Developmental neurobiology: Alternative ends for a familiar story?

DNA double-strand breaks as drivers of neural genomic change, function, and disease

Early work from about two decades ago implicated DNA double-strand break (DSB) formation and repair in neuronal development. Findings emerging from recent studies of DSBs in proliferating neural progenitors and in mature, non-dividing neurons suggest important roles of DSBs in brain physiology, aging, cancer, psychiatric and neurodegenerative disorders. We provide an overview of some findings and speculate on what may lie ahead.

Reversal of Neuronal Atrophy: Role of Cellular Immunity in Neuroplasticity and Aging

Emerging evidence indicates that neuroimmunological changes in the brain can modify intrinsic brain processes that are involved in regulating neuroplasticity. Increasing evidence suggests that in some forms of motor neuron injury, many neurons do not die, but reside in an atrophic state for an extended period of time. In mice, facial motor neurons in the brain undergo a protracted period of degeneration or atrophy following resection of their peripheral axons. Reinjuring the proximal nerve stump of the chronically resected facial nerve stimulates a robust reversal of motor neuron atrophy which results in marked increases in both the number and size of injured motor neurons in the facial motor nucleus. In this brief review, we describe research from our lab which indicates that the reversal of atrophy in this injury model is dependent on normal cellular immunity. The role of T cells in this unique form of neuroplasticity following injury and in brain aging, are discussed. The potential role of yet undiscover intrinsic actions of recombination activating genes in the brain are considered. Further research using the facial nerve reinjury model could identify molecular signals involved in neuroplasticity, and lead to new ways to stimulate neuroregenerative processes in neurotrauma and other forms of brain insult and disease.

Recombination activating gene-2 regulates CpG-mediated interferon-α production in mouse bone marrow-derived plasmacytoid dendritic cells

Using mice that lack recombination activating gene-2 (Rag2), we have found that bone marrow-derived plasmacytoid dendritic cells (pDCs) as main producers of interferon-α (IFNα) require Rag2 for normal development. This is a novel function for Rag2, whose classical role is to initiate B and T cell development. Here we showed that a population of common progenitor cells in the mouse bone marrow possessed the potential to become either B cells or pDCs upon appropriate stimulations, and the lack of Rag2 hindered the development of both types of progeny cells. A closer look at pDCs revealed that Rag2^−/− pDCs expressed a high level of Ly6C and were defective at producing IFNα in response to CpG, a ligand for toll-like receptor 9. This phenotype was not shared by Rag1^−/− pDCs. The induction of CCR7, CD40 and CD86 with CpG, however, was normal in Rag2^−/− pDCs. In addition, Rag2^−/− pDCs retained the function to promote antibody class switching and plasma cell formation through producing IL-6. Further analysis showed that interferon regulatory factor-8, a transcription factor important for both IFNα induction and pDC development, was dysregulated in pDCs lacking Rag2. These results indicate that the generation of interferon response in pDCs requires Rag2 and suggest the lymphoid origin of bone marrow-derived pDCs.

Different gene sets contribute to different symptom dimensions of depression and anxiety

Although many genetic association studies have been carried out, it remains unclear which genes contribute to depression. This may be due to heterogeneity of the DSM-IV category of depression. Specific symptom-dimensions provide a more homogenous phenotype. Furthermore, as effects of individual genes are small, analysis of genetic data at the pathway-level provides more power to detect associations and yield valuable biological insight. In 1,398 individuals with a Major Depressive Disorder, the symptom dimensions of the tripartite model of anxiety and depression, General Distress, Anhedonic Depression, and Anxious Arousal, were measured with the Mood and Anxiety Symptoms Questionnaire (30-item Dutch adaptation; MASQ-D30). Association of these symptom dimensions with candidate gene sets and gene sets from two public pathway databases was tested using the Global test. One pathway was associated with General Distress, and concerned molecules expressed in the endoplasmatic reticulum lumen. Seven pathways were associated with Anhedonic Depression. Important themes were neurodevelopment, neurodegeneration, and cytoskeleton. Furthermore, three gene sets associated with Anxious Arousal regarded development, morphology, and genetic recombination. The individual pathways explained up to 1.7% of the variance. These data demonstrate mechanisms that influence the specific dimensions. Moreover, they show the value of using dimensional phenotypes on one hand and gene sets on the other hand.

