approximately 1mM concentrations within +/-1-3% accuracy. With suitable precautions, all compounds have equal NMR "absorption coefficients" for protons. About 2mg of sample are needed for proteins and nucleic acids with MW=5000, although less accurate determinations could be made with smaller amounts. The technique utilizes standardized internal reference reagent compounds, cacodylic acid or 3-(trimethylsilyl)propionic-2,2,3,3-d(4) acid sodium salt. Spectra were signal-averaged using long interpulse delays so that integrals of nonexchangeable protons could be quantified relative to the reference standard. Accurate determinations require careful optimization of the homogeneity of the magnetic field and meticulous attention to sample preparation and spectral processing. The main source of error is usually the accuracy of micropipets. If sample preparation errors could be eliminated, the lower limit of accuracy with the current generation of NMR spectrometers is probably near 0.4%. However, this would require >99.5% sample purity. Methods are described to establish the concentration of the standards, and applications are illustrated with DNA mono- and oligonucleotides. Similar procedures should apply to proteins, polysaccharides, and other biomolecules, with about the same accuracy and precision.

Structure-based functional design of chemical ligands for AMPA-subtype glutamate receptors

Glutamate receptors (GluRs) function as transmembrane ion channels to regulate intracellular level of ions such as calcium in control of excitatory synaptic transmission of the central nervous system. Dysfunction of these glutamate receptors has been implicated in human brain neurodegenerative diseases, including Alzheimer's, Huntington's, and Parkinson's diseases. Despite such a significant role in both the biology and pathology of the central nervous system, detailed understanding of molecular mechanisms by which subtype- or subunit-specific glutamate receptors function in cells is still lacking. The recently determined three-dimensional crystal structure of the extracellular ligand-binding core of the prototypic AMPA-subtype GluR2, in complex with its agonist, provides a new opportunity for rational design of chemical ligands that could help elucidate the underlying mechanisms and also be useful in the therapy of the neurodegenerative diseases. Here we report our recent development in structure-based functional design of chemical ligands by using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. The NMR structure-based method enables rapid identification of small molecular chemical ligands that bind to specific sites of the target protein. These chemical compounds can be optimized for selective binding to the target protein, and linked to produce chemical ligands with high-affinity and selectivity of the AMPA-subtype glutamate receptors.

High-throughput NMR-based screening with competition binding experiments

The Achilles heel of ligand-based NMR screening methods is their failure to detect high-affinity ligands and molecules that bind covalently to the receptor. We have developed a novel approach for performing high-throughput screening with NMR spectroscopy that overcomes this limitation. The method also permits detection of potential high-affinity molecules that are only marginally soluble, thus significantly enlarging the diversity of compounds amenable to NMR screening. The techniques developed utilize transverse and/or selective longitudinal relaxation parameters in combination with competition binding experiments. Mathematical expressions are derived for proper setup of the NMR experiments and for extracting an approximate value of the binding constant for the identified ligand from a single-point measurement. With this approach it is possible to screen thousands of compounds in a short period of time against protein or DNA and RNA fragments. The methodology can also be applied for screening plant and fungi extracts.

NMR-Based screening with competition water-ligand observed via gradient spectroscopy experiments: detection of high-affinity ligands

Water-ligand observed via gradient spectroscopy (WaterLOGSY) represents a powerful method for primary NMR screening in the identification of compounds interacting with macromolecules, including proteins and DNA or RNA fragments. The method is useful for the detection of compounds binding to a receptor with binding affinity in the micromolar range. The Achille's heel of the method, as with all the techniques that detect the ligand resonances, is its inability to identify strong ligands with slow dissociation rates. We show here that the use of a reference compound with a known K(D) in the micromolar range together with properly designed competition binding experiments (c-WaterLOGSY) permits the detection of strong binders. A derived mathematical expression is used for the selection of the appropriate setup NMR experimental conditions and for an approximate determination of the binding constant. The experiment requires low ligand concentration, therefore allowing its application in the identification of potential strong inhibitors that are only marginally soluble. The technique is particularly suitable for rapid screening of chemical mixtures and plant or fungi extracts.

A method for identification of inhibitors of the phosphorylation reactions of bacterial response regulator proteins using (31)P nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy

Bacterial response regulators are attractive targets for antibacterial drug development, yet random screening against these targets has failed as yet to identify chemicals that constitute viable leads. Alternative methods to provide leads for drug development based on identification and optimization of low affinity ligands from NMR screens have been described. However, leads from these processes still require verification in a bioassay, which is often problematic if compounds have unfavorable optical and solubility properties. A simple method, based on using NMR to observe the activity of the target, is described. It has the advantages of being able to characterize both low affinity leads and a wider selection of compounds in a structure activity relationships series, without the problems affecting a fluorescence assay. In this example we use (31)P to monitor the turnover of a bacterial response regulator, but the generic approach could be applied to other nuclei and thus a range of biological systems.

Oral delivery of biologically active parathyroid hormone

PURPOSE

Parathyroid hormone (PTH), the only drug known to stimulate bone formation. is a peptide therapeutic indicated in the treatment of osteoporosis. Unfortunately, PTH is only effective when dosed by injection because it has no oral bioavailability. Herein we report the oral absorption of PTH in rats and monkeys facilitated by the novel delivery agent, N-[8-(2-hydroxy-4-methoxy)bensoyl]amino caprylic acid (4-MOAC).

METHODS

4-MOAC was selected from a group of 100 delivery agents based on in vitro chromotography studies and in vivo screening studies in rats. The PTH/4-MOAC combination was then tested in monkeys. The interaction of 4-MOAC and PTH was evaluated by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy.

