Physical properties of the Escherichia coli transcription termination factor rho. 1. Association states and geometry of the rho hexamer

Sm-like protein Rof inhibits transcription termination factor ρ by binding site obstruction and conformational insulation

Transcription termination factor ρ is a hexameric, RNA-dependent NTPase that can adopt active closed-ring and inactive open-ring conformations. The Sm-like protein Rof, a homolog of the RNA chaperone Hfq, inhibits ρ-dependent termination in vivo but recapitulation of this activity in vitro has proven difficult and the precise mode of Rof action is presently unknown. Here, our cryo-EM structures of ρ-Rof and ρ-RNA complexes show that Rof undergoes pronounced conformational changes to bind ρ at the protomer interfaces, undercutting ρ conformational dynamics associated with ring closure and occluding extended primary RNA-binding sites that are also part of interfaces between ρ and RNA polymerase. Consistently, Rof impedes ρ ring closure, ρ-RNA interactions and ρ association with transcription elongation complexes. Structure-guided mutagenesis coupled with functional assays confirms that the observed ρ-Rof interface is required for Rof-mediated inhibition of cell growth and ρ-termination in vitro. Bioinformatic analyses reveal that Rof is restricted to Pseudomonadota and that the ρ-Rof interface is conserved. Genomic contexts of rof differ between Enterobacteriaceae and Vibrionaceae, suggesting distinct modes of Rof regulation. We hypothesize that Rof and other cellular anti-terminators silence ρ under diverse, but yet to be identified, stress conditions when unrestrained transcription termination by ρ may be detrimental.

Phase Variation of Flagella and Toxins in Clostridioides difficile is Mediated by Selective Rho-dependent Termination

Clostridioides difficile is an intestinal pathogen that exhibits phase variation of flagella and toxins through inversion of the flagellar (flg) switch controlling flagellar and toxin gene expression. The transcription termination factor Rho preferentially inhibits swimming motility of bacteria with the 'flg-OFF' switch sequence. How C. difficile Rho mediates this selectivity was unknown. C. difficile Rho contains an N-terminal insertion domain (NID) which is found in a subset of Rho orthologues and confers diverse functions. Here we determined how Rho distinguishes between flg-ON and -OFF mRNAs and the roles of the NID and other domains of C. difficile Rho. Using in vitro ATPase assays, we determined that Rho specifically binds a region containing the left inverted repeat of the flg switch, but only of flg-OFF mRNA, indicating that differential termination is mediated by selective Rho binding. Using a suite of in vivo and in vitro assays in C. difficile, we determined that the NID is essential for Rho termination of flg-OFF mRNA, likely by influencing the ability to form stable hexamers, and the RNA binding domain is critical for flg-OFF specific termination. This work gives insight into the novel mechanism by which Rho interacts with flg mRNA to mediate phase variation of flagella and toxins in C. difficile and broadens our understanding of Rho-mediated termination in an organism with an AT-rich genome.

Sm-like protein Rof inhibits transcription termination factor ρ by binding site obstruction and conformational insulation

Transcription termination factor ρ is a hexameric, RNA-dependent NTPase that can adopt active closed-ring and inactive open-ring conformations. The Sm-like protein Rof, a homolog of the RNA chaperone Hfq, inhibits ρ-dependent termination in vivo but recapitulation of this activity in vitro has proven difficult and the precise mode of Rof action is presently unknown. Our electron microscopic structures of ρ-Rof and ρ-RNA complexes show that Rof undergoes pronounced conformational changes to bind ρ at the protomer interfaces, undercutting ρ conformational dynamics associated with ring closure and occluding extended primary RNA-binding sites that are also part of interfaces between ρ and RNA polymerase. Consistently, Rof impedes ρ ring closure, ρ-RNA interactions, and ρ association with transcription elongation complexes. Structure-guided mutagenesis coupled with functional assays confirmed that the observed ρ-Rof interface is required for Rof-mediated inhibition of cell growth and ρ-termination in vitro. Bioinformatic analyses revealed that Rof is restricted to Pseudomonadota and that the ρ-Rof interface is conserved. Genomic contexts of rof differ between Enterobacteriaceae and Vibrionaceae, suggesting distinct modes of Rof regulation. We hypothesize that Rof and other cellular anti-terminators silence ρ under diverse, but yet to be identified, stress conditions when unrestrained transcription termination by ρ would be lethal.

Transcription termination factor ρ polymerizes under stress

Bacterial RNA helicase ρ is a genome sentinel that terminates synthesis of damaged and junk RNAs that are not translated by the ribosome. Co-transcriptional RNA surveillance by ρ is essential for quality control of the transcriptome during optimal growth. However, it is unclear how bacteria protect their RNAs from overzealous ρ during dormancy or stress, conditions common in natural habitats. Here we used cryogenic electron microscopy, biochemical, and genetic approaches to show that residue substitutions, ADP, or ppGpp promote hyper-oligomerization of Escherichia coli ρ. Our results demonstrate that nucleotides bound at subunit interfaces control ρ switching from active hexamers to inactive higher-order oligomers and extended filaments. Polymers formed upon exposure to antibiotics or ppGpp disassemble when stress is relieved, thereby directly linking termination activity to cellular physiology. Inactivation of ρ through hyper-oligomerization is a regulatory strategy shared by RNA polymerases, ribosomes, and metabolic enzymes across all life.

The World of Stable Ribonucleoproteins and Its Mapping With Grad-Seq and Related Approaches

Macromolecular complexes of proteins and RNAs are essential building blocks of cells. These stable supramolecular particles can be viewed as minimal biochemical units whose structural organization, i.e., the way the RNA and the protein interact with each other, is directly linked to their biological function. Whether those are dynamic regulatory ribonucleoproteins (RNPs) or integrated molecular machines involved in gene expression, the comprehensive knowledge of these units is critical to our understanding of key molecular mechanisms and cell physiology phenomena. Such is the goal of diverse complexomic approaches and in particular of the recently developed gradient profiling by sequencing (Grad-seq). By separating cellular protein and RNA complexes on a density gradient and quantifying their distributions genome-wide by mass spectrometry and deep sequencing, Grad-seq charts global landscapes of native macromolecular assemblies. In this review, we propose a function-based ontology of stable RNPs and discuss how Grad-seq and related approaches transformed our perspective of bacterial and eukaryotic ribonucleoproteins by guiding the discovery of new RNA-binding proteins and unusual classes of noncoding RNAs. We highlight some methodological aspects and developments that permit to further boost the power of this technique and to look for exciting new biology in understudied and challenging biological models.

