Mechanically Induced Bacterial Death Imaged in Real Time: A Simultaneous Nanoindentation and Fluorescence Microscopy Study

Effects of Surface Topography and Cellular Biomechanics on Nanopillar-Induced Bactericidal Activity

Bacteria are mechanically resistant biological structures that can sustain physical stress. Experimental data, however, have shown that high-aspect-ratio nanopillars deform bacterial cells upon contact. If the deformation is sufficiently large, it lyses the bacterial cell wall, ultimately leading to cell death. This has prompted a novel strategy, known as mechano-bactericide technology, to fabricate antibacterial surfaces. Although adhesion forces were originally proposed as the driving force for mechano-bactericidal action, it has been recently shown that external forces, such as capillary forces arising from an air-water interface at bacterial surfaces, produce sufficient loads to rapidly kill bacteria on nanopillars. This discovery highlights the need to theoretically examine how bacteria respond to external loads and to ascertain the key factors. In this study, we developed a finite element model approximating bacteria as elastic shells filled with cytoplasmic fluid brought into contact with an individual nanopillar or nanopillar array. This model elucidates that bacterial killing caused by external forces on nanopillars is influenced by surface topography and cell biomechanical variables, including the density and arrangement of nanopillars, in addition to the cell wall thickness and elastic modulus. Considering that surface topography is an important design parameter, we performed experiments using nanopillar arrays with precisely controlled nanopillar diameters and spacing. Consistent with model predictions, these demonstrate that nanopillars with a larger spacing increase bacterial susceptibility to mechanical puncture. The results provide salient insights into mechano-bactericidal activity and identify key design parameters for implementing this technology.

In Situ Single-Cell Bacterial Imaging Provides Mechanistic Insight into the Photodynamic Action of Photosensitizer-Loaded Hydrogels

Hydrogels, three-dimensional hydrophilic polymeric networks with high water retaining capacity, have gained prominence in wound management and drug delivery due to their tunability, softness, permeability, and biocompatibility. Electron-beam polymerized poly(ethylene glycol) diacrylate (PEGDA) hydrogels are particularly useful for phototherapies such as antimicrobial photodynamic therapy (aPDT) due to their excellent optical properties. This work takes advantage of the transparency of PEGDA hydrogels to investigate bacterial responses to aPDT at the single-cell level, in real-time and in situ. The photosensitizer methylene blue (MB) was loaded in PEGDA hydrogels by using two methods: reversible loading and irreversible immobilization within the 3D polymer network. MB release kinetics and singlet oxygen generation were studied, revealing the distinct behaviors of both hydrogels. Real-time imaging of Escherichia coli was conducted during aPDT in both hydrogel types, using the Min protein system to report changes in bacterial physiology. Min oscillation patterns provided mechanistic insights into bacterial photoinactivation, revealing a dependence on the hydrogel preparation method. This difference was attributed to the mobility of MB within the hydrogel, affecting its direct interaction with bacterial membranes. These findings shed light on the complex interplay between hydrogel properties and the bacterial response during aPDT, offering valuable insights for the development of antibacterial wound dressing materials. The study demonstrates the capability of real-time, single-cell fluorescence microscopy to unravel dynamic bacterial behaviors in the intricate environment of hydrogel surfaces during aPDT.

