Four Hapten Spacer Sites Modulating Class Specificity: Nondirectional Multianalyte Immunoassay for 31 β-Agonists and Analogues

Ultrasound probe enhanced enzymatic hydrolysis for rapid separation of β2-adrenergic agonists from animal urine and livestock wastewater: Applicability to biomonitoring investigation

BACKGROUND

An increasing number of β2-adrenergic agonists are illicitly used for growth promoting and lean meat increasing in animal husbandry in recent years, but the development of analytical methods has lagged behind these emerging drugs.

RESULTS

Here, we designed and developed an ultrasound probe enhanced enzymatic hydrolysis reactor for quick separation and simultaneously quantification of 22 β2-adrenergic agonists in animal urine and livestock wastewater. Owing to the enhancement of the conventional enzymatic digestion through the ultrasound acoustic probe power, only 2 min was required for the comprehensively separation of β2-adrenergic agonists from the sample matrices, making it a much more desirable alternative tool for high-throughput investigation. The swine, bovine and sheep urines (n = 287), and livestock wastewater (n = 15) samples, collected from both the north and south China, were examined to demonstrate the feasibility and capability of the proposed approach. Six kinds of β2-adrenergic agonists (clenbuterol, salbutamol, ractopamine, terbutaline, clorprenaline and cimaterol) were found in animal urines, with concentrations ranged between 0.056 μg/L (terbutaline) and 5.79 μg/L (clenbuterol). Up to nine β2-adrenergic agonists were detected in wastewater samples, of which four were found in swine farms and nine in cattle/sheep farms, with concentration levels from 0.069 μg/L (tulobuterol) to 2470 μg/L (clenbuterol).

SIGNIFICANCE

Interestingly, since β2-adrenergic agonists are usually considered to be abused mainly in the pig farms, our data indicate that both the detection frequencies and concentrations of these agonists in the ruminant farms were higher than the pig farms. Furthermore, the findings of this work indicated that there is a widespread occurrence of β2-adrenergic agonists in livestock farms, especially for clenbuterol and salbutamol, which may pose both food safety and potential ecological risks. We recommend that stricter controls should be adopted to prevent the illegally usage of these β2-adrenergic agonists in agricultural animals, especially ruminants, and they should also be removed before discharging to the environment.

Central Chirality and Axial Chirality Recognition of the Enantioselective Antibodies to Herbicide Metolachlor

Enantioselective antibodies have emerged as efficient tools in the field of chiral chemical detection and separation. However, it is complicated to obtain a highly stereoselective antibody due to the unclear recognition mechanism. In this study, the hapten of metolachlor was synthesized and enantio-separated. The absolute configuration of the four haptens obtained was identified by the computed and experimental electronic circular dichroism comparison. Five polyclonal antibodies against the Rac-metolachlor and its enantiomers were generated by immunization. The cross-activity of all the 5 antibodies with 44 structural analogues, including metolachlor enantiomers, was tested. It demonstrated that antibodies have higher specificity to recognize central chirality than axial chirality. Especially, αRR-MET-Ab exhibited excellent specificity and stereoselectivity. Accordingly, 3D-QSAR models were constructed and revealed that paired stereoisomers exhibited opposite interactions with the antibodies. It is the first time that the antibodies against four stereoisomers were prepared and analyzed, which will be conducive to the rational design of the stereoselective antibodies.

A portable automated chip for simultaneous rapid point-of-care testing of multiple β-agonists

Abusive use of β-agonists as feed additives for animals and medication is detrimental to human health and food safety. Conventional assays are restricted to a single type of β-agonists detection and cannot match the multiplexing features to perform automated, high throughput, and rapid quantitative analysis in real samples. In this research, we develop a portable automated chip system (PACS) with highly integrated automated devices in conjunction with portable microfluidic chips to provide simultaneous point-of-care testing of multiple β-agonists in the field, simplifying complex manual methods, shortening assay times, and improving sensitivity. Specifically, silicon film is used as reaction substrates for immobilizing the conjugates of β-agonists to increase the sensitivity of the assay result. Then, the PACS with a chemiluminescence imaging detector is established for automatic high-throughput and sensitive detection of Clenbuterol, Ractopamine, and Salbutamol based on the indirect immunoassay. Newly developed chip with high mixing performance can improve the sensitivity of target determination. Multiplex assays were carried out using the developed system for Clenbuterol, Ractopamine, and Salbutamol with a limit of detection of 54 pg mL-1,59 pg mL-1, and 93 pg mL-1, respectively. Except for sample preparation and coating, the detection in the PACS takes less than 47 min. A satisfactory sample recovery (86.33%-108.12%) was obtained, validating the reliability and practical applicability of this PACS. Meanwhile, the PACS enables sensitive and rapid detection of multiple β-agonists in farms or markets where lacking advanced laboratory facilities.

