Positively Charged Tags Impede Protein Mobility in Cells as Quantified by 19F NMR

In-Cell 19F NMR of Proteins: Recent Progress and Future Opportunities

In vitro, 19F NMR methodology is preferably selected as a complementary and straightforward method for unveiling the conformations, dynamics, and interactions of biological molecules. Its effectiveness in vivo has seen continuous improvement, addressing challenges faced by conventional heteronuclear NMR experiments on structured proteins, such as severe line broadening, low signal-to-noise ratio, and background signals. Herein, we summarize the distinctive advantages of 19F NMR, along with recent progress in sample preparation and applications within the realm of in-cell NMR. Additionally, we offer insights into the future directions and prospects of this methodology based on our understanding.

Single-Molecule Diffusivity Quantification Unveils Ubiquitous Net Charge-Driven Protein-Protein Interaction

Recent microscopy and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) studies have noticed substantial suppression of intracellular diffusion for positively charged proteins, suggesting an overlooked role of electrostatic attraction in nonspecific protein interactions in a predominantly negatively charged intracellular environment. Utilizing single-molecule detection and statistics, here, we quantify in aqueous solutions how protein diffusion, in the limit of low diffuser concentration to avoid aggregate/coacervate formation, is modulated by differently charged interactor proteins over wide concentration ranges. We thus report substantially suppressed diffusion when oppositely charged interactors are added at parts per million levels, yet unvaried diffusivities when same-charge interactors are added beyond 1%. The electrostatic attraction-driven suppression of diffusion is sensitive to the protein net charge states, as probed by varying the solution pH and ionic strength or chemically modifying the proteins and is robust across different diffuser-interactor pairs. By converting the measured diffusivities to diffuser diameters, we further show that in the limit of excess interactors, a positively charged diffuser molecule effectively drags along just one monolayer of negatively charged interactors, where further interactions stop. We thus unveil ubiquitous, net charge-driven protein-protein interactions and shed new light on the mechanism of charge-based diffusion suppression in living cells.

Biomolecular NMR in the AI-assisted structural biology era: Old tricks and new opportunities

Over the last 40 years nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy has established itself as one of the most versatile techniques for the characterization of biomolecules, especially proteins. Given the molecular size limitations of NMR together with recent advances in cryo-electron microscopy and artificial intelligence-assisted protein structure prediction, the bright future of NMR in structural biology has been put into question. In this mini review we argue the contrary. We discuss the unique opportunities solution NMR offers to the protein chemist that distinguish it from all other experimental or computational methods, and how it can benefit from machine learning.

Diffusive intracellular interactions: On the role of protein net charge and functional adaptation

A striking feature of nucleic acids and lipid membranes is that they all carry net negative charge and so is true for the majority of intracellular proteins. It is suggested that the role of this negative charge is to assure a basal intermolecular repulsion that keeps the cytosolic content suitably 'fluid' for function. We focus in this review on the experimental, theoretical and genetic findings which serve to underpin this idea and the new questions they raise. Unlike the situation in test tubes, any functional protein-protein interaction in the cytosol is subject to competition from the densely crowded background, i.e. surrounding stickiness. At the nonspecific limit of this stickiness is the 'random' protein-protein association, maintaining profuse populations of transient and constantly interconverting complexes at physiological protein concentrations. The phenomenon is readily quantified in studies of the protein rotational diffusion, showing that the more net negatively charged a protein is the less it is retarded by clustering. It is further evident that this dynamic protein-protein interplay is under evolutionary control and finely tuned across organisms to maintain optimal physicochemical conditions for the cellular processes. The emerging picture is then that specific cellular function relies on close competition between numerous weak and strong interactions, and where all parts of the protein surfaces are involved. The outstanding challenge is now to decipher the very basics of this many-body system: how the detailed patterns of charged, polar and hydrophobic side chains not only control protein-protein interactions at close- and long-range but also the collective properties of the cellular interior as a whole.

