Photoinduced electron-transfer reaction in a ternary system involving zinc cytochrome c and plastocyanin. Interplay of monopolar and dipolar electrostatic interactions between metalloproteins

Competition between Photoinduced Electron Transfer and Resonance Energy Transfer in an Example of Substituted Cytochrome c-Quantum Dot Systems

Colloidal quantum dots (QDs) are nanoparticles that are able to photoreduce redox proteins by electron transfer (ET). QDs are also able to transfer energy by resonance energy transfer (RET). Here, we address the question of the competition between these two routes of QDs’ excitation quenching, using cadmium telluride QDs and cytochrome c (CytC) or its metal-substituted derivatives. We used both oxidized and reduced versions of native CytC, as well as fluorescent, nonreducible Zn(II)CytC, Sn(II)CytC, and metal-free porphyrin CytC. We found that all of the CytC versions quench QD fluorescence, although the interaction may be described differently in terms of static and dynamic quenching. QDs may be quenchers of fluorescent CytC derivatives, with significant differences in effectiveness depending on QD size. SnCytC and porphyrin CytC increased the rate of Fe(III)CytC photoreduction, and Fe(II)CytC slightly decreased the rate and ZnCytC presence significantly decreased the rate and final level of reduced FeCytC. These might be partially explained by the tendency to form a stable complex between protein and QDs, which promoted RET and collisional quenching. Our findings show that there is a net preference for photoinduced ET over other ways of energy transfer, at least partially, due to a lack of donors, regenerating a hole at QDs and leading to irreversibility of ET events. There may also be a common part of pathways leading to photoinduced ET and RET. The nature of synergistic action observed in some cases allows the hypothesis that RET may be an additional way to power up the ET.

Evolving the [myoglobin, cytochrome b(5)] complex from dynamic toward simple docking: charging the electron transfer reactive patch

We describe photoinitiated electron transfer (ET) from a suite of Zn-substituted myoglobin (Mb) variants to cytochrome b(5) (b(5)). An electrostatic interface redesign strategy has led to the introduction of positive charges into the vicinity of the heme edge through D/E → K charge-reversal mutation combinations at "hot spot" residues (D44, D60, and E85), augmented by the elimination of negative charges from Mb or b(5) by neutralization of heme propionates. These variations create an unprecedentedly large range in the product of the ET partners' total charges (-5 < -q(Mb)q(b(5)) < 40). The binding affinity (K(a)) increases 1000-fold as -q(Mb)q(b(5)) increases through this range and exhibits a surprisingly simple, exponential dependence on -q(Mb)q(b(5)). This is explained in terms of electrostatic interactions between a "charged reactive patch" (crp) on each partner's surface, defined as a compact region around the heme edge that (i) contains the total protein charge of each variant and (ii) encompasses a major fraction of the "reactive region" (Rr) comprising surface atoms with large matrix elements for electron tunneling to the heme. As -q(Mb)q(b(5)) increases, the complex undergoes a transition from fast to slow-exchange dynamics on the triplet ET time scale, with a correlated progression in the rate constants for intracomplex (k(et)) and bimolecular (k(2)) ET. This progression is analyzed by integrating the crp and Rr descriptions of ET into the textbook steady-state treatment of reversible binding between partners that undergo intracomplex ET and found to encompass the full range of behaviors predicted by the model. The generality of this approach is demonstrated by its application to the extensive body of data for the ET complex between the photosynthetic reaction center and cytochrome c(2). Deviations from this model also are discussed.

Electrostatic docking of a supramolecular host-guest assembly to cytochrome c probed by bidirectional photoinduced electron transfer