Two kinds of lateral flow immunoassays based on multifunctional magnetic prussian blue nanoenzyme and colloidal gold for the detection of 38 β-agonists in swine urine and pork

Herein, novel multifunctional magnetic prussian blue nanoenzymes (MPBNs) and colloidal gold (CG) were synthesized and used to develop two kinds of lateral flow immunoassays (LFIAs) for the detection of 38 β-agonists. Since MPBNs has a unique three-in-one function of colorimetric magnetic catalytic activities, the signal intensity and coupling ratio are 2 and 8-fold higher than that of the CG. The cut-off values of the CG-LFIA and MPBNs-LFIA for swine urine and pork are 5/5 and 0.3/0.5 μg/kg, the limits of detection are 0.19/0.29 and 0.02/0.03 μg/kg, respectively. The sensitivity of MPBNs-LFIA is 10-fold higher than that of CG-LFIA, and up to 200-fold higher than that of the reported LFIAs. The recoveries of the LFIAs are 80.0%-116.7%, with coefficients of variation of 1.4%-14.3%. Our study proved that the MPBNs have more advantages than CG, and can offer a promising signal label for ultrasensitive immunoassay techniques.

Ultrasensitive antibody production strategy based on hapten property for simultaneous immunoassay

A high-quality antibody production strategy is significant for immunoassay. In this work, four general haptens were proposed based on the 3D structure and surface electrostatic potential of molecular modeling. It was found that the sensitivity and specificity of polyclonal antibodies (pAbs) mainly depended on the bond angle of shapes liked "V" between haptens and proteins and hydrophobic parts of haptens. The quantified process was employed to obtain pAbs against cyhalofop-butyl and its metabolites (CAFs), with the IC₅₀ value of 4.9 μg·L^-1 under optimal conditions. The limit of quantization (LOQ) of the ultrasensitive icELISA in brown rice was 2 μg·kg^-1. The recoveries were 74%-110%, with a coefficient of variation (CV) less than 10%. This study indicated that the hapten property approach led to an improved immunoassay.

Ultrasensitive Magnetic Assisted Lateral Flow Immunoassay Based on Chiral Monoclonal Antibody against R-(-)-Salbutamol of Broad-Specificity for 38 β-Agonists Detection in Swine Urine and Pork

Screening for ″zero tolerance″ β-agonists requires broad-specificity and sensitivity methods. Herein, R-(-)-salbutamol (SAL) is chirally separated and designed as a hapten, and a monoclonal antibody (mAb) was first prepared with an IC₅₀ of 0.27 ng/mL, which can recognize 38 β-agonists simultaneously. The broad-specificity of chiral mAb was explored by molecular simulation technology. Magnetic nanoparticles (MNPs) were then synthesized and applied as a signal tracer to develop a lateral flow immunoassay (LFIA). The limits of detection of MNPs-LFIA for SAL in swine urine and pork were 0.05 and 0.09 μg/kg, which was (2-125)-fold lower than that of the reported LFIAs. The recoveries were between 95.8 and 116.7%, with the coefficient of variation from 2.7 to 15.4%. Parallel analysis of 44 samples by commercial ELISA kits confirmed the reliability. Therefore, our work not only provides a broad-specificity and ultrasensitive method for β-agonists but also suggests that chirality is the new general theory that guided the rational hapten design.

