Evaluation of a Dual Isolation Width Acquisition Method for Isobaric Labeling Ratio Decompression

Trends in co-fractionation mass spectrometry: A new gold-standard in global protein interaction network discovery

Co-fractionation mass spectrometry (CF-MS) uses biochemical fractionation to isolate and characterize macromolecular complexes from cellular lysates without the need for affinity tagging or capture. In recent years, this has emerged as a powerful technique for elucidating global protein-protein interaction networks in a wide variety of biospecimens. This review highlights the latest advancements in CF-MS experimental workflows including machine learning-guided analyses, for uncovering dynamic and high-resolution protein interaction landscapes with enhanced sensitivity, accuracy and throughput, enabling better biophysical characterization of endogenous protein complexes. By addressing challenges and emergent opportunities in the field, this review underscores the transformative potential of CF-MS in advancing our understanding of functional protein interaction networks in health and disease.

Multiplexing the Identification of Microorganisms via Tandem Mass Tag Labeling Augmented by Interference Removal through a Novel Modification of the Expectation Maximization Algorithm

Having fast, accurate, and broad spectrum methods for the identification of microorganisms is of paramount importance to public health, research, and safety. Bottom-up mass spectrometer-based proteomics has emerged as an effective tool for the accurate identification of microorganisms from microbial isolates. However, one major hurdle that limits the deployment of this tool for routine clinical diagnosis, and other areas of research such as culturomics, is the instrument time required for the mass spectrometer to analyze a single sample, which can take ∼1 h per sample, when using mass spectrometers that are presently used in most institutes. To address this issue, in this study, we employed, for the first time, tandem mass tags (TMTs) in multiplex identifications of microorganisms from multiple TMT-labeled samples in one MS/MS experiment. A difficulty encountered when using TMT labeling is the presence of interference in the measured intensities of TMT reporter ions. To correct for interference, we employed in the proposed method a modified version of the expectation maximization (EM) algorithm that redistributes the signal from ion interference back to the correct TMT-labeled samples. We have evaluated the sensitivity and specificity of the proposed method using 94 MS/MS experiments (covering a broad range of protein concentration ratios across TMT-labeled channels and experimental parameters), containing a total of 1931 true positive TMT-labeled channels and 317 true negative TMT-labeled channels. The results of the evaluation show that the proposed method has an identification sensitivity of 93-97% and a specificity of 100% at the species level. Furthermore, as a proof of concept, using an in-house-generated data set composed of some of the most common urinary tract pathogens, we demonstrated that by using the proposed method the mass spectrometer time required per sample, using a 1 h LC-MS/MS run, can be reduced to 10 and 6 min when samples are labeled with TMT-6 and TMT-10, respectively. The proposed method can also be used along with Orbitrap mass spectrometers that have faster MS/MS acquisition rates, like the recently released Orbitrap Astral mass spectrometer, to further reduce the mass spectrometer time required per sample.

Synthetic Knockout Protein Standard for Evaluating Interference in Tandem Mass Tag-Based Proteomics

Isobaric labeling is widely used for unbiased, proteome-wide studies, and it provides several advantages, such as fewer missing values among samples and higher quantitative precision. However, ion interference may lead to compressed or distorted observed ratios due to the coelution and coanalysis of peptides. Here, we introduced a synthetic KnockOut standard (sKO) for evaluating interference in tandem mass tags-based proteomics. sKO is made by mixing TMTpro-labeled tryptic peptides derived from four nonhuman proteins and a whole human proteome as background at different proportions. We showcased the utility of the sKO standard by exploring ion interference at different peptide concentrations (up to a 30-fold change in abundance) and using a variety of mass spectrometer data acquisition strategies. We also demonstrated that the sKO standard could provide valuable information for the rational design of acquisition strategies to achieve optimal data quality and discussed its potential applications for high-throughput proteomics workflows development.