A water-soluble octacarboxyhemicarcerand was used as a shuttle to transport redox-active substrates across the aqueous medium and deliver them to the target protein. The results show that weak multivalent interactions and conformational flexibility can be exploited to reversibly bind complex supramolecular assemblies to biological molecules. Hydrophobic electron donors and acceptors were encapsulated within the hemicarcerand, and photoinduced electron transfer (ET) between the Zn-substituted cytochrome c (MW = 12.3 kD) and the host-guest complexes (MW = 2.2 kD) was used to probe the association between the negatively charged hemicarceplex and the positively charged protein. The behavior of the resulting ternary protein-hemicarcerand-guest assembly was investigated in two binding limits: (1) when K(encaps) ≫ K(assoc), the hemicarcerand transports the ligand to the protein while protecting it from the aqueous medium; and (2) when K(assoc) > K(encaps), the hemicarcerand-protein complex is formed first, and the hemicarcerand acts as an artificial receptor site that intercepts ligands from solution and positions them close to the active site of the metalloenzyme. In both cases, ET mediated by the protein-bound hemicarcerand is much faster than that due to diffusional encounters with the respective free donor or acceptor in solution. The measured ET rates suggest that the dominant binding region of the host-guest complex on the surface of the protein is consistent with the docking area of the native redox partner of cytochrome c. The strong association with the protein is attributed to the flexible conformation and adaptable charge distribution of the hemicarcerand, which allow for surface-matching with the cytochrome.

Mechanism of electron transfer in fusion protein cytochrome b5-NADH-cytochrome b5 reductase

In the present work we summarize results on construction of expression plasmid, heterologous expression in Escherichia coli, isolation and purification, as well as physicochemical characterization of chimeric protein consisting of hydrophilic domain of cytochrome b(5) and truncated from the N-terminal sequence (Delta(23)) form of NADH-cytochrome b(5) reductase. The kinetics and mechanism of electron transfer between NADH-cytochrome b(5) reductase and cytochrome b(5) in the frames of fusion protein consisting of cytochrome b(5) (94 amino acids) and truncated form of NADH-cytochrome b(5) reductase (277 amino acids) have been studied. It is shown that electron transfer takes place between redox partners belonging to two different molecules of the chimeric protein. Using computer modeling, we built the model of the tertiary structure of the fusion protein, which is in agreement with experimental data. By using Marcus theory of electron transfer in polar media, we demonstrate the inability of the hypothesis of electrostatic repulsions to explain the increase of electron transfer rate on increase of ion concentration in media due to elimination of the repulsion of similar charges. The real reason for the increase of the first order rate constant in some oxidation-reduction reactions between proteins, as shown in the present work, is a decrease of the media reorganization energy resulting in decrease of activation energy for oxidation-reduction reactions.

Structural analysis of zinc-substituted cytochrome c

Zinc-substituted cytochrome c has been widely used in studies of protein-protein interactions and photo-induced electron transfer reactions between proteins. However, the coordination geometry of zinc in zinc-substituted cyt c has not yet been determined; two different opinions about the coordination have been reached. Here the solution structures of zinc-substituted cytochrome c that might be five-coordinated and six-coordinated have been refined separately by using (1)H NMR spectroscopy, and the zinc coordination geometry was determined just by NOE distance constraints. Structural analysis of the energy-minimized average solution structures of both the pentacoordinated and hexacoordinated geometries indicate that that zinc in zinc-substituted cyt c should be bound to both His18 and Met80, which means that the zinc is six-coordinated. RMSD values of the family of 25 six-coordinated structures from the average structure are 0.66+/-0.13 A and 1.09+/-0.16 A for the backbone and all heavy atoms, respectively. A statistical analysis of the structure indicates its satisfactory quality. Comparison of the solution structure of the six-coordinated energy-minimized average structure of zinc-substituted cytochrome c with the solution structure of reduced cytochrome c reveals that for the overall folding the secondary structure elements are very close. The availability of the structure provides for a better understanding of the protein-protein complex and for electron transfer processes between Zn cyt c and other metalloproteins.

