Characteristics and mechanism of formation of peroxide-induced heme to protein cross-linking in myoglobin

Heme d formation in a Shewanella benthica hemoglobin

In our continued investigations of microbial globins, we solved the structure of a truncated hemoglobin from Shewanella benthica, an obligate psychropiezophilic bacterium. The distal side of the heme active site is lined mostly with hydrophobic residues, with the exception of a tyrosine, Tyr34 (CD1) and a histidine, His24 (B13). We found that purified SbHbN, when crystallized in the ferric form with polyethylene glycol as precipitant, turned into a green color over weeks. The electron density obtained from the green crystals accommodated a trans heme d, a chlorin-type derivative featuring a γ-spirolactone and a vicinal hydroxyl group on a pyrroline ring. In solution, exposure of the protein to one equivalent of hydrogen peroxide resulted in a similar green color change, but caused by the formation of multiple products. These were oxidation species released on protein denaturation, likely including heme d, and a species with heme covalently attached to the polypeptide. The Tyr34Phe replacement prevented the formation of both heme d and the covalent linkage. The ready modification of heme b by SbHbN expands the range of chemistries supported by the globin fold and offers a route to a novel heme cofactor.

A biomimetic assay for antioxidant reactivity, based on liposomes and myoglobin

Antioxidant assays are typically based on non-physiologically relevant reagents. We describe here a quantitative assay based on the inhibition of the liposome autooxidation in the presence of myoglobin (ILA-Mb), an oxidative process with direct biomedical relevance. Additional advantages of the assay include the use of standard and readily available reagents (lecithin and myoglobin) and the applicability to lipophilic antioxidants. The ILA-Mb assay is based on previously reported qualitative or semi-quantitative ones that employed cytochrome c instead of myoglobin. A number of antioxidants are tested, and their IC50 parameters are discussed and interpreted to involve direct interaction with both myoglobin and the liposomes.

Hell's Gate Globin-I from Methylacidiphilum infernorum Displays a Unique Temperature-Independent pH Sensing Mechanism Utililized a Lipid-Induced Conformational Change

Hell's Gate globin-I (HGb-I) is a thermally stable globin from the aerobic methanotroph Methylacidiphilium infernorum. Here we report that HGb-I interacts with lipids stoichiometrically to induce structural changes in the heme pocket, changing the heme iron distal ligation coordination from hexacoordinate to pentacoordinate. Such changes in heme geometry have only been previously reported for cytochrome c and cytoglobin, linked to apoptosis regulation and enhanced lipid peroxidation activity, respectively. However, unlike cytoglobin and cytochrome c, the heme iron of HGb-I is altered by lipids in ferrous as well as ferric oxidation states. The apparent affinity for lipids in this thermally stable globin is highly pH-dependent but essentially temperature-independent within the range of 20-60 °C. We propose a mechanism to explain these observations, in which lipid binding and stability of the distal endogenous ligand are juxtaposed as a function of temperature. Additionally, we propose that these coupled equilibria may constitute a mechanism through which this acidophilic thermophile senses the pH of its environment.

Histidine-Bound Dinitrosyl Iron Complexes: Antioxidant and Antiradical Properties

Dinitrosyl iron complexes (DNICs) are important physiological derivatives of nitric oxide. These complexes have a wide range of biological activities, with antioxidant and antiradical ones being of particular interest and importance. We studied the interaction between DNICs associated with the dipeptide L-carnosine or serum albumin and prooxidants under conditions mimicking oxidative stress. The ligands of these DNICs were histidine residues of carnosine or His39 and Cys34 in bovine serum albumin. Carnosine-bound DNICs reduced the level of piperazine free radicals in the reaction system containing tert-butyl hydroperoxide (t-BOOH), bivalent iron ions, a nitroxyl anion donor (Angeli's salt), and HEPES buffer. The ability of carnosine DNICs to intercept organic free radicals produced from t-BOOH decay could lead to this effect. In addition, carnosine DNICs reacted with the superoxide anion radical (O2•-) formed in the xanthine/xanthine oxidase enzymatic system. They also reduced the oxoferryl form of the heme group formed in the reaction of myoglobin with t-BOOH. DNICs associated with serum albumin were found to be rapidly destroyed in a model system containing metmyoglobin and t-BOOH. At the same time, these protein DNICs inhibited the t-BOOH-induced oxidative degradation of coenzymes Q9 and Q10 in rat myocardial homogenate. The possible mechanisms of the antioxidant and antiradical action of the DNICs studied and their role in the metabolism of reactive oxygen and nitrogen species are discussed.

Effects of Mustard Seed Extract on Physicochemical and Storage Characteristics of Dry-aged Pork Loin Ham

This study investigated the effects of mustard seed extracts on physicochemical and storage characteristics of dry-aged pork loin ham during the aging period. In experiment 1, antioxidant activity was assessed for mustard seed extracted with varying ethanol concentrations and the results showed high antioxidant activity at 25%, 50%, and 75% ethanol concentrations. In experiment 2, pork loin was treated with mustard seed extracts obtained using different ethanol concentrations: not treated (control), 25% (MS25), 50% (MS50), and 75% (MS75). Physicochemical and storage characteristics of pork loin ham were measured in wk 0, 2, 4, and 6. The pH, aw, CIE b*, thiobarbituric acid reactive substances and volatile basic nitrogen values were lower in treated samples compared to the control (p<0.05). In conclusion, applying mustard seed extracts, particularly MS75, in the dry-aged pork loin ham production process could enhance storage stability and improve color attributes without having negative impacts on product quality.

Hidden Complexity in the Mechanism of the Autoreduction of Myoglobin Compound II

The non-native oxidation of horse heart myoglobin with hydrogen peroxide produces compound II which autoreduces by utilizing an internal oxidation site. Here, we utilize full UV-visible time-dependent kinetics with global kinetic singular value decomposition analysis to explore the mechanism and uncover more detail about the high-valent heme spectral features. By varying the hydrogen peroxide and myoglobin concentration, we were able to uncover more detailed spectra of myoglobin compound II and the autoreduction rate under several different pH conditions. The compound II spectra demonstrate pH-dependent features with an inflection point around pH 5.7 ± 0.1. The rate of autoreduction of compound II, k 2, increases with lower pH with a half-power proton dependence and no indication of a pK a > 3.9 ± 0.2, indicating that the autoreduction is still dependent on the protonation of the ferryl oxo species. The k 2 also demonstrates both hydrogen peroxide and myoglobin dependency. At myoglobin concentrations greater than 6.6 μM, the k 2 is myoglobin-independent, but for lower concentrations, a pH-sensitive concentration dependence is seen.

