Section 1A: Rh serology. Coordinator's report

Molecular dynamics of the human RhD and RhAG blood group proteins

Introduction: Blood group antigens of the RH system (formerly known as "Rhesus") play an important role in transfusion medicine because of the severe haemolytic consequences of antibodies to these antigens. No crystal structure is available for RhD proteins with its partner RhAG, and the precise stoichiometry of the trimer complex remains unknown. Methods: To analyse their structural properties, the trimers formed by RhD and/or RhAG subunits were generated by protein modelling and molecular dynamics simulations were performed. Results: No major differences in structural behaviour were found between trimers of different compositions. The conformation of the subunits is relatively constant during molecular dynamics simulations, except for three large disordered loops. Discussion: This work makes it possible to propose a reasonable stoichiometry and demonstrates the potential of studying the structural behaviour of these proteins to investigate the hundreds of genetic variants relevant to transfusion medicine.

Rh flow cytometry: An updated methodology for D antigen density applied to weak D types 164 and 165

BACKGROUND

An original methodology for determining the D antigen density on red cells was published in 2000 and has been applied in many publications since. This flow cytometry-based assay remained largely unrevised utilizing monoclonal anti-Ds that are not readily available anymore. We updated the methodology to quantify erythrocyte D antigen sites using microspheres and monoclonal anti-Ds that are commercially available today.

METHODS

The absolute D antigen density of a frozen standard CcDEe cell, drawn in 2003, a fresh blood donation from the same individual, drawn in 2022, and an internal control CcDEe cell, was quantified by flow cytometry using fluorescence-labeled microspheres. The internal control CcDEe cell was used in conjunction with 9 commercial anti-Ds to determine D antigen densities of 7 normal D, 4 partial D, and 11 weak D type samples, including 2 novel alleles.

RESULTS

The reproducibility of the updated assay was evaluated with red cells of published D antigen densities. The current results matched the known ones closely. The new weak D types 164 and 165 carried 4500 and 1505 D antigens/red cell, respectively. The absolute D antigen density decreased from 27,231 to 26,037 in an individual over 19 years.

DISCUSSION

The updated assay gave highly reproducible results for the D antigen densities of Rh phenotypes. Readily available anti-Ds allowed for the determination of the D antigen densities of 7 weak D types. The assay is suitable to evaluate the effects of distinct amino acid substitutions on the RhD phenotype.

Single molecule distribution of RhD binding epitopes on ultraflat erythrocyte ghosts

The Rh blood group system plays a key role in transfusion and organ transplant medicine. The complex transmembrane Rh polypeptides RhD and RhCE carry numerous antigens, including the extremely immunogenic D antigen. The Rh polypeptides form multimolecular Rh complexes with certain transmembrane and skeletal proteins, with so far only incompletely understood physiological functions. Determination of the energy landscape of individual Rh binding epitopes towards their specific interaction partners as well as their localization across the red blood cell (RBC) membrane requires single molecule approaches including large area high resolution recognition imaging. Atomic force microscopy based molecular recognition force spectroscopy in combination with single molecule recognition imaging fulfills these requirements. For unbiased single molecule results, nano-mechanical influences due to cell elasticity have to be eliminated. This is realized by generation of ultra flat erythrocyte ghosts on a solid support. We developed a protocol for the preparation of complete ultraflat erythrocyte ghosts and determined the molecular binding behaviour of different anti-D antibodies towards their binding epitopes on RhD positive and negative erythrocytes. Performing optimized topography and recognition imaging at 16 Mpixel resolution allowed localisation of individual RhD molecules at the single molecule level across an entire RBC. A map of Rh antigens across integer ultraflat RBC ghosts was generated with nanometer resolution. Here we show a homogeneous distribution on rim and dimple regions with comparable receptor densities. Furthermore, differences in the energy landscape between specific monoclonal antibodies were determined at the single molecule level.

Severe hemolytic disease of the fetus and newborn due to allo-anti-D in a patient with a partial DEL phenotype arising from the variant allele described as RHD*148+1T (RHD*01EL.31)

BACKGROUND

RhD DEL variants may show complete or partial expression of RhD epitopes. There have been only rare reports of anti-D causing hemolytic disease of the fetus and newborn (HDFN) in this context. We report a case of severe HDFN associated with a recently described DEL variant.

CASE REPORT

A multiparous woman presented with an allo-anti-D and showed incongruent phenotyping and genotyping results on initial study. Further investigations identified the RHD mutation, defined as RHD*148+1T and named RHD*01EL.31, which had been previously associated with a DEL phenotype. Extended RhD phenotyping by adsorption-elution showed that there was reactivity with four of nine monoclonal anti-D antibodies, suggesting a partial DEL phenotype. The first child showed no clinical evidence of HDFN, although the cord direct antiglobulin test was positive. The second child developed fetal anemia treated with intrauterine transfusion, and neonatal hyperbilirubinemia requiring exchange transfusion.

CONCLUSION

The RHD allele, RHD*148+1T, results in a partial Del phenotype, and the anti-D formed in pregnant women with this phenotype is capable of causing severe HDFN.

[Molecular serological characteristics of weak D antigen types of the Rhesus system]

AIM

to estimate the spread of weak D antigen types of the Rhesus system in the citizens of the Russian Federation and a possibility of serologically identifying these types.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

The red blood cells and DNA of people with weakened expression of D antigen were investigated using erythrocyte agglutination reaction in salt medium (2 methods); agglutination reaction in the gel columns containing IgM + IgG anti-D antibodies, indirect antiglobulin test with IgG anti-D antibodies (2 methods); polymerase chain reaction to establish the type of weak D.