Current Advances in Immunoassays for the Detection of β2-Agonists

β2-agonists are a group of synthetic phenylethanolamine compounds which are traditionally used for treating bronchospasm. These compounds can also increase skeletal muscle mass and decrease body fat. The illegal use of β2-agonists in food-producing animals results in residue of β2-agonists in edible tissues and causes adverse health effects in humans. Thus, the detection of β2-agonists at trace level in complex sample matrices is of great importance for monitoring the abuse of β2-agonists. Many methods have been developed to detect β2-agonists. Among them, a variety of antigen–antibody interaction-based techniques have been established to detect β2-agonists in various samples, including animal feed, urine, serum, milk, tissues and hair. In this review, we summarized current achievement in the extraction of β2-agonists from testing samples and detection of β2-agonists using immunological techniques. Future perspectives were briefly discussed.

Two binding epitopes modulating specificity of immunoassay for β-agonist detection: Quantitative structure-activity relationship

A growing number of β-agonists are illegally using for reducing animal fat deposition in animals, but the development of analytical methods always lags behind the emergence of new illegal compounds. Therefore, class specificity antibody-based immunoassays that can detect a great many β-agonists are important for timely supervision. In this study, a competitive inhibition enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ciELISA) based on a clenbuterol monoclonal antibody was developed to recognize 23 β-agonists and analogues. Holographic and three-dimensional quantitative structure-activity relationship (HQSAR and 3D QSAR) revealed that there are two critical binding epitopes on β-agonist hapten affecting antibody specificity, and these epitopes have been further validated using a ractopamine antibody with narrow specificity. Tert-butyl at C-2' epitope is needed to generate class specific antibodies, and different characteristics of substituents at benzene ring epitope would adjust antibody specificity. This investigation could provide reference for future design of β-agonist haptens.

Multiplex optical bioassays for food safety analysis: Toward on-site detection

Food safety analysis plays a significant role in controlling food contamination and supervision. In recent years, multiplex optical bioassays (MOBAs) have been widely applied to analyze multiple hazards due to their efficiency and low cost. However, due to the challenges such as multiplexing capacity, poor sensitivity, and bulky instrumentation, the further application of traditional MOBAs in food screening has been limited. In this review, effective strategies regarding food safety MOBAs are summarized, such as spatial-resolution modes performed in multi-T lines/dots strips or arrays of strip/microplate/microfluidic chip/SPR chip and signal-resolution modes employing distinguishable colorimetric/luminescence/fluorescence/surface plasma resonance/surface-enhanced Raman spectrum as signal tags. Following this, new trends on how to design engineered sensor architecture and exploit distinguishable signal reporters, how to improve both multiplexing capacity and sensitivity, and how to integrate these formats into smartphones so as to be mobile are summarized systematically. Typically, in the case of enhancing multiplexing capacity and detection throughput, microfluidic array chips with multichannel architecture would be a favorable approach to overcome the spatial and physical limitations of immunochromatographic assay (ICA) test strips. Moreover, noble metal nanoparticles and single-excitation, multiple-emission luminescence nanomaterials hold great potential in developing ultrasensitive MOBAs. Finally, the exploitation of innovative multiplexing strategy hybridized with powerful and widely available smartphones opens new perspectives to MOBAs. In future, the MOBAs should be more sensitive, have higher multiplexing capacity, and easier instrumentation.

Development of 3D-QSAR models for predicting the activities of chemicals to stimulate muscle growth via β2-adrenoceptor

β₂-adrenoceptor (β₂AR) agonists can stimulate skeletal muscle growth. Their illegal use in food-producing animals, human athletes and bodybuilders causes adverse health effects. In the present study, we developed 3D-QSAR models for predicting the activity of chemicals which can stimulate skeletal muscle growth through β₂AR. The activity of 25 β₂AR agonists was measured by β₂AR-cAMP response element (CRE) -luciferase (Luc) reporter assay. The 3D-QSAR models were built using comparative molecular field analysis (CoMFA) and comparative molecular similarity indices analysis (CoMSIA). The CoMFA and CoMSIA models displayed high external predictability (R² 0.996 and 0.992, respectively) and good statistical robustness, and revealed that electrostatic effects were the most prominent forces influencing the activity of β₂AR agonists. The CoMFA and CoMSIA contour plots provided clues regarding the main chemical features responsible for the activity variations and also resulted in predictions which correlate very well with the observed activity. In vitro study with differentiated myotubes showed that the potency orders of β₂AR agonists in activating the β₂AR-CRE-Luc reporter and in upregulating CREB target genes related to muscle growth were consistent. These 3D-QSAR models provide tools for predicting the activity of chemicals which might be illegally used in livestock or humans to stimulate skeletal muscle growth.