Experimental and data analysis advances in thermal proteome profiling

Method development for mass spectrometry (MS)-based thermal shift proteomic assays have advanced to probe small molecules with known and unknown protein-ligand interaction mechanisms and specificity, which is predominantly used in characterization of drug-protein interactions. In the discovery of target and off-target protein-ligand interactions, a thorough investigation of method development and their impact on the sensitivity and accuracy of protein-small molecule and protein-protein interactions is warranted. In this review, we discuss areas of improvement at each stage of thermal proteome profiling data analysis that includes processing of MS-based data, method development, and their effect on the overall quality of thermal proteome profiles. We also overview the optimization of experimental strategies and prioritization of an increased number of independent biological replicates over the number of evaluated temperatures.

A Causal Model of Ion Interference Enables Assessment and Correction of Ratio Compression in Multiplex Proteomics

Multiplex proteomics using isobaric labeling tags has emerged as a powerful tool for the simultaneous relative quantification of peptides and proteins across multiple experimental conditions. However, the quantitative accuracy of the approach is largely compromised by ion interference, a phenomenon that causes fold changes to appear compressed. The degree of compression is generally unknown, and the contributing factors are poorly understood. In this study, we thoroughly characterized ion interference at the MS2 level using a defined two-proteome experimental system with known ground-truth. We discovered remarkably poor agreement between the apparent precursor purity in the isolation window and the actual level of observed reporter ion interference in MS2 scans-a discrepancy that we found resolved by considering cofragmentation of peptide ions hidden within the spectral "noise" of the MS1 isolation window. To address this issue, we developed a regression modeling strategy to accurately predict reporter ion interference in any dataset. Finally, we demonstrate the utility of our procedure for improved fold change estimation and unbiased PTM site-to-protein normalization. All computational tools and code required to apply this method to any MS2 TMT dataset are documented and freely available.

Deep Proteomic Compound Profiling with the Orbitrap Ascend Tribrid Mass Spectrometer Using Tandem Mass Tags and Real-Time Search

Tandem mass tags (TMT) and tribrid mass spectrometers are a powerful combination for high-throughput proteomics with high quantitative accuracy. Increasingly, this technology is being used to map the effects of drugs on the proteome. However, the depth of proteomic profiling is still limited by sensitivity and speed. The new Orbitrap Ascend mass spectrometer was designed to address these limitations with a combination of hardware and software improvements. We evaluated the performance of the Ascend in multiple contexts including deep proteomic profiling. We found that the Ascend exhibited increased sensitivity, yielding higher signal-to-noise ratios than the Orbitrap Eclipse with shorter injection times. As a result, higher numbers of peptides and proteins were identified and quantified, especially with low sample input. TMT measurements had significantly improved signal-to-noise ratios, improving quantitative precision. In a fractionated 16plex sample that profiled proteomic differences across four human cell lines, the Ascend was able to quantify hundreds more proteins than the Eclipse, many of them low-abundant proteins, and the Ascend was able to quantify >8000 proteins in 30% less instrument time. We used the Ascend to analyze 8881 proteins in HCT116 cancer cells treated with covalent sulfolane/sulfolene inhibitors of peptidyl-prolyl cis-trans isomerase NIMA-interacting 1 (PIN1), a phosphorylation-specific peptidyl-prolyl cis-trans isomerase implicated in several cancers. We characterized these PIN1 inhibitors' effects on the proteome and identified discrepancies among the different compounds, which will facilitate a better understanding of the structure-activity relationship of this class of compounds. The Ascend was able to quantify statistically significant, potentially therapeutically relevant changes in proteins that the Eclipse could not detect.

Enhanced Multiplexing Technology for Proteomics

The identification of thousands of proteins and their relative levels of expression has furthered understanding of biological processes and disease and stimulated new systems biology hypotheses. Quantitative proteomics workflows that rely on analytical assays such as mass spectrometry have facilitated high-throughput measurements of proteins partially due to multiplexing. Multiplexing allows proteome differences across multiple samples to be measured simultaneously, resulting in more accurate quantitation, increased statistical robustness, reduced analysis times, and lower experimental costs. The number of samples that can be multiplexed has evolved from as few as two to more than 50, with studies involving more than 10 samples being denoted as enhanced multiplexing or hyperplexing. In this review, we give an update on emerging multiplexing proteomics techniques and highlight advantages and limitations for enhanced multiplexing strategies.

