Discovery of Novel Peptidomimetic Boronate ClpP Inhibitors with Noncanonical Enzyme Mechanism as Potent Virulence Blockers in Vitro and in Vivo

The therapeutic potential of indole hybrids, dimers, and trimers against drug-resistant ESKAPE pathogens

Enterococcus faecium, Staphylococcus aureus, Klebsiella pneumoniae, Acinetobacter baumannii, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, and Enterobacter (ESKAPE) species as causative agents are characterized by increased levels of resistance toward multiple classes of first-line as well as last-resort antibiotics and represent serious global health concerns, creating a critical need for the development of novel antibacterials with therapeutic potential against drug-resistant ESKAPE species. Indole derivatives with structural and mechanistic diversity demonstrated broad-spectrum antibacterial activity against various clinically important pathogens including drug-resistant ESKAPE. Moreover, several indole-based agents that are exemplified by creatmycin have already been used in clinics or under clinical trials for the treatment of bacterial infections, demonstrating that indole derivatives hold great promise for the development of novel antibacterials. This review is an endeavor to highlight the current scenario of indole hybrids, dimers, and trimers with therapeutic potential against drug-resistant ESKAPE pathogens, covering articles published from 2020 to the present, to open new avenues for the exploration of novel antidrug-resistant ESKAPE candidates.

Patenting perspective of modulators of ClpP endopeptidase: 2019-present

INTRODUCTION

ClpP is a highly conserved serine protease that plays a crucial role in maintaining protein homeostasis in both bacterial cells and human mitochondria. Several studies have demonstrated the potential of ClpP as a drug target, with ClpP modulators, including both inhibitors and activators, showing promise in treating a range of conditions such as drug-resistant bacteria, malignant cancers, and fatty liver disease.

AREA COVERED

This review provides an overview of patents related to ClpP modulators filed over the last five years, detailing their claims and therapeutic applications. The sources of patent information included databases of the European Patent Office, the China Patent Office and the U.S.A. patent Office, while relevant research articles were accessed through PubMed.

EXPERT OPINION

The number of patents concerning ClpP modulators is on the rise, reflecting advancements in related research. By summarizing and outlining relevant patents, we aim to stimulate further interest among researchers, ultimately leading to the development of effective drugs based on ClpP modulators. The broad spectrum of diseases associated with ClpP dysfunction underscores the potential for ClpP modulators to address a wide range of therapeutic needs.

Protein degradation by a component of the chaperonin-linked protease ClpP

In cells, proteins are synthesized, function, and degraded (dead). Protein synthesis (spring) is important for the life of proteins. However, how proteins die is equally important for organisms. Proteases are secreted from cells and used as nutrients to break down external proteins. Proteases degrade unwanted and harmful cellular proteins. In eukaryotes, a large enzyme complex called the proteasome is primarily responsible for cellular protein degradation. Prokaryotes, such as bacteria, have similar protein degradation systems. In this review, we describe the structure and function of the ClpXP complex in the degradation system, which is an ATP-dependent protease in bacterial cells, with a particular focus on ClpP.

Discovery and Optimization of Novel SaFabI Inhibitors as Specific Therapeutic Agents for MRSA Infection

As the rate-limiting enzyme in fatty acid biosynthesis, Staphylococcus aureus enoyl-acyl carrier protein reductase (SaFabI) emerges as a compelling target for combating methicillin-resistant S. aureus (MRSA) infections. Herein, compound 1, featuring a 4-(1H-benzo[d]imidazol-2-yl)pyrrolidin-2-one scaffold, was identified as a potent SaFabI inhibitor (IC50 = 976.8 nM) from an in-house library. Subsequent optimization yielded compound n31, with improved inhibitory efficacy on enzymatic activity (IC50 = 174.2 nM) and selective potency against S. aureus (MIC = 1-2 μg/mL). Mechanistically, n31 directly inhibited SaFabI in cellular contexts. Moreover, n31 exhibited favorable safety and pharmacokinetic profiles, and dose-dependently treated MRSA-induced skin infections, outperforming the approved drug, linezolid. The chiral separation of n31 resulted in (S)-n31, with superior activities (IC50 = 94.0 nM, MIC = 0.25-1 μg/mL) and in vivo therapeutic efficacy. In brief, our research proposes (S)-n31 as a promising candidate for SaFabI-targeted therapy, offering specific anti-S. aureus efficacy and potential for further development.