Single-Molecule Displacement Mapping Unveils Sign-Asymmetric Protein Charge Effects on Intraorganellar Diffusion

Using single-molecule displacement/diffusivity mapping (SMdM), an emerging super-resolution microscopy method, here we quantify, at nanoscale resolution, the diffusion of a typical fluorescent protein (FP) in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and mitochondrion of living mammalian cells. We thus show that the diffusion coefficients D in both organelles are ∼40% of that in the cytoplasm, with the latter exhibiting higher spatial inhomogeneities. Moreover, we unveil that diffusions in the ER lumen and the mitochondrial matrix are markedly impeded when the FP is given positive, but not negative, net charges. Calculation shows most intraorganellar proteins as negatively charged, hence a mechanism to impede the diffusion of positively charged proteins. However, we further identify the ER protein PPIB as an exception with a positive net charge and experimentally show that the removal of this positive charge elevates its intra-ER diffusivity. We thus unveil a sign-asymmetric protein charge effect on the nanoscale intraorganellar diffusion.

Single-molecule displacement mapping unveils sign-asymmetric protein charge effects on intraorganellar diffusion

Using single-molecule displacement/diffusivity mapping (SM d M), an emerging super-resolution microscopy method, here we quantify, at nanoscale resolution, the diffusion of a typical fluorescent protein (FP) in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and mitochondrion of living mammalian cells. We thus show that the diffusion coefficients D in both organelles are ~40% of that in the cytoplasm, with the latter exhibiting higher spatial inhomogeneities. Moreover, we unveil that diffusions in the ER lumen and the mitochondrial matrix are markedly impeded when the FP is given positive, but not negative, net charges. Calculation shows most intraorganellar proteins as negatively charged, thus a mechanism to impede the diffusion of positively charged proteins. However, we further identify the ER protein PPIB as an exception with a positive net charge, and experimentally show that the removal of this positive charge elevates its intra-ER diffusivity. We thus unveil a sign-asymmetric protein charge effect on the nanoscale intraorganellar diffusion.

In-cell NMR: Why and how?

NMR spectroscopy has been applied to cells and tissues analysis since its beginnings, as early as 1950. We have attempted to gather here in a didactic fashion the broad diversity of data and ideas that emerged from NMR investigations on living cells. Covering a large proportion of the periodic table, NMR spectroscopy permits scrutiny of a great variety of atomic nuclei in all living organisms non-invasively. It has thus provided quantitative information on cellular atoms and their chemical environment, dynamics, or interactions. We will show that NMR studies have generated valuable knowledge on a vast array of cellular molecules and events, from water, salts, metabolites, cell walls, proteins, nucleic acids, drugs and drug targets, to pH, redox equilibria and chemical reactions. The characterization of such a multitude of objects at the atomic scale has thus shaped our mental representation of cellular life at multiple levels, together with major techniques like mass-spectrometry or microscopies. NMR studies on cells has accompanied the developments of MRI and metabolomics, and various subfields have flourished, coined with appealing names: fluxomics, foodomics, MRI and MRS (i.e. imaging and localized spectroscopy of living tissues, respectively), whole-cell NMR, on-cell ligand-based NMR, systems NMR, cellular structural biology, in-cell NMR… All these have not grown separately, but rather by reinforcing each other like a braided trunk. Hence, we try here to provide an analytical account of a large ensemble of intricately linked approaches, whose integration has been and will be key to their success. We present extensive overviews, firstly on the various types of information provided by NMR in a cellular environment (the "why", oriented towards a broad readership), and secondly on the employed NMR techniques and setups (the "how", where we discuss the past, current and future methods). Each subsection is constructed as a historical anthology, showing how the intrinsic properties of NMR spectroscopy and its developments structured the accessible knowledge on cellular phenomena. Using this systematic approach, we sought i) to make this review accessible to the broadest audience and ii) to highlight some early techniques that may find renewed interest. Finally, we present a brief discussion on what may be potential and desirable developments in the context of integrative studies in biology.

Visualizing Proteins in Mammalian Cells by 19 F NMR Spectroscopy

In-cell NMR spectroscopy is a powerful tool to investigate protein behavior in physiologically relevant environments. Although proven valuable for disordered proteins, we show that in commonly used ¹ H-¹⁵ N HSQC spectra of globular proteins, interactions with cellular components often broaden resonances beyond detection. This contrasts ¹⁹ F spectra in mammalian cells, in which signals are readily observed. Using several proteins, we demonstrate that surface charges and interaction with cellular binding partners modulate linewidths and resonance frequencies. Importantly, we establish that ¹⁹ F paramagnetic relaxation enhancements using stable, rigid Ln(III) chelate pendants, attached via non-reducible thioether bonds, provide an effective means to obtain accurate distances for assessing protein conformations in the cellular milieu.

