Optimal structure of a congenital heart surgery department in Europe

Second harvest of Congenital Heart Surgery Database in Türkiye: Current outcomes

Background

This second harvest of the Congenital Heart Surgery Database intended to compare current results with international databases.

Methods

This retrospective study examined a total of 4007 congenital heart surgery procedures from 15 centers in the Congenital Heart Surgery Database between January 2018 and January 2023. International diagnostic and procedural codes were used for data entry. STAT (Society of Thoracic Surgeons and European Association for Cardiothoracic Surgery) mortality scores and categories were used for comparison of the data. Surgical priority status was modified from American Society of Anesthesiologist guidelines. Centers that sent more than 5 cases to the database were included to the study.

Results

Cardiopulmonary bypass and cardioplegic arrest were performed in 2,983 (74.4%) procedures. General risk factors were present in 22.6% of the patients, such as genetic anomaly, syndrome, or prematurity. Overall, 18.9% of the patients had preoperative risk factors (e.g., mechanical ventilation, renal failure, and sepsis). Of the procedures, 610 (15.2%) were performed on neonates, 1,450 (36.2%) on infants, 1,803 (45%) on children, and 144 (3.6%) on adults. The operative timing was elective in 56.5% of the patients, 34.4% were urgent, 8% were emergent, and 1.1% were rescue procedures. Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation support was used in 163 (4%) patients, with a 34.3% survival rate. Overall mortality in this series was 6.7% (n=271). Risk for mortality was higher in patients with general risk factors, such as prematurity, low birth weight neonates, and heterotaxy syndrome. Mortality for patients with preoperative mechanical ventilation was 17.5%. Pulmonary hypertension and preoperative circulatory shock had 11.6% and 10% mortality rates, respectively. Mortality for patients who had no preoperative risk factor was 3.9%. Neonates had the highest mortality rate (20.5%). Intensive care unit and hospital stay time for neonates (median of 17.8 days and 24.8 days, respectively) were also higher than the other age groups. Infants had 6.2% mortality. Hospital mortality was 2.8% for children and 3.5% for adults. Mortality rate was 2.8% for elective cases. Observed mortality rates were higher than expected in the fourth and fifth categories of the STAT system (observed, 14.8% and 51.9%; expected, 9.9% and 23.1%; respectively).

Conclusion

For the first time, outcomes of congenital heart surgery in Türkiye could be compared to the current world experience with this multicenter database study. Increased mortality rate of neonatal and complex heart operations could be delineated as areas that need improvement. The Congenital Heart Surgery Database has great potential for quality improvement of congenital heart surgery in Türkiye. In the long term, participation of more centers in the database may allow more accurate risk adjustment.

Recommendations for centers performing pediatric heart surgery in the United States

Care and outcomes for the more than 40,000 patients undergoing pediatric and congenital heart surgery in the United States annually are known to vary widely. While consensus recommendations have been published across numerous fields as one mechanism to promote a high level of care delivery across centers, it has been more than two decades since the last pediatric heart surgery recommendations were published in the United States. More recent guidance is lacking, and collaborative efforts involving the many disciplines engaged in caring for these children have not been undertaken to date. The present initiative brings together professional societies spanning numerous care domains and congenital cardiac surgeons, pediatric cardiologists, nursing, and other healthcare professionals from diverse programs around the country to develop consensus recommendations for United States centers. The focus of this initial work is on pediatric heart surgery, and it is recommended that future efforts focus in detail on the adult congenital population. We describe the background, rationale, and methodology related to this collaborative effort, and recommendations put forth for Essential Care Centers (essential services necessary for any program), and Comprehensive Care Centers (services to optimize comprehensive and high-complexity care), encompassing structure, process, and outcome metrics across 14 domains.

Recommendations for Centers Performing Pediatric Heart Surgery in the United States

Care and outcomes for the more than 40,000 patients undergoing pediatric and congenital heart surgery in the United States annually are known to vary widely. While consensus recommendations have been published across numerous fields as one mechanism to promote a high level of care delivery across centers, it has been more than two decades since the last pediatric heart surgery recommendations were published in the United States. More recent guidance is lacking, and collaborative efforts involving the many disciplines engaged in caring for these children have not been undertaken to date. The present initiative brings together professional societies spanning numerous care domains and congenital cardiac surgeons, pediatric cardiologists, nursing, and other healthcare professionals from diverse programs around the country to develop consensus recommendations for United States centers. The focus of this initial work is on pediatric heart surgery, and it is recommended that future efforts focus in detail on the adult congenital population. We describe the background, rationale, and methodology related to this collaborative effort, and recommendations put forth for Essential Care Centers (essential services necessary for any program), and Comprehensive Care Centers (services to optimize comprehensive and high-complexity care), encompassing structure, process, and outcome metrics across 14 domains.

Recommendations for Centers Performing Pediatric Heart Surgery in the United States

Care and outcomes for the more than 40,000 patients undergoing pediatric and congenital heart surgery in the United States annually are known to vary widely. While consensus recommendations have been published across numerous fields as one mechanism to promote a high level of care delivery across centers, it has been more than two decades since the last pediatric heart surgery recommendations were published in the United States. More recent guidance is lacking, and collaborative efforts involving the many disciplines engaged in caring for these children have not been undertaken to date. The present initiative brings together professional societies spanning numerous care domains and congenital cardiac surgeons, pediatric cardiologists, nursing, and other healthcare professionals from diverse programs around the country to develop consensus recommendations for United States centers. The focus of this initial work is on pediatric heart surgery, and it is recommended that future efforts focus in detail on the adult congenital population. We describe the background, rationale, and methodology related to this collaborative effort, and recommendations put forth for Essential Care Centers (essential services necessary for any program), and Comprehensive Care Centers (services to optimize comprehensive and high-complexity care), encompassing structure, process, and outcome metrics across 14 domains.

