Affinity selection of chemically modified proteins: role of lysyl residues in the binding of calmodulin to calcineurin

Calcineurin in the heart: New horizons for an old friend

Calcineurin, also known as PP2B or PPP3, is a member of the PPP family of protein phosphatases that also includes PP1 and PP2A. Together these three phosphatases carryout the majority of dephosphorylation events in the heart. Calcineurin is distinct in that it is activated by the binding of calcium/calmodulin (Ca2+/CaM) and therefore acts as a node for integrating Ca2+ signals with changes in phosphorylation, two fundamental intracellular signaling cascades. In the heart, calcineurin is primarily thought of in the context of pathological cardiac remodeling, acting through the Nuclear Factor of Activated T-cell (NFAT) family of transcription factors. However, calcineurin activity is also essential for normal heart development and homeostasis in the adult heart. Furthermore, it is clear that NFAT-driven changes in transcription are not the only relevant processes initiated by calcineurin in the setting of pathological remodeling. There is a growing appreciation for the diversity of calcineurin substrates that can impact cardiac function as well as the diversity of mechanisms for targeting calcineurin to specific sub-cellular domains in cardiomyocytes and other cardiac cell types. Here, we will review the basics of calcineurin structure, regulation, and function in the context of cardiac biology. Particular attention will be given to: the development of improved tools to identify and validate new calcineurin substrates; recent studies identifying new calcineurin isoforms with unique properties and targeting mechanisms; and the role of calcineurin in cardiac development and regeneration.

Calcineurin signaling in the heart: The importance of time and place

The calcium-activated protein phosphatase, calcineurin, lies at the intersection of protein phosphorylation and calcium signaling cascades, where it provides an essential nodal point for coordination between these two fundamental modes of intracellular communication. In excitatory cells, such as neurons and cardiomyocytes, that experience rapid and frequent changes in cytoplasmic calcium, calcineurin protein levels are exceptionally high, suggesting that these cells require high levels of calcineurin activity. Yet, it is widely recognized that excessive activation of calcineurin in the heart contributes to pathological hypertrophic remodeling and the progression to failure. How does a calcium activated enzyme function in the calcium-rich environment of the continuously contracting heart without pathological consequences? This review will discuss the wide range of calcineurin substrates relevant to cardiovascular health and the mechanisms calcineurin uses to find and act on appropriate substrates in the appropriate location while potentially avoiding others. Fundamental differences in calcineurin signaling in neonatal verses adult cardiomyocytes will be addressed as well as the importance of maintaining heterogeneity in calcineurin activity across the myocardium. Finally, we will discuss how circadian oscillations in calcineurin activity may facilitate integration with other essential but conflicting processes, allowing a healthy heart to reap the benefits of calcineurin signaling while avoiding the detrimental consequences of sustained calcineurin activity that can culminate in heart failure.

Recent developments in protein-ligand affinity mass spectrometry

This review provides an overview of direct and indirect technologies to screen protein–ligand interactions with mass spectrometry. These technologies have as a key feature the selection or affinity purification of ligands in mixtures prior to detection. Specific fields of interest for these technologies are metabolic profiling of bioactive metabolites, natural extract screening, and the screening of libraries for bioactives, such as parallel synthesis libraries and small combichem libraries. The review addresses the principles of each of the methods discussed, with a focus on developments in recent years, and the applicability of the methods to lead generation and development in drug discovery.

Figure

Carbon-13 NMR studies of the lysine side chains of calmodulin and its proteolytic fragments

The pH-titration and dynamic behaviour of the seven lysine side chains in bovine calmodulin were studied by carbon-13 NMR. The amino groups of the calcium saturated protein and its proteolytic fragments TR1C (1-75) and TR2C (78-148) were dimethylated with carbon-13 labeled formaldehyde; this modification did not alter the protein's structure or its ability to activate the enzyme cyclic nucleotide phosphodiesterase. Tentative assignments for 5 out of the 7 dimethyl lysine resonances could be obtained by comparing spectra of the fully and partially modified protein, with those of the proteolytic fragments. The pKa values measured for calcium saturated calmodulin ranged between 9.5 (Lys 75) and 10.2 (Lys 13); two residues (Lys 94 and Lys 13) showed a biphasic titration curve suggesting their possible involvement in ion-pairs. The dynamic behavior of the lysine side chains was deduced from spin lattice relaxation measurements. All side chains were flexible and this was not influenced by the removal of calcium, or the addition of the calmodulin antagonist trifluoperazine. The latter data suggest that the lysine side chains are not directly involved in calmodulin's target binding sites.

