Top-Down Characterization of Denatured Proteins and Native Protein Complexes Using Electron Capture Dissociation Implemented within a Modified Ion Mobility-Mass Spectrometer

[Applications of native mass spectrometry and ultraviolet photodissociation in protein structure and interaction analysis]

Dynamic changes in the structures and interactions of proteins are closely correlated with their biological functions. However, the precise detection and analysis of these molecules are challenging. Native mass spectrometry (nMS) introduces proteins or protein complexes into the gas phase by electrospray ionization, and then performs MS analysis under near-physiological conditions that preserve the folded state of proteins and their complexes in solution. nMS can provide information on stoichiometry, assembly, and dissociation constants by directly determining the relative molecular masses of protein complexes through high-resolution MS. It can also integrate various MS dissociation technologies, such as collision-induced dissociation (CID), surface-induced dissociation (SID), and ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD), to analyze the conformational changes, binding interfaces, and active sites of protein complexes, thereby revealing the relationship between their interactions and biological functions. UVPD, especially 193 nm excimer laser UVPD, is a rapidly evolving MS dissociation method that can directly dissociate the covalent bonds of protein backbones with a single pulse. It can generate different types of fragment ions, while preserving noncovalent interactions such as hydrogen bonds within these ions, thereby enabling the MS analysis of protein structures with single-amino-acid-site resolution. This review outlines the applications and recent progress of nMS and UVPD in protein dynamic structure and interaction analyses. It covers the nMS techniques used to analyze protein-small-molecule ligand interactions, the structures of membrane proteins and their complexes, and protein-protein interactions. The discussion on UVPD includes the analysis of gas-phase protein structures and interactions, as well as alterations in protein dynamic structures, and interactions resulting from mutations and ligand binding. Finally, this review describes the future development prospects for protein analysis by nMS and new-generation advanced extreme UV light sources with higher brightness and shorter pulses.

Structural Elucidation of Ubiquitin via Gas-Phase Ion/Ion Cross-Linking Reactions Using Sodium-Cationized Reagents Coupled with Infrared Multiphoton Dissociation

Accurate structural determination of proteins is critical to understanding their biological functions and the impact of structural disruption on disease progression. Gas-phase cross-linking mass spectrometry (XL-MS) via ion/ion reactions between multiply charged protein cations and singly charged cross-linker anions has previously been developed to obtain low-resolution structural information on proteins. This method significantly shortens experimental time relative to conventional solution-phase XL-MS but has several technical limitations: (1) the singly deprotonated N-hydroxysulfosuccinimide (sulfo-NHS)-based cross-linker anions are restricted to attachment at neutral amine groups of basic amino acid residues and (2) analyzing terminal cross-linked fragment ions is insufficient to unambiguously localize sites of linker attachment. Herein, we demonstrate enhanced structural information for alcohol-denatured A-state ubiquitin obtained from an alternative gas-phase XL-MS approach. Briefly, singly sodiated ethylene glycol bis(sulfosuccinimidyl succinate) (sulfo-EGS) cross-linker anions enable covalent cross-linking at both ammonium and amine groups. Additionally, covalently modified internal fragment ions, along with terminal b-/y-type counterparts, improve the determination of linker attachment sites. Molecular dynamics simulations validate experimentally obtained gas-phase conformations of denatured ubiquitin. This method has identified four cross-linking sites across 8+ ubiquitin, including two new sites in the N-terminal region of the protein that were originally inaccessible in prior gas-phase XL approaches. The two N-terminal cross-linking sites suggest that the N-terminal half of ubiquitin is more compact in gas-phase conformations. By comparison, the two C-terminal linker sites indicate the signature transformation of this region of the protein from a native to a denatured conformation. Overall, the results suggest that the solution-phase secondary structures of the A-state ubiquitin are conserved in the gas phase. This method also provides sufficient sensitivity to differentiate between two gas-phase conformers of the same charge state with subtle structural variations.

The role of solvation on the conformational landscape of α-synuclein

Native ion mobility mass spectrometry has been used extensively to characterize ensembles of intrinsically disordered protein (IDP) conformers, but the extent to which the gaseous measurements provide realistic pictures of the solution conformations for such flexible proteins remains unclear. Therefore, we systematically studied the relationship between the solution and gaseous structural ensembles by measuring electrospray charge state and collision cross section (CCS) distributions for cationic and anionic forms of α-synuclein (αSN), an anionic protein in solution, as well as directly probed gas phase residue to residue distances via ion/ion reactions between gaseous α-synuclein cations and disulfonic acid linkers that form strong electrostatic bonds. We also combined results from in-solution protein crosslinking identified from native tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) with an initial αSN ensemble generated computationally by IDPConformerGenerator to generate an experimentally restrained solution ensemble of αSN. CCS distributions were directly calculated for the solution ensembles determined by NMR and compared to predicted gaseous conformers. While charge state and collision cross section distributions are useful for qualitatively describing the relative structural dynamics of proteins and major conformational changes induced by changes to solution states, the predicted and measured gas phase conformers include subpopulations that are significantly different than those expected from completely "freezing" solution conformations and preserving them in the gas phase. However, insights were gained on the various roles of solvent in stabilizing various conformers for extremely dynamic proteins like α-synuclein.

