Composition-Dependent Functionality of Copper Vanadate Photoanodes

State of the Art Progress in Copper Vanadate Materials for Solar Water Splitting

The development of a single junction photoelectrode material having specific properties is essential and challenging for the efficient application in solar water splitting for oxygen production and a high value-added product, hydrogen. Moreover, the present material solutions based on binary metal oxides offer limited catalytic activity and hydrogen production efficiency. Therefore, it is paramount to develop and exploit a unique range of materials derived from ternary metal oxides with specifically engineered properties to advance in photoelectrochemical (PEC) water splitting. Among the ternary oxides, copper vanadates offer promising characteristics, such as a narrow bandgap and catalytic surface properties along with favorable band edges for facile oxygen evolution reaction (OER), which is considered the bottleneck step in performing overall water dissociation. Furthermore, the copper vanadates allow the tuning of the stoichiometry through which a wide range of polymorphs and materials could be obtained. This review provides a complete outlook on the range of copper vanadates and the established synthesis approach, morphology, crystal structure, band edge properties, and PEC characterizations. Mainly, the underlying charge dynamic properties, carrier path length, effect of doping, and influence of surface catalysts are discussed. The review concludes that the advancement toward obtaining low-bandgap materials is a main challenge to overcome the limitations for efficient water dissociation to OER and copper vanadates, which offer a promising solution with their unique properties and advantages. Importantly, intense and strategically focused research is vital to overcome the scientific challenges involved in copper vanadates and to explore and exploit new polymorphs to set new efficiency benchmarks and PEC water splitting solutions.

Solution Combustion Synthesis and Characterization of Magnesium Copper Vanadates

Magnesium vanadate (MgV2O6) and its alloys with copper vanadate were synthesized via the solution combustion technique. Phase purity and solid solution formation were confirmed by a variety of experimental techniques, supported by electronic structure simulations based on density functional theory (DFT). Powder X-ray diffraction combined with Rietveld refinement, laser Raman spectroscopy, diffuse reflectance spectroscopy, and high-resolution transmission electron microscopy showed single-phase alloy formation despite the MgV2O6 and CuV2O6 end members exhibiting monoclinic and triclinic crystal systems, respectively. DFT-calculated optical band gaps showed close agreement in the computed optical bandgaps with experimentally derived values. Surface photovoltage spectroscopy, ambient-pressure photoemission spectroscopy, and Kelvin probe contact potential difference (work function) measurements confirmed a systematic variation in the optical bandgap modification and band alignment as a function of stoichiometry in the alloy composition. These data indicated n-type semiconductor behavior for all the samples which was confirmed by photoelectrochemical measurements.

Cobalt-doped copper vanadate: a dual active electrocatalyst propelling efficient H2 evolution and glycerol oxidation in alkaline water

Strategically doped metal oxide nanomaterials signify a rapidly growing genre of functional materials with a wide range of practical applications. Copper vanadate (CuV) represents one such highly active system, which has been rarely explored following its doping with an abundant first-row transition metal. Here, we have developed a series of CuV samples with varying cobalt(ii) doping concentrations deploying a relatively simple solid state synthetic procedure. Among the samples, the 10% Co(ii)-doped CuV (Co_10%-CuV) exhibited excellent reactivity for both the H₂ evolution reaction (HER) and glycerol oxidation reaction (GOR) in an alkaline aqueous medium (pH 14.0) during cathodic and anodic scans, respectively. During this dual-active catalysis, surface-immobilized Co_10%-CuV operates at exceptionally low overpotentials of 176 mV and 160 mV for the HER and GOR, respectively, while achieving 10 mA cm² current density. The detailed spectroscopic analysis revealed the formation of formate as the major product during the GOR with a faradaic efficiency of >90%. Therefore, this Co_10%-CuV can be included on either side of a two-electrode electrolyzer assembly to trigger a complete biomass-driven H₂ production, establishing an ideal carbon-neutral energy harvest process.

Heteroepitaxial Growth of GaP Photocathode by Hydride Vapor Phase Epitaxy for Water Splitting and CO2 Reduction

Heteroepitaxial Zn-doped p-GaP was grown on (001) GaAs, (001) Si and (111) Si substrates by hydride vapor phase epitaxy for solar-driven photoelectrochemical applications of hydrogen generation by water splitting and CO2 reduction. Growth of GaP on Si was realized through the implementation of a low-temperature buffer layer, and the morphology and crystalline quality were enhanced by optimizing the precursor flows and pre-heating ambient substrate. The p-GaP/GaAs and p-GaP/Si samples were processed to photoelectrodes with an amorphous TiO2 coating for CO2 reduction and a combination of TiO2 layer and mesoporous tungsten phosphide catalyst for water splitting. P-GaP/GaAs with suitable Zn-doping concentration exhibited photoelectrochemical performance comparable to homoepitaxial p-GaP/GaP for water splitting and CO2 reduction. Degradation of photocurrent in p-GaP/Si photoelectrodes is observed in PEC water splitting due to the high density of defects arising from heteroepitaxial growth.