Rho Protein: Roles and Mechanisms

At the end of the multistep transcription process, the elongating RNA polymerase (RNAP) is dislodged from the DNA template either at specific DNA sequences, called the terminators, or by a nascent RNA-dependent helicase, Rho. In Escherichia coli, about half of the transcription events are terminated by the Rho protein. Rho utilizes its RNA-dependent ATPase activities to translocate along the mRNA and eventually dislodges the RNAP via an unknown mechanism. The transcription elongation factor NusG facilitates this termination process by directly interacting with Rho. In this review, we discuss current models describing the mechanism of action of this hexameric transcription terminator, its regulation by different cis and trans factors, and the effects of the termination process on physiological processes in bacterial cells, particularly E. coli and Salmonella enterica Typhimurium.

Monitoring RNA unwinding by the transcription termination factor Rho from Mycobacterium tuberculosis

Transcription termination factor Rho is a ring-shaped, homo-hexamieric RNA translocase that dissociates transcription elongation complexes and transcriptional RNA-DNA duplexes (R-loops) in bacteria. The molecular mechanisms underlying these biological functions have been essentially studied with Rho enzymes from Escherichia coli or close Gram-negative relatives. However, phylo-divergent Rho factors may have distinct properties. Here, we describe methods for the preparation and in vitro characterization (ATPase and helicase activities) of the Rho factor from Mycobacterium tuberculosis, a specimen with uncharacteristic molecular and enzymatic features. These methods set the stage for future studies aimed at better defining the diversity of enzymatic properties of Rho across the bacterial kingdom.

Mycobacterium tuberculosis Rho is an NTPase with distinct kinetic properties and a novel RNA-binding subdomain

Two mechanisms--factor independent and dependent termination--ensure the completion of RNA synthesis in eubacteria. Factor-dependent mechanism relies on the Rho protein to terminate transcription by interacting with RNA polymerase. Although well studied in Escherichia coli, the properties of the Rho homologs from most bacteria are not known. The rho gene is unusually large in genus Mycobacterium and other members of actinobacteria, having ∼150 additional residues towards the amino terminal end. We describe the distinct properties of Rho from Mycobacterium tuberculosis. It is an NTPase with a preference for purine nucleoside triphosphates with kinetic properties different from E. coli homolog and an ability to use various RNA substrates. The N-terminal subdomain of MtbRho can bind to RNA by itself, and appears to contribute to the interaction of the termination factor with RNAs. Furthermore, the interaction with RNA induces changes in conformation and oligomerization of MtbRho.

The Sm-like RNA chaperone Hfq mediates transcription antitermination at Rho-dependent terminators

In Escherichia coli, the essential motor protein Rho promotes transcription termination in a tightly controlled manner that is not fully understood. Here, we show that the general post-transcriptional regulatory protein Hfq associates with Rho to regulate Rho function. The Hfq:Rho complex can be further stabilized by RNA bridging both factors in a configuration that inhibits the ATP hydrolysis and duplex unwinding activities of Rho and that mediates transcription antitermination at Rho-dependent terminators in vitro and in vivo. Antitermination at a prototypical terminator (λtR1) requires Hfq binding to an A/U-rich transcript region directly upstream from the terminator. Antitermination is modulated by trans-acting factors (NusG or nucleic acid competitors) that affect Hfq association with Rho or RNA. These data unveil a new Hfq function and a novel transcription regulatory mechanism with potentially important implications for bacterial RNA metabolism, gene silencing, and pathogenicity.

Analytical ultracentrifugation of model nanoparticles: comparison of different analysis methods

Sedimentation analysis of nanoparticle (ZrO(2) and SiO(2)) suspensions of different particle sizes in various solvents as nanoparticle model systems was carried out using interference optics in the analytical ultracentrifuge. The particles differed in their morphology: SiO(2) particles were spherical, whereas ZrO(2) particles were in one case spherical and in the second case non-spherical and spherical. Different analysis programs, based on different principles of data analysis, were used for the evaluation of the size distributions of these particles, viz. SEDFIT [ls-g*(s), c(s)], UltraScan (vHW, 2DSA-MC), SedAnal (dcdt) and VelXLAI (GFL) method and SedAnal, in order to ascertain the benefits and limitations of these analysis methods in characterising the examined nanoparticles.

Evidence for amino acid roles in the chemistry of ATP hydrolysis in Escherichia coli Rho

Many proteins that hydrolyze ATP or GTP have comparable amino acid residues for which specific roles have been proposed in a mechanism for the chemistry of hydrolysis. These roles include polarization by a glutamate residue of a water molecule for the attack on the γ-phosphoryl group of the nucleotide, stabilization of the transition state by an arginine finger, discrimination between bound nucleoside triphosphate and diphosphate by a γ sensor residue, and coordination by an aspartate of the Mg(2+) that accompanies the substrate nucleotide. We mutated four candidate residues for these roles in the Escherichia coli transcription termination factor Rho, E211, R366, R212, and D265, and characterized the resulting proteins for oligomerization state, ligand binding, RNA-dependent ATP hydrolysis, and, in rapid mix/chemical quench experiments, achievement of the chemistry step of hydrolysis. All four mutant proteins behaved as expected for Rhos lacking the proposed mechanistic roles. The results provide firm biochemical evidence in support of the proposed model for hydrolysis chemistry.

Analytical ultracentrifugation of colloids

In this contribution the use of Analytical Ultracentrifugation (AUC) for the modern analysis of colloids is reviewed. Since AUC is a fractionation technique, distributions of the sedimentation coefficient, particle size and shape, molar mass and density can be obtained for particle sizes spanning the entire colloidal range. The Ångström resolution and the reliable statistics with which particle size distributions can be obtained from analytical ultracentrifugation makes this a high resolution analysis technique for the characterization of nanoparticles in solution or suspension. Several examples showing successful applications of AUC to complex problems in colloid science are given to illustrate the broad range and versatility of questions that can be answered by AUC experiments.