Molecular insights into the dynamic modulation of bacterial ClpP function and oligomerization by peptidomimetic boronate compounds

Bacterial caseinolytic protease P subunit (ClpP) is important and vital for cell survival and infectivity. Recent publications describe and discuss the complex structure-function relationship of ClpP and its processive activity mediated by 14 catalytic sites. Even so, there are several aspects yet to be further elucidated, such as the paradoxical allosteric modulation of ClpP by peptidomimetic boronates. These compounds bind to all catalytic sites, and in specific conditions, they stimulate a dysregulated degradation of peptides and globular proteins, instead of inhibiting the enzymatic activity, as expected for serine proteases in general. Aiming to explore and explain this paradoxical effect, we solved and refined the crystal structure of native ClpP from Staphylococcus epidermidis (Se), an opportunistic pathogen involved in nosocomial infections, as well as ClpP in complex with ixazomib at 1.90 Å and 2.33 Å resolution, respectively. The interpretation of the crystal structures, in combination with complementary biochemical and biophysical data, shed light on how ixazomib affects the ClpP conformational state and activity. Moreover, SEC-SAXS and DLS measurements show, for the first time, that a peptidomimetic boronate compound also induces the assembly of the tetradecameric structure from isolated homomeric heptameric rings of a gram-positive organism.

ClpP Peptidase as a Plausible Target for the Discovery of Novel Antibiotics

Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) to currently available antibiotics/drugs is a global threat. It is desirable to develop new drugs that work through a novel target(s) to avoid drug resistance. This review discusses the potential of the caseinolytic protease P (ClpP) peptidase complex as a novel target for finding novel antibiotics, emphasising the ClpP's structure and function. ClpP contributes to the survival of bacteria via its ability to destroy misfolded or aggregated proteins. In consequence, its inhibition may lead to microbial death. Drugs inhibiting ClpP activity are currently being tested, but no drug against this target has been approved yet. It was demonstrated that Nblocked dipeptides are essential for activating ClpP's proteolytic activity. Hence, compounds mimicking these dipeptides could act as inhibitors of the formation of an active ClpP complex. Drugs, including Bortezomib, Cisplatin, Cefmetazole, and Ixazomib, inhibit ClpP activation. However, they were not approved as drugs against the target because of their high toxicity, likely due to the presence of strong electrophiles in their warheads. The modifications of these warheads could be a good strategy to reduce the toxicity of these molecules. For instance, a boronate warhead was replaced by a chloromethyl ketone, and this new molecule was shown to exhibit selectivity for prokaryotic ClpP. A better understanding of the structure and function of the ClpP complex would benefit the search for compounds mimicking N-blocked dipeptides that would inhibit ClpP complex activity and cause bacterial death.

[Protein degradation in bacteria: focus on the ClpP protease]

Proteins in the cells are born (synthesized), work, and die (decomposed). In the life of a protein, its birth is obviously important, but how it dies is equally important in living organisms. Proteases secreted into the outside of cells are used to decompose the external proteins and the degradation products are taken as the nutrients. On the other hand, there are also proteases that decompose unnecessary or harmful proteins which are generated in the cells. In eukaryotes, a large enzyme complex called the proteasome is primarily responsible for degradation of such proteins. Bacteria, which are prokaryotes, have a similar system as the proteasome. We would like to explain the bacterial degradation system of proteins or the death of proteins, which is performed by ATP-dependent protease Clp, with a particular focus on the ClpXP complex, and with an aspect as a target for antibiotics against bacteria.