RESULTS

A rhesus phenotype was determined in 5100 people in 2014-2015. The weakened agglutinable properties of red blood cells were detected in 102 (2%) examinees. 63 examinees underwent genotyping to identify the variants of the weak D antigen, which identified 6 weak D types. There were the most common weak D types 3 (n=31 (49.2%)) and weak D type 1 (n=18 (28.6%)), including weak D type 1.1 in one (1.6%) case. The other 4 weak D antigen types were as follows: weak D type 2 (14.3% (n=9)), weak D type 15 (4.8% (n=3)), weak D type 4.2 (DAR) (1.6% (n=1)) and weak D type 6 (1.6% (n=1)). The antiglobulin test in the gel column containing antiglobulin serum was the most sensitive serological assay to identify the weak D antigen. Only a molecular test could establish weak D type 15 in 2 samples of red blood cells with Ccdee and ccdEe phenotypes.

CONCLUSION

The weak D antigen could be serologically identified in 96.8% of cases. When testing for weak D, particular attention should be given to people with the D-negative phenotype who had the C or E antigens. Our investigations conducted for the first time in Russia will be able to improve the immunological safety of red blood cell-containing medium transfusions for patients.

The RHD(1227G>A) DEL-associated allele is the most prevalent DEL allele in Australian D- blood donors with C+ and/or E+ phenotypes

BACKGROUND

Red blood cells (RBCs) with D antigen levels only detected by anti-D adsorption-elution and an antiglobulin test express a DEL phenotype. For two DEL types, including RHD(1227G>A), immunization of D- recipients has been reported. This study's aim was to measure the prevalence of DEL-associated RHD alleles in a cohort of Australian D- donors to develop a model to estimate alloimmunization risk.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

D-, C+ and/or E+ blood donors were screened for RHD exons using quantitative polymerase chain reaction. Donors with RHD signals were DEL phenotyped with MCAD6 anti-D. RHD alleles were characterized via single-nucleotide polymorphism array or sequencing. Extended DEL phenotyping was performed with an anti-D panel.

RESULTS

Among 2027 donors, 39 carried RHD alleles that have been previously reported to associate with either the DEL or the weak D phenotype. An additional five donors carried previously unreported RHD alleles and exhibited the DEL phenotype: RHD(IVS2-2delA), RHD(IVS1+5G>C), RHD(ex9:del/CE), and RHD(ex8:del/CE) represented twice. In total, DEL/weak D-associated RHD alleles were detected in 44 of 2027 donors or 2.17% (95% confidence interval, 1.54%-2.81%). The RHD(1227G>A) DEL allele was the most frequent (n = 16). The risk of transfusing D- females not more than 40 years of age with an RHD(1227G>A) DEL RBC unit (when managed as D-) is estimated to be one in 149,109 transfusions (range, 100,680-294,490).

CONCLUSION

DEL/weak D-associated RHD alleles were found in 2.17% of Australian D-, C+ and/or E+ blood donors. This differs from previous European reports in that the clinically significant RHD(1227G>A) DEL allele is the most prevalent.

Analysis of density and epitopes of D antigen on the surface of erythrocytes from DEL phenotypic individuals carrying the RHD1227A allele

BACKGROUND

The characteristics of the D antigen are important as they influence the immunogenicity of D variant cells. Several studies on antigenic sites have been reported in normal D positive, weak D and partial D cases, including a comprehensive analysis of DEL types in Caucasians. The aim of this study was to assess D antigen density and epitopes on the erythrocyte surface of Asian type DEL phenotypic individuals carrying the RHD1227A allele in the Chinese population.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of 154 DEL phenotypic individuals carrying the RHD1227A allele were identified through adsorption and elution tests and polymerase chain reaction analysis with sequence-specific primers in the Chinese population. D antigen density on the erythrocyte surface of these individuals was detected using a flow cytometric method. An erythrocyte sample with known D antigen density was used as a standard. Blood samples from D-negative and D-positive individuals were used as controls. In addition, D antigen epitopes on the erythrocyte surface of DEL individuals carrying the RHD1227A allele were investigated with 18 monoclonal anti-D antibodies specific for different D antigen epitopes.

RESULTS

The means of the median fluorescence intensity of D antigen on the erythrocyte membrane surface of D-negative, D-positive and DEL individuals were 2.14±0.25, 193.61±11.43 and 2.45±0.82, respectively. The DEL samples were estimated to have approximately 22 D antigens per cell. The samples from all 154 DEL individuals reacted positively with 18 monoclonal anti-D antibodies specific for different D antigen epitopes.

DISCUSSION

In this study, D antigen density on the erythrocyte surface of DEL individuals carrying the RHD1227A allele was extremely low, there being only very few antigenic molecules per cell, but the D antigen epitopes were grossly complete.

Mice expressing RHAG and RHD human blood group genes

Anti-RhD prophylaxis of haemolytic disease of the fetus and newborn (HDFN) is highly effective, but as the suppressive mechanism remains uncertain, a mouse model would be of interest. Here we have generated transgenic mice expressing human RhAG and RhD erythrocyte membrane proteins in the presence and, for human RhAG, in the absence, of mouse Rhag. Human RhAG associates with mouse Rh but not mouse Rhag on red blood cells. In Rhag knockout mice transgenic for human RHAG, the mouse Rh protein is “rescued” (re-expressed), and co-immunoprecipitates with human RhAG, indicating the presence of hetero-complexes which associate mouse and human proteins. RhD antigen was expressed from a human RHD gene on a BAC or from RHD cDNA under control of β-globin regulatory elements. RhD was never observed alone, strongly indicative that its expression absolutely depends on the presence of transgenic human RhAG. This first expression of RhD in mice is an important step in the creation of a mouse model of RhD allo-immunisation and HDFN, in conjunction with the Rh-Rhag knockout mice we have developed previously.