The peroxidatic activities of Myoglobin and Hemoglobin, their pathological consequences and possible medical interventions

Under those pathological conditions in which Myoglobin and Hemoglobin escape their cellular environments and are thus separated from cellular reductive/protective systems, the inherent peroxidase activities of these proteins can be expressed. This activity leads to the formation of the highly oxidizing oxo-ferryl species. Evidence that this happens in vivo is provided by the formation of a covalent bond between the heme group and the protein and this acts as an unambiguous biomarker for the presence of the oxo ferryl form. The peroxidatic activity also leads to the oxidation of lipids, the products of which can be powerful vasoconstrictive agents (e.g. isoprostanes, neuroprostanes). Here we review the evidence that lipid oxidation occurs following rhabdomyolysis and sub-arachnoid hemorrhage and that the products formed from arachidonic acid chains of phospholipids lead, through vasoconstriction, to kidney failure and brain vasospasm. Intervention in these pathological conditions through administration of reducing agents to remove ferryl heme is discussed. Through-protein electron transfer pathways that facilitate ferryl reduction at low reductant concentration have been identified. We conclude with consideration of the therapeutic use of Hemoglobin Based Oxygen carriers and how the toxicity of these may be reduced by engineering such electron transfer pathways into hemoglobin.

A comprehensive insight into the effects of microbial spoilage, myoglobin autoxidation, lipid oxidation, and protein oxidation on the discoloration of rabbit meat during retail display

The effects of the retail display temperature (8 °C, 3 °C and - 1 °C) on the discoloration of the Longissimus thoracis et lumborum of rabbits and the associations among such effects with microbial spoilage, myoglobin autoxidation, lipid oxidation, and protein oxidation were investigated. The total aerobic count, total volatile basic nitrogen content, metmyoglobin content, protein carbonyl content, and contents of thiobarbituric acid-reactive substances steadily increased during retail display. Moreover, the lightness and redness of the rabbit meat significantly (P < 0.05) declined over time, whereas the yellowness increased considerably (P < 0.05) with prolonged retail time. Canonical correlation analysis suggested that microbial spoilage, myoglobin autoxidation, lipid oxidation, and protein oxidation jointly affected rabbit meat color. Linear mixed models further revealed that microbial spoilage, myoglobin autoxidation, lipid oxidation and protein oxidation positively affected yellowness, and they inversely impacted lightness and redness.

Reversible Oxidative Modifications in Myoglobin and Functional Implications

Myoglobin (Mb), an oxygen-binding heme protein highly expressed in heart and skeletal muscle, has been shown to undergo oxidative modifications on both an inter- and intramolecular level when exposed to hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) in vitro. Here, we show that exposure to H₂O₂ increases the peroxidase activity of Mb. Reaction of Mb with H₂O₂ causes covalent binding of heme to the Mb protein (Mb-X), corresponding to an increase in peroxidase activity when ascorbic acid is the reducing co-substrate. Treatment of H₂O₂-reacted Mb with ascorbic acid reverses the Mb-X crosslink. Reaction with H₂O₂ causes Mb to form dimers, trimers, and larger molecular weight Mb aggregates, and treatment with ascorbic acid regenerates Mb monomers. Reaction of Mb with H₂O₂ causes formation of dityrosine crosslinks, though the labile nature of the crosslinks broken by treatment with ascorbic acid suggests that the reversible aggregation of Mb is mediated by crosslinks other than dityrosine. Disappearance of a peptide containing a tryptophan residue when Mb is treated with H₂O₂ and the peptide’s reappearance after subsequent treatment with ascorbic acid suggest that tryptophan side chains might participate in the labile crosslinking. Taken together, these data suggest that while exposure to H₂O₂ causes Mb-X formation, increases Mb peroxidase activity, and causes Mb aggregation, these oxidative modifications are reversible by treatment with ascorbic acid. A caveat is that future studies should demonstrate that these and other in vitro findings regarding properties of Mb have relevance in the intracellular milieu, especially in regard to actual concentrations of metMb, H₂O₂, and ascorbate that would be found in vivo.

Peroxidase Activity of Human Hemoproteins: Keeping the Fire under Control

The heme in the active center of peroxidases reacts with hydrogen peroxide to form highly reactive intermediates, which then oxidize simple substances called peroxidase substrates. Human peroxidases can be divided into two groups: (1) True peroxidases are enzymes whose main function is to generate free radicals in the peroxidase cycle and (pseudo)hypohalous acids in the halogenation cycle. The major true peroxidases are myeloperoxidase, eosinophil peroxidase and lactoperoxidase. (2) Pseudo-peroxidases perform various important functions in the body, but under the influence of external conditions they can display peroxidase-like activity. As oxidative intermediates, these peroxidases produce not only active heme compounds, but also protein-based tyrosyl radicals. Hemoglobin, myoglobin, cytochrome c/cardiolipin complexes and cytoglobin are considered as pseudo-peroxidases. Рeroxidases play an important role in innate immunity and in a number of physiologically important processes like apoptosis and cell signaling. Unfavorable excessive peroxidase activity is implicated in oxidative damage of cells and tissues, thereby initiating the variety of human diseases. Hence, regulation of peroxidase activity is of considerable importance. Since peroxidases differ in structure, properties and location, the mechanisms controlling peroxidase activity and the biological effects of peroxidase products are specific for each hemoprotein. This review summarizes the knowledge about the properties, activities, regulations and biological effects of true and pseudo-peroxidases in order to better understand the mechanisms underlying beneficial and adverse effects of this class of enzymes.

Redox and Peroxidase Activities of the Hemoglobin Superfamily: Relevance to Health and Disease

SIGNIFICANCE

Erythrocyte hemoglobin (Hb) and myocyte myoglobin, although primarily oxygen-carrying proteins, have the capacity to do redox chemistry. Such redox activity in the wider family of globins now appears to have important associations with the mechanisms of cell stress response. In turn, an understanding of such mechanisms in vivo may have a potential in the understanding of cancer therapy resistance and neurodegenerative disorders such as Alzheimer's. Recent Advances: There has been an enhanced understanding of the redox chemistry of the globin superfamily in recent years, leading to advances in development of Hb-based blood substitutes and in hypotheses relating to specific disease mechanisms. Neuroglobin (Ngb) and cytoglobin (Cygb) have been linked to cell protection mechanisms against hypoxia and oxidative stress, with implications in the onset and progression of neurodegenerative diseases for Ngb and cancer for Cygb.

