Understanding mixed sequence DNA recognition by novel designed compounds: the kinetic and thermodynamic behavior of azabenzimidazole diamidines

Single GC base pair recognition by a heterocyclic diamidine: structures, affinities, and dynamics

The recognition of specific genomic arrangements by rationally designed small molecules is fundamental for the expansion of targeted gene expression. Here, we report the first X-ray crystal structures that demonstrate single G (guanine) recognition by a highly selective diamidine (DB2447) in a mixed DNA sequence. The study presents detailed structural information on the mechanism of single G recognition by D2447 and its various interactions in the DNA minor groove. Molecular dynamics and binding studies were used to evaluate the details of our reported structures. The study provides structural insight and resources necessary for understanding single G selection in genomic sequences.

X-ray Structure Characterization of the Selective Recognition of AT Base Pair Sequences

The rational design of small molecules that target specific DNA sequences is a promising strategy to modulate gene expression. This report focuses on a diamidinobenzimidazole compound, whose selective binding to the minor groove of AT DNA sequences holds broad significance in the molecular recognition of AT-rich human promoter sequences. The objective of this study is to provide a more detailed and systematized understanding, at an atomic level, of the molecular recognition mechanism of different AT-specific sequences by a rationally designed minor groove binder. The specialized method of X-ray crystallography was utilized to investigate how the sequence-dependent recognition properties in general, A-tract, and alternating AT sequences affect the binding of diamidinobenzimidazole in the DNA minor groove. While general and A-tract AT sequences give a narrower minor groove, the alternating AT sequences intrinsically have a wider minor groove which typically constricts upon binding. A strong and direct hydrogen bond between the N-H of the benzimidazole and an H-bond acceptor atom in the minor groove is essential for DNA recognition in all sequences described. In addition, the diamidine compound specifically utilizes an interfacial water molecule for its DNA binding. DNA complexes of AATT and AAAAAA recognition sites show that the diamidine compound can bind in two possible orientations with a preference for water-assisted hydrogen bonding at either cationic end. The complex structures of AAATTT, ATAT, ATATAT, and AAAA are bound in a singular orientation. Analysis of the helical parameters shows a minor groove expansion of about 1 Å across all the nonalternating DNA complexes. The results from this systematic approach will convey a greater understanding of the specific recognition of a diverse array of AT-rich sequences by small molecules and more insight into the design of small molecules with enhanced specificity to AT and mixed DNA sequences.

Drug design and DNA structural research inspired by the Neidle laboratory: DNA minor groove binding and transcription factor inhibition by thiophene diamidines

The understanding of sequence-specific DNA minor groove interactions has recently made major steps forward and as a result, the goal of development of compounds that target the minor groove is an active research area. In an effort to develop biologically active minor groove agents, we are preparing and exploring the DNA interactions of diverse diamidine derivatives with a 5'-GAATTC-3' binding site using a powerful array of methods including, biosensor-SPR methods, and X-ray crystallography. The benzimidazole-thiophene module provides an excellent minor groove recognition component. A central thiophene in a benzimidazole-thiophene-phenyl aromatic system provides essentially optimum curvature for matching the shape of the minor groove. Comparison of that structure to one with the benzimidazole replaced with an indole shows that the two structures are very similar, but have some interesting and important differences in electrostatic potential maps, the DNA minor groove binding structure based on x-ray crystallographic analysis, and inhibition of the major groove binding PU.1 transcription factor complex. The binding KD for both compounds is under 10 nM and both form amidine H-bonds to DNA bases. They both have bifurcated H-bonds from the benzimidazole or indole groups to bases at the center of the -AATT- binding site. Analysis of the comparative results provides an excellent understanding of how thiophene compounds recognize the minor groove and can act as transcription factor inhibitors.