Top/Middle-Down Characterization of α-Synuclein Glycoforms

α-Synuclein is an intrinsically disordered protein that plays a critical role in the pathogenesis of neurodegenerative disorders, such as Parkinson's disease. Proteomics studies of human brain samples have associated the modification of the O-linked N-acetyl-glucosamine (O-GlcNAc) to several synucleinopathies; in particular, the position of the O-GlcNAc can regulate protein aggregation and subsequent cell toxicity. There is a need for site specific O-GlcNAc α-synuclein screening tools to direct better therapeutic strategies. In the present work, for the first time, the potential of fast, high-resolution trapped ion mobility spectrometry (TIMS) preseparation in tandem with mass spectrometry assisted by an electromagnetostatic (EMS) cell, capable of electron capture dissociation (ECD), and ultraviolet photodissociation (213 nm UVPD) is illustrated for the characterization of α-synuclein positional glycoforms: T72, T75, T81, and S87 modified with a single O-GlcNAc. Top-down 213 nm UVPD and ECD MS/MS experiments of the intact proteoforms showed specific product ions for each α-synuclein glycoforms associated with the O-GlcNAc position with a sequence coverage of ∼68 and ∼82%, respectively. TIMS-MS profiles of α-synuclein and the four glycoforms exhibited large structural heterogeneity and signature patterns across the 8+-15+ charge state distribution; however, while the α-synuclein positional glycoforms showed signature mobility profiles, they were only partially separated in the mobility domain. Moreover, a middle-down approach based on the Val40-Phe94 (55 residues) chymotrypsin proteolytic product using tandem TIMS-q-ECD-TOF MS/MS permitted the separation of the parent positional isomeric glycoforms. The ECD fragmentation of the ion mobility and m/z separated isomeric Val40-Phe94 proteolytic peptides with single O-GlcNAc in the T72, T75, T81, and S87 positions provided the O-GlcNAc confirmation and positional assignment with a sequence coverage of ∼80%. This method enables the high-throughput screening of positional glycoforms and further enhances the structural mass spectrometry toolbox with fast, high-resolution mobility separations and 213 nm UVPD and ECD fragmentation capabilities.

New Insights into the Intrinsic Electron-Based Dissociation Behavior of Cytochrome c Oligomers

Between 2003 and 2017, four reports were published that demonstrated the intrinsic ability of the native iron-containing proteins cytochrome c and ferritin to undergo radical-based backbone fragmentation in the gas phase without the introduction of exogenous electrons. For cytochrome c in particular, this effect has so far only been reported to occur in the ion source, preventing the in-depth study of reactions occurring after gas-phase isolation of specific precursors. Here, we report the first observation of this intrinsic native electron capture dissociation behavior after quadrupole isolation of specific charge states of the cytochrome c dimer and trimer, providing direct experimental support for key aspects of the mechanism proposed 20 years ago. Furthermore, we provide evidence that, in contrast to some earlier proposals, these oligomeric states are formed in bulk solution rather than during the electrospray ionization process and that the observed fragmentation site preferences can be rationalized through the structure and interactions within these native oligomers rather than the monomer. We also show that the observed fragmentation pattern─and indeed, whether or not fragmentation occurs─is highly sensitive to the provenance and history of the protein samples, to the extent that samples can show distinct fragmentation behavior despite behaving identically in ion mobility experiments. This rather underexplored method therefore represents an exquisitely sensitive conformational probe and will hopefully receive more attention from the biomolecular mass spectrometry community in the future.

Characterization of an Omnitrap-Orbitrap Platform Equipped with Infrared Multiphoton Dissociation, Ultraviolet Photodissociation, and Electron Capture Dissociation for the Analysis of Peptides and Proteins

We describe an instrument configuration based on the Orbitrap Exploris 480 mass spectrometer that has been coupled to an Omnitrap platform. The Omnitrap possesses three distinct ion-activation regions that can be used to perform resonant-based collision-induced dissociation, several forms of electron-associated fragmentation, and ultraviolet photodissociation. Each section can also be combined with infrared multiphoton dissociation. In this work, we demonstrate all these modes of operation in a range of peptides and proteins. The results show that this instrument configuration produces similar data to previous implementations of each activation technique and at similar efficiency levels. We demonstrate that this unique instrument configuration is extremely versatile for the investigation of polypeptides.

Ion Mobility Mass Spectrometry (IM-MS) for Structural Biology: Insights Gained by Measuring Mass, Charge, and Collision Cross Section

The investigation of macromolecular biomolecules with ion mobility mass spectrometry (IM-MS) techniques has provided substantial insights into the field of structural biology over the past two decades. An IM-MS workflow applied to a given target analyte provides mass, charge, and conformation, and all three of these can be used to discern structural information. While mass and charge are determined in mass spectrometry (MS), it is the addition of ion mobility that enables the separation of isomeric and isobaric ions and the direct elucidation of conformation, which has reaped huge benefits for structural biology. In this review, where we focus on the analysis of proteins and their complexes, we outline the typical features of an IM-MS experiment from the preparation of samples, the creation of ions, and their separation in different mobility and mass spectrometers. We describe the interpretation of ion mobility data in terms of protein conformation and how the data can be compared with data from other sources with the use of computational tools. The benefit of coupling mobility analysis to activation via collisions with gas or surfaces or photons photoactivation is detailed with reference to recent examples. And finally, we focus on insights afforded by IM-MS experiments when applied to the study of conformationally dynamic and intrinsically disordered proteins.