Magnetic micromotors crossing lipid membranes

Nano/micromotors are self-propelled particles that show enhanced motion upon being triggered by a stimulus. Their use in nanomedicine has been widely explored, with special focus on imaging or drug delivery. However, a thorough understanding of the requirements for more efficient locomotion is still lacking. In this paper, we assembled magnetically propelled motors of different sizes (i.e., 0.5, 1 and 4 μm) and surface chemistries (positive charge or PEGylated) and assessed their motion in the presence of giant unilamellar lipid vesicles (GUVs) of varying compositions (zwitterionic, negatively charged and saturated lipids). Unexpectedly, the size does not seem to be the dominating characteristics that governs the ability of the motors to cross lipid membranes. Specifically, the 0.5 μm PEGylated motors have very limited ability to cross the lipid membrane of GUVs due to their non-interacting nature compared to their equally sized positively charged counterparts. Furthermore, membranes made of saturated lipids and, in particular, in combination with a weak magnetic field facilitate motors' crossing, regardless of their size. The results were validated by in-house data-driven statistical analysis that employs experimental data to allow for the identification of individual motor motion in the ensemble when meeting the lipid membranes. Altogether, we provide insight into motor locomotion when they interact with a biological barrier considering both the entire ensemble and the individual motors, which has the potential to support considerations of future motor designs.

Antimicrobial mechanisms of nanopatterned surfaces-a developing story

Whilst it is now well recognized that some natural surfaces such as seemingly fragile insect wings possess extraordinary antimicrobial properties, a quest to engineer similar nanopatterned surfaces (NPSs) is ongoing. The stake is high as biofouling impacts critical infrastructure leading to massive social and economic burden with an antimicrobial resistance (AMR) issue at the forefront. AMR is one of the most imminent health challenges the world is facing today. Here, in the effort to find more sustainable solutions, the NPSs are proposed as highly promising technology as their antimicrobial activity arises from the topographical features, which could be realized on multiple material surfaces. To fully exploit these potentials however, it is crucial to mechanistically understand the underlying killing pathways. Thus far, several mechanisms have been proposed, yet they all have one thing in common. The antimicrobial process is initiated with bacteria contacting nanopatterns, which then imposes mechanical stress onto bacterial cell wall. Hence, the activity is called "mechano-bactericidal". From this point on, however, the suggested mechanisms start to diverge partly due to our limited understanding of force interactions at the interface. The aim of this mini review is to analyze the state-of-the-art in proposed killing mechanisms by categorizing them based on the characteristics of their driving force. We also highlight the current gaps and possible future directions in investigating the mechanisms, particularly by shifting towards quantification of forces at play and more elaborated biochemical assays, which can aid validating the current hypotheses.

Damage Behavior with Atomic Force Microscopy on Anti-Bacterial Nanostructure Arrays

The atomic force microscope is a versatile tool for assessing the topography, friction, and roughness of a broad spectrum of surfaces, encompassing anti-bacterial nanostructure arrays. Measuring and comparing all these values with one instrument allows clear comparisons of many nanomechanical reactions and anomalies. Increasing nano-Newton-level forces through the cantilever tip allows for the testing and measuring of failure points, damage behavior, and functionality under unfavorable conditions. Subjecting a grade 5 titanium alloy to hydrothermally etched nanostructures while applying elevated cantilever tip forces resulted in the observation of irreversible damage through atomic force microscopy. Despite the damage, a rough and non-uniform morphology remained that may still allow it to perform in its intended application as an anti-bacterial implant surface. Utilizing an atomic force microscope enables the evaluation of these surfaces before their biomedical application.

Cell Adhesion, Elasticity, and Rupture Forces Guide Microbial Cell Death on Nanostructured Antimicrobial Titanium Surfaces