Conformation changes in E. coli Rho monitored by hydrogen/deuterium exchange and mass spectrometry: response to ligand binding

Escherichia coli Rho is a doughnut-shaped homohexameric ATP-dependent RNA-DNA helicase that releases newly synthesized RNA molecules from transcription complexes. Rho binds 60-80 bases of RNA among six primary RNA binding sites around the inside of its N-terminal crown; the RNA then passes through the central hole of the hexamer. Here it triggers ATP hydrolysis and is moved with respect to the protein. We study protein conformation changes upon ligand binding using amide proton hydrogen/deuterium exchange and mass spectrometry. Global-exchange studies indicate net mass differences of about 15 Da after 1 h of exchange in the presence--versus in the absence--of the ligand MgATP or the RNA poly(C). Sites of ligand-dependent exchange differences were localized by mass determination of the peptic peptides of Rho. A peptide of the N-terminal domain near the known primary RNA sites (aa 56-63) was protected from amide proton exchange in the presence of poly(C), as was a novel N-terminal domain peptide that is not near RNA in the crystal structures or in NMR structures with RNA oligomers (aa 37-46). This result may further define the primary interaction site of RNA with Rho. The Q-loop-containing peptide in the central hole of the protein that interacts with RNA was also protected by RNA (aa 271-286). The exchange rate of one peptide near the ATPase active site (aa 206-218) slowed in the presence of MgATP and increased in the presence of RNA. Overall, the results show changes in a few protein segments rather than a different overall conformation.

An allosteric mechanism of Rho-dependent transcription termination

Rho is the essential RNA helicase that sets the borders between transcription units and adjusts transcriptional yield to translational needs in bacteria. Although Rho was the first termination factor to be discovered, the actual mechanism by which it reaches and disrupts the elongation complex (EC) is unknown. Here we show that the termination-committed Rho molecule associates with RNA polymerase (RNAP) throughout the transcription cycle; that is, it does not require the nascent transcript for initial binding. Moreover, the formation of the RNAP-Rho complex is crucial for termination. We show further that Rho-dependent termination is a two-step process that involves rapid EC inactivation (trap) and a relatively slow dissociation. Inactivation is the critical rate-limiting step that establishes the position of the termination site. The trap mechanism depends on the allosterically induced rearrangement of the RNAP catalytic centre by means of the evolutionarily conserved mobile trigger-loop domain, which is also required for EC dissociation. The key structural and functional similarities, which we found between Rho-dependent and intrinsic (Rho-independent) termination pathways, argue that the allosteric mechanism of termination is general and likely to be preserved for all cellular RNAPs throughout evolution.

Simple enzymatic assays for the in vitro motor activity of transcription termination factor Rho from Escherichia coli

The transcription termination factor Rho from Escherichia coli is a ring-shaped homo-hexameric protein that preferentially interacts with naked cytosine-rich Rut (Rho utilization) regions of nascent RNA transcripts. Once bound to the RNA chain, Rho uses ATP as an energy source to produce mechanical work and disruptive forces that ultimately lead to the dissociation of the ternary transcription complex. Although transcription termination assays have been useful to study Rho activity in various experimental contexts, they do not report directly on Rho mechanisms and kinetics. Here, we describe complementary ATP-dependent RNA-DNA helicase and streptavidin displacement assays that can be used to monitor in vitro Rho's motor activity in a more direct and quantitative manner.

ADP but not P(i) dissociation contributes to rate limitation for Escherichia coli Rho

To define the molecular mechanism by which ATP hydrolysis powers the 5'-->3' travel of homohexameric Escherichia coli transcription termination factor Rho along RNA, rates for association and dissociation of non-RNA substrates and products were measured. Rapid mix/chemical quench and stopped-flow spectrofluorometry measurements were carried out with Rho and [gamma-(32)P]ATP, mantADP, or fluorescently tagged E. coli phosphate-binding protein. The results indicate that the P(i) off-rate is not rate limiting, but at approximately 90 s(-1), the ADP dissociation rate is comparable to the 30 s(-1) k(cat). Previous results indicate that the chemistry step of ATP hydrolysis by Rho is at least 10-fold faster than the overall catalytic cycle. The as yet unmeasured RNA dissociation step, which could be associated with a protein conformation change, might also be a rate-limiting factor.

Structural insights into RNA-dependent ring closure and ATPase activation by the Rho termination factor

Hexameric helicases and translocases are required for numerous essential nucleic-acid transactions. To better understand the mechanisms by which these enzymes recognize target substrates and use nucleotide hydrolysis to power molecular movement, we have determined the structure of the Rho transcription termination factor, a hexameric RNA/DNA helicase, with single-stranded RNA bound to the motor domains of the protein. The structure reveals a closed-ring "trimer of dimers" conformation for the hexamer that contains an unanticipated arrangement of conserved loops required for nucleic-acid translocation. RNA extends across a shallow intersubunit channel formed by conserved amino acids required for RNA-stimulated ATP hydrolysis and translocation and directly contacts a conserved lysine, just upstream of the catalytic GKT triad, in the phosphate-binding (P loop) motif of the ATP-binding pocket. The structure explains the molecular effects of numerous mutations and provides new insights into the links between substrate recognition, ATP turnover, and coordinated strand movement.

