Using Zn Isotopic Signatures for Source Identification in a Contaminated Estuary of Southern China

Detangling past and modern zinc anthropogenic source contributions in an urbanized coastal river by combining elemental, isotope and speciation approaches

The accumulation of trace metals in the environmental compartments of coastal rivers is a global and complex environmental issue, requiring multiple tools to constrain the various anthropogenic sources and biogeochemical processes affecting the water quality of these environments. The Valao fluvio-estuarine system (Rio de Janeiro, Brazil) presents a challenging case of a coastal river contaminated by both modern and historical anthropogenic metal sources, located in the land and in the intra-estuary, continuously mixed by tidal cycles. This study employed a combination of spatial distribution analysis of trace metals including gadolinium (Gd), zinc (Zn) isotopic analyses, and X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) to distinguish between these sources. The concentrations of metals in both dissolved (water samples) and surficial sediment compartments (Suspended Particulate Matter and sediment samples) display an overall enrichment trend from upstream to downstream. Multivariate statistical analysis allows to discriminate geogenic elements derived from watershed geology (Ti, K, and Mg) vs anthropogenic contaminants from urban runoff and domestic sewage discharges (Cu, Cr, Pb, Zn, and Gd); and legacy metal contaminants (Zn and Cd) remobilized from ancient metallurgical wastes and transported upstream in the estuary during tidal cycles. The anthropogenic Gd concentration in the dissolved compartment increases along the watercourse, highlighting continuous ongoing sewage discharge. Zinc solid speciation also indicates that Zn contribution from legacy metallurgy waste is primarily associated with sulfide-Zn and Zn-phyllosilicate in the outlet estuary, while in upstream sediments of fluvio-estuarine system, Zn is found bound to organic matter. Zinc isotope systematically reveals a progressive downstream shift to heavier isotope compositions. Upstream, the relatively pristine site and the urbanized section of the river exhibit a relatively uniform δ66/64Zn value (+0.20 ± 0.07 ‰) in suspended particulate matter (SPM) and surficial sediments. These results indicate that domestic sewage discharges contribute to Zn enrichment in sediments of the Valao fluvio-estuarine system but without modifying its isotope signature in sediments. The sediment of the downstream estuarine section shows a heavier δ66/64Zn value (+0.48 ± 0.08 ‰), indicating the strong influence of the intra-estuarine source identified as the historical metallurgic contamination. An integrated view of the geochemical tracers allows thus inferring that the untreated sewage and legacy metallurgical contamination are the primary sources of anthropogenic Zn contamination. It highlights the progressive mixing along the estuarine gradient under tidal dynamics. The influence of the former source continuously expands from the headland towards the estuary.

Trace metal partitioning in the parnaíba delta in dry season, equatorial coast of Brazil

Trace metal concentrations in the particulate fractions (MP), dissolved fractions (MD) and sediments (MS), such as Ba, Cu, Co, Cr, Pb, Ni and Zn, were determined during the dry season of the largest open sea delta of Americas, the Parnaíba River Delta (Brazil). This study aimed to comprehend the distribution, dynamic changes of metal speciation and environmental quality index of trace metals in the particulate fractions and subsurface sediments in scenario of major marine influence over the delta. The trace metals bound to suspended particulate material (SPM) from weathering the drainage basin exhibited a removal trend under increases in salinity and pH. Desorption influenced the partitioning of BaMP, ZnMP, NiMP, CoMP, CuMP, and the adsorption and precipitation of PbMP and CrMP to the surface sediments. The organic matter contents in the sediments acts as an important geochemical carrier of these contaminants, and the dissolved organic carbon influences the binding of PbMD in the subsurface waters. The geoaccumulation index (Igeo) plays a crucial role in revealing potential contamination with ZnMP contents and weak association to this fraction. These results make possible the assessment of ecological risk by metal contamination and global pollution mitigation in coastal tidal estuaries under intensive physical mixing along the equatorial coast.

Advances in the application of metallic isotopes to the identification of contaminant sources in environmental geochemistry

The development of the economy and society makes heavy metals (HMs) pollution more and more serious. And, pollution source identification is the primary work of environmental pollution control and land planning. Notably, stable isotope technology has a high ability to distinguish pollution sources, and can better reflect the migration behavior and contribution of HMs from diverse sources, which has become a hot research tool for pollution source identification of HMs. Currently, the rapid development of isotope analysis technology provides a relatively reliable reference for pollution tracking. Based on this background, the fractionation mechanism of stable isotopes and the influence of environmental processes on isotope fractionation are reviewed. Furthermore, the processes and requirements for the measurement of metal stable isotope ratios are summarized, and the calibration methods and detection accuracy of sample measurement are evaluated. Besides, the current commonly used binary model and multi-mixed models in the identification of contaminant sources are also concluded. Moreover, the isotopic changes of different metallic elements under natural and anthropogenic conditions are discussed in detail, and the application prospects of multi-isotope coupling in the traceability of environmental geochemistry are evaluated. This work has some guidance for the application of stable isotopes in the source identification of environmental pollution.