CRITICAL ISSUES

Despite advances in the understanding of redox chemistry of globins, the physiological roles of many of these proteins still remain ambiguous at best. Confusion over potential physiological roles may relate to multifunctional roles for globins, which may be modulated by surface-exposed cysteine pairs in some globins. Such roles may be critical in deciphering the relationships of these globins in human diseases.

FUTURE DIRECTIONS

Further studies are required to connect the considerable knowledge on the mechanisms of globin redox chemistry in vitro with the physiological and pathological roles of globins in vivo. In doing so, new therapies for neurodegenerative disorders and cancer therapy resistance may be targeted. Antioxid. Redox Signal. 26, 763-776.

Interaction of glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase and heme: The relevance of its biological function

GAPDH was speculated to function as a transient trap to reduce the potential toxicity of free heme by a specific and reversible binding with heme. Up to now, there has been lack of studies focused on this effect. In this paper, the efficiency of GAPDH-heme complex on catalyzing protein carbonylation and nitration, the cross-linking of heme to protein formation, and cytotoxicity of GAPDH-heme were studied. It was found that the binding of GAPDH could inhibit H₂O₂-mediated degradation of heme. Peroxidase activity of GAPDH-heme complex was higher than that of free heme, but significantly lower than that of HSA-heme. Catalytic activity of heme corresponded complex toward tyrosine oxidation/nitration was decreased in the order of HSA-heme, heme and GAPDH-heme. GAPDH also inhibited heme-H₂O₂-NO₂^- induced protein carbonylation. No covalent bond was formed between heme and GAPDH after treated with H₂O₂. GAPDH was more effective than HSA on protecting cells against heme-NO₂^--H₂O₂ induced cytotoxicity. These results indicate that binding of GAPDH inhibits the activity of heme in catalyzing tyrosine nitration and protects the coexistent protein against oxidative damage, and the mechanism is different from that of HSA. This study may help clarifying the protective role of GAPDH acting as a chaperone in heme transfer to downstream areas.

Modulatory effect of Mangifera indica against carbon tetrachloride induced kidney damage in rats

There is little scientific evidence on the local use of Mangifera indica in kidney diseases. This study investigated the reno-modulatory roles of the aqueous stem bark extract of Mangifera indica (MIASE) against CCl4-induced renal damage. Rats were treated intragastrically with 125, 250 and 500 mg/kg/day MIASE for 7 days before and after the administration of CCl4 (3 ml/kg of 30% CCl4, i.p.). Serum levels of electrolytes (Na+, K+, Cl(-), HCO3(-)), urea and creatinine were determined. Renal tissue reduced glutathione (GSH), malondialdehyde (MDA), catalase (CAT), superoxide (SOD) activities were also assessed. The histopathological changes in kidneys were determined using standard methods. In CCl4 treated rats the results showed significant (p<0.05) increases in serum Na+, K+, Cl(-), urea and creatinine. CCl4 also caused significant (p<0.05) decreases in renal tissue SOD, CAT and GSH and significant (p<0.05) increases in MDA. The oral MIASE treatment (125-500 mg/kg) was found to significantly (p<0.05) attenuate the increase in serum electrolytes, urea and creatinine. Similarly, MIASE significantly (p<0.05) attenuated the decrease in SOD, CAT and GSH levels and correspondingly attenuated increases in MDA. Mangifera indica may present a great prospect for drug development in the management of kidney disease with lipid peroxidation as its etiology.

Cytoglobin ligand binding regulated by changing haem-co-ordination in response to intramolecular disulfide bond formation and lipid interaction

Cytoglobin (Cygb) is a hexa-co-ordinate haem protein from the globin superfamily with a physiological function that is unclear. We have previously reported that the haem co-ordination is changed in the presence of lipids, potentially transforming the redox properties of the protein and hence the function of Cygb in vivo. Recent research suggests that the protein can exist in a number of states depending on the integrity and position of disulfide bonds. In the present study, we show that the monomeric protein with an internal disulfide bond between the two cysteine residues Cys38 and Cys83, interacts with lipids to induce a change in haem co-ordination. The dimeric protein with intermolecular disulfide bonds and monomeric protein without an intramolecular disulfide bond does not exhibit these changes in haem co-ordination. Furthermore, monomeric Cygb with an intramolecular disulfide bond has significantly different properties, oxidizing lipid membranes and binding ligands more rapidly as compared with the other forms of the protein. The redox state of these cysteine residues in vivo is therefore highly significant and may be a mechanism to modulate the biochemical properties of the haem under conditions of stress.

Effect of the distal histidine on the peroxidatic activity of monomeric cytoglobin

The reaction of hydrogen peroxide with ferric human cytoglobin and a number of distal histidine variants were studied. The peroxidase activity of the monomeric wildtype protein with an internal disulfide bond, likely to be the form of the protein in vivo, exhibits a high peroxidase-like activity above that of other globins such as myoglobin. Furthermore, the peroxidatic activity of wildtype cytoglobin shows increased resistance to radical-based degradation compared to myoglobin. The ferryl form of wildtype cytoglobin is unstable, but is able to readily oxidize substrates such as guaiacol. In contrast distal histidine mutants of cytoglobin (H81Y and H81V) show very low peroxidase activity but enhanced radical-induced degradation. Therefore, the weakly bound distal histidine appears to modulate ferryl stability and limit haem degradation. These data are consistent with a role of a peroxidase activity of cytoglobin in cell stress response mechanisms.

Nitrite binding to globins: linkage isomerism, EPR silence and reductive chemistry

•

A DFT-derived barrier for nitrite linkage isomerism on heme center is reported.

•

EPR spectra of nitrite adducts show evidence for linkage isomerism.

•

The electronic structure of Fe(III)-nitrite heme is conformation-dependent.

•

Certain conformations are inducive to EPR silence.

•

Fe(II)-nitrite is undetectable on stopped-flow time scales.

