Fluorine-19 NMR studies of the interaction of selectively labeled actin and myosin

Protein 19F-labeling using transglutaminase for the NMR study of intermolecular interactions

The preparation of stable isotope-labeled proteins is important for NMR studies, however, it is often hampered in the case of eukaryotic proteins which are not readily expressed in Escherichia coli. Such proteins are often conveniently investigated following post-expression chemical isotope tagging. Enzymatic ¹⁵N-labeling of glutamine side chains using transglutaminase (TGase) has been applied to several proteins for NMR studies. ¹⁹F-labeling is useful for interaction studies due to its high NMR sensitivity and susceptibility. Here, ¹⁹F-labeling of glutamine side chains using TGase and 2,2,2-trifluoroethylamine hydrochloride was established for use in an NMR study. This enzymatic ¹⁹F-labeling readily provided NMR detection of protein-drug and protein-protein interactions with complexes of about 100 kDa since the surface residues provided a good substrate for TGase. The ¹⁹F-labeling method was 3.5-fold more sensitive than ¹⁵N-labeling, and could be combined with other chemical modification techniques such as lysine ¹³C-methylation. ¹³C-dimethylated-¹⁹F-labeled FKBP12 provided more accurate information concerning the FK506 binding site.

Use of19F NMR spectroscopy to screen chemical libraries for ligands that bind to proteins

Identification of compounds from chemical libraries that bind to macromolecules by use of NMR spectroscopy has gained increasing importance during recent years. A simple methodology based on (19)F NMR spectroscopy for the screening of ligands that bind to proteins, which also provides qualitative information about relative binding strengths and the presence of multiple binding sites, is presented here. A library of fluorinated compounds was assembled and investigated for binding to the two bacterial chaperones PapD and FimC, and also to human serum albumin (HSA). It was found that library members which are bound to a target protein could be identified directly from line broadening and/or induced chemical shifts in a single, one-dimensional (19)F NMR spectrum. The results obtained for binding to PapD using (19)F NMR spectroscopy agreed well with independent studies based on surface plasmon resonance, providing support for the versatility and accuracy of the technique. When the library was titrated to a solution of PapD chemical shift and linewidth changes were observed with increasing ligand concentration, which indicated the presence of several binding sites on PapD and enabled the assessment of relative binding strengths for the different ligands. Screening by (19)F NMR spectroscopy should thus be a valuable addition to existing NMR techniques for evaluation of chemical libraries in bioorganic and medicinal chemistry.

Actin and the actomyosin interface: a review

This review deals with the structure of the actin monomer, its assembly into filaments and the loci on F-actin involved in binding myosin. Two distinctly different arrangements of monomers have been suggested for actin filaments. One model proposed by Holmes et al. is well developed. It places the so-called 'large' domain close to the filament axis and the so-called 'small' domain out near the surface of the filament. A second, less-well developed, model proposed by Schutt et al. locates the 'small' domain close to the filament axis and they rotate the monomer so that 'bottom' of the 'large' domain is at the highest radius. We analyze the available evidence for the models of F-actin derived from X-ray diffraction, reconstructions from electron micrographs, fluorescence resonance energy transfer spectroscopy, chemical cross-linking, antibody probes, limited proteolysis, site-directed and natural mutations, nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and other techniques. The result is an actin-centered view of the loci on actin which are probably involved in its interaction with the myosin 'head'. From these multiple contacts we speculate on the sequence of steps between the initial weak-binding state of S-1 to the actin filament through to the stable strong-binding state seen in the absence of free Mg-ATP, i.e., the rigor state.

Mobile segments in rabbit skeletal muscle F-actin detected by 1H nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy

Polymerization of actin by increasing the ionic strength leads to a quenching of almost all 1H NMR signals. Surprisingly, distinct signals with relatively small line widths can still be observed in actin filaments (F-actin) indicating the existence of mobile, NMR visible residues in the macromolecular structure. The intensity of the F-actin spectrum is much reduced if one replaces Mg2+ with Ca2+, and a moderate reduction of the signal intensity can also be obtained by increasing the ionic strength. These results can be explained in a two-state model of the actin promoters with a M- (mobile) state and a I- (immobile) state in equilibrium. In the M-state a number of residues in the actin promoter are mobile and give rise to observable NMR signals. This equilibrium is shifted towards the I-state specifically by replacing Mg2+ with Ca(2+)-ions and unspecifically by addition of monovalent ions such as K+. The binding of phalloidin to its high-affinity site in the filaments does not influence the equilibrium between M- and I-state. Phalloidin itself is completely immobilized in F-actin, its exchange with the solvent being slow on the NMR time scale.

