Catalytically active cross-species heterodimers of thymidylate synthase

Modeling functional changes to Escherichia coli thymidylate synthase upon single residue replacements: a structure-based approach

Escherichia coli thymidylate synthase (TS) is an enzyme that is indispensable to DNA synthesis and cell division, as it provides the only de novo source of dTMP by catalyzing the reductive methylation of dUMP, thus making it a key target for chemotherapeutic agents. High resolution X-ray crystallographic structures are available for TS and, owing to its relatively small size, successful experimental mutagenesis studies have been conducted on the enzyme. In this study, an in silico mutagenesis technique is used to investigate the effects of single amino acid substitutions in TS on enzymatic activity, one that employs the TS protein structure as well as a knowledge-based, four-body statistical potential. For every single residue TS variant, this approach yields both a global structural perturbation score and a set of local environmental perturbation scores that characterize the mutated position as well as all structurally neighboring residues. Global scores for the TS variants are capable of uniquely characterizing groups of residue positions in the enzyme according to their physicochemical, functional, or structural properties. Additionally, these global scores elucidate a statistically significant structure–function relationship among a collection of 372 single residue TS variants whose activity levels have been experimentally determined. Predictive models of TS variant activity are subsequently trained on this dataset of experimental mutants, whose respective feature vectors encode information regarding the mutated position as well as its six nearest residue neighbors in the TS structure, including their environmental perturbation scores.

Crosstalk between the subunits of the homodimeric enzyme triosephosphate isomerase

Homodimeric triosephosphate isomerase (TIM) from Trypanosoma cruzi (TcTIM) and T. brucei (TbTIM) are markedly similar in amino acid sequence and three-dimensional structure. In their dimer interfaces, each monomer has a Cys15 that is surrounded by loop3 of the adjoining subunit. Perturbation of Cys15 by methylmethane thiosulfonate (MMTS) induces abolition of catalysis and structural changes. In the two TIMs, the structural arrangements of their Cys15 are almost identical. Nevertheless, the susceptibility of TcTIM to MMTS is nearly 100-fold higher than in TbTIM. To ascertain the extent to which the characteristics of the interface Cys depend on the dynamics of its own monomer or on those of the adjacent monomer, we studied MMTS action on mutants of TcTIM that had the interface residues of TbTIM, and hybrids that have only one interfacial Cys15 (C15ATcTIM-wild type TbTIM). We found that the solvent exposure of the interfacial Cys depends predominantly on the characteristics of the adjoining monomer. The maximal inhibition of activity induced by perturbation of the sole interface Cys in the C15ATcTIM-TbTIM hybrid is around 60%. Hybrids formed with C15ATcTIM monomers and catalytically inert TbTIM monomers (E168DTbTIM) were also studied. Their activity drops by nearly 50% when the only interfacial Cys is perturbed. These results in conjunction with those on C15ATcTIM-wild type TbTIM hybrid indicate that about half of the activity of each monomer depends on the integrity of each of the two Cys15-loop3 portions of the interface. This could be another reason of why TIM is an obligatory dimer.

Crystal structures of thymidylate synthase mutant R166Q: structural basis for the nearly complete loss of catalytic activity

Thymidylate synthase (TS) catalyzes the folate-dependent methylation of deoxyuridine monophosphate (dUMP) to form thymidine monophosphate (dTMP). We have investigated the role of invariant arginine 166, one of four arginines that contact the dUMP phosphate, using site-directed mutagenesis, X-ray crystallography, and TS from Escherichia coli. The R166Q mutant was crystallized in the presence of dUMP and a structure determined to 2.9 A resolution, but neither the ligand nor the sulfate from the crystallization buffer was found in the active site. A second structure determined with crystals prepared in the presence of dUMP and the antifolate 10-propargyl-5,8-dideazafolate revealed that the inhibitor was bound in an extended, nonproductive conformation, partially occupying the nucleotide-binding site. A sulfate ion, rather than dUMP, was found in the nucleotide phosphate-binding site. Previous studies have shown that the substitution at three of the four arginines of the dUMP phosphate-binding site is permissive; however; for Arg166, all the mutations lead to a near-inactive mutant. The present structures of TS R166Q reveal that the phosphate-binding site is largely intact, but with a substantially reduced affinity for phosphate, despite the presence of the three remaining arginines. The position of Cys146, which initiates catalysis, is shifted in the mutant and resides in a position that interferes with the binding of the dUMP pyrimidine moiety.

