Hyperconjugative Aromaticity and Antiaromaticity Control the Reactivities and π-Facial Stereoselectivities of 5-Substituted Cyclopentadiene Diels-Alder Cycloadditions

Computational Organic Chemistry: The Frontier for Understanding and Designing Bioorthogonal Cycloadditions

Computational organic chemistry has become a valuable tool in the field of bioorthogonal chemistry, offering insights and aiding in the progression of this branch of chemistry. In this review, I present an overview of computational work in this field, including an exploration of both the primary computational analysis methods used and their application in the main areas of bioorthogonal chemistry: (3 + 2) and [4 + 2] cycloadditions. In the context of (3 + 2) cycloadditions, detailed studies of electronic effects have informed the evolution of cycloalkyne/1,3-dipole cycloadditions. Through computational techniques, researchers have found ways to adjust the electronic structure via hyperconjugation to enhance reactions without compromising stability. For [4 + 2] cycloadditions, methods such as distortion/interaction analysis and energy decomposition analysis have been beneficial, leading to the development of bioorthogonal reactants with improved reactivity and the creation of orthogonal reaction pairs. To conclude, I touch upon the emerging fields of cheminformatics and machine learning, which promise to play a role in future reaction discovery and optimization.

The application of aromaticity and antiaromaticity to reaction mechanisms

Aromaticity, in general, can promote a given reaction by stabilizing a transition state or a product via a mobility of π electrons in a cyclic structure. Similarly, such a promotion could be also achieved by destabilizing an antiaromatic reactant. However, both aromaticity and transition states cannot be directly measured in experiment. Thus, computational chemistry has been becoming a key tool to understand the aromaticity-driven reaction mechanisms. In this review, we will analyze the relationship between aromaticity and reaction mechanism to highlight the importance of density functional theory calculations and present it according to an approach via either aromatizing a transition state/product or destabilizing a reactant by antiaromaticity. Specifically, we will start with a particularly challenging example of dinitrogen activation followed by other small-molecule activation, C-F bond activation, rearrangement, as well as metathesis reactions. In addition, antiaromaticity-promoted dihydrogen activation, CO2 capture, and oxygen reduction reactions will be also briefly discussed. Finally, caution must be cast as the magnitude of the aromaticity in the transition states is not particularly high in most cases. Thus, a proof of an adequate electron delocalization rather than a complete ring current is recommended to support the relatively weak aromaticity in these transition states.

Computational study of an oxetane 4H-pyrazole as a Diels-Alder diene

We combine the effects of spirocyclization and hyperconjugation to increase the Diels-Alder reactivity of the 4H-pyrazole scaffold. A density functional theory (DFT) investigation predicts that 4H-pyrazoles containing an oxetane functionality at the saturated center are extremely reactive despite having a relatively high-lying lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) energy.

Bioorthogonal 4H-pyrazole "click" reagents

4H-Pyrazoles are emerging as useful click reagents. Fluorinating the saturated center enables 4H-pyrazoles to react rapidly as Diels-Alder dienes without a catalyst but compromises the stability of these dienes under physiological conditions. To identify more stable 4H-pyrazoles for bioorthogonal chemistry applications, we investigated the Diels-Alder reactivity and biological stability of three 4-oxo-substituted 4H-pyrazoles. We found that these dienes undergo rapid Diels-Alder reactions with endo-bicyclo[6.1.0]non-4-yne (BCN) while being much more stable to biological nucleophiles than their fluorinated counterparts. We attribute the rapid Diels-Alder reactivity of the optimal oxygen-substituted pyrazole to a combination of antiaromaticity, predistortion, and spirocyclization. Their reactivity and stability suggest that 4-oxo-4H-pyrazoles can be useful bioorthogonal reagents.

Cycloaddition Reactivities Analyzed by Energy Decomposition Analyses and the Frontier Molecular Orbital Model