Thermodynamic Factors That Drive Sequence-Specific DNA Binding of Designed, Synthetic Minor Groove Binding Agents

Ken Breslauer began studies on the thermodynamics of small cationic molecules binding in the DNA minor groove over 30 years ago, and the studies reported here are an extension of those ground-breaking reports. The goals of this report are to develop a detailed understanding of the binding thermodynamics of pyridine-based sequence-specific minor groove binders that have different terminal cationic groups. We apply biosensor-surface plasmon resonance and ITC methods to extend the understanding of minor groove binders in two directions: (i) by using designed, heterocyclic dicationic minor groove binders that can incorporate a G•C base pair (bp), with flanking AT base pairs, into their DNA recognition site, and bind to DNA sequences specifically; and (ii) by using a range of flanking AT sequences to better define molecular recognition of the minor groove. A G•C bp in the DNA recognition site causes a generally more negative binding enthalpy than with most previously used pure AT binding sites. The binding is enthalpy-driven at 25 °C and above. The flanking AT sequences also have a large effect on the binding energetics with the -AAAGTTT- site having the strongest affinity. As a result of these studies, we now have a much better understanding of the effects of the DNA sequence and compound structure on the molecular recognition and thermodynamics of minor groove complexes.

Mechanistic physicochemical insights into glycation and drug binding by serum albumin: Implications in diabetic conditions

The drug binding ability of serum albumin might get affected as a result of its glycation under diabetic conditions. It requires not only an understanding of the effect of glycation of the protein upon association with the drug, but also calls for an assessment of structure-property-energetics relationships. A combination of ultrasensitive calorimetric, spectroscopic and chromatographic approach has been employed to correlate thermodynamic signatures with recognition, conformation and mechanistic details of the processes involved. An important observation from this work is that 3-(dansylamino) phenyl boronic acid (DnsPBA) assay cannot always determine the extent of glycation as evidenced by MALDI-TOF mass spectra of glycated HSA due to its selectivity for 1,2 or 1,3 cis-diol structures which may be absent in certain AGEs. Protein gets modified post glycation with the formation of advanced glycation end products (AGEs), which are monitored to be targeted by the guanidine group present in anti-diabetic drugs. AGEs formed in the third and fourth week of glycation are significant in the recognition of anti-diabetic drugs. The results with metformin and aminoguanidine suggest that the extent of binding depends upon the number of guanidine group(s) in the drug molecule. Open chain molecules having guanidine group(s) exhibit stronger affinity towards glycated HSA than closed ring entities like naphthalene or pyridine moiety. The observation that the drug binding ability of HSA is not adversely affected, rather strengthened upon glycation, has implications in diabetic conditions. A rigorous structure-property-energetics correlation based on thermodynamic signatures and identification of functional groups on drugs for recognition by HSA are essential in deriving guidelines for rational drug design addressing diabetes.

Mass Spectrometry of Nucleic Acid Noncovalent Complexes

Nucleic acids have been among the first targets for antitumor drugs and antibiotics. With the unveiling of new biological roles in regulation of gene expression, specific DNA and RNA structures have become very attractive targets, especially when the corresponding proteins are undruggable. Biophysical assays to assess target structure as well as ligand binding stoichiometry, affinity, specificity, and binding modes are part of the drug development process. Mass spectrometry offers unique advantages as a biophysical method owing to its ability to distinguish each stoichiometry present in a mixture. In addition, advanced mass spectrometry approaches (reactive probing, fragmentation techniques, ion mobility spectrometry, ion spectroscopy) provide more detailed information on the complexes. Here, we review the fundamentals of mass spectrometry and all its particularities when studying noncovalent nucleic acid structures, and then review what has been learned thanks to mass spectrometry on nucleic acid structures, self-assemblies (e.g., duplexes or G-quadruplexes), and their complexes with ligands.

Synthesis and in vitro evaluation of naphthalimide-benzimidazole conjugates as potential antitumor agents

A series of novel naphthalimide-benzimidazoles was designed and synthesized for the first time and studied for their effect on antiproliferative activity. Some of these compounds possessed good antitumor activity towards the tested cancer cell lines. Noticeably, (diethylamino)ethyl 15 and (dimethylamino)ethyl 23 derivatives displayed superior antiproliferative activity towards human cancer cell lines with MG_MID GI50 values of 1.43 and 1.83 μM, respectively. Preliminary investigation revealed that compounds 15 and 23 might bind with ct-DNA through the intercalation mode which is responsible for potent bioactivity. Moreover, transportation behaviour indicated that these molecules could efficiently bind to and be carried by bovine albumin, and the hydrogen bonding and hydrophobic interactions played important roles in interaction with serum albumin.