Native Top-Down Mass Spectrometry with Collisionally Activated Dissociation Yields Higher-Order Structure Information for Protein Complexes

Native mass spectrometry (MS) of proteins and protein assemblies reveals size and binding stoichiometry, but elucidating structures to understand their function is more challenging. Native top-down MS (nTDMS), i.e., fragmentation of the gas-phase protein, is conventionally used to derive sequence information, locate post-translational modifications (PTMs), and pinpoint ligand binding sites. nTDMS also endeavors to dissociate covalent bonds in a conformation-sensitive manner, such that information about higher-order structure can be inferred from the fragmentation pattern. However, the activation/dissociation method used can greatly affect the resulting information on protein higher-order structure. Methods such as electron capture/transfer dissociation (ECD and ETD, or ExD) and ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) can produce product ions that are sensitive to structural features of protein complexes. For multi-subunit complexes, a long-held belief is that collisionally activated dissociation (CAD) induces unfolding and release of a subunit, and thus is not useful for higher-order structure characterization. Here we show not only that sequence information can be obtained directly from CAD of native protein complexes but that the fragmentation pattern can deliver higher-order structural information about their gas- and solution-phase structures. Moreover, CAD-generated internal fragments (i.e., fragments containing neither N-/C-termini) reveal structural aspects of protein complexes.

Seeing the complete picture: proteins in top-down mass spectrometry

Top-down protein mass spectrometry can provide unique insights into protein sequence and structure, including precise proteoform identification and study of protein–ligand and protein–protein interactions. In contrast with the commonly applied bottom-up approach, top-down approaches do not include digestion of the protein of interest into small peptides, but instead rely on the ionization and subsequent fragmentation of intact proteins. As such, it is fundamentally the only way to fully characterize the composition of a proteoform. Here, we provide an overview of how a top-down protein mass spectrometry experiment is performed and point out recent applications from the literature to the reader. While some parts of the top-down workflow are broadly applicable, different research questions are best addressed with specific experimental designs. The most important divide is between studies that prioritize sequence information (i.e., proteoform identification) versus structural information (e.g., conformational studies, or mapping protein–protein or protein–ligand interactions). Another important consideration is whether to work under native or denaturing solution conditions, and the overall complexity of the sample also needs to be taken into account, as it determines whether (chromatographic) separation is required prior to MS analysis. In this review, we aim to provide enough information to support both newcomers and more experienced readers in the decision process of how to answer a potential research question most efficiently and to provide an overview of the methods that exist to answer these questions.

Top-"Double-Down" Mass Spectrometry of Histone H4 Proteoforms: Tandem Ultraviolet-Photon and Mobility/Mass-Selected Electron Capture Dissociations

Post-translational modifications (PTMs) on intact histones play a major role in regulating chromatin dynamics and influence biological processes such as DNA transcription, replication, and repair. The nature and position of each histone PTM is crucial to decipher how this information is translated into biological response. In the present work, the potential of a novel tandem top-"double-down" approach─ultraviolet photodissociation followed by mobility and mass-selected electron capture dissociation and mass spectrometry (UVPD-TIMS-q-ECD-ToF MS/MS)─is illustrated for the characterization of HeLa derived intact histone H4 proteoforms. The comparison between q-ECD-ToF MS/MS spectra and traditional Fourier-transform-ion cyclotron resonance-ECD MS/MS spectra of a H4 standard showed a similar sequence coverage (∼75%) with significant faster data acquisition in the ToF MS/MS platform (∼3 vs ∼15 min). Multiple mass shifts (e.g., 14 and 42 Da) were observed for the HeLa derived H4 proteoforms for which the top-down UVPD and ECD fragmentation analysis were consistent in detecting the presence of acetylated PTMs at the N-terminus and Lys5, Lys8, Lys12, and Lys16 residues, as well as methylated, dimethylated, and trimethylated PTMs at the Lys20 residue with a high sequence coverage (∼90%). The presented top-down results are in good agreement with bottom-up TIMS ToF MS/MS experiments and allowed for additional description of PTMs at the N-terminus. The integration of a 213 nm UV laser in the present platform allowed for UVPD events prior to the ion mobility-mass precursor separation for collision-induced dissociation (CID)/ECD-ToF MS. Selected c305+ UVPD fragments, from different H4 proteoforms (e.g., Ac + Me2, 2Ac + Me2 and 3Ac + Me2), exhibited multiple IMS bands for which similar CID/ECD fragmentation patterns per IMS band pointed toward the presence of conformers, adopting the same PTM distribution, with a clear assignment of the PTM localization for each of the c305+ UVPD fragment H4 proteoforms. These results were consistent with the biological "zip" model, where acetylation proceeds in the Lys16 to Lys5 direction. This novel platform further enhances the structural toolbox with alternative fragmentation mechanisms (UVPD, CID, and ECD) in tandem with fast, high-resolution mobility separations and shows great promise for global proteoform analysis.

Deciphering combinatorial post-translational modifications by top-down mass spectrometry

Post-translational modifications (PTMs) create vast structural and functional diversity of proteins, ultimately modulating protein function and degradation, influencing cellular signaling, and regulating transcription. The combinatorial patterns of PTMs increase the heterogeneity of proteins and further mediates their interactions. Advances in mass spectrometry-based proteomics have resulted in identification of thousands of proteins and allowed characterization of numerous types and sites of PTMs. Examination of intact proteins, termed the top-down approach, offers the potential to map protein sequences and localize multiple PTMs on each protein, providing the most comprehensive cataloging of proteoforms. This review describes some of the dividends of using mass spectrometry to analyze intact proteins and showcases innovative strategies that have enhanced the promise of top-down proteomics for exploring the impact of combinatorial PTMs in unsurpassed detail.

