Severe clinical expression in X-linked Emery-Dreifuss muscular dystrophy

Abnormal proliferation and spontaneous differentiation of myoblasts from a symptomatic female carrier of X-linked Emery-Dreifuss muscular dystrophy

•

X-linked female presenting with EDMD1 not explained by uneven X-inactivation.

•

First EDMD blood phenotype with highly lobulated lymphocytes in EDMD1 patient.

•

Found high incidence of spontaneous differentiation in cultured patient myoblasts.

•

Faster proliferation of emerin-null than emerin-positive EDMD1 patient myoblasts.

•

Loss of satellite cells from the above might explain EDMD pathology.

Emery–Dreifuss muscular dystrophy (EDMD) is a neuromuscular disease characterized by early contractures, slowly progressive muscular weakness and life-threatening cardiac arrhythmia that can develop into cardiomyopathy. In X-linked EDMD (EDMD1), female carriers are usually unaffected. Here we present a clinical description and in vitro characterization of a mildly affected EDMD1 female carrying the heterozygous EMD mutation c.174_175delTT; p.Y59* that yields loss of protein. Muscle tissue sections and cultured patient myoblasts exhibited a mixed population of emerin-positive and -negative cells; thus uneven X-inactivation was excluded as causative. Patient blood cells were predominantly emerin-positive, but considerable nuclear lobulation was observed in non-granulocyte cells – a novel phenotype in EDMD. Both emerin-positive and emerin-negative myoblasts exhibited spontaneous differentiation in tissue culture, though emerin-negative myoblasts were more proliferative than emerin-positive cells. The preferential proliferation of emerin-negative myoblasts together with the high rate of spontaneous differentiation in both populations suggests that loss of functional satellite cells might be one underlying mechanism for disease pathology. This could also account for the slowly developing muscle phenotype.

Muscular dystrophy-associated SUN1 and SUN2 variants disrupt nuclear-cytoskeletal connections and myonuclear organization

Proteins of the nuclear envelope (NE) are associated with a range of inherited disorders, most commonly involving muscular dystrophy and cardiomyopathy, as exemplified by Emery-Dreifuss muscular dystrophy (EDMD). EDMD is both genetically and phenotypically variable, and some evidence of modifier genes has been reported. Six genes have so far been linked to EDMD, four encoding proteins associated with the LINC complex that connects the nucleus to the cytoskeleton. However, 50% of patients have no identifiable mutations in these genes. Using a candidate approach, we have identified putative disease-causing variants in the SUN1 and SUN2 genes, also encoding LINC complex components, in patients with EDMD and related myopathies. Our data also suggest that SUN1 and SUN2 can act as disease modifier genes in individuals with co-segregating mutations in other EDMD genes. Five SUN1/SUN2 variants examined impaired rearward nuclear repositioning in fibroblasts, confirming defective LINC complex function in nuclear-cytoskeletal coupling. Furthermore, myotubes from a patient carrying compound heterozygous SUN1 mutations displayed gross defects in myonuclear organization. This was accompanied by loss of recruitment of centrosomal marker, pericentrin, to the NE and impaired microtubule nucleation at the NE, events that are required for correct myonuclear arrangement. These defects were recapitulated in C2C12 myotubes expressing exogenous SUN1 variants, demonstrating a direct link between SUN1 mutation and impairment of nuclear-microtubule coupling and myonuclear positioning. Our findings strongly support an important role for SUN1 and SUN2 in muscle disease pathogenesis and support the hypothesis that defects in the LINC complex contribute to disease pathology through disruption of nuclear-microtubule association, resulting in defective myonuclear positioning.

