Why aren't older women getting mammograms and clinical breast exams?

Taking charge of self: breast health practices of older rural women

The purpose of this grounded theory study was to explore breast health practices of older Vermont women residing in rural communities. Although the three components of breast health-mammography, clinical breast exam, and self-breast exam-are recommended for women 40 years and over, minimal research has empirically analyzed the breast health practices of healthy women to ascertain if, in fact, these procedures are followed, and if so, what the motivation is for doing so. Twelve women, 50-64 years, participated in face-to-face, audiotaped interviews. Data analysis, including line-by-line and constant comparative approaches, occurred concurrently with data collection. Taking Charge of Self, the generated theory, describes participants' engagement in a process of learning how to take charge of their lives. The analysis indicates that health care providers have a powerful role in the lives of women in this age group. With an increasing emphasis on health promotion and disease prevention, health care providers are positioned to cultivate and support women's development of the personal or internal motivation for health and well-being.

Contraceptive counseling in managed care: preventing unintended pregnancy in adults

This study examines contraceptive counseling received by adult women in their managed care plans and the relationship between counseling and women's contraceptive attitudes and practices. Telephone interviews were conducted with a random sample of 898 women ages 18 to 44 enrolled in a commercial health maintenance organization (HMO) or point-of-service (POS) health plan. Counseling received in the past 2 years was measured on three dimensions: exposure through any communication channel; content of information; and personalization of discussion. Multiple logistic regression analysis was used to examine the determinants of counseling and the relationship between counseling and four outcomes: satisfaction with counseling received, self-efficacy for preventing unintended pregnancy, current use of contraception (if at risk of unintended pregnancy), and intent to contracept in the next year (if at risk). Overall, 60.5% of women were at risk of unintended pregnancy; among those at risk, 69% received any counseling in the past 2 years, compared with 38% among those not at risk. Receiving personalized counseling (as opposed to no counseling or only informational counseling) significantly increases the odds of satisfaction with counseling, current contraceptive use, and intent to contracept. Informational counseling alone (without personalization) significantly increases the odds of contraceptive use. Women ages 40-44 were less likely than younger women to receive counseling and to use contraception if at risk of unintended pregnancy. We conclude that receiving contraceptive counseling in managed care is associated with contraceptive attitudes and practices among adults and that there is substantial room for quality improvement in the provision of contraceptive counseling.

Managed care and women's health: access, preventive services, and satisfaction

This paper examines insured women's access to health care, receipt of preventive services, and satisfaction with care by the types of health plans in which they are enrolled. Three types of plans are compared: managed care (HMOs and PPOs), fee-for-service with utilization controls, and traditional fee-for-service. For women who have been enrolled in their plans for at least one year, we find the same or better access to care in managed care plans as compared with other plans; receipt of more gender-specific clinical preventive services in managed care plans, but no differences among types of plans for non-gender-specific preventive services or counseling services; and lower satisfaction with care in managed care plans. The implications for practice and policy are discussed.

Psychosocial factors associated with the use of breast cancer screening by women age 60 years or over

This study examined psychosocial factors related to breast cancer screening among older women. Data for the study were obtained from interviews with 719 women age 60 years or over attending rural and urban primary care clinics in North Carolina. The results indicated that 50% of the women had mammograms in the past year, 65% reported clinical breast examinations in the past year, and 31% said they practiced breast self-examinations once a month. Several psychosocial factors were significant predictors of a lower likelihood of being screened. Multivariate analysis confirmed the importance of psychosocial factors as predictors of breast cancer screening. Educational intervention to increase screening for breast cancer in this population is needed, and the results provide specific suggestions regarding the content of effective educational materials and approaches for older women.

Mammography adherence and beliefs in a sample of low-income African American women

The purpose of this article is to describe the relation of perceptions of perceived breast cancer risks and perceived benefits and barriers to mammography and stage of mammography adherence in a convenience sample of low-income African American women. The theoretical framework of the Health Belief Model and the Transtheoretical Model were used to identify concepts and stage of mammography adherence. Data were obtained in waiting rooms of multipurpose centers. Scores for susceptibility and benefits were lowest for those who were in (a) precontemplation (had not thought about having a mammogram); as compared to (b) contemplation (had thought about having a mammogram, but not yet acted); (c) action (had a mammogram as recommended by the American Cancer Society); and (d) relapse (had a mammogram in the past, but overdue). Barriers scores were highest for those who had not had a mammogram (precontemplators and contemplators). In addition, individual barriers were significantly lower for women in action. Results have implications for interventions to increase screening in low-income African American women.

