High Dynamic Range (Δn) Two-Stage Photopolymers via Enhanced Solubility of a High Refractive Index Acrylate Writing Monomer

High Refractive Index, Low Birefringence Holographic Materials via the Homopolymerization of 1,2-Dithiolanes

High refractive index, low birefringence photopolymers were created via the radical-mediated, ring opening homopolymerization of 1,2-dithiolane functionalized monomers and were subsequently evaluated as holographic recording media. This investigation systematically characterized the reaction kinetics, thermodynamics, and volume shrinkage of the 1,2-dithiolane homopolymerization as well as the optical transparency, refractive index, birefringence, and holographic performance of multifunctional 1,2-dithiolane functionalized monomers and their resultant polymers. Real-time kinetic and thermodynamic analyses of a monofunctional 1,2-dithiolane monomer, lipoic acid methyl ester (LipOMe), indicated rapid monomer conversion, exceeding 90% in 60 s, with an overall enthalpy of reaction of 18 ± 1 kJ/mol. The ring-opening polymerization resulted in low shrinkage (10.6 ± 0.3 cm3/mol dithiolane) and a significant bulk refractive index increase (0.030 ± 0.003). The resulting photopolymers exhibited high optical transparency, minimal haze, and negligible birefringence, suggesting the potential of 1,2-homopolymers as optical materials. To further explore the specific capabilities for use as high-performance holographic recording applications, several multifunctional monomers were synthesized with the ethanedithiol lipoic acid monomer (EDT-Lip2) selected for experimentation. Holographic diffraction gratings written using this monomer achieved a peak-to-mean refractive index modulation of 0.008 with minimal haze and birefringence.

High Refractive Index Monomers for Improving the Holographic Recording Performance of Two-Stage Photopolymers

Photopolymers hold great promise for the preparation of transparent volume holographic gratings (VHG), which are core optical elements in many application fields. To improve the holographic recording property of a two-stage photopolymer, four new (meth)acrylate monomers (CTA, CTMA, CTBA, CTBMA) with high refractive indices (1.59-1.63) are designed and synthesized in this study. Using them as one writing monomer, a series of photopolymer samples with different formulations and thicknesses are fabricated for holographic recording. Among them, a formulation containing 9 wt % CTMA shows the best performance. Using it as a recording medium, a VHG with high resolution and diffraction efficiency is constructed. Its refractive index modulation reaches 0.046. Moreover, its total transmittance within 400-800 nm achieves 96.62% after photobleaching. The results indicate that the CTMA-based formulation has great application potential in developing high-performance transparent VHG.

Ramírez M, Beléndez A, Pascual I. Holographic Lens Resolution Using the Convolution Theorem

The similarity between object and image of negative asymmetrical holographic lenses (HLs) stored in a low-toxicity photopolymer has been evaluated theoretically and experimentally. Asymmetrical experimental setups with negative focal lengths have been used to obtain HLs. For this purpose, the resolution of the HLs was calculated using the convolution theorem. A USAF 1951 test was used as an object and the impulse responses of the HLs, which in this case was the amplitude spread function (ASF), were obtained with two different methods: using a CCD sensor and a Hartmann Shack (HS) wavefront sensor. For a negative asymmetrically recorded HL a maximum resolution of 11.31 lp/mm was obtained. It was evaluated at 473 nm wavelength. A theoretical study of object-image similarity had carried out using the MSE (mean squared error) metric to evaluate the experimental results obtained quantitatively.

Highly Sensitive Photopolymer for Holographic Data Storage Containing Methacryl Polyhedral Oligomeric Silsesquioxane

Herein, via introducing eight methacryl polyhedral oligomeric silsesquioxane (Ma-POSS), we dramatically enhance the holographic performance of phenanthraquinone-doped poly(methyl methacrylate) (PQ/PMMA) photopolymer with excellent characteristics of high sensitivity, high diffraction efficiency, and neglectable volume shrinkage for holographic data storage, the photosensitivity, diffraction efficiency, and volume shrinkage reaching 1.47 cm/J, ∼75%, and ∼0.09%, respectively. Ma-POSS here dramatically enhances the photosensitivity ∼5.5 times, diffraction efficiency more than 50%, and suppressed the volume shrinkage over 4 times. Further analysis reveals that Ma-POSS obviously increased the molecular weight by grafting PMMA to be a star-shaped macromolecule. And the residual C═C of POSS-PMMA dramatically increased the photosensitivity. Moreover, the star-shaped POSS-PMMA acting as a plasticizer dramatically enhances the mechanical properties and so reduces the photoinduced volume shrinkage of PQ/PMMA. Finally, by the use of the POSS-PMMA/PQ in a collinear holography system, it appeared to be promising for a fast but low bit error rate in holographic information storage. The current study thence has not only successfully synthesized photopolymer materials with potential for highly sensitive holographic storage applications but also investigated the microphysical mechanism of the impact of Ma-POSS on the holographic properties of PQ/PMMA photopolymer and clarified the thermal- and photoreaction processes of the POSS-PMMA/PQ photopolymer.

