Dibasic inhibitors of human mast cell tryptase. Part 2: structure-activity relationships and requirements for potent activity

Incorporation of an Isohexide Subunit Improves the Drug-like Properties of Bioactive Compounds

An enhanced ability to pre-engineer favorable drug-likeness qualities into bioactive molecules would focus and streamline the drug development process. We find that phenols, carboxylic acids, and a purine react with isosorbide ("GRAS" designated) under Mitsunobu coupling conditions to deliver the isoidide conjugates selectively and efficiently. Such conjugates show improved solubility and permeability properties compared with the bare scaffold compounds themselves, and the purine adduct may have applications as a 2'-deoxyadenosine isostere. We anticipate additional benefits, implied by their structures, in metabolic stability and reduced toxicity of the isoidide conjugates as well.

Mast cell proteases as protective and inflammatory mediators

Proteases are the most abundant class of proteins produced by mast cells. Many of these are stored in membrane-enclosed intracellular granules until liberated by degranulating stimuli, which include cross-linking of high affinity IgE receptor F(c)εRI by IgE bound to multivalent allergen. Understanding and separating the functions of the proteases is important because expression differs among mast cells in different tissue locations. Differences between laboratory animals and humans in protease expression also influence the degree of confidence with which results obtained in animal models of mast cell function can be extrapolated to humans. The inflammatory potential of mast cell proteases was the first aspect of their biology to be explored and has received the most attention, in part because some of them, notably tryptases and chymases, are biomarkers of local and systemic mast cell degranulation and anaphylaxis. Although some of the proteases indeed augment allergic inflammation and are potential targets for inhibition to treat asthma and related allergic disorders, they are protective and even anti-inflammatory in some settings. For example, mast cell tryptases may protect from serious bacterial lung infections and may limit the "rubor" component of inflammation caused by vasodilating neuropeptides in the skin. Chymases help to maintain intestinal barrier function and to expel parasitic worms and may support blood pressure during anaphylaxis by generating angiotensin II. In other life-or-death examples, carboxypeptidase A3 and other mast cell peptidases limit systemic toxicity of endogenous peptideslike endothelin and neurotensin during septic peritonitis and inactivate venom-associated peptides. On the other hand, mast cell peptidase-mediated destruction of protective cytokines, like IL-6, can enhance mortality from sepsis. Peptidases released from mast cells also influence nonmast cell proteases, such as by activating matrix metalloproteinase cascades, which are important in responses to infection and resolution of tissue injury. Overall, mast cell proteases have a variety of roles, inflammatory and anti-inflammatory, protective and deleterious, in keeping with the increasingly well-appreciated contributions of mast cells in allergy, tissue homeostasis and innate immunity.

Mast cell proteases: multifaceted regulators of inflammatory disease

Mast cells (MCs) are currently receiving increased attention among the scientific community, largely because of the recent identification of crucial functions for MCs in a variety of disorders. However, it is in many cases not clear exactly how MCs contribute in the respective settings. MCs express extraordinarily high levels of a number of proteases of chymase, tryptase, and carboxypeptidase A type, and these are stored in high amounts as active enzymes in the MC secretory granules. Hence, MC degranulation leads to the massive release of fully active MC proteases, which probably have a major impact on any condition in which MC degranulation occurs. Indeed, the recent generation and evaluation of mouse strains lacking individual MC proteases have indicated crucial contributions of these to a number of different disorders. MC proteases may thus account for many of the effects ascribed to MCs and are currently emerging as promising candidates for treatment of MC-driven disease. In this review, we discuss these findings.