Serologic and molecular investigations of DAR1 (weak D Type 4.2), DAR1.2, DAR1.3, DAR2 (DARE), and DARA

BACKGROUND

The partial D variant DAR1 (weak D Type 4.2) is caused by three single-point mutations, 602C>G, 667T>G, and 1025T>C. Here we report a molecular study on different D variants belonging to the DAR category (DAR1, DAR1.2, DAR1.3, and DAR2) and their serologic data.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

A total of 42 samples belonging to the DAR category were screened for the presence of the silent mutations 744C>T and 957G>A. The samples were phenotyped for RhD and RhCE, characterized for RhD epitope expression, and sequenced for RHD exons. Flow cytometry was performed to determine RhD antigen density.

RESULTS

The silent mutation 744C>T was found in all six samples previously typed as RHD*DAR2 (602C>G, 667T>G, 957G>A, 1025T>C). In addition to the three nucleotide changes originally reported for the RHD*DAR1 allele, the silent mutations 744C>T and 957G>A were found in 14 of 16 samples previously typed as RHD*DAR1. In the remaining two samples one additional silent mutation, 744C>T, was found. Serologically the DAR1.2 and DAR1.3 samples analyzed in this study showed no distinct difference in their anti-D reaction pattern compared to each other. The anti-D reaction pattern of DARA/DAR2 showed some distinct differences compared to those of DAR1.2 and DAR1.3.

CONCLUSION

RHD*DARA and RHD*DAR2 are the same allele. Furthermore, the alleles RHD*DAR1.2 and RHD*DAR1.3 both exist; however, the silent mutation 957G>A (V319) showed no influence on the RhD phenotype.

Novel RHD alleles with weak hemagglutination and genetic Exon 9 diversity: weak D Types 45.1, 75, and 76

BACKGROUND

Molecular variant RHD allele analysis is best complemented by detailed characterization of the associated D phenotype.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

Variant D types were characterized using molecular typing, RHD sequencing, extended serologic D antigen investigations, and flow cytometric D antigen quantification.

RESULTS

We discovered three novel weak D types termed weak D Types 45.1, 75, and 76 with RHD nucleotide substitutions coding for amino acid exchanges in predicted intracellular RhD polypeptide stretches; antigen densities of approximately 1.990, 900, and 240 D sites per red blood cell were found, respectively. Adsorption-elution technique-supported D epitope mapping of these three weak D types demonstrated the expression of all tested D epitopes. Initial molecular typing of the three investigated samples by RHD gene exon scanning polymerase chain reaction using sequence-specific priming yielded a negative reaction for A1193 located in RHD Exon 9 and could be explained by specific mutations for weak D Types 45.1 (C818T, G1195A), 75 (G1194C), and 76 (A1215C).

CONCLUSION

All novel weak D types expressed all tested D epitopes. It is of interest that for weak D Types 45.1, 75, and 76, similar alleles with a maximal divergence of one amino acid only, that is, weak D Types 45, 41, and 68, respectively, have been reported so far.

RHCE*ceTI encodes partial c and partial e and is often in cis to RHD*DIVa

BACKGROUND

In the Rh blood group system, variant RhD and RhCE express several partial antigens. We investigated RH in samples with partial DIVa that demonstrated weak and variable reactivity with anti-C.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

Standard hemagglutination techniques, polymerase chain reaction-based assays, and RH sequencing were used.

RESULTS

DNA analysis showed that six red blood cell (RBC) samples with weak and inconsistent reactivity with anti-C lacked RHCE*C, but all had RHD*DIVa, which encodes partial D and Go(a) . We then tested RBCs from 19 Go(a+) cryopreserved samples (confirmed to have RHD*DIVa) with four anti-C and observed weak variable reactions. RHCE genotyping found all but one of the samples with RHD*DIVa also had RHCE nt 48G>C and 1025C>T, named RHCE*ceTI. Lookback of samples referred for workup and found to have either allele revealed 47 of 55 had both RHD*DIVa and RHCE*ceTI, four had RHD*DIVa without RHCE*ceTI, and four had RHCE*ceTI without RHD*DIVa. Alloanti-c was found in a patient with c+ RBCs and RHCE*ceTI in trans to RHCE*Ce, and alloanti-e was found in a patient with e+ RBC and RHCE*ceTI in trans to RHCE*cE. RHD*DIVa in trans to RHD erroneously tested as RHD hemizygous.

CONCLUSIONS

RHD*DIVa and RHCE*ceTI almost always, but not invariably, travel together. This haplotype is found in people of African ancestry and the RBCs can demonstrate aberrant reactivity with anti-C. RHCE*ceTI encodes partial c and e antigens. We confirm that RHD zygosity assays are unreliable in samples with RHD*DIVa.

D category IV: a group of clinically relevant and phylogenetically diverse partial D

BACKGROUND

The D typing strategies in several European countries protect carriers of D category VI (DVI) from anti-D immunization but not carriers of other partial D. Besides DVI, one of the clinically most important partial D is D category IV (DIV). A detailed description and direct comparison of the different DIV types was missing.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

RHD nucleotide sequences were determined from genomic DNA. D epitope patterns were established with commercial monoclonal anti-D panels.

RESULTS

DIV comprises several variants of the D antigen with distinct serology, molecular structures, evolutionary origins, and ethnic prevalences. The DIV phenotype is determined by 350H shared by all, but not limited to, DIV variants which are further divided into DIVa and DIVb. The DIVa phenotype is expressed by DIV Type 1.0 harboring 350H and the dispersed amino acids 62F, 137V, and 152T. The DIVb phenotype is expressed by DIV Type 3 to Type 5 representing RHD-CE-D hybrids. Four of the six postulated DIV variants were encountered among 23 DIV samples analyzed. Of 12 DIV carriers with anti-D, 10 were female and seven likely immunized by pregnancy. Two DIV-related alleles are newly described: DWN, which differs from DIV Type 4 by 350D and epitope pattern. DNT carries 152T, known to cause a large D antigen density.

CONCLUSION

DIV alleles arose from at least two independent evolutionary events. DIV Type 1.0 with DIVa phenotype belongs to the oldest extant human RHD alleles. DIV Type 2 to Type 5 with DIVb phenotype arose from more recent gene conversions. Anti-D immunization, especially dreaded in pregnancies, will be avoided not only in carriers of DVI but also in carriers of other D variants like DIV, if our proposed D typing strategy is adopted.