High Refractive Index Photopolymers by Thiol-Yne "Click" Polymerization

A scalable synthesis of high refractive index, optically transparent photopolymers from a family of low-viscosity multifunctional thiol and alkyne monomers via thiol-yne "click" is described herein. The monomers designed to incorporate high refractive index cores consisting of aryl and sulfide groups with high intrinsic molar refraction were synthesized starting from commercially available low-cost raw materials. The low-viscosity (<500 cP) thiol-yne resins formulated with these new multifunctional monomers and a phosphine oxide photoinitiator underwent efficient thiol-yne polymerizations upon exposure to 405 nm light at 30 mW/cm². In contrast to the previously reported thiol-ene systems, the kinetic profile of these photopolymerizations showed significant dependence on the nature of the thiol and alkyne monomers. However, the ability of the thiol-yne reaction to introduce a large number of sulfide linkages compared to that of thiol-ene systems yielded cross-linked high optical quality photopolymers with a polymer refractive index that exceeds 1.68 (n_D/20 °C). Interestingly, the photopolymer formed from the least sterically hindered alkynyl thioether monomer 2b with flexible thioether core and the dithiol 1a exhibited unprecedented difference in the polymer refractive index as compared to that of the resin with polymerization-induced changes reaching up to 0.08. Furthermore, the implementation of these low-viscosity thiol-yne resins was demonstrated by preparing two-stage photopolymeric holographic materials with a dynamic range of ∼0.02 and haze < 1.5% in two-dimensional high refractive index structures.

Holographic Photopolymer Material with High Dynamic Range (Δn) via Thiol-Ene Click Chemistry

A high-performance holographic recording medium was developed based on a unique combination of photoinitiated thiol-ene click chemistry and functional, linear polymers used as binders. Allyl reactive sites were incorporated along the backbone of the linear polymer binder to enable facile film casting and to facilitate cross-linking by photopolymerization of the thiol-ene monomers that also serve as the writing monomers in this distinctive approach to holographic materials. The allyl content and the ratio of the linear polymer to the writing monomers were varied to maximize and control the refractive index contrast. A blade-coating-based film preparation method was developed to form films from the mixture of linear polymer and the thiol-ene monomers. This approach results in a holographic material with a peak to mean index contrast (Δn) that reaches 0.04. The refractive index contrast was stable for at least two weeks. Haze in holograms with a high writing monomer loading was significantly reduced when a higher allyl content was incorporated into the binder, resulting in the lowest haze around 0.2%. Finally, the media exhibit high resolution as demonstrated by the ability to record reflection holograms with 140 nm pitch and diffraction efficiency in excess of 90%.

Aberration-Based Quality Metrics in Holographic Lenses

Aberrations and the image quality of holographic lenses were evaluated by a Hartmann-Shack (HS) wavefront sensor. Two lenses, one recorded with a symmetrical configuration and the other with an asymmetrical one, were stored in a photopolymer called Biophotopol. Each was reconstructed with two different wavelengths, 473 nm and 633 nm. Different metrics were applied to determine and quantify the aberration of the lenses (Zernike coefficients, Seidel coefficients, Marechal tolerances, root-mean-square (RMS), peak to valley, critical fraction of the pupil), and the quality of the image they provided (Strehl ratio, entropy, cutoff frequency, modulation transfer function (MTF), and area under the MTF). Good agreement between the metrics related to optical quality was obtained. The negative asymmetric holographic lenses had less aberration than the positive symmetric ones.

Refractive Index Contrast Polymers: Photoresponsive Systems with Spatial Modulation of Refractive Index for Photonics

The development of an intriguing concept using optical polymers for photonics is reported to enable modulation of refractive index (RI) in solution cast thin films with precise spatial control. While extensive efforts in polymer science have focused on methods to prepare optically transparent polymers with high RI, the creation of photoresponsive polymer systems to spatially adjust the refractive index upon irradiation is a distinct technical challenge requiring development of materials amenable to this process. The ability to create refractive index contrast (i.e., a difference in RI between two domains) is a critical capability required in photonics for the fabrication of integrated photonics devices, such as, polymer waveguides. In this report, we detail the synthesis of optical polymers tailored to this application, termed Refractive Index Contrast (RIC) polymers, in which the RI of the material can be photopatterned where UV exposure in the presence of a photoacid generator resulted in a permanent increase of RI in the exposed regions thus creating regions of high RIC. This process creates the high RI core of waveguides in a single step and lends itself to rapid fabrication of photonic devices via direct laser writing. Waveguides made from RIC polymers were found to have propagation losses of ∼2 dB/cm at 1550 nm.