Impaired social recognition memory in recombination activating gene 1-deficient mice

The recombination activating genes (RAGs) encode two enzymes that play key roles in the adaptive immune system. RAG1 and RAG2 mediate VDJ recombination, a process necessary for the maturation of B- and T-cells. Interestingly, RAG1 is also expressed in the brain, particularly in areas of high neural density such as the hippocampus, although its function is unknown. We tested evidence that RAG1 plays a role in brain function using a social recognition memory task, an assessment of the acquisition and retention of conspecific identity. In a first experiment, we found that RAG1-deficient mice show impaired social recognition memory compared to mice wildtype for the RAG1 allele. In a second experiment, by breeding to homogenize background genotype, we found that RAG1-deficient mice show impaired social recognition memory relative to heterozygous or RAG2-deficient littermates. Because RAG1 and RAG2 null mice are both immunodeficient, the results suggest that the memory impairment is not an indirect effect of immunological dysfunction. RAG1-deficient mice show normal habituation to non-socially derived odors and habituation to an open-field, indicating that the observed effect is not likely a result of a general deficit in habituation to novelty. These data trace the origin of the impairment in social recognition memory in RAG1-deficient mice to the RAG1 gene locus and implicate RAG1 in memory formation.

Immune and nervous systems share molecular and functional similarities: memory storage mechanism

One of the most complex and important features of both the nervous and immune systems is their data storage and retrieval capability. Both systems encounter a common and complex challenge on how to overcome the cumbersome task of data management. Because each neuron makes many synapses with other neurons, they are capable of receiving data from thousands of synaptic connections. The immune system B and T cells have to deal with a similar level of complexity because of their unlimited task of recognizing foreign antigens. As for the complexity of memory storage, it has been proposed that both systems may share a common set of molecular mechanisms. Here, we review the molecular bases of memory storage in neurons and immune cells based on recent studies and findings. The expression of certain molecules and mechanisms shared between the two systems, including cytokine networks, and cell surface receptors, are reviewed. Intracellular signaling similarities and certain mechanisms such as diversity, memory storage, and their related molecular properties are briefly discussed. Moreover, two similar genetic mechanisms used by both systems is discussed, putting forward the idea that DNA recombination may be an underlying mechanism involved in CNS memory storage.

Is there an emerging endosymbiotic relationship between mycobacteria and the human host based on horizontal transfer of genetic sequences?

While not negating the seriousness of tuberculosis and the need to prevent and combat the disease effectively, the large percentage of infected, apparently healthy individuals who harbour latent infections warrants consideration whether an endosymbiotic relationship is being established between mycobacteria and man. By means of a gene decay process eliminating their most metabolically important pathogenic genes associated with an increasing need for host gene products during prolonged intracellular survival, mycobacteria appears to be undergoing a process of establishing a less dangerous relationship with its host. To have tolerated this relationship over time, humans must have benefited. This is suggested to have occurred via changes in DNA higher order structure altering combinatorially regulated gene expression allowing increased cerebrodiversity. It can be expected that, beyond a certain threshold, negative effects ensued, leading to neuropathology and increased susceptibility for certain psychiatric disorders. These processes have probably been happening since the earliest contact with mycobacteria, but recently may have become modified by the emergence of epidemic tuberculosis and waves of increased oxidative stress following the circumstances associated with the Industrial Revolution and the more recent AIDS pandemic. The organism seems to have uniquely exploited the normal stress reaction of the host. Genomic stresses include changes associated with glucocorticoid effects as well as upregulated reactive oxygen species and stress/(heat shock) protein production, the latter two of which result in host cell cycle delay. Subsequently replication dependent chromosomal fragile sites appear in the host genome and together with upregulated chaperonins and mobile element activation, the scene is set for sequence exchange between the organism and host. If proven, these events raise the possibility of modifying chromatin epigenetically to retain the proposed advantages while silencing pathogenicity factors.