The nitrite adducts of globins can potentially bind via O- or N- linkage to the heme iron. We have used EPR (electron paramagnetic resonance) and DFT (density functional theory) to explore these binding modes to myoglobin and hemoglobin. We demonstrate that the nitrite adducts of both globins have detectable EPR signals; we provide an explanation for the difficulty in detecting these EPR features, based on uniaxial state considerations. The EPR and DFT data show that both nitrite linkage isomers can be present at the same time and that the two isomers are readily interconvertible in solution. The millisecond-scale process of nitrite reduction by Hb is investigated in search of the elusive Fe(II)-nitrite adduct.

Myoglobin and haemoglobin-mediated lipid oxidation in washed muscle: observations on crosslinking, ferryl formation, porphyrin degradation, and haemin loss rate

Reduced trout haemoglobin (Hb) is a mixture of oxy- and deoxy-Hb at pH 6.3. Addition of oxy/deoxyHb to washed muscle resulted in detectable ferryl Hb while adding bovine oxyHb, trout metHb, or bovine metHb did not. Trout metHb promoted lipid oxidation more rapidly than bovine metHb, attributable to lower haemin affinity in fish Hbs. Protoporphyrin IX degradation was prevalent during trout and bovine Hb-mediated lipid oxidation. Caffeic acid prevented porphyrin degradation and lipid oxidation. Crosslinked myoglobin (Mb) promoted lipid oxidation more effectively than metMb. Fish metMb released haemin more readily than mammalian metMb at pH 5.5. These studies suggest haemin dissociation from metHb causes formation of free radicals that degrade protoporphyrin and cause lipid oxidation, and appreciable quantities of deoxyHb are needed to generate ferryl Hb oxidant. Crosslinking appears to facilitate Mb-mediated lipid oxidation in washed muscle yet haemin release can occur from fish metMb at low pH.

Tyrosine can protect against oxidative stress through ferryl hemoglobin reduction

The toxic mechanism of hemoglobin (Hb) under oxidative stress is linked to the formations of highly cytotoxic ferryl species and subsequently heme-to-protein cross-linked derivative of Hb (Hb-X). In this study, we have examined the effects of free tyrosine and its analogues (3-chlorotyrosine, phenylalanine) on the stability of ferryl hemoglobin and the formation of Hb-X. The results showed that free tyrosine (not phenylalanine, 10-500 μM) was an efficient reducing agent of ferryl species and also effective at preventing the formation of cytotoxic Hb-X. Meanwhile, the dimeric tyrosine was formed as the oxidation product of tyrosine during Hb redox reaction. Compared with free tyrosine, 3-chlorotyrosine, an oxidation product of tyrosine and a proposed biomarker for hypochlorous acid (HOCl) in vivo, exhibited stronger antioxidant properties in Hb-induced oxidative stress, which was consistent with its more efficient ability in the reduction of ferryl species. These results showed that the presence of tyrosine and its derivative in vivo and vitro could ameliorate oxidative damage through ferryl heme reduction. The antioxidant ability, therefore, may provide new insights into the nutritional and physiological significance of free tyrosine with redox active heme proteins-related oxidative stress.

Tyrosine residues play an important role in heme detoxification by serum albumin

BACKGROUND

Serum albumin binds avidly to heme to form heme-serum albumin complex, also called methemalbumin, and this binding is thought to protect against the potentially toxic effects of heme. However, the mechanism of detoxification has not been fully elucidated.

METHODS

SDS-PAGE and Western blot were used to determine the efficiency of methemalbumin on catalyzing protein carbonylation and nitration. HPLC was used to test the formation of heme to protein cross-linked methemalbumin.

RESULTS

The peroxidase activity of heme increased upon human serum albumin (HSA) binding. Methemalbumin showed higher efficiency in catalyzing tyrosine oxidation than free heme in the presence of H2O2. Methemalbumin catalyzed self-nitration and significantly promoted the nitration of tyrosine in coexistent protein, but decreased the carbonylation of coexistent protein compared with heme. The heme to protein cross-linked form of methemalbumin suggested that HSA trapped the free radical accompanied by the formation of ferryl heme. When tyrosine residues in HSA were modified by iodination, HSA lost of protection effect on protein carbonylation. The low concentration of glutathione could effectively inhibit tyrosine nitration, but had no effect on protein carbonylation.

CONCLUSION

HSA protects against the toxic effect of heme by transferring the free radical to tyrosine residues in HSA, therefore protecting surrounding proteins from irreversible oxidation, rather than by direct inhibiting the peroxidase activity. The increased tyrosine radicals can be reduced by endogenic antioxidants such as GSH.

GENERAL SIGNIFICANCE

This investigation indicated the important role of tyrosine residues in heme detoxification by HSA and suggested a possible novel mechanism.

Differential thermal stability and oxidative vulnerability of the hemoglobin variants, HbA2 and HbE

Apart from few early biophysical studies, the relative thermal instability of HbE has been only shown by clinical investigations. We have compared in vitro thermal stability of HbE with HbA2 and HbA using optical spectroscopy. From absorption measurements in the soret region, synchronous fluorescence spectroscopy and dynamic light scattering experiments, we have found thermal stability of the three hemoglobin variants following the order HbE<HbA<HbA2 in terms of structural unfolding and aggregation pattern. We have found formation of intermolecular dityrosine fluorophores with characteristic fluorescence signature, at pH >11.0 in all the three variants. Under oxidative stress conditions in presence of hydrogen peroxide, HbE has been found to be more vulnerable to aggregation compared to HbA and HbA2. Taken together, these studies have shown thermal and oxidative instability of HbE and points towards the role of HbE in the upregulation of redox regulators and chaperone proteins in erythrocyte proteome of patients suffering from HbEbeta thalassemia.

Redox reactions of myoglobin

SIGNIFICANCE

Failure to maintain myoglobin (Mb) in the reduced state causes the formation of metMb, ferryl Mb species, and cross-linked Mb. Dissociation of ferriprotoporphyrin IX from the globin and release of iron atoms can also occur as oxidized Mb accumulates. These modifications may contribute to various oxidative pathologies in muscle and muscle foods.

RECENT ADVANCES

The mechanism of ferryl Mb-mediated oxidative damage to nearby structures has been partially elucidated. Dissociation of ferriprotoporphyrin IX from metMb occurs more readily at acidic pH values. The dissociated ferriprotoporphyrin IX (also called hemin) readily decomposes preformed lipid hydroperoxides to reactive oxygen species. Heme oxygenase as well as lipophilic free radicals can degrade the protoporphyrin IX moiety, which results in the formation of free iron.