Rho-dependent terminators and transcription termination

Rho-dependent transcription terminators participate in sophisticated genetic regulatory mechanisms, in both bacteria and phages; they occur in regulatory regions preceding the coding sequences of genes and within coding sequences, as well as at the end of transcriptional units, to prevent readthrough transcription. Most Rho-dependent terminators have been found in enteric bacteria, but they also occur in Gram-positive bacteria and may be widespread among bacteria. Rho-dependent termination requires both cis-acting elements, on the mRNA, and trans-acting factors. The only cis-acting element common to Rho-dependent terminators is richness in rC residues. Additional sequence elements have been observed at different Rho termination sites. These 'auxiliary elements' may assist in the termination process; they differ among terminators, their occurrence possibly depending on the function and sequence context of the terminator. Specific nucleotides required for termination have also been identified at Rho sites. Rho is the main factor required for termination; it is a ring-shaped hexameric protein with ATPase and helicase activities. NusG, NusA and NusB are additional factors participating in the termination process. Rho-dependent termination occurs by binding of Rho to ribosome-free mRNA, C-rich sites being good candidates for binding. Rho's ATPase is activated by Rho-mRNA binding, and provides the energy for Rho translocation along the mRNA; translocation requires sliding of the message into the central hole of the hexamer. When a polymerase pause site is encountered, the actual termination occurs, and the transcript is released by Rho's helicase activity. Many aspects of this process are still being studied. The isolation of mutants suppressing termination, site-directed mutagenesis of cis-acting elements in Rho-dependent termination, and biochemistry, are and will be contributing to unravelling the still undefined aspects of the Rho termination machinery. Analysis of the more sophisticated regulatory mechanisms relying on Rho-dependent termination may be crucial in identifying new essential elements for termination.

Mechanochemistry of transcription termination factor Rho

Rho is a ring-shaped hexameric motor protein that translocates along nascent mRNA transcript and terminates transcription of select genes in bacteria. Using a numerical optimization algorithm that simultaneously fits all of the presteady-state ATPase kinetic data, we determine how Rho utilizes the chemical energy of ATP hydrolysis to translocate RNA. A random hydrolysis mechanism is ruled out by the observed inhibition of ATPase in a mixed hexamer containing wt and an inactive Rho mutant. We propose a mechanism in which (1) all six subunits are catalytically competent and hydrolyze ATP sequentially, (2) translocation of RNA is driven by the weak to tight binding transition of nucleotide in the catalytic site, (3) hydrolysis is coordinated between adjacent subunits by the transmission of stress via the catalytic arginine finger, (4) hydrolysis weakens the affinity of a subunit for RNA, and (5) the slow release of inorganic phosphate is controlled by changes in circumferential stress around the ring.

Catalytic cooperativity among subunits of Escherichia coli transcription termination factor Rho. Kinetics and substrate structural requirements

Escherichia coli transcription termination factor Rho shows a 30-fold faster rate of ATP hydrolysis when all three catalytic sites are filled with ATP than when only a single site is filled (Stitt, B. L. and Xu, Y. (1998) J. Biol. Chem. 273, 26477-26486). To study the structural requirements of the substrate for this catalytic cooperativity, rapid mix/chemical quench experiments using various ATP analogs were performed. The results indicate that it is the configuration of the beta- and gamma-phosphoryl groups of ATP that is of primary importance for the rate enhancement. Our results also show that there are kinetically slow branches of the enzyme mechanism that are not seen when the chemistry step of the catalytic cycle is fast. These branches become prominent, however, when two of the three Rho active sites are empty or bear non-hydrolyzable compounds. A first-order step that is slow compared with V(max) catalysis enables a single ATP molecule bound in any one of the three Rho active sites to be hydrolyzed and defines the kinetically slow branches. This first-order step could be a protein conformation change or a rearrangement of bound RNA. The results reinforce the importance of catalytic cooperativity in normal Rho function and suggest that several protein conformations exist along the catalytic pathway.

Influence of substrate composition on the helicase activity of transcription termination factor Rho: reduced processivity of Rho hexamers during unwinding of RNA-DNA hybrid regions

Transcription termination factor Rho forms ring-shaped hexameric structures that load onto segments of the nascent RNA transcript that are C-rich and mostly single-stranded. This interaction converts Rho hexamers into active molecular motors that use the energy resulting from their ATP hydrolase activity to move towards the transcript 3'-end. Upon translocation along the RNA chain, Rho can displace physical roadblocks, such as those formed by RNA-DNA helices, a feature that is likely central to the transcription termination mechanism. To study this "translocase" (helicase) activity, we have designed a collection of Rho substrate chimeras containing an RNA-DNA helix located at various positions with respect to a short (47 nucleotides) artificial loading site. We show that these synthetic constructs represent interesting model substrates able to engage in a productive interaction with Rho and to direct NTP-dependent [5'-->3']-translocation of the hexamers. Using both single and multiple-cycle experimental set-ups, we have also found that Rho helicase activity is strongly dependent on the substrate composition and reaction conditions. For this reason, the rate-limiting step of the helicase reaction could not be identified unambiguously. Yet, the linear dependence of the reaction rate on the hybrid length suggests that helicase action on the RNA-DNA region could be controlled by a unique slow step such as Rho activation, conformational rearrangement, or DNA release. Moreover, removal of the DNA strand occurred at a significant cost for the Rho enzyme, inducing, on average, dissociation from the substrate for every 60-80 base-pairs of hybrid unwound. These results are discussed in relation to the known requirements for Rho substrates, general features of hexameric helicases, and current models for Rho-dependent transcription termination.

Nucleotide binding induces conformational changes in Escherichia coli transcription termination factor Rho

The Escherichia coli Rho protein uses the energy of ATP binding and hydrolysis to translocate along RNA and cause transcription termination. Using fluorescence stopped-flow kinetic studies, we have discerned the conformational changes in the Rho protein that occur upon nucleotide and nucleic acid binding. We show that the 2', (3')-O-[N-methylanthraniloyl] derivative of ATP (mant-ATP) is a good fluorescent substrate of Rho and is hydrolyzed with a K(m) comparable with that for ATP but a k(cat) five to six times slower than that for ATP. The kinetics of ATP and mant-ATP binding indicates that, in the absence of RNA, the Rho protein is structurally distinct from the Rho hexamer found when bound to RNA or DNA. In the absence of RNA, the nucleotide-binding rates are 50- to 70-fold slower, and the dissociation rates are 40- to 120-fold slower than the corresponding rates in the presence of RNA. We conclude that RNA or DNA binding to the primary nucleic acid binding sites causes conformational changes in the Rho hexamer that result in the opening of the subunit interfaces. Furthermore, the kinetic studies revealed a unique protein conformational change in the Rho.RNA complex upon ATP binding that is a result of RNA contacting the secondary nucleic acid binding sites in the central channel of the Rho ring. This conformational change seems to render the Rho ring competent in ATP hydrolysis and translocation.