Emery-Dreifuss muscular dystrophy (EDMD) is an inherited disorder involving muscle wasting and weakness, accompanied by cardiac defects. The disease is variable in its severity and also in its genetic cause. So far, 6 genes have been linked to EDMD, most encoding proteins that form a structural network that supports the nucleus of the cell and connects it to structural elements of the cytoplasm. This network is particularly important in muscle cells, providing resistance to mechanical strain. Weakening of this network is thought to contribute to development of muscle disease in these patients. Despite rigorous screening, at least 50% of patients with EDMD have no detectable mutation in the 6 known genes. We therefore undertook screening and identified mutations in two additional genes that encode other components of the nuclear structural network, SUN1 and SUN2. Our findings add to the genetic complexity of this disease since some individuals carry mutations in more than one gene. We also show that the mutations disrupt connections between the nucleus and the structural elements of cytoplasm, leading to mis-positioning and clustering of nuclei in muscle cells. This nuclear mis-positioning is likely to be another factor contributing to pathogenesis of EDMD.

Contribution of SUN1 mutations to the pathomechanism in muscular dystrophies

Mutations in several genes encoding nuclear envelope (NE) associated proteins cause Emery-Dreifuss muscular dystrophy (EDMD). We analyzed fibroblasts from a patient who had a mutation in the EMD gene (p.L84Pfs*6) leading to loss of Emerin and a heterozygous mutation in SUN1 (p.A203V). The second patient harbored a heterozygous mutation in LAP2alpha (p.P426L) and a further mutation in SUN1 (p.A614V). p.A203V is located in the N-terminal domain of SUN1 facing the nucleoplasm and situated in the vicinity of the Nesprin-2 and Emerin binding site. p.A614V precedes the SUN domain, which interacts with the KASH domain of Nesprins in the periplasmic space and forms the center of the LINC complex. At the cellular level, we observed alterations in the amounts for several components of the NE in patient fibroblasts and further phenotypic characteristics generally attributed to laminopathies such as increased sensitivity to heat stress. The defects were more severe than observed in EDMD cells with mutations in a single gene. In particular, in patient fibroblasts carrying the p.A203V mutation in SUN1, the alterations were aggravated. Moreover, SUN1 of both patient fibroblasts exhibited reduced interaction with Lamin A/C and when expressed ectopically in wild-type fibroblasts, the SUN1 mutant proteins exhibited reduced interactions with Emerin as well.

The LINC complex and human disease

The LINC (linker of nucleoskeleton and cytoskeleton) complex is a proposed mechanical link tethering the nucleo- and cyto-skeleton via the NE (nuclear envelope). The LINC components emerin, lamin A/C, SUN1, SUN2, nesprin-1 and nesprin-2 interact with each other at the NE and also with other binding partners including actin filaments and B-type lamins. Besides the mechanostructural functions, the LINC complex is also involved in signalling pathways and gene regulation. Emerin was the first LINC component associated with a human disease, namely EDMD (Emery-Dreifuss muscular dystrophy). Later on, other components of the LINC complex, such as lamins A/C and small isoforms of nesprin-1 and nesprin-2, were found to be associated with EDMD, reflecting a genetic heterogeneity that has not been resolved so far. Only approximately 46% of the EDMD patients can be linked to genes of LINC and non-LINC components, pointing to further genes involved in the pathology of EDMD. Obvious candidates are the LINC proteins SUN1 and SUN2. Recently, screening of binding partners of LINC components as candidates identified LUMA (TMEM43), encoding a binding partner of emerin and lamins, as a gene involved in atypical EDMD. Nevertheless, such mutations contribute only to a very small fraction of EDMD patients. EDMD-causing mutations in STA/EMD (encoding emerin) that disrupt emerin binding to Btf (Bcl-2-associated transcription factor), GCL (germ cell-less) and BAF (barrier to autointegration factor) provide the first glimpses into LINC being involved in gene regulation and thus opening new avenues for functional studies. Thus the association of LINC with human disease provides tools for understanding its functions within the cell.