CRITICAL ISSUES

The multiple pathways by which Mb can incur toxicity create difficulties in determining the major cause of oxidative damage in a particular system. Peroxides and low pH activate each of the oxidative Mb forms, ferriprotoporphyrin IX, and released iron. Determining the relative concentration of these species is technically difficult, but essential to a complete understanding of oxidative pathology in muscle tissue.

FUTURE DIRECTIONS

Improved methods to assess the different pathways of Mb toxicity are needed. Although significant advances have been made in the understanding of Mb interactions with other biomolecules, further investigation is needed to understand the physical and chemical nature of these interactions.

Application of Electrode Methods in Studies of Nitric Oxide Metabolism and Diffusion Kinetics

Nitric oxide (NO) has many important physiological roles in the body. Since NO electrodes can directly measure NO concentration in the nM range and in real time, NO electrode methods have been generally used in laboratories for measuring NO concentration in vivo and in vitro. This review focuses on the application of electrode methods in studies of NO diffusion and metabolic kinetics. We have described the physical and chemical properties that need to be considered in the preparation of NO stock solution, discussed the effect of several interfering factors on the measured curves of NO concentration that need to be eliminated in the experimental setup for NO measurements, and provided an overview of the application of NO electrode methods in measuring NO diffusion and metabolic kinetics in solution and in biological systems. This overview covers NO metabolism by oxygen (O₂), superoxide, heme proteins, cells and tissues. Important conclusions and physiological implication of these studies are discussed.

Familial secondary erythrocytosis due to increased oxygen affinity is caused by destabilization of the T state of hemoglobin Brigham (α₂β₂(Pro100Leu))

Hemoglobin Brigham (β Pro100 to Leu) was first reported in a patient with familial erythrocytosis. Erythrocytes of an affected individual from the same family contain both HbA and Hb Brigham and exhibit elevated O₂ affinity compared with normal cells (P₅₀ = 23 mm Hg vs. 31 mmHg at pH 7.4 at 37°C). O₂ affinities measured for hemolysates were sensitive to changes in pH or chloride concentrations, indicating little change in the Bohr and Chloride effects. Hb Brigham was separated from normal HbA by nondenaturing cation exchange liquid chromatography, and the amino acid substitution was verified by mass spectrometry. The properties of Hb Brigham isolated from the patient's blood were then compared with those of recombinant Hb Brigham expressed in Escherichia coli. Kinetic experiments suggest that the rate constants for ligand binding and release in the high (R) and low (T) affinity quaternary states of Hb Brigham are similar to those of native hemoglobin. However, the Brigham mutation decreases the T to R equilibrium constant (L) which accelerates the switch to the R state during ligand binding to deoxy-Hb, increasing the rate of association by approximately twofold, and decelerates the switch during ligand dissociation from HbO₂, decreasing the rate approximately twofold. These kinetic data help explain the high O₂ affinity characteristics of Hb Brigham and provide further evidence for the importance of the contribution of Pro100 to intersubunit contacts and stabilization of the T quaternary structure.

Towards hemerythrin-based blood substitutes: comparative performance to hemoglobin on human leukocytes and umbilical vein endothelial cells

Hemerythrin is a dioxygen-carrying protein whose oxidative/nitrosative stress-related reactivity is lower than that of hemoglobin, which may warrant investigation of hemerythrin as raw material for artificial oxygen carriers ('blood substitutes'). We report here the first biological tests for hemerythrin and its chemical derivatives, comparing their performance with that of a representative competitor, glutaraldehyde-polymerized bovine hemoglobin. Hemerythrin (native or derivatized) exhibits a proliferative effect on human umbilical vein endothelial cell (HUVEC) cultures, as opposed to a slight inhibitory effect of hemoglobin. A similar positive effect is displayed on human lymphocytes by glutaraldehyde-polymerized hemerythrin, but not by native or polyethylene glycol-derivatized hemerythrin.

Mechanism-based therapeutic approaches to rhabdomyolysis-induced renal failure

Rhabdomyolysis-induced renal failure represents up to 15% of all cases of acute renal failure. Many studies over the past 4 decades have demonstrated that accumulation of myoglobin in the kidney is central in the mechanism leading to kidney injury. However, some discussion exists regarding the mechanism mediating this oxidant injury. Although the free-iron-catalyzed Fenton reaction has been proposed to explain the tissue injury, more recent evidence strongly suggests that the main cause of oxidant injury is myoglobin redox cycling and generation of oxidized lipids. These molecules can propagate tissue injury and cause renal vasoconstriction, two of the three main conditions associated with acute renal failure. This review presents the evidence supporting the two mechanisms of oxidative injury, describes the central role of myoglobin redox cycling in the pathology of renal failure associated with rhabdomyolysis, and discusses the value of therapeutic interventions aiming at inhibiting myoglobin redox cycling for the treatment of rhabdomyolysis-induced renal failure.

The synthetic polyphenol tert-butyl-bisphenol inhibits myoglobin-induced dysfunction in cultured kidney epithelial cells

Abstract Rhabdomyolysis caused by severe burn releases extracellular myoglobin (Mb) that accumulates in the kidney and urine (maximum [Mb] approximately 50 microM) (termed myoglobinuria). Extracellular Mb can be a pro-oxidant. This study cultured Madin-Darby-canine-kidney-Type-II (MDCK II) cells in the presence of Mb and tested whether supplementation with a synthetic tert-butyl-polyphenol (tert-butyl-bisphenol; t-BP) protects these renal cells from dysfunction. In the absence of t-BP, cells exposed to 0-100 microM Mb for 24 h showed a dose-dependent decrease in ATP and the total thiol (TSH) redox status without loss of viability. Gene expression of superoxide dismutases-1/2, haemoxygenase-1 and tumour necrosis factor increased and receptor-mediated endocytosis of transferrin and monolayer permeability decreased significantly. Supplementation with t-BP before Mb-insult maintained ATP and the TSH redox status, diminished antioxidant/pro-inflammatory gene responses, enhanced monolayer permissiveness and restored transferrin uptake. Overall, bolstering the total antioxidant capacity of the kidney may protect against oxidative stress induced by experimental myoglobinuria.