Postpartum Rh immunoprophylaxis

The postpartum dose of Rh immune globulin varies according to an individual laboratory estimation of fetal red blood cells in each mother's peripheral blood. In the United States, a four-step procedure determines the postpartum dose (number of vials of 300 micrograms; 1,500 international units) of Rh immune globulin (anti-D) for each RhD-negative mother who has delivered an RhD-positive newborn and has not already formed anti-D. The first step is a rosette fetal red blood cell screen to determine whether an excessive (greater than 30 mL fetal whole blood) fetomaternal hemorrhage occurred. If the rosette screen is negative, the mother receives one vial of Rh immune globulin for Rh immunoprophylaxis. If the rosette screen is positive, the blood sample is retested by a quantitative method, typically an acid-elution (Kleihauer-Betke) assay. The result of the acid-elution assay is converted to an estimation of the volume of the fetomaternal hemorrhage, which is the basis for calculating the dose of Rh immune globulin. The acid-elution assay is subjective, imprecise, and poorly reproducible. As a result, the formula for calculating the dose includes a precautionary adjustment, adding an extra vial in borderline situations to prevent underdosing. Flow cytometry is a more precise method for quantifying a fetomaternal hemorrhage. However, few hospitals use flow cytometry, because it is not cost-effective to maintain an expensive, high-technology laboratory service for the relatively few occasions when a precise quantitative determination of fetomaternal hemorrhage is required.

RHCE*ceCF encodes partial c and partial e but not CELO, an antigen antithetical to Crawford

BACKGROUND

RH43 (Crawford) is encoded by RHCE*ce with nucleotide changes 48G>C, 697C>G, and 733C>G (RHCE*ceCF). We investigated the Rh antigen expression and antibody specificities in four patients with this allele.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

Hemagglutination tests, DNA extraction, polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-restriction fragment length polymorphism, allele-specific PCR, reticulocyte RNA isolation, reverse transcription-PCR cDNA analyses, cloning, and sequencing were performed by standard procedures.

RESULTS

Red blood cells (RBCs) from two patients typed D+C-E-c+e+/-, hrS-/+W, hrB- and their serum was reactive (3+) with all RBC samples of common Rh phenotype tested, but nonreactive with Rhnull or D-- RBCs (apparent alloanti-Rh17). At the RHCE locus, Patient 1 was homozygous for RHCE*ceCF, and Patient 2 inherited RHCE*ceCF in trans to a silenced RHCE*cE. Cross-testing of serum and RBCs from these two samples showed mutual compatibility, indicating that both antibodies define the same novel high-prevalence antigen on Rhce. Two additional patients, one whose serum contained alloanti-c but the RBCs typed C+c+ and one whose serum contained anti-e but the RBCs typed E+e+, also had RHCE*ceCF. RHCE*Ce was present in trans in the former and RHCE*cE in the latter patient.

CONCLUSION

We report that amino acid changes on RhceCF (Trp16Cys, Gln233Glu, and Leu245Val) alter the protein to the extent that c and e antigens are partial, and a high-prevalence antigen, we have named CELO (provisional ISBT Number 004058; RH58) is not expressed. CELO is antithetical to RH43 (Crawford).

D variants at the RhD vestibule in the weak D type 4 and Eurasian D clusters

BACKGROUND

One branch of the RHD phylogenetic tree is represented by the weak D type 4 cluster of alleles with F223V as the primordial amino acid substitution. F223V as well as a large number of further substitutions causing D variants are located at the extracellular RhD protein vestibule, which represents the entrance to the transmembraneous channel of the RhD protein.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

RHD and RHCE nucleotide sequences were determined from genomic DNA and cDNA. D epitope patterns were established with commercial monoclonal anti-D panels.

RESULTS

The RHD alleles DOL-1 and DOL-2 had the two amino acid substitutions M170T (509T>C) and F223V (667T>G) in common. DOL-2 harbored the additional substitution L378V (1132C>G). Both alleles were observed in Africans and are probably evolutionary related. DMI carried M170I (510G>A), which differed from the DOL-typical substitution. DFW and DFL harbored the substitutions H166P (497A>C) and Y165C (494A>G). The antigen densities of DOL-1, DFL, and DFW were only moderately reduced.

CONCLUSION

DOL-1 and DOL-2 belong to the weak D type 4 cluster of RHD alleles. Together with DMI, DFL, and DFW they represent D variants with amino acid substitutions located at extracellular loops 3 or 4 lining the RhD protein vestibule. These substitutions were of minor influence on antigen density while adjacent substitutions in the transmembraneous section caused weak D antigen expression. All these D variants were partial D and alloanti-D immunizations have been observed in DOL-1, DMI, and DFL carriers. The substitution at position 170 causes partial D although located deep in the vestibule.

Characterization of anti-D monoclonal antibody reagents based on their reactivity with the weak D phenotype

BACKGROUND

Anti-D monoclonal antibody (MoAb) reagents have improved D typing in routine tests. However, they exhibit a wide range of reactivity with the weak D phenotype depending on the characteristics of the different MoAbs used. We analyzed the reactivity of immunoglobulin (IgM) anti-D by cluster analysis to characterize MoAb that have similar reactivities with the weak D phenotype.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

We used 36 consecutive samples with weak D phenotype in routine testing and determined their reactivity with different IgM and IgG anti-D MoAbs. The samples were characterized as belonging to a weak D type or category using commercial molecular biology kits.

RESULTS

The various anti-D MoAbs showed a wide grade of reactivity with the weak D samples. Similarities and dissimilarities in the behavior of the anti-D MoAbs with the weak D phenotype samples were detected with cluster analysis and the multidimensional scaling analysis. These analyses indicated different families of MoAbs characterized as having a high degree of homogeneity in their reactivity with the weak D phenotype. Between these MoAb families, the most effective at reacting with the weak D phenotype were RUM-1 and 175-2.