Mast cell peptidases: chameleons of innate immunity and host defense

Mast cells make and secrete an abundance of peptidases, which are stored in such large amounts in granules that they comprise a high fraction of all cellular protein. Perhaps no other immune cell is so generously endowed with peptidases. For many years after the main peptidases were first described, they were best known as markers of degranulation, for they are released locally in response to mast cell stimulation and can be distributed systemically and detected in blood. The principal peptidases are tryptases, chymases, carboxypeptidase A3, and dipeptidylpeptidase I (cathepsin C). Numerous studies suggest that these enzymes are important and even critical for host defense and homeostasis. Endogenous and allergen or pathogen-associated targets have been identified. Belying the narrow notion of peptidases as proinflammatory, several of the peptidases limit inflammation and toxicity of endogenous peptides and venoms. The peptidases are interdependent, so that absence or inactivity of one enzyme can alter levels and activity of others. Mammalian mast cell peptidases--chymases and tryptases especially--vary remarkably in number, expression, biophysical properties, and specificity, perhaps because they hyper-evolved under pressure from the very pathogens they help to repel. Tryptase and chymase involvement in some pathologies stimulated development of therapeutic inhibitors for use in asthma, lung fibrosis, pulmonary hypertension, ulcerative colitis, and cardiovascular diseases. While animal studies support the potential for mast cell peptidase inhibitors to mitigate certain diseases, other studies, as in mice lacking selected peptidases, predict roles in defense against bacteria and parasites and that systemic inactivation may impair host defense.

Engineered cystine knot miniproteins as potent inhibitors of human mast cell tryptase beta

Here we report the design, chemical and recombinant synthesis, and functional properties of a series of novel inhibitors of human mast cell tryptase beta, a protease of considerable interest as a therapeutic target for the treatment of allergic asthma and inflammatory disorders. These inhibitors are derived from a linear variant of the cyclic cystine knot miniprotein MCoTI-II, originally isolated from the seeds of Momordica cochinchinensis. A synthetic cyclic miniprotein that bears additional positive charge in the loop connecting the N- and C-termini inhibits all monomers of the tryptase beta tetramer with an overall equilibrium dissociation constant K(i) of 1 nM and thus is one of the most potent proteinaceous inhibitors of tryptase beta described to date. These cystine knot miniproteins may therefore become valuable scaffolds for the design of a new generation of tryptase inhibitors.

Discontinued drugs in 2006: pulmonary-allergy, dermatological, gastrointestinal and arthritis drugs

This perspective is the second in a series discussing drugs dropped from development in 2006, with a focus on pulmonary-allergy, dermatological, gastrointestinal and arthritis drugs. A survey of discontinued drugs from 2006 is provided, based on data from the Pharmaprojects database, along with an analysis of biology, mechanisms of action and economic considerations in developing new drugs.

Mast Cell Proteases

Mast cells (MCs) are traditionally thought of as a nuisance for its host, for example, by causing many of the symptoms associated with allergic reactions. In addition, recent research has put focus on MCs for displaying harmful effects during various autoimmune disorders. On the other hand, MCs can also be beneficial for its host, for example, by contributing to the defense against insults such as bacteria, parasites, and snake venom toxins. When the MC is challenged by an external stimulus, it may respond by degranulation. In this process, a number of powerful preformed inflammatory "mediators" are released, including cytokines, histamine, serglycin proteoglycans, and several MC-specific proteases: chymases, tryptases, and carboxypeptidase A. Although the exact effector mechanism(s) by which MCs carry out their either beneficial or harmful effects in vivo are in large parts unknown, it is reasonable to assume that these mediators may contribute in profound ways. Among the various MC mediators, the exact biological function of the MC proteases has for a long time been relatively obscure. However, recent progress involving successful genetic targeting of several MC protease genes has generated powerful tools, which will enable us to unravel the role of the MC proteases both in normal physiology as well as in pathological settings. This chapter summarizes the current knowledge of the biology of the MC proteases.