The redox activity of hemoglobins: from physiologic functions to pathologic mechanisms

Pentacoordinate respiratory hemoproteins such as hemoglobin and myoglobin have evolved to supply cells with oxygen. However, these respiratory heme proteins are also known to function as redox enzymes, reacting with compounds such as nitric oxide and peroxides. The recent discoveries of hexacoordinate hemoglobins in vertebrates and nonsymbiotic plants suggest that the redox activity of globins is inherent to the molecule. The uncontrolled formation of radical species resulting from such redox chemistry on respiratory hemoproteins can lead to oxidative damage and cellular toxicity. In this review, we examine the functions of various globins and the mechanisms by which these globins act as redox enzymes under physiologic conditions. Evidence that redox reactions also occur under disease conditions, leading to pathologic complications, also is examined, focusing on recent discoveries showing that the ferryl oxidation state of these hemoproteins is present in these disease states in vivo. In addition, we review the latest advances in the understanding of globin redox mechanisms and how they might affect cellular signaling pathways and how they might be controlled therapeutically or, in the case of hemoglobin-based blood substitutes, through rational design.

Unmasking the Janus face of myoglobin in health and disease

For more than 100 years, myoglobin has been among the most extensively studied proteins. Since the first comprehensive review on myoglobin function as a dioxygen store by Millikan in 1939 and the discovery of its structure 50 years ago, multiple studies have extended our understanding of its occurrence, properties and functions. Beyond the two major roles, the storage and the facilitation of dioxygen diffusion, recent physiological studies have revealed that myoglobin acts as a potent scavenger of nitric oxide (NO•) representing a control system that preserves mitochondrial respiration. In addition, myoglobin may also protect the heart against reactive oxygen species (ROS), and, under hypoxic conditions, deoxygenated myoglobin is able to reduce nitrite to NO• leading to a downregulation of the cardiac energy status and to a decreased heart injury after reoxygenation. Thus, by controlling the NO• bioavailability via scavenging or formation, myoglobin serves as part of a sensitive dioxygen sensory system. In this review, the physiological relevance of these recent findings are delineated for pathological states where NO• and ROS bioavailability are known to be critical determinants for the outcome of the disease, e.g. ischemia/reperfusion injury. Detrimental and beneficial effects of the presence of myoglobin are discussed for various states of tissue oxygen tension within the heart and skeletal muscle. Furthermore, the impact of myoglobin on parasite infection, rhabdomyolysis, hindlimb and liver ischemia, angiogenesis and tumor growth are considered.

Redox reactivity in propolis: direct detection of free radicals in basic medium and interaction with hemoglobin

Propolis is one of many natural products with known antioxidant properties. The present work aims to investigate the intimate molecular-level mechanisms of this antioxidant reactivity. Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR)-detectable free radical signals are described here for the first time in propolis extracts. The shape of these signals and the conditions in which they were obtained, point to polyphenolic flavonoids as the sites of the radicals. An inverse correlation between antioxidant capacity and free radical signal intensity is shown. The free radical reactivity of propolis is also illustrated by the effect it exerts on the biologically-relevant peroxide reactivity of hemoglobin. A new test of antioxidant ability in natural extracts such as propolis is proposed, based on modulation of the ascorbate peroxidase activity of hemoglobin (HAPX). Results of this test correlate well with those obtained via traditional methods such as those based on DPPH (2,2-diphenyl-1-picrylhydrazyl), or on ABTS (2,2'-azinobis(3-ethylbenzothiazoline-6-sulfonic acid).

Acetaminophen inhibits hemoprotein-catalyzed lipid peroxidation and attenuates rhabdomyolysis-induced renal failure

Hemoproteins, hemoglobin and myoglobin, once released from cells can cause severe oxidative damage as a consequence of heme redox cycling between ferric and ferryl states that generates radical species that induce lipid peroxidation. We demonstrate in vitro that acetaminophen inhibits hemoprotein-induced lipid peroxidation by reducing ferryl heme to its ferric state and quenching globin radicals. Severe muscle injury (rhabdomyolysis) is accompanied by the release of myoglobin that becomes deposited in the kidney, causing renal injury. We previously showed in a rat model of rhabdomyolysis that redox cycling between ferric and ferryl myoglobin yields radical species that cause severe oxidative damage to the kidney. In this model, acetaminophen at therapeutic plasma concentrations significantly decreased oxidant injury in the kidney, improved renal function, and reduced renal damage. These findings also provide a hypothesis for potential therapeutic applications for acetaminophen in diseases involving hemoprotein-mediated oxidative injury.

Peroxidase activity of hemoglobin-haptoglobin complexes: covalent aggregation and oxidative stress in plasma and macrophages

As a hemoprotein, hemoglobin (Hb) can, in the presence of H(2)O(2), act as a peroxidase. In red blood cells, this activity is regulated by the reducing environment. For stroma-free Hb this regulation is lost, and the potential for Hb to become a peroxidase is high and further increased by inflammatory cells generating superoxide. The latter can be converted into H(2)O(2) and feed Hb peroxidase activity. Haptoglobins (Hp) bind with extracellular Hb and reportedly weaken Hb peroxidase activity. Here we demonstrate that: (i) Hb peroxidase activity is retained upon binding with Hp; (ii) in the presence of H(2)O(2), Hb-Hp peroxidase complexes undergo covalent cross-linking; (iii) peroxidase activity of Hb-Hp complexes and aggregates consumes reductants such as ascorbate and nitric oxide; (iv) cross-linked Hb-Hp aggregates are taken up by macrophages at rates exceeding those for noncovalently cross-linked Hb-Hp complexes; (v) the engulfed Hb-Hp aggregates activate superoxide production and induce intracellular oxidative stress (deplete endogenous glutathione and stimulate lipid peroxidation); (vi) Hb-Hp aggregates cause cytotoxicity to macrophages; and (vii) Hb-Hp aggregates are present in septic plasma. Overall, our data suggest that under conditions of severe inflammation and oxidative stress, peroxidase activity of Hb-Hp covalent aggregates may cause macrophage dysfunction and microvascular vasoconstriction, which are commonly seen in severe sepsis and hemolytic diseases.