CONCLUSIONS

The results show that it is possible to classify the anti-D MoAbs on the basis of their reactivity with the weak D phenotype. This provides information about different MoAbs' properties on the basis of their belonging to a given of anti-D family.

Large-scale blood group genotyping: clinical implications

The molecular background of blood group antigen expression of the major clinically significant blood group antigens has been largely accomplished. Despite this large body of work, blood group phenotype prediction by genotyping has a marginal supporting role in the routine blood bank. It has however had a major impact in the prenatal determination of fetal blood group status in the management of haemolytic disease of the fetus and newborn. In the past few years several high throughput systems have been in development that have the potential capacity to perform genotyping on a mass scale. Such systems have been designed for use on donor- and patient-derived DNA and provide much more comprehensive information regarding an individuals blood group than is possible by using serological methods alone. DNA-based typing methodology is easier to standardize than serology and has the potential to replace it as a front line diagnostic in blood banks. This review overviews the current situation in this area and attempts to predict how blood group genotyping will evolve in the future.

DCS-1, DCS-2, and DFV share amino acid substitutions at the extracellular RhD protein vestibule

BACKGROUND

RhD and RhCE are structurally related to ammonium transporter proteins, yet their physiologic function remains unclear. Recent three-dimensional homology modeling with Escherichia coli AmtB as a template defined a putative transmembraneous channel. Three RhD variants with amino acid substitutions located at the extracellular channel aperture are described.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

Blood samples were selected because of serologic abnormalities. RHD, RHCE, and LW nucleotide sequences were determined from genomic DNA. D epitope patterns were established with monoclonal anti-D panels. Three-dimensional Rh structures were calculated by alignment to AmtB.

RESULTS

The RHD allele DCS-1 was found to carry the two amino acid substitutions F223V (667T > G) and A226P (676G > C) caused by missense mutations in RHD exon 5. This study compared DCS-1 with the D variants DFV (F223V) and DCS-2 (A226P), harboring solely one or the other of the two substitutions. All three D variants were associated with a cDE haplotype. The antigen densities were approximately 3,000 D antigens per red blood cell for DCS-1, 800 for DCS-2, and 9,300 for DFV. DCS-1 and DCS-2 were partial D, because they lacked distinct epitopes. DFV presented as an almost normal D phenotype; the sample contained allo-anti-LW(a). The D(w) antigen was absent from DCS-1, DFV, and DAU-4, but expressed by DAU-5.

CONCLUSION

DCS-1, DCS-2, and DFV carry amino acid substitutions at the extracellular vestibule, visualized by 3-dimensional modeling. Proline at position 226 greatly influenced the D antigen density and may reduce the RhD membrane integration. Although the F223V substitution is regarded as the initial event in the evolution of the weak D Type 4 cluster, the current DFV allele probably evolved independently, as evident from different RHCE haplotypes.

Mosaicism due to myeloid lineage–restricted loss of heterozygosity as cause of spontaneous Rh phenotype splitting

Spontaneous Rh phenotype alteration interferes with pretransfusion and prenatal blood group examinations and may potentially indicate hematologic disease. In this study, the molecular background of this biologic phenomenon was investigated. In 9 patients (3 with hematologic disease), routine RhD typing showed a mixture of D-positive and D-negative red cells not attributable to transfusion or hematopoietic stem-cell transplantation. In all patients, congenital and acquired chimerism was excluded by microsatellite analysis. In contrast to D-positive red cells, D-negative subpopulations were also negative for C or E in patients genotyped CcDdee or ccDdEe, respectively, which suggested the presence of erythrocyte precursors with an apparent homozygous cde/cde or hemizygous cde/— genotype. Except for one patient with additional Fyb antigen anomaly, no other blood group systems were affected. RH genotyping of single erythropoietic burst-forming units, combined with microsatellite analysis of blood, different tissues, sorted blood cell subsets, and erythropoietic burst-forming units, indicated myeloid lineage–restricted loss of heterozygosity (LOH) of variable chromosome 1 stretches encompassing the RHD/RHCE gene loci. Fluorescent in situ hybridization studies indicated that LOH was caused by either somatic recombination or deletion. Therefore, most cases of spontaneous Rh phenotype splitting appear to be due to hematopoietic mosaicism based on LOH on chromosome 1.

In-frame triplet deletions in RHD alter the D antigen phenotype

BACKGROUND

The deletion of three adjacent nucleotides in an exon may cause the lack of a single amino acid, while the protein sequence remains otherwise unchanged. Only one such in-frame deletion is known in the two RH genes, represented by the RHCE allele ceBP expressing a "very weak e antigen."

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

Blood donor samples were recognized because of discrepant results of D phenotyping. Six samples came from Switzerland and one from Northern Germany. The molecular structures were determined by genomic DNA nucleotide sequencing of RHD.

RESULTS

Two different variant D antigens were explained by RHD alleles harboring one in-frame triplet deletion each. Both single-amino-acid deletions led to partial D phenotypes with weak D antigen expression. Because of their D category V-like phenotypes, the RHD(Arg229del) allele was dubbed DVL-1 and the RHD(Lys235del) allele DVL-2. These in-frame triplet deletions are located in GAGAA or GAAGA repeats of the RHD exon 5.

CONCLUSION

Partial D may be caused by a single-amino-acid deletion in RhD. The altered RhD protein segments in DVL types are adjacent to the extracellular loop 4, which constitutes one of the most immunogenic parts of the D antigen. These RhD protein segments are also altered in all DV, which may explain the similarity in phenotype. At the nucleotide level, the triplet deletions may have resulted from replication slippage. A total of nine amino acid positions in an Rhesus protein may be affected by this mechanism.