Naturally occurring and synthetic nanostructured surfaces have been widely reported to resist microbial colonization. The majority of these studies have shown that both bacterial and fungal cells are killed upon contact and subsequent surface adhesion to such surfaces. This occurs because the presence of high-aspect-ratio structures can initiate a self-driven mechanical rupture of microbial cells during the surface adsorption process. While this technology has received a large amount of scientific and medical interest, one important question still remains: what factors drive microbial death on the surface? In this work, the interplay between microbial-surface adhesion, cell elasticity, cell membrane rupture forces, and cell lysis at the microbial-nanostructure biointerface during adsorptive processes was assessed using a combination of live confocal laser scanning microscopy, scanning electron microscopy, in situ amplitude atomic force microscopy, and single-cell force spectroscopy. Specifically, the adsorptive behavior and nanomechanical properties of live Gram-negative (Pseudomonas aeruginosa) and Gram-positive (methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus) bacterial cells, as well as the fungal species Candida albicans and Cryptococcus neoformans, were assessed on unmodified and nanostructured titanium surfaces. Unmodified titanium and titanium surfaces with nanostructures were used as model substrates for investigation. For all microbial species, cell elasticity, rupture force, maximum cell-surface adhesion force, the work of adhesion, and the cell-surface tether behavior were compared to the relative cell death observed for each surface examined. For cells with a lower elastic modulus, lower force to rupture through the cell, and higher work of adhesion, the surfaces had a higher antimicrobial activity, supporting the proposed biocidal mode of action for nanostructured surfaces. This study provides direct quantification of the differences observed in the efficacy of nanostructured antimicrobial surface as a function of microbial species indicating that a universal, antimicrobial surface architecture may be hard to achieve.

Hydrodynamic tearing of bacteria on nanotips for sustainable water disinfection

Water disinfection is conventionally achieved by oxidation or irradiation, which is often associated with a high carbon footprint and the formation of toxic byproducts. Here, we describe a nano-structured material that is highly effective at killing bacteria in water through a hydrodynamic mechanism. The material consists of carbon-coated, sharp Cu(OH)2 nanowires grown on a copper foam substrate. We show that mild water flow (e.g. driven from a storage tank) can efficiently tear up bacteria through a high dispersion force between the nanotip surface and the cell envelope. Bacterial cell rupture is due to tearing of the cell envelope rather than collisions. This mechanism produces rapid inactivation of bacteria in water, and achieved complete disinfection in a 30-day field test. Our approach exploits fluidic energy and does not require additional energy supply, thus offering an efficient and low-cost system that could potentially be incorporated in water treatment processes in wastewater facilities and rural communities.

Time-dependent plastic behavior of bacteria leading to rupture

A study of the mechanical response of bacteria is essential in designing an antibacterial surface for implants and food packaging applications. This research evaluated the mechanical response of Escherichia coli under different loading conditions. Indentation and prolonged creep tests were performed to understand their viscoelastic-plastic response. The results indicate that varying loading rates from 1 μm/s to 5 μm/s show an increase in modulus of 182% and 90%, calculated in the loading and unloading cycles, respectively, and a decrease in adhesion force by 42%. However, on varying loads from 5 nN to 25 nN, nominal change is observed in both modulus and adhesion force. The rupture curve at 100 nN load shows elastic and a small plastic deformation accompanied by a sharp peak indicating the cell wall rupture. The rupture force at the peak was found to be 34.38 ± 5.15 nN, irrespective of the loading rate, making it a failure criterion for bacteria rupture. The creep response of bacteria increases (for 6 s) and then remains constant (for 15 s) with time, indicating that a standard linear solid (SLS) model applies to this behavior. This work attempts to evaluate the mechanical properties of E. coli bacteria focusing on its rupture by contact killing mechanism.

Bioinspired bi-phasic 3D nanoflowers of MgO/Mg(OH)2 coated melamine sponge as a novel bactericidal agent

By roughly mimicking the surface architectural design of dragonfly wings, novel bi-phasic 3D nanoflowers of MgO/Mg(OH)2 were successfully synthesized via the electrospinning technique. The 3D nanoflowers were coated over a commercial melamine sponge and extensively characterized by SEM, XRD, FTIR, and EDS. The formation of distinct dense 3D nano petals was revealed by SEM images whereby the mean petal thickness and mean distance between the adjacent petals were found to be 36 nm and 121 nm, respectively. The bactericidal activities of synthesized 3D nano-flowers coated melamine sponges were assessed against five different bacteria (Staphylococcus aureus, Enterococcus faecalis, Escherichia coli, Klebsiella pneumoniae, and Pseudomonas aeruginosa). This study demonstrated significant bactericidal activity of MgO/Mg(OH)2 3D nanoflowers coated MS against Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria. Plausible bactericidal mechanisms include envelope deformation, penetration, and induction of oxidative stress. This study introduces novel bioinspired biomaterial with the capacity to reduce the risk associated with pathogenic bacterial infections, especially in medical devices.