Position statement for the development of adult congenital heart disease units in Latin America and the Caribbean: Recommendations by the adult congenital heart disease chapter and pediatric cardiology council of the interamerican society of cardiology …

In 2020, there was an estimated prevalence of more than 1.8 million adults with congenital heart disease (ACHDs) living in South America, and 677,000 in Central America and the Caribbean. The ACHD mortality is higher in developing countries, compared with developed countries, and it has been shown that concentrating this population in specialized ACHD units improves their survival and prognosis. Currently, Latin American (LATAM) and Caribbean countries have an insufficient number of specialists and specialized ACHD units. Analyzing this situation, the Inter-American Society of Cardiology's (IASC) ACHD chapter and Pediatric Cardiology Council have prepared the first recommendations for developing ACHD units in LATAM and Caribbean countries. This article is the first collaborative work between South American, Central American and Caribbean countries. It describes the main points for organizing and developing ACHD units adapted to our own reality. Each point has been discussed in terms of barriers and challenges, followed by specific recommendations for improving and developing ACHD care. They have been reviewed and endorsed by the International Society for Adult Congenital Heart Disease (ISACHD), and the goal of their implementation is for each ACHD unit in the region to have the standards of quality and efficiency to improve the prognosis and survival of ACHDs in the region.

Recommendations for developing effective and safe paediatric and congenital heart disease services in low-income and middle-income countries: a public health framework

The global burden of paediatric and congenital heart disease (PCHD) is substantial. We propose a novel public health framework with recommendations for developing effective and safe PCHD services in low-income and middle-income countries (LMICs). This framework was created by the Global Initiative for Children's Surgery Cardiac Surgery working group in collaboration with a group of international rexperts in providing paediatric and congenital cardiac care to patients with CHD and rheumatic heart disease (RHD) in LMICs. Effective and safe PCHD care is inaccessible to many, and there is no consensus on the best approaches to provide meaningful access in resource-limited settings, where it is often needed the most. Considering the high inequity in access to care for CHD and RHD, we aimed to create an actionable framework for health practitioners, policy makers and patients that supports treatment and prevention. It was formulated based on rigorous evaluation of available guidelines and standards of care and builds on a consensus process about the competencies needed at each step of the care continuum. We recommend a tier-based framework for PCHD care integrated within existing health systems. Each level of care is expected to meet minimum benchmarks and ensure high-quality and family centred care. We propose that cardiac surgery capabilities should only be developed at the more advanced levels on hospitals that have an established foundation of cardiology and cardiac surgery services, including screening, diagnostics, inpatient and outpatient care, postoperative care and cardiac catheterisation. This approach requires a quality control system and close collaboration between the different levels of care to facilitate the journey and care of every child with heart disease. This effort was designed to guide readers and leaders in taking action, strengthening capacity, evaluating impact, advancing policy and engaging in partnerships to guide facilities providing PCHD care in LMICs.

Management of Hypoplastic Left Heart Syndrome in Low-Resource Settings and the Ethics of Decision-Making

Hypoplastic left heart syndrome (HLHS) is possibly the most challenging congenital heart defect to confront in any setting. The highly specialized infrastructure and resources needed to treat HLHS is not available in many low-resource settings. However, low-resource settings must not be assumed to be synonymous with low- and middle-income countries as national income is not necessarily indicative of a country's prioritization of healthcare resources. Besides, a low-resource setting may be institution-specific as well as country-specific. We have stratified institutional capabilities for addressing the requirements of treatment for HLHS into five levels based on the capacity for diagnosis, intervention, and post-discharge monitoring. Depending on institutional capabilities, children born with HLHS in low-resource settings experience a spectrum of outcomes ranging from death without diagnosis to the hybrid or Norwood stage 1 palliation. The decision-making is ethically challenging when resources are scarce and economic efficiency must be considered in the context of distributive justice. Even in settings that would be classified as resource-rich where survival after surgery and quality of life afterward keep improving, not every parent would choose surgical intervention for their hypothetical child with HLHS.

Infrastructure Availability for the Care of Congenital Heart Disease Patients and Its Influence on Case Volume, Complexity and Access Among Healthcare Institutions in 17 Middle-Income Countries

The care for patients with congenital heart disease (CHD) is multi-disciplinary and resource intensive. There is limited information about the infrastructure available among programs that care for CHD patients in low and middle-income countries (LMIC). A survey covering the entire care-pathway for CHD, from initial assessment to inpatient care and outpatient follow-up, was administered to institutions participating in the International Quality Improvement Collaborative for Congenital Heart Disease (IQIC). Surgical case complexity-mix was collected from the IQIC registry and estimated surgical capacity requirement was based on population data. The statistical association of selected infrastructure with case volume, case-complexity and percentage of estimated case-burden actually treated, was analyzed. Thirty-seven healthcare institutions in seventeen countries with median annual surgical volume of 361 (41-3503) operations completed the survey. There was a median of two (1-16) operating room/s (OR), nine (2-80) intensive care unit (ICU) beds, three (1-20) cardiac surgeons, five (3-30) OR nurses, four (2-35) anesthesiologists, four (1-25) perfusionists, 28 (5-194) ICU nurses, six (0-30) cardiologists and three (1-15) interventional cardiologists. Higher surgical volume was associated with higher OR availability (p = 0.007), number of surgeons (p = 0.002), OR nurses (0.008), anesthesiologists (p = 0.04), perfusionists (p = 0.001), ICU nurses (p < 0.001), years of experience of the most senior surgeon (p = 0.03) or cardiologist (p = 0.05), and ICU bed capacity (p = 0.001). Location in an upper-middle income country (P = 0.04), OR availability (p = 0.02), and number of cardiologists (p = 0.004) were associated with performing a higher percentage of complex cases. This study demonstrates an overall deficit in the infrastructure available for the care of CHD patients among the participating institutions. While there is considerable variation across institutions surveyed, deficits in infrastructure that requires long-term investment like operating rooms, intensive care capacity, and availability of trained staff, are associated with reduced surgical capacity and access to CHD care.

