Preferential Control of Forward Reaction Kinetics in Hydrogels Crosslinked with Reversible Conjugate Additions

Internal Catalysis in Dynamic Hydrogels with Associative Thioester Cross-Links

Thioesters are an essential functional group in biosynthetic pathways, which has motivated their development as reactive handles in probes and peptide assembly. Thioester exchange is typically accelerated by catalysts or elevated pH. Here, we report the use of bifunctional aromatic thioesters as dynamic covalent cross-links in hydrogels, demonstrating that at physiologic pH in aqueous conditions, transthioesterification facilitates stress relaxation on the time scale of hundreds of seconds. We show that intramolecular hydrogen bonding is responsible for accelerated exchange, evident in both molecular kinetics and macromolecular stress relaxation. Drawing from concepts in the vitrimer literature, this system exemplifies how dynamic cross-links that exchange through an associative mechanism enable tunable stress relaxation without altering stiffness.

Accessing pluripotent materials through tempering of dynamic covalent polymer networks

Pluripotency, which is defined as a system not fixed as to its developmental potentialities, is typically associated with biology and stem cells. Inspired by this concept, we report synthetic polymers that act as a single "pluripotent" feedstock and can be differentiated into a range of materials that exhibit different mechanical properties, from hard and brittle to soft and extensible. To achieve this, we have exploited dynamic covalent networks that contain labile, dynamic thia-Michael bonds, whose extent of bonding can be thermally modulated and retained through tempering, akin to the process used in metallurgy. In addition, we show that the shape memory behavior of these materials can be tailored through tempering and that these materials can be patterned to spatially control mechanical properties.

Connecting Molecular Exchange Dynamics to Stress Relaxation in Phase-Separated Dynamic Covalent Networks

A suite of phase separated dynamic covalent networks based on highly tunable dynamic benzalcyanoacetate (BCA) thia-Michael acceptors are investigated. In situ kinetic studies on small molecule model systems are used in conjunction with macroscopic characterization of phase stability and stress relaxation to understand how the molecular dynamics relate to relaxation modes. Electronic modification of the BCA unit strongly impacts the exchange dynamics (particularly the rate of dissociation) and the overall equilibrium constant (Keq) of the system, with electron-withdrawing groups leading to decreased dissociation rate and increased Keq. Critically, below a chemistry-defined temperature cutoff (related to the stability of the hard phase domains), the stress relaxation behavior of these phase separated materials is dominated by the molecular exchange dynamics, allowing for networks with a tailored thermomechanical response.

Photothermal Modulation of Dynamic Covalent Poly(ethylene glycol)/PEDOT Composite Hydrogels for On-Demand Drug Delivery

Hydrogels are cross-linked three-dimensional polymer networks that have tissue-like properties. Dynamic covalent bonds (DCB) can be utilized as hydrogel cross-links to impart injectability, self-healing ability, and stimuli responsiveness to these materials. In our research, we utilized dynamic thiol-Michael bonds as cross-links in poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG)-based hydrogels. Because the equilibrium of the reversible, exothermic thiol-Michael reaction can be modulated by temperature, we investigated the possibility of using thermal and photothermal stimuli to modulate the gel-to-sol transition of these materials with the aim of developing an on-demand pulsatile cargo release system. For this purpose, we incorporated poly(3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene) (PEDOT) nanoparticles within the hydrogel to facilitate photothermal modulation using near-infrared light. PEDOT nanoparticles of 50 nm in diameter and with strong near-infrared absorption were prepared by oxidative emulsion polymerization. We then used Michael addition of thiol-ene pairs from 4-arm PEG-thiol (PEG-SH) and 4-arm PEG-benzylcyanoacetamide (PEG-BCA) to form dynamically cross-linked hydrogels. PEDOT nanoparticles were entrapped in situ to form Gel/PEDOT composites. Rheology and inverted tube test studies showed that the gel-to-sol transition occurred at 45-50 °C for 5 wt % gels and that this transition could be tailored by varying the wt % of the polymer precursors. The hydrogels were found to be capable of self-healing and being injected with a clinically relevant injection force. Bovine serum albumin-fluorescein isothiocyanate (BSA-FITC), a fluorescently labeled protein, was then loaded into the Gel/PEDOT as a therapeutic mimic. Increased release of BSA-FITC upon direct thermal stimulation and photothermal stimulation with an 808 nm laser was observed. Pulsatile release of BSA-FITC over seven cycles was demonstrated. MTS and live-dead assays demonstrated that Gel/PEDOT was cytocompatible in MDA-MB-231 breast cancer and 3T3 fibroblast cell lines. Further studies demonstrated that the encapsulation and laser-triggered release of the chemotherapeutic agent doxorubicin (DOX) could also be achieved. Altogether, this work advances our understanding of the temperature-dependent behavior of a dynamic covalent hydrogel, Gel/PEDOT, and leverages that understanding for application as a photothermally responsive biomaterial for controlled release.