A monomeric mutant of restriction endonuclease EcoRI nicks DNA without sequence specificity

We have mutated the monomer-monomer interface of the restriction endonuclease EcoRI in order to destabilize the homodimer and to stabilize heterodimers. Mutations of Leu158 to charged amino acid residues result in strong destabilization of the dimer. The largest effect was detected for the L158D mutant which is monomeric even at higher concentrations. It unspecifically degrades DNA by cleaving both single strands independently every 15 nucleotides on the average. Although cleavage is reproducible, it is not determined by nucleotide sequence but by general properties like conformation or deformability as has been found for other unspecific nucleases. Mutations of Ile230, which is in direct contact with Leu158 of the other subunit, cause structural changes with the loss of about ten percent alpha-helix content, but interfere only marginally with homodimerization and double strand cleavage. Again the mutation to aspartate shows the strongest effects. Mixtures of single mutants, one containing aspartate at one of the two positions and the other lysine at the corresponding position, form heterodimers. These are mainly stabilized compared to the homodimers by re-establishment of the wild-type hydrophobic interaction at the not mutated residues while an interaction of aspartate and lysine seems energetically unfavorable in this structural context.

Differences in natural ligand and fluoropyrimidine binding to human thymidylate synthase identified by transient-state spectroscopic and continuous variation methods

Thymidylate synthase (TS) is a central target for the design of chemotherapeutic agents due to its vital role in DNA synthesis. Structural studies of binary complexes between Escherichia coli TS and various nucleotides suggest the chemotherapeutic agent FdUMP and the natural ligand dUMP bind similarly. We show, however, that FdUMP binding to human TS yields a substantially greater decrease in fluorescence than does dUMP. Because the difference in quenching due to ligand binding was approximately two-fold and this difference was not seen when using ecTS, the intriguing result indicated a significant difference in the mode of FdUMP binding to the human enzyme. We compared the binding affinities of dUMP, FdUMP, and TMP to TS from both species and found no significant differences for the individual ligands. Because binding affinities were not different among the ligands, the method of continuous variation was employed to determine binding stoichiometry. Similar to that found for dUMP binding to human and ecTS, FdUMP displayed single site occupancy with both enzymes. These results show that nucleotide binding differences exist for FdUMP and dUMP binding to the human enzyme. The observed differences are not due to differences in stoichiometry or ligand affinity. Therefore, although the crystal structure of human TS with various nucleotide ligands has not been solved, these results show that the differences observed using fluorescence methods result from as yet unidentified differential interactions between the human enzyme and nucleotide ligands.

Serine and alanine racemase activities of VanT: a protein necessary for vancomycin resistance in Enterococcus gallinarum BM4174

Vancomycin resistance in Enterococcus gallinarum results from the production of UDP-MurNAc-pentapeptide[D-Ser]. VanT, a membrane-bound serine racemase, is one of three proteins essential for this resistance. To investigate the selectivity of racemization of L-Ser or L-Ala by VanT, a strain of Escherichia coli TKL-10 that requires D-Ala for growth at 42 degrees C was used as host for transformation experiments using plasmids containing the full-length vanT from Ent. gallinarum or the alanine racemase gene (alr) of Bacillus stearothermophilus: both plasmids were able to complement E. coli TKL-10 at 42 degrees C. No alanine or serine racemase activities were detected in the host strain E. coli TKL-10 grown at 30, 34 or 37 degrees C. Serine and alanine racemase activities were found almost exclusively (96%) in the membrane fraction of E. coli TKL-10/pCA4(vanT): the alanine racemase activity of VanT was 14% of the serine racemase activity in both E. coli TKL-10/pCA4(vanT) and E. coli XL-1 Blue/pCA4(vanT). Alanine racemase activity was present mainly (95%) in the cytoplasmic fraction of E. coli TKL-10/pJW40(alr), with a trace (1.6%) of serine racemase activity. Additionally, DNA encoding the soluble domain of VanT was cloned and expressed in E. coli M15 as a His-tagged polypeptide and purified: this polypeptide also exhibited both serine and alanine racemase activities; the latter was approximately 18% of the serine racemase activity, similar to that of the full-length, membrane-bound enzyme. N-terminal sequencing of the purified His-tagged polypeptide revealed a single amino acid sequence, indicating that the formation of heterodimers between subunits of His-tagged C-VanT and endogenous alanine racemases from E. coli was unlikely. The authors conclude that the membrane-bound serine racemase VanT also has alanine racemase activity but is able to racemize serine more efficiently than alanine, and that the cytoplasmic domain is responsible for the racemase activity.