The Current Landscape of Congenital Heart Surgery in Northern China: A Geographic and Population-Based Analysis

Background: Congenital heart disease (CHD) is the leading birth defect in China, and many patients require congenital heart surgery (CHS) to achieve optimal outcomes. However, the current landscape and population accessibility to specialist resources for CHS in China are unclear. Methods: Care facilities performing CHS were identified from the 2018 white book of Chinese cardiovascular surgery and were categorized as full or limited facilities based on specialist capacity. Census-based population data and road data were obtained from administrative sources. Service area analysis of all facilities was performed to estimate geographic accessibility. Results: Of 93 facilities in 14 provinces and municipalities in northern China, only 30.1% had full specialist capacity. The shortage of pediatric cardiologists and mechanical circulatory support was the primary limiting factor. In 2018, 61.3% of facilities performed <200 CHS cases, and 31.6% of all CHS cases (N = 30,921) were performed in limited facilities with substantially lower volume than full-capacity facilities (median value: 85.0 vs. 368.0). Beijing had a disproportionately higher CHS volume (367 cases per million population) than other provinces. Of all children under 5 in northern China, only 12.9% live within 30 km (a typical half-day visit) of the service areas of all facilities. Compared to children from the eastern region (31.4%), 71.8% of children from the central region and 70.2% of children from the western region needed to travel >180 km (a typical overnight visit) to receive care in full-capacity facilities. Conclusions: Many facilities for CHS in northern China had limited specialist capacity, and many CHD patients received suboptimal surgical care. Policy measures should address the significant geographic disparities to receive high-quality surgical care among disadvantaged patients.

Congenital Cardiac Surgery and Parental Perception of Risk: A Quantitative Analysis

INTRODUCTION

Interpretation of risk by parents of children undergoing congenital cardiac surgery is poorly documented. The available evidence highlights a dichotomy where clinicians suggest parents may not grasp the complexity and risk associated with procedures, while some parents suggest risk is unnecessarily overemphasized.

AIM

To quantify how risk is perceived by parents.

METHODS

One hundred six parents of children undergoing cardiac surgery were recruited and completed a Likert-type scale from 1 (perceived low risk) to 6 (perceived high risk), at 5 points: arrival at preadmission, post discussion with anethetist/surgeon, day of surgery, discharge from intensive care, and at outpatient follow-up. The surgical sample was stratified according to Risk Adjustment in Congenital Heart Surgery level.

ANALYSIS

Data were analyzed using Wilcoxon rank tests for differences in distributions of scores and Krippendorff α to examine the level of agreement.

RESULTS

Median parental risk scores varied over time, with no consistent risk scores observed. Maternal scores were consistently higher than paternal scores at every time point (P < .001). Postoperative complications resulted in a persistent rise in risk perception at follow-up (P < .001). Analysis of parental risk scores and objective measures of surgical risk highlighted poor agreement that was particularly marked at the extremes of risk.

CONCLUSIONS

Parents perceived higher risk scores than those reported by the clinical team. Mothers reported statistically significantly higher scores than their partners, highlighting potential tensions. In addition, the changing perception of risk over time emphasizes the need for flexible levels of support and information as parents navigate uncertainty.

A Risk Management Strategy for Managing Critical Human Resource Changes in a Pediatric Heart Program

BACKGROUND

Relocation, recruitment, or retirement of critical team members may lead to changes in the expertise pool that could threaten patient outcomes in a pediatric heart program. We developed a quality initiative aimed at risk management that uses risk-stratified case complexity and outcomes to guide a program during critical fluxes in the expert staff. The Ramp Down/Up protocol is a systematic, voluntary reduction in the complexity of cases performed, followed by a transparent and intentional escalation of case complexity.

METHODS

Institutional Ethics Review Board approval for this quality initiative was obtained. Patient/caregiver consent for quality data collection is obtained at the time of hospital admission. Every surgical patient having their index cardiac surgical procedure at the Izaak Walton Killam (IWK) from January 1, 2003, to December 2015 is included. The Ramp Down/Up protocol evolved to have to 4 critical elements: (1) a trigger and a reduction in case complexity; (2) an external/objective expert observer; (3) an escalation in case complexity; and (4) data (qualitative and quantitative) collection and analysis.

RESULTS

The Ramp Down/Up protocol was used 3 times over a 12-year period to address critical expert human resource challenges. The protocol was used for variable duration (3.5-9 months). Patient operative mortality was benchmarked to the Congenital Cardiac Surgery database, and outcomes were stable during and after protocol employment.

CONCLUSIONS

A quality initiative aimed at risk management has allowed 1 pediatric heart team to ensure that patient outcomes were maintained during critical human resource changes.

Italian survey on cardiac surgery for adults with congenital heart disease: which surgery, where and by whom?

OBJECTIVES

The population of ageing adults with congenital heart disease (ACHD) is increasing; surgery in these patients presents major difficulties in management. A great debate has developed about whether these patients should be cared for at an adult or paediatric hospital and by an acquired or congenital cardiac surgeon. We analysed data of the surgical treatment of ACHD from the Italian cardiac surgery centres in 2016, focusing on the type of surgery performed, where these patients were operated on and by whom.

METHODS

Ninety-two Italian cardiac surgery centres were contacted and 70 centres participated in this study. We collected data on the types of cardiac operations performed in congenital heart defect patients older than 18 years. In 2016, a total of 913 patients with ACHD were operated on: 440 by congenital cardiac surgeons (group I) in centres with paediatric and adult cardiac surgery units, and 473 by adult cardiac surgeons (group II) in centres with exclusively adult cardiac surgery units.

RESULTS

Pathologies of the right ventricular outflow tract were the most frequent diseases treated in group I and pathologies of the left ventricular outflow tract in group II. Group I included more complex and heterogeneous cases than group II. Surgery for ACHD represented 12% of the activity of congenital cardiac surgeons and only 1% of the activity of adult cardiac surgeons.