A New Generation of Minor-Groove-Binding-Heterocyclic Diamidines That Recognize G·C Base Pairs in an AT Sequence Context

We review the preparation of new compounds with good solution and cell uptake properties that can selectively recognize mixed A·T and G·C bp sequences of DNA. Our underlying aim is to show that these new compounds provide important new biotechnology reagents as well as a new class of therapeutic candidates with better properties and development potential than other currently available agents. In this review, entirely different ways to recognize mixed sequences of DNA by modifying AT selective heterocyclic cations are described. To selectively recognize a G·C base pair an H-bond acceptor must be incorporated with AT recognizing groups as with netropsin. We have used pyridine, azabenzimidazole and thiophene-N-methylbenzimidazole GC recognition units in modules crafted with both rational design and empirical optimization. These modules can selectively and strongly recognize a single G·C base pair in an AT sequence context. In some cases, a relatively simple change in substituents can convert a heterocyclic module from AT to GC recognition selectivity. Synthesis and DNA interaction results for initial example lead modules are described for single G·C base pair recognition compounds. The review concludes with a description of the initial efforts to prepare larger compounds to recognize sequences of DNA with more than one G·C base pairs. The challenges and initial successes are described along with future directions.

Thermodynamics and site stoichiometry of DNA binding by a large antiviral hairpin polyamide

PA1 (dIm-PyPyβPyPyPy-γ-PyPyβPyPyPyPyβ-Ta) is a large (14-ring) hairpin polyamide that was designed to recognize the DNA sequence 5'-W₂GW₇-3', where W is either A or T. As is common among the smaller 6-8-ring hairpin polyamides (PAs), it binds its target recognition sequence with low nM affinity. However, in addition to its large size, it is distinct from these more extensively characterized PAs in its high tolerance for mismatches and antiviral properties. In ongoing attempts to understand the basis for these distinctions, we conducted thermodynamics studies of PA1-DNA interactions. The temperature dependence of binding affinity was measured using TAMRA-labeled hairpin DNAs containing a single target sequence. PA1 binding to either an ATAT/TATA or an AAAA/TTTT pattern is consistently entropically driven. This is in contrast to the A/T pattern-dependent driving forces for DNA binding by netropsin, distamycin, and smaller hairpin polyamides. Analysis of the salt dependence of PA1-DNA binding reveals that within experimental error, there is no dependence on ionic strength, indicating that the polyelectrolyte effect does not contribute to PA1-DNA binding energetics. This is similar to that observed for smaller PAs. PA1-DNA recognition sequence binding stoichiometries were determined at both nM (fluorescence) and μM (circular dichroism) concentrations. With all sequences and under both conditions, multiple PA1 molecules bind the small DNA hairpin that contains only a single recognition sequence. Implications for these observations are discussed.

Small molecule binders recognize DNA microstructural variations via an induced fit mechanism

Regulation of gene-expression by specific targeting of protein-nucleic acid interactions has been a long-standing goal in medicinal chemistry. Transcription factors are considered "undruggable" because they lack binding sites well suited for binding small-molecules. In order to overcome this obstacle, we are interested in designing small molecules that bind to the corresponding promoter sequences and either prevent or modulate transcription factor association via an allosteric mechanism. To achieve this, we must design small molecules that are both sequence-specific and able to target G/C base pair sites. A thorough understanding of the relationship between binding affinity and the structural aspects of the small molecule-DNA complex would greatly aid in rational design of such compounds. Here we present a comprehensive analysis of sequence-specific DNA association of a synthetic minor groove binder using long timescale molecular dynamics. We show how binding selectivity arises from a combination of structural factors. Our results provide a framework for the rational design and optimization of synthetic small molecules in order to improve site-specific targeting of DNA for therapeutic uses in the design of selective DNA binders targeting transcription regulation.