Somatic DNA recombination in the brain

Possible somatic DNA recombination in the brain has been investigated by attempting to capture direct or indirect evidence of it. Until recently, the biological significance of the DNA event, the genes is involved in the recombination, or even whether the event actually occurs in the brain has remained unclear. The DNA-rearranged locus-oriented approach and the recombination activity-oriented approach have mutually contributed to the elucidation of the biological features of extra-immune system somatic DNA recombination. There have been only 2 loci proposed for the candidate, one is a repetitive sequence and the other DNA recombination is nonrepetitive locus. This review states conventional concepts and discussions chronologically and finally to the newest aspects of DNA rearrangement in the brain.

Somatic DNA recombination in a mouse genomic region, BC-1, in brain and non-brain tissueThis paper is one of a selection of papers published in this Special Issue, entitled The Nucleus: A Cell Within A Cell

The genomic region BC-1 (GenBank acc. No. AB075899 ) on mouse chromosome 16 has been reported as a genomic region undergoing somatic DNA recombination producing circular DNA and genomic deletion in brain during late embryogenesis. The present study shows that the BC-1 circular DNA production had already started on the 13th day of embryonic age, earlier than the previous observation that the circular DNA production started on the 15th through 17th embryonic day. The BC-1 deletion was also observed in the spleen and ocular lens. In situ hybridization analysis indicated that a human-homologous region in the BC-1 sequence was expressed in the lens at a perinatal period. These data suggest that the somatic DNA recombination in the BC-1 region is not restricted to brain tissue, and that the BC-1 DNA recombination relates to lens development.

Failed clearance of aneuploid embryonic neural progenitor cells leads to excess aneuploidy in the Atm-deficient but not the Trp53-deficient adult cerebral cortex

Aneuploid neurons populate the normal adult brain, but the cause and the consequence of chromosome abnormalities in the CNS are poorly defined. In the adult cerebral cortex of three genetic mutants, one of which is a mouse model of the human neurodegenerative disease ataxia-telangiectasia (A-T), we observed divergent levels of sex chromosome (XY) aneuploidy. Although both A-T mutated (Atm)- and transformation related protein 53 (Trp53)-dependent mechanisms are thought to clear newly postmitotic neurons with chromosome abnormalities, we found a 38% increase in the prevalence of XY aneuploidy in the adult Atm-/- cerebral cortex and a dramatic 78% decrease in Trp53-/- mutant mice. A similar 43% decrease in adult XY aneuploidy was observed in DNA repair-deficient Xrcc5-/- mutants. Additional investigation found an elevated incidence of aneuploid embryonic neural progenitor cells (NPCs) in all three mutants, but elevated apoptosis, a likely fate of embryonic NPCs with severe chromosome abnormalities, was observed only in Xrcc5-/- mutants. These data lend increasing support to the hypothesis that hereditary mutations such as ATM-deficiency, which render abnormal cells resistant to developmental clearance, can lead to late-manifesting human neurological disorders.

Science imitates art: the cloning of mice from olfactory sensory neurons

The functional identity of an olfactory sensory neuron is defined by its expression of one odorant receptor from a large multigene family. The complexity of this process has led to speculation that DNA rearrangements are used to limit the expression of one receptor gene per cell. However, a recent report in Nature directly rules out irreversible DNA rearrangements as a mechanism for odorant receptor gene choice.