Trapped Ion Mobility Spectrometry, Ultraviolet Photodissociation, and Time-of-Flight Mass Spectrometry for Gas-Phase Peptide Isobars/Isomers/Conformers Discrimination

Trapped ion mobility spectrometry (TIMS) when coupled with mass spectrometry (MS) offers great advantages for the separation of isobaric, isomeric, and/or conformeric species. In the present work, we report the advantages of coupling TIMS with a low-cost, ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) linear ion trap operated at few mbars prior to time-of-flight (ToF) MS analysis for the effective characterization of isobaric, isomeric, and/or conformeric species based on mobility-selected fragmentation patterns. These three traditional challenges to MS-based separations are illustrated for the case of biologically relevant model systems: H3.1 histone tail PTM isobars (K4Me3/K18Ac), lanthipeptide regioisomers (overlapping/nonoverlapping ring patterns), and a model peptide conformer (angiotensin I). The sequential nature of the TIMS operation allows for effective synchronization with the ToF MS scans, in addition to parallel operation between the TIMS and the UVPD trap. Inspection of the mobility-selected UVPD MS spectra showed that for all three cases considered, unique fragmentation patterns (fingerprints) were observed per mobility band. Different from other IMS-UVPD implementations, the higher resolution of the TIMS device allowed for high mobility resolving power (R > 100) and effective mobility separation. The mobility selected UVPD MS provided high sequence coverage (>85%) with a fragmentation efficiency up to ∼40%.

Multiplexed Conformationally Selective, Localized Gas-Phase Hydrogen Deuterium Exchange of Protein Ions Enabled by Transmission-Mode Electron Capture Dissociation

In this article, we present an approach for conformationally multiplexed, localized hydrogen deuterium exchange (HDX) of gas-phase protein ions facilitated by ion mobility (IM) followed by electron capture dissociation (ECD). A quadrupole-IM-time of flight instrument previously modified to enable ECD in transmission mode (without ion trapping) immediately following a mobility separation was further modified to allow for deuterated ammonia (ND₃) to be leaked in after m/z selection. Collisional activation was minimized to prevent deuterium scrambling from giving structurally irrelevant results. Gas-phase HDX with ECD fragmentation for exchange site localization was demonstrated with the extensively studied protein folding models ubiquitin and cytochrome c. Ubiquitin was ionized from conditions that stabilize the native state and conditions that stabilize the partially folded A-state. IM of deuterated ubiquitin 6⁺ ions allowed the separation of more compact conformers from more extended conformers. ECD of the separated subpopulations revealed that the more extended (later arriving) conformers had significant, localized differences in the amount of HDX observed. The 5⁺ charge state showed many regions with protection from HDX, and the 11⁺ charge state, ionized from conditions that stabilize the A-state, showed high levels of deuterium incorporation throughout most of the protein sequence. The 7⁺ ions of cytochrome c ionized from aqueous conditions showed greater HDX with unstructured regions of the protein relative to interior, structured regions, especially those involved in heme binding. With careful tuning and attention to deuterium scrambling, our approach holds promise for determining region-specific information on a conformer-selected basis for gas-phase protein structures, including localized characterizations of ligand, epitope, and protein-protein binding.

Native top-down mass spectrometry for higher-order structural characterization of proteins and complexes

Progress in structural biology research has led to a high demand for powerful and yet complementary analytical tools for structural characterization of proteins and protein complexes. This demand has significantly increased interest in native mass spectrometry (nMS), particularly native top-down mass spectrometry (nTDMS) in the past decade. This review highlights recent advances in nTDMS for structural research of biological assemblies, with a particular focus on the extra multi-layers of information enabled by TDMS. We include a short introduction of sample preparation and ionization to nMS, tandem fragmentation techniques as well as mass analyzers and software/analysis pipelines used for nTDMS. We highlight unique structural information offered by nTDMS and examples of its broad range of applications in proteins, protein-ligand interactions (metal, cofactor/drug, DNA/RNA, and protein), therapeutic antibodies and antigen-antibody complexes, membrane proteins, macromolecular machineries (ribosome, nucleosome, proteosome, and viruses), to endogenous protein complexes. The challenges, potential, along with perspectives of nTDMS methods for the analysis of proteins and protein assemblies in recombinant and biological samples are discussed.

Surface-induced Dissociation Mass Spectrometry as a Structural Biology Tool

Native mass spectrometry (nMS) is evolving into a workhorse for structural biology. The plethora of online and offline preparation, separation, and purification methods as well as numerous ionization techniques combined with powerful new hybrid ion mobility and mass spectrometry systems has illustrated the great potential of nMS for structural biology. Fundamental to the progression of nMS has been the development of novel activation methods for dissociating proteins and protein complexes to deduce primary, secondary, tertiary, and quaternary structure through the combined use of multiple MS/MS technologies. This review highlights the key features and advantages of surface collisions (surface-induced dissociation, SID) for probing the connectivity of subunits within protein and nucleoprotein complexes and, in particular, for solving protein structure in conjunction with complementary techniques such as cryo-EM and computational modeling. Several case studies highlight the significant role SID, and more generally nMS, will play in structural elucidation of biological assemblies in the future as the technology becomes more widely adopted. Cases are presented where SID agrees with solved crystal or cryoEM structures or provides connectivity maps that are otherwise inaccessible by "gold standard" structural biology techniques.

Differentiation of leucine and isoleucine residues in peptides using charge transfer dissociation mass spectrometry (CTD-MS)

RATIONALE

The function of a protein or the binding affinity of an antibody can be substantially altered by the replacement of leucine (Leu) with isoleucine (Ile), and vice versa, so the ability to identify the correct isomer using mass spectrometry can help resolve important biological questions. Tandem mass spectrometry approaches for Leu/Ile (Xle) discrimination have been developed, but they all have certain limitations.

METHODS

Four model peptides and two wild-type peptide sequences containing either Leu or Ile residues were subjected to charge transfer dissociation (CTD) mass spectrometry on a modified three-dimensional ion trap. The peptides were analyzed in both the 1+ and 2+ charge states, and the results were compared to conventional collision-induced dissociation spectra of the same peptides obtained using the same instrument.