This Account describes our quest to understand and predict organic reactivity, a principal goal of physical and theoretical organic chemistry. The focus is on the development and testing of models for the prediction of cycloaddition reactivities and selectivities. We describe the involvement of the Houk group, and other groups, in the evolution of theoretical models that can achieve ever greater accuracy as well as provide practical heuristic models for understanding and prediction.Is the venerable frontier molecular orbital (FMO) model, the basis of Kenichi Fukui's 1981 Nobel Prize, still useful, or must it be replaced with more advanced models? In particular, models such as Conceptual Density Functional, the Pauli Exclusion Model, and the recent popularity of Electrostatic Potential Plots and Dispersion Energies have not only added to our understanding, but they have also created uncertainty about whether the simple FMO heuristic model has a place in 21st century discussions. This Account addresses this issue and asserts the value of the FMO model.Beginning with brief descriptions of selected models for cycloaddition reactivity starting with early donor-acceptor (nucleophile-electrophile) charge-transfer concepts, this Account reviews Fukui's frontier molecular orbital model, Salem and Klopman's orbital, electrostatic and Pauli repulsion model, the conceptual DFT model by Parr and later by Domingo and others, the recent Houk and Bickelhaupt Distortion/Interaction Activation Strain model, and the Bickelhaupt-Hamlin's Pauli-repulsion lowering model.Computations and analyses of four well-studied Diels-Alder cycloadditions, both normal and inverse electron-demand types, are presented. Most were studied earlier in our published work but are presented here with new insights from calculations with modern methods. Depending on the types of substrates (cycloaddends), the dominant factors controlling reactivity can be orbital interactions, electrostatics and polarization, or Pauli repulsion and dispersion effects, or a combination of all of these.By comparing orbital interactions, especially the frontier molecular orbital interactions, with the other factors that influence reactivity, we show why the FMO model is such a powerful─and theoretically meaningful─heuristic for understanding and predicting reactivity. We also present a method to understand Pauli repulsion effects on activation barriers, ρ(1.1). The use of a new reaction coordinate, the extent of Pauli repulsion along the reaction path, is advocated to emphasize the role of repulsive occupied orbital interactions on reactivity.Fukui's frontier molecular orbital model is effective because FMO interactions parallel all the quantities that influence reactivity. The FMO model continues to provide a practical model to understand and guide experiments.

Three-Dimensional Fully π-Conjugated Macrocycles: When 3D-Aromatic and When 2D-Aromatic-in-3D?

Several fully π-conjugated macrocycles with puckered or cage-type structures were recently found to exhibit aromatic character according to both experiments and computations. We examine their electronic structures and put them in relation to 3D-aromatic molecules (e.g., closo-boranes) and to 2D-aromatic polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. Using qualitative theory combined with quantum chemical calculations, we find that the macrocycles explored hitherto should be described as 2D-aromatic with three-dimensional molecular structures (abbr. 2D-aromatic-in-3D) and not as truly 3D-aromatic. 3D-aromatic molecules have highly symmetric structures (or nearly so), leading to (at least) triply degenerate molecular orbitals, and for tetrahedral or octahedral molecules, an aromatic closed-shell electronic structure with 6n + 2 electrons. Conversely, 2D-aromatic-in-3D structures exhibit aromaticity that results from the fulfillment of Hückel’s 4n + 2 rule for each macrocyclic path, yet their π-electron counts are coincidentally 6n + 2 numbers for macrocycles with three tethers of equal lengths. It is notable that 2D-aromatic-in-3D macrocyclic cages can be aromatic with tethers of different lengths, i.e., with π-electron counts different from 6n + 2, and they are related to naphthalene. Finally, we identify tetrahedral and cubic π-conjugated molecules that fulfill the 6n + 2 rule and exhibit significant electron delocalization. Yet, their properties resemble those of analogous compounds with electron counts that differ from 6n + 2. Thus, despite the fact that these molecules show substantial π-electron delocalization, they cannot be classified as true 3D-aromatics.

Inorganic salt-assisted assembly of anionic π-conjugated rings enabling 7Li NMR-based evaluation of antiaromaticity

A cluster composed of three dilithium dibenzosilepinides and two Li2O molecules showed downfield shifted 7Li{1H} NMR signals (δ = 6.3, 4.4) due to the paratropic ring currents of the dianionic dibenzosilepins.

π-Facial Stereoselectivity in Acyl Nitroso Cycloadditions to 5,5-Unsymmetrically Substituted Cyclopentadienes: Computational Exploration of Origins of Selectivity and the Role of Substituent Conformations on Selectivity

The π-facial selectivity of Diels-Alder cycloadditions of 5-monosubstituted cyclopentadienes is known experimentally and has been extensively studied computationally. Previous studies on 5-monosubstituted cyclopentadienes by the Burnell and Houk groups showed that facial selectivity arises principally from hyperconjugative aromaticity or antiaromaticity of polar groups that cause distortion of the cyclopentadiene; steric effects of nonpolar groups can also be important. We have now explored the stereoselective cycloaddition of 5,5-unsymmetrically substituted cyclopentadienes to an acyl nitroso dienophile reported by Kan and co-workers. Computational studies with M06-2X/6-311+G(d,p) indicate that the stereoselectivity in the cycloadditions of 5,5-unsymmetrically substituted cyclopentadienes is not just a simple combination of effects found for monosubstituted counterparts. Substituent conformations and diene-dienophile steric and electronic interaction effects all influence stereoselectivity. Predictions are made about several as-yet-unstudied cyclopentadiene cycloadditions.