Alteration of gene expression by chromosome loss in the postnatal mouse brain

Frequent chromosomal aneuploidy has recently been discovered in normal neurons of the developing and mature murine CNS. Toward a more detailed understanding of aneuploidy and its effects on normal CNS cells, we examined the genomes of cells in the postnatal subventricular zone (SVZ), an area that harbors a large number of neural stem and progenitor cells (NPCs), which give rise to neurons and glia. Here we show that NPCs, neurons, and glia from the SVZ are frequently aneuploid. Karyotyping revealed that approximately 33% of mitotic SVZ cells lost or gained chromosomes in vivo, whereas interphase fluorescence in situ hybridization demonstrated aneuploidy in postnatal-born cells in the olfactory bulb (OB) in vivo, along with neurons, glia, and NPCs in vitro. One possible consequence of aneuploidy is altered gene expression through loss of heterozygosity (LOH). This was examined in a model of LOH: loss of transgene expression in mice hemizygous for a ubiquitously expressed enhanced green fluorescent protein (eGFP) transgene on chromosome 15. Concurrent examination of eGFP expression, transgene abundance, and chromosome 15 copy number demonstrated that a preponderance of living SVZ and OB cells not expressing eGFP lost one copy of chromosome 15; the eGFP transgene was lost in these cells as well. Although gene expression profiling revealed changes in expression levels of several genes relative to GFP-expressing controls, cells with LOH at chromosome 15 were morphologically normal and proliferated or underwent apoptosis at rates similar to those of euploid cells in vitro. These findings support the view that NPCs and postnatal-born neurons and glia can be aneuploid in vivo and functional gene expression can be permanently altered in living neural cells by chromosomal aneuploidy.

Diversity of the cadherin-related neuronal receptor/protocadherin family and possible DNA rearrangement in the brain

Both the brain and the immune systems are complex. The complexity is generated by enormously diversified single cells. In the immune system, extensive cell death, gene regulation of immunoglobulin (Ig) and T-cell receptor (TCR) gene expression, and somatic rearrangement and mutations are known to generate an enormous diversity of lymphocytes. In this process, double-strand DNA breaks (DSBs) and DSB repair play significant roles. These processes at a DNA level are also physiologically significant in the nervous system during neurogenesis, and chromosomal variations have been detected in the nucleus of differentiated neurones. In another parallel with the immune system, cadherin-related neuronal receptors (CNRs) are diversified synaptic proteins. The CNR genes belong to protocadherin (Pcdh) gene clusters. Genomic organizations of CNR/Pcdh genes are similar to that of the Ig and TCR genes. Somatic mutations in and combinatorial gene regulation of CNR/Pcdh transcripts during neurogenesis have been reported. This review focuses on the diversity of the CNR/Pcdh genes and possible DNA diversification in the nervous system.

Chromosomal variation in neurons of the developing and adult mammalian nervous system

A basic assumption about the normal nervous system is that its neurons possess identical genomes. Here we present direct evidence for genomic variability, manifested as chromosomal aneuploidy, among developing and mature neurons. Analysis of mouse embryonic cerebral cortical neuroblasts in situ detected lagging chromosomes during mitosis, suggesting the normal generation of aneuploidy in these somatic cells. Spectral karyotype analysis identified approximately 33% of neuroblasts as aneuploid. Most cells lacked one chromosome, whereas others showed hyperploidy, monosomy, and/or trisomy. The prevalence of aneuploidy was reduced by culturing cortical explants in medium containing fibroblast growth factor 2. Interphase fluorescence in situ hybridization on embryonic cortical cells supported the rate of aneuploidy observed by spectral karyotyping and detected aneuploidy in adult neurons. Our results demonstrate that genomes of developing and adult neurons can be different at the level of whole chromosomes.