Activation of enzymes by calmodulins containing intramolecular cross-links

We have reacted calmodulins containing cysteines substituted at positions 3 and 146 or 5 and 146 with bismaleimidohexane (BMH) to generate intramolecularly cross-linked proteins termed BMHCM or BMHCM1, respectively. Reactions were also performed with N-ethylmaleimide (NEM) in place of BMH to generate corresponding S-ethylsuccinimidylated proteins termed NEMCM or NEMCM1. The abilities of these proteins to activate plant NAD kinase, erythrocyte Ca(2+)-ATPase and bovine brain calcineurin activities were assessed. The BMH- or NEM-reacted proteins activate calcineurin activity as does control calmodulin. Kact values for Ca(2+)-ATPase activation by BMHCM and BMHCM1 are increased 10-fold relative to the control value, with no corresponding change in Vmax values. Activation of this enzyme by NEMCM or NEMCM1 is not different from the control. In NAD kinase activation experiments BMHCM and BMHCM1 are associated with a 10 to 20-fold increase in Kact values and a 60-75% reduction in Vmax values relative to the control. NEMCM1 is not associated with any apparent changes in NAD kinase activation, however, NEMCM is associated with a 10-fold increase in the Kact value. NEM-reacted calmodulin containing a cysteine only at position 3 is not associated with an increased Kact value, implying that this change is due to interactions between S-(ethylsuccinimido)cysteines at positions 3 and 146. In conclusion, cross-linking and associated distortions in the structure of calmodulin appear to have little or no effect on activation of calcineurin enzyme activity. However, bending in the central helix and/or steric restrictions associated with cross-linking increase significantly the Kact value for Ca(2+)-ATPase and NAD kinase activation, and dramatically reduce maximal activation of NAD kinase activity.

Tertiary structure of calcineurin B by homology modeling

The crystal structure of the calcium-binding protein calmodulin is used to model the immunologically important calcineurin subunit B. The rough structure is produced by computer-aided homology modeling. Refinement of this using molecular dynamics leads to a suggested structure which appears to satisfy reasonable hydrophilicity and hydrogen-bonding criteria. In the absence of a crystal structure, the model may prove useful in modeling of its interactions with the phosphatase catalytic subunit calcineurin A, and help to explain the calcium modulation of this protein.

Phosphorylation by casein kinase II alters the biological activity of calmodulin

Calmodulin is the major intracellular Ca(2+)-binding protein, providing Ca(2+)-dependent regulation of numerous intracellular enzymes. The phosphorylation of calmodulin may provide an additional mechanism for modulating its function as a signal transducer. Phosphocalmodulin has been identified in tissues and cells, and calmodulin is phosphorylated both in vitro and in intact cells by various enzymes. Phosphorylation of calmodulin on serine/threonine residues by casein kinase II decreases its ability to activate both myosin-light-chain kinase and cyclic nucleotide phosphodiesterase. For myosin-light-chain kinase the primary effect is an inhibition of the Vmax. of the reaction, with no apparent change in the concentration at which half-maximal velocity is attained (K0.5) for either Ca2+ or calmodulin. In contrast, for phosphodiesterase, phosphorylation of calmodulin significantly increases the K0.5 for calmodulin without noticeably altering the Vmax. or the K0.5 for Ca2+. The higher the stoichiometry of phosphorylation of calmodulin, the greater the inhibition of calmodulin-stimulated activity for both enzymes. Therefore the phosphorylation of calmodulin by casein kinase II appears to provide a Ca(2+)-independent mechanism whereby calmodulin regulates at least two important target enzymes, myosin-light-chain kinase and cyclic nucleotide phosphodiesterase.