The production and characterization of artificial heterodimers of the restriction endonuclease EcoRV

A novel approach to studying the inter- and intrasubunit communication required for the activity of homodimeric proteins is described. It was developed for the restriction endonuclease EcoRV, but should also be useful for other homodimeric enzymes. Two ecorV genes encoding different EcoRV mutants are coexpressed in the same Escherichia coli cell leading to homo- and heterodimeric variants of the enzyme. The two ecorV genes carry either a 5' extension coding for the glutathione-S-transferase or a His6-tag. The EcoRV heterodimer produced in vivo is separated from the two EcoRV homodimers and purified to homogeneity by affinity chromatography. Purified EcoRV heterodimers are stable and are not subject to reassortment of the subunits. To investigate the interdependence of the two catalytic centers, EcoRV heterodimers consisting of one subunit with wild type sequence and one subunit with amino acid substitutions in the PD...(D/E)XK motif, characteristic for the active sites of many restriction endonucleases, were produced. While the homodimeric EcoRV active site mutants are catalytically inactive, the heterodimeric EcoRV variants with one active and one inactive catalytic center display a twofold reduced activity toward oligodeoxynucleotide substrates compared to the wild type, and preferentially nick supercoiled plasmid DNA. From these results we conclude that in the wild type enzyme both catalytic centers function independently of each other.

The subunit interfaces of oligomeric enzymes are conserved to a similar extent to the overall protein sequences

It is well established that, within families of homologous enzymes, amino acid residues that are involved in the chemistry of the reaction are highly conserved. To determine if residues at the subunit interface of oligomeric enzymes with shared active sites are also conserved, comparative analysis of five enzyme families was undertaken. For the chosen enzyme families, sequence data were available for a large number of proteins and a three-dimensional structure was known for at least two members of each family. The analysis indicates that the subunit interface and the hydrophobic core of proteins from all five families have diverged to a similar extent to the overall protein sequences.

Use of a purified heterodimer to test negative cooperativity as the basis of substrate inactivation of Escherichia coli thymidylate synthase (Asn177-->Asp)

BACKGROUND

Thymidylate synthase (TS) converts deoxyuridylate to thymidylate, an essential DNA precursor. Replacement of Asn177 with aspartate (Asn177-->Asp) in Escherichia coli TS creates a novel ability to methylate 2'-deoxycytidylate (dCMP). The dCMP-methylase activity of TS(Asn177-->Asp) is transiently inactivated by reaction with deoxyuridylate and methylene-tetrahydrofolate, the methyl donor. We have tested the possibility that the inactivation is due to negative cooperativity, created in the TS dimer by the Asn177-->Asp mutation.

RESULTS

A heterodimeric form of TS, containing one wild type and one Asn177-->Asp active site, was created to test for negative cooperativity. Substrate inactivation still occurred, even with the mutation present at only one active site.

CONCLUSIONS

Inactivation of TS(Asn177-->Asp) by deoxyuridylate is not due to negative cooperativity created by the mutation. The 'artificial isozyme' method we have developed for purifying heterodimers away from the progenitor homodimers is generally applicable to other hetero-oligomeric proteins.