Non-Canonical Amino Acids in Analyses of Protease Structure and Function

All known organisms encode 20 canonical amino acids by base triplets in the genetic code. The cellular translational machinery produces proteins consisting mainly of these amino acids. Several hundred natural amino acids serve important functions in metabolism, as scaffold molecules, and in signal transduction. New side chains are generated mainly by post-translational modifications, while others have altered backbones, such as the β- or γ-amino acids, or they undergo stereochemical inversion, e.g., in the case of D-amino acids. In addition, the number of non-canonical amino acids has further increased by chemical syntheses. Since many of these non-canonical amino acids confer resistance to proteolytic degradation, they are potential protease inhibitors and tools for specificity profiling studies in substrate optimization and enzyme inhibition. Other applications include in vitro and in vivo studies of enzyme kinetics, molecular interactions and bioimaging, to name a few. Amino acids with bio-orthogonal labels are particularly attractive, enabling various cross-link and click reactions for structure-functional studies. Here, we cover the latest developments in protease research with non-canonical amino acids, which opens up a great potential, e.g., for novel prodrugs activated by proteases or for other pharmaceutical compounds, some of which have already reached the clinical trial stage.

Anti-infective therapy using species-specific activators of Staphylococcus aureus ClpP

The emergence of methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus isolates highlights the urgent need to develop more antibiotics. ClpP is a highly conserved protease regulated by ATPases in bacteria and in mitochondria. Aberrant activation of  bacterial ClpP is an alternative method of discovering antibiotics, while it remains difficult to develop selective  Staphylococcus aureus ClpP activators that can avoid disturbing Homo sapiens ClpP functions. Here, we use a structure-based design to identify (R)- and (S)-ZG197 as highly selective Staphylococcus aureus ClpP activators. The key structural elements in Homo sapiens ClpP, particularly W146 and its joint action with the C-terminal motif, significantly contribute to the discrimination of the activators. Our selective activators display wide antibiotic properties towards an array of multidrug-resistant staphylococcal strains in vitro, and demonstrate promising antibiotic efficacy in zebrafish and murine skin infection models. Our findings indicate that the species-specific activators of Staphylococcus aureus ClpP are exciting therapeutic agents to treat staphylococcal infections.

Discovery of a Novel Oral Proteasome Inhibitor to Block NLRP3 Inflammasome Activation with Anti-inflammation Activity

NLRP3 inflammasome activation plays a critical role in inflammation-related disorders. More small-molecule entities are needed to study the mechanism of NLRP3 inflammasome activation and to validate the efficacy and safety of the NLRP3 pathway. Herein, we report the discovery of an orally bioavailable proteasome inhibitor NIC-0102 (27) that specifically prevents NLRP3 inflammasome activation but has no effect on NLRC4 or AIM2 inflammasomes. In vitro studies revealed that NIC-0102 induced the polyubiquitination of NLRP3, interfered with the NLRP3-ASC interaction, and blocked ASC oligomerization, thereby resulting in the inhibition of NLRP3 inflammasome activation. In addition, NIC-0102 also inhibited the production of pro-IL-1β. Importantly, NIC-0102 showed potent anti-inflammatory effects on DSS-induced ulcerative colitis model in vivo. As a result of these studies, a potential small molecule is identified to demonstrate the possible link between the proteasome and NLRP3 pathway, which supports further exploration of potentially druggable nodes to modulate NLRP3 inflammasome activation.

Discovery of a Novel Series of Imipridone Compounds as Homo sapiens Caseinolytic Protease P Agonists with Potent Antitumor Activities In Vitro and In Vivo

Homo sapiens caseinolytic protease P (HsClpP) plays an important role in maintaining mitochondrial proteostasis. Activating HsClpP has been proved to be a potential strategy for cancer therapy. In this paper, a novel class of HsClpP agonists is designed and synthesized using a position shift strategy based on the imipridone ONC201. Among these newly synthesized imipridone derivatives, compound 16z exhibits remarkably enhanced antitumor activity (IC₅₀ = 0.04 μM against HCT116 cells). It can improve HsClpP thermal stability and induce mitochondrial dysfunction, reactive oxygen species production, cell cycle arrest in the G0/G1 phase, and apoptosis of HCT116 cells. Moreover, compound 16z possesses excellent pharmacokinetic profiles and significantly inhibits tumor growth in HCT116 cell-inoculated xenograft nude mouse models. Our study demonstrates that 16z has potential to be an antitumor drug candidate for further development and provides insights for the design of the next generation of HsClpP agonists for cancer treatment.