Preparation, characterization and biological properties of biotinylated derivatives of calmodulin

Biotinylated derivatives of calmodulin (CaM) were prepared and their biological properties characterized by using enzyme assays, affinity and hydrophobic-interaction chromatography. Several N-hydroxysuccinimidobiotin derivatives [sulphosuccinimidobiotin (sulpho-NHS) and sulphosuccinimido-6-(biotinamido)hexanoate (BNHS-LC)] differing in spacer arm length were used to modify CaM. The shorter-spacer-arm CaM derivative (sulpho-CaM) activated CaM-dependent cyclic nucleotide phosphodiesterase and CaM-dependent protein kinase II; preincubation with avidin blocked its ability to activate these enzymes. The extended-spacer-arm derivative (BNHS-LC-CaM) activated CaM-dependent enzymes both in the presence and in the absence of avidin, suggesting that the longer spacer arm diminished steric effects from avidin preincubation. Other biotinylated CaM derivatives were prepared with biotinylated tyrosine and/or histidine residues (diazobenzoylbiocytin; DBB-CaM) or nucleophilic sites (photobiotin acetate; photo-CaM). These derivatives activated CaM-dependent enzymes in the presence and in the absence of avidin. Oriented affinity columns were constructed with covalently immobilized avidin complexed to each biotinylated CaM derivative. The chromatographic profiles obtained revealed that each column interacted with a specific subset of CaM-binding proteins. Elution profiles of biotinyl CaM derivatives on phenyl-Sepharose hydrophobic-interaction chromatography suggested that several derivatives displayed diminished binding to the matrix in the presence of Ca2+. Development and characterization of a series of biotinylated CaM molecules can be used to identify domains of CaM that interact with specific CaM-dependent enzymes.

The phosphorylation of calmodulin and calmodulin fragments by kinase fractions from bovine brain

The phosphorylation of intact calmodulin and of fragments obtained by trypsin digestion was studied, using a protein kinase partially purified from bovine brain. Brain extracts were made in the presence of the detergent CHAPS (3-[3-cholamidopropyl)-dimethylammonio]-1-propanesulfonate). The protein kinase catalyzed the incorporation of nearly 1 mol of 32P from [gamma-32P]ATP into calmodulin fragment 1-106. Incorporation was exclusively into serine 101. With fragment 78-148, the extent of phosphorylation was somewhat less and 32P appeared mainly in threonine residues. Fragment 1-90 was also a fairly good substrate, but the phosphorylation of intact calmodulin never exceeded 0.01 mol per mol. Little or no phosphorylation was seen with parvalbumin, the brain Ca2+-binding protein (CBP-18) and intestinal calcium-binding protein. The protein kinase had no requirement for cAMP or phospholipids. High levels of Mg2+ (60-70 mM) stimulated phosphorylation of the fragments 20-fold. Millimolar concentrations of Ca2+ were inhibitory. It is suggested that the calmodulin fragments were in a conformation more favorable for phosphorylation than intact soluble calmodulin.

Domain II of calmodulin is involved in activation of calcineurin

A family of mutant proteins related to calmodulin (CaM) has been produced using cDNA constructs in bacterial expression vectors. The new proteins contain amino acid substitutions in Ca2+-binding domains I, II, both I and II, or both II and IV. The calmodulin-like proteins have been characterized with respect to mobility on SDS-polyacrylamide gels, Ca2+-dependent enhancement of tyrosine fluorescence, and abilities to activate the CaM-dependent phosphatase calcineurin. These studies suggest that an intact Ca2+-binding domain II is minimally required for full activation of calcineurin.

Determination of the effect of acetylation of specific lysine residues in human growth hormone on its affinity for somatogenic receptors by an affinity selection technique

A technique is described to study the effect of acetylation of individual lysine residues in peptide hormones on the affinity for their receptors, and is illustrated for the case of human growth hormone (hGH) binding to somatogenic receptors. The hGH was partially acetylated with high specific activity [3H]-acetic anhydride and the product ([3H]-Ac-hGH) was incubated with solubilised affinity-purified somatogenic receptors (from male rat liver) in the presence and absence of excess unlabelled hGH. The receptor-bound and unbound labelled hormone were separated by gel filtration and subjected to HPLC tryptic peptide mapping after the addition of cold carrier Ac-hGH. Peaks of [3H] radioactivity were assigned to peptides corresponding to the acetylation of specific lysine residues in the hGH sequence by amino acid analysis and sequencing. Comparison of the relative intensities of corresponding [3H] peaks in the peptide maps of added receptor, bound and unbound [3H]-Ac-hGH, enabled the relative receptor-binding potencies of different acetylated hGH species to be determined. Acetylation of lysine 168 or 172 in hGH greatly decreases its receptor-binding affinity, acetylation of lysine 115 probably causes a minor decrease, whereas acetylation of lysines 38, 70, and the N-terminal amino group have no appreciable effect. Acetylation of lysine 140 causes a significant increase in receptor-binding affinity.