RESULTS

CTD resulted in 100% sequence coverage for each of the studied peptides and provided a variety of side-chain cleavages, including d, w and v ions. Using CTD, reliable d and w ions of Xle residues were observed more than 80% of the time. When present, d ions are typically greater than 10% of the abundance of the corresponding a ions from which they derive, and w ions are typically more abundant than the z ions from which they derive.

CONCLUSIONS

CTD has the benefit of being applicable to both 1+ and 2+ precursor ions, and the overall performance is comparable to that of other high-energy activation techniques like hot electron capture dissociation and UV photodissociation. CTD does not require chemical modifications of the precursor peptides, nor does it require additional levels of isolation and fragmentation.

Enhanced Top-Down Protein Characterization with Electron Capture Dissociation and Cyclic Ion Mobility Spectrometry

Tandem mass spectrometry of denatured, multiply charged high mass protein precursor ions yield extremely dense spectra with hundreds of broad and overlapping product ion isotopic distributions of differing charge states that yield an elevated baseline of unresolved "noise" centered about the precursor ion. Development of mass analyzers and signal processing methods to increase mass resolving power and manipulation of precursor and product ion charge through solution additives or ion-ion reactions have been thoroughly explored as solutions to spectral congestion. Here, we demonstrate the utility of electron capture dissociation (ECD) coupled with high-resolution cyclic ion mobility spectrometry (cIMS) to greatly increase top-down protein characterization capabilities. Congestion of protein ECD spectra was reduced using cIMS of the ECD product ions and "mobility fractions", that is, extracted mass spectra for segments of the 2D mobiligram (m/z versus drift time). For small proteins, such as ubiquitin (8.6 kDa), where mass resolving power was not the limiting factor for characterization, pre-IMS ECD and mobility fractions did not significantly increase protein sequence coverage, but an increase in the number of identified product ions was observed. However, a dramatic increase in performance, measured by protein sequence coverage, was observed for larger and more highly charged species, such as the +35 charge state of carbonic anhydrase (29 kDa). Pre-IMS ECD combined with mobility fractions yielded a 135% increase in the number of annotated isotope clusters and a 75% increase in unique product ions compared to processing without using the IMS dimension. These results yielded 89% sequence coverage for carbonic anhydrase.

Recent technological developments for native mass spectrometry

Native mass spectrometry (MS), the analysis of proteins and protein complexes from solutions that stabilize native solution structures, is a rapidly expanding area. There is strong evidence supporting the retention of proteins' native folds in the absence of solvent under the experimental timescales of MS experiments. Therefore, instrumentation has been developed to use gas-phase native-like protein ions to exploit the speed, sensitivity, and selectivity of mass spectrometry approaches to solve emerging problems in structural biology. This article reviews some of the recent advances and applications in gas-phase instrumentation for structural proteomics.

Determining Copper and Zinc Content in Superoxide Dismutase Using Electron Capture Dissociation Under Native Spray Conditions

Localizing metal binding to specific sites in proteins remains a challenging analytical problem in vitro and in vivo. Although metal binding can be maintained by "native" electrospray ionization with intact proteins for quantitation by mass spectrometry, subsequent fragmentation of proteins with slow-heating methods like collision-induced dissociation (CID) can scramble and detach metals. In contrast, electron capture dissociation (ECD) fragmentation produces highly localized bond cleavage that is well known to preserve posttranslational modifications. We show how a newly available ECD tool that can be retrofitted on standard QTOF mass spectrometers allows the sites of copper and zinc binding to be localized in the antioxidant enzyme Cu, Zn superoxide dismutase (SOD1). The loss of zinc from Cu, Zn SOD1 has been shown to induce motor neuron death and could have a causal role in the fatal neurodegenerative disease, amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). The methods described enable copper loss to be distinguished from zinc using distinct ECD fragments of SOD1 and are broadly applicable to other metalloproteins.

Extending Native Top-Down Electron Capture Dissociation to MDa Immunoglobulin Complexes Provides Useful Sequence Tags Covering Their Critical Variable Complementarity-Determining Regions

Native top-down mass spectrometry (MS) is gaining traction for the analysis and sequencing of intact proteins and protein assemblies, giving access to their mass and composition, as well as sequence information useful for identification. Herein, we extend and apply native top-down MS, using electron capture dissociation, to two submillion Da IgM- and IgG-based oligomeric immunoglobulins. Despite structural similarities, these two systems are quite different. The ∼895 kDa noncovalent IgG hexamer consists of six IgG subunits hexamerizing in solution due to three specifically engineered mutations in the Fc region, whereas the ∼935 kDa IgM oligomer results from the covalent assembly of one joining (J) chain and 5 IgM subunits into an asymmetric “pentamer” stabilized by interchain disulfide bridges. Notwithstanding their size, structural differences, and complexity, we observe that their top-down electron capture dissociation spectra are quite similar and straightforward to interpret, specifically providing informative sequence tags covering the highly variable CDR3s and FR4s of the Ig subunits they contain. Moreover, we show that the electron capture dissociation fragmentation spectra of immunoglobulin oligomers are essentially identical to those obtained for their respective monomers. Demonstrated for recombinantly produced systems, the approach described here opens up new prospects for the characterization and identification of IgMs circulating in plasma, which is important since IgMs play a critical role in the early immune response to pathogens such as viruses and bacteria.