Lamin A/C-dependent localization of Nesprin-2, a giant scaffolder at the nuclear envelope

The vertebrate proteins Nesprin-1 and Nesprin-2 (also referred to as Enaptin and NUANCE) together with ANC-1 of Caenorhabditis elegans and MSP-300 of Drosophila melanogaster belong to a novel family of alpha-actinin type actin-binding proteins residing at the nuclear membrane. Using biochemical techniques, we demonstrate that Nesprin-2 binds directly to emerin and the C-terminal common region of lamin A/C. Selective disruption of the lamin A/C network in COS7 cells, using a dominant negative lamin B mutant, resulted in the redistribution of Nesprin-2. Furthermore, using lamin A/C knockout fibroblasts we show that lamin A/C is necessary for the nuclear envelope localization of Nesprin-2. In normal skin where lamin A/C is differentially expressed, strong Nesprin-2 expression was found in all epidermal layers, including the basal layer where only lamin C is present. This indicates that lamin C is sufficient for proper Nesprin-2 localization at the nuclear envelope. Expression of dominant negative Nesprin-2 constructs and knockdown studies in COS7 cells revealed that the presence of Nesprin-2 at the nuclear envelope is necessary for the proper localization of emerin. Our data imply a scaffolding function of Nesprin-2 at the nuclear membrane and suggest a potential involvement of this multi-isomeric protein in human disease.

The nuclear muscular dystrophies

Nuclear muscular dystrophies are referred to as inherited muscular dystrophies caused by mutations in genes--(STA) or lamina (LMNA)--encoding components of the nuclear envelope. Phenotypically, they present as Emery-Dreifuss muscular dystrophy (EDMD), limb-girdle muscle dystrophy 1B (LGMD1B), or dilated cardiomyopathy with conduction defects (DCM-CD). Genetically related are the Dunnigan-type of familial partial lipodystrophy (FPLD) and Charcot-Marie-Tooth neuropathy type 2 (CMT2B). Until now, approximately 70 unique STA mutations, leading to X-linked EDMD or DCM-CD, have resulted mostly in a complete lack of emerin. Further 50 mostly missense mutations in LMNA result in autosomal-dominant EDMD, autosomal-recessive EDMD, LGMD1B, DCM-CD, FPLD, or CMT2B. Independent of type or location of the mutations, emerinopathies and laminopathies show wide clinical intrafamilial and interfamilial variability. Although structural abnormalities of nuclei in animal and cell models have been observed, the molecular pathology of the nuclear muscular dystrophies needs still to be elucidated.

The cell cycle dependent mislocalisation of emerin may contribute to the Emery-Dreifuss muscular dystrophy phenotype

Emerin is the nuclear membrane protein defective in X-linked Emery-Dreifuss muscular dystrophy (X-EDMD). The majority of X-EDMD patients have no detectable emerin. However, there are cases that produce mutant forms of emerin, which can be used to study its function. Our previous studies have shown that the emerin mutants S54F, P183T, P183H, Del95-99, Del236-241 (identified in X-EDMD patients) are targeted to the nuclear membrane but to a lesser extent than wild-type emerin. In this paper, we have studied how the mislocalisation of these mutant emerins may affect nuclear functions associated with the cell cycle using flow cytometry and immunofluorescence microscopy. We have established that cells expressing the emerin mutant Del236-241 (a deletion in the transmembrane domain), which was mainly localised in the cytoplasm, exhibited an aberrant cell cycle length. Thereafter, by examining the intracellular localisation of endogenously expressed lamin A/C and exogenously expressed wild-type and mutant forms of emerin after a number of cell divisions, we determined that the mutant forms of emerin redistributed endogenous lamin A/C. The extent of lamin A/C redistribution correlated with the amount of EGFP-emerin that was mislocalised. The amount of EGFP-emerin mislocalized, in turn, was associated with alterations in the nuclear envelope morphology. The nuclear morphology and redistribution of lamin A/C was most severely affected in the cells expressing the emerin mutant Del236-241.

It is believed that emerin is part of a novel nuclear protein complex consisting of the barrier-to-autointegration factor (BAF), the nuclear lamina, nuclear actin and other associated proteins. The data presented here show that lamin A/C localisation is dominantly directed by its interaction with certain emerin mutants and perhaps wild-type emerin as well. These results suggest that emerin links A-type lamins to the nuclear envelope and that the correct localisation of these nuclear proteins is important for maintaining cell cycle timing.