Effects of dimerization on protein electron transfer

In order to investigate the relationship between the rate of protein-protein electron transfer and the structure of the association complex, a dimer of the blue copper protein azurin was constructed and its electron exchange properties were determined. For this purpose, a site for covalent cross-linking was engineered by replacing the surface-exposed asparagine 42 with a cysteine. This mutation enabled the formation of disulfide-linked homo-dimers of azurin. Based on NMR line-broadening experiments, the electron self-exchange (e.s.e.) rate constant for this dimer was determined to be 4.2(+/-0.7) x 10(5)M(-1)s(-1), which is a seven-fold decrease relative to wild-type azurin. This difference is ascribed to a less accessible hydrophobic patch in the dimer. To discriminate between intramolecular electron transfer within a dimer and intermolecular electron transfer between two dimers, the e.s.e. rate constant of (Cu-Cu)-N42C dimers was compared with that of (Zn-Cu)- and (Ag-Cu)-N42C dimers. As Zn and Ag are redox inactive, the intramolecular electron transfer reaction in these latter dimers can be eliminated. The e.s.e. rate constants of the three dimers are the same and an upper limit for the intramolecular electron transfer rate of 10 s(-1) could be determined. This rate is compatible with a Cu-Cu distance of 18 A or more, which is larger than the Cu - Cu distance of 15 A observed in the wild-type crystal structure that shows two monomers that face each other with opposing hydrophobic patches. Modelling of the dimer shows that the Cu-Cu distance should be in the range of 17 A < rCu-Cu < 28 A, which is in agreement with the experimental findings. For efficient electron transfer, it appears crucial that the two molecules interact in the proper orientation. Direct cross-linking may disturb the formation of such an optimal electron transfer complex.

Cross-linking between cytochrome c3 and flavodoxin from Desulfovibrio gigas

Tetraheme cytochrome c3 (13 kDa) and flavodoxin (16 kDa), are small electron transfer proteins that have been used to mimic, in vitro, part of the electron-transfer chain that operates between substract electron donors and respiratory electron acceptors partners in Desulfovibrio species (Palma, N., Moura, I., LeGall, J., Van Beeumen, J., Wampler, J., Moura, J. J. G. (1994) Biochemistry 33, 6394-6407). The electron transfer between these two proteins is believed to occur through the formation of a specific complex where electrostatic interaction is the main driving force (Stewart, D., LeGall, J., Moura, I., Moura, J.J.G., Peck, H.D., Xavier, A.V., Weiner, P.K. and Wampler, J.E. (1988) Biochemistry 27, 2444-2450, Stewart, D., LeGall, J., Moura, I., Moura, J.J.G., Peck, H.D., Xavier, A.V., Weiner, P., Wampler, J. (1989) Eur. J. Biochem. 185, 695-700). In order to obtain structural information of the pre-complex, a covalent complex between the two proteins was prepared. A water-soluble carbodiimide [EDC (1-ethyl-3(3 dimethylaminopropyl) carbodiimide hydrochloride] was used for the cross linking reaction. The reaction was optimized varying a wide number of experimental parameters such as ionic strength, protein and cross linker concentration, and utilization of different cross linkers and reaction time between the crosslinker and proteins.

Comparing the rates and the activation parameters for the forward reaction between the triplet state of zinc cytochrome c and cupriplastocyanin and the back reaction between the zinc cytochrome c cation radical and cuproplastocyanin

This is a comparative study of the photoinduced (so-called forward) electron-transfer reaction 3Zncyt/pc(II) --> Zncyt+/pc(I), between the triplet state of zinc cytochrome c (3Zncyt) and cupriplastocyanin [pc(II)], and the thermal (so-called back) electron-transfer reaction Zncyt+/pc(I) --> Zncyt/pc(II), between the cation (radical) of zinc cytochrome c (Zncyt+) and cuproplastocyanin [pc(I)], which follows it. Both reactions occur between associated (docked) reactants, and the respective unimolecular rate constants are kF and kB. Our previous studies showed that the forward reaction is gated by a rearrangement of the diprotein complex. Now we examine the back reaction and complare the two. We study the effects of temperature (in the range 273.3-302.9 K) and viscosity (in the range 1.00-17.4 cP) on the rate constants and determine enthalpies (DeltaH), entropies (DeltaS), and free energies (DeltaG) of activation. We compare wild-type spinach plastocyanin, the single mutants Tyr83Leu and Glu59Lys, and the double mutant Glu59Lys/Glu60Gln. The rate constant kB for wild-type spinach plastocyanin and its mutants markedly depends on viscosity, an indication that the back reaction is also gated. The activation parameters DeltaH and DeltaS show that the forward and back reactions have similar mechanisms, involving a rearrangement of the diprotein complex from the initial binding configuration to the reactive configuration. The rearrangements of the complexes 3Zncyt/pc(II) and Zncyt+/pc(I) that gate their respective reactions are similar but not identical. Since the back reaction of all plastocyanin variants is faster than the forward reaction, the difference in free energy between the docking and the reactive configuration is smaller for the back reaction than for the forward reaction. This difference is explained by the change in the electrostatic potential on the plastocyanin surface as Cu(II) is reduced to Cu(I). It is the smaller DeltaH that makes DeltaG smaller for the back reaction than for the forward reaction.