The RHCE allele ceCF: the molecular basis of Crawford (RH43)

BACKGROUND

The Crawford antigen (RH43) was described in 1980. It occurred in African American people, as a low-prevalence Rhesus antigen, who were also VS+.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

Twelve blood samples were analyzed because of inquiries into discrepant reactions in routine anti-D typing. The RHCE alleles were determined by nucleotide sequencing from genomic DNA. The D epitope profile was determined with 60 monoclonal anti-D. The population frequency was estimated in four major US regional blood centers.

RESULTS

The novel RHce(W16C, Q233E, L245V) allele, dubbed ceCF, was found to be occurring in the cde haplotype as cause of the reactivity with the immunoglobulin M anti-D GAMA401. The ceCF phenotype expressed few D epitopes resembling but not matching the reaction patterns observed with other RhCE variants, like R0 (Har), ceRT, and ceSL. The frequency of the ceCF phenotype was 0.056 percent among African American persons and 0.007 percent in the general US population.

CONCLUSION

The novel RHce(W16C, Q233E, L245V) allele, which is a variant of the known ce(s) allele, RHce(W16C, L245V), occurs in a haplotype with the RHD deletion and represents the molecular basis of the Crawford antigen.

Outliers in RhD membrane integration are explained by variant RH haplotypes

BACKGROUND

Variations in a multipass transmembrane protein may affect its membrane integration. To study this effect, the systematic molecular characterization of variant D antigen density is a suitable model. Unlike most other membrane proteins, the expression of the D antigen is often determined by a single allele, because it occurs frequently in hemizygous form.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

The D antigen density distribution of 530 CcDee, 475 ccDEe, and 514 ccDee random samples was established by flow cytometry. The molecular bases of samples with D antigen densities outside a bell-shaped peak was investigated.

RESULTS

The antigen densities of 499 CcDee, 437 ccDEe, and 480 ccDee samples formed bell-shaped peaks. Three, 10, and 12 samples, respectively, had decreased antigen densities and carried variant RHD alleles. Weak D type 19, RHD(I204T); weak D type 20, RHD(F417S); and the partial D DYU (also known as DQC), RHD(R234W) were new RHD alleles. Twenty-eight CcDee, 28 ccDEe, and 22 ccDee samples had increased antigen densities; 53 of them lacked a hybrid Rhesus box and were thus predicted to be RHD homozygous. Eight ccDee samples were predicted to be heterozygous despite a large relative dose of RHD to RHCE alleles in quantitative polymerase chain reaction. One of these samples was further investigated and carried an RHD-CE hybrid transcript characteristic for a -D- haplotype.

CONCLUSIONS

Unusual little and large RhD protein integration into the membrane could be traced to a host of distinct protein variants. Weak expression of D antigen was invariably associated with variant RHD alleles. Larger than normal D antigen density may often be caused by the presence of two D encoding alleles, which may be located in cis, and confounding zygosity testing that is solely based on gene copy number.

The D category VI type 4 allele is prevalent in the Spanish population

BACKGROUND

The D category VI (DVI) is one of the clinically most important partial D. Three different molecular structures causing the DVI phenotype have been described.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

To determine the molecular basis of the DVI phenotype in the Spanish population, 20 DVI samples, previously detected in serologic screening, were examined by polymerase chain reaction with RHD exon-specific primers. Unexpected findings were further pursued by cDNA nucleotide sequencing.

RESULTS

A novel pattern of RHD exon amplification was detected, which did not correspond to any of the previously described molecular structures. The cDNA sequence led to the identification of the new hybrid RHD-Ce(3-5)-D allele. The origin of exon 2 is undeterminable, because the 5' breakpoint was located within a region of RHD and RHCE identical sequence, which encompasses this exon. Sequencing of intron 5 allowed the 3' breakpoint to be mapped between the sixth and seventh polymorphic sites. Serologically, the hybrid protein has a D epitope expression pattern identical to the previously described DVI phenotypes and an antigen density slightly lower than DVI type 3. The new DVI variant is linked to the DCe haplotype and expresses the low-incidence BARC antigen.

CONCLUSION

A novel structure causing the DVI phenotype, here named DVI type 4, has been characterized. This novel structure is the most frequent cause of DVI in Spain.

RHD(T201R, F223V) cluster analysis in five different ethnic groups and serologic characterization of a new Ethiopian variant DARE, the DIII type 6, and the RHD(F223V)

BACKGROUND

The RHD phylogeny in humans shows four main clusters of which three are predominantly observed in (African) black persons. Each of the African clusters is characterized by specific amino acid substitutions relative to the Eurasian RHD allele. RH phylogeny defines the framework for identification of clinically relevant aberrant alleles. This study focuses on the weak D type 4 cluster (characterized by RHD(T201R, F223V) (602C>G 667T>G)) in five ethnic groups.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

A total of 1702 samples were screened for the presence of 602C>G and 667T>G by sequence-specific polymerase chain reaction (PCR-SSP). Eighty samples were assigned to the weak D type 4 cluster and were molecularly characterized by PCR-SSP and RHD sequencing. Antigens of aberrant alleles were characterized with monoclonal anti-D according to the 37-epitope model when possible.

RESULTS

Five new aberrant alleles, DIII type 6, DIII type 7, DARE, RHD(T201R, F223V) (without 819G>A), and RHD(F223V), were identified and DIII type 6, DARE, and RHD(F223V) were serologically characterized with monoclonal anti-D. Both the DARE and RHD(F223V) showed epitope loss. It is postulated that the 1136C>T nucleotide substitution (characteristic for the DAU allele cluster) is present on the DVa(KOU) allele.

CONCLUSION

Identification of the new variant alleles refines the phylogeny of RHD in humans. The proposed DVa(KOU) allele with 1136C>T (DVa(KOU)T379M) is probably caused by conversion of the DAU0 allele and the DVa(KOU) allele, forming a phylogenetic link between the DV allele and the DAU cluster. By describing the RHD(F223V) (602C>G) and RHD(T201R, F223V) (602C>G and 667T>G) alleles formal proof is given for the origin of the non-Eurasian cluster.