Shear Thickening Behavior in Injectable Tetra-PEG Hydrogels Cross-Linked via Dynamic Thia-Michael Addition Bonds

Injectable poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG)-based hydrogels were reversibly cross-linked through thia-conjugate addition bonds and demonstrated to shear thicken at low shear rates. Cross-linking bond exchange kinetics and dilute polymer concentrations were leveraged to tune hydrogel plateau moduli (from 60 to 650 Pa) and relaxation times (from 2 to 8 s). Under continuous flow shear rheometry, these properties affected the onset of shear thickening and the degree of shear thickening achieved before a flow instability occurred. The changes in viscosity were reversible whether the shear rate increased or decreased, suggesting that chain stretching drives this behavior. Given the relevance of dynamic PEG hydrogels under shear to biomedical applications, their injectability was investigated. Injection forces were found to increase with higher polymer concentrations and slower bond exchange kinetics. Altogether, these results characterize the nonlinear rheology of dilute, dynamic covalent tetra-PEG hydrogels and offer insight into the mechanism driving their shear thickening behavior.

Dynamic-bond-induced sticky friction tailors non-Newtonian rheology

Frictional network formation has become a new paradigm for understanding the non-Newtonian shear-thickening behavior of dense suspensions. Recent studies have exclusively focused on interparticle friction that instantaneously vanishes when applied shear is ceased. Herein, we investigate a friction that emerges from dynamic chemical bridging of functionalized particle surfaces sheared into close proximity. This enables tailoring of both friction magnitude and the time release of the frictional coupling. The experiments use dense suspensions of thiol-functionalized particles suspended in ditopic polymers endcapped with benzalcyanoacetamide Michael-acceptors. The subsequent room temperature, catalyst-free dynamic thia-Michael reactions can form bridging interactions between the particles with dynamic covalent bonds that linger after formation and release in the absence of shear. This chemical friction mimics physical friction but is stickier, leading to tunable rheopexy. The effect of sticky friction on dense suspension rheology is explored by varying the electronic nature of the benzalcyanoacetamide moiety, the molecular weight of the ditopic polymers, the amount of a competitive bonding compound, and temperature. These results demonstrate how dynamic-bond-induced sticky friction can be used to systematically control the time dependence of the non-Newtonian suspension rheology.

Tailoring Dynamic Hydrogels by Controlling Associative Exchange Rates

Dithioalkylidenes are a newly-developed class of conjugate acceptors that undergo thiol exchange via an associative mechanism, enabling decoupling of key material properties for sustainability, biomedical, and sensing applications. Here, we show that the exchange rate is highly sensitive to the structure of the acceptor and tunable over four orders of magnitude in aqueous environments. Cyclic acceptors exchange rapidly, from 0.95 to 15.6 M-1s-1, while acyclic acceptors exchange between 3.77x10-3 and 2.17x10-2 M-1s-1. Computational, spectroscopic, and structural data suggest that cyclic acceptors are more reactive than their acyclic counterparts because of resonance stabilization of the tetrahedral exchange intermediate. We parametrize molecular reactivity with respect to computed descriptors of the electrophilic site and leverage this insight to design a compound with intermediate characteristics. Lastly, we incorporate this dynamic bond into hydrogels and demonstrate that the characteristic stress relaxation time (τ) is directly proportional to molecular kex.