Effects of single and double mutations in plastocyanin on the rate constant and activation parameters for the rearrangement gating the electron-transfer reaction between the triplet state of zinc cytochrome c and cupriplastocyanin

The unimolecular rate constant for the photoinduced electron-transfer reaction 3Zncyt/pc(II) --> Zncyt+/pc(I) within the electrostatic complex of zinc cytochrome c and spinach cupriplastocyanin is kF. We report the effects on kF of the following factors, all at pH 7.0: 12 single mutations on the plastocyanin surface (Leu12Asn, Leu12Glu, Leu12Lys, Asp42Asn, Asp42Lys, Glu43Asn, Glu59Gln, Glu59Lys, Glu60Gln, Glu60Lys, Gln88Glu, and Gln88Lys), the double mutation Glu59Lys/Glu60Gln, temperature (in the range 273.3-302.9 K), and solution viscosity (in the range 1. 00-116.0 cP) at 283.2 and 293.2 K. We also report the effects of the plastocyanin mutations on the association constant (Ka) and the corresponding free energy of association (DeltaGa) with zinc cytochrome c at 298.2 K. Dependence of kF on temperature yielded the activation parameters DeltaH, DeltaS, and DeltaG. Dependence of kF on solution viscosity yielded the protein friction and confirmed the DeltaG values determined from the temperature dependence. The aforementioned intracomplex reaction is not a simple electron-transfer reaction because donor-acceptor electronic coupling (HAB) and reorganizational energy (lambda), obtained by fitting of the temperature dependence of kF to the Marcus equation, deviate from the expectations based on precedents and because kF greatly depends on viscosity. This last dependence and the fact that certain mutations affect Ka but not kF are two lines of evidence against the mechanism in which the electron-transfer step is coupled with the faster, but thermodynamically unfavorable, rearrangement step. The electron-transfer reaction is gated by the slower, and thus rate determining, structural rearrangement of the diprotein complex; the rate constant kF corresponds to this rearrangement. Isokinetic correlation of DeltaH and DeltaS parameters and Coulombic energies of the various configurations of the Zncyt/pc(II) complex consistently show that the rearrangement is a facile configurational fluctuation of the associated proteins, qualitatively the same process regardless of the mutations in plastocyanin. Correlation of kF with the orientation of the cupriplastocyanin dipole moment indicates that the reactive configuration of the diprotein complex involves the area near the residue 59, between the upper acidic cluster and the hydrophobic patch. Kinetic effects and noneffects of plastocyanin mutations show that the rearrangement from the initial (docking) configuration, which involves both acidic clusters, to the reactive configuration does not involve the lower acidic cluster and the hydrophobic patch but involves the upper acidic cluster and the area near the residue 88.

Effects of viscosity and temperature on the kinetics of the electron-transfer reaction between the triplet state of zinc cytochrome c and cupriplastocyanin

This is a study of the effects of viscosity (in the range of 0.8-790 cP), of temperature (in the range of 260.7-307.7 K), and of ionic strength (in the range of 2.5-20.0 mM) on the kinetics of photoinduced electron-transfer reaction 3Zncyt/pc(II) --> Zncyt+/pc(I) within the electrostatic complex of zinc cytochrome c and cupriplastocyanin at pH 7.0. The unimolecular rate constant is kF. The apparent activation parameters DeltaH*, DeltaS*, and DeltaG* for this reaction were obtained in experiments with aqueous glycerol solutions having a constant composition. The interpolation of kF values obtained at the constant composition into the dependence of kF on temperature at constant viscosity gave the proper activation parameters, which agree with those obtained in experiments with solutions having a constant viscosity. This agreement validates the latter method, which is more efficient than the former, for determining activation parameters of processes that are modulated by viscosity. The smooth change in kF is governed by the change in viscosity, not in other properties of the solvent, and it does not depend on the choice of the viscosigen. Donor/acceptor electronic coupling (HAB) and reorganizational energy (lambda), obtained by fitting of the temperature dependence of kF to the Marcus equation, are consistent with true electron transfer and with electron transfer that is coupled to, or gated by, a preceding structural rearrangement of the diprotein complex 3Zncyt/pc(II). The fact that at very high viscosity kF approaches zero shows that the reaction is probably gated throughout the investigated range of viscosity. Kinetic effects and noneffects of ionic strength, viscosity, and thermodynamic driving force indicate, but do not prove, that the reaction under consideration is gated. The kinetic effect of viscosity is analyzed in terms of two models. Because ln kF is a nonlinear function of ln eta, protein friction has to be considered in the analysis of viscosity effects on kinetics.