Peptidomimetics: An Overview of Recent Medicinal Chemistry Efforts toward the Discovery of Novel Small Molecule Inhibitors

The use of peptides as therapeutics has often been associated with several drawbacks such as poor absorption, low stability to proteolytic digestion, and fast clearance. Peptidomimetics are developed by modifications of native peptides with the aim of obtaining molecules that are more suitable for clinical development and, for this reason, are widely used as tools in medicinal chemistry programs. The effort to disclose innovative peptidomimetic therapies is recurrent and constantly evolving as demonstrated by the new lead compounds in clinical trials. Synthetic strategies for the development of peptidomimetics have also been implemented with time. This perspective highlights some of the most recent efforts for the design and synthesis of peptidomimetic agents together with their biological evaluation toward a panel of targets.

ClpP inhibitors are produced by a widespread family of bacterial gene clusters

The caseinolytic protease (ClpP) is part of a highly conserved proteolytic complex whose disruption can lead to antibacterial activity but for which few specific inhibitors have been discovered. Specialized metabolites produced by bacteria have been shaped by evolution for specific functions, making them a potential source of selective ClpP inhibitors. Here, we describe a target-directed genome mining strategy for discovering ClpP-interacting compounds by searching for biosynthetic gene clusters that contain duplicated copies of ClpP as putative antibiotic resistance genes. We identify a widespread family of ClpP-associated clusters that are known to produce pyrrolizidine alkaloids but whose connection to ClpP has never been made. We show that previously characterized molecules do not affect ClpP function but are shunt metabolites derived from the genuine product of these gene clusters, a reactive covalent ClpP inhibitor. Focusing on one such cryptic gene cluster from Streptomyces cattleya, we identify the relevant inhibitor, which we name clipibicyclene, and show that it potently and selectively inactivates ClpP. Finally, we solve the crystal structure of clipibicyclene-modified Escherichia coli ClpP. Clipibicyclene's discovery reveals the authentic function of a family of natural products whose specificity for ClpP and abundance in nature illuminate the role of eco-evolutionary forces during bacterial competition.

Function, molecular mechanisms, and therapeutic potential of bacterial HtrA proteins: An evolving view

Members of the high temperature requirement A (HtrA) protein family are widely distributed amongst prokaryotic and eukaryotic species. HtrA proteins have ATP-independent dual chaperone-protease activity and mediate protein quality control. Emerging evidence indicates that HtrA family members are vital for establishing infections and bacterial survival under stress conditions. Bacterial HtrA proteins are increasingly thought of as important new targets for antibacterial drug development. Recent literature suggests that HtrA protein AlgW from Pseudomonas aeruginosa has distinct structural, functional, and regulatory characteristics. The novel dual-signal activation mechanism seen in AlgW is required to modulate stress and drug responses in bacteria, prompting us to review our understanding of the many HtrA proteins found in microorganisms. Here, we describe the distribution of HtrA gene orthologues in pathogenic bacteria, discuss their structure–function relationships, outline the molecular mechanisms exhibited by different bacterial HtrA proteins in bacteria under selective pressure, and review the significance of recently developed small molecule inhibitors targeting HtrA in pathogenic bacteria.

Recent developments in the medicinal chemistry of single boron atom-containing compounds

Various boron-containing drugs have been approved for clinical use over the past two decades, and more are currently in clinical trials. The increasing interest in boron-containing compounds is due to their unique binding properties to biological targets; for example, boron substitution can be used to modulate biological activity, pharmacokinetic properties, and drug resistance. In this perspective, we aim to comprehensively review the current status of boron compounds in drug discovery, focusing especially on progress from 2015 to December 2020. We classify these compounds into groups showing anticancer, antibacterial, antiviral, antiparasitic and other activities, and discuss the biological targets associated with each activity, as well as potential future developments.