Expression and characterization of recombinant γ-tryptase

Tryptases are trypsin-like serine proteases whose expression is restricted to cells of hematopoietic origin, notably mast cells. gamma-Tryptase, a recently described member of the family also known as transmembrane tryptase (TMT), is a membrane-bound serine protease found in the secretory granules or on the surface of degranulated mast cells. The 321 amino acid protein contains an 18 amino acid propeptide linked to the catalytic domain (cd), followed by a single-span transmembrane domain. gamma-Tryptase is distinguished from other human mast cell tryptases by the presence of two unique cysteine residues, Cys(26) and Cys(145), that are predicted to form an intra-molecular disulfide bond linking the propeptide to the catalytic domain to form the mature, membrane-anchored two-chain enzyme. We expressed gamma-tryptase as either a soluble, single-chain enzyme with a C-terminal His tag (cd gamma-tryptase) or as a soluble pseudozymogen activated by enterokinase cleavage to form a two-chain protein with an N-terminal His tag (tc gamma-tryptase). Both recombinant proteins were expressed at high levels in Pichia pastoris and purified by affinity chromatography. The two forms of gamma-tryptase exhibit comparable kinetic parameters, indicating the propeptide does not contribute significantly to the substrate affinity or activity of the protease. Substrate and inhibitor library screening indicate that gamma-tryptase possesses a substrate preference and inhibitor profile distinct from that of beta-tryptase. Although the role of gamma-tryptase in mast cell function is unknown, our results suggest that it is likely to be distinct from that of beta-tryptase.

Biology of mast cell tryptase. An inflammatory mediator

In 1960, a trypsin-like activity was found in mast cells [Glenner GG & Cohen LA (1960) Nature 185, 846-847] and this activity is now commonly referred to as 'tryptase'. Over the years, much knowledge about mast cell tryptase has been gathered, and a recent (18 January 2006) PubMed search for the keywords 'tryptase + mast cell*' retrieved 1661 articles. However, still very little is known about its true biological function. For example, the true physiological substrate(s) for mast cell tryptase has not been identified, and the potential role of tryptase in mast cell-related disease is not understood. Mast cell tryptase has several unique features, with perhaps the most remarkable being its organization into a tetrameric state with all of the active sites oriented towards a narrow central pore and its consequent complete resistance towards endogenous macromolecular protease inhibitors. Much effort has been invested to elucidate these properties of tryptase. In this review we summarize the current knowledge of mast cell tryptase, including novel insights into its possible biological functions and mechanisms of regulation.

Combinatorial approaches towards the discovery of new tryptase inhibitors

The synthesis and evaluation as tryptase inhibitors of a library of 2,5-diketopiperazine derivatives containing guanidine or amidine functional groups is reported. Among the compounds evaluated, derivatives 6{CG4-CG8} and 6{CG4-CG9} are the most active compounds and have marked selectivity towards tryptase in front of trypsin.

Affinity Chromatography of Tryptases: Design, Synthesis and Characterization of a Novel Matrix-Bound Bivalent Inhibitor

beta-Tryptases are mast cell-derived serine proteases that are enzymatically active in the form of an oligomer consisting of four subunits each with trypsin-like activity. The active-site clefts, which are directed toward the central pore of the tetramer, form spatial arrays of four negatively charged S1 binding pockets. Therefore, dibasic inhibitors of appropriate geometry can bind in a bivalent fashion to neighboring subunits. We have recently identified a potent bivalent inhibitor (K(i)=18 nM), based on the bifunctional scaffold cyclo-(-D-Asp-L-Asp-) and the arginine mimetic dl-3-aminomethyl-phenylalanine methyl ester as a ligand for S1 pockets that takes advantage of the this unique tetrameric geometry. To generate an affinity matrix, the bivalent ligand was modified and immobilized on a Sepharose matrix by use of the PEG derivative Jeffamine ED 900 as spacer. This matrix selectively recognizes and binds beta-tryptase from crude protein mixtures and thus is useful as a geometry-driven means of isolating and purifying human mast cell tryptases.

Inhibition of human β-tryptase by Bowman–Birk inhibitor derived peptides: creation of a new tri-functional inhibitor