A new strategy for hyperconjugative antiaromatic compounds utilizing negative charges: a dibenzo[b,f]silepinyl dianion

Herein we propose a new strategy for hyperconjugative antiaromatic compounds utilizing negative charges and design the 5,5-diphenyldibenzo[b,f]silepinyl dianion (pseudo 16π-electron system) in which negative hyperconjugation occurs between the anionic π-cloud and the σ*(Si-Ph) orbital. Essentially, reduction of the dibenzo[b,f]silepin with lithium readily generated a dilithium salt of the dibenzosilepinyl dianion, and its hyperconjugative antiaromaticity has been evidenced by the upfield shifts of ¹H NMR signals and theoretical calculations, including large NICS_zz values and ACID plots.

Machine Learning to Predict Diels-Alder Reaction Barriers from the Reactant State Electron Density

Reaction barriers are key to our understanding of chemical reactivity and catalysis. Certain reactions are so seminal in chemistry that countless variants, with or without catalysts, have been studied, and their barriers have been computed or measured experimentally. This wealth of data represents a perfect opportunity to leverage machine learning models, which could quickly predict barriers without explicit calculations or measurement. Here, we show that the topological descriptors of the quantum mechanical charge density in the reactant state constitute a set that is both rigorous and continuous and can be used effectively for the prediction of reaction barrier energies to a high degree of accuracy. We demonstrate this on the Diels-Alder reaction, highly important in biology and medicinal chemistry, and as such, studied extensively. This reaction exhibits a range of barriers as large as 270 kJ/mol. While we trained our single-objective supervised (labeled) regression algorithms on simpler Diels-Alder reactions in solution, they predict reaction barriers also in significantly more complicated contexts, such a Diels-Alder reaction catalyzed by an artificial enzyme and its evolved variants, in agreement with experimental changes in k_cat. We expect this tool to apply broadly to a variety of reactions in solution or in the presence of a catalyst, for screening and circumventing heavily involved computations or experiments.

Geminal Repulsion Disrupts Diels-Alder Reactions of Geminally Substituted Cyclopentadienes and 4H-Pyrazoles

We have experimentally and computationally explored the sluggish Diels-Alder reactivities of the geminally substituted 5,5-dimethylcyclopentadiene and 5,5-dimethyl-2,3-diazacyclopentadiene (4,4-dimethyl-4H-pyrazole) scaffolds. We found that geminal dimethylation of 1,2,3,4-tetramethylcyclopentadiene to 1,2,3,4,5,5-hexamethylcyclopentadiene decreases the Diels-Alder reactivity towards maleimide by 954-fold. Quantum mechanical calculations revealed that the decreased Diels-Alder reactivities of gem-dimethyl substituted cyclopentadienes and 2,3-diazacyclopentadienes are not a consequence of unfavorable steric interactions between the diene and dienophile as reported previously, but a consequence of the increased repulsion within the gem-dimethyl group in the transition state. The findings have implications for the use of cyclopentadienes in "click" chemistry.

Click Chemistry with Cyclopentadiene

Cyclopentadiene is one of the most reactive dienes in normal electron-demand Diels-Alder reactions. The high reactivities and yields of cyclopentadiene cycloadditions make them ideal as click reactions. In this review, we discuss the history of the cyclopentadiene cycloaddition as well as applications of cyclopentadiene click reactions. Our emphasis is on experimental and theoretical studies on the reactivity and stability of cyclopentadiene and cyclopentadiene derivatives.

Tuning the hyperconjugative aromaticity in Au(III)-substituted indoliums

As a fundamental concept in chemistry, aromaticity has been extended from traditional organics to organometallics. Similarly, hyperconjugative aromaticity (HCA) has also been developed from main group to transition metal systems through the hyperconjugation of the substituents. However, it remains unclear that how the oxidation state of transition metal in the substituents affects the HCA. Herein, we demonstrate via density functional theory calculations that HCA could disappear in indoliums when the Au(i) substituents are changed to the Au(iii) ones. By tuning the ligand or cis-trans isomerization, HCA could be regained or enhanced in indoliums containing Au(iii) substitutents.