Characterization of zinc-substituted cytochrome c by circular dichroism and resonance Raman spectroscopic methods

Iron(III) in cytochrome c is replaced with zinc(II) by a modification of a method published by others, and the procedure is described in full detail. Three forms of cytochrome c-those containing iron(III), iron(II), and zinc(II)-are examined by circular dichroism spectroscopy and resonance Raman spectroscopy. Spectra of both kinds show that introduction of zinc(II) ions does not appreciably alter the overall structure and conformation of cytochrome c. Resonance Raman spectra indicate the size of the porphyrin "core" that is inconsistent with six-coordination and consistent with five-coordination. Unlike the iron(III) and iron(II) ions, which are bound to two axial ligands (His 18 and Met 80), the zinc(II) ion in cytochrome c seems to be bound to only one, most probably His 18. Evidence pertaining to the question of axial coordination is discussed.

Effects of mutations in plastocyanin on the kinetics of the protein rearrangement gating the electron-transfer reaction with zinc cytochrome c. Analysis of the rearrangement pathway

We study, by flash kinetic spectrophotometry on the microsecond time scale, the effects of ionic strength and viscosity on the kinetics of oxidative quenching of the triplet state of zinc cytochrome c (3Zncyt) by the wild-type form and the following nine mutants of cupriplastocyanin: Leu12Glu, Leu12Asn, Phe35Tyr, Gln88Glu, Tyr83Phe, Tyr83His, Asp42Asn, Glu43Asn, and the double mutant Glu59Lys/Glu60Gln. The unimolecular rate constants for the quenching reactions within the persistent diprotein complex, which predominates at low ionic strengths, and within the transient diprotein complex, which is involved at higher ionic strengths, are equal irrespective of the mutation. Evidently, the two complexes are the same. In both reactions, the rate-limiting step is rearrangement of the diprotein complex from a configuration optimal for docking to the one optimal for the subsequent electron-transfer step, which is fast. We investigate the effects of plastocyanin mutations on this rearrangement, which gates the overall electron-transfer reaction. Conversion of the carboxylate anions into amide groups in the lower acidic cluster (residues 42 and 43), replacement of Tyr83 with other aromatic residues, and mutations in the hydrophobic patch in plastocyanin do not significantly affect the rearrangement. Conversion of a pair of carboxylate anions into a cationic and a neutral residue in the upper acidic cluster (residues 59 and 60) impedes the rearrangement. Creation of an anion at position 88, between the upper acidic cluster and the hydrophobic patch, facilitates the rearrangement. The rate constant for the rearrangement smoothly decreases as the solution viscosity increases, irrespective of the mutation. Fittings of this dependence to the modified Kramers's equation and to an empirical equation show that zinc cytochrome c follows the same trajectory on the surfaces of all the plastocyanin mutants but that the obstacles along the way vary as mutations alter the electrostatic potential. Mutations that affect protein association (i.e., change the binding constant) do not necessarily affect the reaction between the associated proteins (i.e., the rate constant) and vice versa. All of the kinetic and thermodynamic effects and noneffects of mutations consistently indicate that in the protein rearrangement the basic patch of zinc cytochrome c moves from a position between the two acidic clusters to a position at or near the upper acidic cluster.