Facile synthesis of single-crystalline Fe-doped copper vanadate nanoparticles for the voltammetric monitoring of lethal hazardous fungicide carbendazim

The highly selective and sensitive electrochemical detection of highly toxic fungicide carbendazim (CBZ) by the iron (Fe)-doped copper vanadate (CuVO₄; CuV) is discussed. The Fe-doped copper vanadate (Fe-CuV) is prepared by the simple co-precipitation method followed by an annealing process which produced high crystallinity. The material properties of Fe-CuV are characterized by XRD, Raman spectrometry, XPS analysis, HRTEM, and SAED pattern. The electrochemical characterization of Fe-CuV towards CBZ detection are done by CV and DPV techniques. The Fe-CuV/GCE exhibits good electroanalytical activity towards the electro-oxidation of CBZ at the potential of 0.81 V vs Ag/AgCl. The developed sensor electrode revealed a linear range of 0.01 to 83.1 μM and a limit of detection of about 5 nM. In addition, Fe-CuV/GCE reveals good storage stability (RSD = 2.63%) and reproducibility (RSD = 2.85%) for the electro-oxidation of CBZ. The electrode material was applied to the detection of CBZ in apple juice and soy milk samples, and the results were discussed. Thus, our projected Fe-CuV/GCE can be employed as electrode material in a rapid onsite sensor for the detection and determination of noxious pollutants.

Nanoscale Heterogeneities and Composition-Reactivity Relationships in Copper Vanadate Photoanodes

The photoelectrochemical performance of thin film photoelectrodes can be impacted by deviations from the stoichiometric composition, both at the macroscale and at the nanoscale. This issue is especially pronounced for the class of ternary compounds that are currently investigated for simultaneously achieving the optoelectronic characteristics and chemical stability required for solar fuel generation. Here, we combine macroscopic photoelectrochemical testing with atomic force microscopy (AFM) and scanning transmission X-ray microscopy (STXM) to reveal relationships between photoelectrochemical activity, nanoscale morphology, and local chemical composition in copper vanadate (CVO) thin films as a model system. For films with varying Cu/(Cu + V) ratios around the ideal stoichiometry of stoiberite Cu₅V₂O₁₀, AFM resolves submicrometer morphology variations, which correlate with variations of the Cu content resolved by STXM. Both stoichiometric and Cu-deficient films exhibit a clear photoresponse, which indicates electronic tolerance to reduced Cu content. While both films exhibit homogeneous O and V content, they are also characterized by local regions of Cu enrichment and depletion that extend beyond individual grains. By contrast, Cu-rich photoelectrodes exhibit a tendency toward CuO secondary phase formation and a significantly reduced photoelectrochemical activity, indicating a significantly poor electronic tolerance to Cu-enrichment. These findings highlight that the average film composition at the macroscale is insufficient for defining structure-function relationships in complex ternary compounds. Rather, correlating microscopic variations in chemical composition to macroscopic photoelectrochemical performance provides insights into photocatalytic activity and stability that are otherwise not apparent from pure macroscopic characterization.

High-Throughput Exploration of Metal Vanadate Thin-Film Systems (M-V-O, M = Cu, Ag, W, Cr, Co, Fe) for Solar Water Splitting: Composition, Structure, Stability, and Photoelectrochemical Properties

Combinatorial synthesis and high-throughput characterization of thin-film materials libraries enable to efficiently identify both photoelectrochemically active and inactive, as well as stable and instable systems for solar water splitting. This is shown on six ternary metal vanadate (M-V-O, M = Cu, Ag, W, Cr, Co, Fe) thin-film materials libraries, fabricated using combinatorial reactive magnetron cosputtering with subsequent annealing in air. By means of high-throughput characterization of these libraries correlations between composition, crystal structure, photocurrent density, and stability of the M-V-O systems in different electrolytes such as acidic, neutral and alkaline media were identified. The systems Cu-V-O and Ag-V-O are stable in alkaline electrolyte and exhibited photocurrents of 170 and 554 μA/cm², respectively, whereas the systems W-V-O, Cr-V-O, and Co-V-O are not stable in alkaline electrolyte. However, the Cr-V-O and Co-V-O systems showed an enlarged photoactive region in acidic electrolyte, albeit with very low photocurrents (<10 μA/cm²). Complete data sets obtained from these different screening sets, including information on nonpromising systems, lays groundwork for their use to predict new systems for solar water splitting, for example, by machine learning.