In-Cell Structural Biology by NMR: The Benefits of the Atomic Scale

In-cell structural biology aims at extracting structural information about proteins or nucleic acids in their native, cellular environment. This emerging field holds great promise and is already providing new facts and outlooks of interest at both fundamental and applied levels. NMR spectroscopy has important contributions on this stage: It brings information on a broad variety of nuclei at the atomic scale, which ensures its great versatility and uniqueness. Here, we detail the methods, the fundamental knowledge, and the applications in biomedical engineering related to in-cell structural biology by NMR. We finally propose a brief overview of the main other techniques in the field (EPR, smFRET, cryo-ET, etc.) to draw some advisable developments for in-cell NMR. In the era of large-scale screenings and deep learning, both accurate and qualitative experimental evidence are as essential as ever to understand the interior life of cells. In-cell structural biology by NMR spectroscopy can generate such a knowledge, and it does so at the atomic scale. This review is meant to deliver comprehensive but accessible information, with advanced technical details and reflections on the methods, the nature of the results, and the future of the field.

Macromolecular Crowding Is More than Hard-Core Repulsions

Cells are crowded, but proteins are almost always studied in dilute aqueous buffer. We review the experimental evidence that crowding affects the equilibrium thermodynamics of protein stability and protein association and discuss the theories employed to explain these observations. In doing so, we highlight differences between synthetic polymers and biologically relevant crowders. Theories based on hard-core interactions predict only crowding-induced entropic stabilization. However, experiment-based efforts conducted under physiologically relevant conditions show that crowding can destabilize proteins and their complexes. Furthermore, quantification of the temperature dependence of crowding effects produced by both large and small cosolutes, including osmolytes, sugars, synthetic polymers, and proteins, reveals enthalpic effects that stabilize or destabilize proteins. Crowding-induced destabilization and the enthalpic component point to the role of chemical interactions between and among the macromolecules, cosolutes, and water. We conclude with suggestions for future studies. Expected final online publication date for the Annual Review of Biophysics, Volume 51 is May 2022. Please see http://www.annualreviews.org/page/journal/pubdates for revised estimates.

Radio Signals from Live Cells: The Coming of Age of In-Cell Solution NMR

A detailed knowledge of the complex processes that make cells and organisms alive is fundamental in order to understand diseases and to develop novel drugs and therapeutic treatments. To this aim, biological macromolecules should ideally be characterized at atomic resolution directly within the cellular environment. Among the existing structural techniques, solution NMR stands out as the only one able to investigate at high resolution the structure and dynamic behavior of macromolecules directly in living cells. With the advent of more sensitive NMR hardware and new biotechnological tools, modern in-cell NMR approaches have been established since the early 2000s. At the coming of age of in-cell NMR, we provide a detailed overview of its developments and applications in the 20 years that followed its inception. We review the existing approaches for cell sample preparation and isotopic labeling, the application of in-cell NMR to important biological questions, and the development of NMR bioreactor devices, which greatly increase the lifetime of the cells allowing real-time monitoring of intracellular metabolites and proteins. Finally, we share our thoughts on the future perspectives of the in-cell NMR methodology.

Small, but powerful and attractive: 19F in biomolecular NMR

Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy is a versatile tool for probing structure, dynamics, folding, and interactions at atomic resolution. While naturally occurring magnetically active isotopes, such as ¹H, ¹³C, or ¹⁵N, are most commonly used in biomolecular NMR, with ¹⁵N and ¹³C isotopic labeling routinely employed at the present time, ¹⁹F is a very attractive and sensitive alternative nucleus, which offers rich information on biomolecules in solution and in the solid state. This perspective summarizes the unique benefits of solution and solid-state ¹⁹F NMR spectroscopy for the study of biological systems. Particular focus is on the most recent studies and on future unique and important potential applications of fluorine NMR methodology.