Effects of temperature on the kinetics of the gated electron-transfer reaction between zinc cytochrome c and plastocyanin. Analysis of configurational fluctuation of the diprotein complex

This is a study of the effects of temperature (in the range 273.3-307.7 K) and of ionic strength (in the range 2.5-100 mM) on the kinetics of photoinduced electron-transfer reaction 3Zncyt/pc(II)--> Zncyt+/pc(I) within the electrostatic complex of zinc cytochrome c and cupriplastocyanin at pH 7.0. In order to separate direct and indirect effects of temperature on the rate constants, viscosity of the solutions was fixed, at different values, by additions of sucrose. The activation parameters for the reaction within the preformed complex, at the low ionic strength, are delta H++ = 13 +/- 2 kJ/mol and delta S++ = -97 +/- 4 J/K mol. The activation parameters for the reaction within the encounter complex, at the higher ionic strength, are delta H++ = 13 +/- 1 kJ/mol and delta S++ = -96 +/- 3 J/K mol. Evidently, the two complexes are the same. The proteins associate similarly in the persistent and the transient complex, i.e., at different ionic strengths. In both complexes, however, electron transfer is gated by a rearrangement, as previous studies from this laboratory showed. Changes in the solution viscosity modulate this rearrangement by affecting delta H++, not delta S++. The activation parameters are analyzed by empirical methods. The thermodynamic parameters delta H and delta S for the formation of the complex Zncyt/pc(II) are determined and related to changes in hydrophilic and hydrophobic surfaces upon protein association in three configurations. A difference between the values of delta H for the configuration providing optimal electronic coupling between the redox sites and the configuration providing optimal docking equals the experimental value delta H++ = 13 kJ/mol for the rearrangement of the latter configuration into the former. Enthalpy of activation may reflect a change in the character of the exposed surface as the diprotein complex rearranges. Entropy of activation may reflect tightening of the contact between the associated proteins.

Enforced interaction of one molecule of plastocyanin with two molecules of cytochrome c and an electron-transfer reaction involving the hydrophobic patch on the plastocyanin surface

Laser flash photolysis is used to study the photoinduced electron-transfer reaction cyt(III)//pc(II) + 3Zncyt --> cyt(III)//pc(I) + Zincyt+ at pH 7.0 and 25 degrees. In the covalent (symbol//) complex cyt(III)//pc(II) the acidic patch in cupriplastocyanin is directly cross-linked to the basic patch in ferricytochrome c. The triplet state of zinc cytochrome c reduces the pc(II) moiety, not the cyt(III) moiety, of the covalent complex. The reaction is strictly bimolecular in the entire range of ionic strength studied, from 1.25 mM to 1.00 M. The two reactants interact only transiently, in a collisional complex, and do not form a persistent complex cyt(III)//pc(II)/Zncyt. Because noncovalent (symbol/) association of three separate protein molecules is far less probable than association of the covalent complex and another protein molecule, we conclude that, without the aid of covalent cross-links, one molecule of plastocyanin will not form a ternary complex with two molecules of cytochrome c, cyt/pc/cyt. Dependence of the rate constant on ionic strength is analyzed in terms of van Leeuwen theory of electrostatic interactions, which recognizes the importance of dipole moments of the proteins. This analysis shows that 3Zncyt reacts with the hydrophobic patch in the pc(II) moiety of the covalent complex cyt(III)//pc(II). At high ionic strength, at which electrostatic interactions are practically abolished, the blue copper site is reduced with approximately equal rates via the hydrophobic patch in the pc(II) moiety of the complex and via the acidic patch in free pc(II). This is evidence that the two distinct patches on the plastocyanin surface are comparable in their intrinsic "conductivity" for electrons coming to the copper site. Positively charged and electroneutral redox partners tend to react at the acidic patch (although not necessarily at the initial docking site in this broad patch) for electrostatic, not electronic, reasons. Earlier theorectical studies disagreed about the relative electronic conductivities of the two patches. This experimental study corroborates very recent theoretical studies that found the two patches to be comparable in the efficiency of electron transfer.

Biological electron transfer: structural and mechanistic studies

The developments in the field of biological electron transfer over the past 2 years are reviewed. Attention is given to theoretical developments, especially with respect to the concept of 'electronic pathways' inside proteins, and the association process of redox proteins in solution and the idea of 'conformational gating'.