Photoswitchable dynamic conjugate addition-elimination reactions as a tool for light-mediated click and clip chemistry

Phototriggered click and clip reactions can endow chemical processes with high spatiotemporal resolution and sustainability, but are challenging with a limited scope. Herein we report photoswitchable reversible covalent conjugate addition-elimination reactions toward light-addressed modular covalent connection and disconnection. By coupling between photochromic dithienylethene switch and Michael acceptors, the reactivity of Michael reactions was tuned through closed-ring and open-ring forms of dithienylethene, allowing switching on and off dynamic exchange of a wide scope of thiol and amine nucleophiles. The breaking of antiaromaticity in transition states and enol intermediates of addition-elimination reactions provides the driving force for photoinduced change in kinetic barriers. To showcase the versatile application, light-mediated modification of solid surfaces, regulation of amphiphilic assemblies, and creation/degradation of covalent polymers on demand were achieved. The manipulation of dynamic click/clip reactions with light should set the stage for future endeavors, including responsive assemblies, biological delivery, and intelligent materials.

Stress-Induced Shape-Shifting Materials Possessing Autonomous Self-Healing and Scratch-Resistant Ability

Covalent adaptable networks (CANs) capable of both shape-shifting and self-healing ability offer a viable alternative to 4D printing technology to gain access to various complex shapes in a simplified manner. However, most of the reported CANs exhibit shape-shifting ability in the presence of temperature, light or chemical stimuli, which restricts their further utilization as realization of such a controlled environment is not feasible under complex scenarios. Herewith, we report a set of CANs based on a room-temperature exchangeable thia-Michael adduct, which undergoes rearrangement in network topology on application of external stress. These CANs with tensile strength (≤6 MPa) and modulus (≤71.4 MPa) adopt to any programmed shape under application of nominal stress. The CANs also exhibit stress-induced recyclability, self-welding and self-healing ability under ambient conditions. The transparency and ambient condition self-healing ability render these CANs to be utilized as scratch-resistant coatings on display items.

Dynamic Covalent Michael Acceptors to Penetrate Cells: Thiol-Mediated Uptake with Tetrel-Centered Exchange Cascades, Assisted by Halogen-Bonding Switches

Chalcogen-centered cascade exchange chemistry is increasingly understood to account for thiol-mediated uptake, that is, the ability of reversibly thiol-reactive agents to penetrate cells. Here, reversible Michael acceptors are shown to enable and inhibit thiol-mediated uptake, including the cytosolic delivery of proteins. Dynamic cyano-cinnamate dimers rival the best chalcogen-centered inhibitors. Patterns generated in inhibition heatmaps reveal contributions from halogen-bonding switches that occur independent from the thyroid transporter MCT8. The uniqueness of these patterns supports that the entry of tetrel-centered exchangers into cells differs from chalcogen-centered systems. These results expand the chemical space of thiol-mediated uptake and support the existence of a universal exchange network to bring matter into cells, abiding to be decoded for drug delivery and drug discovery in the broadest sense.

Structure-Reactivity-Property Relationships in Covalent Adaptable Networks

Polymer networks built out of dynamic covalent bonds offer the potential to translate the control and tunability of chemical reactions to macroscopic physical properties. Under conditions at which these reactions occur, the topology of covalent adaptable networks (CANs) can rearrange, meaning that they can flow, self-heal, be remolded, and respond to stimuli. Materials with these properties are necessary to fields ranging from sustainability to tissue engineering; thus the conditions and time scale of network rearrangement must be compatible with the intended use. The mechanical properties of CANs are based on the thermodynamics and kinetics of their constituent bonds. Therefore, strategies are needed that connect the molecular and macroscopic worlds. In this Perspective, we analyze structure-reactivity-property relationships for several classes of CANs, illustrating both general design principles and the predictive potential of linear free energy relationships (LFERs) applied to CANs. We discuss opportunities in the field to develop quantitative structure-reactivity-property relationships and open challenges.