Investigation of Soft Matter Nanomechanics by Atomic Force Microscopy and Optical Tweezers: A Comprehensive Review

Soft matter exhibits a multitude of intrinsic physico-chemical attributes. Their mechanical properties are crucial characteristics to define their performance. In this context, the rigidity of these systems under exerted load forces is covered by the field of biomechanics. Moreover, cellular transduction processes which are involved in health and disease conditions are significantly affected by exogenous biomechanical actions. In this framework, atomic force microscopy (AFM) and optical tweezers (OT) can play an important role to determine the biomechanical parameters of the investigated systems at the single-molecule level. This review aims to fully comprehend the interplay between mechanical forces and soft matter systems. In particular, we outline the capabilities of AFM and OT compared to other classical bulk techniques to determine nanomechanical parameters such as Young's modulus. We also provide some recent examples of nanomechanical measurements performed using AFM and OT in hydrogels, biopolymers and cellular systems, among others. We expect the present manuscript will aid potential readers and stakeholders to fully understand the potential applications of AFM and OT to soft matter systems.

Antibacterial Nanomaterials: Mechanisms, Impacts on Antimicrobial Resistance and Design Principles

Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) is one of the biggest threats to the environment and health. AMR rapidly invalidates conventional antibiotics, and antimicrobial nanomaterials have been increasingly explored as alternatives. Interestingly, several antimicrobial nanomaterials show AMR-independent antimicrobial effects without detectable new resistance and have therefore been suggested to prevent AMR evolution. In contrast, some are found to trigger the evolution of AMR. Given these seemingly conflicting findings, a timely discussion of the two faces of antimicrobial nanomaterials is urgently needed. This review systematically compares the killing mechanisms and structure-activity relationships of antibiotics and antimicrobial nanomaterials. We then focus on nano-microbe interactions to elucidate the impacts of molecular initiating events on AMR evolution. Finally, we provide an outlook on future antimicrobial nanomaterials and propose design principles for the prevention of AMR evolution.

On Nanomachines and Their Future Perspectives in Biomedicine

Nano/micromotors are a class of active matter that can self-propel converting different types of input energy into kinetic energy. The huge efforts that are made in this field over the last years result in remarkable advances. Specifically, a high number of publications have dealt with biomedical applications that these motors may offer. From the first attempts in 2D cell cultures, the research has evolved to tissue and in vivo experimentation, where motors show promising results. In this Perspective, an overview over the evolution of motors with focus on bio-relevant environments is provided. Then, a discussion on the advances and challenges is presented, and eventually some remarks and perspectives of the field are outlined.

Optimising correlative super resolution and atomic force microscopies for investigating the cellular cytoskeleton

Correlative imaging methods can provide greater information for investigations of cellular ultra-structure, with separate analysis methods complementing each other’s strengths and covering for deficiencies. Here we present a method for correlative applications of super resolution and atomic force microscopies, optimising the sample preparation for correlative imaging of the cellular cytoskeleton in COS-7 cells. This optimisation determined the order of permeabilisation and fixation, the concentration of Triton X-100 surfactant used and time required for sufficient removal of the cellular membrane while maintaining the microtubule network. Correlative SMLM/AFM imaging revealed the different information that can be obtained through each microscopy. The widths of microtubules and microtubule clusters were determined from both AFM height measurements and Gaussian fitting of SMLM intensity cross sections, these were then compared to determine the orientation of microtubules within larger microtubule bundles. The ordering of microtubules at intersections was determined from the AFM height profiles as each microtubule crosses the other. The combination of both microtubule diameter measurements enabled greater information on their structure to be found than either measurement could individually.