Copper Vanadate Nanobelts as Anodes for Photoelectrochemical Water Splitting: Influence of CoOx Overlayers on Functional Performances

The design and development of environmentally friendly and robust anodes for photoelectrochemical (PEC) water splitting plays a critical role for the efficient conversion of radiant energy into hydrogen fuel. In this regard, quasi-1D copper vanadates (CuV₂O₆) were grown on conductive substrates by a hydrothermal procedure and processed for use as anodes in PEC cells, with particular attention on the role exerted by cobalt oxide (CoO_x) overlayers deposited by radio frequency (RF) sputtering. The target materials were characterized in detail by a multitechnique approach with the aim at elucidating the interplay between their structure, composition, morphology, and the resulting activity as photoanodes. Functional tests were performed by standard electrochemical techniques like linear sweep voltammetry, impedance spectroscopy, and by the less conventional intensity modulated photocurrent spectroscopy, yielding an important insight into the material PEC properties. The obtained results highlight that, despite the fact that the supposedly favorable band alignment between CuV₂O₆ and Co₃O₄ did not yield a net current density increase, cobalt oxide-functionalized anodes afforded a remarkable durability enhancement, an important prerequisite for their eventual real-world applications. The concurrent phenomena accounting for the observed behavior are presented and discussed in relation to material physico-chemical properties.

Kinetics mechanism insights into the oxygen evolution reaction on the (110) and (022) crystal facets of β-Cu2V2O7

We study the kinetics mechanism for the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) on the (110) and (022) facets of β-Cu₂V₂O₇ using the density functional theory and find that the (110) orientation is more OER active than (022).

Progress on ternary oxide-based photoanodes for use in photoelectrochemical cells for solar water splitting

Solar water splitting using photoelectrochemical cells (PECs) has emerged as one of the most promising routes to produce hydrogen as a clean and renewable fuel source. Among various semiconductors that have been considered as photoelectrodes for use in PECs, oxide-based photoanodes are particularly attractive because of their stability in aqueous media in addition to inexpensive and facile processing compared to other types of semiconductors. However, they typically suffer from poor charge carrier separation and transport. In the past few years, there has been tremendous progress in developing ternary oxide-based photoelectrodes, specifically, photoanodes. The use of ternary oxides provides more opportunities to tune the composition and electronic structure of the photoelectrode compared to binary oxides, thus providing more freedom to tune the photoelectrochemical properties. In this article, we outline the important characteristics to analyze when evaluating photoanodes and review the major recent progress made on the development of ternary oxide-based photoanodes. For each system, we highlight the favorable and unfavorable features and summarize the strategies utilized to address the challenges associated with each material. Finally, by combining our analyses of all the photoanodes surveyed in this review, we provide possible future research directions for each compound and an outlook for constructing more efficient oxide-based PECs. Overall, this review will provide a critical overview of current ternary oxide-based photoanodes and will serve as a platform for the design of future oxide-based PECs.

Disentangling the Role of Surface Chemical Interactions on Interfacial Charge Transport at BiVO4 Photoanodes

Chemical transformations that occur on photoactive materials, such as photoelectrochemical water splitting, are strongly influenced by the surface properties as well as by the surrounding environment. Herein, we elucidate the effects of oxygen and water surface adsorption on band alignment, interfacial charge transfer, and charge-carrier transport by using complementary Kelvin probe measurements and photoconductive atomic force microscopy on bismuth vanadate. By observing variations in surface potential, we show that adsorbed oxygen acts as an electron-trap state at the surface of bismuth vanadate, whereas adsorbed water results in formation of a dipole layer without inducing interfacial charge transfer. The apparent change of trap state density under dry or humid nitrogen, as well as under oxygen-rich atmosphere, proves that surface adsorbates influence charge-carrier transport properties in the material. The finding that oxygen introduces electronically active states on the surface of bismuth vanadate may have important implications for understanding functional characteristics of water splitting photoanodes, devising strategies to passivate interfacial trap states, and elucidating important couplings between energetics and charge transport in reaction environments.