Bowman-Birk inhibitor proteins (BBIs), which are potent inhibitors of chymotrypsin-like proteases, do not inhibit human beta-tryptase despite this protein having a chymotrypsin-like fold. We have reported previously that, in contrast, BBI-derived peptides (whose sequences incorporate the solvent exposed reactive site loop motif) are able to inhibit human beta-tryptase. This is due to their small size, which allows them to access the restricted active site(s) of tryptase, which has an unusual tetrameric arrangement with four active sites flanking a central pore. In this paper, we have examined the possibility of creating additional interactions within this pore by adding extensions to the BBI-peptide motif. We have taken the core disulfide-bridged sequence SCTKSIPPQCY and examined a series of extensions, at both the C- and N-termini, that bear a second positively charged Lys residue at their end. The aim was to construct inhibitors that could make additional interactions in tryptase by spanning the gap between adjacent active sites in the enzyme, producing a double-headed inhibitor; a positively charged group was used as the dominant specificity of this enzyme is for a positively charged P1 residue. Both N- and C-terminal extensions are found to produce inhibitors of much increased potency, with a strong dependence of potency on chain length. Moreover, it was found that the C- and N-terminal extensions were able to synergise, with their combination on the same peptide producing an even better inhibitor with a potency 10(4)-fold greater than the original sequence. We suggest that the C- and N-terminal extensions are picking up interactions with separate additional sites on the tryptase, making the doubly extended BBI peptide a tri-functional tryptase inhibitor.

Design of bivalent ligands using hydrogen bond linkers: synthesis and evaluation of inhibitors for human β-tryptase

We exploit the concept of using hydrogen bonds to link multiple ligands for maintaining simultaneous interactions with polyvalent binding sites. This approach is demonstrated by the syntheses and evaluation of pseudo-bivalent ligands as potent inhibitors of human beta-tryptase.

Potent bivalent inhibition of human tryptase-beta by a synthetic inhibitor

Human tryptase-beta (HTbeta) is a unique serine protease exhibiting a frame-like tetramer structure with four active sites directed toward a central pore. Potent inhibition of HTbeta has been attained using CRA-2059. This compound has two phenylguanidinium head groups connected via a linker capable of spanning between two active sites. The properties of the CRA-2059:HTbeta interaction were defined in this study. Tight-binding reversible inhibition was observed with an inhibition constant (Ki) of 620 pM, an association rate constant of 7x10(7) M(-1) s(-1) and a relatively slow dissociation rate constant of 0.04 s(-1). Bivalent inhibition was demonstrated by displacement of p-aminobenzamidine from the primary specificity pocket with a stoichiometry, [CRA-2059]0/[HTbeta]0, of 0.5. The potency of the bivalent interaction was illustrated by CRA-2059 inhibition of HTbeta, 24% or 53% inhibited by pre-incubation with an irreversible inhibitor. Two interactions were observed consistent with mono- and bi-valent binding; the Ki value for bivalent inhibition was at least 10(4)-fold lower than that for monovalent inhibition. Comparison of the affinities of CRA-2059 and phenylguanidine for HTbeta finds an approximate doubling of the free energy change upon bivalent binding. This doubling suggests that the linker portion minimally hinders the binding of CRA-2059 to HTbeta. The potency of CRA-2059 is thus attributable to effective bivalent binding.

Design, synthesis and biological activity of a targeted library of potential tryptase inhibitors

We have designed, synthesized, and tested two small collections of potential tryptase inhibitors. The first library consists of diversely N-substituted 3-aminopiperidin-2-ones 6, and the second (compounds 7) was prepared by dimerising compounds 6 through the 3-amino function using diverse carbon chains. We have established efficient routes for obtaining 6 both in solution and on solid supports. We have also compared the dimerisation on-resin and in solution. Four of the compounds showed a high degree of tryptase inhibition at 1 microM, but none surpassed the tryptase inhibition activity of BABIM.

The crystal structure of human alpha1-tryptase reveals a blocked substrate-binding region

Human mast cell tryptases represent a subfamily of trypsin-like serine proteinases implicated in asthma. Unlike beta-tryptases, alpha-tryptases apparently are proteolytically inactive. We have solved the 2.2A crystal structure of mature human alpha1-tryptase. It reveals a frame-like tetrameric architecture that, surprisingly, does not require heparin-binding for stability. In marked contrast to beta2-tryptase, the Ser214-Gly219 segment, which normally provides the template for substrate binding, is kinked in alpha-tryptase, thereby blocking its non-primed subsites. This so far unobserved subsite distortion is incompatible with productive substrate binding and processing. alpha-Tryptase apparently is trapped in this off-conformation by repulsions and attractions of the Asp216 side-chain. However, proteolytic activity could be generated by an induced-fit mechanism.