SILAC-IodoTMT for Assessment of the Cellular Proteome and Its Redox Status

Stable isotope labeling by amino acids in cell culture (SILAC) and iodoacetyl tandem mass tag (iodoTMT) are well-implemented mass spectrometry-based approaches for quantification of proteins and for site-mapping of cysteine modification. We describe here a combination of SILAC and iodoTMT to assess ongoing changes in the global proteome and cysteine modification levels using liquid chromatography separation coupled with high-resolution mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS).

SimPLIT: Simplified Sample Preparation for Large-Scale Isobaric Tagging Proteomics

Large scale proteomic profiling of cell lines can reveal molecular signatures attributed to variable genotypes or induced perturbations, enabling proteogenomic associations and elucidation of pharmacological mechanisms of action. Although isobaric labeling has increased the throughput of proteomic analysis, the commonly used sample preparation workflows often require time-consuming steps and costly consumables, limiting their suitability for large scale studies. Here, we present a simplified and cost-effective one-pot reaction workflow in a 96-well plate format (SimPLIT) that minimizes processing steps and demonstrates improved reproducibility compared to alternative approaches. The workflow is based on a sodium deoxycholate lysis buffer and a single detergent cleanup step after peptide labeling, followed by quick off-line fractionation and MS2 analysis. We showcase the applicability of the workflow in a panel of colorectal cancer cell lines and by performing target discovery for a set of molecular glue degraders in different cell lines, in a 96-sample assay. Using this workflow, we report frequently dysregulated proteins in colorectal cancer cells and uncover cell-dependent protein degradation profiles of seven cereblon E3 ligase modulators (CRL4CRBN). Overall, SimPLIT is a robust method that can be easily implemented in any proteomics laboratory for medium-to-large scale TMT-based studies for deep profiling of cell lines.

Highly accurate and precise quantification strategy using stable isotope dimethyl labeling coupled with GeLC-MS/MS

Shotgun proteomics is a powerful method for comprehensively identifying and quantifying tryptic peptides, but it is difficult to analyze proteolytic events. One-dimensional gel and liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (GeLC-MS/MS) enables the separation of proteolytic fragments using SDS-PAGE followed by identification using LC-MS/MS. GeLC-MS/MS is thus an excellent method for identifying fragmentation. However, the lower reproducibility of gel extraction and nano flow LC-MS/MS can produce inaccurate results in comparative analyses of protein quantification among samples. In this study, a novel GeLC-MS/MS method coupled with stable isotope dimethyl labeling was developed. In the method, a mixture of light- and heavy-labeled samples is loaded onto an SDS-PAGE gel, and proteins with different isotopes in one extracted band are quantitatively analyzed by one-shot injection. This procedure enables accurate determination of the abundance ratio of peptides between two samples, even in cases of low peptide abundance, and it is not affected by the reproducibility of the gel extraction or LC-MS procedures. Therefore, our new GeLC-MS/MS method coupled with stable isotope dimethyl labeling provides high accuracy and comprehensive peptide comparisons, enabling the detection of proteolysis events caused by disease or physiological processes.

Improved Proteomics-Based Drug Mechanism-of-Action Studies Using 16-Plex Isobaric Mass Tags

Multiplexed quantitative proteomics enabled complex workflows to study the mechanisms by which small molecule drugs interact with the proteome such as thermal proteome profiling (TPP) or multiplexed proteome dynamics profiling (mPDP). TPP measures changes in protein thermal stability in response to drug treatment and thus informs on direct targets and downstream regulation events, while the mPDP approach enables the discovery of regulated protein synthesis and degradation events caused by small molecules and other perturbations. The isobaric mass tags available for multiplexed proteomics have thus far limited the efficiency and sensitivity by which such experiments could be performed. Here we evaluate a recent generation of 16-plex isobaric mass tags and demonstrate the sensitive and time efficient identification of Staurosporine targets in HepG2 cell extracts by recording full thermal denaturation/aggregation profiles of vehicle and compound treated samples in a single mass spectrometry experiment. In 2D-TPP experiments, isothermal titration over seven concentrations per temperature enabled comprehensive selectivity profiling of Staurosporine with EC₅₀ values for kinase targets tightly matching to the kinobeads gold standard assay. Finally, we demonstrate time and condition-based multiplexing of dynamic SILAC labeling experiments to delineate proteome-wide effects of the molecular glue Indisulam on synthesis and degradation rates.