Zinc Stable Isotope Fractionation Mechanisms during Adsorption on and Substitution in Iron (Hydr)oxides

The Zn isotope fingerprint is widely used as a proxy of various environmental geochemical processes, so it is crucial to determine which are the mechanisms responsible for isotopic fractionation. Iron (Fe) (hydr)oxides greatly control the cycling and fate and thus isotope fractionation factors of Zn in terrestrial environments. Here, Zn isotope fractionation and related mechanisms during adsorption on and substitution in three FeOOH polymorphs are explored. Results demonstrate that heavy Zn isotopes are preferentially enriched onto solids, with almost similar isotopic offsets (Δ^66/64Zn_{solid-solution} = 0.25-0.36‰) for goethite, lepidocrocite, and feroxyhyte. This is consistent with the same average Zn-O bond lengths for adsorbed Zn on these solids as revealed by Zn K-edge X-ray absorption fine structure spectroscopy. In contrast, at an initial Zn/Fe molar ratio of 0.02, incorporation of Zn into goethite and lepidocrocite by substituting for lattice Fe preferentially sequesters light Zn isotopes with Δ^66/64Zn_{substituted-stock solution} of -1.52 ± 0.09‰ and -1.18 ± 0.15‰, while Zn-substituted feroxyhyte (0.06 ± 0.11‰) indicates almost no isotope fractionation. This is closely related to the different crystal nucleation and growth rates during the Zn-doped FeOOH formation processes. These results provide direct experimental evidence of incorporation of isotopically light Zn into Fe (hydr)oxides and improve our understanding of Zn isotope fractionation mechanisms during mineral-solution interface processes.

Saltwater intrusion regulates the distribution and partitioning of heavy metals in water in a dynamic estuary, South China

The mixing processes of fresh-salt water in estuarine and coastal regions have a substantial impact on the characteristics of heavy metals. A study was conducted in the Pearl River Estuary (PRE), located in South China, to examine the distribution and partitioning of heavy metals and the factors that influence their presence. Results showed that the hydrodynamic force, caused by the landward intrusion of the salt wedge, was the major contributor to the aggregation of heavy metals in the northern and western PRE. Conversely, metals were diffused seaward at lower concentrations along the plume flow in surface water. The study found that some metals, including Fe, Mn, Zn and Pb, were significantly higher in surface water than in bottom water in eastern waters, but the reverse was true in the southern offshore area, where limited mixing hindered the vertical transfer of metals in the water column. The partitioning coefficients (K_D) of metals varied, with Fe exhibiting the highest K_D (1038 ± 1093 L/g), followed by Zn (579 ± 482 L/g) and Mn (216 ± 224). The highest K_D values of metals in surface water were observed in the west coast, while the highest K_D in bottom water was found in eastern areas. Furthermore, re-suspension of sediment and the mixing of seawater and freshwater offshore, caused by seawater intrusion, resulted in the partitioning of Cu, Ni and Zn towards particulate phases in offshore waters. This study provides valuable insights into the migration and transformation of heavy metals in dynamic estuaries influenced by the interaction of freshwater and saltwater and highlights the importance of continued research in this field.

Insights into the kinetic regulation of Zn bioaccumulation at trace levels: Lighting up Saccharomycescerevisiae

Zn displays a double-edged effect by acting both as a micronutrient and a toxic metal, and quantitative analysis of its kinetic flux under low environmental concentrations is critical to understand its intracellular regulation. In the present study, we employed a Zn sensitive model eukaryote, the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, which responded to intracellular Zn levels by increasing its autofluorescence, to quantify Zn influx, transportation between labile and storage pools, and efflux under different Zn exposure levels (<1 μM). We demonstrated that the yeast regulated Zn uptake from the extracellular source by a gradually decreased accumulation following an initial high accumulation rate. The subsequent reduced accumulation rate resulted in a steady-state Zn accumulation at 0.061 and 0.073 μg Zn/μg P as the threshold values for the control yeast and Zn-depleted yeast, respectively, independently of the extracellular Zn concentration. Compared with the control yeast, the Zn-depleted yeast possessed a higher accumulation rate, but the difference of bioaccumulation was maintained at approximately 0.01 μg Zn/μg P under different concentrations of extracellular Zn. In contrast, transportation between labile Zn and storage Zn pools or Zn efflux to the extracellular environment was not obvious after Zn exposure, indicating that the Zn dose was below a basal requirement. Such stabilized Zn accumulation was only induced by controlling the Zn influx at the bio-interface. With the novel monitoring of the kinetic changes of autofluorescence, our study demonstrated a remarkably tight Zn regulation system in yeast, providing enlightenment for Zn homeostasis in eukaryotes under low Zn exposure in aqueous environments.

