Cognitive performance in older people after mild traumatic brain injury: Trauma effects and other risk factors

Critical Review of Recently Published Studies Claiming Long-Term Neurocognitive Abnormalities in Mild Traumatic Brain Injury

Mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI) is the most common claimed personal injury condition for which neuropsychologists are retained as forensic experts in litigation. Therefore, it is critical that experts have accurate information when testifying as to neurocognitive outcome from concussion. Systematic reviews and six meta-analyses from 1997 to 2011 regarding objective neurocognitive outcome from mTBI provide no evidence that concussed individuals do not return to baseline by weeks to months post-injury. In the current manuscript, a critical review was conducted of 21 research studies published since the last meta-analysis in 2011 that have claimed to demonstrate long-term (i.e., ≥12 months post-injury) neurocognitive abnormalities in adults with mTBI. Using seven proposed methodological criteria for research investigating neurocognitive outcome from mTBI, no studies were found to be scientifically adequate. In particular, more than 50% of the 21 studies reporting cognitive dysfunction did not appropriately diagnose mTBI, employ prospective research designs, use standard neuropsychological tests, include appropriate control groups, provide information on motive to feign or use PVTs, or exclude, or adequately consider the impact of, comorbid conditions known to impact neurocognitive scores. We additionally analyzed 15 studies published during the same period that documented no longer term mTBI-related cognitive abnormalities, and demonstrate that they were generally more methodologically robust than the studies purporting to document cognitive dysfunction. The original meta-analytic conclusions remain the most empirically-sound evidence informing our current understanding of favorable outcomes following mTBI.

Associations Between Traumatic Brain Injury Characteristics and Memory Outcomes: Insights from the Health and Retirement Study

Traumatic brain injury (TBI) is an established risk factor for accelerated cognitive decline and increased dementia risk. The specific characteristics of TBI (e.g., type of head trauma, presence of a gap in memory, age of onset) that confer the greatest risk to cognitive health remain comparatively less clear. Using data from the 2014 Health and Retirement Study (HRS) experimental module, we examined associations between TBI characteristics and memory outcomes in a national adult lifespan sample. We tested whether the age of onset and presence of a memory gap in TBI resulting from a vehicle accident, from a fall or being hit, or from playing sports or playing on a playground were associated with self-rated memory and recall memory performance in a subsample of HRS respondents across the adult lifespan (N = 414, mean age = 66.28, SD = 9.70, 52% female). In cases where participants reported TBI from three different types of injury (vehicle accident, fall, and playing sports or playing on a playground), they shared whether they experienced a gap in their memory and their age when the head trauma occurred. Participants also reported on self-rated memory and performed a recall memory task. Hierarchical linear regression models were adjusted for age, sex, race, ethnicity, education, and self-rated health. Older age of onset for TBI from a fall was associated with worse self-rated memory (Est. = -0.11, SE = 0.04, p = 0.01) and recall performance (Est. = -0.33, SE = 0.15, p = 0.03). Encountering a memory gap from the TBI that resulted from a vehicle accident (Est. = -0.22, SE = 0.10, p = 0.03), a fall (Est. = -0.23, SE = 0.09, p = 0.01), and from playing sports or playing on a playground (Est. = -0.40, SE = -0.13, p < 0.01) were all significantly associated with worse self-rated memory. Links between encountering a memory gap and recall performance were comparatively scant. Results indicate the impact of TBI on memory varies as a function of type of trauma, age of onset, and presence of memory gap from the head trauma. Our study takes a preclinical, preventative approach to inform public health efforts that target the mitigation of specific types of head trauma at different developmental phases of the lifespan.

Mild Traumatic Brain Injury in Older Adults: Recovery Course and Insights on Early Predictors of Outcome

Mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI) is a growing health concern in the context of an aging population. Older adults comprise a distinct population, with an increased vulnerability for mTBI due to comorbid diseases and age-associated frailty compared with the adult population. The aim of this study was to assess the recovery course and determinants of outcome in a large cohort of older patients with mTBI. For this study, 154 patients aged ≥60 years with mTBI admitted to the Emergency Department were investigated in a prospective observational cohort (ReCONNECT study). Demographics and injury characteristics (computed tomography scan, Glasgow Coma Scale) were determined on admission. Early determinants of outcome were assessed at 2 weeks post-injury (e.g., early post-traumatic complaints and emotional distress) with validated questionnaires. Quality of life (QoL) was determined at 3 months with the World Health Organization Quality of Life Scale-Shortened Version. Functional outcome was determined at 3 (early) and 6 months (long term) post-injury with the Glasgow Outcome Scale Extended (GOSE). Logistic regression analyses identified predictors of outcome with dichotomized GOSE scores as dependent variable (incomplete recovery was defined by GOSE ≤ 7 and complete recovery by GOSE 8). Complete recovery was observed in 42% of patients at 3 months post-injury without significant sex differences. More early post-traumatic complaints were present in patients with incomplete recovery, compared with patients with complete recovery (p < 0.001). Scores on overall QoL, general health-related QoL and all subdomains were lower for patients with incomplete recovery compared with patients with complete recovery (p < 0.05). Incomplete recovery at 3 months post-injury was predicted by increased physical frailty and early post-traumatic complaints (Nagelkerke R2 = 0.25). At 6 months post-injury, 53% of patients had complete recovery with higher frequency in males (60%) compared with females (42%) (p = 0.025). None of the investigated variables significantly predicted long-term outcome at 6 months post-injury (Nagelkerke R2 = 0.14), which might be explained by the changing cohort characteristics over time due to age-related morbidity. Our results demonstrate that almost half of older patients with mTBI show complete recovery with complaints and physical frailty as predictors of outcome at 3 months post-injury. Recovery still improves after 3 months and further follow-up is necessary to identify other factors that are associated with long-term outcomes in this specific category of patients with mTBI. The recovery course in older patients with mTBI is dynamic and further research on factors associated with long-term outcomes in this specific patient population is imperative to enhance treatment strategies.

Traumatic brain injuries: a neuropsychological review

The best predictor of functional outcome in victims of traumatic brain injury (TBI) is a neuropsychological evaluation. An exponential growth of research into TBI has focused on diagnosis and treatment. Extant literature lacks a comprehensive neuropsychological review that is simultaneously scholarly and practical. In response, our group included, and went beyond a general overview of TBI's, which commonly include definition, types, severity, and pathophysiology. We incorporate reasons behind the use of particular neuroimaging techniques, as well as the most recent findings on common neuropsychological assessments conducted in TBI cases, and their relationship to outcome. In addition, we include tables outlining estimated recovery trajectories of different age groups, their risk factors and we encompass phenomenological studies, further covering the range of existing-promising tools for cognitive rehabilitation/remediation purposes. Finally, we highlight gaps in current research and directions that would be beneficial to pursue.

Cognitive impairment in Chinese traumatic brain injury patients: from challenge to future perspectives

Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI) is a prevalent form of neurological damage that may induce varying degrees of cognitive dysfunction in patients, consequently impacting their quality of life and social functioning. This article provides a mini review of the epidemiology in Chinese TBI patients and etiology of cognitive impairment. It analyzes the risk factors of cognitive impairment, discusses current management strategies for cognitive dysfunction in Chinese TBI patients, and summarizes the strengths and limitations of primary testing tools for TBI-related cognitive functions. Furthermore, the article offers a prospective analysis of future challenges and opportunities. Its objective is to contribute as a reference for the prevention and management of cognitive dysfunction in Chinese TBI patients.

Quality of life and psychological health after mild traumatic brain injury in older people: Three- and six-month follow up

OBJECTIVES

Examine quality of life (QoL) and psychological health after mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI) in older people (65+ years) at 3- and 6-month follow-up and explore which injury factors predicted QoL.

METHODS

mTBI patients were compared to trauma comparison (TC) and community comparison (CC) groups. QoL and psychological health were measured at both timepoints. After accounting for 3-month psychological health, injury severity, neuroimaging, and 3-month neuropsychological performance were assessed as predictors of 6-month QoL.

RESULTS

Overall 3-month QoL was lower for mTBI (Cohen's d = 0.938) and TC (Cohen's d = 0.485) groups compared to CCs, but by 6 months only mTBI patients continued to report poorer overall QoL (Cohen's d = 0.577) and physical QoL (Cohen's d = 0.656). Despite group differences, QoL for most (~92%) was within normative limits. 3-month psychological health predicted QoL 6-months postinjury (β = -.377, 95% CI -.614, -.140) but other proposed risk factors (GCS <15, neuroimaging, 3-month neuropsychological performance) did not uniquely predict QoL.

CONCLUSIONS

Older adults following mTBI reported lower QoL up to 6-months postinjury compared to non-injured peers, indicating that mTBI patients were particularly susceptible to ongoing differences in QoL 6-months postinjury.