A "parallel plate" electrostatic model for bimolecular rate constants applied to electron transfer proteins

A "parallel plate" model describing the electrostatic potential energy of protein-protein interactions is presented that provides an analytical representation of the effect of ionic strength on a biomolecular rate constant. The model takes into account the asymmetric distribution of charge on the surface of the protein and localized charges at the site of electron transfer that are modeled as elements of a parallel plate condenser. Both monopolar and dipolar interactions are included. Examples of simple (monophasic) and complex (biphasic) ionic strength dependencies obtained from experiments with several electron transfer protein systems are presented, all of which can be accommodated by the model. The simple cases do not require the use of both monopolar and dipolar terms (i.e., they can be fit well by either alone). The biphasic dependencies can be fit only by using dipolar and monopolar terms of opposite sign, which is physically unreasonable for the molecules considered. Alternatively, the high ionic strength portion of the complex dependencies can be fit using either the monopolar term alone or the complete equation; this assumes a model in which such behavior is a consequence of electron transfer mechanisms involving changes in orientation or site of reaction as the ionic strength is varied. Based on these analyses, we conclude that the principal applications of the model presented here are to provide information about the structural properties of intermediate electron transfer complexes and to quantify comparisons between related proteins or site-specific mutants. We also conclude that the relative contributions of monopolar and dipolar effects to protein electron transfer kinetics cannot be evaluated from experimental data by present approximations.

Electron-transfer from cytochrome c to ascorbate oxidase and its type 2 copper-depleted derivatives

Rate constants have been determined for the electron-transfer reactions between reduced horse heart cytochrome c and resting cucumber ascorbate oxidase as functions of pH, ionic strength, and temperature. The second-order rate constant for the oxidation of reduced cytochrome c was determined to be k = 820 M-1 s-1 in 0.2 M phosphate buffer at pH 6.0 and 25 degrees C. The activation parameters were estimated to be delta H++ = 5 kJ mol-1 and delta S++ = -188 Jmol-1 K-1. The rate constants increased with decreasing buffer concentration, indicating that the electron-transfer from cytochrome c to ascorbate oxidase is realized by the local electrostatic interaction between them in spite of the reaction between positively charged proteins. Reactions of type 2 copper-depleted ascorbate oxidase whose type 3 coppers were in the reduced or oxidized form indicated that the type 1 copper site accepts an electron from cytochrome c. The reaction rate was remarkably increased with decreasing pH for both the native enzyme and derivatives. Further, on addition of hexametaphosphate anion the rate of the electron-transfer decreased because the association of both proteins to realize the electron-transfer was inhibited due to a change in distribution of the local charge on the protein surface(s).

A thermodynamic study by laser-flash photolysis of plastocyanin and cytochrome c6 oxidation by photosystem I from the green alga Monoraphidium braunii

Plastocyanin and cytochrome c6 from the green alga Monoraphidium braunii reduce the photo-oxidized algal photosystem I (PSI) reaction center chlorophyll (P700) with similar kinetics, as expected from their functional equivalence. The observed P700+ reduction rate constants show a non-linear dependence on metalloprotein concentration, which indicates a (minimal) two-step kinetic mechanism involving complex formation prior to electron transfer. The dependence of the observed rate constants on NaCl concentration suggests that the electrostatic interaction forces between the negatively charged donor proteins and PSI are repulsive at neutral pH and relatively low ionic strength (I), although attractive dipole-dipole interactions may play a role at higher ionic strengths. Activation parameters for P700+ reduction by cytochrome c6 and plastocyanin have been determined by studying the temperature dependence of the respective rate constants at varying ionic strength and pH. Changes in NaCl concentration and pH induce significant changes in the activation free energy of the overall reaction, even though the corresponding values for activation enthalpy and entropy undergo changes in opposite directions. Such a compensation effect between enthalpy and entropy is observed with both cytochrome c6 and plastocyanin. Protein concentration dependencies of the observed rate constants at different temperatures has allowed an estimate of the free energy change during complex association, as well as the activation parameters for electron transfer, according to a two-step kinetic model.