The binding of C10 oligomers to Escherichia coli transcription termination factor Rho

The binding of C10 RNA oligomers to wild type and mutant Escherichia coli transcription termination factor Rho provides a model for the enzyme-RNA interactions that lead to transcription termination. One surprising finding is that wild type Rho binds between five and six C10 oligomers per hexamer with KD = 0.3 microm, and five to six additional C10 molecules with KD = 7 microm. Previously, approximately half this number of oligomer-binding sites was reported (Wang, Y., and von Hippel, P. H. (1993) J. Biol. Chem. 268, 13947-13955); however, the E155K mutant form of Rho, thought at the time to be wild type, was used in that work. The present results with E155K Rho agree with the earlier work. C10 binding with mutant forms of Rho that are altered in RNA interactions, bearing amino acid changes F62S, G99V, F232C, T286A, or K352E, indicate that the higher affinity binding sites constitute what has been termed the primary RNA site, and the lower affinity sites constitute the secondary sites. The binding data together with the crystal structures for wild type Rho (Skordalakes, E., and Berger, J. M. (2003) Cell 114, 135-146) support structurally distinct locations on Rho for the two classes of C10-binding sites. The results are consistent with participation of residues 33 A apart in secondary site RNA interactions. The data further indicate that not all RNA sites on Rho must be filled for full ATPase and transcription termination activity, and suggest a model in which RNA binding to the higher affinity sites leads to a protein conformation change that exposes the previously hidden lower affinity sites.

ATP binding to Rho transcription termination factor. Mutant F355W ATP-induced fluorescence quenching reveals dynamic ATP binding

Rho transcription termination factor mutant, F355W, showed tryptophan fluorescence intensity approximately twice that of wild-type Rho at equivalent protein concentrations and underwent a decrease in relative fluorescence intensity at 350 nm when 100 microm ATP was added in the presence or absence of RNA. Titration of this fluorescence quenching with varying concentrations of ATP (0-600 microm), where Rho is shown to exist as a hexamer (400 nm Rho), revealed tight and loose ATP-binding sites. Bicyclomycin, a specific inhibitor of Rho, increased the tight ATP binding and was used to calibrate ATP-induced fluorescence quenching by using [gamma-(32)P]ATP filter binding. For the Rho mutant F355W, three tight (K(d)(1) = 3 +/- 0.3 microm) and three loose (K(d)(2) = 58 +/- 3 microm) ATP-binding sites per hexamer were seen on Scatchard analysis in the absence of bicyclomycin and poly(C). In the presence of bicyclomycin, the K(d)(1) changed from 3.0 to 1.4 microm, but K(d)(2) underwent a lesser change. The non-hydrolyzable ATP analogue, gamma-S-ATP, gave a similar profile with three tight (K(d)(1) = 0.2 microm) and three loose (K(d)(2) = 70 microm) ATP-binding sites per hexamer. Adding poly(C) to F355W did not alter the K(d)(1) or K(d)(2) for ATP or for gamma-S-ATP. ADP-induced quenching produced 5.5 loose (K(d) = 92 microm) binding sites in the absence of poly(C), and the binding became weaker (K(d) = 175 microm) in the presence of poly(C). The data suggest that in the presence of ADP Rho has six equivalent nucleotide-binding sites. When ATP was added these sites converted to three tight and three loose binding loci. We propose an alternating ATP site mechanism where ATP binding creates heterogeneity in the ATP binding in adjacent subunits, and we suggest that ATP binding to a neighboring loose site stimulates hydrolysis at a neighboring tight binding site such that all six subunits can be potential "active" sites for ATP hydrolysis. The dynamic nature of the ATP binding to Rho is discussed in the terms of the mechanism of RNA tracking driven by ATP hydrolysis.

Rho-dependent termination and ATPases in transcript termination

Transcription factor Rho is a ring-shaped, homohexameric protein that causes transcript termination through actions on nascent RNAs that are coupled to ATP hydrolysis. The Rho polypeptide has a distinct RNA-binding domain (RNA-BD) of known structure as well as an ATP-binding domain (ATP-BD) for which a structure has been proposed based on homology modeling. A model is proposed in which Rho first makes an interaction with a nascent RNA on a C-rich, primarily single-stranded rut region of the transcript as that region emerges from the exit site of RNA polymerase. A subsequent step involves a temporary release of one subunit of the hexamer to allow the 3' segment of the nascent transcript to enter the central channel of the Rho ring. Actions of the Rho structure in the channel on the 3' segment that are coupled to ATP hydrolysis pull the RNA from its contacts with the template and RNA polymerase, thus causing termination of its synthesis.

Structure and function of hexameric helicases

Helicases are motor proteins that couple the hydrolysis of nucleoside triphosphate (NTPase) to nucleic acid unwinding. The hexameric helicases have a characteristic ring-shaped structure, and all, except the eukaryotic minichromosomal maintenance (MCM) helicase, are homohexamers. Most of the 12 known hexameric helicases play a role in DNA replication, recombination, and transcription. A human genetic disorder, Bloom's syndrome, is associated with a defect in one member of the class of hexameric helicases. Significant progress has been made in understanding the biochemical properties, structures, and interactions of these helicases with DNA and nucleotides. Cooperativity in nucleotide binding was observed in many, and sequential NTPase catalysis has been observed in two proteins, gp4 of bacteriophage T7 and rho of Escherichia coli. The crystal structures of the oligomeric T7 gp4 helicase and the hexamer of RepA helicase show structural features that substantiate the observed cooperativity, and both are consistent with nucleotide binding at the subunit interface. Models are presented that show how sequential NTP hydrolysis can lead to unidirectional and processive translocation. Possible unwinding mechanisms based on the DNA exclusion model are proposed here, termed the wedge, torsional, and helix-destabilizing models.