Effective discrimination of gas-phase peptide conformers using TIMS-ECD-ToF MS/MS

In the present work, four, well-studied, model peptides (e.g., substance P, bradykinin, angiotensin I and AT-Hook 3) were used to correlate structural information provided by ion mobility and ECD/CID fragmentation in a TIMS-q-EMS-ToF MS/MS platform, incorporporating an electromagnetostatic cell (EMS). The structural heterogeneity of the model peptides was observed by (i) multi-component ion mobility profiles (high ion mobility resolving power, R ∼115-145), and (ii) fast online characteristic ECD fragmentation patterns per ion mobility band (∼0.2 min). Particularly, it was demonstrated that all investigated species were probably conformers, involving cis/trans-isomerizations at X-Pro peptide bond, following the same protonation schemes, in good agreement with previous ion mobility and single point mutation experiments. The comparison between ion mobility selected ECD spectra and traditional FT-ICR ECD MS/MS spectra showed comparable ECD fragmentation efficiencies but differences in the ratio of radical (˙)/prime (') fragment species (H˙ transfer), which were associated with the differences in detection time after the electron capture event. The analysis of model peptides using online TIMS-q-EMSToF MS/MS provided complementary structural information on the intramolecular interactions that stabilize the different gas-phase conformations to those obtained by ion mobility or ECD alone.

Sequential Ion-Ion Reactions for Enhanced Gas-Phase Sequencing of Large Intact Proteins in a Tribrid Orbitrap Mass Spectrometer

Obtaining extensive sequencing of an intact protein is essential in order to simultaneously determine both the nature and exact localization of chemical and genetic modifications which distinguish different proteoforms arising from the same gene. To effectively achieve such characterization, it is necessary to take advantage of the analytical potential offered by the top-down mass spectrometry approach to protein sequence analysis. However, as a protein increases in size, its gas-phase dissociation produces overlapping, low signal-to-noise fragments. The application of advanced ion dissociation techniques such as electron transfer dissociation (ETD) and ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) can improve the sequencing results compared to slow-heating techniques such as collisional dissociation; nonetheless, even ETD- and UVPD-based approaches have thus far fallen short in their capacity to reliably enable extensive sequencing of proteoforms ≥30 kDa. To overcome this issue, we have applied proton transfer charge reduction (PTCR) to limit signal overlap in tandem mass spectra (MS²) produced by ETD (alone or with supplemental ion activation, EThcD). Compared to conventional MS² experiments, following ETD/EThcD MS² with PTCR MS³ prior to m/z analysis of deprotonated product ions in the Orbitrap mass analyzer proved beneficial for the identification of additional large protein fragments (≥10 kDa), thus improving the overall sequencing and in particular the coverage of the central portion of all four analyzed proteins spanning from 29 to 56 kDa. Specifically, PTCR-based data acquisition led to 39% sequence coverage for the 56 kDa glutamate dehydrogenase, which was further increased to 44% by combining fragments obtained via HCD followed by PTCR MS³.

Analysis of intact proteins with capillary zone electrophoresis coupled to mass spectromery using uncoated and coated capillaries

Although, in general, the application of coated capillaries is recommended for the separation of intact proteins, bare silica capillary is still the most often used capillary due to its simplicity and cheapness. In this work, the performance of bare fused silica capillary for intact protein analysis was compared to that of different (dynamically coated polybrene (PB) and permanently coated linear polyacrylamide (LPA)) coated capillaries using capillary zone electrophoresis - mass spectrometry (CZE-MS). In cases where low pH (pH=1.8) was used in bare silica capillaries, good precision (0.56-0.78 RSD% and 1.7-6.5 RSD% for migration times and peak areas, respectively), minimal adsorption and separation efficiency (N= 27 000/m - 322 000/m) similar to or even better than those obtained with the coated capillaries (created by an intricate multi-step process) was achieved. The PB and the LPA capillaries demonstrated their slightly better resolving power in terms of separating the different forms/variants of the same protein (e.g., hemoglobin subunits). Among the studied capillaries the one with LPA coating showed the most stable separations in the long term (n=25: 0.18-0.49 RSD% and 3.1-4.9 RSD% for migration times and peak areas, respectively). For the separation of a few proteins or even a larger number of proteins in biological samples (e.g., snake venom) the application of the simple and cheap bare fused silica capillary can be considered as an efficient choice.

Improved Protein and PTM Characterization with a Practical Electron-Based Fragmentation on Q-TOF Instruments

Electron-based dissociation (ExD) produces uncluttered mass spectra of intact proteins while preserving labile post-translational modifications. However, technical challenges have limited this option to only a few high-end mass spectrometers. We have developed an efficient ExD cell that can be retrofitted in less than an hour into current LC/Q-TOF instruments. Supporting software has been developed to acquire, process, and annotate peptide and protein ExD fragmentation spectra. In addition to producing complementary fragmentation, ExD spectra enable many isobaric leucine/isoleucine and isoaspartate/aspartate pairs to be distinguished by side-chain fragmentation. The ExD cell preserves phosphorylation and glycosylation modifications. It also fragments longer peptides more efficiently to reveal signaling cross-talk between multiple post-translational modifications on the same protein chain and cleaves disulfide bonds in cystine knotted proteins and intact antibodies. The ability of the ExD cell to combine collisional activation with electron fragmentation enables more complete sequence coverage by disrupting intramolecular electrostatic interactions that can hold fragments of large peptides and proteins together. These enhanced capabilities made possible by the ExD cell expand the size of peptides and proteins that can be analyzed as well as the analytical certainty of characterizing their post-translational modifications.