Armeniaspirols inhibit the AAA+ proteases ClpXP and ClpYQ leading to cell division arrest in Gram-positive bacteria

Multi-drug-resistant bacteria present an urgent threat to modern medicine, creating a desperate need for antibiotics with new modes of action. As natural products remain an unsurpassed source for clinically viable antibiotic compounds, we investigate the mechanism of action of armeniaspirol. The armeniaspirols are a structurally unique class of Gram-positive antibiotic discovered from Streptomyces armeniacus for which resistance cannot be readily obtained. We show that armeniaspirol inhibits the ATP-dependent proteases ClpXP and ClpYQ in vitro and in the model Gram-positive Bacillus subtilis. This inhibition dysregulates the divisome and elongasome supported by an upregulation of key proteins FtsZ, DivIVA, and MreB inducing cell division arrest. The inhibition of ClpXP and ClpYQ to dysregulate cell division represents a unique antibiotic mechanism of action and armeniaspirol is the only known natural product inhibitor of the coveted anti-virulence target ClpP. Thus, armeniaspirol possesses a promising lead scaffold for antibiotic development with unique pharmacology.

Recent advances in Clp protease modulation to address virulence, resistance and persistence of MRSA infection

The Clp protease is an AAA⁺ protease that executes abnormally folded or malfunctioning proteins, and has an important role in producing virulence factors, forming biofilms or persisters and developing methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA). Recent studies showed that Clp protease controls virulence via agr signaling and degrades antitoxins of the toxin-antitoxin system to modulate the formation of persisters and biofilms. In this review, we focus on recent developments concerning the virulence and persistence regulatory pathways and resistance-related mechanism of Clp protease in S. aureus, with an overview of the Clp modulators developed to treat MRSA infection.

Structural characterization of PaFkbA: A periplasmic chaperone from Pseudomonas aeruginosa

Bacterial Mip-like FK506-binding proteins (FKBPs) mostly exhibit peptidyl-prolyl-cis/trans-isomerase (PPIase) and chaperone activities. These activities are associated with various intracellular functions with diverse molecular mechanisms. Herein, we report the PA3262 gene-encoded crystal structure of the Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAO1's Mip-like protein PaFkbA. Biochemical characterization of PaFkbA demonstrated PaFkbA's chaperone activity for periplasmic protein MucD, a negative regulator of alginate biosynthesis. Furthermore, structural analysis of PaFkbA was used to describe the key features of PaFkbA chaperone activity. The outcomes of this analysis showed that the hinge region in the connecting helix of PaFbkA leads to the crucial conformational state transition for PaFkbA activity. Besides, the N-terminal domains participated in dimerization, and revealed its potential connection with FKBP domain and substrate binding. Mutagenesis and chaperone activity assay supported the theory that inter-domain motions are essential for PaFkbA function. These results provide biochemical and structural insights into the mechanism for FKBP's chaperone activity and establish a plausible correlation between PaFkbA and P. aeruginosa MucD.

β-Lactams against the Fortress of the Gram-Positive Staphylococcus aureus Bacterium

The biological diversity of the unicellular bacteria-whether assessed by shape, food, metabolism, or ecological niche-surely rivals (if not exceeds) that of the multicellular eukaryotes. The relationship between bacteria whose ecological niche is the eukaryote, and the eukaryote, is often symbiosis or stasis. Some bacteria, however, seek advantage in this relationship. One of the most successful-to the disadvantage of the eukaryote-is the small (less than 1 μm diameter) and nearly spherical Staphylococcus aureus bacterium. For decades, successful clinical control of its infection has been accomplished using β-lactam antibiotics such as the penicillins and the cephalosporins. Over these same decades S. aureus has perfected resistance mechanisms against these antibiotics, which are then countered by new generations of β-lactam structure. This review addresses the current breadth of biochemical and microbiological efforts to preserve the future of the β-lactam antibiotics through a better understanding of how S. aureus protects the enzyme targets of the β-lactams, the penicillin-binding proteins. The penicillin-binding proteins are essential enzyme catalysts for the biosynthesis of the cell wall, and understanding how this cell wall is integrated into the protective cell envelope of the bacterium may identify new antibacterials and new adjuvants that preserve the efficacy of the β-lactams.