CONCLUSIONS

In Italy, ACHD patients are operated on both by congenital and adult cardiac surgeons. Congenital cardiac surgeons working in centres with both paediatric and adult cardiac surgery are more involved with ACHD patients and with more complex cases.

Linking world bank development indicators and outcomes of congenital heart surgery in low-income and middle-income countries: retrospective analysis of quality improvement data

OBJECTIVE

Many low-income and middle-income countries (LMICs) struggle to provide the health services investment required for life-saving congenital heart disease (CHD) surgery. We explored associations between risk-adjusted CHD surgical mortality from 17 LMICs and global development indices to identify patterns that might inform investment strategies.

DESIGN

Retrospective analysis: country-specific standardised mortality ratios were graphed against global development indices reflective of wealth and healthcare investment. Spearman correlation coefficients were calculated.

SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS

The International Quality Improvement Collaborative (IQIC) keeps a volunteer registry of outcomes of CHD surgery programmes in low-resource settings. Inclusion in the IQIC is voluntary enrolment by hospital sites. Patients in the registry underwent congenital heart surgery. Sites that actively participated in IQIC in 2013, 2014 or 2015 and passed a 10% data audit were asked for permission to share data for this study. 31 sites in 17 countries are included.

OUTCOME MEASURES

In-hospital mortality: standardised mortality ratios were calculated. Risk adjustment for in-hospital mortality uses the Risk Adjustment for Congenital Heart Surgery method, a model including surgical risk category, age group, prematurity, presence of a major non-cardiac structural anomaly and multiple congenital heart procedures during admission.

RESULTS

The IQIC registry includes 24 917 congenital heart surgeries performed in children<18 years of age. The overall in-hospital mortality rate was 5.0%. Country-level congenital heart surgery standardised mortality ratios were negatively correlated with gross domestic product (GDP) per capita (r=-0.34, p=0.18), and health expenditure per capita (r=-0.23, p=0.37) and positively correlated with under-five mortality (r=0.60, p=0.01) and undernourishment (r=0.39, p=0.17). Countries with lower development had wider variation in mortality. GDP per capita is a driver of the association between some other measures and mortality.

CONCLUSIONS

Results display a moderate relationship among wealth, healthcare investment and malnutrition, with significant variation, including superior results in many countries with low GDP per capita. These findings provide context and optimism for investment in CHD procedures in low-resource settings.

Fellowship Training in Pediatric Cardiac Anesthesia: History, Maturation, and Current Status

Pediatric cardiac anesthesia as a discipline has evolved over the years to become a well recognized sub-specialty. Education and training in the field has also continued to change and develop. In this review, the author outline the changes in the field over the years and suggest a structure for an organized fellowship training process.

Admission to dedicated pediatric cardiac intensive care units is associated with decreased resource use in neonatal cardiac surgery

OBJECTIVE

Neonates undergoing congenital heart surgery require highly specialized, resource-intensive care. Location of care and degree of specialization can vary between and within institutions. Using a multi-institutional cohort, we sought to determine whether location of admission is associated with an increase in health care costs, resource use and mortality.

METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed admission for neonates (<30 days) undergoing congenital heart surgery between 2004 and 2013 by using the Pediatric Health Information Systems database (44 children's hospitals). Multivariate generalized estimating equations adjusted for center- and patient-specific risk factors and stratified by age at admission were performed to examine the association of admission intensive care unit (ICU) with total hospital costs, mortality, and length of stay.

RESULTS

Of 19,984 neonates (60% male) identified, 39% were initially admitted to a cardiac ICU (CICU), 48% to a neonatal ICU (NICU), and 13% to a pediatric ICU. In adjusted models, admission to a CICU versus NICU was associated with a $20,440 reduction in total hospital cost for infants aged 2 to 7 days at admission (P = .007) and a $23,700 reduction in total cost for infants aged 8 to 14 days at admission (P = .01). Initial admission to a CICU or pediatric ICU versus NICU at <15 days of age was associated with shorter hospital and ICU length of stay and fewer days of mechanical ventilation. There was no difference in adjusted mortality by admission location.

CONCLUSIONS

Admission to an ICU specializing in cardiac care is associated with significantly decreased hospital costs and more efficient resource use for neonates requiring cardiac surgery.

Department of Pediatric Cardiac Surgery in Gdansk in its new location - previous activity and perspectives for development

The Department of Pediatric Cardiac Surgery in Gdansk is the only pediatric cardiac surgery center in northern Poland providing comprehensive treatment to children with congenital heart defects. The Department of Pediatric Cardiac Surgery in Gdansk currently offers a full spectrum of advanced procedures of modern cardiac surgery and interventional cardiology dedicated to patients from infancy to adolescence. January 19, 2016 marked the official opening of its new location.

Paediatric cardiac surgery in a peripheral European region: is a joint programme a safe alternative to regionalisation?

BACKGROUND

In 2007, a partnership was initiated between a small-volume paediatric cardiac surgery unit located in Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, Spain, and a large-volume cardiac surgery unit located in Milan, Italy. The main goal of this partnership was to provide surgical treatment to children with CHD in the Canary Islands.

METHODS

An operative algorithm for performing surgery in elective, urgent, and emergency cases was adopted by the this joint programme. Demographic and in-hospital variables were collected from the medical records of all the patients who had undergone surgical intervention for CHD from January, 2009 to March, 2013. Data were introduced into the congenital database of the European Congenital Heart Surgeons Association Congenital Database and the database was interrogated.

RESULTS

In total, 65 surgical mission trips were performed during the period of this study. The European Congenital Heart Surgeons Association Congenital Database documented 214 total patients with a mean age at operation of 36.45 months, 316 procedures in total with 198 cardiopulmonary bypass cases, 46 non-cardiopulmonary bypass cases, 26 cardiovascular cases without cardiopulmonary bypass, 22 miscellaneous other types of cases, 16 interventional cardiology cases, six thoracic cases, one non-cardiac, non-thoracic procedure on a cardiac patient with cardiac anaesthesia, and one extracorporeal membrane oxygenation case. The 30-day mortality was 6.07% (13 patients).