On the osmotic pressure of cells

The chemical potential of water ( $ {\mu}_{{\mathrm{H}}_2\mathrm{O}} $ ) provides an essential thermodynamic characterization of the environment of living organisms, and it is of equal significance as the temperature. For cells, $ {\mu}_{{\mathrm{H}}_2\mathrm{O}} $ is conventionally expressed in terms of the osmotic pressure (πosm). We have previously suggested that the main contribution to the intracellular πosm of the bacterium E. coli is from soluble negatively-charged proteins and their counter-ions. Here, we expand on this analysis by examining how evolutionary divergent cell types cope with the challenge of maintaining πosm within viable values. Complex organisms, like mammals, maintain constant internal πosm ≈ 0.285 osmol, matching that of 0.154 M NaCl. For bacteria it appears that optimal growth conditions are found for similar or slightly higher πosm (0.25-0.4 osmol), despite that they represent a much earlier stage in evolution. We argue that this value reflects a general adaptation for optimising metabolic function under crowded intracellular conditions. Environmental πosm that differ from this optimum require therefore special measures, as exemplified with gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria. To handle such situations, their membrane encapsulations allow for a compensating turgor pressure that can take both positive and negative values, where positive pressures allow increased frequency of metabolic events through increased intracellular protein concentrations. A remarkable exception to the rule of 0.25-0.4 osmol, is found for halophilic archaea with internal πosm ≈ 15 osmol. The internal organization of these archaea differs in that they utilize a repulsive electrostatic mechanism operating only in the ionic-liquid regime to avoid aggregation, and that they stand out from other organisms by having no turgor pressure.

Simultaneous Quantification of Biothiols and Deciphering Diverse GSH Stability in Different Live Cells by 19F-Tag

GSH, Cys, Hcy, and H₂S are important biothiols and play important roles in the living systems. Quantitative and simultaneous determination of these biothiols under physiological conditions is still a challenge. Herein, we developed an effective ¹⁹F-reactive tag that readily interacts with these four biothiols for the generation of stable thioether products that have distinguishable ¹⁹F-chemical shifts. These thioester compounds encode the characteristic fingerprint profiles of each biothiols, allowing one to simultaneously quantify and determine these biothiols by 1D ¹⁹F NMR spectroscopy. The intra-/extracellular GSH in live cells was assessed by the established strategy, and remarkable variations in the GSH stability were determined between the normal mammalian cells and cancer cells. It is notable that GSH hydrolyzes efficiently in the out-membrane of the cancer cells and the lysates. In contrast, GSH remains stable in the tested normal cells.

19F NMR viewed through two different lenses: ligand-observed and protein-observed 19F NMR applications for fragment-based drug discovery

19F NMR has emerged as a powerful tool in drug discovery, particularly in fragment-based screens. The favorable magnetic resonance properties of the fluorine-19 nucleus, the general absence of fluorine in biological settings, and its ready incorporation into both small molecules and biopolymers, has enabled multiple applications of 19F NMR using labeled small molecules and proteins in biophysical, biochemical, and cellular experiments. This review will cover developments in ligand-observed and protein-observed 19F NMR experiments tailored towards drug discovery with a focus on fragment screening. We also cover the key advances that have furthered the field in recent years, including quantitative, structural, and in-cell methodologies. Several case studies are described for each application to highlight areas for innovation and to further catalyze new NMR developments for using this versatile nucleus.

The intracellular environment affects protein-protein interactions

Protein-protein interactions are essential for life but rarely thermodynamically quantified in living cells. In vitro efforts show that protein complex stability is modulated by high concentrations of cosolutes, including synthetic polymers, proteins, and cell lysates via a combination of hard-core repulsions and chemical interactions. We quantified the stability of a model protein complex, the A34F GB1 homodimer, in buffer, Escherichia coli cells and Xenopus laevis oocytes. The complex is more stable in cells than in buffer and more stable in oocytes than E. coli Studies of several variants show that increasing the negative charge on the homodimer surface increases stability in cells. These data, taken together with the fact that oocytes are less crowded than E. coli cells, lead to the conclusion that chemical interactions are more important than hard-core repulsions under physiological conditions, a conclusion also gleaned from studies of protein stability in cells. Our studies have implications for understanding how promiscuous-and specific-interactions coherently evolve for a protein to properly function in the crowded cellular environment.

Dynamical spectroscopy and microscopy of proteins in cells

With a strong understanding of how proteins fold in hand, it is now possible to ask how in-cell environments modulate their folding, binding and function. Studies accessing fast (ns to s) in-cell dynamics have accelerated over the past few years through a combination of in-cell NMR spectroscopy and time-resolved fluorescence microscopies. Here, we discuss this recent work and the emerging picture of protein surfaces as not just hydrophilic coats interfacing the solvent to the protein's core and functional regions, but as critical components in cells controlling protein mobility, function and communication with post-translational modifications.