Thia-Michael Reaction: The Route to Promising Covalent Adaptable Networks

While the Michael addition has been employed for more than 130 years for the synthesis of a vast diversity of compounds, the reversibility of this reaction when heteronucleophiles are involved has been generally less considered. First applied to medicinal chemistry, the reversible character of the hetero-Michael reactions has recently been explored for the synthesis of Covalent Adaptable Networks (CANs), in particular the thia-Michael reaction and more recently the aza-Michael reaction. In these cross-linked networks, exchange reactions take place between two Michael adducts by successive dissociation and association steps. In order to understand and precisely control the exchange in these CANs, it is necessary to get an insight into the critical parameters influencing the Michael addition and the dissociation rates of Michael adducts by reconsidering previous studies on these matters. This review presents the progress in the understanding of the thia-Michael reaction over the years as well as the latest developments and plausible future directions to prepare CANs based on this reaction. The potential of aza-Michael reaction for CANs application is highlighted in a specific section with comparison with thia-Michael-based CANs.

Polymeric Microneedle Arrays with Glucose-Sensing Dynamic-Covalent Bonding for Insulin Delivery

The ongoing rise in diabetes incidence necessitates improved therapeutic strategies to enable precise blood glucose control with convenient device form factors. Microneedle patches are one such device platform capable of achieving therapeutic delivery through the skin. In recent years, polymeric microneedle arrays have been reported using methods of in situ polymerization and covalent crosslinking in microneedle molds. In spite of promising results, in situ polymerization carries a risk of exposure to toxic unreacted precursors remaining in the device. Here, a polymeric microneedle patch is demonstrated that uses dynamic-covalent phenylboronic acid (PBA)-diol bonds in a dual role affording both network crosslinking and glucose sensing. By this approach, a pre-synthesized and purified polymer bearing pendant PBA motifs is combined with a multivalent diol crosslinker to prepare dynamic-covalent hydrogel networks. The ability of these dynamic hydrogels to shear-thin and self-heal enables their loading to a microneedle mold by centrifugation. Subsequent drying then yields a patch of uniformly shaped microneedles with the requisite mechanical properties to penetrate skin. Insulin release from these materials is accelerated in the presence of glucose. Moreover, short-term blood glucose control in a diabetic rat model following application of the device to the skin confirms insulin activity and bioavailability. Accordingly, dynamic-covalent crosslinking facilitates a route for fabricating microneedle arrays circumventing the toxicity concerns of in situ polymerization, offering a convenient device form factor for therapeutic insulin delivery.

Designing Stress-Adaptive Dense Suspensions Using Dynamic Covalent Chemistry

The non-Newtonian behaviors of dense suspensions are central to their use in technological and industrial applications and arise from a network of particle–particle contacts that dynamically adapt to imposed shear. Reported herein are studies aimed at exploring how dynamic covalent chemistry between particles and the polymeric solvent can be used to tailor such stress-adaptive contact networks, leading to their unusual rheological behaviors. Specifically, a room temperature dynamic thia-Michael bond is employed to rationally tune the equilibrium constant (K_eq) of the polymeric solvent to the particle interface. It is demonstrated that low K_eq leads to shear thinning, while high K_eq produces antithixotropy, a rare phenomenon where the viscosity increases with shearing time. It is proposed that an increase in K_eq increases the polymer graft density at the particle surface and that antithixotropy primarily arises from partial debonding of the polymeric graft/solvent from the particle surface and the formation of polymer bridges between particles. Thus, the implementation of dynamic covalent chemistry provides a new molecular handle with which to tailor the macroscopic rheology of suspensions by introducing programmable time dependence. These studies open the door to energy-absorbing materials that not only sense mechanical inputs and adjust their dissipation as a function of time or shear rate but also can switch between these two modalities on demand.

Sulfur in Dynamic Covalent Chemistry

Sulfur has been important in dynamic covalent chemistry (DCC) since the beginning of the field. Mainly as part of disulfides and thioesters, dynamic sulfur-based bonds (DSBs) have a leading role in several remarkable reactions. Part of this success is due to the almost ideal properties of DSBs for the preparation of dynamic covalent systems, including high reactivity and good reversibility under mild aqueous conditions, the possibility of exploiting supramolecular interactions, access to isolable structures, and easy experimental control to turn the reaction on/off. DCC is currently witnessing an increase in the importance of DSBs. The chemical flexibility offered by DSBs opens the door to multiple applications. This Review presents an overview of all the DSBs used in DCC, their applications, and remarks on the interesting properties that they confer on dynamic chemical systems, especially those containing several DSBs.