RNA passes through the hole of the protein hexamer in the complex with the Escherichia coli Rho factor

Escherichia coli transcription termination factor Rho is a ring-shaped hexameric protein that uses the energy derived from ATP hydrolysis to dissociate RNA transcripts from the ternary elongation complex. To test a current model for the interaction of Rho with RNA, three derivatives of Rho were made containing single cysteine residues and modified with a photo-activable cross-linker. The positions for the cysteines were: 1) in part of the primary RNA-binding site in the N terminus (Cys-82 Rho); 2) in a connecting polypeptide proposed to be on the outside of the hexamer (Cys-153 Rho); and 3) near the proposed secondary RNA-binding site in the ATP-binding domain (Cys-325 Rho). Results from the cross-linking of the modified Rho proteins to a series of lambda cro RNA derivatives showed that Cys-82 Rho formed cross-links with all transcripts containing the Rho utilization (rut) site, that Cys-325 Rho formed cross-links to transcripts that had the rut site and 10 or more residues 3' of the rut site, and that Cys-153 did not form cross-links with any of the transcripts. From a model of the quaternary structure of Rho, which is largely based on homology to the F(1)-ATPase, amino acid 82 is located near the top of the hexamer, and amino acid 325 is located on a solvent-accessible loop in the center of the hexamer. These data are consistent with binding of the rut region of RNA around the crown, with its 3'-segment passing through the center of the Rho hexamer.

Two different oligomeric states of the RuvB branch migration motor protein as revealed by electron microscopy

In prokaryotes, the RuvA, B, and C proteins play major roles at the late stage of DNA homologous recombination, where RuvB complexed with RuvA acts as an ATP-dependent motor for branch migration. The oligomeric structures of negatively stained and frozen hydrated RuvB from Thermus thermophilus HB8 were investigated by electron microscopy. RuvB oligomers free of DNA formed a ring structure of about 14 nm in diameter. The averaged top view image clearly indicated a sevenfold symmetry, suggesting that it exists as a heptamer. The RuvB oligomers complexed with duplex DNA formed a smaller ring of about 13 nm in diameter. The averaged top view images represented a sixfold symmetry. This difference in oligomerization indicates that the oligomeric structure of RuvB may convert from a heptamer to a hexamer upon DNA binding. In addition, this finding provides the lesson that great care should be taken in investigating the subunit organizations of DNA binding proteins, because their oligomeric states are more sensitive to DNA interactions than expected.

Three-dimensional reconstruction of transcription termination factor rho: orientation of the N-terminal domain and visualization of an RNA-binding site

The Escherichia coli rho transcription termination protein is a hexameric helicase, and is believed to function by separating an RNA-DNA hybrid. Unlike hexameric DNA helicases, where a single strand of DNA passes through the central channel, it has been proposed that the RNA wraps around the outside of the ring. We have generated a three-dimensional reconstruction of rho, and localized a tRNA molecule bound to the primary RNA-binding site to the outside of the ring. An atomic structure of the N-terminal domain of rho fits into our reconstruction uniquely, with the residues involved in RNA-binding on the outside of the ring. Although rho shares a common structural core with the F1-ATPase and other hexameric helicases, there has been a divergence in function due to rho's N-terminal domain, which has no homology to other helicases.

Implication of gene distribution in the bacterial chromosome for the bacterial cell factory

As bacterial genome sequences accumulate, more and more pieces of data suggest that there is a significant correlation between the distribution of genes along the chromosome and the physical architecture of the cell, suggesting that the map of the cell is in the chromosome. Considering sequences and experimental data indicative of cell compartmentalisation, mRNA folding and turnover, as well as known structural features of protein and membrane complexes, we show that preliminary in silico analysis of whole genome sequences strongly substantiates this hypothesis. If there is a correlation between the genome sequence and the cell architecture, it must derive from some selection pressure in the organisms growing in the wild. As a consequence, the underlying constraints should be optimised in genetically modified organisms if one is to expect high product yields. Consequences in terms of gene expression for biotechnology are straightforward: knocking genes out and in genomes should not be randomly performed, but should follow the rules of chromosome organisation.

The mechanism of ATP hydrolysis at the noncatalytic sites of the transcription termination factor Rho

Escherichia coli transcription termination factor rho is a hexamer with three catalytic subunits that turnover ATP at a fast rate and three noncatalytic subunits that turnover ATP at a relatively slow rate. The mechanism of the ATPase reaction at the noncatalytic sites was determined and was compared with the ATPase mechanism at the catalytic sites. A sequential mechanism for ATP binding or hydrolysis that was proposed for the catalytic sites was not observed at the noncatalytic sites. Pre-steady-state pulse-chase experiments showed that three ATPs were tightly bound to the noncatalytic sites and these were simultaneously hydrolyzed at a rate of 1.8 s(-1) at 18 degrees C. The apparent bimolecular rate constant for ATP binding was determined as 5.4 x 10(5) M(-1) s(-1) in the presence of poly(C) RNA. The ATP hydrolysis products dissociated from the noncatalytic sites at 0.02 s(-1). The hydrolysis of ATP at the noncatalytic sites was at least 130 times slower, and the overall ATPase turnover was 1500 times slower than that at the catalytic sites. These results from studies of the rho protein are likely to be general to hexameric helicases. We propose that the ATPase activity at the noncatalytic site is too slow to drive translocation of the protein on the nucleic acid or to provide energy for nucleic acid unwinding.

Transcription termination factor Rho contains three noncatalytic nucleotide binding sites

The active form of transcription termination factor rho from Escherichia coli is a homohexamer, but several studies suggest that the six subunits of the hexamer are not functionally identical. Rho has three tight and three weak ATP binding sites. Based on our findings, we propose that the tight nucleotide binding sites are noncatalytic and the weak sites are catalytic. In the presence of RNA, the rho-catalyzed ATPase rate is fast, close to 30 s-1. However, under these conditions the three tightly bound nucleotides dissociate from the rho hexamer at a slow rate of 0.02 s-1, indicating that the three tight nucleotide binding sites of rho do not participate in the fast ATPase turnover. These slowly exchanging nucleotide binding sites of rho are capable of hydrolyzing ATP, but the resulting products (ADP and Pi) bind tightly and dissociate from rho about 1500 times slower than the fast ATPase turnover. Both RNA and excess ATP in solution are necessary for stabilizing nucleotide binding at these sites. In the absence of RNA, or when solution ATP is hydrolyzed to ADP, a faster dissociation of nucleotides was observed. Based on these results, we propose that the rho hexamer is similar to the F1-ATPase and T7 DNA helicase-containing noncatalytic sites that do not participate in the fast ATPase turnover. We propose that the three tight sites on rho are the noncatalytic sites and the three weak sites are the catalytic sites.