Broadly Neutralizing Synthetic Cannabinoid Vaccines

Synthetic cannabinoids (SCs) constitute a significant portion of psychoactive substances forming a major public health risk. Due to the wide variety of SCs, broadly neutralizing antibodies generated by active immunization present an intriguing pathway to combat cannabinoid use disorder. Here, we probed hapten design for antibody affinity and cross reactivity against two classes of SCs. Of the 10 haptens screened, 3 vaccine groups revealed submicromolar IC₅₀, each targeting 5-6 compounds in our panel of 22 drugs. Moreover, SCs were successfully sequestered when administered by vaping or intraperitoneal injection, which was confirmed within animal models by observing locomotion, body temperature, and pharmacokinetics. We also discovered synergistic effects to simultaneously blunt two drug classes through an admixture vaccine approach. Collectively, our study provides a comprehensive foundation for the development of vaccines against SCs.

Conformational adaptability determining antibody recognition to distomer: structure analysis of enantioselective antibody against chiral drug gatifloxacin

Enantioselective antibodies have great potential to separate and detect chiral compounds. However, cross-reactivity of enantioselective antibodies to the distomer may limit the application. An in-depth understanding of interactions between antibodies and chiral drugs could be helpful to investigate antibody recognition to the distomer. In this study, a monoclonal antibody against chiral quinolone S-(−)-gatifloxacin (S-GAT) was produced and its Fab fragment was prepared by proteolysis. The S-GAT Fab exhibited 10% cross-reactivity against the R-enantiomer compared to that of the S-enantiomer in an indirect competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (icELISA). The crystal structures of the S-GAT Fab apo form and complex with S-GAT were analyzed, and molecular docking of the R-enantiomer was carried out. The ligand conformation was further studied using molecular dynamics simulations. The results showed that the distomer R-enantiomer could enter the chiral center recognition region of the antibody by adjusting the piperazine ring conformation. Meanwhile, the antibody binding cavity had obvious conformational adaptability during ligand binding. It demonstrated that conformational change of both ligand and antibody was the key reason why antibodies recognize the distomer. Restricting conformational adaptability could improve the enantioselective recognition ability of antibodies. This study provided a new explanation for the cross-reactivity of enantioselective antibodies to the distomer, and could help to modulate antibody enantioselectivity for immunoassay of chiral drugs.

The conformational adaptability of both antibody and ligand could determine the antibody enantioselectivity in chiral drug immunoassay.

Rapid Multi-Residue Detection Methods for Pesticides and Veterinary Drugs

The excessive use or abuse of pesticides and veterinary drugs leads to residues in food, which can threaten human health. Therefore, there is an extremely urgent need for multi-analyte analysis techniques for the detection of pesticide and veterinary drug residues, which can be applied as screening techniques for food safety monitoring and detection. Recent developments related to rapid multi-residue detection methods for pesticide and veterinary drug residues are reviewed herein. Methods based on different recognition elements or the inherent characteristics of pesticides and veterinary drugs are described in detail. The preparation and application of three broadly specific recognition elements-antibodies, aptamers, and molecular imprinted polymers-are summarized. Furthermore, enzymatic inhibition-based sensors, near-infrared spectroscopy, and SERS spectroscopy based on the inherent characteristics are also discussed. The aim of this review is to provide a useful reference for the further development of rapid multi-analyte analysis of pesticide and veterinary drug residues.