CONCLUSIONS

A joint programme between a small-volume centre and a large-volume centre may represent a valid and reproducible model for safe paediatric cardiac surgery in the context of a peripheral region.

Larger Centers May Produce Better Outcomes: Is Regionalization in Congenital Heart Surgery a Superior Model?

Efforts to correlate outcomes of children undergoing heart surgery with center volume and characteristics are not novel. In the current era, outcomes are defined as, and in many cases limited to, mortality rates. Over the past two decades, several investigators have explored various aspects of the volume-mortality relationship. The association between center volume and mortality, although not uniform, is highly implicated by the current literature. Notwithstanding, varied population densities in the United States makes regionalization of specialized services, such as pediatric cardiac surgery, undeniably challenging. There may be an unfortunate reality that larger centers have some advantage in achieving, at the very least, timely measures. However, as pediatric cardiac surgery progresses as a specialty, the definition of 'outcomes' must be expanded beyond simplified, dichotomous parameters. While mortality has been our historical primary focus, as it should be, it is reasonable to propose that our focus should be increasingly refined towards patient- and family-centric measures, including morbidity, cost/value ratio, and overall hospital experience.

Training in paediatric cardiac surgery and the American Board of Thoracic Surgery

Congenital heart surgery has evolved into its own specialty requiring unique techniques and skills. Recognizing the need to establish a special certification in congenital heart surgery, the American Board of Thoracic Surgery began the process in 2005, eventually granting the first certifications to qualified applicants in 2009. The American Council for Graduate Medical Education and the Thoracic Surgery Residency Review Committee have now approved specific training programs throughout the United States that will help to ensure the proper training of congenital heart surgeons for the future.

[Pulmonary hypertension associated with congenital heart disease and Eisenmenger syndrome]

Pulmonary arterial hypertension is a common complication of congenital heart disease (CHD). Congenital cardiopathies are the most frequent congenital malformations. The prevalence in our country remains unknown, based on birthrate, it is calculated that 12,000 to 16,000 infants in our country have some cardiac malformation. In patients with an uncorrected left-to-right shunt, increased pulmonary pressure leads to vascular remodeling and endothelial dysfunction secondary to an imbalance in vasoactive mediators which promotes vasoconstriction, inflammation, thrombosis, cell proliferation, impaired apotosis and fibrosis. The progressive rise in pulmonary vascular resistance and increased pressures in the right heart provocated reversal of the shunt may arise with the development of Eisenmenger' syndrome the most advanced form de Pulmonary arterial hypertension associated with congenital heart disease. The prevalence of Pulmonary arterial hypertension associated with CHD has fallen in developed countries in recent years that is not yet achieved in developing countries therefore diagnosed late as lack of hospital infrastructure and human resources for the care of patients with CHD. With the development of targeted medical treatments for pulmonary arterial hypertension, the concept of a combined medical and interventional/surgical approach for patients with Pulmonary arterial hypertension associated with CHD is a reality. We need to know the pathophysiological factors involved as well as a careful evaluation to determine the best therapeutic strategy.

What evidence is there for a relationship between organisational features and patient outcomes in congenital heart disease services? A rapid review

Background

The purpose of this rapid evidence synthesis is to support the current NHS England service review on organisation of services for congenital heart disease (CHD). The evidence synthesis team was asked to examine the evidence on relationships between organisational features and patient outcomes in CHD services and, specifically, any relationship between (1) volume of cases and patient outcomes and (2) proximity of colocated services and patient outcomes. A systematic review published in 2009 had confirmed the existence of this relationship, but cautioned this was not sufficient to make recommendations on the size of units needed.

Objectives

To identify and synthesise the evidence on the relationship between organisational features and patient outcomes for adults and children with CHD.

Data sources

A systematic search of medical- and health-related databases [MEDLINE, EMBASE, Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature (CINAHL), The Cochrane Library and Web of Science] was undertaken for 2009–14 together with citation searching, reference list checking and stakeholder recommendations of evidence from 2003 to 2014.

Review methods

This was a rapid review and, therefore, the application of the inclusion and exclusion criteria to retrieved records was undertaken by one reviewer, with 10% checked by a second reviewer. Five reviewers extracted data from included studies using a bespoke data extraction form which was subsequently used for evidence synthesis. No formal quality assessment was undertaken, but the usefulness of the evidence was assessed together with limitations identified by study authors.

Results

Thirty-nine papers were included in the review. No UK-based studies were identified and 36 out of 39 (92%) studies included only outcomes for paediatric patients. Thirty-two (82%) studies investigated the relationship between volume and mortality and seven (18%) investigated other service factors or outcomes. Ninety per cent were from the USA, 92% were multicentre studies and all were retrospective observational studies. Twenty-five studies (64%) included all CHD conditions and 14 (36%) included single conditions or procedures. Although the evidence does demonstrate a relationship between volume and outcome in the majority of studies, this relationship is not consistent. The relationship was stronger for single-complex conditions or procedures. A mixed picture emerged revealing a range of factors as well as volume that influence outcome, including condition severity, individual centre and surgeon effects and clinical advances over time. We found limited (seven studies) evidence about the impact of proximity and colocation of services on outcomes, and about volume on non-mortality outcomes.

Limitations

This was a rapid review that followed standard methods to ensure transparency and reproducibility. The main limitations of the included studies were the retrospective nature, reliance on routine data sets, completeness, selection bias and lack of data on key clinical and service-related processes.

Conclusions

This review identified a substantial number of studies reporting a positive relationship between volume and outcome, but the complexity of the evidence requires careful interpretation. The heterogeneity of findings from observational studies suggests that, while a relationship between volume and outcome exists, this is unlikely to be a simple, independent and directly causal relationship. The effect of volume on outcome relative to the effect of other as yet undetermined health system factors remains a complex and unresolved research question.

Funding

The National Institute for Health Research Health Services and Delivery Research programme.