Cancer screening of older women : a primary care issue

PURPOSE

The purpose of this retrospective chart review was to examine whether family practice physicians and residents were screening older women for breast, gynecologic, and colorectal cancers as recommended by the American Cancer Society, the Guide to Clinical Preventive Services, and Healthy People 2000.

METHODS

A retrospective chart review of women 60 years and older who were seen at least twice between July 1, 1992, and June 30, 1993, in a midwestern family practice residency program was completed. From the original sample of 660 potential subjects, a systematic random selection of every third chart was identified for review, resulting in a sample of 201. Analysis of the data was performed by descriptive statistics and chi-square tests. A series of multiple regression models using age, number of visits, type and gender of provider, and personal or family history of cancer as predictor variables was performed.

RESULTS

Breast cancer screening was offered to approximately 70% of the sample, with only about one third of the older women receiving mammography or clinical breast examination. Recommendations for gynecologic cancer screening were given to 63% of the sample, with less than one third receiving Papanicolaou smears. Recommendations for digital rectal examination, fecal occult blood test, and flexible sigmoidoscopy were 58%, 59%, and 30%, respectively. The percentages of patients who actually received these tests were considerably lower.

CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS

Barriers for appropriate cancer screening for older women exist for both the provider and the patient; however, many of these obstacles can be overcome. Improving the resident's exposure to the current recommendations, increasing geriatric content in the training program, and initiating a reminder system may reduce some of the provider barriers. The use of midlevel providers may increase the preventive services offered to older women as well as educate and empower these women to become responsible for their own healthcare. Together, physicians and midlevel providers can become patient advocates through political activism, encouraging legislation that guarantees payment for cancer screening tests. Finally, primary care providers can become actively engaged in research that explores the healthcare concerns of older women.

Learn, share, and live: breast cancer education for older, urban minority women

Among older urban minority women, for whom breast cancer risk is high and the propensity to be screened is low, both social support and breast cancer knowledge have been linked to mammography use. The authors describe a theory-based breast cancer education program implemented via an existing informal network for low-income urban elderly coordinated by a social service agency. The program is both structured and flexible. Core education sessions include delineated content and methods and are led by health professionals. Participants choose from a variety of follow-up activities to promote screening within their community. Pre- and posttests administered among 80 program attendees in two sites indicate significant improvement in knowledge (p < .001). Program attendees in each site also planned and participated in follow-up activities to promote screening among their peers. Learn, Share, and Live seems to be an effective program for promoting breast cancer screening among older, urban, primarily minority women.

Relationship of age to mammography compliance

Mammography use varies by age, with older women showing decreased use. The purpose of this research was to identify variables that affect screening use within two different age groups of women, those younger than 50 and those 50 and older. Predictor variables were identified using the Health Belief Model and Theory of Reasoned Action and included susceptibility, seriousness, benefits, barriers, health motivation, control, social influence, and experiential/demographic variables. A probability sample of 581 women aged 35 and older was included for analyses. Two measures of mammography compliance were tested: compliance with American Cancer Society (ACS) guidelines for the 5 years before the study and compliance with the ACS guidelines for the year before the study. An in-home interview was conducted by graduate research assistants. Compliance rates were significantly lower for women 50 and older than they were for younger women for both the 5-year compliance and the single year of compliance. Barriers were more significant for older women. Having a mammography suggested by a health care professional was most important in the older group, indicating that less weight may be given to personal decision making by this population. Higher socioeconomic status was significant with older but not younger women. For older women, interventions need to be directed toward both the physician and the individual woman. Programs that provide knowledge and address cost issues may be the most important primary components for younger women.

What do women do now?

Current issues surrounding research of the efficacy and utilization of mammography in women aged 40-49 are presented in the broader context of the psychosocial, economic, and information needs and dynamics that can affect consumer decision-making and access to mammography. Specific recommendations are made concerning the need for new approaches to research in detection methods. The relevance of federal regulatory developments in quality control to questions of outcomes and efficacy generally, and particularly in the 40-49 age group, is discussed. Opportunities created by new Public Health Service initiatives to increase access to mammography by improving utilization, professional education, and quality of care, thus developing meaningful outcome data, are highlighted.

Improving the use of cancer screening for older women

Breast cancer is a serious disease in terms of incidence and mortality for older women. Older women are likely to receive substantial benefit from mammography because of their increased risk for the disease. However, most women older than 65 years are not getting regular mammograms. There are a number of barriers to breast screening for older women, but perhaps none is more important than the lack of a physician recommendation. Tailored programs are needed if the promise of breast cancer screening is to be realized for older women. Such programs should reflect the heterogeneity of older women. In addition, physicians must be collaborators because of their central role influence.