Surface Wettability Is a Key Feature in the Mechano-Bactericidal Activity of Nanopillars

Nanopillar-textured surfaces are of growing interest because of their ability to kill bacteria through physical damage without relying on antimicrobial chemicals. Although research on antibacterial nanopillars has progressed significantly in recent years, the effect of nanopillar hydrophobicity on bactericidal activity remains elusive. In this study, we investigated the mechano-bactericidal efficacy of etched silicon nanopillars against Pseudomonas aeruginosa at nanopillar hydrophobicities from superhydrophilic to superhydrophobic. Assessing cell viability and bacterial morphology in immersed wet conditions, we observed negligible bactericidal activity; however, air/liquid interface displacement during water evaporation established a bactericidal effect that strongly depends on substrate hydrophobicity. Specifically, bactericidal activity was highest on superhydrophilic surfaces but abated with increasing hydrophobicity, diminishing at substrate contact angles larger than 90°. Calculation of the surface tension and Laplace pressure forces during water evaporation for each substrate subsequently highlighted that the total capillary force, as an external driving force responsible for bacterial deformation, is significantly weaker on hydrophobic substrates. These findings suggest that superhydrophilic nanopillared surfaces are a superior choice for mechano-bactericidal activity, whereas superhydrophobic surfaces, although not bactericidal, may have antibiofouling properties through their self-cleaning effect. These findings provide new insights into the design and application of nanopillared surfaces as functional antibacterial materials.

Min Oscillations as Real-time Reporter of Sublethal Effects in Photodynamic Treatment of Bacteria

The Min protein system is a cell division regulator in Escherichia coli. Under normal growth conditions, MinD is associated with the membrane and undergoes pole-to-pole oscillations. The period of these oscillations has been previously proposed as a reporter for the bacterial physiological state at the single-cell level and has been used to monitor the response to sublethal challenges from antibiotics, temperature, or mechanical fatigue. Using real-time single-cell fluorescence imaging, we explore here the effect of photodynamic treatment on MinD oscillations. Irradiation of bacteria in the presence of the photosensitizer methylene blue disrupts the MinD oscillation pattern depending on its concentration. In contrast to antibiotics, which slow down the oscillation, photodynamic treatment results in an abrupt interruption, reflecting divergent physiological mechanisms leading to bacterial death. We show that MinD oscillations are sensitive to mild photodynamic effects that are overlooked by traditional methods, expanding the toolbox for mechanistic studies in antimicrobial photodynamic therapy.

Insights into complex nanopillar-bacteria interactions: Roles of nanotopography and bacterial surface proteins

Nanopillared surfaces have emerged as a promising strategy to combat bacterial infections on medical devices. However, the mechanisms that underpin nanopillar-induced rupture of the bacterial cell membrane remain speculative. In this study, we have tested three medically relevant poly(ethylene terephthalate) (PET) nanopillared-surfaces with well-defined nanotopographies against both Gram-negative and Gram-positive bacteria. Focused ion beam scanning electron microscopy (FIB-SEM) and contact mechanics analysis were utilised to understand the nanobiophysical response of the bacterial cell envelope to a single nanopillar. Given their importance to bacterial adhesion, the contribution of bacterial surface proteins to nanotopography-mediated cell envelope damage was also investigated. We found that, whilst cell envelope deformation was affected by the nanopillar tip diameter, the nanopillar density affected bacterial metabolic activities. Moreover, three different types of bacterial cell envelope deformation were observed upon contact of bacteria with the nanopillared surfaces. These were attributed to bacterial responses to cell wall stresses resulting from the high intrinsic pressure caused by the engagement of nanopillars by bacterial surface proteins. Such influences of bacterial surface proteins on the antibacterial action of nanopillars have not been previously reported. Our findings will be valuable to the improved design and fabrication of effective antibacterial surfaces.