Identifying genes involved in regulating differentiation of neuroblastoma cells

The genes regulating the induction of differentiation in neurons are not definitively known. Some neuronal tumors retain the ability to differentiate into mature, functional neurons in response to pharmacological agents, despite the presence of genetic anomalies. We hypothesized that some of the genes whose expression is altered between undifferentiated and differentiated states may be those responsible for inducing differentiation. To investigate this, we used a mouse neuroblastoma (NB) cell line, NBP(2), in which > or =90% of the cells in the culture terminally differentiate upon elevation of intracellular adenosine 3',5'-cyclic monophosphate (cAMP) levels. Gene expression was analyzed using cDNA array blots containing 588 known genes. mRNA from cultures of undifferentiated and differentiated NB cells was used to make cDNA probes for blot hybridization. We identified several genes that are predominantly expressed in either undifferentiated or differentiated NB cells. In addition, numerous genes are moderately up- or down-regulated during differentiation of NB cells. We identified the N-myc protooncogene, cyclin B1, and protease nexin 1 as genes that are expressed in undifferentiated NB cells and whose levels are significantly down-regulated upon differentiation. In contrast, the c-fes and c-fos protooncogenes and the RAG-1 gene activator are genes whose expression is significantly up-regulated during differentiation of NB cells. These findings were confirmed by RT-PCR analysis. The transcript size and expression level of N-myc, cyclin B1, protease nexin 1, c-fes, and c-fos were verified by Northern blotting. These genes may represent key mediators involved in the regulation of NB cell differentiation.

Recombinase activating gene enzymes of lymphocytes

Expression of T-cell receptor and surface immunoglobulins on T and B lymphocytes, respectively, is strictly dependent on the variable, (diversity) joining exon (V(D)J) recombination process, which is initiated by the lymphoid-specific recombinase activating gene proteins 1 and 2 (RAG1 and RAG2). Recent advances have highlighted the functional organization of the RAG1 and RAG2 proteins and have provided important information on the regulation of RAG gene expression. Depending on the severity of their effects on the V(D)J recombination process, mutations of the RAG genes account for a spectrum of combined immune deficiencies in humans.

Xrcc2 is required for genetic stability, embryonic neurogenesis and viability in mice

Repair of DNA damage by homologous recombination has only recently been established as an important mechanism in maintaining genetic stability in mammalian cells. The recently cloned Xrcc2 gene is a member of the mammalian Rad51 gene family, thought to be central to homologous recombination repair. To understand its function in mammals, we have disrupted Xrcc2 in mice. No Xrcc2(-/-) animals were found alive, with embryonic lethality occurring from mid-gestation. Xrcc2(-/-) embryos surviving until later stages of embryogenesis commonly showed developmental abnormalities and died at birth. Neonatal lethality, apparently due to respiratory failure, was associated with a high frequency of apoptotic death of post- mitotic neurons in the developing brain, leading to abnormal cortical structure. Embryonic cells showed genetic instability, revealed by a high level of chromosomal aberrations, and were sensitive to gamma-rays. Our findings demonstrate that homologous recombination has an important role in endogenous damage repair in the developing embryo. Xrcc2 disruption identifies a range of defects that arise from malfunction of this repair pathway, and establishes a previously unidentified role for homologous recombination repair in correct neuronal development.

Defective neurogenesis resulting from DNA ligase IV deficiency requires Atm

Ataxia telangiectasia results from mutations of ATM and is characterized by severe neurodegeneration and defective responses to DNA damage. Inactivation of certain DNA repair genes such as DNA ligase IV results in massive neuronal apoptosis and embryonic lethality in the mouse, indicating the occurrence of endogenously formed DNA double-strand breaks during nervous system development. Here we report that Atm is required for apoptosis in all areas of the DNA ligase IV-deficient developing nervous system. However, Atm deficiency failed to rescue deficits in immune differentiation in DNA ligase IV-null mice. These data indicate that ATM responds to endogenous DNA lesions and functions during development to eliminate neural cells that have incurred genomic damage. Therefore, ATM could be important for preventing accumulation of DNA-damaged cells in the nervous system that might eventually lead to the neurodegeneration observed in ataxia telangiectasia.

Developmental neurobiology: a genetic Cheshire cat?

In the wake of evidence that essential neurogenic processes might involve aspects of DNA rearrangement, recent discoveries about the unusual arrangement of genes encoding neuronal adhesion molecules known as protocadherins are very intriguing. But is this just a coincidence?