Bacterial helicases

Helicases are proteins that use the energy of ATP hydrolysis to open double-stranded DNA, RNA, or RNA-DNA hybrids into two single strands. Based upon sequence analysis, at least 12 helicases exist in Escherichia coli. We know that these proteins play important roles in DNA replication, recombination, repair, and transcription, as well as in RNA processing. Recent crystallographic studies have revealed a highly conserved catalytic core in the helicases, shared with the RecA protein and the F1-ATPase. However, evidence suggests that the functional divergence may be large.

Silent mutations in the Escherichia coli ompA leader peptide region strongly affect transcription and translation in vivo

In order to test the effect of silent mutations on the regulation of gene expression, we monitored several steps of transcription and translation of the ompA gene in vivo , in which some or all codons between codons 6 and 14, frequently used in Escherichia coli , had been exchanged for infrequent synonymous codons. Northern blot analysis revealed an up to 4-fold reduction in the half-life of the mutated messengers and a >10-fold reduction in their steady-state amounts. Western blot analysis showed a 10-fold reduction in the amount of OmpA protein. Use of a system expressing a Rho-specific anti-terminator allowed us to detect a strong transcription polarity effect in the silent mutants. These results demonstrate that silent mutations can severely inhibit several steps of gene expression in E. coli and that code degeneracy is efficiently exploited in this species for setting signals for gene control and regulation.

Sequential hydrolysis of ATP molecules bound in interacting catalytic sites of Escherichia coli transcription termination protein Rho

Escherichia coli transcription termination protein Rho, an RNA-dependent ATPase, disrupts transcription complexes, releasing RNA and allowing RNA polymerase to recycle. Homohexameric Rho binds three molecules of MgATP in a single class of catalytically competent sites. In rapid mix chemical quench experiments, when Rho saturated with ATP was mixed with RNA and the reaction was quenched after various times, hydrolysis of the three bound ATP molecules was not simultaneous. A hydrolysis burst of one molecule of ATP per hexamer occurred at >300 s-1, followed by steady-state hydrolysis at 30 s-1 per hexamer. The burst also shows that a step following ATP hydrolysis is rate-limiting for overall catalysis and requires communication among the three catalytic sites during net ATP hydrolysis. The rate of hydrolysis of radiolabeled ATP when one labeled and two unlabeled ATP molecules are bound indicates a sequential pattern of hydrolysis. Positive cooperativity of catalysis occurs among the catalytic sites of Rho; when only one ATP molecule is bound per hexamer, ATP hydrolysis upon addition of RNA is 30-fold slower than when ATP is saturating. These behaviors are comparable to those of F1-type ATPases, with which Rho shares a number of structural features.

Effects of reaction conditions on RNA secondary structure and on the helicase activity of Escherichia coli transcription termination factor Rho

The ATPase and helicase activities of the Escherichia coli transcription termination protein rho have been studied under a variety of reaction conditions that alter its transcription termination activity. These conditions include KCl, KOAc, or KGlu concentrations from 50 to 150 mM and Mg(OAc)2 concentrations from 1 to 5 mM (in the presence of 1 mM ATP). In higher KCl or higher Mg(OAc)2 concentrations we found that the translocation of rho hexamers along RNA was slower and less processive than the same process measured at 50 mM monovalent salt concentrations and 1 mM Mg(OAc)2. The ATPase activity of rho was also decreased under reaction conditions that slowed translocation. RNA melting experiments showed that the decreased ATPase activity of rho and the slower helicase activity at increased KCl or Mg(OAc)2 concentrations are accompanied by a concomitant increase in the secondary structure of the RNA portion of the helicase substate. In contrast, the ATPase activity of rho in the presence of poly(rC), a synthetic RNA that does not form salt-concentration-dependent secondary structure, was shown to be the same in each of the three monovalent salts. Thus, the salts do not directly affect the structure or conformation of the rho protein or the binding of rho to single-stranded RNA. However, the translocation of rho along RNA was more processive in 150 mM KOAc or KGlu than in 150 mM KCl, while the RNA secondary structure was the same in all three monovalent salts. Therefore, the monovalent salt present in the reaction may directly affect rho-RNA interactions when the RNA substrate can form secondary structure. Helicase experiments with an RNA molecule that does not contain a rho loading-site showed that rho translocates less processively along this potential helicase substrate. These results suggest that the helicase activity of rho may be significantly regulated by RNA secondary structure. In addition, one of the mechanisms to concentrate the activity of rho on transcripts containing unstructured rho loading sites may be that rho translocation along such molecules is more processive than it is along more structured RNA molecules in the cell.

Dimerization of simian virus 40 T-antigen hexamers activates T-antigen DNA helicase activity

Chromosomal DNA replication in higher eukaryotes takes place in DNA synthesis factories containing numerous replication forks. We explored the role of replication fork aggregation in vitro, using as a model the simian virus 40 (SV40) large tumor antigen (T antigen), essential for its DNA helicase and origin-binding activities. Previous studies have shown that T antigen binds model DNA replication forks primarily as a hexamer (TAgH) and to a lesser extent as a double hexamer (TAgDH). We find that DNA unwinding in the presence of ATP or other nucleotides strongly correlates with the formation of TAgDH-DNA fork complexes. TAgH- and TAgDH-fork complexes were isolated, and the TAgDH-bound fork was denatured at a 15-fold-higher rate during the initial times of unwinding. TAgDH bound preferentially to a DNA substrate containing a 50-nucleotide bubble, indicating the bridging of each single-stranded DNA/duplex DNA junction, and this DNA molecule was also unwound at a high rate. Both the TAgH- and TAgDH-fork complexes were relatively stable, with the half-life of the TAgDH-fork complex greater than 40 min. Our data therefore indicate that the linking of two viral replication forks serves to activate DNA replication.