"Baby Heart Project": the Italian project for accreditation and quality management in pediatric cardiology and cardiac surgery

Optimization of the relationship between the supply and the demand for medical services should ideally be taken into consideration for the planning within each national Health System. Although government national health organizations embrace this policy specifically, the contribution of expert committees (under the scientific societies' guarantee in any specific medical field) should be advocated for their capability to collect and analyze the data reported by the various national institutions. In addition, these committees have the competence to analyze the need for the resources necessary to the operation of these centers. The field of pediatric cardiology and cardiac surgery may represent a model of clinical governance of particular interest with regard to programming and to a definition of the quality standards that may be extended to highly specialized institutions and ideally to the entire Health System. The "Baby Heart Project," which represents a model of governance and clinical quality in the field of pediatric cardiology and cardiac surgery, was born from the spontaneous aggregation of a committee of experts, supported by duly appointed Italian Scientific Societies and guided by a national agency for accreditation. The ultimate aim is to standardize both procedures and results for future planning within the national Health System.

Mexican registry of pediatric cardiac surgery. First report

BACKGROUND

Currently, there is a spreading worldwide tendency to characterize health issues and to propose alternative solutions via the creation of computerized databases. The aim of this study was to present the results in a computerized database of pediatric cardiac surgeries developed under the auspices of the Mexican Association of Specialists in Congenital Heart Diseases (Asociación Mexicana de Especialistas en Cardiopatías Congénitas A.C) and coordinated by the collegiate group of Pediatric Cardiology and Surgery as petitioned by the National Institutes of Health and High Specialty Hospitals Coordinating Commission.

METHODS

We analyzed all cases registered in the database during a 1-year observation period (August 1, 2011 to July 31, 2012) by all major Health Ministry-dependent institutes and hospitals offering surgical services related to pediatric cardiopathies to the non-insured population.

RESULTS

Seven institutions participated voluntarily in completing the database. During the analyzed period, 943 surgeries in 880 patients with 7% reoperations (n=63) were registered. Thirty-eight percent of the surgeries were performed in children <1 year of age. The five most common cardiopathies were patent ductus arteriosus (n=96), ventricular septal defect (n=86), tetralogy of Fallot (n=72), atrial septal defect (n=68), and aortic coarctation (n=54). Ninety percent of surgeries were elective and extracorporeal circulation was used in 62% of surgeries. Global mortality rate was 7.5% with the following distribution in the RACHS-1 score categories: 1 (n=4, 2%), 2 (n=19, 6%), 3 (n=22, 8%), 4 (n=12, 19%), 5 (n=1, 25%), 6 (n=6, 44%), and non-classifiable (n=2, 9%).

CONCLUSIONS

This analysis provides a representative view of the surgical practices in cardiovascular diseases in the pediatric population at the national non-insured population level. However, incorporating other health institutions to the national registry database will render a more accurate panorama of the national reality in surgical practices in the population <18 years of age.

Congenital Heart Disease in Mexico

Consistent with the mission of the World Society for Pediatric and Congenital Heart Surgery to promote health care for children with congenital heart disease all around the world, a Mexican Association of Specialists in Congenital Heart Disease (abbreviated in Spanish as AMECC) was created in Mexico in 2008. Our efforts were coordinated with those of the National Health Secretary with the objective being implementation of a national plan for regionalization of care for patients with congenital heart disease. To improve our knowledge related to technologic and human resources for management of congenital heart disease, we developed a national survey. Finally, a national database was created for collecting all Mexican centers’ information related to congenital heart disease care in order to quantify the advances related to the proposed plans. The database utilized international consensus nomenclature. The aim of this article is to show the sequence of our actions in relation to direct accomplishments and the current status of congenital heart disease care in Mexico. This article emphasizes the main aspects of these actions: regionalization project implementation, national survey results, and cardiovascular pediatric surgical database creation. Knowledge of outcomes related to successful actions would be useful for those countries that face similar challenges and may lead them to consider adoption of similar measures with the respective adjustments to their own reality.

[Care of the critically ill child with heart disease in Spain]

INTRODUCTION

The objective of the present study is to present the organization of the resources of paediatric cardiac critical care in Spain.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Data were collected through questionnaires sent by e-mail to Spanish PICUs.

RESULTS

22 PICUs were enrolled. The median number of beds were 9.5 (4-18 beds). Total cardiac admissions represented a 20 % of total PICUs admissions per year, firstly for congenital heart defects, and secondly for respiratory problems. Cardiac surgical activities were carried out in 16 centres, centralized in PICU in 10 cases. Mechanical support of the myocardium was performed in 7 PICUs. A total of 10 participating PICUs considered echocardiograph training necessary and also an increase in the amount of activity for better results.

CONCLUSIONS

Paediatric cardiac critical care involves a significant use of resources, including PICUs with no surgical activity. This study is useful for detecting common problems and for improving clinical care.

Management of patients with congenitally malformed hearts in Indonesia

At a crude rate in Indonesia of 20 births per 1000 population, the total number of annual live-births is approximately 4.5 million. Considering the estimate of 9 of each 1000 affected live-births, 40,500 infants with congenitally malformed hearts are added every year to the total pool. The number of surgical procedures for such congenital cardiac malformations in the whole country in 2005 was 706. The majority of cases are undetected, contributing to a high rate of infant mortality. In the period of 3 years from 2003 through 2005, 1366 patients underwent open and closed cardiac surgical procedures at the National Cardiovascular Center in Jakarta. The rate of death was 5.56%, with a complexity score as calculated for the Aristotle system of 6.25, which is at the medium level. The proportion of surgical procedures performed in infancy has increased, but the rate of mortality for complex surgery in this particular group is still high. Non-surgical interventions have increased every year, but the cost is higher than for surgery, except for balloon pulmonary valvoplasty. Thus, by any reckoning, paediatric cardiac care in Indonesia is still in its infancy. The barriers are: lack of awareness of congenitally malformed hearts, limited resources and facilities, the high cost of treatment, and limited financial support. Training programmes exclusively dedicated to paediatric cardiology and paediatric cardiac surgery need to be established in centers with good standards of paediatric cardiac care.