Bound Compound, Interfacial Water, and Phenyl Ring Rotation Dynamics of a Compound in the DNA Minor Groove

DB2277, a heterocyclic diamidine, is a successful design for mixed base pair (bp) DNA sequence recognition. The compound has a central aza-benzimidazole group that forms two H-bonds with a GC bp that has flanking AT bps. The nuclear magnetic resonance structure of the DB2277-DNA complex with an AAGATA recognition site sequence was determined, and here we report extended molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of the structure. DB2277 has two terminal phenyl-amidine groups, one of which is directly linked to the DB2277 heterocyclic core and the other through a flexible -OCH₂- group. The flexibly linked phenyl is too far from the minor groove floor to make direct H-bonds but is linked to an AT bp through water-mediated H-bonds. The flexibly linked phenyl-amidine with water-mediated H-bonds to the bases at the floor of the minor groove suggested that it might rotate in time spans accessible in MD. To test this idea, we conducted multimicrosecond MD simulations to determine if these phenyl rotations could be observed for a bound compound. In a 3 μs simulation, highly dynamic torsional motions were observed for the -OCH₂-linked phenyl but not for the other phenyl. The dynamics periodically reached a level to allow 180° rotation of the phenyl while it was still bound in the minor groove. This is the first observation of rotation of a phenyl bound to DNA, and the results provide mechanistic details about how a rotation can occur as well as how mixed bp recognition can occur for monomer compounds bound to the minor groove.

Systematic synthetic and biophysical development of mixed sequence DNA binding agents

It is now well established that, although only about 5% of the human genome codes for protein, most of the DNA has some function, such as synthesis of specific, functional RNAs and/or control of gene expression. These functional sequences open immense possibilities in both biotechnology and therapeutics for the use of cell-permeable, small molecules that can bind mixed-base pair sequences of DNA for regulation of genomic functions. Unfortunately very few types of modules have been designed to recognize mixed DNA sequences and for progress in targeting specific genes, it is essential to have additional classes of compounds. Compounds that can be rationally designed from established modules and which can bind strongly to mixed base pair DNA sequences are especially attractive. Based on extensive experience in design of minor-groove agents for AT recognition, a small library of compounds with two AT specific binding modules, connected through linkers which can recognize the G·C base pairs, were prepared. The compound-DNA interactions were evaluated with a powerful array of biophysical methods and the results show that some pyridyl-linked compounds bind with the target sequence with sub-nanomolar K_D, with very slow dissociation kinetics and 200 times selectivity over the related sequence without a G·C base pair. Interestingly, a set of compounds with AT module connected by different linkers shows cooperative dimer recognition of related sequences. This type of design approach can be expanded to additional modules for recognition of a wide variety of sequences.

First Structure of a Designed Minor Groove Binding Heterocyclic Cation that Specifically Recognizes Mixed DNA Base Pair Sequences

The high-resolution NMR structure of the first heterocyclic, non-amide, organic cation that strongly and selectively recognizes mixed AT/GC bp (bp=base pair) sequences of DNA in a 1:1 complex is described. Compound designs of this type provide essential methods for control of functional, non-genomic DNA sequences and have broad cell uptake capability, based on studies from animals to humans. The high-resolution structural studies described in this report are essential for understanding the molecular basis for the sequence-specific binding as well as for new ideas for additional compound designs for sequence-specific recognition. The molecular features, in this report, explain the mechanism of recognition of both A⋅T and G⋅C bps and are an interesting molecular recognition story. Examination of the experimental structure and the NMR restrained molecular dynamics model suggests that recognition of the G⋅C base pair involves two specific H-bonds. The structure illustrates a wealth of information on different DNA interactions and illustrates an interfacial water molecule that is a key component of the complex.

DNA microstructure influences selective binding of small molecules designed to target mixed-site DNA sequences

Specific targeting of protein–nucleic acid interactions is an area of current interest, for example, in the regulation of gene-expression. Most transcription factor proteins bind in the DNA major groove; however, we are interested in an approach using small molecules to target the minor groove to control expression by an allosteric mechanism. In an effort to broaden sequence recognition of DNA-targeted-small-molecules to include both A·T and G·C base pairs, we recently discovered that the heterocyclic diamidine, DB2277, forms a strong monomer complex with a DNA sequence containing 5΄-AAAGTTT-3΄. Competition mass spectrometry and surface plasmon resonance identified new monomer complexes, as well as unexpected binding of two DB2277 with certain sequences. Inherent microstructural differences within the experimental DNAs were identified through computational analyses to understand the molecular basis for recognition. These findings emphasize the critical nature of the DNA minor groove microstructure for sequence-specific recognition and offer new avenues to design synthetic small molecules for effective regulation of gene-expression.