In Silico Reagent Design for Electron-Transfer Dissociation on a Q-TOF

Electron-transfer dissociation is an important technique capable of probing the primary and higher order structure of a wide variety of biomolecules and yielding information that is often inaccessible using other common MS methods. The source of the electron used to initiate the fragmentation event is a radical anion, and the fragmentation process therefore depends intimately on the electronic properties of both the reagent and analyte ions. A good reagent must ionize easily and be sufficiently robust to survive transport to the reaction location, but must also be capable of donating an electron to analyte cations efficiently enough to overcome competition with other ion-ion reaction channels. Inspired by the work of Gunawardena et al. ( J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2005, 127, 12627), an in silico workflow to allow prescreening of potential electron-transfer reagents for use in glow-discharge sources is described. Approximately 150 candidate molecules have been characterized using this workflow. We discuss in detail the properties of a selected subset of singly and doubly substituted benzenes and introduce five effective new reagents that have been identified as a result of this work.

Proteoform Differentiation using Tandem Trapped Ion Mobility, Electron Capture Dissociation, and ToF Mass Spectrometry

Comprehensive characterization of post-translationally modified histone proteoforms is challenging due to their high isobaric and isomeric content. Trapped ion mobility spectrometry (TIMS), implemented on a quadrupole/time-of-flight (Q-ToF) mass spectrometer, has shown great promise in discriminating isomeric complete histone tails. The absence of electron activated dissociation (ExD) in the current platform prevents the comprehensive characterization of unknown histone proteoforms. In the present work, we report for the first time the use of an electromagnetostatic (EMS) cell devised for nonergodic dissociation based on electron capture dissociation (ECD), implemented within a nESI-TIMS-Q-ToF mass spectrometer for the characterization of acetylated (AcK18 and AcK27) and trimethylated (TriMetK4, TriMetK9 and TriMetK27) complete histone tails. The integration of the EMS cell in a TIMS-q-TOF MS permitted fast mobility-selected top-down ECD fragmentation with near 10% efficiency overall. The potential of this coupling was illustrated using isobaric (AcK18/TriMetK4) and isomeric (AcK18/AcK27 and TriMetK4/TriMetK9) binary H3 histone tail mixtures, and the H3.1 TriMetK27 histone tail structural diversity (e.g., three IMS bands at z = 7+). The binary isobaric and isomeric mixtures can be separated in the mobility domain with R_IMS > 100 and the nonergodic ECD fragmentation permitted the PTM localization (sequence coverage of ∼86%). Differences in the ECD patterns per mobility band of the z = 7+ H3 TriMetK27 molecular ions suggested that the charge location is responsible for the structural differences observed in the mobility domain. This coupling further enhances the structural toolbox with fast, high resolution mobility separations in tandem with nonergodic fragmentation for effective proteoform differentiation.

Capillary Zone Electrophoresis-Electron-Capture Collision-Induced Dissociation on a Quadrupole Time-of-Flight Mass Spectrometer for Top-Down Characterization of Intact Proteins

Mass spectrometry (MS)-based denaturing top-down proteomics (dTDP) requires high-capacity separation and extensive gas-phase fragmentation of proteoforms. Herein, we coupled capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE) to electron-capture collision-induced dissociation (ECciD) on an Agilent 6545 XT quadrupole time-of-flight (Q-TOF) mass spectrometer for dTDP for the first time. During ECciD, the protein ions were first fragmented using ECD, followed by further activation and fragmentation by applying a CID potential. In this pilot study, we optimized the CZE-ECciD method for small proteins (lower than 20 kDa) regarding the charge state of protein parent ions for fragmentation and the CID potential applied to maximize the protein backbone cleavage coverage and the number of sequence-informative fragment ions. The CZE-ECciD Q-TOF platform provided extensive backbone cleavage coverage for three standard proteins lower than 20 kDa from only single charge states in a single CZE-MS/MS run in the targeted MS/MS mode, including ubiquitin (97%, +7, 8.6 kDa), superoxide dismutase (SOD, 87%, +17, 16 kDa), and myoglobin (90%, +16, 17 kDa). The CZE-ECciD method produced comparable cleavage coverage of small proteins (i.e., myoglobin) with direct-infusion MS studies using electron transfer dissociation (ETD), activated ion-ETD, and combinations of ETD and collision-based fragmentation on high-end orbitrap mass spectrometers. The results render CZE-ECciD a new tool for dTDP to enhance both separation and gas-phase fragmentation of proteoforms.

Gas-Phase Ion/Ion Chemistry for Structurally Sensitive Probes of Gaseous Protein Ion Structure: Electrostatic and Electrostatic to Covalent Cross-Linking

Intramolecular interactions within a protein are key in maintaining protein tertiary structure and understanding how proteins function. Ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IM-MS) has become a widely used approach in structural biology since it provides rapid measurements of collision cross sections (CCS), which inform on the gas-phase conformation of the biomolecule under study. Gas-phase ion/ion reactions target amino acid residues with specific chemical properties and the modified sites can be identified by MS. In this study, electrostatically reactive, gas-phase ion/ion chemistry and IM-MS are combined to characterize the structural changes between ubiquitin electrosprayed from aqueous and denaturing conditions. The electrostatic attachment of sulfo-NHS acetate to ubiquitin via ion/ion reactions and fragmentation by electron-capture dissociation (ECD) provide the identification of the most accessible protonated sites within ubiquitin as the sulfonate group forms an electrostatic complex with accessible protonated side chains. The protonated sites identified by ECD from the different solution conditions are distinct and, in some cases, reflect the disruption of interactions such as salt bridges that maintain the native protein structure. This agrees with previously published literature demonstrating that a high methanol concentration at low pH causes the structure of ubiquitin to change from a native (N) state to a more elongated A state. Results using gas-phase, electrostatic cross-linking reagents also point to similar structural changes and further confirm the role of methanol and acid in favoring a more unfolded conformation. Since cross-linking reagents have a distance constraint for the two reactive sites, the data is valuable in guiding computational structures generated by molecular dynamics. The research presented here describes a promising strategy that can detect subtle changes in the local environment of targeted amino acid residues to inform on changes in the overall protein structure.