Occurrence, partition, and risk of four adjacent transition metals in seawater, sediments and demersal fish from the Pearl River Estuary, South China Sea

The spatio-seasonal variation, bioaccumulation and potential ecological risk of four metals (Co, Ni, Cu and Zn) in the multi-media of the Pearl River Estuary (PRE) were assessed. The degree of contamination and ecological risk of the four metals followed this pattern: Cu > Zn > Ni > Co, upstream > downstream, wet season > dry season. There were non-linear and linear correlations for Co, linear and non-linear correlations for Ni, and non-linear and no correlation for both Cu and Zn, between metals in bottom water or bioavailable concentrations in sediment and fish muscle. Co and Ni showed lightly polluted levels; Cu and Zn showed heavily polluted levels. This study demonstrates a tendency of cross-accumulation in fish of these four transition metals within specific habitats of the PRE.

Zinc in soil reflecting the intensive coal mining activities: Evidence from stable zinc isotopes analysis

In the mining area affected by coal mining activities for a long time, heavy metal Zn pollution poses a serious threat to soil quality and human health, and direct evidence showing the relationship between Zn accumulation mechanism in soils and mining activities is lacking. In this study, the Zn content and isotopes composition (δ⁶⁶Zn) from soil and environmental samples around mining area were determined and analyzed to clarify the Zn characteristics in soil. Moreover, the distribution and source of Zn content in soil of mining area were analyzed by mathematical statistics, correlation analysis and isotope mass mixing model. The results showed that: (1) the Zn content in soil ranged from 95 to 327 mg·kg^-1 (mean: 233 mg·kg^-1), exceeding the control point and the soil background value of Anhui Province; (2) the results of Zn isotope analysis showed that Zn in soil mainly derived from the wind dispersion input of fine particles in gangue and fly ash, followed by the natural weathering of parent material; (3) isotopic mass mixing model can be used to distinguish the contribution of anthropogenic and natural Zn sources. Mining input was the main contribution source of Zn in soil (mean: 67%), followed by natural background (mean: 33%). The employment of Zn isotopes can effectively evaluate the impact of anthropogenic and natural long-term processes on Zn in the soil of the mining area, and provide important information for the formulation of soil metal pollution control measures.

Heavy metals and Pb isotopes in a marine sediment core record environmental changes and anthropogenic activities in the Pearl River Delta over a century

Heavy metal accumulation in marine sediments is associated with changes in both the natural environment and human activities. This study used heavy metals and Pb isotopes in a precisely dated (by ²¹⁰Pb and ¹³⁷Cs) sediment core from the Macao Sea to reconstruct the historical changes in anthropogenic activities and the environment in the western Pearl River Estuary (PRE). The distribution of heavy metals in the sediment core could be divided into four stages (pre-1950, 1950-1976, 1976-2000, and post-2000), which corresponded to the changes in anthropogenic activities and environment of the Pearl River Delta during the past 100 years. The contribution of anthropogenic metals (Pb and Zn) in the sediments increased gradually over time. However, the concentrations, enrichment factors, and fluxes of heavy metals in the sediments all displayed a downward trend since 2010, revealing a decline in metal pollutant input due to strict emission reduction policies implemented in the last decade. The Pb isotopes in the sediments showed a similar trajectory to the heavy metals, reflecting the changes in Pb sources in the sediments at different stages. Based on a binary Pb isotope mixing model, the calculated proportions of anthropogenic and natural Pb in the sediments were 0-50.9% (mean 15.9%) and 49.1-100% (mean 84.1%), respectively, suggesting that the Pb in the PRE sediments is mainly controlled by natural sources.

Tracing and quantifying the sources of heavy metals in the upper and middle reaches of the Pearl River Basin: New insights from Sr-Nd-Pb multi-isotopic systems

A method based on Sr, Nd and Pb multi-isotopic systems indicates that the different rock types (carbonate rock, basalt and black rock series) and sulfide deposits exposed in the Pearl River Basin show markedly different Sr, Nd and Pb isotopic characteristics. By establishing the mass balance equations of heavy metal content and isotope ratios, we use the inverse method to obtain the contribution that natural weathering of carbonate rocks, basalts and black rock series as well as the mining of sulfide deposits have on heavy metal content in riverbed sediments in the Pearl River Basin. Even though carbonate rocks constitute more than 60% of the exposed area in the upper reaches of the Pearl River Basin, this lithology only contributes 9% of the heavy metal content in sediments due to the relatively low content of heavy metals found in this rock type. Basalt weathering on average contributes 64% of the Cr content and 42% of the Ni content found in the sediments, while 53% of the Cd content is derived from the weathering of the black rock series. The negative impact mining has on this environment cannot be ignored as it is the most important source of As (71%) and Pb (60%) in all samples. This is especially the case in the Diaojiang River Basin, where sulfide mining activities still contribute more than 90% of the content of Zn, Pb, Cd and As within the sediments even though many mining sites have been closed since 2000.