The RHCE allele ceSL: the second example for D antigen expression without D-specific amino acids

BACKGROUND

The example of ceRT proved that the expression of some D epitopes does not require D-specific amino acids. This allele denoted as RHce(R154T) caused the "false-positive" reactions that were observed in ccddee blood donors who typed positive for the D antigen with some monoclonal anti-D. No other example exposing a similar molecular mechanism was known.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

Eleven donor and 1 patient ccddee samples were collected in Switzerland that typed "false-positive" with some monoclonal anti-D in bromelain technique. Their RHCE alleles were determined by nucleotide sequencing from genomic DNA and by a polymerase chain reaction with sequence-specific priming. The D epitope profile was compared to ceRT. The population frequencies were estimated in Switzerland and Germany by serology or at the molecular level, respectively.

RESULTS

The "false-positive" reactions were caused by the RHCE allele RHce(S122L) occurring in the cde haplotype. Its ceSL phenotype expressed few D epitopes that belonged to the D epitope 6 group. The frequency of ceSL among D- donors was about 1:675 in the region of Bern, Switzerland. No ceSL donors were found elsewhere in Switzerland or in southwestern Germany.

CONCLUSION

ceSL represented the second molecular mechanism for D antigen expression without any D-specific amino acids. ceSL and ceRT were useful to delineate the molecular mechanisms of D expression by RhCE proteins carrying amino acids not representative for the RhD proteins. The ceSL population frequencies differed significantly among three Swiss and German populations.

A comprehensive analysis of DEL types: partial DEL individuals are prone to anti-D alloimmunization

BACKGROUND

The D antigen of the polymorphic Rh blood group system is of particular clinical importance regarding transfusion- and pregnancy-induced alloimmunization. Different RhD variants with specific clinical implications have been characterized. The least expressed D variants collectively called DEL are serologically detectable only by adsorption-elution techniques, with so far only poorly defined antigenic properties.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

A comprehensive immunohematologic analysis of five of the six currently known DEL genotypes was performed. DEL phenotypes associated with the RHD(M295I), RHD(IVS3+1g>a), RHD(K409K), RHD(X418L), or RHD(IVS5-38del4) allele were characterized with extended serology and flow cytometry.

RESULTS

Epitope mapping with adsorption-elution revealed a prominent D epitope loss in the RHD(IVS3+1g>a)-associated DEL phenotype, whereas in the other four DEL types no signs of qualitative D antigen alteration were detected. The observation of alloanti-D in two RHD(IVS3+1g>a) cases confirmed the partial nature of this DEL phenotype. The RHD(M295I) phenotype exhibited the highest D antigen expression among all investigated DEL types, as determined by a semiquantitative adsorption-elution approach and flow cytometry.

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, evidence is provided that different DEL genotypes code either for partial or complete D antigen expression and that this finding is clinically relevant.

Novel weak D types 31 and 32: adsorption-elution-supported D antigen analysis and comparison to prevalent weak D types

BACKGROUND

Weak D types are thought to express rather quantitative than qualitative D antigen variants. Distinct type-specific phenotypes and weak D cases with anti-D alloimmunization, however, suggest a variable degree of D antigen alteration.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

Variant D types were investigated by use of molecular typing, RHD sequencing, extended serologic D antigen investigations, and flow cytometric D antigen density determination.

RESULTS

Two novel weak D types were discovered, termed weak D type 31 and 32 with single RHD nucleotide substitutions coding for amino acid exchanges in predicted intracellular RhD polypeptide stretches, with antigen densities of approximately 130 and 50 D sites per red blood cell, respectively. Adsorption-elution technique-supported D epitope mapping of these two weak D types, the recently described weak D type 26, and of the most common Central European weak D types (weak D types 1, 2, 3, 4.0, and 4.1) demonstrated the expression of all tested D epitopes. In contrast, a distinct D epitope loss was detected in weak D type 15 and partial D control samples.

CONCLUSION

All novel and prevalent weak D types expressed all tested D epitopes. Our results indicate that adsorption-elution techniques may be of advantage whenever D epitope loss is suspected in extremely weak D variants.

Anti-D immunization by DEL red blood cells

BACKGROUND

No data are available on the immunogenicity of extremely weak D variants called DEL. Evaluation of alloanti-D formation in a D- female patient after transfusion of apparently D- blood from an Austrian donor led to discovery of a so far unknown DEL type.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

Standard blood group serologic methods were applied. Molecular typing, RHD sequencing, and D epitope mapping was performed and the absolute D antigen density determined.

RESULTS

After transfusion of RBCs typed D- by routine serology, the recipient developed alloanti-D. Further evaluation with an indirect antiglobulin test confirmed donor RBCs to be D-. Molecular typing, however, demonstrated the presence of the RHD gene in one donor, and RHD sequencing revealed a deletion of four nucleotides in RHD intron 5 (RHD IVS5-38del4) as the only difference compared to the normal RHD gene. Adsorption-elution techniques demonstrated a DEL phenotype without apparent loss of D epitopes.

CONCLUSION

This study documents the clinical significance of the DEL phenotype in blood units that was capable of inducing anti-D in a recipient. Qualitative data are provided on D epitope expression in DEL RBCs.

Detection of weak D with a fully automated solid-phase red cell adherence system

BACKGROUND

Microplate agglutination methods (MAMs) and column agglutination technology are widely employed for red cell typing and can be automated. Some tests, however, such as detection of weak D, require manual testing. The possibility of detecting weak D by a solid-phase RBC adherence (SPRCA) test was studied in a fully automated system.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

The results of 2609 blood samples, characterized as being D- or with a incomplete agglutination reaction, were analyzed for the presence of the weak D phenotype. The 2609 samples were tested by a weak D tube test (antiglobulin method) and a weak D-test with the new SPRCA method. When weak D was detected, which D epitope was involved and whether it was associated with a partial D phenotype were determined.