Reflection suppression via elastomeric films

Transparent substrates introduce challenges in optical metrology, recording, and microscopy. Backside reflections reduce signal to noise, are recorded as artifacts, or introduce spurious signals. These reflections often need to be suppressed, but large angular and spectral bandwidths preclude the use of anti-reflection (AR) coatings. Using elastomeric materials doped with optical absorbers, we detail a method and a materials set for temporary suppression of Fresnel reflections for multiple substrates spanning wide spectral and angular bandwidths. Tuning the refractive index of the elastomer to match a substrate minimizes reflection and the addition of different absorptive dopants allow for either broadband or wavelength-selective reflection suppression. As performance is limited only by the index mismatch, both spectral and angular performances significantly exceed those of AR coatings. We demonstrate reflection suppression in excess of 30 dB spanning a bandwidth over 500 nm. After use, these light traps may be removed and reused without damaging the substrate.

Stereolithographic 3D Printing for Deterministic Control over Integration in Dual-Material Composites

This work introduces a rapid and facile approach to predictably control integration between two materials with divergent properties. Programmed integration between photopolymerizable soft and stiff hydrogels was investigated for their promise in applications such as tissue engineering where heterogeneous properties are often desired. Spatial control afforded by grayscale 3D printing was leveraged to define regions at the interface that permit diffusive transport of a second material in-filled into the 3D printed part. The printing parameters (i.e., effective exposure dose) for the resin were correlated directly to mesh size to achieve controlled diffusion. Applying this information to grayscale exposures led to a range of distances over which integration was achieved with high fidelity. A prescribed finite distance of integration between soft and stiff hydrogels led to a 33% increase in strain to failure under tensile testing and eliminated failure at the interface. The feasibility of this approach was demonstrated in a layer-by-layer 3D printed part fabricated by stereolithography, which was subsequently infilled with a soft hydrogel containing osteoblastic cells. In summary, this approach holds promise for applications where integration of multiple materials and living cells is needed by allowing precise control over integration and reducing mechanical failure at contrasting material interfaces.

High efficiency Fresnel lens design and fabrication in a two-stage photopolymer

We show the design and fabrication of high diffraction efficiency, optically recorded gradient-index Fresnel lenses in a two-stage photopolymer. A design analysis reveals that lens f/# is limited by the material refractive index contrast, motivating use of recent high-contrast polymers. The number of pixels required for the optical exposure is typically well beyond available spatial light-modulator resolutions, motivating the use of a photolithographic mask. We use a dithered binary chrome mask with 9000×9000 pixels of 2.5 μm diameter to write lenses up to 23 mm in diameter. Lenses down to f/44 with 76% diffraction efficiency and f/79 with 83% diffraction efficiency are demonstrated.

Diffractive and Interferometric Characterization of Nanostructured Photopolymer for Sharp Diffractive Optical Elements Recording

We study the behavior of a nanoparticle-polymer composite (NPC) material, based on a thiol-ene monomer system, working with long grating spacing. Thus, we evaluate the suitability of the NPC for storing complex diffractive optical elements with sharp profiles, such as blazed gratings. Using holographic methods, we measure the "apparent" diffusion of the material and the influence of the spatial period on this diffusion. The applicability of this material in complex diffractive optical elements (DOEs) recording is analyzed using an interferometric method. Supported by the results of this analysis, we record blazed gratings with different grating spacing and measure the maximum diffraction efficiency (DE) achieved. The results show that NPC has a good behavior in this range of spatial frequencies.

Holographic Lenses in an Environment-Friendly Photopolymer

In this paper, we theoretically and experimentally evaluated the quality of volume phase transmission lenses stored in an environmentally friendly photopolymer. Holographic lenses (HLs) were obtained using symmetrical and asymmetrical experimental setups with the same positive and negative focal length and pupil diameter. The image quality was evaluated from the calculation of the modulation transfer function (MTF) by capturing the point spread function (PSF) with a charge-coupled device (CCD). A maximum frequency of 14 L/mm, reaching an MTF value of 0.1, was obtained for a negative asymmetrically recorded HL, evaluated at 473 nm wavelength. A theoretical study of aberrations was carried out to qualitatively evaluate the experimental results obtained.