Update in adult congenital cardiac surgery

The number of grown-up patients with congenital heart disease (GUCH) is constantly increasing and will equal the number of children requiring surgery for congenital heart disease (CHD). Specialized centers dealing with the medical and paramedical problems of these patients are required. GUCH patients can be divided into the following groups: (1) patients with minor cardiac malformations presenting at adult age for first treatment; (2) patients presenting for correction as adults because they are either naturally balanced or were surgically palliated; (3) patients presenting for expected reoperations after correction in childhood; (4) patients requiring repair of residual defects after correction; (5) patients developing heart failure after correction or palliation of CHD requiring thoracic transplantation; and (6) patients developing acquired heart disease in addition to CHD. Special aspects of malformations frequently occurring in GUCH patients are discussed in detail. Acquired heart disease in this patient population is expected to increase in the coming decades as survivors of CHD grow old.

Aristotle Score Predicts Outcome in Patients Requiring Extracorporeal Circulatory Support Following Repair of Congenital Heart Disease

Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) has become the standard technique of mechanical support for the failing circulation following repair of congenital heart lesions. The objective of this study was to identify predictors of survival in patients requiring postcardiotomy ECMO. The Aristotle score, a method developed to evaluate quality of care based on complexity, was investigated as a potential predictor of outcome. Between 2003 and 2005, 37 patients required ECMO following corrective surgery for congenital heart disease. Records were reviewed retrospectively with emphasis on factors affecting survival to discharge. The comprehensive Aristotle complexity score was calculated for each patient. Overall, 28 patients (76%) survived to decannulation and 17 patients (46%) survived to discharge. There were 24 (65%) neonates and 10 patients (27%) with single ventricle physiology, with a hospital survival of 42% (10 of 24) and 50% (5 of 10), respectively. Univariate factors associated with survival included Aristotle score, duration of support, reexploration, multiple organ failure, and number of complications. Age, weight, and single-ventricle physiology were not significant. In a logistic regression model, an Aristotle score < 14 was identified as a predictor of survival (OR 0.12, CI 0.02-0.87). The Aristotle score is predictive of outcome in patients requiring postcardiotomy ECMO and may serve as a uniform criterion when comparing and evaluating quality of care and performance in this complex patient population.

Report of the 2005 STS Congenital Heart Surgery Practice and Manpower Survey

BACKGROUND

Limited information is available concerning the congenital heart surgery workforce in North America. To obtain reliable data, The Society of Thoracic Surgeons (STS) Workforce on Congenital Heart Surgery undertook a subspecialty focused survey.

METHODS

Preliminary research of websites and databases revealed a potential target group of 263 congenital heart surgeons, including 248 surgeons at 121 US centers and 15 at eight Canadian sites. Surveys were sent to these, plus any additional individuals who listed an interest in congenital or pediatric heart surgery on CTSNet or STS websites. Responders include active congenital heart surgeons, inactive, or retired surgeons, adult cardiac surgeons, and surgeons in training. Analysis is based exclusively on the responses of 217 active congenital heart surgeons (>80% of target).

RESULTS

Average age was 48.3 +/- 8.3 years (range, 33 to 78). Ten were female (5%), 207 male (95%). American Medical School graduates were 170 (79%), with 9.2 +/- 1.6 years of postgraduate training. Eighty-five percent are Thoracic Board certified. Congenital heart surgery training outside the United States or Canada was obtained by 29 (14%). One hundred twenty-eight (59%) do exclusively congenital heart surgery. One third perform fewer than 100 congenital cases per year, one third perform 100 to 199, and one third perform 200 or more. Congenital heart surgeons have been in their current positions for 9.5 +/- 8.2 years. Eleven are in their first year of practice. Mean anticipated years to retirement is 15.7 +/- 7.5 (range, 1 to 34). Three anticipate retirement within 1 year. At the same time, 39 fellows will complete postgraduate training at 28 centers this year, and 19 will seek positions in North America.

CONCLUSIONS

These data should help to facilitate rational plans to meet manpower needs, including evolving policies concerning training and certification.

Delivery of care for adult patients with congenital heart disease in Europe: results from the Euro Heart Survey

AIMS

The increasing number of adults with congenital heart disease (CHD) has prompted the development of recommendations for the management of these patients and for the organization of their healthcare. The aim of this report is to describe the delivery of care in Europe for adults with congenital cardiac anomalies.

METHODS AND RESULTS

As part of the Euro Heart Survey on Adult Congenital Heart Disease, we obtained data from 71 voluntarily participating centres that detailed their care practices for these patients. Forty-eight of these centres were specialist centres and 23 were non-specialist centres. We found that only 19% of the specialist centres complied with defined standards for optimal care structure. The criteria that appeared to be most difficult for all centres to achieve were performing 50 congenital heart operations or more per year and involving nurse specialists in the care of these patients.

CONCLUSION

This survey indicated that the provision of care in Europe for adults with congenital heart defects is suboptimal. To fully realize the benefits of cardiac surgery performed in infants and children, continuous effort must be applied by healthcare professionals in order to implement the recommendations on the organization of care for these patients.

Postoperative extracorporeal life support in pediatric cardiac surgery: recent results

We retrospectively reviewed the files of 19 extracorporeal life support (ECLS) applications performed after cardiac surgery in 15 patients from January 2002 to December 2004. We placed 16 arteriovenous ECLS applications with oxygenator, 2 venovenous ECLS applications with oxygenator, and 1 biventricular ECLS application without oxygenator (graft dysfunction after heart transplant). Mean age was 4.9 +/- 7 years (median 5.9 months, range 11 days to 21 years). All patients underwent surgery for congenital heart disease, except for one patient who had a heart transplant. Indications were hemodynamic failure in 12 cases, respiratory failure in 5 cases, and mixed failure in 2 cases. Four patients were undergoing cardiopulmonary resuscitation during ECLS placement (no deaths). Mean delay between surgery and ECLS placement was 3.2 +/- 3.4 days (median 2 days). Mean ECLS duration was 3.4 +/- 5.8 days (mean 6 days, range 3-16 days). Three patients had further surgery for residual lesions. Thirteen patients (86.7%) survived to ECLS weaning; 12 patients survived to hospital discharge (80%). No survivor presented obvious neurologic damage. Specific morbidity included reentry for bleeding, multiple transfusions, and mediastinitis. These results support early placement of ECLS in children whenever a severe postoperative hemodynamic or respiratory failure, refractory to medical treatment, is present.