RESULTS

Weak D was detected in 60 (2.3%) of the 2609 samples. The 60 samples that were weak D by the tube test were also weak D+ with the new automated SPRCA test. The sensitivity and specificity for the new weak D typing method were 100 percent, when compared with the standard weak D manual test.

CONCLUSIONS

These results support the possibility of performing weak D detection with a SPRCA fully automated system. These preliminary results are encouraging, showing good sensitivity and specificity of the test. Detection of weak D will permit full automation of blood typing.

Measurement of anti-D intrinsic affinity with unlabeled antibodies

BACKGROUND

The method most commonly used for measuring the affinity of MoAbs specific for the D antigen is a binding assay using 125I-labeled MoAb. Although the method is relatively simple, there are several drawbacks that can lead to inaccurate results. The objective of the present work was to develop a method for the determination of the affinity of anti-D MoAb using unlabelled antibodies.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

Rh-positive RBCs were sensitized with varying amounts of unlabeled anti-D MoAb, and, at equilibrium, the amount of anti-D bound to the RBCs was measured by ELISA. The affinity and the number of antigenic sites were determined with the Scatchard and Langmuir equations.

RESULTS

The method was applied to determine the affinity of several MoAbs specific for the D antigen on RBCs of different Rh-positive phenotypes. Similar results were observed with both equations. The affinity constant (Ka) for 3 MoAbs specific for the D antigen on group O R1r RBCs ranged from 1.3 to 7.4 108 M-1, depending on the antibody. When measured by a binding assay with 125I-labeled anti-D MoAbs, the Ka were significantly lower, indicating that 125I-labeling diminishes anti-D affinity, even when the labeling is at a low level.

CONCLUSION

A simple ELISA method was developed for the measurement of the affinity of anti-D MoAbs for the D antigen and for the number of antigenic sites per RBC. As a result, the affinity of anti-D can be estimated accurately, thus avoiding the drawbacks inherent in modification of the antibody by 125I-labeling.

Molecular and serologic characterization of DWI, a novel “high-grade” partial D

BACKGROUND

Accurate D antigen identification is essential for pretransfusion and prenatal evaluation to prevent anti-D alloimmunization. Quantitative and qualitative D variants may pose typing problems and require particular consideration because of differing potential for anti-D induction.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

A novel partial D, DWI, was discovered in an anti-D-alloimmunized D+ Austrian woman. This D variant was investigated by RHD genotyping and nucleotide sequencing, as well as characterization of its serologic properties.

RESULTS

The proposita exhibited a single-nucleotide exchange in RHD Exon 7 (1073T>C) predicting a Met358Thr substitution in the sixth extracellular loop of the RhD polypeptide. All DWI individuals identified (the proposita and two relatives) were genotyped DWIdCcee, which, together with the family tree, was highly suggestive of a DWICe haplotype association. Epitope mapping studies revealed only minor D antigen modification with weakening but not loss of epitopes D1.1, D9.1, and D16.1. Antigen density varied individually between 8000 and 8600 D sites per erythrocyte. No known low-frequency Rh antigen was detected. Despite the highly retained D epitope composition, the DWI proposita's serum sample contained alloanti-D from an immunization event many years earlier.

CONCLUSION

The findings of this investigation emphasize the possible clinical significance of "high-grade" partial D variants that are likely to be missed by routine serology.

The RHCE allele ceRT: D epitope 6 expression does not require D-specific amino acids

BACKGROUND

False-positive D typing in patients may lead to anti-D immunization caused by D+ transfusions or by omission of anti-D prophylaxis. Known causes of such errors are RhCE variants carrying RhD-specific amino acids and cold agglutinin activity of some frequently used monoclonal anti-D.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

The molecular basis of eight samples referred because of "false-positive" reactions with some commercial monoclonal anti-D was investigated by PCR and nucleotide sequencing from genomic DNA. PCR with sequence-specific priming was developed to specifically detect the underlying aberrant RHCE allele. The D epitope profile of the allele was determined by serology.

RESULTS

The aberrant reactivity of the samples was caused by the RHCE allele RHCE(R154T) that occurred in a cde haplotype. The phenotype dubbed ceRT expressed the important D epitope 6, which is the target epitope of most monoclonal anti-D used in routine typing.

DISCUSSION

The characterization of ceRT demonstrated a previously unknown mechanism of antigen D expression that does not require any D-specific amino acid. At least for some D epitopes, D-like structures may be mimicked by RhCE proteins carrying amino acid substitutions not representative for RhD.

Competitive enzyme-linked immunoassay of monoclonal immunoglobulin G anti-D preparations

The development of monoclonal immunoglobulin G (IgG) anti-D for prophylaxis necessitates estimation of their potency in terms of their red cell-binding ability, but it is unclear which quantification methodology is most suitable for this. The aim of this study was to assess 50 monoclonal anti-D from the 4th International Workshop for quantitative and qualitative binding to red cells in a competitive enzyme-linked immunoassay (EIA) in which varying amounts of monoclonal antibodies (MoAbs) and a constant amount of biotinylated monoclonal anti-D (BRAD-5) compete for red cell binding. The potencies of the MoAb were estimated against the International Reference Preparation (IRP) for anti-D Ig. Two MoAbs as supplied were insufficiently inhibitory of biotinylated BRAD-5 binding to be quantified; the potencies of the remainder ranged from 4 to 343 IU mL-1 and included 11 MoAbs showing dose-responses that were nonparallel to those of other MoAb and the IRP. Estimation of the concentration of antibody in the supernatants by radial immunodiffusion ranged from 0.5 to 61 micro g mL-1, giving specific activities of <1-24 IU micro g-1. The results show that competitive EIA is suitable for quantitating most monoclonal anti-D for development and quality control purposes, regardless of their D epitope reactivity.