NMR-Based Methods for Protein Analysis

Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy is a well-established method for analyzing protein structure, interaction, and dynamics at atomic resolution and in various sample states including solution state, solid state, and membranous environment. Thanks to rapid NMR methodology development, the past decade has witnessed a growing number of protein NMR studies in complex systems ranging from membrane mimetics to living cells, which pushes the research frontier further toward physiological environments and offers unique insights in elucidating protein functional mechanisms. In particular, in-cell NMR has become a method of choice for bridging the huge gap between structural biology and cell biology. Herein, we review the recent developments and applications of NMR methods for protein analysis in close-to-physiological environments, with special emphasis on in-cell protein structural determination and the analysis of protein dynamics, both difficult to be accessed by traditional methods.

Connecting Longitudinal and Transverse Relaxation Rates in Live-Cell NMR

In the cytosolic environment, protein crowding and Brownian motions result in numerous transient encounters. Each such encounter event increases the apparent size of the interacting molecules, leading to slower rotational tumbling. The extent of transient protein complexes formed in live cells can conveniently be quantified by an apparent viscosity, based on NMR-detected spin-relaxation measurements, that is, the longitudinal (T1) and transverse (T2) relaxation. From combined analysis of three different proteins and surface mutations thereof, we find that T2 implies significantly higher apparent viscosity than T1. At first sight, the effect on T1 and T2 seems thus nonunifiable, consistent with previous reports on other proteins. We show here that the T1 and T2 deviation is actually not a inconsistency but an expected feature of a system with fast exchange between free monomers and transient complexes. In this case, the deviation is basically reconciled by a model with fast exchange between the free-tumbling reporter protein and a transient complex with a uniform 143 kDa partner. The analysis is then taken one step further by accounting for the fact that the cytosolic content is by no means uniform but comprises a wide range of molecular sizes. Integrating over the complete size distribution of the cytosolic interaction ensemble enables us to predict both T1 and T2 from a single binding model. The result yields a bound population for each protein variant and provides a quantification of the transient interactions. We finally extend the approach to obtain a correction term for the shape of a database-derived mass distribution of the interactome in the mammalian cytosol, in good accord with the existing data of the cellular composition.

Intact ribosomes drive the formation of protein quinary structure

Transient, site-specific, or so-called quinary, interactions are omnipresent in live cells and modulate protein stability and activity. Quinary intreactions are readily detected by in-cell NMR spectroscopy as severe broadening of the NMR signals. Intact ribosome particles were shown to be necessary for the interactions that give rise to the NMR protein signal broadening observed in cell lysates and sufficient to mimic quinary interactions present in the crowded cytosol. Recovery of target protein NMR spectra that were broadened in lysates, in vitro and in the presence of purified ribosomes was achieved by RNase A digestion only after the structure of the ribosome was destabilized by removing magnesium ions from the system. Identifying intact ribosomal particles as the major protein-binding component of quinary interactions and consequent spectral peak broadening will facilitate quantitative characterization of macromolecular crowding effects in live cells and streamline models of metabolic activity.

Diffusive protein interactions in human versus bacterial cells

Random encounters between proteins in crowded cells are by no means passive, but found to be under selective control. This control enables proteome solubility, helps to optimise the diffusive search for interaction partners, and allows for adaptation to environmental extremes. Interestingly, the residues that modulate the encounters act mesoscopically through protein surface hydrophobicity and net charge, meaning that their detailed signatures vary across organisms with different intracellular constraints. To examine such variations, we use in-cell NMR relaxation to compare the diffusive behaviour of bacterial and human proteins in both human and Escherichia coli cytosols. We find that proteins that ‘stick’ in E. coli are generally less restricted in mammalian cells. Furthermore, the rotational diffusion in the mammalian cytosol is less sensitive to surface-charge mutations. This implies that, in terms of protein motions, the mammalian cytosol is more forgiving to surface alterations than E. coli cells. The cellular differences seem not linked to the proteome properties per se, but rather to a 6-fold difference in protein concentrations. Our results outline a scenario in which the tolerant cytosol of mammalian cells, found in long-lived multicellular organisms, provides an enlarged evolutionary playground, where random protein-surface mutations are less deleterious than in short-generational bacteria.

•

Random protein encounters and diffusibility in cells are controlled by surface charge.

•

Protein rotational diffusion is less restricted in human cells than in E. coli.

•

Human cells are less sensitive to alterations of protein charge than Escherichia coli cells.