Probing hyperconjugative aromaticity in 2H-pyrrolium and cyclopentadiene containing group 9 transition metal substituents: bridged carbonyl ligands can enhance aromaticity

Bridged carbonyls can enhance hyperconjugative aromaticity of group 9 transition metal disubstituted 2H-pyrrolium and cyclopentadiene.

Antiaromaticity Gain Activates Tropone and Nonbenzenoid Aromatics as Normal-Electron-Demand Diels-Alder Dienes

We propose a carbonyl umpolung strategy for activating tropone as a normal-electron-demand Diels-Alder diene. Tropone has low reactivity for Diels-Alder reactions because of its [4n+2] π-aromaticity. Conversion of the carbonyl group into a hydrazone ion (═N-NR-) reverses the polarity of the exocyclic double bond, increases the [4n] ring π-antiaromaticity, and raises the HOMO energy. Computed gas-phase activation free energies for a Diels-Alder reaction with maleimide suggest a billion-fold rate increase when the tropone C═O is replaced by ═N-NR- (R = H or SO2CH3). Other nonbenzenoid aromatics can be activated as normal-electron-demand Diels-Alder dienes in the same way.

Differential Effects of Nitrogen Substitution in 5- and 6-Membered Aromatic Motifs

The replacement of carbon with nitrogen can affect the aromaticity of organic rings. Nucleus-independent chemical shift (NICS) calculations at the center of the aromatic π-systems reveal that incorporating nitrogen into 5-membered heteroaromatic dienes has only a small influence on aromaticity. In contrast, each nitrogen incorporated into benzene results in a sequential and substantial loss of aromaticity. The contrasting effects of nitrogen substitution in 5-membered dienes and benzene are reflected in their Diels-Alder reactivities as dienes. 1,2-Diazine experiences a 10¹¹ -fold increase in reactivity upon nitrogen substitution at the 4- and 5-positions, whereas a 5-membered heteroaromatic diene, furan, experiences a comparatively incidental 10² -fold increase in reactivity upon nitrogen substitution at the 3- and 4-positions.

Synthesis and Diels-Alder Reactivity of 4-Fluoro-4-Methyl-4H-Pyrazoles

4H-Pyrazoles are emerging scaffolds for “click” chemistry. Late-stage fluorination with Selectfluor^® is found to provide a reliable route to 4-fluoro-4-methyl-4H-pyrazoles. 4-Fluoro-4-methyl-3,5-diphenyl-4H-pyrazole (MFP) manifested 7-fold lower Diels–Alder reactivity than did 4,4-difluoro-3,5-diphenyl-4H-pyrazole (DFP), but higher stability in the presence of biological nucleophiles. Calculations indicate that a large decrease in the hyperconjugative antiaromaticity in MFP relative to DFP does not lead to a large loss in Diels–Alder reactivity because the ground-state structure of MFP avoids hyperconjugative antiaromaticity by distorting into an envelope-like conformation like that in the Diels–Alder transition state. This predistortion enhances the reactivity of MFP and offsets the decrease in reactivity from the diminished hyperconjugative antiaromaticity.

Hyperconjugative aromaticity and protodeauration reactivity of polyaurated indoliums

Aromaticity generally describes a cyclic structure composed of sp²-hybridized carbon or hetero atoms with remarkable stability and unique reactivity. The doping of even one sp³-hybridized atom often damages the aromaticity due to the interrupted electron conjugation. Here we demonstrate the occurrence of an extended hyperconjugative aromaticity (EHA) in a metalated indole ring which contains two gem-diaurated tetrahedral carbon atoms. The EHA-involved penta-aurated indolium shows extended electron conjugation because of dual hyperconjugation. Furthermore, the EHA-induced low electron density on the indolyl nitrogen atom enables a facile protodeauration reaction for the labile Au-N bond. In contrast, the degraded tetra-aurated indolium with a single gem-dimetalated carbon atom exhibits poor bond averaging and inertness in the protodeauration reaction. The aromaticity difference in such two polyaurated indoliums is discussed in the geometrical and electronic perspectives. This work highlights the significant effect of metalation on the aromaticity of polymetalated species.

Hyperconjugative aromaticity combines the concepts of hyperconjugation and aromaticity and explains cyclopentadiene stability. Here, the authors demonstrate extended hyperconjugative aromaticity in a metallated indole ring, which shows extended electron conjugation due to the dual hyperconjugation.