Diboronate crosslinking: Introducing glucose specificity in glucose-responsive dynamic-covalent networks

Dynamic-covalent motifs are increasingly used for hydrogel crosslinking, leveraging equilibrium-governed reversible bonds to prepare viscoelastic materials with dynamic properties and self-healing character. The bonding between aryl boronates and diols is one dynamic-covalent chemistry of interest. The extent of network crosslinking using this motif may be subject to competition from ambient diols such as glucose; this approach has long been explored for glucose-directed release of insulin to control diabetes. However, the majority of such work has used phenylboronic acids (PBAs) that suffer from low-affinity glucose binding, limiting material responsiveness. Moreover, many PBA chemistries also bind with higher affinity to certain non-glucose analytes like fructose and lactate than they do to glucose, limiting their specificity of sensing and therapeutic deployment. Here, dynamic-covalent hydrogels are prepared that, for the first time, use a new diboronate motif with enhanced glucose binding-and importantly improved glucose specificity-leveraging the ability of rigid diboronates to simultaneously bind two sites on a single glucose molecule. Compared to long-used PBA-based approaches, diboronate hydrogels offer more glucose-responsive insulin release that is minimally impacted by non-glucose analytes. Improved responsiveness translates to more rapid blood glucose correction in a rodent diabetes model. Accordingly, this new dynamic-covalent crosslinking chemistry is useful in realizing more sensitive and specific glucose-responsive materials.

Effect of pH on the Properties of Hydrogels Cross-Linked via Dynamic Thia-Michael Addition Bonds

Hydrogels cross-linked with dynamic covalent bonds exhibit time-dependent properties, making them an advantageous platform for applications ranging from biomaterials to self-healing networks. However, the relationship between the cross-link exchange kinetics, material properties, and stability of these platforms is not fully understood, especially upon addition of external stimuli. In this work, pH was used as a handle to manipulate cross-link exchange kinetics and control the resulting hydrogel mechanics and stability in a physiologically relevant window. Poly(ethylene glycol)-based hydrogels were cross-linked with a reversible thia-Michael addition reaction in aqueous buffer between pH 3 and pH 7. The rate constants of bond exchange and equilibrium constants were determined for each pH value, and these data were correlated with the resulting mechanical profiles of the bulk hydrogels. With increasing pH, both the forward and the reverse rate constants increased, while the equilibrium constant decreased. These changes led to faster stress relaxation and less stiff hydrogels at more basic pH values. The elevated pH values also led to an increased mass loss and a faster rate of release of an encapsulated model bovine serum albumin fluorescent protein. The connection between the kinetics, mechanics, and molecular release profiles provides important insight into the structure–property relationships of dynamic covalent hydrogels, and this system offers a promising platform for controlled release between physiologically relevant pH values.

Star-Polymer-DNA Gels Showing Highly Predictable and Tunable Mechanical Responses

Dynamically crosslinked gels are appealing materials for applications that require time-dependent mechanical responses. DNA duplexes are ideal crosslinkers for building such gels because of their excellent sequence addressability and flexible tunability in bond energy. However, the mechanical responses of most DNA gels are complicated and unpredictable. Here, a DNA gel with a highly homogeneous gel network and well predictable mechanical behaviors is demonstrated by using a pair of star-polymer-DNA precursors with presimulated DNA sequences showing the two-state transition. The melting curve analysis of the DNA gels reveals the good correspondence between the thermodynamic potentials of the DNA crosslinkers and the presimulated values by DNA calculators. Stress-relaxation tests and dissociation kinetics measurements show that the macroscopic relaxation time of the DNA gels is approximately equal to the lifetime of the DNA crosslinkers over 4 orders of magnitude from 0.1-2000 s. Furthermore, a series of durability tests find the DNA gels are hysteresis-less and self-healable after the applications of repeated temperature and mechanical stimuli. These results demonstrate the great potential of star-polymer-DNA precursors for building gels with predictable and tunable viscoelastic properties, suitable for applications such as stress-response extracellular matrices, injectable solids, and soft robotics.