Importance of protein rearrangement in the electron-transfer reaction between the physiological partners cytochrome f and plastocyanin

Cytochrome f from turnip and plastocyanin from French bean were noninvasively cross-linked in the presence of the carbodiimide EDC so that the exposed heme edge in the former protein abuts the acidic patch remote from the copper site in the latter [Morand, L.Z., Frame, M.K., Colvert, K.K., Johnson, D.A., Krogmann, D.W., & Davis, D.J. (1989) Biochemistry 28, 8039]. The molecular mass, reduction potentials, and UV-visible and ESR spectra of the covalent complex were consistent with the composition cyt/pc and with a lack of noticeable structural perturbations of the protein molecules. Isoelectric focusing showed the presence of N-acylurea groups, byproducts of the cross-linking reaction [Zhou, J.S., Brothers, H.M. II, Neddersen, J.P., Peerey, L.M., Cotton, T.M., & Kostić, N.M. (1992) Bioconjugate Chem. 3, 382]. Laser flash spectroscopy, with riboflavin semiquinone as the reductant, showed that the electrontransfer reaction within the covalent complex cyt(II)/pc(II) is either undetectably slow or reversible. The question was resolved by monitoring, during redox titrations, the 1H NMR line widths of the heme methyl groups in free ferricytochrome f and in this protein cross-linked to plastocyanin.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Comparison of electrostatic interactions and of protein-protein orientations in electron-transfer reactions of plastocyanin with the triplet state of zinc cytochrome c and with zinc cytochrome c cation radical

Photoinduced reduction of cupriplastocyanin by the triplet state of zinc cytochrome c (the "forward" reaction) and the subsequent thermal oxidation of cuproplastocyanin by zinc cytochrome c cation radical (the "back" reaction) at ionic strengths from 40 mM to 3.00 M are studied by laser kinetic spectroscopy (so-called flash photolysis). Variation of the bimolecular rate constants over the entire range of ionic strength cannot be explained in terms of monopole-monopole interactions between the protein molecules, but it can be explained in terms of monopole-monopole, monopole-dipole, and dipole-dipole interactions. Analysis of the kinetic results in terms of these electrostatic interactions reveals the overall protein-protein orientation for electron transfer. In both the forward and back reactions the exposed heme edge in zinc cytochrome c apparently abuts the negatively-charged (acidic) patch on the plastocyanin surface, which is remote from the copper atom, and not the electroneutral (hydrophobic) patch, which is proximate to the copper atom. The acidic patch is large, and this analysis cannot rule out a relatively small difference in protein-protein orientations for the forward and back reactions. These two reactions are compared with the previously studied reduction of cupriplastocyanin by ferrocytochrome c. Although native cytochrome c and its zinc derivative have very similar structural and electrostatic properties, the reactive forms of the cytochrome c/plastocyanin and zinc cytochrome c/plastocyanin complexes may adopt somewhat different protein-protein orientations or may adopt similar orientations but differ in dynamic properties.

Transient kinetics of electron transfer from a variety of c-type cytochromes to plastocyanin

Plastocyanin (PC) and its physiological reaction partner cytochrome (cyt) f form a complex which is electrostatically stabilized by interactions between complementary localized charges. We have measured the kinetics of intracomplex electron transfer between several reduced cytochromes and PC using laser flash photolysis. With spinach cyt f and spinach PC, we obtain first-order rate constants, kforward = 2780 s-1 and kreverse = 1050 s-1, for the reversible reaction and a complex dissociation constant of about 23 microM at an ionic strength (I) of 5 mM. The observed rate constant increases by a factor of 2 between I = 5 and 40 mM and then decreases monotonically at higher ionic strengths. This indicates that the complex is not completely dissociated until I = 150 mM and that the proteins within the electrostatically most stable complex are not optimally oriented for electron transfer. Similar results were obtained with turnip cyt f and spinach PC, although in this case intracomplex electron transfer is about 4 times as fast. Horse cyt c also forms an electrostatically stabilized complex with PC, and yields a limiting rate constant for intracomplex electron transfer (1750 s-1) and a dissociation constant (10 microM) comparable to those for spinach cyt f. The ionic strength dependence shows that the complex is more readily dissociated (complete at I = 25 mM) than is that of cyt f and that rearrangement is not required for optimal electron transfer. Addition of polylysine results in 10-fold inhibition of the rate of electron transfer. Pseudomonas cyt c-551 is an acidic cytochrome which does not form a complex with PC.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)