Two trifluoperazine-binding sites on calmodulin predicted from comparative molecular modeling with troponin-C

Among the known regulatory proteins that are conformationally sensitive to the binding of calcium ions, calmodulin and troponin-C have the greatest primary sequence homology. This observation has led to the conclusion that the most accurate predicted molecular model of calmodulin would be based on the X-ray crystallographic coordinates of the highly refined structure of turkey skeletal troponin-C. This paper describes the structure of calmodulin built from such a premise. The resulting molecular model was subjected to conjugate gradient energy minimization to remove unacceptable intramolecular non-bonded contacts. In the analysis of the resulting structure, many features of calmodulin, including the detailed conformation of the Ca2+-binding loops, the amino- and carboxy-terminal hydrophobic patches of the Ca2+-bound form, and the several clusters of acidic residues can be reconciled with much of the previously published solution data. Calmodulin is missing the N-terminal helix characteristic of troponin-C. The deletion of three residues from the central helical linker (denoted D/E in troponin-C) shortens the molecule and changes the orientation of the two domains of calmodulin by 60 degrees relative to those in troponin-C. The molecular model has been used to derive two possible binding sites for the antipsychotic drug trifluoperazine, a potent competitive inhibitor of calmodulin activity.

Stimulation of the erythrocyte Ca2+-ATPase and of bovine brain cyclic nucleotide phosphodiesterase by chemically modified calmodulin

Chemically modified calmodulins have been used to investigate structural features which are important for the interaction of the activator with targets. Carbamoylation of lysine residues had no influence on the ability of calmodulin to stimulate the plasma membrane Ca2+-ATPase whereas the stimulation of the bovine brain cyclic-nucleotide phosphodiesterase was reduced up to 50%. Different species of carbamoylated calmodulin have been isolated but no differences were detected in their interaction with the cyclic-nucleotide phosphodiesterase. Modification of arginine residues by 1,2-cyclohexanedione had no effect of the stimulation of the phosphodiesterase but reduced by 40% the stimulation of the erythrocyte Ca2+ ATPase. Mild oxidation of methionines by N-chlorosuccinimide produced a number of differently modified calmodulins. The different species have been purified and the modified residues have been identified. They affected the two different test enzymes to different extents indicating that methionines in the central helix of calmodulin are of greater importance for the interaction with the phosphodiesterase, whereas methionines located in the C-terminal half of calmodulin are more important for the interaction with the Ca2+-ATPase.

Association of calmodulin and smooth muscle myosin light chain kinase: application of a label selection technique with trace acetylated calmodulin

A method is described for rapidly surveying the effects of modifying individual amino acid residues of a protein on its ability to interact specifically with another macromolecule. The procedure has been used to examine the individual roles of the seven lysyl residues of calmodulin in its ability to bind to smooth muscle myosin light chain kinase; previous studies by Jackson et al. (J. Biol. Chem. 261:1226-12232, 1986) have suggested that certain lysines may be located close to the interaction site. Trace [3H]-acetylated calmodulin, consisting predominantly of molecules acetylated at single sites together with unmodified protein, was incubated in excess (five- to 20-fold) with smooth muscle MLC kinase to allow the modified and unmodified molecules to compete for binding to the enzyme. Subsequently, the calmodulin-enzyme complex was separated from unbound calmodulin, and the level of acetylation of each of the seven lysines of the bound fraction of calmodulin was determined and compared to that of each corresponding group of the starting preparation. Significant changes were found at only two of the lysines, 21 and 75, where the extent of acetylation in the bound fraction was three- and fivefold lower, respectively, than that in the original preparation. These results were reproducible in three separate selection experiments employing both chicken and turkey gizzard MLC kinase. It is concluded that acetylation of calmodulin at either lysine 21 or 75 markedly reduces its affinity for MLC kinase, but acetylation at any of the other lysines (13, 30, 77, 94, or 148) has only minor effects.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)