Probing the phalloidin binding site of actin

Phallotoxins form tight complexes with filamentous actin and stabilize the polymer against shearing stress. In the present study a phalloidin derivative containing a thiol-capturing moiety was prepared and reacted with single thiol groups of monomeric muscle actin. Sites of attachment in the protein were Cys-374 next to the C-terminus and Cys-10, close to the N-terminus; the latter was recently shown to be uncovered during a slow but reversible conformational transition occurring in ADP-G-actin. Phalloidin bound to Cys-374 stabilizes filaments against shearing stress almost as effectively as free phalloidin, indicating that the phalloidin binding site cannot be far from the C-terminus of actin. Stabilization was also achieved when the phalloidin reagent was added to F-actin, however, the subsequent formation of a covalent linkage with Cys-374 was not observed, most likely due to a restricted mobility of the reactants. In contrast to the efficient stabilization of filaments by phalloidin linked to Cys-374 a destabilizing effect was observed when phalloidin was attached to Cys-10. It appears that phalloidin located close to the N-terminus is unable to bind to the normal binding site in its own filament. Pronounced gelification of this actin derivative suggests that the toxin is able to mediate crosslinking with neighbouring filaments. From these results we conclude that the phalloidin binding site of actin is distant from the N-terminus, but close to the C-terminus. Furthermore, the data provide evidence that binding of phalloidin reduces the mobility of the C-terminus.

Cooperative effects on filament stability in actin modified at the C-terminus by substitution or truncation

We have studied the contribution of the C-terminus of actin to filament stability by chemical modification and limited proteolysis. Formation of mixed disulfides of the penultimate C-terminal cysteine residue 374 with various low-molecular-mass thiols resulted in filament destabilization, as reflected by an increase in critical concentration and steady-state ATPase activity. These effects were fully reversed by the addition of phalloidin. Both the destabilization by glutathionylation and the reversal of it by phalloidin exhibited a high degree of cooperativity; half-maximal destabilization required the modification of four out of five actin subunits, and half-maximal restabilization by phalloidin was already reached when only one out of 20 actin subunits was complexed. C-terminal truncation by limited trypsinolysis of filamentous actin resulted in a similar destabilization of the polymer, as shown by a 2-3-fold increase in the steady-state ATPase activity. This effect was likewise cooperative and could be reversed by phalloidin. Since truncation of the C-terminus of actin has an effect on stability similar to that of chemical modification with bulky substituents, the possibility can be excluded that, in the latter case, destabilization was caused by steric hindrance. Rather, it seems that the highly conserved C-terminal part of actin plays an active role in establishing a tight contact between neighbouring subunits.

Antibody and peptide probes of interactions between the SH1-SH2 region of myosin subfragment 1 and actin's N-terminus

The negatively charged residues in the N-terminus of actin and the 697-707 region on myosin subfragment 1 (S-1), containing the reactive cysteines SH1 and SH2, are known to be important for actin-activated myosin ATPase activity. The relationship between these two sites was first examined by monitoring the rates of SH1 and SH2 modification with N-ethylmaleimide in the presence of actin and, secondly, by testing for direct binding of SH1 peptides to the N-terminal segment on actin. While actin alone protected SH1 from N-ethylmaleimide modification, this effect was abolished by an antibody against the seven N-terminal amino acids on actin, F(ab)(1-7), and was greatly reduced when the charge of acidic residues at actin's N-terminus was altered by carbodiimide coupling of ethylenediamine. Neither F(ab)(1-7) nor ethylenediamine treatment reversed the effect of F-actin on SH2 reactivity in SH1-modified S-1. These results show a communication between the SH1 region on S-1 and actin's N-terminus in the acto-S-1 complex. To test whether such a communication involves the binding of the SH1 site on S-1 to the N-terminal segment of actin, the SH1 peptide IRICRKG-NH2(4+) was used. Cosedimentation experiments revealed the binding of three to six peptides per actin monomer. Peptide binding to actin was affected slightly, if at all, by F(ab)(1-7). The antibody also did not change the polymerization of G-actin by the peptides. The peptides caused a small reduction in the binding of S-1 to actin and did not change the binding of F(ab)(1-7).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Models of the actin monomer and filament from fluorescence resonance-energy transfer