Bivalent inhibition of beta-tryptase: distance scan of neighboring subunits by dibasic inhibitors

Based on bifunctional diketopiperazines as templates and m-aminomethyl-phenylalanine as arginine mimetic, we have synthesized a new class of structurally related dibasic tryptase inhibitors with systematically increasing spacer length. These compounds were used to scan the distance between the active sites of two neighboring subunits of the beta-tryptase tetramer. The K(i)-values obtained are a function of the distance between the terminal amino groups and indicate optimal binding of inhibitors with 29-31 bonds between the amino groups. These experimental data are in full agreement with predictions derived from a novel modeling program that allows the docking of bivalent ligands.

Inhibition of human beta-tryptase by Bowman-Birk inhibitor derived peptides

Four 11-residue peptides based on the Bowman-Birk inhibitor (BBI) structure were synthesized. These were tested for their ability to inhibit human beta-tryptase. Peptides with a basic residue at P1 inhibited tryptase even though the intact BBI protein is inactive. This result is interpreted in terms of the unique structural arrangement of active sites in tryptase which prevent access by large protein inhibitors.

Monocharged inhibitors of mast cell tryptase derived from potent and selective dibasic inhibitors

Truncation of potent and selective dibasic inhibitors afforded monocharged inhibitors of human mast-cell tryptase. Using two classes of analogues as lead structures, several monocharged derivatives were identified with K(i) values ranging from 0.084 to 0.21 microM against the enzyme.

Dibasic inhibitors of human mast cell tryptase. Part 3: identification of a series of potent and selective inhibitors containing the benzamidine functionality

A survey of charged groups and linkers for a series of symmetrical and unsymmetrical dibasic inhibitors is described, leading to several classes of potent and selective inhibitors. In particular, the benzamidine functionality was identified as the most potent charged group investigated.

Bivalent inhibition of human beta-tryptase

BACKGROUND

Human beta-tryptase is a mast cell specific trypsin-like serine protease that is thought to play a key role in the pathogenesis of diverse allergic and inflammatory disorders like asthma and psoriasis. The recently resolved crystal structure revealed that the enzymatically active tetramer consists of four quasi-identical monomers. The spatial display of the four identical active sites represents an ideal basis for the rational design of bivalent inhibitors.

RESULTS

Based on modeling experiments homobivalent inhibitors were constructed using (i) 6A,6D-dideoxy-6A,6D-diamino-beta-cyclodextrin as a rigid template to bridge the space between the two pairs of identical active sites and (ii) 3-(aminomethyl)benzene as a headgroup to occupy the arginine/lysine specific S1 subsites. A comparative analysis of the inhibitory potencies of synthetic constructs that differ in size and type of the spacer between headgroup and template revealed that the construct contained two 3-(aminomethyl)benzenesulfonyl-glycine groups linked to the 6A,6D-diamino groups of beta-cyclodextrin as an almost ideal bivalent inhibitor with a cooperativity factor of 1.9 vs. the ideal value of 2. The bivalent binding mode is supported by the inhibitor/tetramer ratio of 2:1 required for inactivation of tryptase and by X-ray analysis of the inhibitor/tryptase complex.

CONCLUSION

The results obtained with the rigid cyclodextrin template underlined the importance of a minimal loss of conformational entropy in bivalent binding, but also showed the limitations imposed by such rigid core molecules in terms of optimal occupancy of binding sites and thus of enthalpic strains in bidentate binding modes. The main advantage of bivalent inhibitors is their high selectivity for the target enzyme that can be achieved utilizing the principle of multivalency.

Monitor: molecules and profiles

Monitor provides an insight into the latest developments in drug discovery through brief synopses of recent presentations and publications together with expert commentaries on the latest technologies. There are two sections: Molecules summarizes the chemistry and the pharmacological significance and biological relevance of new molecules reported in the literature and on the conference scene; Profiles offers commentary on promising lines of research, emerging molecular targets, novel technology, advances in synthetic and separation techniques and legislative issues.