A highlight of myoglobin diversity: the nitrite reductase activity during myocardial ischemia-reperfusion

Myoglobin, famous as an important intracellular oxygen binding hemeprotein, displays a variety of functions. The first pioneering review on myoglobin was published as early as 1939, in which Millikan concluded that "muscle hemoglobin" acts primarily as a short-term dioxygen store, tiding the muscle over from one contraction to the next. Since that time, myoglobin has become one of the most widely studied proteins in a variety of research fields ranging from chemistry to medicine. Recently it was discovered that in the heart myoglobin changes its function in dependence of oxygen tension, acting as an oxygen sensor. Under normoxic conditions myoglobin plays the role of a nitric oxide (NO(*)) scavenger, protecting the heart from the deleterious effects of excessive NO(*). During hypoxia however, myoglobin changes its role from an NO(*) scavenger to an NO(*) producer. Deoxygenated myoglobin reduces nitrite to bioactive NO(*). The produced NO(*) downregulates the cardiac energy status and reduces myocardial oxygen consumption, thus protecting the heart. Myoglobin also exhibits a nitrite reductase function under further pathophysiological conditions. During myocardial reperfusion after ischemia, myoglobin - via nitrite - regulates respiration and cellular viability. This leads to a dramatic reduction of myocardial infarct size and to an improvement of myocardial function. The reaction between myoglobin and nitrite thus seems to play an imminent role in the regulation of cardiac function in physiology and pathophysiology.

Spin scavenging analysis of myoglobin protein-centered radicals using stable nitroxide radicals: characterization of oxoammonium cation-induced modifications

Spin scavenging combined with chromatographic and mass spectrometric procedures can, in principle, be employed to detect and identify protein-based radicals within complex biological matrices. This approach is based on the well-known ability of stable synthetic nitroxide radicals to scavenge carbon-centered radicals, forming stable diamagnetic addition products. Hence, characterization of these addition products would allow for the identification of specific free radicals. In the present work, we have explored the use of the stable nitroxide radical 4-hydroxy-2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine 1-oxyl (TEMPOL) in scavenging protein-based radicals generated in a horse heart metmyoglobin/hydrogen peroxide (metMb/H(2)O(2)) system. Inclusion of a substoichiometric amount of TEMPOL in the metMb/H(2)O(2) system resulted in a complete loss of peroxyl and tyrosyl radical signals and effectively inhibited the formation of oxidatively damaged heme species, as monitored by electron paramagnetic resonance and reversed-phase liquid chromatography. Scavenging of globin radicals by TEMPOL did not lead to the formation of stable diamagnetic addition adducts; in fact, reversed-phase liquid chromatographic studies and oxygen electrode measurements indicated that TEMPOL acts as a catalyst and is recycled in this system. The oxoammonium cation generated in the course of this reaction initiated secondary reactions resulting in the formation of a free carbonyl on the N-terminal Gly-residue of the protein. This oxidative deamination was confirmed through the combined use of reversed-phase liquid chromatographic purification, tandem MS experiments, and chemical analysis (e.g., by use of 2,4-dinitrophenyl hydrazine). The results reveal the pitfalls inherent in using stable nitroxide radicals such as TEMPOL to identify sites of radical formation on hemoproteins.

In VitroNonenzymatic Glycation Enhances the Role of Myoglobin as a Source of Oxidative Stress

Metmyoglobin (Mb) was glycated by glucose in a non-enzymatic in vitro reaction. Amount of iron release from the heme pocket of myoglobin was found to be directly related with the extent of glycation. After in vitro glycation, the unchanged Mb and glycated myoglobin (GMb) were separated by ion exchange (BioRex 70) chromatography, which eliminated free iron from the protein fractions. Separated fractions of Mb and GMb were converted to their oxy forms -MbO2 and GMbO2, respectively. H2O2-induced iron release was significantly higher from GMbO2 than that from MbO2. This free iron, acting as a Fenton reagent, might produce free radicals and degrade different cell constituents. To verify this possibility, degradation of different cell constituents catalyzed by these fractions in the presence of H2O2 was studied. GMbO2 degraded arachidonic acid, deoxyribose and plasmid DNA more efficiently than MbO2. Arachidonic acid peroxidation and deoxyribose degradation were significantly inhibited by desferrioxamine (DFO), mannitol and catalase. However, besides free iron-mediated free radical reactions, role of iron of higher oxidation states, formed during interaction of H2O2 with myoglobin might also be involved in oxidative degradation processes. Formation of carbonyl content, an index of oxidative stress, was higher by GMbO2. Compared to MbO2, GMbO2 was rapidly autooxidized and co-oxidized with nitroblue tetrazolium, indicating increased rate of Mb and superoxide radical formation in GMbO2. GMb exhibited more peroxidase activity than Mb, which was positively correlated with ferrylmyoglobin formation in the presence of H2O2. These findings correlate glycation-induced modification of myoglobin and a mechanism of increased formation of free radicals. Although myoglobin glycation is not significant within muscle cells, free myoglobin in circulation, if becomes glycated, may pose a serious threat by eliciting oxidative stress, particularly in diabetic patients.

The reaction of hydrogen peroxide with hemoglobin induces extensive alpha-globin crosslinking and impairs the interaction of hemoglobin with endogenous scavenger pathways

Cell-free hemoglobin (Hb) enhances the oxidation-related toxicity associated with inflammation, ischemia, and hemolytic disorders. Hb is highly vulnerable to oxidative damage, and irreversible structural changes involving iron/heme oxidation, heme-adduct products, and amino acid oxidation have been reported. Specific structural features of Hb, such as unconstrained alpha-chains and molecular size, determine the efficiency of interactions between the endogenous Hb scavengers haptoglobin (Hp) and CD163. Using HPLC, mass spectrometry, and Western blotting, we show that H(2)O(2)-mediated Hb oxidation results in the formation of covalently stabilized globin multimers, with prominent intramolecular crosslinking between alpha-globin chains. These structural alterations are associated with reduced Hp binding, reduced CD163 interaction, and severely impaired endocytosis of oxidized Hb by the Hp-CD163 pathway. As a result, when exposed to oxidized Hb, CD163-positive HEK293 cells and human macrophages do not increase hemeoxygenase-1 (HO-1) expression, the physiological anti-oxidative macrophage response to Hb exposure. Failed Hb clearance, inadequate HO-1 expression, and the subsequent accumulation of oxidatively damaged Hb species might thus contribute to pathologies related to oxidative stress.