Selective extraction and detection of β-agonists in swine urine for monitoring illegal use in livestock breeding

The illegal use of β-agonists often endangers animal-derived food safety. In this study, a selective detection method for β-agonists in swine urine was established via the combination of polymeric ionic liquid-molecularly imprinted graphene oxide-miniaturized pipette tip solid-phase extraction and high-performance liquid chromatography. It is worth noting that this method relied mainly on the designed adsorbent, which presented a rich adsorption mechanism, fast mass transfer rate, and high selectivity, and was successfully utilized in the selective extraction of β-agonists from swine urine samples. The proposed method has low LOD (0.20-0.56 ng/mL), high recovery (94.9-107.9%), and high reusability (4 times, 91.9-108.8%), which indicates its high potential as a selective, sensitive, accurate, and nonfatal method for monitoring the illegal use of β-agonists in the livestock breeding stage.

Modulating Linker Composition of Haptens Resulted in Improved Immunoassay for Histamine

Histamine (HA) is an important food contaminant generated during food fermentation or spoilage. However, an immunoassay for direct (derivatization free) determination of HA has rarely been reported due to its small size to induce the desired antibodies by its current hapten-protein conjugates. In this work, despite violating the classical hapten design criteria which recommend introducing a linear aliphatic (phenyl free) linker into the immunizing hapten, a novel haptens, HA-245 designed and synthesized with a phenyl-contained linker, exhibited significantly enhanced immunological properties. Thus, a quality-improved monoclonal antibody (Mab) against HA was elicited by its hapten-carrier conjugates. Then, as the linear aliphatic linker contained haptens, Hapten B was used as linker-heterologous coating haptens to eliminate the recognition of linker antibodies. Indirect competitive ELISA (ic-ELISA) was developed with a 50% inhibition concentration (IC₅₀) of 0.21 mg/L and a limit of detection (LOD) of 0.06 mg/L in buffer solution. The average recoveries of HA from spiked food samples for this ic-ELISA ranged from 84.1% and 108.5%, and the analysis results agreed well with those of referenced LC-MS/MS. This investigation not only realized derivatization-free immunoassay for HA, but also provided a valuable guidance for hapten design and development of immunoassay for small molecules.

Using molecular descriptors for assisted screening of heterologous competitive antigens to improve the sensitivity of ELISA for detection of enrofloxacin in raw milk

The use of the heterologous competitive strategy has become a vital method to improve the sensitivity of ELISA. In this work, we prepared an anti-enrofloxacin (ENR) mAb with ENR-bovine serum albumin (BSA) as immunogen. The molecular descriptors of quinolones were then used to screen heterologous coating antigens for the detection of ENR based on an ensemble learning method to improve the sensitivity of the ELISA. Results indicated that 6 of the 7 selected heterologous competitive antigens could enhance the sensitivity of ELISA. The ELISA sensitivity for the detection of ENR with sarafloxacin-BSA as heterologous coating antigen was improved 10-fold (in PBS) and 6-fold (in milk) compared with that with ENR-BSA as homologous antigen. The strategy can effectively screen suitable heterologous competitive antigens to improve the sensitivity of ELISA, followed by preparation of mAb with no additional modification to the corresponding immunogen.

Application of quantitative structure-activity relationship analysis on an antibody and alternariol-like compounds interaction study

The antigen-antibody interaction determines the sensitivity and specificity of competitive immunoassay for hapten detection. In this paper, the specificity of a monoclonal antibody against alternariol-like compounds was evaluated through indirect competitive ELISA. The results showed that the antibody had cross-reactivity with 33 compounds with the binding affinity (expressed by IC₅₀ ) ranging from 9.4 ng/mL to 12.0 μg/mL. All the 33 compounds contained a common moiety and similar substituents. To understand how this common moiety and substituents affected the recognition ability of the antibody, a three-dimensional quantitative structure-activity relationship (3D-QSAR) between the antibody and the 33 alternariol-like compounds was constructed using comparative molecular field analysis (CoMFA) and comparative molecular similarity indices analysis (CoMSIA) methods. The q² values of the CoMFA and CoMSIA models were 0.785 and 0.782, respectively, and the r² values were 0.911 and 0.988, respectively, indicating that the models had good predictive ability. The results of 3D-QSAR showed that the most important factor affecting antibody recognition was the hydrogen bond mainly formed by the hydroxyl group of alternariol, followed by the hydrophobic force mainly formed by the methyl group. This study provides a reference for the design of new hapten and the mechanisms for antibody recognition.