The quaternary geometry of transcription termination factor rho: assignment by chemical cross-linking

Transcription termination factor rho from Escherichia coli is a ring-shaped homohexamer of 419 amino acid subunits and catalyzes an ATP-dependent release of nascent RNA transcripts. Previous chemical cross-linking studies suggested that the rho hexamer might have D3 symmetry with three isologous dimers as protomers. However, our recent mutational analysis of rho alongside its putative structural homology to F1-ATPase rather argued for C6 symmetry. To resolve this discrepancy, we have re-investigated the pattern of cross-linking of rho using various cross-linkers with different functional groups and spacer lengths. Upon reaction with dimethyl suberimidate followed by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, rho protein generated a series of cross-linked oligomers up to hexamers, of which dimers migrated as distinct doublet bands of approximately equal intensities. However, the lower band became much stronger than the upper one with dimethyl adipimidate and difluorodinitrobenzene, and vice versa with disuccinimidyl glutarate, disuccinimidyl suberate and disulfosuccinimidyl tartarate. Furthermore, the trimeric products also produced doublet bands, whose relative intensities were again variable with cross-linkers, but in an inverse correlation with those of the dimer bands. These results combined with theoretical considerations support a C6 symmetry model in which cross-linking is assumed to occur stochastically at one of two alternative sites within each subunit interface with variable relative frequencies depending on cross-linkers. The D3 symmetry is excluded, for the putative trimeric subspecies should always retain mutually equal intensities in that case. Detailed inspections of the cross-linking kinetics further revealed a moderate characteristic of C3 symmetry for the rho hexamer such that the collective as well as relative rates of cross-linking at the two available sites could fluctuate between alternating interfaces. The final model designated as C3/6 is also compatible with other functional and structural properties known for rho.

The antibiotic bicyclomycin affects the secondary RNA binding site of Escherichia coli transcription termination factor Rho

The interaction of Rho and the antibiotic bicyclomycin was probed using in vitro transcription termination reactions, poly(C) binding assays, limited tryptic digestions, and the bicyclomycin inhibition kinetics of ATPase activity in the presence of poly(dC) and ribo(C)10. The approximate I50 value for the bicyclomycin inhibition of transcription termination at Rho-dependent sites within a modified trp operon template was 5 microM. At antibiotic concentrations near the I50 value, bicyclomycin inhibition of Rho-dependent transcripts was accompanied by the appearance of a new set of transcripts whose size was midway between the Rho-dependent transcripts and the readthrough transcripts. Bicyclomycin did not inhibit poly(C) binding to Rho. In the presence of poly(dC), bicyclomycin showed a reversible mixed inhibition of the ribo(C)10-stimulated ATPase activity. The extrapolated Ki for bicyclomycin was 2.8 microM without ribo(C)10 and increased to 26 microM in the presence of ribo(C)10. Correspondingly, the Km(app) for ribo(C)10 without bicyclomycin was 0.8 microM and with bicyclomycin was 5 microM at infinite inhibitor concentration. The data suggested that the antibiotic binds to Rho, influencing the secondary RNA binding (tracking) site on Rho and slows the tracking of Rho toward the bound RNA polymerase.

RuvB protein-mediated ATP hydrolysis: functional asymmetry in the RuvB hexamer

A survey of RuvB protein-mediated ATP hydrolysis yields the following observations. (1) The RuvB protein exhibits a DNA-independent ATPase activity with a turnover number (based on a RuvB monomer) approaching 6 min-1 and a Km of 154 microM. Single-stranded DNA and linear duplex DNA have small but significant effects on this activity. (2) At ATP concentrations near the Km, the ATPase activity is attenuated after approximately 60 turnovers/RuvB monomer. The attenuation does not reflect inhibition by ADP. Addition of ATP to 3 mM triggers an immediate resumption of ATP hydrolysis. The attention is enhanced somewhat by ssDNA and reduced somewhat by linear dsDNA. (3) ATP hydrolysis is dramatically stimulated by circular dsDNA, reinforcing the notion that RuvB translocates along the DNA in a reaction coupled to ATP hydrolysis. The kcat increases by at least 2-4-fold on circular duplexes depending on conditions, and the inactivation of RuvB at ATP concentrations near the Km does not occur. The ATPase activity on circular dsDNA also exhibits a partial substrate inhibition by ATP. (4) Optimal ATP hydrolysis requires approximately 1 DNA circle/RuvB hexamer, suggesting that multiple RuvB hexamers on a circle have an inhibitory effect on the ATPase activity. (5) With or without any of these DNA cofactors, a burst of ATP hydrolysis is observed under pre-steady-state conditions equivalent to 1 ATP per 3-3.3 RuvB monomers (2 ATP/hexamer). The substrate inhibition and burst results suggest the presence of nonequivalent ATP hydrolytic sites in a RuvB hexamer. The attenuation of ATPase activity observed under some conditions may also be a manifestation of nonequivalent ATP hydrolytic sites.

The phage T4-coded DNA replication helicase (gp41) forms a hexamer upon activation by nucleoside triphosphate

Sedimentation and high performance liquid chromatography studies show that the functional DNA replication helicase of bacteriophage T4 (gp41) exists primarily as a dimer at physiological protein concentrations, assembling from gp41 monomers with an association constant of approximately 10(6) M-1. Cryoelectron microscopy, analytical ultracentrifugation, and protein-protein cross-linking studies demonstrate that the binding of ATP or GTP drives the assembly of these dimers into monodisperse hexameric complexes, which redissociate following depletion of the purine nucleotide triphosphatase (PuTP) substrates by the DNA-stimulated PuTPase activity of the helicase. The hexameric state of gp41 can be stabilized for detailed study by the addition of the nonhydrolyzable PuTP analogs ATP gamma S and GTP gamma S and is not significantly affected by the presence of ADP, GDP, or single-stranded or forked DNA template constructs, although some structural details of the hexameric complex may be altered by DNA binding. Our results also indicate that the active gp41 helicase exists as a hexagonal trimer of asymmetric dimers, and that the hexamer is probably characterized by D3 symmetry. The assembly pathway of the gp41 helicase has been analyzed, and its structure and properties compared with those of other helicases involved in a variety of cellular processes. Functional implications of such structural organization are also considered.