Autosomal dominant Emery-Dreifuss muscular dystrophy: a new family with late diagnosis

Emery-Dreifuss muscular dystrophy is characterized by the clinical triad of early onset contractures of elbows, Achilles tendons and spine, wasting and weakness with a predominantly humero-peroneal distribution and life-threatening cardiac conduction defects and/or cardiomyopathy. Two main types of inheritance have been described: the X-linked form is caused by mutations in the STA gene on locus Xq28 and the gene for the autosomal dominant form (LMNA gene) has been localized on chromosome 1q11-q23. Recently, mutations in this LMNA gene have been also found to be responsible for the less frequent autosomal recessive form of the disease. Although all forms share a similar clinical presentation, some differences appear to exist between them as has been described recently in a large number of patients. We present the first documented Spanish family genetically confirmed to have autosomal dominant Emery-Dreifuss muscular dystrophy. Clinical, pathological and genetic data are described. We emphasize the difficulties in diagnosis, especially in sporadic cases or young patients in whom the clinical picture is not completely established.

Nuclear envelope proteins and associated diseases

There is a growing body of evidence in favour of the presence of human diseases caused by mutations in genes that encode the nuclear envelope proteins emerin and lamin A/C (lamin A and C are alternatively spliced variants of the same gene). Emerin deficiency results in X-linked Emery-Dreifuss muscular dystrophy (EDMD). Lamin A/C mutations cause the autosomal-dominant form of EDMD, limb-girdle muscular dystrophy with atrioventricular conduction disturbances (type 1B), hypertrophic cardiomyopathy and Dunnigan-type familial partial lipodystrophy. In the targeted mouse model of lamin A gene deficiency, loss of lamin A/C is associated with mislocalization of emerin. Thus, one plausible pathomechanism for EDMD, limb-girdle muscular dystrophy type 1B, hypertrophic cardiomyopathy and familial partial lipodystrophy is the presence of specific abnormalities of the nuclear envelope. Therefore, a group of markedly heterogeneous disorders can be classified as 'nuclear envelopathies'. The present review summarizes recent findings on nuclear envelope proteins and diseases.

Emery-Dreifuss muscular dystrophy - a 40 year retrospective

Emery-Dreifuss muscular dystrophy (EDMD) was delineated as a separate form of muscular dystrophy nearly 40 years ago, based on the distinctive clinical features of early contractures and humero-peroneal weakness, and cardiac conduction defects. The gene, STA at Xq28, for the commoner X-linked EDMD encodes a 34 kD nuclear membrane protein designated 'emerin', and in almost all cases on immunostaining is absent in muscle, skin fibroblasts, leucocytes and even exfoliative buccal cells, and a mosaic pattern in female carriers. The gene, LMNA at 1q21, for the autosomal dominant Emery-Dreifuss muscular dystrophy encodes other nuclear membrane proteins, lamins A/C. The diagnosis (at present) depends on mutation analysis rather than protein immunohistochemistry. It is still not at all clear how defects in these nuclear membrane proteins are related to the phenotype, even less clear that LMNA mutations can also be associated with familial dilated cardiomyopathy with no weakness, and even familial partial lipodystrophy with diabetes mellitus and coronary heart disease! What began as clinical studies in a relatively rare form of dystrophy has progressed to detailed research into the functions of nuclear membrane proteins particularly in regard to various forms of heart disease.

The nuclear envelope, muscular dystrophy and gene expression

Lamins and other nuclear envelope proteins organize nuclear architecture through structural attachments that vary dynamically during the cell cycle and cell differentiation. Genetic studies have now shown that people with mutations in either lamins A/C or emerin, a nuclear membrane protein, develop Emery-Dreifuss muscular dystrophy. A mouse model for this rare disease has been created by knocking out the gene that encodes lamin A/C. This article discusses these and other recent results in the wider context of nuclear envelope function, as a framework for thinking about the possible ways in which defects in nuclear envelope proteins can lead to disease.