Sizable Excitonic Effects Undermining the Photocatalytic Efficiency of β-Cu2V2O7

Copper vanadates have been proposed as promising photoanodes for water-splitting photoelectrochemical cells, but their performance has recently been shown to be severely limited. To understand this behavior, we study the electronic structure and the optical properties of β-Cu₂V₂O₇ both experimentally and computationally. The measured absorption spectrum shows an absorption peak at 1.5 eV followed by the onset of an apparent continuum at 2.26 eV, as generally found for this class of materials. We perform calculations within the framework of the QS GW̃ method and the Bethe-Salpeter equation while including effects of magnetic ordering, nuclear quantum motion, and thermal vibrations. We demonstrate the occurrence of two kinds of excitons with high binding energies upon optical excitation in β-Cu₂V₂O₇, which account for the first absorption peak and the lower edge of the apparent continuum. The results are confirmed by photoluminescence measurements, where sub-band-gap emissions are found for both excitons. These results provide an explanation for the low photocatalytic efficiencies of copper vanadates, despite the favorable size of their optical band gaps.

Visible Light Driven Photoanodes for Water Oxidation Based on Novel r-GO/β-Cu₂V₂O₇/TiO₂ Nanorods Composites

This paper describes the preparation and the photoelectrochemical performances of visible light driven photoanodes based on novel r-GO/β-Cu₂V₂O₇/TiO₂ nanorods/composites. β-Cu₂V₂O₇ was deposited on both fluorine doped tin oxide (FTO) and TiO₂ nanorods (NRs)/FTO by a fast and convenient Aerosol Assisted Spray Pyrolysis (AASP) procedure. Ethylenediamine (EN), ammonia and citric acid (CA) were tested as ligands for Cu²⁺ ions in the aerosol precursors solution. The best-performing deposits, in terms of photocurrent density, were obtained when NH₃ was used as ligand. When β-Cu₂V₂O₇ was deposited on the TiO₂ NRs a good improvement in the durability of the photoanode was obtained, compared with pure β-Cu₂V₂O₇ on FTO. A further remarkable improvement in durability and photocurrent density was obtained upon addition, by electrophoretic deposition, of reduced graphene oxide (r-GO) flakes on the β-Cu₂V₂O₇/TiO₂ composite material. The samples were characterized by X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS), Raman, High Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy (HR-TEM), Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM), Wide Angle X-ray Diffraction (WAXD) and UV–Vis spectroscopies. The photoelectrochemical (PEC) performances of β-Cu₂V₂O₇ on FTO, β-Cu₂V₂O₇/TiO₂ and r-GO/β-Cu₂V₂O₇/TiO₂ were tested in visible light by linear voltammetry and Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy (EIS) measurements.

Chemical transformations at the nanoscale: nanocrystal-seeded synthesis of β-Cu2V2O7 with enhanced photoconversion efficiencies

Nanocrystal-seeded synthesis relies on the reaction of nanocrystal seeds with a molecular precursor and it can be regarded as the link between sol–gel and solid-state chemistries.

Nanocrystal-seeded synthesis relies on the reaction of nanocrystal seeds with a molecular precursor and it can be regarded as the link between sol–gel and solid-state chemistries. This synthesis approach aims at accessing compositionally complex materials, yet to date its full potential remains unexploited. Herein, surface oxidized Cu nanocrystal seeds with diameters from 6 nm to 70 nm are reacted with vanadium acetylacetonate to form β-Cu₂V₂O₇ with a tunable grain size ranging from 29 nm to 63 nm. In situ X-ray diffraction measurements evidence the occurrence of a solid-state reaction between the NC seeds and the vanadium oxide formed during the annealing. The variation of the ion diffusion lengths, the homogeneity of the precursor solution and the number of nucleation sites with the NC seed size explains the lower formation temperature, the smaller grain size and the higher grain size monodispersity of β-Cu₂V₂O₇ as the seed size decreases. Finally, the tunability afforded by the nanocrystal-seeded synthesis provides a unique opportunity to correlate the photoelectrochemical performance with the grain size in a size regime close to the charge carrier diffusion length of β-Cu₂V₂O₇ (20–40 nm). The net photocurrent density peaks when the grain size is 39 nm by reaching 0.23 mA cm^–2 at 1.23 V vs. RHE in the presence of a hole scavenger. While still far from the theoretical limit, this result overcomes the current state-of-the-art for β-Cu₂V₂O₇. An interesting double fold increase in the photocurrent is found in mixed phase β-Cu₂V₂O₇/CuV₂O₆ samples, suggesting that nanostructuring and heterostructuring are beneficial to the performance.