Distinguishing multiple Zn sources in oysters in a complex estuarine system using Zn isotope ratio signatures

The Pearl River Estuary (PRE), the largest estuary in Southern China, historically has suffered from metal contamination as a result of inputs from different riverine discharges. Determining the sources of metals accumulation in local aquatic flora and fauna remains a great challenge for this estuarine system with complex water circulation. In this study, Zn isotope ratios were measured in local oysters (Crassostrea hongkongensis) collected at 8 locations in the estuary on four occasions from 2014 to 2018, to better understand and assess the contamination sources. The results showed no significant differences (p < 0.05) in δ⁶⁶Zn values in oysters among the four sampling dates within individual sites. However, approximately a 0.67‰ (range from -0.66‰ to 0.01‰) difference in average δ⁶⁶Zn values was consistently found in oysters collected from the east side of the estuary compared to the west side, despite their comparable Zn concentrations. A mixing model was subsequently used to estimate the relative contributions from various sources to the δ⁶⁶Zn values in these oysters. The mixing model predicts that zinc derived from the dissolved fraction (approximately 80 %) was the dominant uptake pathway for oysters collected at the east shore whereas approximately 50 % of the Zn in oysters collected at the west shore was derived from the particulate fraction. The mixing model also was used to estimate the relative impacts of fresh versus saline water on the measured δ⁶⁶Zn values. Contributions from these two sources also varied between the east and west shores. This study presents the first data for Zn isotope ratios in oysters from the PRE, providing new insight for using Zn isotope ratios in oysters as a powerful tracer of sources in a complex estuarine system.

Zinc source differentiation in hydrothermal vent mollusks: Insight from Zn isotope ratios

Hydrothermal vent represents an extreme environment where metal-enriched fluids are in contact with chemosymbiotic animals. In the present study, Zn isotopic compositions were determined in multiple tissues of three dominant hydrothermal vent mollusks (the mussel Bathymodiolus marisindicus and two gastropods Chrysomallon squamiferum and Gigantopelta aegis) collected from a hydrothermal vent field (Southwest Indian Ridge in the Indian Ocean). We found approximately 1.78‰ differences in the δ⁶⁶Zn values among the three vent mollusks despite of their similar range of Zn concentrations. The significant variation in the δ⁶⁶Zn values was considered to be indicative of different Zn uptake sources among the three species as a result of their morphological adaptations. Zinc uptake associated with symbiotic activities may be more relevant in the vent gastropods, whereas Zn uptake from hydrothermal fluids during filter-feeding may also play a role in the vent mussels. However, no significant difference in δ⁶⁶Zn values was observed among tissues of any of the mollusks, showing the absence of Zn isotope fractionation during internal Zn transport. Our results demonstrated that variable Zn uptake pathways existed among different hydrothermal vent mollusks and could be differentiated by determining the Zn isotopic compositions in their tissues. We also highlight that Zn isotope ratios can be used to track Zn sources to the vent mollusks.

Catchment Runoff in Industrial Areas Exports Legacy Pollutant Zinc from the Topsoil Rather than Geogenic Zn

In highly industrialized, densely populated parts of Central Europe, mobilization of legacy Zn pollution from forest ecosystems may negatively affect the quality of water resources. To test this hypothesis, we determined the ⁶⁶Zn/⁶⁴Zn isotope ratios of 15 Zn reservoirs and fluxes in an acidified, spruce die-back affected mountain-slope catchment in northern Czech Republic. The δ⁶⁶Zn values of precipitation, organic horizon, and runoff were statistically indistinguishable. In contrast, δ⁶⁶Zn values of bedrock orthogneiss and mineral soil were significantly different from δ⁶⁶Zn values of runoff. The magnitude of within-site Zn isotope fractionations appeared to be relatively small. Despite the large potential source of Zn in bedrock, runoff exported mostly young pollutant Zn that had been temporarily stored in the organic horizon. This conclusion was corroborated by comparing Zn input-output mass balances in the polluted northern catchment and in a relatively unpolluted catchment situated 250 km to the south. Seven-times higher Zn export via runoff at the northern site was controlled by a combination of 10-times higher atmospheric Zn input and five-times higher DOC leaching, compared to the southern site. In industrial areas, atmospherically deposited Zn is leached from headwater catchments in a direct analogy to leaching of highly toxic pollutant Pb.