Internal and External Catalysis in Boronic Ester Networks

In dynamic materials, the reversible condensation between boronic acids and diols provides adaptability, self-healing ability, and responsiveness to small molecules and pH. The thermodynamics and kinetics of bond exchange determine the mechanical properties of dynamic polymer networks. Here, we investigate the effects of diol structure and salt additives on the rate of boronic acid-diol bond exchange, binding affinity, and the mechanical properties of the corresponding polymer networks. We find that proximal amides used to conjugate diols to polymers and buffering anions induce significant rate acceleration, consistent with an internal and external catalysis, respectively. This rate acceleration is reflected in the stress relaxation of the gels. These findings contribute to the fundamental understanding of the boronic ester dynamic bond and offer molecular strategies to tune the macromolecular properties of dynamic materials.

Synthetic hydrogels as blood clot mimicking wound healing materials

Excessive bleeding-or hemorrhage-causes millions of civilian and non-civilian casualties every year. Additionally, wound sequelae, such as infections, are a significant source of chronic morbidity, even if the initial bleeding is successfully stopped. To treat acute and chronic wounds, numerous wound healing materials have been identified, tested, and adopted. Among them are topical dressings, such as gauzes, as well as natural and biomimetic materials. However, none of these materials successfully mimic the complex and dynamic properties of the body's own wound healing material: the blood clot. Specifically, blood clots exhibit complex mechanical and biochemical properties that vary across spatial and temporal scales to guide the wound healing response, which make them the ideal wound healing material. In this manuscript, we review blood clots' complex mechanical and biochemical properties, review current wound healing materials, and identify opportunities where new materials can provide additional functionality, with a specific focus on hydrogels. We highlight recent developments in synthetic hydrogels that make them capable of mimicking a larger subset of blood clot features: as plugs and as stimuli for tissue repair. We conclude that future hydrogel materials designed to mimic blood clot biochemistry, mechanics, and architecture can be combined with exciting platelet-like particles to serve as hemostats that also promote the biological wound healing response. Thus, we believe synthetic hydrogels are ideal candidates to address the clear need for better wound healing materials.

Controlling the Morphology of Dynamic Thia-Michael Networks to Target Pressure-Sensitive and Hot Melt Adhesives

A series of multistage (pressure-sensitive/hot melt) adhesives utilizing dynamic thia-Michael bonding motifs are reported. The benzalcyanoacetate Michael acceptors used in this work undergo bond exchange under ambient conditions without external catalysis, facilitating pressure-sensitive adhesion. A key feature of this system is the dynamic reaction-induced phase separation that lends reinforcement to the otherwise weakly bonded materials, enabling weak, repeatable pressure-sensitive adhesion under ambient conditions and strong adhesion when processed as a hot melt adhesive. By using different pairs of benzalcyanoacetate cross-linking units, the phase separation characteristics of the adhesives can be directly manipulated, allowing for a tailored adhesive response.

Thermo-Viscoelastic Response of Protein-Based Hydrogels

Because of the bioactivity and biocompatibility of protein-based gels and the reversible nature of bonds between associating coiled coils, these materials demonstrate a wide spectrum of potential applications in targeted drug delivery, tissue engineering, and regenerative medicine. The kinetics of rearrangement (association and dissociation) of the physical bonds between chains has been traditionally studied in shear relaxation tests and small-amplitude oscillatory tests. A characteristic feature of recombinant protein gels is that chains in the polymer network are connected by temporary bonds between the coiled coil complexes and permanent cross-links between functional groups of amino acids. A simple model is developed for the linear viscoelastic behavior of protein-based gels. Its advantage is that, on the one hand, the model only involves five material parameters with transparent physical meaning and, on the other, it correctly reproduces experimental data in shear relaxation and oscillatory tests. The model is applied to study the effects of temperature, the concentration of proteins, and their structure on the viscoelastic response of hydrogels.