Acid-Induced Liberation of Polysubstituted Cyclopentadiene Ligands from Cyclopentadienyl Cobalt: A [2 + 2 + 1] Cycloaddition Route toward 1,2,4-Trisubstituted Cyclopentadienes

Here, we report that trifluoroacetic acid (TFAH) induces demetallation and protodesilylation of the cyclopentadiene ligand in cobalt-η⁴-cyclopentadiene complexes of general formula [(η⁵-C₅H₅)Co(η⁴-exo-C(TMS)═C(SO₂Ph)CH═CRCH(CO₂Et))] (1-Ph, R = Ph; 1-Ar^tBu, R = p-C₆H₄^tBu; 1-ArNMe₂, R = p-C₆H₄NMe₂; and 1-Me, R = Me). The trisubstituted cyclopentadiene products are isolated as a mixture of two tautomers, [(CH₂C(SO₂Ph)═CHC(CO₂Et)═CR)] (8-R-A) and [(CH═C(SO₂Ph)CH₂C(CO₂Et)═CR)] (8-R-B). The endo isomer, [(η⁵-C₅H₅)Co(η⁴-endo-C(TMS)═C(SO₂Ph)CH═CPhCH(CO₂Et))] (1-Ph-endo), also undergoes demetallation and protodesilylation to give 8-Ph-A and 8-Ph-B in excellent yield. The cobalt-cyclopentadiene complex, [(η⁵-C₅H₅)Co(η⁴-exo-C(TMS)═C(SO₂Ph)CH═C(CO₂Me)CH(CO₂Et))] (1-CO₂Me), undergoes demetallation and protodesilylation upon treatment with TFAH to give a hydrogen-bonded fulvenol (8-CO₂Me). Liberation of the ethoxy-substituted cyclopentadiene ligand of [(η⁵-C₅H₅)Co(η⁴-exo-C(TMS)═C(SO₂Ph)CH═C(OEt)CH(CO₂Et))] (1-OEt) leads to formation of a cyclopentenone derivative (11). Thermolysis of 8-Ph-A/8-Ph-B in the presence of maleimide leads to a highly functionalized Diels-Alder adduct, whereas 8-Ph-A/8-Ph-B serves as precursors to trisubstituted ruthenocenes by in situ deprotonation and reaction with [(η⁵-C₅R₅)Ru(NCMe)₃]PF₆ (16-H, R = H; 16-Me, R = Me).

Hyperconjugative Antiaromaticity Activates 4H-Pyrazoles as Inverse-Electron-Demand Diels-Alder Dienes

The Diels-Alder reactivity of 4,4-difluoro-3,5-diphenyl-4H-pyrazole was investigated experimentally and computationally with endo-bicyclo[6.1.0]non-4-yne. The computationally predicted rate enhancement from hyperconjugative antiaromaticity induced by fluorination of cyclopentadienes at the 5-position extends to five-membered heterocyclic dienes containing a saturated center. 4,4-Difluoro-4H-pyrazoles are new electron-deficient dienes with rapid reactivities toward strained alkynes.

Bonded to Carbon or Nitrogen? This is a Question on the Regioselectivity in Hyperconjugative Aromaticity

In chemistry, regioselectivity is the preference of one direction of chemical bond making or breaking over all other possible directions. Although it has been extensively investigated in various reactions, the regioselectivity of hyperconjugative aromaticity on either main group systems or transition metal ones remains elusive due to the challenge of synthesizing the target products. Here we report a joint theoretical and experimental study on this issue. Theoretical calculations predicted that electron-withdrawing groups prefer an attachment to the sp³-hybridized carbon atom rather than the nitrogen atom in indoliums. For the electron-donating groups, the two isomers bonded to the sp³-hybridized carbon or nitrogen atom are almost isoenergetic. When both sp²- and sp³-hybridized carbon and nitrogen atoms in the five-membered ring of indoliums are considered, the isomer with the polyaurated substituents bonded to the sp³-hybridized carbon atom is thermodynamically more stable than that with the polyaurated substituents bonded to the sp³-hybridized nitrogen atom. This prediction is reasonably verified by experimental observation. Bond dissociation energy is found to be more important than aromaticity in rationalizing such a preference. Our findings could help experimentalists to design and realize more novel hyperconjugative aromatics.

Reaction mechanisms of iron(iii) catalyzed carbonyl–olefin metatheses in 2,5- and 3,5-hexadienals: significant substituent and aromaticity effects

Theoretical calculations reveal significant substituent and aromaticity effects on Fe(iii)-catalyzed carbonyl–olefin metatheses of hexadienals.