Tandem surface-induced dissociation of protein complexes on an ultrahigh resolution platform

We describe instrumentation for conducting tandem surface-induced dissociation (tSID) of native protein complexes on an ultrahigh resolution Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (FT-ICR) mass spectrometer. The two stages of SID are accomplished with split lenses replacing the entrance lenses of the quadrupole mass filter (stage 1, referred to herein as SID-Q) and the collision cell (stage 2, Q-SID). After SID-Q, the scattered projectile ions and subcomplexes formed in transit traverse the 20 mm pre-filter prior to the mass-selecting quadrupole, providing preliminary insights into the SID fragmentation kinetics of noncovalent protein complexes. The isolated SID fragments (subcomplexes) are then fragmented by SID in the collision cell entrance lens (Q-SID), generating subcomplexes of subcomplexes. We show that the ultrahigh resolution of the FT-ICR can be used for deconvolving species overlapping in m/z, which are particularly prominent in tandem SID spectra due to the combination of symmetric charge partitioning and narrow product ion charge state distributions. Various protein complex topologies are explored, including homotetramers, homopentamers, a homohexamer, and a heterohexamer.

Developments in tandem ion mobility mass spectrometry

Ion Mobility (IM) coupled to mass spectrometry (MS) is a useful tool for separating species of interest out of small quantities of heterogenous mixtures via a combination of m/z and molecular shape. While tandem MS instruments are common, instruments which employ tandem IM are less so with the first commercial IM-MS instrument capable of multiple IM selection rounds being released in 2019. Here we explore the history of tandem IM instruments, recent developments, the applications to biological systems and expected future directions.

Enhanced Collision Induced Unfolding and Electron Capture Dissociation of Native-like Protein Ions

Native ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IM-MS) is capable of revealing much that remains unknown within the structural proteome, promising such information on refractory protein targets. Here, we report the development of a unique drift tube IM-MS (DTIM-MS) platform, which combines high-energy source optics for improved collision induced unfolding (CIU) experiments and an electromagnetostatic cell for electron capture dissociation (ECD). We measured a series of high precision collision cross section (CCS) values for protein and protein complex ions ranging from 6-1600 kDa, exhibiting an average relative standard deviation (RSD) of 0.43 ± 0.20%. Furthermore, we compare our CCS results to previously reported DTIM values, finding strong agreement across similarly configured instrumentation (average RSD of 0.82 ± 0.73%), and systematic differences for DTIM CCS values commonly used to calibrate traveling-wave IM separators (-3% average RSD). Our CIU experiments reveal that the modified DTIM-MS instrument described here achieves enhanced levels of ion activation when compared with any previously reported IM-MS platforms, allowing for comprehensive unfolding of large multiprotein complex ions as well as interplatform CIU comparisons. Using our modified DTIM instrument, we studied two protein complexes. The enhanced CIU capabilities enable us to study the gas phase stability of the GroEL 7-mer and 14-mer complexes. Finally, we report CIU-ECD experiments for the alcohol dehydrogenase tetramer, demonstrating improved sequence coverage by combining ECD fragmentation integrated over multiple CIU intermediates. Further improvements for such native top-down sequencing experiments were possible by leveraging IM separation, which enabled us to separate and analyze CID and ECD fragmentation simultaneously.

Higher-order structural characterisation of native proteins and complexes by top-down mass spectrometry

In biology, it can be argued that if the genome contains the script for a cell's life cycle, then the proteome constitutes an ensemble cast of actors that brings these instructions to life. Their interactions with each other, co-factors, ligands, substrates, and so on, are key to understanding nearly any biological process. Mass spectrometry is well established as the method of choice to determine protein primary structure and location of post-translational modifications. In recent years, top-down fragmentation of intact proteins has been increasingly combined with ionisation of noncovalent assemblies under non-denaturing conditions, i.e., native mass spectrometry. Sequence, post-translational modifications, ligand/metal binding, protein folding, and complex stoichiometry can thus all be probed directly. Here, we review recent developments in this new and exciting field of research. While this work is written primarily from a mass spectrometry perspective, it is targeted to all bioanalytical scientists who are interested in applying these methods to their own biochemistry and chemical biology research.

Recent progress in the analysis of protein deamidation using mass spectrometry

Deamidation is a nonenzymatic and spontaneous posttranslational modification (PTM) that introduces changes in both structure and charge of proteins, strongly associated with aging proteome instability and degenerative diseases. Deamidation is also a common PTM occurring in biopharmaceutical proteins, representing a major cause of degradation. Therefore, characterization of deamidation alongside its inter-related modifications, isomerization and racemization, is critically important to understand their roles in protein stability and diseases. Mass spectrometry (MS) has become an indispensable tool in site-specific identification of PTMs for proteomics and structural studies. In this review, we focus on the recent advances of MS analysis in protein deamidation. In particular, we provide an update on sample preparation, chromatographic separation, and MS technologies at multi-level scales, for accurate and reliable characterization of protein deamidation in both simple and complex biological samples, yielding important new insight on how deamidation together with isomerization and racemization occurs. These technological progresses will lead to a better understanding of how deamidation contributes to the pathology of aging and other degenerative diseases and the development of biopharmaceutical drugs.