Multi-Q 2 software facilitates isobaric labeling quantitation analysis with improved accuracy and coverage

Mass spectrometry-based proteomics using isobaric labeling for multiplex quantitation has become a popular approach for proteomic studies. We present Multi-Q 2, an isobaric-labeling quantitation tool which can yield the largest quantitation coverage and improved quantitation accuracy compared to three state-of-the-art methods. Multi-Q 2 supports identification results from several popular proteomic data analysis platforms for quantitation, offering up to 12% improvement in quantitation coverage for accepting identification results from multiple search engines when compared with MaxQuant and PatternLab. It is equipped with various quantitation algorithms, including a ratio compression correction algorithm, and results in up to 336 algorithmic combinations. Systematic evaluation shows different algorithmic combinations have different strengths and are suitable for different situations. We also demonstrate that the flexibility of Multi-Q 2 in customizing algorithmic combination can lead to improved quantitation accuracy over existing tools. Moreover, the use of complementary algorithmic combinations can be an effective strategy to enhance sensitivity when searching for biomarkers from differentially expressed proteins in proteomic experiments. Multi-Q 2 provides interactive graphical interfaces to process quantitation and to display ratios at protein, peptide, and spectrum levels. It also supports a heatmap module, enabling users to cluster proteins based on their abundance ratios and to visualize the clustering results. Multi-Q 2 executable files, sample data sets, and user manual are freely available at http://ms.iis.sinica.edu.tw/COmics/Software_Multi-Q2.html.

Simple Method to Quantify Protein Abundances from 1000 Cells

The rise of single-cell transcriptomics has created an urgent need for similar approaches that use a minimal number of cells to quantify expression levels of proteins. We integrated and optimized multiple recent developments to establish a proteomics workflow to quantify proteins from as few as 1000 mammalian stem cells. The method uses chemical peptide labeling, does not require specific equipment other than cell lysis tools, and quantifies >2500 proteins with high reproducibility. We validated the method by comparing mouse embryonic stem cells and in vitro differentiated motor neurons. We identify differentially expressed proteins with small fold changes and a dynamic range in abundance similar to that of standard methods. Protein abundance measurements obtained with our protocol compared well to corresponding transcript abundance and to measurements using standard inputs. The protocol is also applicable to other systems, such as fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS)-purified cells from the tunicate Ciona. Therefore, we offer a straightforward and accurate method to acquire proteomics data from minimal input samples.

TomahaqCompanion: A Tool for the Creation and Analysis of Isobaric Label Based Multiplexed Targeted Assays

Triggered by Offset, Multiplexed, Accurate mass, High resolution, and Absolute Quantitation (TOMAHAQ) is a recently introduced targeted proteomics method that combines peptide and sample multiplexing. TOMAHAQ assays enable sensitive and accurate multiplexed quantification by implementing an intricate data collection scheme that comprises multiple MSⁿ scans, mass inclusion lists, and data-driven filters. Consequently, manual creation of TOMAHAQ methods can be time-consuming and error prone, while the resulting TOMAHAQ data may not be compatible with common mass spectrometry analysis pipelines. To address these concerns we introduce TomahaqCompanion, an open-source desktop application that enables rapid creation of TOMAHAQ methods and analysis of TOMAHAQ data. Starting from a list of peptide sequences, a user can perform each step of TOMAHAQ assay development including (1) generation of priming run target list, (2) analysis of priming run data, (3) generation of TOMAHAQ method file, and (4) analysis and export of quantitative TOMAHAQ data. We demonstrate the flexibility of TomahaqCompanion by creating a variety of methods testing TOMAHAQ parameters (e.g., number of SPS notches, run length, etc.). Lastly, we analyze an interference sample comprising heavy yeast peptides, a standard human peptide mixture, TMT11-plex, and super heavy TMT (shTMT) isobaric labels to demonstrate ∼10-200 attomol limit of quantification within a complex background using TOMAHAQ.