Current status of the European Association for Cardio-Thoracic Surgery and the Society of Thoracic Surgeons Congenital Heart Surgery Database

BACKGROUND

After utilizing separate congenital databases in the early 1990s, the Society of Thoracic Surgeons (STS) and the European Association for Cardio-Thoracic Surgery (EACTS) collaborated on several joint database initiatives.

METHODS

In 1998, the joint EACTS-STS International Congenital Heart Surgery Nomenclature and Database Project Committee was created and a common nomenclature and common core minimum database dataset were adopted and published by the STS and the EACTS. In 1999, the joint EACTS-STS Aristotle Committee was created and the Aristotle Score was adopted and published as a method to provide complexity adjustment for congenital heart surgery. Collaborative efforts involving the EACTS and STS are underway to develop mechanisms to verify data completeness and accuracy.

RESULTS

Since 1998, this nomenclature, database, and methodology of complexity adjustment have been used by both the STS and EACTS to analyze outcomes of over 40,000 patients. A huge amount of data have been generated which allow comparison of practice patterns and outcomes analysis between Europe and North America. The aggregate data from the first 5 years of data collection not only make for interesting comparison but also allow examination of regional difference in practice patterns. For example, in the EACTS, out of 4,273 neonates, 885 (20.7%) underwent arterial switch procedures and 297 (6.95%) underwent Norwood stage 1 procedures. In the STS, out of 3,988 neonates, 472 (11.8%) underwent arterial switch procedures and 575 (14.4%) underwent Norwood stage 1 procedures.

CONCLUSIONS

This analysis of the EACTS-STS multi-institutional outcomes database confirms that in both Europe and North America, case complexity and mortality is highest among neonates, then infants, and then children. Regional differences in practice patterns are demonstrated, with the overall goal being the continued upgrade in the quality of surgery for congenital heart disease worldwide.

The Aristotle method: a new concept to evaluate quality of care based on complexity

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Evaluation of quality of care is a duty of the modern medical practice. A reliable method of quality evaluation able to compare fairly institutions and inform a patient and his family of the potential risk of a procedure is clearly needed. It is now well recognized that any method that purports to evaluate quality of care should include a case mix/risk stratification method. No valuable method was available until recently in pediatric cardiac surgery.

RECENT FINDINGS

The Aristotle method is a new concept of evaluation of quality of care in congenital heart surgery based on the complexity of the surgical procedures. Involving a panel of expert surgeons, the project started in 1999 and included 50 pediatric surgeons from 23 countries. The basic score adjusts the complexity of a given procedure and is calculated as the sum of potential for mortality, potential for morbidity and anticipated technical difficulty. The Comprehensive Score further adjusts the complexity according to the specific patient characteristics (anatomy, associated procedures, co-morbidity, etc.). The Aristotle method is original as it introduces several new concepts: the calculated complexity is a constant for a given patient all over the world; complexity is an independent value and risk is a variable depending on the performance; and Performance = Complexity x Outcome.

SUMMARY

The Aristotle score is a good vector of communication between patients, doctors and insurance companies and may stimulate the quality and the organization of heath care in our field and in others.

Evaluation of quality of care for congenital heart disease

There is widespread recognition that surgical outcomes differ by surgeon and institution; however, the definition and measurement of quality in pediatric cardiac surgery is in its infancy. This article discusses the definition of quality, what has been done to define and measure quality of pediatric cardiac surgery, and how to proceed. Descriptions of assessment of quality by evaluating structure, process, and outcome measures; efforts to establish a global congenital heart surgery database; and a comparison of risk-adjusted mortality rates using the Risk Adjustment for Congenital Heart Surgery method are included.

Newborn heart surgery: reasonable expectations and outcomes

This article discusses the necessity for standards for reasonable expectations and outcomes for neonatal treatment of congenital heart disease and the databases that allow such standards to be measured and to be compared among treatment centers.

Registro español sobre organización, recursos y actividades en Cardiología Pediátrica

INTRODUCTION

We present the findings of the registry of activities and resources of the Spanish Society of Pediatric Cardiology in 2002, with the objective of providing a national reference for professionals and entities involved in the study and treatment of congenital heart defects.

METHODS

Data were retrospectively collected through questionnaires sent from the Spanish Society of Pediatric Cardiology to the heads of pediatric cardiology units with medical and surgical activities, as well as to all the members of the Society and those of the Pediatric Cardiology Section of the Spanish Society of Cardiology.

RESULTS

Thirty-eight centers, including 17 national centers with medical and surgical activities, completed the questionnaire. Human resources consisted of 110 cardiologists, 43 surgeons and 12 residents in training. All the centers had the elementary tools for diagnosis and all except one had Echo-2D-Doppler. There were eight catheterization laboratories exclusively used for pediatric activities and nine further laboratories that combined adult and pediatric activities. A total of 83,061 patients were attended in outpatient clinics and there were 6,938 hospital admissions in 22 centres. A total of 279 ablation procedures were performed in 12 electrophysiology laboratories. The seventeen centres with surgical activities performed 2,498 cardiac catheterisms (968 interventional) and 2,292 cardiac surgical interventions.

CONCLUSIONS

Given the large number of participating centers, the present report provides exhaustive information on the organization, resources and activities of pediatric cardiology in Spain. Pediatric cardiology should be granted official recognition of its work so that teaching hospitals, organization, resources and activities can be regulated.