Chemically Propelled Nano and Micromotors in the Body: Quo Vadis?

The active delivery of drugs to disease sites in response to specific biomarkers is a holy grail in theranostics. If successful, it would greatly diminish the therapeutic dosage and reduce collateral cytotoxicity. In this context, the development of nano and micromotors that are able to harvest local energy to move directionally is an important breakthrough. However, serious hurdles remain before such active systems can be employed in vivo in therapeutic applications. Such motors and their energy sources must be safe and biocompatible, they should be able to move through complex body fluids, and have the ability to reach specific cellular targets. Given the complexity in the design and deployment of nano and micromotors, it is also critically important to show that they are significantly superior to inactive "smart" nanoparticles in theranostics. Furthermore, receiving regulatory approval requires the ability to scale-up the production of nano and micromotors with uniformity in structure, function, and activity. In this essay, the limitations of the current nano and micromotors and the issues that need to be resolved before such motors are likely to find theranostic applications are discussed.

Theoretical and computational investigations into mechanobactericidal activity of nanostructures at the bacteria-biomaterial interface: a critical review

Mechanobactericidal surfaces kill bacteria upon contact by posing landscapes hostile to them and have rapidly gained popularity amongst researchers over the past decade. But several fundamental aspects of the physical interactions between bacteria and nanostructures and the underlying killing mechanisms are still poorly understood. This is partly attributable to the difficulties associated with the characterization of the bacteria-nanostructure interface in a biological environment during the killing process and to the stochastic and non-linear behaviors generally associated with biological systems. However, several analytical and computational models have presented and analyzed possible killing routes and have proven useful in understanding different aspects of the phenomena. Analytical models formulate equations, often based on energy considerations, and aim to predict optimal nanostructure dimensions. They are more widely used than computational models that try to simulate the killing process and the stress or strain fields in the cell membrane through numerical methods. These models provide insights into the forces responsible for the spontaneous penetration of the cell into the nanostructures, which are still highly debated in the field. They have also helped to correlate the nanostructure dimensions with their bactericidal activity to optimize such values and facilitate the translation of this technology to physiological conditions. This review focuses on the rupture of the bacterial cell wall by nanopillars or similar high aspect ratio structures and applying these principles to the deformation of the cell membrane. Many recent interesting experimental results that either refute our current understanding or have the potential to challenge the current consensus are also discussed. Lastly, the limitations of the current strategies and opportunities to address the unresolved gaps in the field are also presented.

Physics Comes to the Aid of Medicine-Clinically-Relevant Microorganisms through the Eyes of Atomic Force Microscope

Despite the hope that was raised with the implementation of antibiotics to the treatment of infections in medical practice, the initial enthusiasm has substantially faded due to increasing drug resistance in pathogenic microorganisms. Therefore, there is a need for novel analytical and diagnostic methods in order to extend our knowledge regarding the mode of action of the conventional and novel antimicrobial agents from a perspective of single microbial cells as well as their communities growing in infected sites, i.e., biofilms. In recent years, atomic force microscopy (AFM) has been mostly used to study different aspects of the pathophysiology of noninfectious conditions with attempts to characterize morphological and rheological properties of tissues, individual mammalian cells as well as their organelles and extracellular matrix, and cells’ mechanical changes upon exposure to different stimuli. At the same time, an ever-growing number of studies have demonstrated AFM as a valuable approach in studying microorganisms in regard to changes in their morphology and nanomechanical properties, e.g., stiffness in response to antimicrobial treatment or interaction with a substrate as well as the mechanisms behind their virulence. This review summarizes recent developments and the authors’ point of view on AFM-based evaluation of microorganisms’ response to applied antimicrobial treatment within a group of selected bacteria, fungi, and viruses. The AFM potential in development of modern diagnostic and therapeutic methods for combating of infections caused by drug-resistant bacterial strains is also discussed.