RESULTS

Monkeys were administered an aqueous solution containing 4-MOAC and PTH and mean peak serum PTH concentrations of about 3000 pg/mL were obtained. The relative bioavailability of oral PTH was 2.1% relative to subcutaneous administration. The biological activity of the orally-delivered PTH was further evaluated in a rat model of osteoporosis. These studies showed that the bone formed following oral PTH/4-MOAC administration was comparable to that formed following PTH injections. The 4-MOAC mediated absorption of PTH is hypothesized to be the result of a noncovalent interaction between 4-MOAC and PTH. The preliminary evaluation of this interaction by NMR is described.

CONCLUSIONS

4-MOAC facilitates the absorption of PTH following oral administration to both rats and monkeys. The orally-absorbed PTH is biologically active as demonstrated in a rat model of osteoporosis.

Automation of measurements and data evaluation in biomolecular NMR screening

This article reviews the equipment required for biomolecular screening applications in the automated preparation of samples and the acquisition of a large number of NMR data sets. New hardware connecting lab-bench and NMR spectrometers is introduced. In addition, the article focuses on software used for the automated processing of data and the calculation of similarity between spectra - a prerequisite for the identification of test compounds interacting with a target molecule.

Applications of NMR in drug discovery

NMR, already some 50 years old, has long been an invaluable analytical method in industry for verification of chemical synthesis and compound characterisation. The range of molecular information accessible through NMR, however, offers a far larger horizon of applications. Of these, ligand screening by NMR has emerged as a very promising new method in drug discovery. Its unmatched screening sensitivity, combined with the abundance of available information on the structure and nature of molecular binding, justifies the growing interest in this dynamically expanding NMR application.

NMR-restrained docking of a peptidic inhibitor to the N-terminal domain of the phosphoenolpyruvate:sugar phosphotransferase enzyme I

Starting from the NMR structure of the binary complex between the N-terminal domain of the unphosphorylated enzyme I (EIN) of the phosphoenolpyruvate:sugar phosphotransferase (PTS) and the histidine-containing phosphocarrier protein (HPr), a molecular model of the phosphorylated transition state of the related complex was established using constrained simulated annealing. The coordinates of the phosphorylated EIN enzyme were then used in a second step for flexible docking of a decapeptide inhibitor of EIN whose enzyme-bound conformation itself was determined by NMR using transferred nuclear Overhauser effects. Two phosphorylation models of the peptide inhibitor were investigated and shown to be both functional. Interestingly, one model is very similar to that of the complex between EIN and its natural substrate HPr. The present study demonstrates that NMR-guided flexible docking constitutes an interesting tool for docking highly flexible peptide ligands and facilitates the upcoming protein-based design of nonpeptide EIN inhibitors for discovering new antibiotics.

Use of direct-infusion electrospray mass spectrometry to guide empirical development of improved conditions for expression of secondary metabolites from actinomycetes

A major barrier in the discovery of new secondary metabolites from microorganisms is the difficulty of distinguishing the minor fraction of productive cultures from the majority of unproductive cultures and growth conditions. In this study, a rapid, direct-infusion electrospray mass spectrometry (ES-MS) technique was used to identify chemical differences that occurred in the expression of secondary metabolites by 44 actinomycetes cultivated under six different fermentation conditions. Samples from actinomycete fermentations were prepared by solid-phase extraction, analyzed by ES-MS, and ranked according to a chemical productivity index based on the total number and relative intensity of ions present in each sample. The actinomycete cultures were tested for chemical productivity following treatments that included nutritional manipulations, autoregulator additions, and different agitation speeds and incubation temperatures. Evaluation of the ES-MS data from submerged and solid-state fermentations by paired t test analyses showed that solid-state growth significantly altered the chemical profiles of extracts from 75% of the actinomycetes evaluated. Parallel analysis of the same extracts by high-performance liquid chromatography-ES-MS-evaporative light scattering showed that the chemical differences detected by the ES-MS method were associated with growth condition-dependent changes in the yield of secondary metabolites. Our results indicate that the high-throughput ES-MS method is useful for identification of fermentation conditions that enhance expression of secondary metabolites from actinomycetes.

RNA as a drug target: methods for biophysical characterization and screening

RNA folds into complex structures that can interact specifically with effector proteins. These interactions are essential for various biological functions. In order to discover small molecules that can affect important RNA-protein complexes, a thorough analysis of the thermodynamics and kinetics of RNA-protein binding is required. This can facilitate the formulation of high-throughput screening strategies and the development of structure-activity relationships for compound leads. In addition to traditional methods, such as filter binding, gel mobility shift assay and various fluorescence techniques, newer methods such as surface plasmon resonance and mass spectrometry are being used for the study of RNA-protein interactions.

NMR techniques for characterization of ligand binding: utility for lead generation and optimization in drug discovery

Over the last ten years, nmr spectroscopy has evolved into an important discipline in drug discovery. Initially, nmr was most useful as a technique to provide structural information regarding protein drug targets and target-ligand interactions. More recently, it has been shown that nmr may be used as an alternative method for identification of small molecule ligands that bind to protein drug targets. High throughput implementation of these experiments to screen small molecule libraries may lead to identification of potent and novel lead compounds. In this review, we will use examples from our own research to illustrate how nmr experiments to characterize ligand binding may be used to both screen for novel compounds during the process of lead generation, as well as provide structural information useful for lead optimization during the latter stages of a discovery program.

Applications of NMR in drug discovery

In the half-century since its discovery, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) has become the single most powerful form of spectroscopy in both chemistry and structural biology. The dramatic technical advances over the past 10-15 years, which continue apace, have markedly increased the range of applications for NMR in the study of protein-ligand interactions. These form the basis for its most exciting uses in the drug discovery process, which range from the simple identification of whether a compound (or a component of a mixture) binds to a given protein, through to the determination of the full three-dimensional structure of the complex, with all the information this yields for structure-based drug design.