The Thiophene "Sigma-Hole" as a Concept for Preorganized, Specific Recognition of G⋅C Base Pairs in the DNA Minor Groove

In spite of its importance in cell function, targeting DNA is under-represented in the design of small molecules. A barrier to progress in this area is the lack of a variety of modules that recognize G⋅C base pairs (bp) in DNA sequences. To overcome this barrier, an entirely new design concept for modules that can bind to mixed G⋅C and A⋅T sequences of DNA is reported herein. Because of their successes in biological applications, minor-groove-binding heterocyclic cations were selected as the platform for design. Binding to A⋅T sequences requires hydrogen-bond donors whereas recognition of the G-NH2 requires an acceptor. The concept that we report herein uses pre-organized N-methylbenzimidazole (N-MeBI) thiophene modules for selective binding with mixed bp DNA sequences. The interaction between the thiophene sigma hole (positive electrostatic potential) and the electron-donor nitrogen of N-MeBI preorganizes the conformation for accepting an hydrogen bond from G-NH2 . The compound-DNA interactions were evaluated with a powerful array of biophysical methods and the results show that N-MeBI-thiophene monomer compounds can strongly and selectively recognize single G⋅C bp sequences. Replacing the thiophene with other moieties significantly reduces binding affinity and specificity, as predicted by the design concept. These results show that the use of molecular features, such as sigma-holes, can lead to new approaches for small molecules in biomolecular interactions.

Lithium Hexamethyldisilazane Transformation of Transiently Protected 4-Aza/Benzimidazole Nitriles to Amidines and their Dimethyl Sulfoxide Mediated Imidazole Ring Formation

Trimethylsilyl-transient protection successfully allowed the use of lithium hexamethyldisilazane to prepare benzimidazole (BI) and 4-azabenzimidazole (azaBI) amidines from nitriles in 58-88% yields. This strategy offers a much better choice to prepare BI/azaBI amidines than the lengthy, low-yielding Pinner reaction. Synthesis of aza/benzimidazole rings from aromatic diamines and aldehydes was affected in dimethyl sulfoxide in 10-15 min, while known procedures require long time and purification. These methods are important for the BI/azaBI-based drug industry and for developing specific DNA binders for expanded therapeutic applications.

Imino proton NMR guides the reprogramming of A•T specific minor groove binders for mixed base pair recognition

Sequence-specific binding to DNA is crucial for targeting transcription factor-DNA complexes to modulate gene expression. The heterocyclic diamidine, DB2277, specifically recognizes a single G•C base pair in the minor groove of mixed base pair sequences of the type AAAGTTT. NMR spectroscopy reveals the presence of major and minor species of the bound compound. To understand the principles that determine the binding affinity and orientation in mixed sequences of DNA, over thirty DNA hairpin substrates were examined by NMR and thermal melting. The NMR exchange dynamics between major and minor species shows that the exchange is much faster than compound dissociation determined from biosensor–surface plasmon resonance. Extensive modifications of DNA sequences resulted in a unique DNA sequence with binding site AAGATA that binds DB2277 in a single orientation. A molecular docking result agrees with the model representing rapid flipping of DB2277 between major and minor species. Imino spectral analysis of a ¹⁵N-labeled central G clearly shows the crucial role of the exocyclic amino group of G in sequence-specific recognition. Our results suggest that this approach can be expanded to additional modules for recognition of more sequence-specific DNA complexes. This approach provides substantial information about the sequence-specific, highly efficient, dynamic nature of minor groove binding agents.

Mixed up minor groove binders: Convincing A·T specific compounds to recognize a G·C base pair

DNA minor-groove-binding compounds have limited biological applications, in part due to problems with sequence specificity that cause off-target effects. A model to enhance specificity has been developed with the goal of preparing compounds that bind to two AT sites separated by G·C base pairs. Compounds of interest were probed using thermal melting, circular dichroism, mass spectrometry, biosensor-SPR, and molecular modeling methods. A new minor groove binder that can strongly and specifically recognize a single G·C base pair with flanking AT sequences has been prepared. This multi-site DNA recognition mode offers novel design principles to recognize entirely new DNA motifs.