Tyrosine residues as redox cofactors in human hemoglobin: implications for engineering nontoxic blood substitutes

Respiratory proteins such as myoglobin and hemoglobin can, under oxidative conditions, form ferryl heme iron and protein-based free radicals. Ferryl myoglobin can safely be returned to the ferric oxidation state by electron donation from exogenous reductants via a mechanism that involves two distinct pathways. In addition to direct transfer between the electron donor and ferryl heme edge, there is a second pathway that involves "through-protein" electron transfer via a tyrosine residue (tyrosine 103, sperm whale myoglobin). Here we show that the heterogeneous subunits of human hemoglobin, the alpha and beta chains, display significantly different kinetics for ferryl reduction by exogenous reductants. By using selected hemoglobin mutants, we show that the alpha chain possesses two electron transfer pathways, similar to myoglobin. Furthermore, tyrosine 42 is shown to be a critical component of the high affinity, through-protein electron transfer pathway. We also show that the beta chain of hemoglobin, lacking the homologous tyrosine, does not possess this through-protein electron transfer pathway. However, such a pathway can be engineered into the protein by mutation of a specific phenylalanine residue to a tyrosine. High affinity through-protein electron transfer pathways, whether native or engineered, enhance the kinetics of ferryl removal by reductants, particularly at low reductant concentrations. Ferryl iron has been suggested to be a major cause of the oxidative toxicity of hemoglobin-based blood substitutes. Engineering hemoglobin with enhanced rates of ferryl removal, as we show here, is therefore likely to result in molecules better suited for in vivo oxygen delivery.

Tyrosine as a redox-active center in electron transfer to ferryl heme in globins

A wide range of organic reductants, including many iron chelators, reduce ferryl myoglobin to its ferric states in exponential time courses whose rate constants display double hyperbolic dependencies on the reductant concentration. This concentration dependence is consistent with a mechanism in which electron transfer to the heme takes place at two independent sites where reductants appear to bind. We propose that the low-affinity site is located close to the heme edge, within the heme pocket; the maximum rate of electron transfer is highly variable depending on the nature of the reductant (0.005 to >10 s(-1)). The other site has higher apparent affinity (K(D) 0.2-50 microM) but a low maximum rate of electron transfer (0.005 to 0.01 s(-1)). By examining native and engineered proteins we have determined that the high-affinity pathway represents a through-protein electron transfer pathway that involves a specific tyrosine residue. The low apparent rate constant for electron transfer from the tyrosine to the heme (approximately 5 A) is accounted for by proposing that electron transfer occurs only in a very poorly populated protonated state of ferryl heme and tyrosine. Hemoglobin shows similar kinetics but only one subunit exhibits double rectangular hyperbolic concentration dependency. The consequence of a high-affinity through-protein electron transfer pathway to the cytotoxicity of ferryl heme is discussed.

Iron chelators can protect against oxidative stress through ferryl heme reduction

Iron chelators such as desferrioxamine have been shown to ameliorate oxidative damage in vivo. The mechanism of this therapeutic action under non-iron-overload conditions is, however, complex, as desferrioxamine has properties that can impact on oxidative damage independent of its capacity to act as an iron chelator. Desferrioxamine can act as a reducing agent to remove cytotoxic ferryl myoglobin and hemoglobin and has recently been shown to prevent the formation of a highly cytotoxic heme-to-protein cross-linked derivative of myoglobin. In this study we have examined the effects of a wide range of iron chelators, including the clinically used hydroxypyridinone CP20 (deferriprone), on the stability of ferryl myoglobin and on the formation of heme-to-protein cross-linking. We show that all hydroxypyridinones, as well as many other iron chelators, are efficient reducing agents of ferryl myoglobin. These compounds are also effective at preventing the formation of cytotoxic derivatives of myoglobin such as heme-to-protein cross-linking. These results show that the use of iron chelators in vivo may ameliorate oxidative damage under conditions of non-iron overload by at least two mechanisms. The antioxidant effects of chelators in vivo cannot, therefore, be attributed solely to iron chelation.

Oxygen-binding haem proteins

Myoglobin and haemoglobin, the respiratory pigments of mammals and some molluscs, annelids and arthropods, belong to an ancient superfamily of haem-associated globin proteins. Members of this family share common structural and spectral features. They also share some general functional characteristics, such as the ability to bind ligands, e.g. O2, CO and NO, at the iron atom and to undergo redox changes. These properties are used in vivo to perform a wide range of biochemical and physiological roles. While it is acknowledged that the major role of haemoglobin is to bind oxygen reversibly and deliver it to the tissues, this is not its only function, while the often-stated role of myoglobin as an oxygen storage protein is possibly a misconception. Furthermore, haemoglobin and myoglobin express enzymic activities that are important to their function, e.g. NO dioxygenase activity or peroxidatic activity that may be partly responsible for pathophysiology following haemorrhage. Evidence for these functions is described, and the discussion extended to include proteins that have recently been discovered and that are expressed at low levels within the cell. These proteins are hexaco-ordinate, unlike haemoglobin and myoglobin, and are widely distributed throughout the animal kingdom (e.g. neuroglobins and cytoglobins). They may have specialist roles in oxygen delivery to particular sites within the cell but may also perform roles associated with O2 sensing and signalling and in responses to stress, e.g. protection from reactive oxygen and nitrogen species. Haemoglobins are also widespread in plants and bacteria and may serve similar protective functions.

Crystallographic and Spectroscopic Studies of Peroxide-derived Myoglobin Compound II and Occurrence of Protonated FeIV–O

High resolution crystal structures of myoglobin in the pH range 5.2-8.7 have been used as models for the peroxide-derived compound II intermediates in heme peroxidases and oxygenases. The observed Fe-O bond length (1.86-1.90 A) is consistent with that of a single bond. The compound II state of myoglobin in crystals was controlled by single-crystal microspectrophotometry before and after synchrotron data collection. We observe some radiation-induced changes in both compound II (resulting in intermediate H) and in the resting ferric state of myoglobin. These radiation-induced states are quite unstable, and compound II and ferric myoglobin are immediately regenerated through a short heating above the glass transition temperature (<1 s) of the crystals. It is unclear how this influences our compound II structures compared with the unaffected compound II, but some crystallographic data suggest that the influence on the Fe-O bond distance is minimal. Based on our crystallographic and spectroscopic data we suggest that for myoglobin the compound II intermediate consists of an Fe(IV)-O species with a single bond. The presence of Fe(IV) is indicated by a small isomer shift of delta = 0.07 mm/s from Mössbauer spectroscopy. Earlier quantum refinements (crystallographic refinement where the molecular-mechanics potential is replaced by a quantum chemical calculation) and density functional theory calculations suggest that this intermediate H species is protonated.