We have developed algorithms for combining fluorescence resonance-energy transfer (FRET) efficiency measurements into structural models which predict the relative positions of the chemical groups used in FRET. We used these algorithms to construct models of the actin monomer and filament derived solely from FRET measurements based on seven distinct loci. We found a mirror-image pair of monomer models which best fit the FRET data. One of these models agrees well with the atomic-resolution crystal structure recently published by Kabsch et al. in Heidelberg [Kabsch, W., Mannherz, H. G., Suck, D., Pai, E. F. & Holmes, K. C. (1990) Nature 347, 37-44]. The root-mean-square deviation between this FRET model and the crystal structure was about 0.9 nm. Other macromolecular models assembled from FRET measurements are likely to have a similar resolution. The largest discrepancy was for the Cys10 locus which deviated 1.44 nm from the crystal position. We discuss the limitations of the FRET method that may have contributed to this discrepancy, and conclude that the Cys10 FRET data have probably located Cys10 incorrectly in the FRET monomer model. Using the FRET monomer models, we found three orientations in the filament which best fit the intermonomer FRET data. These orientations differ substantially from the atomic-resolution filament model proposed by the Heidelberg group [Holmes, K., Popp, D., Gebhard, W. & Kabsch, W. (1990) Nature 347, 44-49], largely because of the discrepancies in the Cys10 data. These data should probably be excluded from the analysis; however, this would leave too few measurements to assemble a filament model. In the near future, we hope to obtain additional FRET measurements to other actin loci so that the filament modelling can be done without the Cys10 data.

Removing the two C-terminal residues of actin affects the filament structure

We define conditions under which the two C-terminal residues of actin, Cys-374 and Phe-375, can be selectively removed by proteolysis with trypsin. This modification had little effect on the secondary structure of actin detected by Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy. However, removing these residues caused small but significant decreases in the critical concentration of actin, in its ability to activate myosin ATPase, and in its interaction with tropomyosin and troponin. Removing residues 374-375 caused dramatic changes in the actin filament as seen by electron microscopy. The filaments had a much greater and more irregular curvature and were intertwined into disordered multifilament bundles. Removing 374-375 also significantly lowered the flow viscosity of filamentous-actin solutions. These data suggest an increase in the flexibility and fragility of the filament, supporting the idea that the C-terminus forms one of the major intermonomer contacts in the filament.

Specific cross-linking of the SH1 thiol of skeletal myosin subfragment 1 to F-actin and G-actin

Recently, we reported that (maleimidobenzoyl)-G-actin (MBS-G-actin), which was resistant to the salt and myosin subfragment 1 (S-1) induced polymerizations, reacts reversibly and covalently in solution with the S-1 heavy chain at or near the strong F-actin binding region [Bettache, N., Bertrand, R., & Kassab, R. (1989) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 86, 6028-6032]. Here, we have readily converted the MBS-G-actin into MBS-F-actin in the presence of phalloidin and salts. The binding of S-1 to the two actin derivatives carrying on their surface free reactive maleimidobenzoyl groups was investigated comparatively in cross-linking experiments performed under various conditions to probe further the molecular structure of the actin-heavy chain complex before and after the polymerization process. Like MBS-G-actin, the isolated MBS-F-actin, which did not undergo any intersubunit cross-linking, bound stoichiometrically to S-1, generating two kinds of actin-heavy chain covalent complexes migrating on electrophoretic gels at 180 and 140 kDa. The relative extent of their production was essentially dependent on pH for both G-and F-actins. At pH 8.0, the 180-kDa species was predominant, and at pH 7.0, the amount of the 140-kDa adduct increased at the expense of the 180-kDa entity. The cross-linking of MBS-F-actin to S-1 led to the superactivation of the MgATPase substantiating the ability of this derivative to stimulate the S-1 ATPase as the native protein.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Atomic structure of the actin:DNase I complex

The atomic models of the complex between rabbit skeletal muscle actin and bovine pancreatic deoxyribonuclease I both in the ATP and ADP forms have been determined by X-ray analysis at an effective resolution of 2.8 A and 3A, respectively. The two structures are very similar. The actin molecule consists of two domains which can be further subdivided into two subdomains. ADP or ATP is located in the cleft between the domains with a calcium ion bound to the beta- or beta- and gamma-phosphates, respectively. The motif of a five-stranded beta sheet consisting of a beta meander and a right handed beta alpha beta unit appears in each domain suggesting that gene duplication might have occurred. These sheets have the same topology as that found in hexokinase.

Glutathionyl(cysteine-374) actin forms filaments of low mechanical stability

Rabbit muscle actin reacts with 2,4-dinitrophenylglutathionyldisulfide, forming a mixed disulfide in position 374. the product S-(cysteine-374)glutathionyl actin forms filaments which are easily disrupted under shearing stress. Even weak mechanical strain, as exerted, for example, during capillary viscometry or heating the solution to 37 degrees C, leads to considerable breakage of these filaments. Because of spontaneous repair which consumes ATP, the mechanically broken filaments exhibit an approx. 6-fold enhanced steady-state ATPase activity as compared to normal F-actin. Monomers of glutathionyl actin have a reduced affinity for their bound nucleotide and a slightly increased critical concentration. Disruption of the filaments and enhanced ATPase activity are reversed by the addition of KCl or the mushroom toxin phalloidin. By the large stabilizing effects of KCl and phalloidin on glutathionyl actin filaments we propose glutathionyl actin as a tool for detecting filament-stabilizing agents and for studying the different mechanisms of filament stabilization.